24
Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p. m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments Approval Minutes for the December 18, 2018 meeting. New Business 1. Request of David Robison for a variance to allow the construction of a swimming pool enclosure located 6 feet from the rear lot line, in lieu of the required rear setback of 10 feet. Located at 1491 Summerland Avenue Zoned R- 1AA 2. Request of Jeanne Atkinson for variances to allow the construction of a room addition and a garage conversion into a cabana with a minor addition on a property which currently has a nonconforming side setback of 9. 9 feet in lieu the required setback of 13 feet to the south side lot line. Located at 900 N. Park Ave Zoned R- 1AA appeals & assistance If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Board with respect to any matter considered at this hearing, a record of the proceedings is needed to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. F. S. 286. 0105 Persons with disabilities needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact the City Clerk' s Office 407- 599- 3277 at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.

Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    7

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

Board of Adjustments

January 15, 2019 at 5 p. m.

Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida

Opening comments

Approval

Minutes for the December 18, 2018 meeting.

New Business

1. Request of David Robison for a variance to allow the

construction of a swimming pool enclosure located 6 feetfrom the rear lot line, in lieu of the required rear setback

of 10 feet.

Located at 1491 Summerland Avenue Zoned R- 1AA

2. Request of Jeanne Atkinson for variances to allow the

construction of a room addition and a garage conversion

into a cabana with a minor addition on a property whichcurrently has a nonconforming side setback of 9. 9 feet inlieu the required setback of 13 feet to the south side lot

line.

Located at 900 N. Park Ave Zoned R- 1AA

appeals & assistance

If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Board with respect to any matter considered at this hearing, arecord of the proceedings is needed to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the

testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. F. S. 286. 0105

Persons with disabilities needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact the City Clerk' s Office407- 599- 3277 at least 48 hours in advance of the meeting.

Page 2: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

T0: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS MEMBERS

FROM: GEO GE WIGGINS, DIRECTOR OF BLDG/ LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS

1 ` DATE: JANUARY 15, 2019

SUBJ: ROBISON VARIANCE REQUEST, 1491 SUMMERLAND AVENUE

CITT of WLNRE AND IIERITAQE

The applicant is requesting a variance to allow the constructionCITT OF WINTER DARK of a swimming pool enclosure located 6 feet from the rear lot

line-_wher_eas--th_e_required rear setback is'- 1-0- feet.

401 Park Avenue South The swimming pool on this property was originally built in 1988and complied with the required setbacks for a pool without an,

enclosure: 5' to rear lot line to deck and 10' to rear lot line to

Winter Park, Florida the water' s edge of the pool. The applicants state that theyhave lived there 19 years and need to have the pool enclosed

due to extreme sensitivity to mosquito bites. In addition the32789- 4386 placement of a portion of the pool closer to the rear lot line

requires that a screen enclosure come within inches of the spa

portion of the pool leaving inadequate distance to walk aroundthis pool at this one location.

The high point of the proposed dome shaped enclosure ( 14. 5

feet) is at the furthest distance away for the rear lot line with itsloping downward at the rear to a height of 10. 5 feet at the 6foot setback. At the rear of this property, the applicants have adense hedge which they estimate to be 8 feet in height to actas a buffer to the neighbor to the rear.

With respect to allowable area for the new pool enclosure, the

new total area with be 1, 378 square feet with an allowable area

of 1, 431 square feet after adding unused floor area of thehome ( 341 square feet). No new impervious coverage is beingadded.

A letter of non- objection has been provided from the abuttingneighbor at the rear from residents of 1500 Cardinal Court.

www. cityofwinterpark. org

Page 3: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

VARIANCE APPLECATIONBUILDING and PERMITTING SERVICED DEPARTMENT

Building & Permitting Department Date Received401 South Park Avenue AssignedWinter Park, FL 32739

Date of HearingPh: 407- 599-3237

Applicant:Owner: i f AIM

77

A dress) Addy ss

City, State ZIP) City, State) Zip)Phone- Home) Phone - Home)

Phone- Work or Cell)

elI

Phone - Work or Cell)

Email Address) Email Address)

If the applicant is not the owner, attach a copy of the purchase contract, or option on theproperty, or a letter signed by the owner of record authorizing the applicant to act as an agentfor the owner.

