22
"# !"#$%&& '()*+,-( /+(01234*5 6*+*7-8-+2 93*,24,-1 '::/;<6=<> ? "#$% &'()%*)#$ +*#,- '#&.'% -*/#$0 1(%02' 34567748

Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "#!

!

!"#$%&&!'()*+,-(./+(01234*5.6*+*7-8-+2.

93*,24,-1.

.

.

.

'::/;<6=<>.?.

"#$%!&'()%*)#$!+*#,-!'#&.'%!.

!-*/#$0!1(%02'!

34567748!!.

Page 2: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! $#!

>*@5-.AB.CA+2-+21.!"#$%&'(&()*+,%-&.........................................................................................................................&/!

%0%1+!)2%&-+33",4&...................................................................................................................&5!

"#! )6!,'7+1!)'6&.......................................................................................................................&8!

"#"! %&'()*+&,-!.%/01-!2'&(3!############################################################################################################!4!

"#$! 5()60&'-!%*6!-1(.+&1-!###############################################################################################################!4!

"#7! -'(%'18+&!%*6!)51(%'+)*%/!&9%*81-!##########################################################################################!:!

$#! 1+,,%6!&3"6+("1!+,)6*&9,"1!)1%&...................................................................................&:!

$#"! /)%6(+'1;!5()60&'!<!.%*+//%!+*6+&%')(!###############################################################################!""!

$#$! =%*>%*!####################################################################################################################################!"7!

$#7! 4-!'1&9*+?01-!##########################################################################################################################!"@!

$#@! &%/+>(%'+)*!#############################################################################################################################!"@!

$#4! +*'1(*%/!%06+'!5()&1--!#############################################################################################################!"4!

7#! )--+%-&....................................................................................................................................&;8!

7#"! &)*-'(%+*'-!#############################################################################################################################!"4!

7#$! 90A%*!(1-)0(&1-!####################################################################################################################!":!

7#7! 10()51BA0/'+!/%*80%81!2A16+%!5%&=+*83!#################################################################################!"C!

7#@! D%-'1!)E!+*.1*')(F!#################################################################################################################!"C!

7#4! %E'1(!-%/1-!-1(.+&1!###################################################################################################################!"C!

@#! "(!%,&-"$%-&-%,2)1%&.............................................................................................................&;<!

@#"! &0((1*'!5()>/1A-!###################################################################################################################!"G!

@#$! >1-'!5(%&'+&1-!#########################################################################################################################!"H!

@#7! (1&)AA1*6%'+)*-!###################################################################################################################!$I!

@#@! &9%//1*81-!##############################################################################################################################!$"!

4#! 1'61$+-)'6-&........................................................................................................................&==!

:#! ,%(%,%61%-&...........................................................................................................................&==!

!

!

!

!

Page 3: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! 7#!

!

>*@5-.AB.D4703-1.!

E+80(1!"#!/)%6(+'1!A%*0E%&'0(+*8!5()&1--! C!

E+80(1!$!-'(0&'0(1!)E!'91!-055/F!%*6!&9%+*!615%('A1*'! H!

E+80(1!7#!%--1A>/F!/%F)0'! "I!

E+80(1!@#!2%3!%--1A>/F!%(1%!2>3!J)>!>%8!%*6!A%'1(+%/!-91/.1-! ""!

E+80(1!4#!.%*+//%!%*6!E/%.)0(16!+*6+&%')(-! "$!

E+80(1!:#!2%3!=%*!>%*!A%(=1'K!2>3!1A5'F!=%*!>%*!&)*'%+*1(!2&3!E+*%/!5%&=*8!%(1%! "7!

E+80(1!C#!.%*+//%!+*6+&%')(-!')!E+*%/!-9+55+*8! "@!

E+80(1!G#!&0((1*'!2%3!%*6!5()5)-16!2>3!-'(0&'0(1!E)(!-1(.+&1!&))(6+*%'+)*!%'!%&'()*+&! $"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 4: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! @#!

!

=E-,024)-.:088*3F.!

%LMNOPQL!'RLSPOTOUQRV!QV!W!XONTY!TRWYRN!OZ!OP[OWNY!XRQUSQPU!VOT\MQOPV!ZON!XSRRT!TOWYRNVK!R]LW^WMONVK!

LOP^R_ON![RTMVK!ZON`TQZMV!WPY!^WNQO\V!OMSRN!TOWYQPU!Ra\QbcRPMV#!'SQV!NRbONM!YQVL\VVRV!WPY!WMMRcbMV!MO!

LNQMQLWTT_!WPWT_VR!QMV!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!bNOLRVVRV!WPY!cWPWURcRPM!bNWLMQLRV#!!

DQMS!W!^QVQOP!MO![RLOcR!XONTY!TRWYRN!QP!Y_PWcQL!XRQUSQPU!V_VMRc!%LMNOPQL!SWV!\PYRNUOPR!W!cWdON!

MNWPVZONcWMQOP!bNOLRVV!WPY!WYObMRY!TRWP!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!WPY!MOMWT!a\WTQM_!cWPWURcRPM#!+M!SWV![RRP!

QYRPMQZQRY! MSWM! VRN^QLRW[QTQM_! OZ! bNOY\LMVK! V`QTT! VSONMWURV! WPY! O[VOTRVLRV! OZ! MRLSPOTOU_! QV! W! cWdON!

LW\VR!OZ!LOPLRNP!ZON!%LMNOPQL#!'SR!VRN^QLR! ! QVV\R!SWV! ![RRP!Z\NMSRN! QP^RVMQUWMRY#!EQPWTT_K!MSQV!NRbONM!

V\UURVMV!VOcR!cRWV\NRV!MO!WYYNRVV!MSR!VRN^QLR!QVV\R#!

6RVQUPecRMSOYOTOU_eWbbNOWLS!f!'SR!W\MSON!QV!W!L\NNRPM!RcbTO_RR!WM!%LMNOPQL!'RLSPOTOUQRV!/MY!WPY!

SWV![RRP!XON`QPU!ZON!TWVM!VR^RP!_RWNV#!'SR!YWMW!SWV![RRP!LOTTRLMRY![_!O[VRN^WMQOPK!QPMRN^QRXQPU!MSR!

LOTTRWU\RVK!UTO[WT!V\bbT_!<!LSWQP!cWPWURNK!MSR!WVVQVMWPM!cWPWURN!2b\NLSWVR!<!bNOY\LMQOP!bTWPPQPU3!

WPY!bNOY\LMQOP!V\bRN^QVON#!!

=R_!XONYg!/RWP!AWP\ZWLM\NQPUK!/OWYNQMRhK!=WP[WPK!J\VM!QP!MQcR!2J+'3K!.WPQTTW!+PYQLWMONV!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

Page 5: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! 4#!

59 /+23A(0,24A+.!

%LMNOPQL! QV! W!XONTY! TRWYRN! OZ! OP[OWNY!XRQUSQPU! VOT\MQOPV! ZON!XSRRT! TOWYRNVK! R]LW^WMONVK! LOP^R_ON!

[RTMVK!ZON`TQZMV!WPY!^WNQO\V!OMSRN!TOWYQPU!Ra\QbcRPMV!RcbTO_V!O^RN!"II!bRNVOPV!QP!VQ]!LO\PMNQRV#'SR!

LOcbWP_!SWV!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!\PQM! QP!*RX!iRWTWPY#!%LMNOPQL!QV!W!UTO[WT!LOcbWP_!XQMS!OZZQLRV!QP!*RX!

iRWTWPYK! 0-%K! %\VMNWTQWK! &SQPW! WPY!*RMSRNTWPYV#! 'SR! LOcbWP_! QPMRPYV! MO! R]MRPY! QMV! TRWYRNVSQb! MO!

PRX!UROUNWbSQL!cWN`RMV!bWNMQL\TWNT_!+PYQWK!-O\MS!%cRNQLW!WPY!&SQPW!MO!VMNRPUMSRP!QMV!bOVQMQOP!WV!MSR!

TRWYRNV!ZON!QcbNO^RY!bNOY\LMQ^QM_!QP!MSR!WUUNRUWMRVK!XWVMRK!cQPQPUK!WPY!OMSRN!SRW^_!QPY\VMNQRV#!

)^RN!7I!_RWNV!WUOK!%LMNOPQL!'RLSPOTOUQRV!/MY!QP!*RX!iRWTWPY!YR^RTObRY!W!NRTQW[TR!Y_PWcQL!XRQUSQPU!

V_VMRc!MO!VWMQVZ_!MSR!PRRY!OZ!WLL\NWMRT_!XRQUSQPU!MSR!TOWY!OP!XSRRT! TOWYRNV#!%LMNOPQL!XWV!MSR!ZQNVM!

LOcbWP_!QP!MSR!XONTY!MO!QPMNOY\LR!bNRLQVQOP!Y_PWcQL!XRQUSQPU!2%LMNOPQL3#!-QPLR!MSRPK!%LMNOPQL!SWV!

[RRP! YRVQUPQPUK! YR^RTObQPU! WPY! cWP\ZWLM\NQPU! LOPMNOT! WPY! cRWV\NRcRPM! V_VMRcV! ZON! SRW^_!

QPY\VMNQRV#!!

?$? ',23A+4,G1.H*50-1.I>CJK.

!"#$%&'() #*+) ,#'-*"'./01.>& &OObRNWMQPU! QP! SQUS! bRNZONcQPU! MRWcV! WPY! bWNMPRNVSQbV! MO! WLSQR^R!

bRNZONcWPLR! UWQPV! ZON! RPY! L\VMOcRNV#! %LMQPU! SOPRVMT_K! NRTQW[T_! WPY! XQMS! c\M\WT! MN\VM! QP! O\N!

NRTWMQOPVSQbV!WPY![RQPU!ObRP!MO!YQZZRNQPU!^QRXV!<!ObQPQOPV#!

23.-&$"') 4#53") 6&73."+8)DON`QPU! LTOVRT_! XQMS! YQVMNQ[\MONV! WPY! OMSRN! cWN`RM! bWNMPRNV! MO! YRTQ^RN!

TWVMQPU![RPRZQMV!MO!RPY!L\VMOcRNV![WVRY!OP!W!YRRb!\PYRNVMWPYQPU!OZ!MSRQN!QVV\RV!WPY!PRRYV#!DON`QPU!

QPPO^WMQ^RT_! MO! bNO^QYR! RZZRLMQ^R! VOT\MQOPV! MO! cRRM! L\VMOcRN! PRRYV#! 'SR! bNOY\LM! QV! RWV_! ZON! RPY!

L\VMOcRNV!MO!YO![\VQPRVV!XQMS#!!

9".35-.) :'0;"*8)6NQ^RP! XQMS! \NURPL_! MO! WLSQR^R! O\MVMWPYQPU! NRV\TMV! ZONg! L\VMOcRNVK! VSWNRSOTYRNVK!

VMWZZ!WPY!MSR!RP^QNOPcRPM#!

?$! 93A(0,21.*+(.:-3)4,-1.%LMNOPQL!bNOY\LMV!LWP![R!LWMRUONQjRY!QPMO!MXO!NWPURVg!/OWYNQMRh!WPY!/OUNQMRh#!/OWYNQMRh!QV!W!Y_PWcQL!

OPB[OWNY!XRQUSQPU!V_VMRc!MSWM!WLL\NWMRT_!cRWV\NRV!MSR!XRQUSM!XSRP!TOWY!QV!TQZMRY#!+M!LWP![R!\VRY!OP!

XSRRT! TOWYRNVK! ZON`TQZMVK! R]LW^WMONVK! UWN[WUR! MN\L`V! WPY! OMSRN! SRW^_! TOWYQPU! Ra\QbcRPMV! 2k%[O\M!

/OWYNQMRKk3#! /OUNQMRh! bNOY\LMV! WNR! cWP\ZWLM\NRY! ZON! MSR! )1A! DWNWMWS! /QcQMRY#! DWNWMWS!

