brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    1/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 1

    A BRAND AUDIT PROJECT

    ONTITAN

    FINAL REPORT

    Submitted by:

    Section B Group 13

    Group Members:

    Abhishek Palo (FT12403)

    Himanshu Yadav (FT12431)

    P Gouthem Karthik (FT12325)

    S Kesavan (FT12224)

    Srinivasrao Dhenuvukonda (FT12467)

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    2/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 2

    Table of Contents

    History .................................................................................................................................. 3

    Corporate information ........................................................................................................... 4

    Product Related Attributes .................................................................................................... 4

    Brand portfolio....................................................................................................................... 6

    Communication, pricing and distribution ................................................................................ 6

    Customer Knowledge ............................................................................................................ 7

    Sources of Brand Equity ....................................................................................................... 8

    CBBE Model for Titan Watches ............................................................................................. 9

    TITAN in various Brand Ratings .......................................................................................... 10

    TITANs Brands Architecture.............................................................................................. 11

    TITANs Brand Hierarchy Evaluation ................................................................................... 11

    TITANs fit in a broader brand portfolio ................................................................................ 12

    TITANs Growth strategy Assessment ................................................................................. 12

    Brand Awareness ................................................................................................................ 14

    Brand Attitude ..................................................................................................................... 15

    Attitude- Product ................................................................................................................. 16

    Level of Desire for the Brand ............................................................................................... 17

    Behavioural Tendencies ...................................................................................................... 18

    Recommendations .............................................................................................................. 22

    References ......................................................................................................................... 23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    3/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 3

    History

    With presence in over 4 continents and 40 countries,$ 1.46 billion company, Titan is the

    worlds fifth largest and Indias largest wrist watch manufacturer. Since its inception as JV

    between Tata group and TIDCO in 1984, the company has grown to develop and offer Titan,

    Octane, Regalia, Fastrack, Nebula, Raga Xylys brands in the wrist watch market and has

    extended to jewellery and accessories market through the brand Tanishq in 1995 and more

    recently has entered into eye wear by launching eye gear sunglasses and prescription

    sunglasses. As market leaders with over 60% market share in domestic organized watch

    markets, Titan has recently claimed to have manufactured the worlds slimmest watch

    Titan Edge through devotion to extensive R&D activities.

    Titan had set up its first plant for the manufacture of analog electronic watches in the state

    industries promotion corporation of Tamil Nadu at Hosur in the year 1984 and went on to get

    into an collaboration agreement with France Ebauches for technical documentation and

    assistance in procurement of equipment and materials. In the year 1991 a joint venture

    Company along with Economic Development Council of Goa, Daman & Diu Ltd., in the name

    of Titan Time Products, Ltd., was set up at Goa, for the manufacture of Electronic Circuit

    Blocks. The name of the Company was changed from Titan Watches, Ltd. to Titan Industries

    Ltd. in the year 1993, in view of the fact that the Company's products consisted of not only

    watches but also jewellery. Since then the company has consistently captured new markets

    and thrown out many existing players to capture market leadership in the domestic market

    and markets abroad.

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    4/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 4

    Corporate information

    Some key changes in the history of corporate professionals profile include the induction of

    Mr Jeyakodi as a director of the company in 2002 followed by resignation of Mr. Jacob

    Curien in 2003. However the management was a given a boost by the appointment of Mr.

    Harish Bhatt as Chief operating officer of watches and accessories division in the year 2006

    followed by induction and then resignation of Mr. Sunil Palliwal as the board of director of

    the company in 2007. However the following is the brief list of senior management team of

    the Titan Industries as of 2011.

    Name Designation

    Susan Mathew Chairman / Chair Person

    N Sundaradevan Director

    Ishaat Hussain Director

    T K Balaji Director

    Vinita Bali Director

    R Poornalingam Director

    Name Designation

    Bhaskar Bhat Managing Director

    V Parthasarathy Director

    N N Tata Director

    C G Krishnadas Nair Director

    Hema Ravichandar Director

    Das Narayandas Independent Director

    Product Related Attributes

    All watches provide the time of day, giving at least the hour and minute, and usually the

    second. Most also provide the current date, and often the day of the week as well. However,

    many watches also provide a great deal of information beyond the basics of time and date.