This request is for a variance from requirements of Article III, Zoning of the Land DevelopmentCode of Winter Park, Section E, l I , Subsection_( dl_, Zoning 12- 1

State briefly( Clearly Printed or Word Processed) answers to all questions.Note: Submit E- Mail address to have application forwarded to you for word processing.Street address of

property / edi 's.

Legal descriptio' of

wwepropertfJ

Describe variancerequest

This section may be left blank for completion by city staff'sResidential Fee-$ 200. 00/ Commercial, Multi- Family Fee-$ 400. 00 payable upon submission ofapplication.( The fee is doubled for after- the- fact requests.) Applicants tabled at the request ofthe applicant, within 10 days of the Planning and Zoning meeting or Board of Adjustmentmeeting will be charged for addition advertising and notification costs, plus$ 100. 00.

Page 4: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

Variance ApplicationPage 2 of 2

What are the special conditions and circumstances, peculiar to the land, structures or buildingsinvolved?

How long have you owned the property?

How long have you occupied the property?

What rights or privileges commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district willthe applicant be deprived of because of enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance?

441, 40- 40EE

r

Describe fully the hardship ( from zoning requirements) upon which this request is based, bespecific in describing the hardship and give all reasons explaining why you need to vary fromthe Zoning Code requirements. Dote: Financial reasons are not considered a hardship.

Iffy

Will' applicant accept a limited variance? For example: Height, lengths, position, etc. of signs,

fences, shrubbery, enclosures of structures or carports, parking spaces, etc? If so, to whatextent?

04

gn e f Ap cant ate Ram e of Applicant ( PRINT)

Vanance app ] 2 0 - Instru tions, and setback sheet- attached.

Page 5: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

L

INSCt

Q

La

I

o

A

N

i

A

Q

CwdinalCt

b

f!

StewartStCDr

y

i

7-

14'd__

44

X99

t5al

Ido

u

eh

d

A

CL

Z

i'`

1

RaintreePI

Page 6: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

12/ 18/ 2018

Variance Narrative

David Robison

1491 Summerland Ave.

Winter Park, Fl.

Requesting an approval of 4 feet into a 10 foot rear setback for a pool enclosure onexisting slab to have ingress, egress around pool waters edge that was built by previousOwner in 1988. Also, this requested encroachment is for only 27 of the 100 feet acrossthe back of the property.

The main reason for this request is because of a hypersensitivity to mosquito bites byMother and Daughter, as well as needing access around pool waters edge on existingslab.

As seen in photos, there are high foliage walls on side and rear walls of proposed area

and the neighbors adjoining the proposed encroachment have signed a letter of consentattached).

The proposed pool enclosure was designed to take up the minimum amount ofencroached area and with the surrounding walls and foliage would be virtuallyunnoticed.

Page 7: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

Date: 12/ 19/ 18

To: City of Winter Park, Building Dept and Florida Pool Enclosures

From: Garland and Lisa Gould

Re: e.g. Setbackfor Pool Enclosure

To Whom it Concerns,

We reside at 1500 Cardinal Court and share a common property line at the back of our lotwith our neighbors of more than 15 years, David and Deborah Robison at 1491 Summerland

Avenue.

The Robisons have submitted application with the city to build a pool enclosure and that

screen wall closest to our property line is going approximately 4 feet into the 10-foot setback.

The screen wall will be significantly blocked by our existing hedge and fence plus theRobison' s plant covered lattice screen, both of which are over 8 feet tall and run the entirelength of the proposed pool screen wall.

We do not have an issue with this minor variance.

k9hature(SN

z,r

Printed name

Page 8: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

3UNDART SURVEY FOR/ CERTIFIED TO: David Robinson and Deborah Robinson

Winderweedle, Haines, Ward 6 Woodman, P. A.. Attorneys' Title Insurance Fund, Inc.

Suss Financial, Inc.

ESCRIMON AS FORAI5B73D: Lot 11 and the South 41 feet of Lot 12, Block C. WINFLOR COURT, as recorded in Plat Book k,

ige 33, Public Records of Orange County, Florida.