QPLONbONWMRV! /OUNQMRh! QPMO! MSRQN! 9WN^RVMRN! 9RWY! \VRY! MO! L\M! MNRRV! QP! W! bNRYRMRNcQPRY! TOU! VQjR!

Page 6: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! :#!

2%LMNOPQLK!$II73#!'SR!cWQP!UNO\bV!OZ!L\VMOcRNV!ZON!/OWYNQMR!bNOY\LMV!WNR!WUUNRUWMRVK!cQPQPUK!XWVMR!

cWPWURcRPM!QPY\VMNQRVK!XSRNRWV!MSR!/OUNQMR!NWPUR!QV!cWQPT_!\VRY!QP!MSR!ZONRVMN_!QPY\VMN_#!

?$L :23*2-74,.*+(.MN-3*24A+*5.CO*+7-1.-QPLR! $IICK! %LMNOPQL! SWV! [RRP! \PYRNUOQPU! W! cWdON! MNWPVZONcWMQOP! bNOLRVV! bNOcbMRY! [_! cWN`RM!

ObbONM\PQMQRV! WPY! MSR! T\NR!OZ! UNRWMRN! V\LLRVV#! 'SR! LOcbWP_! WYObMRY![OMS! VMNWMRU_! WPY!ObRNWMQOP!

ONQRPMRY! WbbNOWLSRV#! 'SR! LOcbWP_! SWV! VbNRWY! QMV! XQPUV! MO! PRX! UROUNWbSQLWT!cWN`RMV! R#U#! -O\MS!

%cRNQLWK!&SQPWK!1\NObR!WPY!+PYQW#!'SR!PRX!cWN`RM!LSWPPRTV!SW^R![RRP!RVMW[TQVSRY#!*RX!YQVMNQ[\MONV!

SW^R![RRP! NRLN\QMRY!WPY!WTVO! LOcbWP_!SWV!ObRPRY! QMV! NRUQOPWT!OZZQLRV! QP!&SQPWK!0-%K!1\NObRK!WPY!

%\VMNWTQW#!+M!VMWNMRY!VRTTQPU!YQNRLMT_!QP!&SQPW#!%LMNOPQL!QV!SRWYQPU!MOXWNYV!VRTTQPU!\P[\PYTRY!bNOY\LMV!

MO!bNO^QYR!QPMRUNWMRY!VOT\MQOP#!!

-OcR!OZ!MSR!ObRNWMQOP!ONQRPMRY!WbbNOWLSRV!QPLT\YR!NRVMN\LM\NQPU!MSR!V\bbT_!WPY!LSWQP!YRbWNMcRPM#!

%!AWP\ZWLM\NQPU!'RLSPQLWT!'RWc!2A''3K!5NOY\LMQOP!'RWcK!5\NLSWVR!<!bTWPPQPU!'RWc!WPY!-MONR!<!

VSQbbQPU! MRWc! XWV! QPMRUNWMRY! QPMO! V\bbT_! WPY! LSWQP! YRbWNMcRPM! ! ZON! [RMMRN! LOONYQPWMQOP! WPY!

RZZRLMQ^R! LOcc\PQLWMQOP#! &RNMWQP! bWNMV! WPY! V\[BWVVRc[TQRV! XRNR! O\MVO\NLRY! MO! NRUQOPV! V\LS! WV!

&SQPW#! EON! R]WcbTRK! MSR! /OWYNQMR! bNQPMRN! MSWM!XWV! RWNTQRN! WVVRc[TRY! WPY! MRVMRY! QPBSO\VR!SWV! POX!

[RRP!O\MVO\NLRY! MO! W! 5&>!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU! LOcbWP_! QP!*RX!iRWTWPY#! 'SR! LOcbWP_! QV! LOPMQP\O\VT_!

RcbTO_QPU! TOX! XWURV! <! SQUS! V`QTTRY! PRX! cQUNWPMV#! %LMNOPQL! WTVO! SRTbV! QMV! RcbTO_RRV! MO! UWQP! ON!

LOP^RNM! XON`! ^QVW! QP! MO! bRNcWPRPM! NRVQYRPM! ^QVW#! %! P\c[RN! OZ! bNOLRVV! NRBRPUQPRRNQPUK! bNOLRVV!

VMWPYWNYQVWMQOP!WPY!XR[!RPW[TRY!MOOTV!XRNR!QPMNOY\LRY!2AWMSNWPQK!$I"$3#!+P!WYYQMQOPK!MSR!LOcbWP_!

SWV!VMWNMRY!/RWP!dO\NPR_!WPY!QPMNOY\LRY!TRWP!MOOTV!WPY!MRLSPQa\RV!V\LS!WV!=WP[WPK!4-K!J+'!RML#!!

! !

Page 7: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! C#!

!

:9 C033-+2.8*+0B*,2034+7.N3*,24,-.!

/OWYNQMR!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!bNOLRVVRV!WNR!+-)HII"!LRNMQZQRY#!>RTOX!QV!MSR!O^RN^QRX!OZ!MSR!bNOLRVV#!!

!

(?@ABC&;.&$DEFB?GC&HEIAJEKGAB?I@&LBDKCMM&

!

%LLONYQPU! MO! 8WN^QP! RM! WT#K! MSRNR! WNR! MXO! WbbNOWLSRV! MO! LOPZONcWPLRg! %cRNQLWP! WPY! 'WU\LSQ!

WbbNOWLSRV!28NQUUK!$I"Il!(WOK!"HH:3#!%LMNOPQL!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!bNOLRVV!WPY!LOPZONcWPLR!QV![WVRY!OP!

MSR! %cRNQLWP! MSQP`QPU! OZ! mLOPZONcWPLR! XQMS! cRRMQPU! VbRLQZQLWMQOPVm#! %TT! QPLOcQPU! cWMRNQWTV! Q#R#!

5&>VK!LW[TRVK!SWNYXWNRK!RTRLMNOPQL!LOcbOPRPMVK!cWP\WTVK!RML#!WNR!VWcbTRY!WPY!cWMLSRY!XQMS!bNRB

RVMW[TQVSRY! VMWPYWNYV#! 'SR! bWNMV! ON! LOcbOPRPMV! MSWM! LOcbT_!XQMS! VbRLQZQLWMQOPV! bWVV! MO! MSR! PR]M!

bNOLRVV!ON!RTVR!MSR!XSOTR![WMLS!QV!NRdRLMRY!WPY!NRM\NPRY!MO!MSR!V\bbTQRN#!*ONcWTT_K!MSR!VWcbTQPU!NWMR!

QV!"In#!+PQMQWT!MXO![WMLSRV!ZNOc!W!PRX!^RPYON!WNR!LSRL`RY!"IInK!ZOTTOXRY![_!4In!WPY!WP!OPUOQPU!

"In!LSRL`QPU#!!

E\TT!Z\PLMQOPWT!MRVM!QV!LWNNQRY!O\M!ZON!WTT!5&>V#!%ZMRN!WVVRc[T_K!MSR!bNOY\LM!\PYRNUORV!W!MRcbRNWM\NR!

L_LTR!MRVMK!XSRNR[_!MSR!cOY\TRV!WNR!`RbM!QP!W!LSWc[RN!XQMS!MRcbRNWM\NR!^WN_QPU!ZNOc!I!MO!4I!o&!WPY!

bOXRN! MO! MSR!cOY\TRV!^WN_QPU! ZNOc!"$! MO!7$.#!%\MOcWMQL! MRVM!Ra\QbcRPM!WLa\QNRV!WPY! VMONRV! MSR!

MRVM! YWMW! WPY! MSRNR[_! UQ^RV! W! 5WVVeEWQT! NRV\TM! [WVRY! OP! MSR! YWMW! LOPZONcQPU! MO! MSR! VbRLQZQLWMQOP!

Page 8: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! G#!

TQcQMV#!'SRVR!MRVM!NRV\TMV!WNR!VW^RY! QP!WP! QPMRNPWT!YWMW[WVR!MSWM!RPV\NRV!MNWLQPU!OZ!MSR!bNOY\LM!MRVM!

YRMWQTV!WM!W!TWMRN!YWMR#!%!EQPWT!MRVM!QV!MSRP!LWNNQRY!O\M!MO!MRVM!MSR!Z\PLMQOPWTQM_!OZ!MSR!bNOY\LM![RZONR!

bWL`WUQPU#!1^RN_!MRVM!bNOLRVV!LSRL`V!WPY!LOPZQNcV!MSWM!MSR!bNOY\LM!LOPZONcV!MO!MSR!VMWPYWNYV#!

!".-),/05&.&1/<)

+P!WP!WMMRcbM!MO!WLSQR^R!SQUS!a\WTQM_K!NRTQW[TR!bNOY\LMV!WM!WZZONYW[TR!LOVMK!%LMNOPQL!!YR^RTObRY!W!MRVM!

bSQTOVObS_!XSRNR!R^RN_!bNOY\LM!YRTQ^RNRY!cRRMV!WTT!L\VMOcRN!NRa\QNRcRPMVl!ZWQT\NRV!WNR! QYRPMQZQRY!

WPY!NRbWQNRY!WM!MSR!TOXRVM!TR^RT!OZ!WVVRc[T_l!MRVMQPU!QV!W\MOcWMRY!ZON!cW]Qc\c!RZZQLQRPL_l!WPY!MSR!

MRVM!bNOLRVV!QV!LOPMQP\WTT_!QcbNO^RY#!'SQV!MRVM!bSQTOVObS_!SWV![RRP!WbbTQRY!MO!MSR!WNRWV!OZ!QPBbNOLRVV!

MRVMQPU#!

+P! MSR! QPBbNOLRVV! MRVMQPU!RZZONMK! MRVMQPU! QV!LOPY\LMRY!WM!WTT! TR^RTV!OZ!WVVRc[T_!\PMQT! MSR!V\LLRVV!NWMR!

XWNNWPMV!MRVM!RTQcQPWMQOP#!&OcbOPRPMV!WNR!VLNRRPRY!MO!RPV\NR!MSWM!OPT_!UOOY!cWMRNQWT!QV!WTTOXRY!OP!

MSR!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!ZTOON#!'RVMQPU!QV!W\MOcWMRYK!XSRNR!ZRWVQ[TRK!MO!NRY\LR!MRVM!MQcRK!WPY!MSR!P\c[RN!

OZ!YQZZRNRPM!MRVM!V_VMRcV!QV!cQPQcQjRY#!+P!WLLRbMWPLR!MRVMQPUK!MSR!UOWT!QV!MO!RZZRLMQ^RT_!cRRM!L\VMOcRN!

NRa\QNRcRPMV! [_! ^WTQYWMQPU! WTT! Ra\QbcRPM! WPY! bNOLRY\NRV! WPY! bNOLRY\NR! MNWLRW[QTQM_! MO!

NRa\QNRcRPMVK! WbbT_! LOPZQU\NWMQOP!cWPWURcRPM! MO!WTT! MRVM!bNOLRY\NRV!WPY!Ra\QbcRPMK! LOPMNOT! MSR!

LSWPUR! bNOLRVVK! WPY! W\MOcWMR! MRVMQPU! XSRP! bOVVQ[TR#! EQPWTT_K! QP! MSR! QcbNO^RcRPM! bNOUNWcK!

LOcbWP_! QV! LOPMQP\O\VT_! NR^QRXQPU! MRVM! YWMW! ZON! ZWQT\NR! MNRPYV! MO! NRcO^R! NOOM! LW\VRVK! QcbNO^R!

a\WTQM_K! NRY\LR! LOVMK! WPY! NRWLM! MO! MNRPYV! [RZONR! ZWQT\NR! OLL\NV#! 'SR! MRVM! bNOLRVV! QV! bRNQOYQLWTT_!

NR^QRXRY!ZON!QcbNO^RcRPM!MO!NRcO^R!MRVMV!XQMS!W!SQUS!V\LLRVV!NWMRK!NRY\LR!MRVM!MQcRK!WPY!QcbNO^R!