    Some watches include alarms. Other elaborate and more expensive watches, both pocket

    and wrist models also incorporate striking mechanisms or repeater functions, so that the

    wearer could learn the time by the sound emanating from the watch. This announcement or

    striking feature is an essential characteristic of true clocks and distinguishes such watches

    from ordinary timepieces. This feature is available on most digital watches.

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    5/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 5

    A complicated watch has one or more functions beyond the basic function of displaying the

    time and the date; such functionality is called complication. Two popular complications are

    the chronograph complication, which is the ability of the watch movement to function as a

    stopwatch, and the moon phase complication, which is a display of the lunar phase.

    Other more expensive complications include Tourbillon, Perpetual calendar, Minute

    repeater, and Equation of time. A truly complicated watch has many of these complications

    at once. Some watches can both indicate the direction of Mecca and have alarms that can

    be set for all daily prayer requirements. Among watch enthusiasts, complicated watches are

    especially collectible. Some watches include a second 12-hour display for UTC (as Pontos

    Grand Guichet GMT).

    The similar-sounding terms chronograph and chronometer are often confused, although

    they mean altogether different things. A chronograph has a stopwatch complication, as

    explained above, while a chronometer watch has a high quality mechanical or a thermo-

    compensated quartz movement that has been tested and certified to operate within a certain

    standard of accuracy by the COSC (Contrle Officiel Suisse des Chronomtres). The

    concepts are different but not mutually exclusive; so a watch can be a chronograph, a

    chronometer, both, or neither.

    Many computerized wristwatches have been developed, but none have had long-term sales

    success, because they have awkward user interfaces due to the tiny screens and buttons,

    and a short battery life. As miniaturized electronics became cheaper, watches have been

    developed containing calculators, tonometer, barometers, altimeters, a compass using both

    hands to show the N/S direction, video games, digital cameras, key drives, GPS receivers

    and cellular phones. In the early 1980s Seiko marketed a watch with a television in it. Such

    watches have also had the reputation as unsightly and thus mainly geek toys. Several

    companies have however attempted to develop a computer contained in a wristwatch.

    Braille watches have analogue displays with raised bumps around the face to allow blind

    users to tell the time. Their digital equivalents use synthesised speech to speak the time on

    command.

    Some key unique features of Titan are:

    1) Distinct watches in Gold and Leather

    2) Stylish watches in Gold and Precious metals

    3) Contemporary watches in stainless steel to withstand rigors of daily life

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    6/23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    7/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 7

    Distribution

    The company has over 317 exclusive World of Titan' showrooms and over 50 Fastrack

    stores. It also has a large network of over 650 after-sales-service centres.

    Customer Knowledge

    TITAN has revolutionized the watch market by making quartz its watch and is the

    unquestioned leader in the segment. Many consumers brand associations for TITAN were

    simple and stylish, Elegant, High Quality. The mental map is given below for the TITAN

    watches.

    Image:Time

    Amazing DesignElegantSimple and StylishTotally Inspiring, Talismanic, Amazing andNiceRemember the titans movieWatchPower of TIMEDistinct sound of their advertisementsTITANSGreek GOD

    Performance:Ruggedness

    Durability

    Sports:TrendyAdvanced FeaturesDigital

    People:High-ClassFashionStyle

    Negative

    People

    Performance

    TITAN

    Sports

    Image

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    8/23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    9/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 9

    Brand Associations: By being associated with Amir Khan, M.S. Dhoni, Rani Mukherjee it

    has clearly communicated that this watch is the choice of Leaders.

    CBBE Model for Titan Watches

    In the CBBE model, Titan is undoubtedly in the Resonance stage. People used Titan

    watches over time and they seem quite satisfied and happy with their experience, which

    explains the repeat purchases. Titan as a brand is extremely strong and also has delivered

    Wrist Watches

    Pocket Watches

    Reliable, Sturdy,

    Long lasting or durable,

    Chronographs, alarms,

    Available in diff prices

    Stylish and trendy,

    No. of models, Colours,

    Segmented approach,

    Huge no of outlets

    High Quality,

    Trustworthy,

    Superior, likeable

    Pride,

    Status,

    Social Approval

    Loyalty,

    Attachment,

    Sense of community

    Brand Response

    (What about you?)