NI

1

dlI

I

II

II

I

I

1.

ewuVDaR eo LOT Is SweK C. I

I e. 19! 5. 00' ISir Ys' t. t. ew

e. et' 4S wM1L: U. M eft M- LH:f 4SlGNO VD.

e f• ,

STEPl

M.

i

4T. 4'

O

r r GONG. O0..

M N

D

t' MR11 41ow

eCOV• D•

CoLIlT1'!.

a Come. S1. xlc' G' 7

0 PAWK

jO [+

6e j fp16.

O

1r LOT 11 Y

u 1

POOL

e

e

1S1 • K.' 6'

A

S

Vr

74e• •

lt1

b

ON

yp.IG. e. r 6 Vii)

MM. 1' LRI

tfa. I. I.P.

IQC 11 LP.

NO 1. 0. _ YO I.D. __. I s. 00 NO I. D•EAST I e. ft• NeefN

I LOT IO1

aaa( sK • G.

I

Q/L

GRUSENMEYER- SCOTT & ASSOC. INC. -- LAND SURVEYORS5400 E. COLOWIAL DR. ORLANM FL 32807 ( 4M 277,-M2 FAX.( 407) 01438

w.f e : cewtw`'- r u, olt NOTES: 1. TN! UNDMIMM OM" 11111M M. W- V TMW TMS PJIVMY MEET! TM U04OKM TECHNICAL 1nANOMM MT FCWM Ne. le• e . ee- TM? RArM A MAM OF 10" CIM810MAL LAW N ItIaNO 19 NI CNA" M N10ri• f FIDIMM AOMNI. STpATNE CODE TURIUAIHT

cv. o• a,. a.• ew.. • . oa• se• wrw 10887 M47.1-W ArDIMOAIDQLREf.a• nlv. lw.

Ice. wee v. . mer 1 Z Inn.rae t fiG3IdU M'. TN tURVf10K' 8 SEAL TMs BUpVEY is M01 MLW AND 0 MIESENYED F011 001MMATIONAL

Page 9: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

N

e

r

iv

33'' 10•oy0.

Florida Pool Enclosures Job# 161381 tax;:

City of Winter Park The locations of doors are incidental to the

922 HickorySt. ProjectAd' design.

David Robison date: Girts remain the same throughout the design

Altamonte Springs, FL 01/ 07/ 19 scale: NTS unless otherwise noted.

407- 260- 2800 1491 Summerland Ave. Dimensions are to center ofwalls and members.

fax 407- 260- 6411 Winter Park, FL 32789prep bY' Allen Thompson length given for knee braces represents

horizontal and vertical displacements.

Page 10: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

N0s

CONTINUOUS PERIMETER FOOTING 10

O /\ 3000 PSI. MIN.) 8' X12X3'

2) A5 REBAR. CONTINUOUS tu

6P

3" MIN, CONC. COVER. 24• MIN. dUP SPLICE EXISTING DECK

C ti

O Ln N

SCREEN AREA1277 SQ. FT.suvvoaT

HOST STRUCTURE L7 ,.. I

LU

7" SUPER GUTTER Ln HU

2X2XO. 044 F 2X2X0044\

KNEE BRACE ` BEAM PER PLAN BEAM PER PLANROOF BEAM F

PER PLAM V

co

T 36' VERT. ROOF BEAM J 00 0

12 PLC' S) 2X2XOO44 gPERP UN J 0

U. N. O.) PURLIN T 045 RECEIVING CHANNEL a

BEAM PER1/ 8^% 2•% 2-% SURFACE LENGTH ANGLE E/ S

coFPLAN cY)

COL PER PUNLENGTH= BEAM SIZE L FASTEN ANGLE LEG TO CARRIER BEAMN10X 3/ 4" SMS INTO Z a W/ N10 X 14' SMS THROUGH ANGLE LEG W

