Upload
peter26194
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
1/9
Engin eering 1000
Add it ion: Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculat ions
Adapted from original course notes developed by R. Hornsey
B. M. Quine
B. M. QuineBOTE 2
Outl ine
n What is a back-of-the-envelope calculation and why is it
useful?
n Examples
n General approaches
n Excercises
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
2/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 3
What & Why?
n Often during brainstorming, discussions, out in the field
engineers need to make rapid estimates
n to eliminate candidate solutions
n establish feasibility
n sketch out potential paths to a solution
n Although most engineers remember key numbers related to
their field, no-one has every detail at their fingertips
n Hence we need to estimate not only the values of numbers we
need, but which numbers are appropriate, and how to perform
the calculation
n the emphasis here is on order of magnitude estimates to the
nearest factor of 10
n it is also important to remember that these are rough estimates and toplace only appropriate reliance on the results
B. M. QuineBOTE 4
Accu racy of calcu lat ions
n A well-known curve of a calculations accuracy versus mental
effort goes like:
% error
effort
errors in various
assumptions cancel
out so rapid apparent
improvement is made
better understanding
may actually make
things worse
hard work means that the
model yields improved results
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
3/9
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
4/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 7
How m any piano tuners in NYC?
n Approximately how many people are in New York City?
n 10,000,000
n Does every individual own a piano?
n No
n Would it be reasonable to assert that "individuals don't tend to
own pianos; families do?
n Yes.
n About how many families are there in a city of 10 million
people?
n Perhaps there are 2,000,000 families in NYC.
n Does every family own a piano?
n No.
n Perhaps one out of every five does.
n That would mean there are about 400,000 pianos in NYC.
B. M. QuineBOTE 8
n How many piano tuners are needed for 400,000 pianos?
n Some people never get around to tuning their piano; some people tune
their piano every month. If we assume that "on the average" every
piano gets tuned once a year, then there are 400,000 "piano tunings"
every year.
n How many piano tunings can one piano tuner do?
n Let's assume that the average piano tuner can tune four pianos a day.
Also assume that there are 200 working days per year. That means
that every tuner can tune about 800 pianos per year.
n How many piano tuners are needed in NYC?n The number of tuners is approximately 400,000/800 or 500 piano
tuners.
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
5/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 9
General p r inciplesn When you use back-of-the-envelope calculations, be sure to
recall Einstein's famous advice.
n everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler
n Dont worry about specific factors
n round to the nearest sensible value
n corollary: dont make numbers more precise than is necessary
n Guess numbers you dont know
n but try to make your guesses good ones and within the bounds of
common sense
n common sense requires some education the accuracy of common
sense increases with experience
n Adjust geometry etc. to suit you
n
assume a human is spherical if it helpsn Extrapolate from what you do know
n e.g. use ratios
n assume unknown value is same as a similar known quantity
B. M. QuineBOTE 10
General pr inc ip les ctd
n Use the principle of conservation
n what goes in must either come out or stay inside
n things are not generally destroyed, so work out where they have gone
n Ensure formulas are dimensionally correct
n i.e. an expression to tell you the length of something must have overalldimensions of metres [THIS IS VERY POWERFUL TECHNIQUE]
n Apply a plausibility filter
n if an answer seems unbelievable, it probably is
n you can usually set a range of possible/reasonable values for aquantity that will indicate a major mistake (e.g. speed cannot be fasterthan speed of light!)
n Bound or threshold problems to scope design solutions
n Eg: Will it fit in? No it is 100 times too large even with optimistic values.
n Consider your results in context with the assumptions youhave made.
n Use two different methods to contrast Rough Order ofMagnitude ROM estimates (eg estimation and comparison).
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
6/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 11
G. I. Taylor s famous 1947 Analysis us ing radius ,
energy, densi ty, t ime
Published U.S.
Atomic Bomb
was 18 kilotondevice a fact
considered top
secret at the time!