    Brand Meaning

    (What are you?)

    Brand Identity

    (Who are you?)

    Resonance

    Judgement

    Performance

    Brand Salience

    Feelings

    Imagery

    Brand Loyalty

    (What about you & me?)

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    10/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 10

    its promise over the years. So, there is a sense of satisfaction/accomplishment when the

    product is used, which in turn means Titan has connected extremely well with its target

    audience through all its brands. Customers feel attached to Titan watches and hence exhibit

    great loyalty towards it.

    TITAN in various Brand Ratings

    In 2001, Indian consumers rated Titan as Most Admired Brand in India in a first ever

    survey done by Brand Equity.

    In 2011, TITAN is ranked 73rd in Economic Times Brand Equity Indias Most Trusted

    Brands.

    According to the Brand Trust Report, India Study, 2011, Titan is at no 10 among the

    total of 16000 brands studied in the report. Titan brand won the Most Valuable Brand in the State award at the IIPM & The

    Sunday Times STATE EXCELLENCE AWARD

    Both Titan and Sonata feature in the Top 100 Brands-2009 in the Annual Survey

    conducted by Economic Times. While Titan is ranked at Number 4, Sonata increase

    their rank to 86. Titan is ranked number 1 in the consumer durables category.

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    11/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 11

    TITANs Brands Architecture

    Brand architecture goes beyond the visual/graphic naming relationship of brands and sub-

    brands. It is about the overall experience created for your customer segments.

    The Titan brand architecture comprises of several sub-brands:

    Titan Edge - world's slimmest watch based on the philosophy less is more,

    Titan Raga - feminine and sensuous accessory for today's woman,

    Nebula - crafted with solid 18k gold and precious stones.

    Several other popular collections like Heritage, Aviator, Automatic, Regalia, Obaku, HTSE

    also form a part of the Titan portfolio. Generally brand architecture comprises of two major

    tiers. The top tier happens to be the corporate brand, TITAN and the second tier comprises

    of sub-brands, Nebula, Heritage.

    Tier One focus: Companies that develop the corporate or parent brand as the

    umbrella for overall products and services.

    Tier Two focus: Companies that primarily support their product/service brands.

    A New Tier: One of the most innovative solutions is to create a new model that introduces a

    new, third tier sitting between the parent and the product/service brands. This tier serves as

    a platform for marketing efforts that is valuable from a number of perspectives. In the TITAN

    portfolio of high premium watches, there seems to be a mismatch for the Tier twoapproaches. TITAN corporate brand covers the Connoisseur segment watches but at the

    same time these brands are on their own. A brand portraying the elegance is missing, which

    might help TITAN to attract customers in that segment. TITAN which is basically known for

    its product catering to semi premium segments, the high end segment requires more

    branding and attention.

    TITANs Brand Hierarchy Evaluation

    The brand hierarchy of TITAN is apt. The core brand acts as the umbrella brand which

    represents the institution as a whole. The sub brand identities of Nebula, Aviator, and

    heritage are great and delivered their promise of elegance. The below diagram shows how

    the brand has delivered, feeling of elegance and superiority right from the attribute level to

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    12/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 12

    the highest level,. TITAN as a brand has been very conservative in approach but still has

    managed to push itself as a sought after brand in the young generation.

    TITANs fit in a broader brand portfolio

    The TITAN portfolio owns around 60% of domestic market share in organized watch market.

    The TITAN brand has been extended to eye wear, which retails sunglasses under the fast

    track brand. It has overall developed a sense of homely and indigenous product which has

    mastered the latest technology and offers a wide range of products.

    TITANs Growth strategy Assessment

    Titan Industries Ltd has posted an increased sales turnover during the third quarter of the

    fiscal by 40 per cent from Rs.105.85crore to Rs147.97crore in the current year while the

    Something Bigger

    Elegant, Feeling

    Superior

    Functional Benefit

    Durable

    Emotional End Benefit

    Socially Acceptable.

    Attributes

    Time, Good, Sharp

    Colour

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    13/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 13

    company's profit after tax has gone up by 28 per cent from Rs1.37crore to Rs1.96crore

    During the nine month period, Titan's watch sales rose from 31.38 lakh pieces to 36.90 lakh

    units marking a growth of 18 per cent, led by brands like Regalia, Raga, Fastback, Sonata

    (plastic) and its newly launched Dash labels. The growth has been exceptionally great and is

    attributed to the following factors.