INTERSECT"N R ECT" BEAM E/ S S Z Q U2R

6 INTO

ILAMANNER- SEEANGLE LEG TO SMBO ,

mSIO Mr FOR OUANIN SEE TABLE& 1" ^ E m

Z Q O QIN SIMILAR MANNER- SEE TABLE S1 FOR

R ALTERNATELY. SIDE VIEW

FASTENER OUANTITV U

N2X2XO. 044 1/ B' X2" X2"%SURFACE

JC> _V

PURLIN FRONT VIEW LENGTH ANGLE ES w _ pooN10% 3/ 4'$ MS INTO

TABLE S- 1-

J (n

INTERSECTING BEAM E/ SSMB TO CARRIER

MAIN BEAM TO CARRIER BEAM wLL C

OFOR OUAMTY SEE TABLE St- SCREWS

CONNECTION SCALE: NTSQl I L-

f +° Z W N

ro Xxi

BEAM TO BEAM CONNECTION D ~_ co C2% 2X0. 044 SCALE: NTSPURLIN z p

O)

T GABLE ENDQ C(

m

z xxv 2% 2x0. 044

PURLIN

F_ 04

40

N

NO p o

M2X2% 0. 044 2X8 SMB LL 00PURLIN

x I'

7O f

2%4X0. 050iv X y

Zm

2X2XO. 044CHAIR ry

7X2 0.8. Vui

1X2 O. B. L6'- 94'- 6'- 94-'- 6'- 94" 6' 94" 6'• 6' 4" 6'- 84"L i

O

347.-

43..

5'- 11" 15"- 38" d

3.

POOL ENCLOSURE PLAN

4

O21'- 28"

684

FRAMING ELEVATION - iU)

FRAMING ELEVATION - 2w

I)

2% 2x0. 044

O

Page 11: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

12/ 12/ 2018 IMG_ 1091. jpg

Olr

AOP

https: Hmail. google. com/ mail/ u/ 0/# inbox? projector- 1 1/ 1

Page 12: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

12/ 12/ 2018 IMG_ 1090. jpg

y

pM;

w

https:// mail.google. com/ mail/ u/ 0/# inbox/ FMfcgxvzMBpBTMSngkxdTWXLQXDZWWhN? projector- 1& messagePartld= 0. 7 1/ 1

Page 13: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

12/

12/

2018

IMG_

1089.jpg

a

t

e

V

Ap

y1

fi4«.

drily.!'

i

Q111ff66`6̀r,

t ¢

https://mail.

google.com/mail/u/

O/#

inbox?

projector--1

Page 14: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

5•.

e

a

1 `

a

R' .

fid=

t

Air

144

law

i

3

j

any'

w ._-

1 ' !.

a- ,,

i~

o

r

1

4-•

1

Page 15: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

SETBACK/ COVERAGE WORKSHEET

For Single Family Zoning Districts( R- 1A, R- 1AA& R- 1AAA) i

Address: 1491 Summerland Ave. Winter Park, FL 32789 Lot width 2: 101. 00'

Submitted by: Florida Pool Enclosures Lot area': 13, 625

Maximum% Existing Additional New Total Maximum

Allowed Area" Proposed Area" Area Allowed Area

IMPERVIOUS LOT COVERAGE. 2 story- 50%Include bldg footprint, driveways, sidewalks, patios, swimming

pools, A/ C pads, artificial turf, etc. 1 story- 60% 6559.38 43.2 6602. 58 8175

Lots< 11, 600 sf:

Use 38% Base FAR or w/ increasedFLOOR AREA RATIO ( F. A. R.)

5, 6, 7

side setbacks: 43% Max FARFor one and two story bldgs( include 1st& 2nd floors,

Lots 11,600 sf to 13,600 sfgarages/ carports, stair areas on both floors, areas on 2nd floors

which are open to the 1 stfloors,

and accessory Bldgs. Use 4. 500 Base area&sf

EXCLUDE- pool screen enclosure areas and certain open front, 5. 200 sf Maximum area

9 Lots> 13, 600 sf133

side& rear porches .