MRVMV!MO!RTQcQPWMR!ZWQT\NR!WM!PR]M!TR^RT!OZ!WVVRc[T_#!

'SR! cWP\ZWLM\NQPU! bNWLMQLRV! QP! %LMNOPQL! WNR! WYObMRYK! WbbTQRY! WPY! cOPQMONRY! [_! MSR! -\bbT_! WPY!

&SWQP! YRbWNMcRPM! OZ! %LMNOPQL#! EQU\NR! $! O\MTQPRV! MSR! L\NNRPM! VMN\LM\NR! OZ! MSR! V\bbT_! WPY! LSWQP!

YRbWNMcRPM#!!!

Page 9: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! H#!

!

(?@ABC&=&-GBAKGABC&DJ&GNC&-ALLOP&EIF&1NE?I&FCLEBGHCIG&

!

%VVQVMWPM! AWPWURN! 2bNOY\LMQOP! <! bTWPPQPU3! LOPY\LMV! cOPMST_! cRRMQPUV! XQMS! bNOY\LM! cWPWURNV#!

6\NQPU! MSQV! cRRMQPU! bNOY\LM! cWPWURNV! bNO^QYR! VWTRV! ZONRLWVM! ZON! YQZZRNRPM! bNOY\LMV! [WVRY! OP!

ZRRY[WL`! ZNOc! NRUQOPWT!cWPWURNVK! YRWTRNVK! YQVMNQ[\MONV! WPY!)1A! L\VMOcRNV#! -WTRV! ZONRLWVM! YNQ^RP!

YRcWPY!WPY!bNOY\LM!YRcWPY!QV!ZRY!QPMO!LOcb\MRN!2A%5+&!A(5!-D3#!&Ocb\MRN!URPRNWMRV!cWMRNQWT!

NRa\QNRcRPM! NRbONM! WPY! W! b\NLSWVR! ONYRN! QV! NWQVRY! WLLONYQPUT_#! ! )PLR! MSR!cWMRNQWT! QV! NRLRQ^RY! [_!

VMONRK!dO[V!WNR!NRTRWVRY![_!VLSRY\TR#!

(RLRPMT_K! %LMNOPQL! cO^RY! MO! W! PRX! TOLWMQOPK! XSRNR! MSR! bTWPM! XWV! YRVQUPRY! MO! V\bbONM! /RWP!

5SQTOVObS_! WPY! ObMQcQjR! MSR! XWVMR! OZ! cO^RcRPM#! 'SR! bTWPM! TW_O\M! QV! VSOXP! QP! EQU\NR! 7#! 'SR!

cWMRNQWTV!QVV\RY![_!VMONR!WUWQPVM!W!dO[!WNR!`RbM!QP!VcWTT!LOPMWQPRNV!XSQLS!VQM!OP!MSR!NWL`![RSQPY!MSR!

WVVRc[T_!ObRNWMON#!'RLSPQa\RV!V\LS!WV!=WP[WP!WPY!J+'!2QPMNOY\LMQOP!OZ!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV3!SW^R![RRP!

YQVL\VVRY!Z\NMSRN!QP!VRLMQOPV![RTOX#!!

!

!

!

!

8TO[WT!-\bbT_!WPY!&SWQP!AWPWURN!

%VVQVMWPM!AWPWURN!2-MONR3!

-SQbbQPU!&OONYQPWMON!

-MONRbRNVOPV!2]73!

%VVQVMWPM!AWPWURN!25(6!<!

A(53!

5\NLSWVQPU!)pLRN!

'RLSPQLWT!AWPWURN!

5NOY\LqOP!1PUQPRRN!

'RVM!1PUQPRRN!2r$3!

'RLSPQLQWPV!2]@3!

5NOY\LqOP!-\bRN^QVON!

%VVRc[TRNV!2]G3!

Page 10: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "I#!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

EQU\NRg!bNOY\LMQOP!<!%VVRc[T_!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

(?@ABC&/.&"MMCHQOP&OEPDAG&

)^RP!!

=-&'")JO[!>WUV!<!AWMRNQWT!

-SRT^RV!

%VVRc[TRN!5NOY\LMQOP!!'RLSPQLQWPV!2'RVM!%NRW3!!

EQPQVSRY!8OOYV!2-_VMRc!5WTTRMV3!-MONR!

-_VMRc!%VVRc[T_!%NRW!

EQPWT!

5WL`!

%NRW!!

%VVVRc

[TRY!5WNMV!!

=WP[WP!

.WPQTTW!

+PYQLWMON!

-SQbbQPU!%NRW!

Page 11: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! ""#!

!

(?@ABC&5.&RES&"MMCHQOP&"BCE&RQS&TDQ&#E@&EIF&3EGCB?EO&-NCOUCM&

!

!$? PM'QJ/>=R.93A(0,2.S.H*+455*./+(4,*2A3.'SR! /)%6(+'1;! V_VMRc! QV! MSR! s[NRWY! WPY! [\MMRN,! OZ! %LMNOPQL! LOPMNQ[\MQPU! HIn! MO! MSR! [\VQPRVV!

bNOZQMV#!+M!cRWV\NRV!MSR!XRQUSM!OZ!W!TOWY!TQZMRY![_!XSRRT!TOWYRNVK!ZON`TQZM!MN\L`V!WPY!VQcQTWN!cWLSQPRV!

MSWM!\VR!S_YNW\TQL!NWcV!MO!TQZM!QM#!'SR!cWQP!bWNMV!OZ!MSR!/)%6(+'1;!V_VMRc!WNR!MSR!LOPVOTR!2QPVMWTTRY!

QP!MSR!LW[!OZ!MSR!TOWYRN3!WPY!LOPPRLMRY!VRPVONV!2MNQUURN!QPVMWTTRY!OP!MSR!TQZMQPU!WNcV3#!%V!MSR!TOWY!QV!

TQZMRYK! MSR! MNQUURN! WPY! S_YNW\TQL! bNRVV\NR! MNWPVY\LRNV! VRPY! QPZONcWMQOP! MO! MSR! LOPVOTR#! 'SQV!

QPZONcWMQOP! QV! LOP^RNMRY! QPMO! W! YQUQMWT! XRQUSM! NRWYQPU! XSQLS! WbbRWNV! OP! MSR! /)%6(+'1;! LOPVOTR!

2%LMNOPQLK!$II73#!'SR!/)%6(+'1;!V_VMRc!LWP!WYY!RWLS! TOWY! TQZMRY! MO! N\PPQPU! MOMWTVK! VO! MSWM! MN\L`V!

LWP! [R! TOWYRY! NQUSM! MSR! ZQNVM! MQcR! WPY! YWQT_! bNOY\LMQ^QM_! TR^RTV! LWP! [R! MNWL`RY#! 'SR! /)%6(+'1;!

LOPVOTR!SWV!WP! QPMRNPWT!cRcON_!MSWM!VMONRV!VRMMQPUV!WPY!bNOY\LMQOP!YWMW!R^RP!XSRP! QM! QV!VXQMLSRY!

OZZ#!!

'SR! L\VMOcRN! ONYRN! ZON! /OWYNQMRh! V_VMRc! LOPVQVMV! OZ! V\[! WVVRc[TQRV! V\LS! WV! +PYQLWMONK! MNQUURNK!

bNRVV\NR! MNWPVY\LRNK! LW[TR! bWL`K! bNQPMRNK! MQTM! VRPVONK! YWMW! cOY\TR! 2ObMQOPWT3! WPY! cO\PMQPU!

WLLRVVONQRV#!'SRNR!WNR!cONR!MSWP!"I!^WNQWPMV!OZ! QPYQLWMONV!XQMS!MSNRR!M_bRV!OZ!MNQUURN#!%LMNOPQL!SWV!

QPMNOY\LRY! W! .WPQTTW! QPYQLWMONK!XSQLS! WV! MSR! PWcR! V\UURVMVK! QV! WP! QPYQLWMON!XQMSO\M! W! mZTW^O\Nt#! +M!

WTTOXV!YRTW_! QP!WVVQUPQPU!WP! QYRPMQM_!\PMQT! QM! QV!`POXP!XSWM!M_bR!OZ! QPYQLWMON!L\VMOcRNV!WNR![\_QPU#!

'SR! ^WPQTTW! QPYQLWMON! LWP! [R! a\QL`T_! LOP^RNMRY! QP! MO! WP_! ZTW^O\NRY! QPYQLWMON! [_! \bTOWYQPU! MSR!

WbbNObNQWMR!VOZMXWNR!WPY!WbbT_QPU!MSR!WbbNObNQWMR!YRLWTV!WPY!TW[RTV#!!

'SR!.WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV!_QRTY!MSR!ZOTTOXQPU!WY^WPMWURVg!

• AONR!ZTR]Q[TR!VMOL`!B!%LMNOPQL!LWP!a\QL`T_!cRRM!WP!QPLNRWVR!QP!YRcWPY!ZON!W!bWNMQL\TWN!M_bR!OZ!

QPYQLWMON#!EON!R]WcbTRK!QZ!TWNUR!ONYRNV!OZ!/$"GI!V_VMRcV!WNR!NRLRQ^RYK!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV!LWP![R!

LOP^RNMRY!QPMO!/$"GI!QPYQLWMONV!WPY!MSR!ONYRN!LWP![R!R]RL\MRY#!!

Page 12: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "$#!

• /RVV!(RXON`! B! +P! MSR!bWVMK!%LMNOPQL!SWV![RRP! `RRbQPU! TWNUR! VMOL`!OZ! ZTW^O\NRY! QPYQLWMONV! R#U#!

/$"GIK!r$74IK!EONLRK!-bNQPM!RMLl![WVRY!OP!VWTRV!ZONRLWVM#!)ZMRP!L\VMOcRNV!LSWPUR!MSRQN!cQPY!WM!

MSR!TWVM!cOcRPM!W[O\M!MSR!M_bR!OZ!QPYQLWMON!MSR_!XWPM!MO![\_#!'O!cRRM!MSQV!LSWPUR!QP!YRcWPYK!

%LMNOPQL!SWY!MO!MW`R!W!bRNZRLMT_!UOOY!QPYQLWMON!WPY!NRXON`!QM!QPMO!W!YQZZRNRPM!M_bR#!'SR!\VR!OZ!

.WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV!RTQcQPWMRY!MSQV!XWVMR#!

• (RY\LRY! +P^RPMON_! B! (WMSRN! MSWP!SOTYQPU! W!bNRYRMRNcQPRY!P\c[RN!OZ! RWLS! M_bR!OZ! QPYQLWMON!

md\VM!QP!LWVRtK!%LMNOPQL!POX![\QTYV!R]WLMT_!MSR!M_bR!OZ!QPYQLWMON!PRRYRY!md\VM!QP!MQcRt#!

!

!

!

!

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

(?@ABC&8.&2EI?OOE&EIF&(OEUDABCF&)IF?KEGDBM&

.WPQTTW!+PYQLWMON!

rB$74I!-bNQPM!

/$"GI!

&SQPRVR!\PQM!

Page 13: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "7#!

>_!MSR!QPMNOY\LMQOP!OZ!.WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONVK!%LMNOPQL!SWV!NRY\LRY!MSR!XWVMR!OZ!O^RN!bNOY\LMQOPK!XWVMR!

OZ!QP^RPMON_!WPY!XWVMR!OZ!LONNRLMQOP#!

!$! T*+@*+.+P! ONYRN! MO! LOONYQPWMR! MSR!bNOY\LMQOP! WPY!cO^RcRPM!OZ! WVVRc[TQRV! WPY! V\[WVVRc[TQRV! WPY! W^OQY!