    The Customer and Market Focus checks how the company determines customer

    groups

    Strategic Planning criterion examines how the company develops strategic objectives

    The Information and Analysis criteria check whether the organisation has key metrics

    in place

    The Human Resources Focus checks the appraisal system, the work environment

    Process management examines the product design, production and delivery process

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    14/23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    15/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 15

    H0: Geography is independent of familiarity with brand

    HI: Geography is dependent on familiarity with brand

    The results from the test gave a p-value (probability) of less than 0.05, which indicates that

    there is enough statistical evidence to reject the null hypothesis. Therefore, geography does

    have an influence on whether the respondent will be familiar with the brand.

    Chi-Square Tests

    Value d

    Asp. Sig. (2-

    sided)

    Pearson Chi-

    Square

    5.033a 4 .004

    Likelihood Ratio 5.427 4 .006

    N of Valid Cases 248

    Brand Attitude

    The second brand characteristic that was investigated was Attitude towards the TITAN

    brand. Attitudes are usually measured with multi-attribute scales that are suitable for survey

    research, such as a Liker scale.

    1. Correlation Tests between Geography and Brand Attitude Variables

    (Likeability, Quality, Attractive, Desirable & Superior)

    Coefficients

    Model Unstandardized

    Coefficients

    Standardized

    Coefficients

    t Sig.B Std. Error Beta

    1 Constant .240 1.046 .230 .019

    Likeability -.381 .341 -.230 -1.116 .021

    Quality .698 .267 .483 2.609 .012

    Attractive

    ness

    -.115 .272 -.086 -.421 .076

    Desire -.108 .267 -.094 -.407 .460

    Superior .354 .285 .265 1.242 .221

    a. Dependent Variable: Geography

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    16/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 16

    2. Correlation Tests between Gender and Brand Attitude Variables (Likeability,

    Quality, Attractive, Desirable & Superior).

    Variables

    Score d Sig.

    Step 0 Variables Likeability .639 1 .024

    Quality .250 1 .017

    Attractiveness .462 1 .550

    Desire .436 1 .039

    Superior .518 1 .472

    Overall Statistics .769 5 .979

    Dependent Variable: Gender

    Attitude- Product

    1. Correlation Tests between Geography and Product Attitude Variables

    (Interesting, beneficial, fond of, value for money, exceptional).

    11

    Model

    Unstandardized Coefficients

    Standardized

    Coefficients

    t Sig.B Std. Error Beta1 (Constant) -.265 1.222 -.217 .029

    Interesting .416 .284 .317 1.466 .015

    Beneficial .014 .301 .008 .048 .006

    Fond of -.396 .245 -.333 -1.612 .015

    Value for money .438 .258 .273 1.702 .006

    Exceptional .126 .300 .094 .421 .076

    a. Dependent Variable: Geography

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    17/23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    18/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 18

    The p-value for this test is 0.03, indicating that there is enough statistical evidence to reject

    the Null hypothesis. It was found that there is a significant difference between the means of

    the various geographic groups.

    Whether there is a relationship between Desire for the Brand and Product Usage

    A one-way variance test was applied to determine whether there was a difference in the

    means

    Between those respondents who have used TITAN products and their level of desire for the

    Brand. The null hypothesis and alternative hypothesis for this test is:

    H0: Desire for the brand is not related to Usage of TITAN products

    HI: Desire for the brand is related to Usage of TITAN products

    The results of the test yielded a p-value of less than 0.01, which indicates that there is

    enough Statistical evidence to reject the null hypothesis. The results indicate that the desire

    of those Respondents who have used TITAN products is stronger.

    Behavioural Tendencies

    The fifth brand characteristic that was investigated was the specific Behavioural

    Tendencies with regard to the usage / purchase of Titan products. The information that was

    sought included:

    Which ethnic group is the majority user of Titan products?

    How many respondents have used TITAN products as well as products from category?

    Comparison of the three geographic groups that were analysed throughout the study and

    identifies which geographic group has the most positive usage behaviour of Titan products.

