Upload
kristian-henry
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refining East State Of the Refining East State Of the BusinessBusiness
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refining East ReviewRefining East Review Refining East Units: Coker, Hydrocracker (HCU – 2 stages), Hydrogen Plant, Naphtha Hydrotreater (NHT), Diesel
Hydrotreater (DHT), Catalytic Reformer #1 (CR1; Paused), Catalytic Reformer #2 (CR2), Sulfur Plant #2 (S2), Sour Water Strippers (SWS).
Staffing: 118 total (excluding 2 on loan to PEI and 1 to USW Tops Representative).– 9 Shift Leaders, 3 Production Specialists, 1 Operations and Maintenance Coordinator (OMC), 3
Operations/Maintenance Liaison (OMLs will be staff by end of September), 1 Projects Coordinator, 1 Reliability Specialist, 1 T/A planning, 99 operators (26 Alky operators, 31 DU5/SATS/S3 operators, 42 RCCU/RGHT operators)
– Coker – 4 operating positions (1 Console operator, RCM Operators: FEL Operator, Structure Operator, Utilities Operator)
– HCU / HP – 4 operating positions (2 Console operators, RCM Operators: HP / HCU 1st Stage Operator, HCU 2nd Stage Operator)
– NHT – 1 operating position (Console / RCM)– DHT – 1 operating position (Console / RCM)– S2/SWS – 1 operating position (Console / RCM)– CR1 – 1 operating position (Console / RCM) Currently not using this position– CR2 – 2 operating positions (Console operator, RCM operator)
Staffing plan reductions to align with SPI-100: – Absorb S3 from Refining West into S2 Board– Absorb RGHT from Refining West into NHT/DHT Board– Combine NHT/CR1/CR2 RCM position into 1 position during nights / weekends– Combine Coker Utilities / Coker Structure RCM Positions during nights / weekends
Future Moves:– Fill 2 Operation Maintenance Liason positions (posting closed)– Fill CTL positions (Only 4 of 8 CTL positions are filled with permanent staff employees)
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Unit CapacitiesUnit Capacities
Unit Maximum Capacities:– HCU Safeguarded at 38MBD, 1st Stage at 28MBD. Work ongoing to really understand limits– Coker Safeguarded at 28.5 MBD. Need to understand this limit.– CR2 Safeguarded at 40MBD. Limit is system pressure. Don’t foresee running at 40MBD– CR1 Safeguarded at 22MBD. Don’t foresee running at 22MBD.– S2: 90 LTD. Limit not well understood.– NHT Safeguarded at 38MBD. Preliminary plans to debottleneck to 42 MBD. – DHT Safeguarded at 70 MBD. Not too long ago we were safeguarded at 55 MBD.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refinery ’08 Score Card ReviewRefinery ’08 Score Card Review
2008 YTD Actual Target Status
Best Yields/Optimal Energy Energy Intensity Index, EII 90.7 91.0 Crude API 30.3 32.3 Crude Added value 0.8 Tons of Sulfur (Lt/day) 111 150.0 Electricity Consumption (mwh) 48.9 43.1 Fuel Gas (knlfeb) 535.0 562.8 Best Yields % (Gas, Jet, Diesel) 97.67 100.0Lowest Sustainable Cost Non-Energy Variable Costs(NEVC) 15.0 13.1 Direct Fixed Costs (ICP) 117.8 115.1 Achieve Net Income Target, $MM -30.6 75.7People Absenteeism - Hrly & Staff 3.3 3.5 Overtime - site 13.3 10.0
Norco Refining2008 Business Objectives
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refinery Combined Injury RateRefinery Combined Injury Rate
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007 J F M A M J J A S O N D
7/14/08
4/25 - C - at DHT T/A – mouth injury
4/26 – E - at Coker – finger fracture, sutures
5/5 – C – (LTI) - at Hydro – knee injury, surgical repair.
6/3 – C – at Hydro T/A – finger laceration, sutures.
6/6 – C – at Hydro T/A – fractured wrist.
6/11 – C – at Hydro T/A – smashed finger (sutures)
6/26 – C – at Logistics – finger laceration, sutures.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007 J F M A M J J A S O N D
7/14/08
4/25 - C - at DHT T/A – mouth injury
4/26 – E - at Coker – finger fracture, sutures
5/5 – C – (LTI) - at Hydro – knee injury, surgical repair.
6/3 – C – at Hydro T/A – finger laceration, sutures.