VSONMWUR! ON! R]LRVVK! %LMNOPQL! \VRV! MSR! =WP[WP! V_VMRc#! 'SRNR! QV! W! VTObQPU! NWL`! [RVQYRV! MSR! ZQPWT!

bWL`QPU!WNRWK!XSQLS!LOPMWQPV!/OWYNQMR!V_VMRc!LOcbOPRPMV!R#U#!ETW^O\NRY! QPYQLWMONV! 2/$"GIK!/$"$GK!

r$74IK! &"G4I3K! MNQUURNV! 2cWUPRMQLK! ObMQLWTK! NOMWN_3K! LW[TR! VRMVK!cO\PMQPU!cRLSWPQVcK! MNWPVY\LRNVK!

RML#!!'SRVR!WVVRc[TQRV!WNR!`RbM!QP!W!=WP[WP![O]!ON!LOPMWQPRN!2>WTTu!<!>WTTuK!$II43#!=WP[WP!QV!W!VQUPWT#!

+M! bNO^QYRV! W\MSONQVWMQOP! MO! YRTQ^RN! ON! bNOY\LR! bWNMV#! EON! R]WcbTRK! OPLR! W! =WP[WP! [O]! OZ! /$"GI!

QPYQLWMON! QV! RcbM_! ON! N\PPQPU! TOXK! ^WPQTTW! QPYQLWMONV! WNR! LOP^RNMRY! MO! /$"GI! QPYQLWMONV! WPY! MSR!

=WP[WP![O]!QV!NRBVMOL`RY#!!!

!

(?@ABC&V.&RES&WEI&#EI&HEBXCGY&RQS&%HLGP&WEI&#EI&KDIGE?ICB&RKS&(?IEO&LEKXI@&EBCE&

'SRNR!WNR!ZO\N!=WP[WP!LOPMWQPRNV!OZ!.WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV#!1WLS!LOPMWQPRN!SOTYV!MSQNM_!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONVK!

MSR! a\WPMQM_! OZ! XSQLS! QV!cOPQMONRY! [_! MSR! bNOY\LMQOP! WPY! MRLSPQLQWP! MRWc#! 'SR! =WP[WP! a\WPMQM_!

NRU\TWMRV! MSR! cWP\ZWLM\NQPUebNOY\LMQOP! VbRRY! OZ! ^WPQTTW! QPYQLWMONV#! DSRP! W! dO[! QV! NWQVRY! [_! MSR!

bNOY\LMQOP!bTWPPQPU!YRbWNMcRPMK!bNOY\LMQOP!VbRRYV!\b!MSR!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMON!bNOY\LMQOP!NWMR#!!

'SR!=WP![WP!a\WPMQM_!OZ!^WPQTTW! QPYQLWMONV!WV!XRTT!WV!OMSRN!WVVRc[TQRV!<!V\[WVVRc[TQRV! QV!NR^QRXRY!

bRNQOYQLWTT_! [_! cWPWURcRPM! bNOY\LMQOP! WPY! bTWPPQPU! YRbWNMcRPM! WPY! LWP! [R! WTMRNRY! YRbRPYQPU!

\bOP!MSR!TWVM!_RWN!WPP\WT!VWTRVK!Z\M\NR!ZONRLWVM!RML#!!-TObQPU!NWL`V!2=WP[WP!B!V\bRNcWN`RMV3!WNR!\VRY!

MSNO\USO\M!MSR!bNOLRVV!ZNOc!MSR!\VR!OZ!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMONV!\PMQT!ZQPWT!bNOY\LM!bWL`QPU!2VRR!EQU\NR!C3#!

Page 14: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "@#!

!

(?@ABC&:.&2EI?OOE&?IF?KEGDBM&GD&J?IEO&MN?LL?I@&

.

!$L &:.2-,O+4U0-1.%LMNOPQL!\VRV!4-!MRLSPQa\RV!ZON! QcbNO^RcRPM!WPY!VMWPYWNYQVWMQOP!OZ!XON`!WNRW!2>SWVQP!<!>\NLSRNK!

$II:l!(R.RTTRK!$II"3#!!

-DBG>&5RNQOYQLWTT_!QMRcV!WNR!VONMRY!WLLONYQPU!MO!MSRQN!QcbONMWPLR!WPY!\VR!WPY!\PPRLRVVWN_!QMRcV!WNR!

YQVbOVRY!OZZ#!

-CG& ?I&DBFCB>&-RTRLMRY! QMRcV!WNR!WNNWPURY! QP!W!XRTT!ONUWPQjRY!WPY!cRWPQPUZ\T!cWPPRN!R#U#!=RRbQPU!

MSR!MOOTV!\VRY!ZNRa\RPMT_!PRWN!MO!MSR!XON`RN#!'SR!YRYQLWMRY!MRVM!dQUV!WPY!cRWV\NQPU!QPVMN\cRPMV!WNR!

`RbM!QP!MSR!NWL`!PRWN!MRVM!WNRW#!!

-N?IC>&'SR!XSOTR!XON`!WNRW!QV!`RbM!LTRWP#!'RVM!Ra\QbcRPMV!WPY!MOOTV!WNR!QPVbRLMRY!ZON!RWNT_!VQUPV!OZ!

YRZRLMV#!

-GEIFEBF?ZC>& 1WLS! WPY! 1^RN_! RcbTO_RR! ZOTTOXV! MSR! W[O^R! MSNRR! N\TRV! MO! WLSQR^R! W! UOOY! WPY!

ONUWPQjRY!XON`!bTWLR#!

-AMGE?I>&5RObTR!WM!%LMNOPQL!WNR!MNWQPRY!WPY!cOMQ^WMRY!MO!ZOTTOX!MSRVR!UOOY!bNWLMQLRV!VQcbT_!WV!W!bWNM!

OZ!MSRQN!YW_!MO!YW_!TQZR#!1^RN_OPR!Qc[Q[RV!MSR!YQVLQbTQPR!MO!WLSQR^R!MSR!O[dRLMQ^R!OZ!MSR!ONUWPQjWMQOP#!!

!$% C*54@3*24A+.%LMNOPQL! cWQPMWQPV! W! MOOT! QP^RPMON_! OZ! WbbNO]QcWMRT_! 4I! QMRcV! R#U#! 'RVM! dQUVK! W\MOcWMRY! MRVM!

Ra\QbcRPMVK!MRVM!WPY!cRWV\NQPU!QPVMN\cRPMVK!XSQLS!NRa\QNR!bRNQOYQL!LWTQ[NWMQOP#!%LMNOPQL!SWV!MSNRR!

M_bRV! OZ! NRZRNRPLR! cRMRNV! \VRY! ZON! cRWV\NQPU! ^OTMWUR! 2c\TMQcRMRN3K! MRcbRNWM\NR! 2MRcbRNWM\NR!

cRMRN3! WPY! MQcR! 2OVLQTTOVLObR3#! 'SRVR! NRZRNRPLR!cRMRNV! NRa\QNR!*%'%! -MWPYWNY! LWTQ[NWMQOP! MSWM! QV!

%VVRc[TRN!bQL`V!MSR!^WPQTTW!QPYQLWMON!!ZNOc!=WP[WP!!<!LOP^RNMV!

QPMO!W!vW^O\NRY!+PYQLWMON!R#U#!!/$"GI!!

'RLSPQLQWP!TOWYV!WbbNObNQWMR!!-D!<!!wPWT!MRVM!!

5NOY\LqOP!!bWL`V!QP!wPWT!bWL`QPU!!WNRW!<!

wTTV!=WP[WP!LOPMWQPRN!

-MONR!bQL`V!\b!V_VMRcxV!cOY\TRV!ZNOc!=WP[WP!!&OPMWQPRN!!

R#U#!ZON!/$"GI#()'#-F-B!

2!]"!/$"GI3y2]"!(OMWN_!'NQUURN!3y!2]$!'NWPVY\LRNV3y!LW[TR!VRMy!

AO\PqPU!`QM!

-SQbbQPU!MO!L\VMOcRN!

Page 15: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "4#!

YOPR![_!VMWPYWNY!WPY!W\MSONQVRY!TW[ONWMONQRV#!)MSRN!cRWV\NQPU!WPY!MRVM!QPVMN\cRPMV!WNR!LWTQ[NWMRY!

QPBSO\VR#!'O![RMMRN!RPV\NR!MSQV!bNOLRVV!QV!LOcbTRMRY!OP!MQcR!WPY!MSWM!PO!\PBLWTQ[NWMRY!MOOTVWNR!OP!

MSR!VSOb!ZTOONK!%LMNOPQL!YR^RTObRY!W!SQUST_!RZZRLMQ^R!WPY!NRTQW[TR!cOPQMONQPU!V_VMRc!ZON!MNWL`QPU!WPY!

NRLWTTQPU! MOOTV! ZON! NRLWTQ[NWMQOP#! 'SR! MRLSPQLWT! MRWc! QV! NRVbOPVQ[TR! ZON! LWTQ[NWMQOP! WLMQ^QMQRV! V\LS! WV!

LWTQ[NWMQOP! bTWPPQPUK! LOPMNOT! WPY! MQcRT_! LWTQ[NWMQOP! OZ! WTT! dQUV#! %TT! MSR! MOOTV! WPY! Ra\QbcRPMV! WNR!

MWUURY!XQMS!LWTQ[NWMQOP!VMQL`RNV!VSOXQPU!LWTQ[NWMQOP!YRMWQTV!R#U#!LWTQ[NWMRY!OP!YWMRK!PR]M!LWTQ[NWMQOP!

Y\R! OPK! RML#! AONRO^RN! LWTQ[NWMQOP! NRLONYV! WNR! `RbM! OP! QPMNWPRM! XSQLS! QV! NRU\TWNT_! cOPQMONRY! [_!

QPMRNPWT!WV!XRTT!WV!R]MRNPWT!W\YQMONV#!!!

!$& /+2-3+*5.*0(42.N3A,-11.'SR!b\NbOVR!OZ!MSR!QPMRNPWT!W\YQM!bNOLRVV!QV!MO!bNO^QYR!O[dRLMQ^R!R^QYRPLR!MSWM!MSR!a\WTQM_!V_VMRc!QP!

bTWLR! LOcbTQRV!XQMS! MSR!bTWPPRY!WNNWPURcRPMV!WPY! MSR! TWQY!YOXP!YOL\cRPMWMQOP#!DSRP!WP!W\YQM!

QYRPMQZQRV!WP!R^RPM!OZ!POPBLOPZONcWPLR!ON!bNO[TRcV!QP!MSR!V_VMRcK!LONNRLMQ^R!WPY!bNR^RPMQ^R!WLMQOP!

QV!MW`RP![_!MSR!ONUWPQjWMQOP!MO!QcbNO^R!MSR!a\WTQM_!V_VMRc#!'SR!LONNRLMQ^R!WLMQOP!WTTR^QWMRV!MSR!VSONM!

MRNc!bNO[TRcV!OZ! MSR! V_VMRcl!XSRNRWV! MSR!bNR^RPMWMQ^R!WLMQOP!WLMV! MO!bNR^RPM! MSR! VWcR!bNO[TRc!

ZNOc! OLL\NNQPU! WUWQP! [_! RVVRPMQWTT_! RTQcQPWMQPU! MSR! LW\VR! OZ! MSR! bNO[TRc! 2k>RVM! 5NWLMQLRV! -\N^R_g!

/OL`SRRY!AWNMQP!1TRLMNOPQLV!WPY!AQVVQTRV!kK!"HH43#!

;9 /110-1.%LMNOPQL!RPdO_V!SQUS!NRb\MWMQOP!cWQPT_! QP!MSR!%\VMNWTQWP!WPY!MSR!0-!cWN`RMV#!&\NNRPMT_K!%LMNOPQL! QV!

WMMRcbMQPU!MO!R]MRPY!QMV!cWN`RM!MO!%VQWP!WPY!1\NObRWP!LO\PMNQRV#!'SRNR!WNR!W!P\c[RN!OZ!`R_!QVV\RV!