Use 33% Base FAR or w/ increased 14 d 444016side setbacks: 38% Max FAR

SCREEN POOL ENCLOSURE 8%10

1334. 65 43. 2 1378 1; 6=8 : jI lL}-

Minimum% n scape Area New Total Minimum

Re uiredExisting

Area11

Reduggd11

Area Required AreaFFRONTARD LANDSCAPE COVERAGE

ped green areas- exclude hard surfaces and all50%

ay surfaces( pervious& impervious).

ot Area:NOTES:

1. Windsong& Waterbridge may use these standards, except lot types A, B,& C in Windsong. Provisions on side articulations& accessory bldgs are mandatory.

2. Lot width measured at the front bldg line across lot. The bldg line is located at the required front setback for vacant lots or front bldg wall closest to the street of existing homes. For unusual( pie) shaped lots, an average lot width may beutilized as measured between the front setback line and the required rear setback line or shall be determined by the Building Director. For a proposed home, determine the front setback as described on page 2.

3. Submerged lands or land across the street shall not be included.

4. Percentage based on the lot area.

5. One story homes with a sloping roof, 12: 12 or less, may utilize the maximum RA.R. and may provide roof dormers, 8 ft. maximum width and 2.5 ft. back from the required setback, occupying 45% of roof area within the same roof plane.6. Area forming a room behind 2nd floor walls shall be included in the gross floor area.

7. See page 3 on how to achieve maximum F.A.R.

8. Vautled and cathedral ceiling areas count twice if the height from the floor to the ceiling is 17.5 feet or greater.9. The area of open front porches and entries may be excluded from the gross floor area subject to a maximum area of 400 square feet. The area within an open or screened rear and/or side porches, lanai, porte cochere or other covered

areas may be excluded from the gross floor area up to 500 sf of floor area. On 2nd floor, rear and/or side porches shall have an exterior sides that are 75% open in order to utilized up to 300 sf of the total 500 sf excludable gross floor area.

10. Any area not already used in the permitted floor area ratio( FAR) may be added to this 8% for additional screened pool enclosure area.11. These columns only apply to existing homes. pan i6) PAGE 1

Page 16: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

T0: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS MEMBERS

FROM: GEORGE WIGGINS, DIRECTOR OF BLDG/ LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS

1 " DATE: JANUARY 15, 2019

d. SUBJ: ATKINSON VARIANCE REQUEST, 900 NORTH PARK AVENUE

ITT of CVLTt1RE AND HERITAGE

The applicant is requesting variances to allow the construction

CITY OF WINTER DARK of a room addition and a garage conversion into a cabana with

a. minor___addition on- a- property which currently has a-nonconforming side setback of 9. 9 feet in lieu the required

401 Park Avenue South setback of 13 feet to the south side lot line.

The request includes increasing the height of an existing 7 footWinter Park, Florida high masonry wall and roofing this area as a bathroom and

closet area of with 143 square feet of space. In addition, the

applicant proposes to enclose with a glazed opening an existing32789-4386 open area under roof line on a rear single car garage. The

remainder of the garage will also be converted into a poolcabana.

Overall, the request is unusual in that there' s no exterior

additions to the existing home and rear garage building butonly enclosures that exceed the floor area ratio based onhaving an existing nonconforming 9. 9 foot side setback to aportion of the home. The nonconforming side setback limits thefloor area ratio to 33% which for this lot size ( 18, 050 sf) is a

limit of 5, 956 square feet. The total new area is 239 squarefeet.

One factor that minimizes this request is that the portion of the

home which has the 9. 9 foot side setback is only 20 feet inlength on the south side of the property representing a smallportion of the entire home. The remainder of the home is

within inches of meeting the required setbacks.

No letters has been provided for this request at this point in

time.

www. cityofwinterpark. org

Page 17: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

CITY OF WINTER PARKVARIANCE APPLICATION

BUILDING and PERMITTING SERVICES DEPARTMENT

Building & Permitting Department Date Received 9a 2 1 9-401 South Park Avenue AssignedWinter Park, FL 32789 Date of Hearing 11 iyj 1, 1Ph: 407- 599- 3237

Applicant: Owner: 5F,4A1 5 #Tfcia.