6/6 – C – at Hydro T/A – fractured wrist.
6/11 – C – at Hydro T/A – smashed finger (sutures)
6/26 – C – at Logistics – finger laceration, sutures.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
RE YTD - No Body Gets HurtRE YTD - No Body Gets Hurt
Mo. YTD Mo. YTD Mo. YTD Mo. YTD Mo. YTD Mo. YTD Mo YTD 03to07 Mo. YTD 03to07
Coker 0 1 0 3 0 1 0 1 2 45 2 6 3 3 1 1 1 0
Hydro 0 0 5 9 0 0 3 4 32 55 0 3 3 5 0 0 0 1
Total 0 1 5 12 0 1 3 5 34 100 2 9 6 8 1 1 1 1
Open Serious CROWS
REFINING_EAST
JUNE 2008 NORCO HSE KPI
NOBODY GETS HURTFirst Aids-Employees
First Aids Contractors
Recordables Employees
Recordables Contractors
CROWS Submitted
Serious CROWS
Open CROWS 2003 to 4/30/08YTD
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refinery Environmental PerformanceRefinery Environmental Performance
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
RE 100% Compliance RE 100% Compliance
21 Overdue CAIR’s (CAIR 1’s = “0”) (CAIR 2’s = “13”) (CAIR 3’s = “8”) 6 Deferrals, All Internal Inspections 100% Procedure Review Compliance 100% Checklist Compliance 88% Lab Calibration Compliance. 99.26% CBT refresher training No Environmental Corporate Chargeables. No PSM incidents
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
0
5
10
15
20
25
J F M A M J J A S O N D
25
27
29
31
33
35
37
39
41
43
45
J F M A M J J A S O N D
CR-1 CR-2
25
27
29
31
33
35
37
39
41
J F M A M J J A S O N D
NHT
20
22
24
26
28
30
32
34
36
38
40
J F M A M J J A S O N D
HCU
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
J F M A M J J A S O N D
Coker
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
J F M A M J J A S O N D
DHT
Refining East
MOP
T&R Plan
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refinery ’08 Net Income After TaxRefinery ’08 Net Income After Tax
338362
148
114
312
-31
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
'04 '05 '06 '07 '08Plan
'08 YTD
$MM
4.7
-5.0-3.4
-25.3
-14.6
13
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
J F M A M J J A S O N D
Actual Estimate Plan
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Quick Hit Ideas to Improve IncomeQuick Hit Ideas to Improve Income Blend HCU Heavy Naphtha to HCU Bottoms
to ULSD. Feed RCCU Heavy Naphtha to DHT.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Refining East NEVCRefining East NEVCJul
ActualJul Plan
YTD Actual
YTD Plan
Catalyst 0 0 285 0
Chemical 187 126 1,592 816
Non-Energy Utility 97 83 762 681
Other Variable (56) (4) (462) (25)
Total NEVC 228 206 2,177 1,473
YTD:
– Catalyst: No budget for Catalyst Change Outs (PVs 631-NHT/PHT Reactor, 887-CR1/Chloride Absorber, 889-CR2/ Chloride Absorber, 968 & 969-CR2 Dryers) ~ $284K
– Chemical: Used Nitrogen for T/A start-up ~ $133K
– Chemical: Higher than plan expenses for Baker Petrolite chemicals, Caustic, and other Nitrogen purchases
July:
– Chemical: Sulfolane and DIPA for Tank Re-inventory ~ $143K
– Nitrogen & DMDS Credit received for Catalyst Change-Out for T/A.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Salaries & WagesSalaries & WagesJul Actual Jul Plan
FTEs 91 99
Redistributed (6) (12)
Net FTEs 85 87
Jul Actual
Jul Plan
YTD Actual
YTD Plan
Salaries & Wages 1,134 987 7,767 6,763
– (Uncontrollable) GESPP Payments, OPEB Adjustments, 2 ICP Increases, and Stock Appreciation Rights Adjustment ~ $364K
– Not redistributing out the level of FTE’s to Projects, T/A, MTC as communicated in budget ~ $331K
– Not yet at budgeted 10% overtime ~ $612K
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
MaintenanceMaintenance
Jul Actual
Jul Plan
YTD Actual
YTD Plan
Preventative 140 139 1,126 1,060
Corrective 961 648 5,284 4,205
Non-Routine 331 495 10,097 10,892
Admin 24 21 233 148