XSQLS!cW_!SQPYRN!MSR!LOcbWP_,V!RZZRLMQ^RPRVV!WPY!b\M![NRW`V!OP!QMV!UNOXMS#!

L$? CA+123*4+21.%!LOPVMNWQPM! QV!WP_MSQPU!MSWM!bNR^RPMV! MSR!V_VMRc!ZNOc!WLSQR^QPU!cONR!OZ! QMV!UOWT#!&OPVQYRNQPU!MSR!

V_VMRc!WV!W!LSWQPK!MSR!XRW`RVM!TQP`!OZ!MSR!LSWQP!QV!W!LOPVMNWQPM#!!

>#5(?@*)?A;"*)%TT! bNOY\LMV! \PYRNUO! W! MRcbRNWM\NR! L_LTR! MRVMK!XSRNR[_! MSR!cOY\TRV! WNR! `RbM! QP! W! LSWc[RN!XQMS!

MRcbRNWM\NR!^WN_QPU!ZNOc!I!MO!4I!o&#!'SR!LSWc[RN!NOOc!2XWT`BQP!O^RP3!XWV!QYRPMQZQRY!WV!OPR!OZ!MSR!

LOPVMNWQPMV! QP!%LMNOPQL#!>QU!bQTRV!OZ! QP^RPMON_!WPY!QPM\QMQOP!OZ!bNOLRVV!XON`RNV!UQ^R!WP!QPYQLWMQOP!OZ!

LWbWLQM_! LOPVMNWQPMV#! 'SR!O^RP! MRVM!YRMRLMV! MSR! ZTOX!OZ!cWMRNQWTK! [WMLS! VQjR! WPY!bNR^RPMV! VcWTT! TOM!

bNOY\LMQOP#! 'SR! O^RP! MRVM! QV! W! TOPU! MRVM! TWVMQPU! \b! MO! $@! SNV! WPY! SWV! W! VRM\b! MQcR! OZ! @B4! SO\NV#!

AW]Qc\c!:I!QPYQLWMONV!ON!!MNQUURNV!LWP![R!MRVMRY!QP!OPR!N\P#!!+P!W!XRR`K!cW]Qc\c!MSNRR!TOMV!Q#R#!"GI!

QPYQLWMONV! LWP! [R! MRVMRY#! 6\R! MO! ^WNQRM_! OZ! NRWVOPV! V\LS! WV! b\[TQL! SOTQYW_VK! MRLSPQLWT! bNO[TRcV! QP!

SRWMQPU!ON!LOOTQPU!V_VMRcV!RMLK!cOVM!OZMRP!OPT_!MXO!TOMV!Q#R#!"$I!QPYQLWMONV!WNR!MRVMRY!QP!W!XRR`#!!

Page 16: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! ":#!

&\NNRPMT_K! %LMNOPQL! QV! VRTTQPU! @II! V_VMRcV! QP! W! cOPMS! WPY! QV! UNOXQPU! ^RN_! NWbQYT_#! +P! Z\M\NR! QM! QV!

bOVVQ[TR! MSWM! LOPVMNWQPMV! QP! MSR! cWN`RM! LWP! [R! cO^RY! MO! XWT`! QP! O^RP! WPY! LOcbWP_!cW_! ZWQT! MO!

YRTQ^RN! MSR! V_VMRcV! OP! MQcR#! %LMNOPQL! ZOTTOXV! MSR! ZQ^RBVMRb! bNOLRVV! OZ! OPUOQPU! QcbNO^RcRPM!

bNObOVRY![_!8OTYNWMM!28OTYNWMM!<!&O]K!"HH$3!QPLT\YQPUg!

"# +PYRPMQZ_!MSR!V_VMRcxV!LOPVMNWQPM2V3!!

$# 6RLQYR!SOX!MO!R]bTOQM!MSR!LOPVMNWQPM2V3!!

7# -\[ONYQPWMR!R^RN_MSQPU!MO!MSR!W[O^R!YRLQVQOP!!

@# 1TR^WMR!MSR!V_VMRc!LOPVMNWQPM!2+Z!PRLRVVWN_3!!

4# 8O![WL`!MO!VMRb!"!QZ!MSR!LOPVMNWQPM!cO^RV![\M!YOPxM!TRM!QPRNMQW!LW\VR!W!V_VMRc!LOPVMNWQPM!

'SR!MRLSPQLQWP! TOWYV! MSR! QPYQLWMONV!OPR![_!OPR! QPMO! MSR! MNOTTR_K! TRWYQPU! MO! MSR!XWVMR!OZ!cOMQOP#! +P!

ONYRN! MO! RTQcQPWMR! MSQV!XWVMRK! MRLSPQLQWPV! LWP! \VR! W! VbRLQWTQjRY! MNOTTR_! MO! VTQYR! QPYQLWMONV! QPMO! MSR!

O^RPK!NRY\LQPU!MQcR!MO!TOWY#!'SQV!LWP!RPV\NR!OPR!TOM!OZ!O^RP!MRVM!LWP![R!N\P!bRN!YW_#!!!!

L$! V08*+.J-1A03,-1.%La\QNQPU!WPY!NRMWQPQPU!SQUSBa\WTQM_!MWTRPM!QV!LNQMQLWT!MO!WP!ONUWPQjWMQOP,V!V\LLRVV#!%V!MSR!dO[!cWN`RM!

[RLOcRV! QPLNRWVQPUT_!LOcbRMQMQ^R!WPY!MSR!W^WQTW[TR!V`QTTV!UNOX!cONR!YQ^RNVRK!NRLN\QMRNV!PRRY!MO![R!

cONR! VRTRLMQ^R! QP! MSRQN! LSOQLRVK! VQPLR! bOON! NRLN\QMQPU! YRLQVQOPV! LWP! bNOY\LR! TOPUBMRNc! PRUWMQ^R!

RZZRLMV#!%cOPUVM! MSRc!WNR!SQUS!MNWQPQPU!WPY!YR^RTObcRPM!LOVMV! MO!cQPQcQjR!MSR! QPLQYRPLR!OZ!bOON!

bRNZONcWPLR!WPY!SQUS! M\NPO^RNK!XSQLS! QP! M\NPK! QcbWLM! VMWZZ!cONWTRK! MSR!bNOY\LMQOP!OZ!SQUS!a\WTQM_!

UOOYV!WPY!VRN^QLRV!WPY!MSR!NRMRPMQOP!OZ!ONUWPQjWMQOPWT!cRcON_#!%M!XONVMK!MSR!ONUWPQjWMQOP!LWP!ZWQT!

MO!WLSQR^R!QMV!O[dRLMQ^RVK!MSRNR[_!TOVQPU!QMV!LOcbRMQMQ^R!RYUR!WPY!QMV!VSWNR!OZ!MSR!cWN`RM#!

AN#!8OMMZNQRY!5W\VLSK!&1)!OZ!%LMNOPQL!SWV!QYRPMQZQRY!MWTRPM!NRLN\QMcRPM!WPY!cWPWURcRPM!WV!OPR!OZ!

MSR!`R_!NRa\QNRcRPMV!WV!XRTT!WV!LSWTTRPURV!OZ!WP!ONUWPQjWMQOP!V\LS!WV!%LMNOPQL#!+P!W!NRLRPM!VMWMRcRPM!

QP!WP!QPMRNPWT!cOPMST_!LOPZQYRPMQWT!NRbONM!MO!MSR!%LMNOPQL!VMWZZK!SR!VWQYK!mA3')B3.0*"..)/#.)#)1&'-C&50&)

&C)D'"#-)1'&+37-.E)#).7#5#B5")$07'&?$#'("-)7/#**"5)$&+"5)#*+)#).-'&*D)B'#*+F)!/")$#G&')7&*.-'#0*-)

-/#-)B5&7(.)-/").7#50*D)&C)#)&3')B3.0*"..)0.)#7H30'0*D)#*+)'"-#0*0*D)&C)D'"#-)1"&15")I)1"&15")-&)."5"7-)

#*+) -'#0*) *"%)+0.-'0B3-&'.) 0*) *"%)$07'&)$#'("-.E) 1"&15") -&) ."55)J) .311&'-) *"%)1'&+37-.) 0*-&) *"%)

-"''0-&'0".E) 1"&15") %/&) (*&%) /&%) -&) +";"5&1) *"%) 2&'") !"7/) #*+) *"%) "*+?3."') #11507#-0&*.) #*+)

1"&15")%/&)$#*3C#7-3'")#*+)-".-)#55)-/".")1'&+37-.F)K.)#)'#10+5<)D'&%0*D)7&$1#*<)%")#'")D&0*D)-&)

*""+)"L7"1-0&*#5)1"&15"E)7#1#B5")&C)%&'(0*D)0*)$35-015")735-3'".)#*+)$#'("-.FM)

Page 17: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "C#!

'SRNR!WNR!VR^RP!LOcbOPRPMV!OZ!VMNWMRUQL!VMWZZQPU#!'SRVR!WLMQ^QMQRV!WNR!XON`ZONLR!bTWPPQPUK!VO\NLQPUK!

NRLN\QMQPUK!VRTRLMQPUK!WLa\QNQPUK!YRbTO_QPU!WPY!NRMWQPQPU! MWTRPM#!%LMNOPQL! NRLN\QMV!RQMSRN! QPMRNPWTT_!ON!

R]MRNPWTT_#!(RLN\QMcRPM!QV!LOPY\LMRY!QPMRNPWTT_!MSNO\US!bNOcOMQOP!WPY!MNWPVZRN!OZ!R]QVMQPU!bRNVOPPRT!

ON! MSNO\US! NRZRNNWTVK! [_! L\NNRPM! VMWZZ!cRc[RNVK! OZ! ZNQRPYV! WPY! ZWcQT_!cRc[RNV#! JO[! ObRPQPUV! WNR!

WY^RNMQVRY! OP! MSR! LOcbWP_! +PMNWPRM#! (RZRNNWTV! WNR! \V\WTT_! XONYBOZBcO\MS! WY^RNMQVRcRPMV#! EON!

NRLN\QMQPU! R]MRNPWT! LWPYQYWMRVK! %LMNOPQL! NRTQRV! \bOP! MSR! NRLN\QMcRPM! LOPV\TMWPMV#! 'SR! LOPV\TMWPMV!

WY^RNMQVR! MSR! bOVQMQOP! XSQLS! QV! MQcR! LOPV\cQPU! WPY! LOVMT_#! +M! QV! NRLOccRPYRY! MO! \VR! OMSRN!

WTMRNPWMQ^RV! V\LS! WV! YQNRLM! NRLN\QMcRPMK! \PQ^RNVQM_! bWNMPRNVSQbVK! QPMRNPVSQbVK! cWQPMWQPQPU! W! bNRB

VLNRRPRY!WbbTQLWPM!bOOTK!\VQPU!VOLQWT!cRYQW!2/QP`RY!+P;K!'XQMMRN;3K!RML#!

L$L =03AN-W60524.5*+70*7-.I6-(4*.N*,X4+7K.%LMNOPQL!RPMRNRY!QPMO!MSR!1\NObRWP!AWN`RM!W[O\M!ZQ^R!_RWNV!WUO!WPY!ObRPRY!W!NRUQOPWT!OZZQLR!QP!MSR!

*RMSRNTWPYV#! %LMNOPQL! VRTTV! WTT! O^RN! MSR! 1\NObRWP! LOPMQPRPM! QPLT\YQPU! 8RNcWP_K! -bWQPK! 9\PUWN_K!

ENWPLRK!5ONM\UWT! MSNO\US! QMV!YQVMNQ[\MON!PRMXON`#!'O! Z\TZQTT! MSR![QTQPU\WT! NRa\QNRcRPMV!OZ! NRVbRLMQ^R!

1\NObRWP! LO\PMNQRVK! %LMNOPQL! b\[TQVSRV! MSR! bNOY\LM! QPZONcWMQOP! WPY! cWP\WTV! QP! MSR! NRVbRLMQ^R!