    A chi square test was applied to analyse whether there is a dependence of Geography

    (variable 1) on used Titan products (variable 2). The null hypothesis and alternative

    hypothesis for this test are:

    H0: Geography is independent of product usage

    HI: Geography is dependent on product usage

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    19/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 19

    The results of the test yielded a p-value of 0.046 which indicates that there is enough

    statistical evidence to reject the null hypothesis. Therefore, ethnicity does have an influence

    on whether the consumer has used any Titan products.

    Value Proposition

    The sixth, and final, brand characteristic that was investigated was the Value Proposition of

    the brand. The information that was sought included:

    The ability to determine which ethnic group places the most / least emphasis on functional,

    emotional and self-expressive benefits as sought by the brand / products. Only one test was

    found to be statistically significant. The result of a one-way analysis of variance test of

    geography (variable 1) and functional benefits sought by the using the brand (variable 2).

    The null and alternative hypotheses are as follows:

    H0:south India =North India=west India=east India=central India

    HI: At least one of the means of these populations differs

    The p-value for this test is 0.01, indicating that there is enough statistical evidence to reject

    the null hypothesis. After the Bonferroni adjustment and the post-hoc test, it was found that

    there is a significant difference between the means of the various geographic groups.

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    20/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 20

    Summary of the Statistically Significant Tests ( = 0.05)

    Brand Characteristic Variable1Variable 2

    Statistic Test

    employed p-value

    Brand awareness Geography

    Familiarity with

    brand

    Chi-square

    0.004

    Brand attitude

    Geography Likeability

    Linear regression

    0.021

    Geography Quality 0.012

    Geography Attractive 0.076

    Geography Desire 0.46

    Geography Superior 0.221

    Gender Likeability

    Logistic regression

    0.024

    Gender Quality 0.017

    Gender Attractive 0.55

    Gender Desire 0.039

    Gender Superior 0.472

    Attitude -product

    Geography Interesting

    Linear regression

    0.015

    Geography Beneficial 0.006

    Geography Fond of 0.015

    Geography

    Value for

    money0.006

    Geography Exceptional 0.076

    Income bracket Interesting

    Linear regression

    0.006

    Income bracket Beneficial 0.032

    Income bracket Fond of 0.042

    Income bracket

    Value for

    money

    0.041

    Income bracket Exceptional 0.078

    Desirability Geography

    Positive

    towards the

    brand

    one way Anova

    0.03

    Behavioural

    Tendencies

    Geography

    Preference to

    the brandone way Anova

    0.01

    Geography

    Loyalty to the

    brandone way Anova

    0.046

    Value preposition

    Geography

    Emotional

    benefitsone way Anova

    0.01

    Geography

    Self-expressive

    benefitsone way Anova

    0.01

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    21/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    Section B Group 13 Page 21

    TITAN- BRAND EQUITY PYRAMID BASED EMPIRICAL RESEARCH

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    22/23

  • 7/31/2019 brandaudittitan-111201005711-phpapp02

    23/23

    Great Lakes Institute of Management

    S ti B G 13 P 23

    The company can have tie-ups with schools and colleges across the country and can increase its

    market penetration by recommending the educational institutions to offer their products to the new

    students. Also the company must try to understand the emerging consumer needs in the young

    generation and try to be updated and also some disruptive technological innovation like having a

    radio tuner card in a watch, health monitor incorporated in a watch, having a speedometer, digital

    camera etc. to stay abreast with the competition and maintain and grow market share.

    Titan can extend into new markets like wallets, handbags, clothes etc. before any of its competitors

    in this product category would enter and thereby increase its brand equity and develop long term

    relationships with its customers.

    References

    1. http://www.trustadvisory.info/allindia.html

    2. http://www.titanworld.com/country/in/the-titan-story

    3. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/topbrands.cms

    4. http://www.trustadvisory.info/allindia.html

    5. http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=brand+titan+&aq=f

    6. Strategic brand management, third edition, by Kevin lane Keller

    7. http://www.infibeam.com/Watches/Titan.xhtml

    8. http://www.managementparadise.com/tirthsoni/documents/535/

    9. http://www.authorstream.com/Presentation/Hamid403-642094-product-and-brand-

    managment/