Address) Address)

City, State) Zip) City, State) Zip)

Phone– Home-) Phone– Home)

Phone– Work or Cell)4403–J '

P e– Work or Cell)h 0 eAnn6 M4_!l. CftK

Email Address) 5-:mail Addres )

If the applicant is not the owner, attach a copy of the purchase contract, or option on theproperty, or a letter signed by the owner of record authorizing the: applicant to act as an agentfor the owner.

This request is for a variance.from requirements of Article III, Zoning of the Land DevelopmentCode of Winter Park, Section 59 66 , Paragraph r- Zonings_.

State briefly (Clearly Printed or Word Processed) answers to all questions.Note: Submit E- Mail address to have application forwarded to you for word processing.Street address of

propertyLegal description of

property / oLF l/ i, e jZ GG G1yZ G677 y' N Zoe ®F 407`

Describe variance

request z6. 5- 1. P/Asr FLo4 57sT3. 4c-k PF J3 gxis7 we— /s le i

3yf,5-X 5F,40aD 6460 5Er' OF 17' 0Xi S 2,yal- / S # `

This section may be left blank for completion by city staff*Residential Fee-$ 200. 00 / Commercial, Multi- Family Fee-$400. 00 payable upon submission ofapplication.( The fee is doubled for after- the- fact requests.) Applicants tabled at the request ofthe applicant, within 10 days of the Planning and Zoning meeting or Board of Adjustmentmeeting will be charged for addition advertising and notification costs, plus $ 100. 00.

Page 18: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

Variance ApplicationS Q[ r'J f It-Page 2 of 2 I

What are the special conditions and circumstances., peculiar to the land, structures or buildingsinvolved?

How long have you owned the property? 9 o t ;

How long have you occupied the property? 67/ AOMM,S

What rights or privileges commonly enjoyed by other properties in. the same zoning district willthe applicant be deprived of because of enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance?

Describe fully the-hardship ( from zoning requirements) upon which this. request is based, bespecific in describing the hardship and give all reasons explaining why you need to vary fromthe Zoning Code requirements. (Vote; Financial reasons are not considered a hardship.

Will applicant accept a limited variance? For example: Height, lengths, position, etc. of signs,fences, shrubbery, enclosures of structures or carports, parking spaces, etc? If so, to whatextent?

Sig ture of Applicant a a Name of Applicant( PRINT)

Variance app 12/ 00 - Instructions,_ and setback sheet- attached.

Page 19: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

I

What are the special conditions and circumstances, peculiar to the land, structures orbuildings involved?

Applicant' s Response: Applicant wishes to create a " mother in law" suite on the first floor of the house

for an elderly parent( 95 yrs. old) that has mobility challenges. The house is constructed in such amanner that there are no other locations on the ground floor for an additional living space save for afront room which needs a small expansion to provide adequate accommodation. The room would be

expanded northerly to construct a bathroom and closet area. The expansion would occur totally withinthe existing wall locations on the north end of the house. The walls presently exist with a small roofoverhang as shown in the picture attached to this application. The small overhang would be replaced bya roof to be aesthetically consistent with the rest of the house.

The other modification would be to glass in the front of a small walkway that accesses a free standingsingle car garage which will be converted into a cabana and a seating area where the walkway presentlyexists. This would allow the aging parent to spend time in the pool area within a climate controlledenvironment.

What rights or privileges commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning districtwill the applicant be deprived of because of enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance?

Granting the request will not confer on the applicant a privilege that is denied by the zoningcode to other lands. Indeed, granting the request will be in harmony with the general purposeand intent of the zoning code. Additionally, the granting of a variance must not be injurious to

the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. The variance provides little

to no visual impact from the outside of the property.

Describe fully the hardship ( from zoning requirements) upon which this request is based, be

specific in describing the hardship and give all reason explaining why you need to vary fromthe Zoning Code Requirements. ( Vote: Financial reasons are not considered a hardship.

It is applicant' s understanding that the maximum gross square footage allowed on the subject

property has been allocated to the structure as designed. Part of the structure that existed at

purchase are the walls and small overhang located on the front of the residence. Applicant will

be able to enclose the area that now exists and to provide a proper roof if a variance is grantedto a side set back line. The Winter Park Code would allow applicant to build slightly more grossfloor area and would allow the enclosure of the room as set forth above. A review of the

pictures submitted with this application shows the minor nature of the improvement and the

consistence with the existing architecture.