TWPU\WURV#! %! bNOY\LM! cWP\WTK! QP! OPR! TWPU\WURK! LOPMWQPV! PRWNT_! 4I! bWURV#! +M! QV! QcbOVVQ[TR! ZON! W!

LOcbWP_!MO!cW`R!4II!bWURV!LOcbNRSRPVQ^R!cWP\WT!LO^RNQPU!WTT!"I!YQZZRNRPM! TWPU\WURV#!/OWYNQMR,V!

YQVMNQ[\MONV!bTWLR!MSR!ONYRN!QP![\T`#!'SR!ONYRN!bNOLRVVQPU!WPY!VSQbbQPU!YRbWNMcRPM!WM!%LMNOPQL!QV!POM!

WXWNR!XSRNR!MSR!bNOY\LM!QV!UOQPU!MO![R!QPVMWTTRY#!+M!QV!bOVVQ[TR!MSWM!cWMRNQWTV!ONYRNRY![_!MSR!8RNcWP!

YQVMNQ[\MON!cW_![R!QPVMWTTRY!QP!9\PUWN_#!!

L$% Y*12-.AB./+)-+2A3F./OWYNQMR!V_VMRc!\VRV!VbRLQWTQjRY!R]bRPVQ^R!bWNMV!R#U#!'NWPVY\LRNVK!5&>VK!TOWY!LRTTV!RML#!AOVM!OZ!MSRVR!

bWNMV!WNR!cWYR!O^RNVRWV!WPY!SW^R!SQUS!TRWYBMQcR#!9RPLRK!%LMNOPQL!`RRbV!W![\ZZRN!VMOL`!MO!cRRM!MSR!

\PR]bRLMRY!YRcWPYV!OZ!L\VMOcRNV#!-OcR!OZ!MSR!QMRcV![RLOcR!O[VOTRMR!Y\R!MO!W!LSWPUR!QP!YRVQUP!

ON!MRLSPOTOU_!MSWM!TRWYV!MO!XWVMR!OZ!QP^RPMON_#!1^RPM\WTT_!LOcbWP_!SWV!MO!YQVbOVR!OZZ!MSRVR!QMRcV!MO!

W^OQY!LWNN_QPU!LOVM#!!

L$& 'B2-3.1*5-1.1-3)4,-.'SR!/OWYNQMR!bNOY\LMV!XRNR!WVVRVVRY!QP!MRNcV!OZ!MSR!RQUSM!YQcRPVQOPV!OZ!a\WTQM_!YRZQPRY![_!8WN^QP!

QPLT\YQPU!5RNZONcWPLRK!ERWM\NRVK!(RTQW[QTQM_K!6\NW[QTQM_K!&OPZONcWPLRK!-RN^QLRW[QTQM_K!%RVMSRMQLV!WPY!

5RNLRQ^RY!a\WTQM_! 2>RL`ZONYK!$IIHl!8WN^QPK!"HGG3#! +P!MSR!XRQUSQPU! QPY\VMN_K!WLL\NWL_K! NRTQW[QTQM_!WPY!

Y\NW[QTQM_! WNR! MSR! cOVM! QcbONMWPM! a\WTQM_! bWNWcRMRNV#! /OWYNQMR! NWMRV! UOOY! QP! MRNcV! OZ! QMV!

bRNZONcWPLRK!NRTQW[QTQM_K!Y\NW[QTQM_!WPY!LOPZONcWPLR!MO!VMWPYWNYV#!/OWYNQMR,V!bRNZONcWPLR!QV!d\YURY!

[WVRY!OP!QMV!WLL\NWL_!OZ!I#$B"n!XSQLS!QV![RMMRN!MSWP!cOVM!OZ!QMV!LOcbRMQMONV,#!

Page 18: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "G#!

8WN^QP! YRZQPRV! VRN^QLRW[QTQM_! WV! MSR! VbRRYK! LOcbRMRPLRK! LO\NMRV_! WPY! RWVR!OZ! NRbWQN#! %LMNOPQLK! /MY!

bNO^QYRV!WZMRN!VWTRV!VRN^QLR!XWNNWPM_!ZON!7!_RWNV#!AWP_!OZ!MSR!cOY\TRV!WNR!POM!VRN^QLRW[TR!WPY!SRPLR!

PRRY!NRbTWLRcRPM#!%V!/OWYNQMR! QV!\VRY! QP!^Q[NWMQOP!bNOPR!RP^QNOPcRPMVK! VOcR!OZ! MSR!cOY\TRV!WPY!

LOcbOPRPMV!WNR!UT\RY!WPY! ZQTTRY!XQMS!RbO]_#!'SQV!cW`RV! QM!YQZZQL\TM! MO! NRbWQN!OPLR! QM![NRW`V!YOXP#!

'SQV!bNRZRNRPLR!OZ!MSR!LOcbWP_!ZON!NRbTWLQPU!NWMSRN!MSWP!NRbWQNQPU!MSRQN!bNOY\LMVK!QV!R]bRPVQ^R!WPY!

TRVV!RP^QNOPcRPM!ZNQRPYT_#!!

AONRO^RNK!MSR!VRN^QLR!MRLSPQLQWPV!WNR!POM!MNWQPRY!WLLONYQPU!MO!ZQRTY!LOPYQMQOPV!WPY!WNR!POM!WXWNR!OZ!

MSR!WbbTQLWMQOPV!OZ!MSR!bNOY\LM#!'SR!ZWLMON_!MRLSPQLQWPV!WNR!POM!W[TR!MO!NRbTQLWMR!MSR!ZW\TM!YRVLNQ[RY!

[_!MSR!L\VMOcRNV! QP!MSR!ZWLMON_!RP^QNOPcRPM#!'SR!QPVMWTTWMQOP!OZ!MSR!bNOY\LM! QV!YOPR![_!MSR!YRWTRN!

WPY!MSR!LOcbWP_!YORV!POM!LOPY\LM!ZQRTY!WLLRbMWPLR!MRVMQPU#!E\NMSRNcONRK!WTT!NRbWQN!WPY!VRN^QLQPU!OZ!

MSR! bNOY\LM! QV! LRPMNWTQjRY! QPY\LQPU! cONR! MQcR! WPY! RZZONM! ZON! MSR! L\VMOcRN! QP! MSR! bNOLRVV#! EON!

R]WcbTRK!L\VMOcRNV!ZNOc!&SQPW!WPY!%\VMNWTQW!WNR!NRa\QNRY!MO!VRPY!MSRQN!ZW\TM_!cOY\TRV!MO!%\L`TWPYK!

*RX!iRWTWPYK! MS\V!WYYQPU!cONR!YRTW_! QP! MSR! VRN^QLR!bNOLRY\NR#!'SR!VRN^QLR! MQcR! QV!OP!W^RNWUR!$I!

YW_V#!9OXR^RNK!MO!LOc[WM!MSQV!QVV\RK!%LMNOPQL!bNO^QYRV!MSR!YRWTRNV!XQMS!V\NbT\V!VMOL`!XSQLS!WNR!\VRY!

WV!WP!QPMRNQc!NRbTWLRcRPM!ZON!ZW\TM_!bNOY\LMVK!\PMQT!NRbWQNRY#!

0VRNV! QP! %VQWP!cWN`RMV! VRRc! MO! UQ^R!cONR! bNRZRNRPLR! MO! ZQRTY! VRN^QLQPU#! EON! [RMMRN! VWMQVZWLMQOP! OZ!

V\LS!L\VMOcRNVK!QM!QV!RVVRPMQWT!MSWM!MSR!VRN^QLQPU!QV!YRBLRPMNWTQjRY!WPY!MSR!MRLSPQLQWPV!WNR!MNWQPRY!MO!

XON`!QP!ZQRTY!LOPYQMQOPV#!!

89 'B2-3.:*5-1.:-3)4,-.!

%$? C033-+2.N3A@5-81.%P_!LOcbTWQPMV! ZNOc!MSR!L\VMOcRN!WNR!NRUQVMRNRY![_!MSR!YQVMNQ[\MONV!XSO!WNR!LWbW[TR!OZ!bNO^QYQPU!

OPT_! MSR! [WVQL! ObRNWMQOPWT! WPY! Z\PLMQOPWT! TR^RT! V\bbONM#! 'SRVR! YQVMNQ[\MONV! WNR! MNWQPRY! [_! MSR!

%LMNOPQL! MRLSPQLWT! V\bbONM! MRWc! ZON! QPVMWTTWMQOP!WPY!OMSRN! Z\PLMQOPWT! V\bbONM#!%P_!\PQMV! MSWM!PRRY!

MRLSPQLWT!QP^RVMQUWMQOP!WNR!NRM\NPRY!MO!MSR!%LMNOPQL!VRN^QLR!LRPMNR![WVRY!QP!%\L`TWPYK!*RX!iRWTWPY#!

'SR!VRN^QLR!LOONYQPWMON![WVRY!WM!MSR!%\L`TWPY!VRN^QLR!LRPMNR!NRUQVMRNV!MSR!QVV\R!WPY!bWVVRV!QM!OPMO!

MSR! VRN^QLR! MRLSPQLQWPV! QP! MSR! bNOY\LMQOP! MRWc! ZON! NRbWQN#! 'SR! MRLSPQLQWPV! [WVRY! WM! MSQV! VQMR! MSRP!

QP^RVMQUWMR!WPY!NRbWQN!MSR!\PQMV#!AONR!OZMRP!MSWP!POMK!QM!QV!ZO\PY!MSWM!\PQMV!MSWM!ZWQT!QP!MSR!ZQRTY!VSOX!

*EE!2PO!ZWQT\NR!ZO\PY3!QP!MSR!VRN^QLR!LRPMNR#!+M!QV!YQZZQL\TM!ZON!MRLSPQLQWPV!MO!NRbTQLWMR!MSR!ZQRTY!bNO[TRc!

QP! MSR! VRN^QLR! LRPMNR! RP^QNOPcRPM! WPY! SRPLR! ZQPY! MSR! NOOM! LW\VR! OZ! MSR! bNO[TRc#!AONRO^RNK! MSR!

cWQP!ZOL\V!OZ!MSR!VRN^QLR!MRLSPQLQWPV!QV!OP!bNOY\LMQOPK!XSQTR!YRWTQPU!XQMS!MSR!NRbWQN!\PQMV!WV!WP!R]MNW!

TOWY#!!

Page 19: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! "H#!

6\R! MO! MSR! L\NNRPM! VMN\LM\NRK! QM! QV! ^RN_! YQZZQL\TM! MO! YRMRLM! MSR! bNO[TRc! bWMSXW_! Q#R#! XSRMSRN! MSR!

bNO[TRc!TQRV!QP!MSR!ObRNWMQOPV!OZ!MSR!\PQM!2WM!MSR!ZQRTY3!ON!XSRMSRN!MSRNR!QV!WP!WLM\WT!ZW\TM!XQMS!MSR!

YR^QLR#! 'SRNR! QV! W! S\UR! LOcc\PQLWMQOP! UWb! [RMXRRP! MSR! L\VMOcRNVK! YQVMNQ[\MONVK! MSR! VRN^QLR!

LOONYQPWMON! WPY! MSR! VRN^QLR! MRLSPQLQWPV! WPY! SRPLR! MSRNR! QV! PO! VQPUTR! bRNVOP! ON! MRWc! [RQPU! SRTY!

WLLO\PMW[TR!ZON!MSR!NRbWQN!bNOLRVV#!'SQV!bNWLMQLR!OZ!LRPMNWT!VRN^QLR!V\bbONM!QV!L\c[RNVOcR!WPY!OZMRP!

TRWYV! MO! TOPU! VRN^QLR! MQcRV!cWQPT_!Y\R! MO! VSQbbQPU!WPY! MNWPVbONM!OZ! MSR! NRbWQNeNRXON`RY!UOOYV!WV!