B. M. QuineBOTE 12
Excercises
n What area of space-based solar panels would it take to replace
Ontarios existing hydro (coal, gas, nuclear) power generating
capacity?
n How many air molecules do you breathe in your life that were
breathed by Pythagoras?
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
7/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 13
Uncertainty
n Once you have a method to solve the problem, you can include
best- or worst-case estimates
n e.g. how many light bulbs are there in the U.S.?
n somewhere between 108 and 109 people
n not less than 1 light bulbs/person
n likely not more than 103 /person
n so the range of the answer is from 108 to 1012 light bulbs
n The bounding box
n between what values are we sure the answer lies
n to get the largest possible overestimate, multiply all the largest possible
values and divide by all the smallest possible values
n and vice versa for the lowest possible underestimate
n The likely box
n similar to the bounding box but using the largest and smallest likely
values
B. M. QuineBOTE 14
Landmarksn Why create landmarks? To have stepping-stones for thought.
n For thought and imagination to move easily, one needs
handholds, markers
n bits of easily accessible knowledge scattered across the landscape.
Making its shape visible, and providing places to stand.
n Why remember landmarks when we have them in books?
n to carry them with us.
n Books can be a source of landmarks, and a place to keep
landmarks you don't often use
n also a place to keep more detailed versions of the landmarks you carryaround
n but when something would be useful, it doesn't help much to know just
where you left it, forgotten at home
n either it is ready at hand, or you need to use something else.
n Over time we change what we carry with us. Choose
knowledge which helps with our interests and current
questions about the world
http://www.vendian.org/envelope/dir0/landmarks.html
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
8/9
B. M. QuineBOTE 15
Example
n How much paper does The New York Times use in a week? A
paper company that wishes to make a bid to become their sole
supplier needs to know whether they have enough current
capacity. If the company were to store a two-week supply of
newspaper, will their empty 14,000 square foot warehouse be
big enough?
http://www.nap.edu/html/hs_math/be.html
B. M. QuineBOTE 16
Solut ionn The New York Times. Answering this question requires two preliminary estimates: the circulation
of The New York Times and the size of the newspaper. The answers will probably be different on
Sundays. Though The New York Times is a national newspaper, the number of subscribers
outside the New York metropolitan area is probably small compared to the number inside. The
population of the New York metropolitan area is roughly ten million people. Since most familiesbuy at most one copy, and not all families buy The New York Times, the circulation might be
about 1 million newspapers each day. (A circulation of 500,000 seems too small and 2 million
seems too big.) The Sunday and weekday editions probably have different circulations, but
assume that they are the same since they probably differ by less than a factor of two--much less
than an order of magnitude. When folded, a weekday edition of the paper measures about 1/2
inch thick, a little more than 1 foot long, and about 1 foot wide. A Sunday edition of the paper is
the same width and length, but perhaps 2 inches thick. For a week, then, the papers would stack
6 x 1 / 2 + 2 = 5 inches thick, for a total volume of about 1 ft x 1 ft x 5 / 12 ft x 0.5 ft3 .
n The whole circulation, then, would require about 1/2 million cubic feet of paper per week, or
about 1 million cubic feet for a two-week supply.n Is the company's warehouse big enough? The paper will come on rolls, but to make the
estimates easy, assume it is stacked. If it were stacked 10 feet high, the supply would require
100,000 square feet of floor space. The company's 14,000 square foot storage facility will
probably not be big enough as its size differs by almost an order of magnitude from the estimate.
The circulation estimate and the size of the newspaper estimate should each be within a factor of
2, implying that the 100,000 square foot estimate is off by at most a factor of 4--less than an
order of magnitude.
n How big a warehouse is needed? An acre is 43,560 square feet so about two acres of land is
needed. Alternatively, a warehouse measuring 300 ft x 300 ft (the length of a football field in both
directions) would contain 90,000 square feet of floor space, giving a rough idea of the size.
7/28/2019 Back of the Envelope (BOTE) Calculations.pdf
9/9