Total Mtc 1,455 1,304 16,740 16,304
– Correctiv: Maintenance Capital Identified and Approved:
– F-51 Air Pre-Heater Rebuild ~ $397K,
– P-3131 (Jet Pump), ~$250K
– P-4210 (Boiler Feed Water Pump) ~ $140K
– P-2053 (CR2 Charge Pump) ~$150K
– Corrective: High Coker Loader Costs ~ $774K
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Operating ExpenseOperating ExpenseJul
ActualJul Plan
YTD Actual
YTD Plan
Total Operating 233 446 2,558 3,121
SGS 2 0 74 0
– OPEX: On budget. Issues listed in threats
– SGS: Nothing budgeted, but expenses for Coke Drum and Feed Piping Tech Analysis, Coker Thermographs, and HCU IR Service ~ $72K
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Sundries ExpenseSundries Expense
Jul Actual
Jul Plan
YTD Actual
YTD Plan
Total Sundries 35 25 226 172
Casualty Loss 0 0 17 0
– Sundries: Unidentified Payroll Payment in March (DHT/S2 Recognition) ~ $44K
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
RE Top 10 ThreatsRE Top 10 Threats
Risk Score Unit Responsible Group Threat Title Status Description RAM_Box_No
12,045,000.00 DHT ProjectsULSD Rundown Hydraulics Limiting Product to 67 MBPD
Risk Scored, Needs Action(s) Assigned E5
4,964,000.00 HCU ElectricalFirst Stage Charge Pump Motor DP-1933 is unspared.
Mitigation/Solution In Progress C5
4,352,000.00 HCU Machinery Fin Fan Efficiency in Refining EastMitigation/Solution In Progress E4
4,238,576.00 Coker PEI Coke Drum Feed Line VibrationsRisk Scored, Needs Action(s) Assigned D4
4,237,500.00 HCU MachineryK-1927 HCU Make-Up Compressor Foundation Repair & Overhaul
Mitigation/Solution In Progress D5
3,715,200.00 HCU Electrical Failure of Transformer T1601MMitigation/Solution In Progress C5
2,309,500.00 DHT Machinery K-5337 Vent Gas CompressorMitigation/Solution In Progress D4
2,154,000.00 HCU PEI E-1071 Metallurgy UpgradeMitigation/Solution In Progress E4
1,800,000.00 Coker Instrument EOV-13 failure in-between the T/A cycle.Entered Into Projects Database E4
1,731,000.00 CokerProcess Engineering Loss of Coker Debutanizer
Risk Scored, Needs Action(s) Assigned E4
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Risk Score Unit Responsible Group Threat Title Status Description RAM_Box_No
4,238,576.00 Coker PEI Coke Drum Feed Line VibrationsRisk Scored, Needs Action(s) Assigned D4
3,715,200.00 HCU Electrical Failure of Transformer T1601MMitigation/Solution In Progress C5
2,939,363.64 DHT Machinery K-5337 Vent Gas CompressorMitigation/Solution In Progress D4
1,800,000.00 Coker Instrument EOV-13 failure in-between the T/A cycle.Entered Into Projects Database E4
1,731,000.00 CokerProcess Engineering Loss of Coker Debutanizer
Risk Scored, Needs Action(s) Assigned E4
1,429,550.00CR-2 - Bad
Actor Machinery P-2200/01 CR-2 (25°/50° Caustic Pumps)Work Completed, Monitoring Results D4
1,216,000.00 NHTProcess Engineering Increased fouling rates of the PHT
Mitigation/Solution In Progress E4
1,210,546.00 NHT OperationsNHT Reduced rates due to furnace fouling – Tube skin limitations
Mitigation/Solution In Progress D4
1,069,000.00 CokerComputer/Digital Control Coker Drum Level Measurement
Entered Into Projects Database C5
1,068,500.00 CokerProcess Engineering Antifoam Injection New Entry C5
RE Top 10 ThreatsRE Top 10 Threats
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
RE Top 5 Threats OverviewRE Top 5 Threats Overview1. Coke Drum Feed Line Vibrations (4,200,000) : The coker feed line vibrates. Dynamic stress analysis of the line
shows that failure is likely in ~2 years. Failure of the line would yield an environmental event, potential safety event and would shut the coker down for 1 week. A new design has been completed, and will be implemented at the end of September.