XRTT!WV!MSR!LOcc\PQLWMQOP![WNNQRN![RMXRRP!YQZZRNRPM!RPMQMQRV#!!

%$! Z-12.93*,24,-1.="';07"?7"*-'07)-'#*.C&'$#-0&*)+P! ONYRN! MO! V\LLRVVZ\TT_! NRVbOPY! MO! MSR! LSWPUQPU! YRcWPYV! OZ! L\VMOcRNVK! cWP\ZWLM\NRNV! WNR!

MNWPVZONcQPU!MSRQN![\VQPRVV!cOYRTV!MO!QPLONbONWMR!VRN^QLR!ZOL\V!WTOPU!XQMS!MSR!bNOY\LM!ZOL\V#!%V!W!

bWNM!OZ! MSQV! MNWPVZONcWMQOP!bNOLRVVK! QM! QV! ^QMWT! MSWM!cWP\ZWLM\NRNV!cONR! V_VMRcWMQLWTT_!b\NV\R! MSRQN!

WZMRNBVWTR!VRN^QLR!ObbONM\PQMQRV#!'SR!cOVM!LOcbRMQMQ^R!LOcbWPQRV!WNR!bRNZONcQPU!sLONR!^V#!LOPMR]M,!

WPWT_VQVl!ZOL\VQPU!OP!MSRQN!LONR!LWbW[QTQMQRVl!WPY!ZQPYQPU!bWNMPRNV!ZON!SWPYTQPU!OMSRN!NRa\QNRcRPMV!OZ!

MSR![\VQPRVV!2(O\VRK!$II:3#!

AWP_! LOcbWPQRV! SW^R! WYObMRY! MSQV! MNWPZONcWMQOP! bNOLRVV! [_! MNRWMQPU! MSRQN! VRN^QLR! [\VQPRVV! WV! W!

VMNWMRUQL! NR^RP\R! URPRNWMON#! .WNQO\V! R]WcbTRV! OZ! +'! ZQNcV! V\LS! WV! +>AK! 6RTT! &Ocb\MRNVK! rRNO]K!

9RXTRMMB5WL`WNY!WPY!8RPRNWT!1TRLMNQL!SW^R!\PYRNUOPR!MSQV!MNWPVZONcWMQOP!bNOLRVV!QP!ONYRN!MO![RMMRN!

YNQ^R!MSRQN!bNOY\LM!VWTRV!WPY!bNOZQMRW[QTQM_!2'9+*=VMNWMRUQRVK!$II@3#!!

+>A,V! MNWPVZONcWMQOP! ZNOc! W! V_VMRcV! LOcbWP_! MO! W! VRN^QLRVBTRY! VOT\MQOPV! bNO^QYRN! SWV! [RLOcR! W!

cOYRT! ZON! MSR!RPMQNR! +'! QPY\VMN_#!)^RN! MSR!bWVM!YRLWYRK! +>A,V!VRN^QLRV![\VQPRVV!URPRNWMRY!O^RN!GI!

bRNLRPM! OZ! +>A,V! MOMWT! NR^RP\R! UNOXMS#! 6RTT! &Ocb\MRN! WTVO! LSWPURY! QMV! [\VQPRVV! cOYRT! MO! SQUSB

cWNUQP! VRN^QLR! NR^RP\R! URPRNWMQOP! QP! ONYRN! MO! LOcbRPVWMR! ZON! ZWTTQPU! cWNUQPV! 2'9+*=VMNWMRUQRVK!

$II@3#!

N:"O)7"*-'#50P#-0&*))NUWPQjWMQOPV!bNO^QYQPU!VRN^QLRV!YQZZRN!^WVMT_! QP! MSRQN![\VQPRVV!VMNWMRU_!OZ!cRRMQPU!L\VMOcRN!PRRYV!

YRbRPYQPU!OP!MSR!M_bR!OZ!VRN^QLRV!MSR_!bNO^QYR!WV!XRTT!WV!MSR!W^WQTW[TR!NRVO\NLRVK!WM!MSR!VWcR!MQcR!

cW]QcQjQPU!bNOZQMV#!'SRVR![\VQPRVV!VMNWMRUQRV!R^OT^R!ZNOc!LOPY\LMQPU!W!LOPMQPURPL_!WbbNOWLS![WVRY!

OP!c\TMQbTR!ZWLMONV!V\LS!WV!MSR!bNOY\LMK!MSR!LOcbWP_!WZMRNBVWTRV!VMNWMRU_K!MSR!VRN^QLR!LSWNWLMRNQVMQLV!

WPY!MSR!bNOY\LM!YQVMNQ[\MQOP!V\bbT_!LSWQP#!EON!R]WcbTRK!VOcR!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!ZQNcV!SW^R!MSR!ZQPWPLQWT!

NRVO\NLRV!PRRYRY!MO!bRNZONc!cOVM!ON!WTT!QMV!WLMQ^QMQRV!NWPUQPU!ZNOc!NRVRWNLS!MO!bNOY\LM!YR^RTObcRPM!

MO!WZMRN!VWTRV!V\bbONM#!+P!LOPMNWVMK!OMSRN!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU!\PQMVK!ObRNWMQPU!XQMS!TQcQMRY!NRVO\NLRVK!cW_!

Page 20: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! $I#!

TWL`!MSR!W[QTQM_!MO!bRNZONc!V\LS!WLMQ^QMQRV!V\LS!WV!bNOY\LM!YQVMNQ[\MQOP!WPY!VRN^QLR!V\bbONM!YQNRLMT_#!

2%NcQVMRWY!<!&TWN`K!"HH$3#!

EON! R]WcbTRK! %>&! &ONbONWMQOP! YRLRPMNWTQjRY! [OMS! QMV! bNOY\LM! YQVMNQ[\MQOP! WPY! WZMRNBVWTRV! VRN^QLR!

V\bbONM! Z\PLMQOPV#! 'SR! LOcbWP_! LSOVR! QPVMRWY! MO! LOPLRPMNWMR! OP! YR^RTObQPU! QMV! bNOY\LM! TQPR! WPY!

LOPMNWLMRY!XQMS!)1AV!QP!ONYRN!MO!V\N^Q^R!QP!MSR!ZWVMBR^OT^QPU!LOcb\MRN!QPY\VMN_#!+P!LOPMNWVMK!%TbSW!

AQLNOV_VMRcVK!W!cW`RN!OZ!cQYNWPUR!LOcb\MRN!V_VMRcVK!LSOVR!MO!LRPMNWTQjR![OMS!bNOY\LM!YQVMNQ[\MQOP!

WPY!WZMRNBVWTRV! VRN^QLR! V\bbONM! Z\PLMQOPV#!%TbSW!AQLNOV_VMRcV!cWYR! VRN^QLR! WP! QPMRUNWT! bWNM! OZ! QMV!

[\VQPRVV!QP!ONYRN!MO!bNOMRLM!QMV!cWN`RM!VSWNR!QP!MSR!LOcb\MRN!QPY\VMN_!2/OOc[WK!"HH:3#!

%$L J-,A88-+(*24A+1.6\R!MO!MSR!PWM\NR!OZ!%LMNOPQL,V!^WVM!YQVMNQ[\MQOP!LSWPPRTVK!YRLRPMNWTQjWMQOP!OZ!MSR!WZMRN!VWTRV!V\bbONM!

WPY!VRN^QLR!XQMS!LRPMNWT!LOONYQPWMQOP!XO\TY![R!URMMQPU!LTOVR!MO!MSR!WZONRcRPMQOPRY![RVM!bNWLMQLRV#!

%LMNOPQL! SWV! W! XQYR! YQVMNQ[\MON! PRMXON`! QP! ^WNQO\V! NRUQOPWT! TOLWMQOPV#! 'SR! YQVMNQ[\MONV! LWP! [R!

MRLSPQLWTT_! MNWQPRY! MO! LOPY\LM! QPBZQRTY! cWQPMRPWPLR! WPY! NRbWQN#! %! VbRLQWTQjRY! cWP\ZWLM\NQPU! ZQNc!

V\LS!WV!%LMNOPQL!LWP![RPRZQM!ZNOc!SW^QPU!VRN^QLR!WV!W!NR^RP\R!URPRNWMON#!%LMNOPQL!LWP![RPRZQM!ZNOc!

OZZRNQPU! WZMRN! VWTRV! V\bbONM! QP! ZONcV! OZ! WP! R]MRPYRY!XWNNWPM_K! XSRNR[_! MSR! ZQRTY! MRLSPQLQWPV! LWP!

OZZRN! NRU\TWN! cWQPMRPWPLR! WPY! VRN^QLR! V\bbONM#! +Z! MSR! ZW\TM! QV! QNNRbWNW[TRK! %LMNOPQL! LWP! bNO^QYR! W!

NRbTWLRcRPMK!bNO^QYRY!MSR!bNOY\LM!QV!XQMSQP!MSR!XWNNWPM_!bRNQOY#!!

6RLRPMNWTQjWMQOP!OZ!VRN^QLR!V\bbONM!LWP![R! QPQMQWMRY! QP! ZRX!`R_! TOLWMQOPV#!'SQV!PRMXON`!LWP!MSRP![R!

UNWY\WTT_!R]bWPYRY! QPMO!OMSRN! NRUQOPWT! TOLWMQOPV#!1QMSRNg! 2Q3!-RM!\b!W!VbRLQWTQjRY!VRN^QLQPU! MRWc!ZON!

^WNQO\V!TOLWMQOPV!ON!2QQ3!'NWQP!YQVMNQ[\MONV!MO!bNO^QYR!VWTRV!WPY!VRN^QLR!V\bbONM#!'SQV!2QQ3!XQTT!NRY\LR!MSR!

LOVMV!WVVOLQWMRY!XQMS!SW^QPU!W!VbRLQWTQjRY!MRLSPQLWT!V\bbONM!MRWc#!!

%LMNOPQL! LWP! WbbOQPM! W! UTO[WT! VRN^QLR! V\bbONM! LOONYQPWMONecWPWURN! LRPMNWTT_! QP! %\L`TWPY! XSO! QV!

MRLSPQLWTT_!VO\PY!WPY!LOcc\PQLWMRV!XQMS!MSR!ZQRTY!MRLSPQLQWPV!ZON!LOONYQPWMQOP!OZ!VRN^QLR!WLMQ^QMQRV#!

'SR! VRN^QLR!LOONYQPWMON!XQTT![R! NRVbOPVQ[TR! ZON!`RRbQPU! MNWL`!OZ! MSR! VRN^QLR! VMWM\VK! LOcc\PQLWMQPU!

XQMS!MSR!ZQRTY!MRLSPQLQWPV!OP!MRLSPQLWT!cWMMRNVK!ONUWPQjR!QP^RVMQUWMQOPV!WPY!NRbWQNV!MO![R!YOPR!WM!MSR!

VRN^QLR! LRPMNR! QZ! MSR! NRbWQN! LWPPOM! [R! YOPR! [_! MSR! ZQRTY! MRLSPQLQWPV! WPY! SW^R! W! VbRLQWTQjRY! MRWc!

2WT[RQM! VcWTT3! MSWM! YRWTV!XQMS! OPT_! MSR! WZMRN! VWTRV! VRN^QLR! V\bbONM! WPY! NRbWQNV#! 'SQV! MRWc! LWP! WTVO!

bNO^QYR! V\bbONM! QP! MRNcV! OZ! MNWQPQPU! MSR! YQVMNQ[\MON! PRMXON`! OP! W! NRU\TWN! [WVQV#! 'SR! VRN^QLR!

LOONYQPWMON! WPY! SQV! MRWc! XQTT! WTVO! [R! NRVbOPVQ[TR! ZON! MSR! VRN^QLR! YWMW[WVRK! XSQLS! LWP! [R! `RbM!