Will applicant accept a limited variance? For example: height, lengths, positon, etc. of signs,

fences, shrubbery, enclosures of structures or carports, parking spaces, etc.? If so, to what

degree:

Yes, applicant will accept all reasonable conditions.

Page 20: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

900 North Park Ave

r, a

z

u,

oz

QL ii s

ML

t Parkjcity

47e

Unlvefwlt Glut)

Of Winter Park

University ClubOf Winter Park

r Ave E Webster Ave

Page 21: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

N

00AIX34V95.00'

I

in

b

i

I

i

I

I

I

i

1

II ZCID m

rA

I

a

I I

N

OOA13"34"

W

95.00'

g

M900PARKAVE

NMI, a

D

Q

rte •,,,....

O

z

900N

PARKAVE

leenApple

S

WINTERPARK,FLORIDA

Archiwep""

4

Zllmmm

u

ROMAUo

w.

oamw

Page 22: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

ARNSETBACK / COVERAGE WORKSHEET

For Single Family Zoning Districts( R- 1A, R- 1AA& R- 1AA#

Address: A&T- Lot width':

Submitted by: Lot area3:

Maximum% Existing Additional New Total Maximum

Allowed`1 Area11

ProposedAreal!

Area Allowed Area

IMPERVIOUS LOT COVERAGE 2 story- 50%Include bldg footprint, driveways, sidewalks, patios, swimming

pools, AIC pads, artificial turf, etc. 1 story- 60%

Lots< 11, 600 sf:

Use 38% Base FAR or w/ increased

FLOOR AREA RATIO [ F. A. R.)5' 6''

side setbacks: 43% Max FAR

For one and two story Bldgs( include 1st&' 2nd floors, Lots 11, 600 sf to 13, 600 sf

garages/ carports,. stair areas on both floors, areas on 2nd floors

which are open to the 1st floor., and accessory bldgs. Use 4. 500• sf' Base area& FA

EXCLUDE- pool screen enclosure areas and certain open front, 5. 200 sf Maximum area 3:9. 3 20

9 Lots> 13, 600 sfside& rear porches..

Use 33% Base FAR or w/ increased S I 2,-3side setbacks: 38% Max FAR

SCREEN POOL ENCLOSURE 8/10

Minimum% 11Lan scape Area New Total Minimum

Re uiredExisting Area

Epaduced11

Area Re uired Area

FRONT YARD LANDSCAPE COVERAGE

Count all landscaped green areas- exclude hard surfaces and all

driveway surfaces( pervious& impervious), 50%

Front Lot Area:VOTES:

1. Windsong& Waterbridge may: use these standards, except lot types A, B,& C in Windsong.. Provisions on side articulations& accessory bldgs are mandatory.

2. Lot width measured at the front bldg line. across lot. The bldg line is located at the required front setback for vacant lots or front bldg wall closest to the street of existing homes: For unusual( pie) shaped. lots, an average lot width maybeutilized as measured between the front setback line and the required rear setback line or shall be determined by the Building Director. For a proposed home, determine the front setback as described on page. 2.

3. Submerged lands or land across the street shall not be included.

4. Percentage based on the lot area.

5. One story homes with a sloping roof, 12: 12 or less, may utilize the maximum F,A, R. and may provide•roof dormers, 8 ft. maximum width and 2,5 ft. back from the required setback, occupying 45% of roof area.wilhin the same roof plane.6. Area forming a room behind 2nd floor walls shall be included to the gross. floor area.7. See page 3 on how to achieve maximum F.A. R.