2. Failure of Transformer T1601 (3,700,000). This is a very large transformer with a 50 week delivery time. This transformer feeds most of the electrical equipment at the HCU, and would thus shut the unit down until we replaced it. The long term mitigation for this transformer is a new HCU substation with different transformer design. We are in the process of submitting a project to buy a spare transformer (~$600K) until the substation gets built.
3. Unspared K-5337 DHT Vent Gas Compressor (3,000,000): Loss of this compressor is an automatic environmental corporate chargeable event, and we would stop producing 70MBD of diesel. We could run at reduced rates by piping some of the vent gas to S2 scrubber, and/or to a portable scrubber. Long term mitigation may be to purchase and install a spare compressor. Economics are being evaluated.
4. EOV 13 Failure in between T/A cycles (1,800,000). This electrically operated valve is a key valve in switching of Coker Drums. It has had a history of leaking and otherwise failing between T/A cycles. As we attempt to increase the intervals between T/A cycles, this becomes more of a threat. The mitigation is to have a spare valve at the warehouse. Alternative valve designs are being considered.
5. Loss of Coker Debutanizer (1,200,000): Coker gasoline goes to NHT, not having a debutanizer at the Coker means that we send butanes to the NHT, thus bottlenecking that unit. The economics of this threat are based on increasing naphtha yields at NHT.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Bad Actor ListBad Actor ListNorco Refinery Bad Actors
(Aug'07 - July'08)
1 P-2310/2510/2511/4242 HCU Condensate Injection 7 1.7 4/9/08 Mitigation/Solution In Progress 03/16/072 P-3152/53 COK OWS Oil Sump 4 3.0 6/15/08 Mitigation/Solution In Progress3 P-5947/48 DHT Diesel Booster 4 3.0 7/30/08 New Entry4 P-1752/1753/2819 DIS Oil Water Separator 3 4.0 4/20/2008 Mitigation/Solution In Progress 06/19/075 P-8139 RGHT Wash Water Booster 3 4.0 10/24/07 Mitigation/Solution In Progress6 P-7046/7047 RCCU Caustic Addition 3 4.0 4/8/087 P-1524/1525 NHT Stripper Reflux 2 6.0 5/29/088 P-2762/63/64 DIS Prototype Fuel 2 6.0 9/24/07 Mitigation/Solution In Progress9 P-2575/2576 DTL 1st Stage Water 1 12.0 11/13/07 Mitigation/Solution In Progress
1011121314
14 24
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
RE Mechanical Equipment MTBRRE Mechanical Equipment MTBRMTBR
Jul'07 - Jun'08
64.0059.38
92.47
78.92
55.35
87.10
20.00
40.00
60.00
80.00
100.00
120.00
ALKY COK DIS DTL HCU RCCU
Mo
nth
s
Refinery Average74.44
ALKYDIMKTRMTBE
COKCR1DHTNHTSP2SWS
(ALL LOGISTICS) MVR QC (LAB)SC (SHOPS/CRAFTS) VAT
HCUCR2H-2
RCCURGHTSBA
Refinery Target
DTLDIHDU5SP3VF
76.00
– HCU lower than average mainly due to condensate injection pump. Issue largely resolved
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
Major Threats to 08 PlanMajor Threats to 08 Plan
– Front End Loader Repair costs YTD is high. Need to see if trend will continue ~ $774K
– Delta Valve Repairs (will be submitted for Maintenance Capital)
– Equipment Isolation Packages NHT/CR2 ~$150K
– Overtime Threat – Many employees approaching 30%
– SWS Stripper #2 Column, Valves, Plate Exchanger Cleanings, etc… ~ $350K
– PHT Reactor ~ Potential additional $150K before year end.
Business ConfidentialRespect For People…Honesty and Integrity…Excellence…Courageous Leadership…Winning Attitude…Enterprise First
– NHT Reactor cut from 2008 Plan
– Personnel Lift vs. Scaffold Cost Reduction (Also loaning to other areas) ~ $24K/mo
– Extending CR2 Regen Cycles to save on Chemical Costs and optimize utilities
– Deep dive research into Unit Supplies expected to deliver > $50K/yr cost savings.
– Front end loader reliability team revitalization expected to yield cost reductions.
– Expected efficiency gains from on-site loader mechanic.
– F-51 On-line spalling to reduce future costs of De-Coking
– Site-wide focus on frac tanks resulted in $52K/month reduction in RE alone.
Waste/Cost Reduction OpportunitiesWaste/Cost Reduction Opportunities