\bYWMRY!VO!MSWM!QPZONcWMQOP!LWP![R!b\TTRY!O\M!RWVQT_!VSO\TY!W!ZW\TM!QV!NRbRWMRY#!EQU\NR!G!YQVbTW_V!MSR!

L\NNRPM!WPY!bNObOVRY!VMN\LM\NR!2[_!MSR!W\MSON3!OZ!VRN^QLR!cWPWURcRPM!WM!%LMNOPQL#!!

!

Page 21: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! $"#!

!

!

!

!

(?@ABC&<.&1ABBCIG&RES&EIF&9BDLDMCF&RQS&MGBAKGABC&JDB&MCBU?KC&KDDBF?IEG?DI&EG&"KGBDI?K&

!

%$% CO*55-+7-1.+cbNO^QPU! WP! WZMRNBVWTRV! [\VQPRVV! QV! POM! WP! RWV_! \PYRNMW`QPU#! )ZMRPK! MSRNR! WNR! P\cRNO\V! QPMRNPWT!

[WNNQRNV!MO!O^RNLOcR#!EQNcV!WNR!\V\WTT_!\PWXWNR!OZ!MSR!cWN`RM!bOMRPMQWT!OZ!MSR!WZMRN!VWTRV![\VQPRVVl!

SRPLR! ZQPY! QM! YQZZQL\TM! MO! ZONc! [\VQPRVV! VMNWMRUQRV! WNO\PY! MSR! WZMRN! VWTRV! bWNM! OZ! MSR! [\VQPRVV#! %P!

WZMRNBVWTRV![\VQPRVV!OZMRP!SWV!W! TOXRN!LONbONWMR!WbbRWT!MSWP!W!PRX!bNOY\LM![\VQPRVV#!9RPLRK!ZQNcV!

WNR!NRT\LMWPM!MO!YRYQLWMR!MQcR!WPY!MWTRPM!MO!MSR!VRN^QLR!bWNM!OZ!MSR![\VQPRVV#!AWPWURNV!OZMRP![RTQR^R!

MSWM! RPMRNQPU! MSR! WZMRNBVWTRV! [\VQPRVV! XQTT! YRMNWLM! ZNOc! MSR! XON`! OZ! VRTTQPU! PRX! bNOY\LMV#! -WTRV!

YRbWNMcRPMV! ZNRa\RPMT_! NRUWNY! WP! WZMRNBVWTRV! UNO\b! WV! W! NQ^WTK! WPY! VO! YQVLO\NWUR! MSR! bNOWLMQ^R!

cWN`RMQPU!WPY!VWTRV!OZ!QMV!VRN^QLRV#!%P!RZZRLMQ^R!WbbNOWLS!SRNR!XO\TY![R!MO!LOP^QPLR!MSR!VWTRV!VMWZZ!

MSWM!XSRNR! MSRNR! QV! W! YRcWPY! ZON! WZMRNBVWTRV! VRN^QLR! MSWM! QV! POM!cRM! [_! MSR!ONUWPQjWMQOPK! RQMSRN! W!

VbRLQWTQjRY!LOcbRMQMON!XQTT!VRQjR!MSR!ObbONM\PQM_!ON!MSR!L\VMOcRNV!XQTT!VXQMLS!MO!WPOMSRN!Ra\QbcRPM!

V\bbTQRN! MSWM! bNO^QYRV! MSR! V\bbONM! MSR_! NRa\QNR#! EQPWTT_K! QPV\ZZQLQRPM! LOONYQPWMQOP! XQMSQP! WP!

ONUWPQjWMQOP!LWP!TRWY!MO!L\VMOcRN!LOPZ\VQOP!WPY!YQVVWMQVZWLMQOP!2=PRLSMK!/RVjQPV`QK!<!DR[RNK!"HH73#!

&1)!

8TO[WT!-RN^QLR!-\bbONM!AWPWURN!

EQRTY!-RN^QLR!1PUQPRRN!

(RUQOP!%!!

EQRTY!-RN^QLR!1PUQPRRN!!

(RUQOP!>!

EQRTY!-RN^QLR!1PUQPRRN!!

(RUQOP!&!

-RN^QLR!1PUQPRRNe'RLSPQLQWP!!

%\L`TWPY!ZWLMON_!

&\VMOcRN!(RTWqOPVSQb!AWPWURN!

&1)!

-\bbT_!<!LSWQP!AWPWURN!

AZU!MRLS!AWPWURN!

25NOY\LqOP!<!5\NLSWVR3!

&\VMOcRN!NRTWqOPVSQb!cWPWURN!

-RN^QLR!&OONYQPWMON!

2W3!

2[3!

Page 22: Assignment_1_DineshMathur_22_feedback

! ! !!

! ! $$#!

49 CA+,5014A+1.!

'SQV! NRbONM! LNQMQLWTT_! WPWT_VRY! MSR! L\NNRPM!cWP\ZWLM\NQPU! bNOLRVVRV! WPY!cWPWURcRPM! bNWLMQLRV! WM!

%LMNOPQL#!%ZMRN! VWTRV! VRN^QLR!WM!WLMNOPQL!XWV! NRLOUPQjRY! MO![R!W!cWdON! QVV\R! ZON!%LMNOPQL#!ENOc!MSR!

WPWT_VQV!W[O^RK! QM! QV!R^QYRPM! MSWM!bNOY\LM!YQVMNQ[\MQOP!WPY!WZMRNBVWTRV!VRN^QLR!V\bbONM!VMNWMRUQRV!WNR!

LTOVRT_!TQP`RY!MO!RWLS!OMSRN#!'SRNR!QV!PO!OPR![RVM!bNWLMQLR!MSWM!W!ZQNc!LWP!ZOTTOX!MO!U\WNWPMRR!MSRQN!

V\LLRVV#!EON!%LMNOPQLK!QMV!WZMRN!VWTRV!VRN^QLR!WPY!V\bbONM!LWP![RPRZQM!ZNOc!YRLRPMNWTQjWMQOP!WV!XRTT!WV!

YQZZRNRPMQWMQOP! OZ! MSR! V\bbT_! WPY! LSWQP! YRbWNMcRPM#! -OcR! OZ! MSR! bOMRPMQWT! LSWTTRPURV! MSWM! QM!cW_!

ZWLR!QP!MSQV!bNOLRVV!SW^R!WTVO![RRP!NRLOUPQjRY#!!

69 J-B-3-+,-1.!

%[O\M!/OWYNQMR#!!!(RMNQR^RY!"!AW_K!$I"$K!ZNOc!SMMbgeeXXX#TOWYNQMRVLWTRV#LOceW[O\MTOWYNQMR#SMcT#!%LMNOPQL#!ZNOc!SMMbgeeXXX#WLMNOPQLMRLSPOTOUQRV#LOc#!%LMNOPQL#!$I""K!ZNOc!SMMbgeeXXX#WLMNOPQLMRLSPOTOUQRV#LOc!%LMNOPQL#!2$II73#!>"0D/0*D)=<.-"$)@*.-#55#-0&*)D30+"#!%LMNOPQL#!!!%NcQVMRWYK! &#! 8#K! <! &TWN`K! 8#! 2"HH$3#! &\VMOcRN! -RN^QLR! WPY! -\bbONMg! +cbTRcRPMQPU! 1ZZRLMQ^R!

-MNWMRUQRV#!!>WTTuK!E#K!<!>WTTuK!A#!2$II43#!'SR!8OTY!AQPRg!%!*O^RT!OZ!/RWP!'\NPWNO\PY#!!>RL`ZONYK!J#!2$IIH3#!Q3#50-<8)K)2'0-07#5)@*-'&+37-0&*g!'W_TON!<!ENWPLQV#!>RVM! 5NWLMQLRV! -\N^R_g! /OL`SRRY! AWNMQP! 1TRLMNOPQLV! WPY! AQVVQTRV! 2"HH43K! ZNOc!

SMMbgeeXXX#[cbLOR#ONUe[RVMbNWLMQLRVeQPMRNPWTeTcRceQPYR]#SMcT!>SWVQPK!-#K!<!>\NLSRNK!5#!2$II:3#!/RWP!^QRXRY!WV!W!bSQTOVObS_#!R&3'*#5)&C)S#*3C#7-3'0*D)!"7/*&5&D<)

S#*#D"$"*-E)TU2"3K!4:BC$#!!8WN^QPK!6#!%#!2"HGG3#!S#*#D0*D)H3#50-<8)-/").-'#-"D07)#*+)7&$1"-0-0;")"+D"F!*RX!FON`g!ENRR!5NRVV#!8OTYNWMMK!1#!A#K!<!&O]K!J#!2"HH$3#!'SR!UOWTg!W!bNOLRVV!OZ!OPUOQPU!QcbNO^RcRPM#!!8NQUUK!*#!2$I"I3#!Q3#50-<)=<.-"$.):".0D*)=-3+<)V30+"#!AWVVR_!0PQ^RNVQM_#!%\L`TWPYK!*RX!iRWTWPY#!!=PRLSMK!'#K!/RVjQPV`QK!(#K!<!DR[RNK!E#!%#!2"HH73#!AW`QPU!5NOZQMV!WZMRN!MSR!VWTR#!!/")S7W0*."<)Q3#'-"'5<E)

X#!/OOc[WK! %#! 5#! -#! 2"HH:3#! /QP`WURV! [RMXRRP! bNOY\LM! YQVMNQ[\MQOP! WPY! VRN^QLR! V\bbONM! Z\PLMQOPV#!

@*-"'*#-0&*#5)R&3'*#5)&C),/<.07#5):0.-'0B3-0&*)J)Y&D0.-07.)S#*#D"$"*-E)Z[2@3K!@B$$#!!AWMSNWPQK!-#!2$I"$3#!%Y^WPLR!+PY\VMNQWT!AWPWURcRPM!5NWLMQLRV!-M\Y_!8\QYR#g!AWVVR_!0PQ^RNVQM_#!(WOK! %#! 2"HH:3#! !&-#5) Q3#50-<) S#*#D"$"*-8) K) 2'&..?63*7-0&*#5) ,"'.1"7-0;"g! JOSP! DQTR_! <! -OPV!

&WPWYW#!(R.RTTRK! J#!>#! 2$II"3#!AWP\ZWLM\NQPU!9WPY[OO`!OZ!>RVM!5NWLMQLRV! g!%P! +PPO^WMQOPK!5NOY\LMQ^QM_K! WPY!

?\WTQM_!EOL\Vg!>OLW!(WMOPK!10%!g!-M#!/\LQR!5NRVV#!(O\VRK!D#!>#!2$II:3#!1PMRNbNQVR!'NWPVZONcWMQOPg!0PYRNVMWPYQPU!WPY!1PW[TQPU!E\PYWcRPMWT!&SWPUR#!!'9+*=VMNWMRUQRV#! 2$II@3#! 'NWPVZONcQPU! MSR! -RN^QLR! >\VQPRVV! +PMO! W! (R^RP\R! 1PUQPRK! ZNOc!

SMMbgeeXXX#MSQP`VMNWMRUQRV#LOceQcWURVe1PLO^RNzDSQMRbWbRN#bYZ!

!

!

Sanjay Mathrani
An insightful and well written report that presents an evaluation of manufacturing processes and practices at Actronic Technologies. The report highlights issues, reviews best practices and provides recommendations. However, some parts of the report could have been better explained. For example, section 3.1 includes issues of oven constraints and the proposed solution is the use of specialised trolley reducing loading time. But, no details of the proposed trolley system are provided. Also, section 3.3 addresses the issue of multi-language manual packaging and its use in different countries. Here, the current and proposed process could have been better clarified. In the after sales discussion in section 4.1, current issues relate to communication gap between stakeholders. A solution to this issue is not clearly evident, although a decentralised service operation as a revenue generator is proposed. Some of these issues and solutions could have been analysed and explained more. Some good references have been reviewed, however review of more recent journal articles in the related topics would have enhanced the presentation. Although, overall the report is well presented. Well done. Grade: B+