8. Vaulted and cathedral ceiling areas count twice if the height from the floor to the ceiling is 17. 5 feet or greater.

9. The area of open front porches and entries may be excluded from the gross floor area subject to a maximum area of 400 square feet. The area within an open or screened rear and/ or side porches, lanai, porte cechere or other covered

areas maybe excluded from the gross floor area up to 500 sf of floor area. On 2nd floor, rear and/ or side porches shall have an exterior sides that are 75% open In order to utilized up to 300 sf of the total 500 sf excludable gross floor area.10 Any area not already used in the permitted floor area ratio( FAR) may be added to this 8% for additional screened' pool enclosure area.11. These columns only apply to existing. homes. Jan 16) PAGE 1

Page 23: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

SETBACKS ( complete boxes A and B. first)

Minimum Allowable Dimensions Existing13,

Proposed

FRONTAverage of 2 adjacent homes on each side. If corner lot,

use 3 adjacent homes. 51sr

SIDES', 21st Floor See 10/

pages

see other side setback options on pg 4) 2nd Floor 3& 4 Z 31

1st Floor 25 ft.I......................................

REAR'1. 4

2nd Floor 35 ft' 731

I............................................... ...... I......... .............................................

Lakefront see note 6

Lot width 5 65 ft. is ft.

1stFloor 1—..........................................------------------------------

CORNER LOT5 ftLot.width> 6

720 ft.

Lot width: 5. 65 ft. is ft.

2ndFloor

Lot width>. 65 ft7

22. 5 ft,

BUILDINGHEIGHT8, s" O" 1, 12

30 ft.- 35 ft. plus 2 ft. or 40 ft. (see notes 11& 12) 77 01-

6

Notes:

1. Any building wall that exceeds 12 ft, in height measured from natural grade to top of wall plate or truss kneewall must meet the setbacks for the 2nd floor.2. Accessory buildings' maximum side wall height( natural grade to roof sheathing) shall not exceed 10. 5 ft. and interior side setback is 5 ft. minimum( no gable end allowed) for garages up to 600.sf, pool cabana up to 500 sf and all other

accessory buildings up to 320 sf. Other accessory buildings used for habitation shall meet setbacks of the main residence.

3. Rear setbacks for properties abutting non- residential zoned. R- 3/ RA, or a permanent stormwater retention area over 25 ft. in width may be 10 ft. For lots that are 7511 deep or less a first floor setback of 10ft and a second floor setback of

25ft Is allowed, For lots which are 105ft deep or less a first Poor setback of 15ft and a second floor setback of 30ft is allowed,4. Accessory buildings: garagetcarport up to.820 sf, pool cabana up to 500 sf and storage bldg up to 320 sf'- minimum rear setback shall be 10 ft.. Other accessory buildings used for habitation shall meet setbacks of the main residence,5, The rear setback may be, reduced to 25 ft. for two- story components when those consist of a second story loft or mezzanine that is within the normal scale and 18- ft max height of atypical one- story structure.6. Require Planning& Zoning commission approval. Lakefront setback is based on the average setback establish by the adjacent residences within 200 It. or 50 I' Li whichever is greater, measured from ordinary high water line,7. Setbacks given are measured on the side yard adjacent to the streetA lots over 75 ft, with 1st and 2nd floor setbacks of 25 ft. may reduce the rear setback by 5 ft. on each floor.

8. Building height is the vertical distance measured from the average elevation of the existing lot grade measured directly adjacent to the front of Hie building or proposed building.9. No building or portion thereof shall exceed 30 ft. In height except for homes with a. roof slope of 8; 12 or greater may be permitted to have 2 ft. additional building height..

10. Accessory building that exceeds 18 ft. in height shall meet the same setbacks as the principal building on the property,11. Properties or lots with at least 80 ft. of width at the building line are permitted to have a building height of 35 ft. if the side setbacks are increased to 20 ft. at 30 ft, above the side lot line. Exception: homes. with a roof slope of 8: 12. or

greater are permitted 2 ft. of additional building height.12; Properties or lots exceeding. 50, 000 sq, ft. in size with at least 100fiwidth at the building line may be permitted building heights of 40 ft, if side setbacks are Increased to 35 ft. to the portion of the roof over 30 ft. in height.13. This column only applies to existing homes. Jan 2016) PAGE 2

Page 24: Board of Adjustments · Board of Adjustments January 15, 2019 at 5 p.m. Commission Chambers • City Hall Second Floor 401 South Park Avenue • Winter Park, Florida Opening comments

f

h -

i 1

x

li IlliR

1

I

900 PARK AVE