Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Voluntary and involuntary actions
• In voluntary actions, we know what we are doing and we bring it about ourselves– Force and ignorance render actions
involuntary– 3 cases of stepping on someone’s
foot
Force
• Physical force and psychological pressure– Don’t blame someone where psychological
pressure is very strong– When we act involuntarily, we do so with
pain and regret• What of sailors throwing goods
overboard in a storm?– This is voluntary, in that it is chosen to
avoid a greater evil– And we praise them for their choice – praise
and blame attaches only to voluntary action
Ignorance
• Whether an action done from ignorance is involuntary or ‘not voluntary’ depends on regret– Stepping on someone’s foot (caring, not caring)
• Acting in ignorance ≠ acting from ignorance– E.g. acting when drunk or in a rage – it is these
conditions, not ignorance, that bring about the action
• Involuntary action from ignorance involves ignorance of the particular circumstances of action– What you are actually doing, its consequences,
your manner of acting …
Voluntary action
• Again: In voluntary actions, we know what we are doing and we bring it about ourselves
• Actions done from desire or emotion are still voluntary– If not, then neither children nor animals ever act
voluntarily– Many good actions, that we ought to do, are
done from desire or emotion– Involuntary actions are painful, many actions
done from desire are pleasant– Our desires and emotions are part of us – we act
from them
What is choice?
• Everything we choose to do is voluntary, but not everything voluntary is chosen– E.g. the actions of children
• Choice is what we decide upon as a result of deliberation
• Deliberation is reasoning about what we can change– Esp. where we need to act not from habit
but differently on different occasions
Deliberating about ends
• Do we deliberate about means only, or also ends?– I might deliberate about whether it is worth
the effort to get good grades– I might deliberate about which end to
pursue when two ends conflict• Aristotle: we don’t deliberate about
ends as ends, i.e. we always have some end in view– Getting good grades as a means to an end– Which end to pursue as part of the good life
Are bad actions voluntary?
• Do people who are bad do bad things voluntarily and by choice?– Socrates: no - everyone aims at what they
believe is good and doing something bad is acting from ignorance
– Aristotle: it involves ignorance, but is still voluntary
• To know (fully) what the right act is involves understanding why it is right– Bad people desire what is not truly desirable,
but they are ignorant of this fact – Something bad can seem desirable if we think it
is pleasant
Bad people act voluntarily
• What it is in our power to do, it is in our power not to do. So we can choose to do either good or bad actions. So bad actions are voluntary.
• We encourage people not to do bad actions, yet we don’t encourage people not to do things that are out of their power.
Moral responsibility
• Obj: Bad people act voluntarily, but are not morally responsible, because they do not know that what they desire is not desirable.
• Reply: Bad people became bad as a result of their choices. Therefore, they are responsible for becoming bad, and thus becoming ignorant of what is good.
Moral responsibility
• We acquire a particular state of character by acting in a corresponding way.
• Like becoming drunk and then not knowing what you are doing; or becoming ill through ignoring medical advice; we are responsible for becoming bad through the choices we made.
• Bad action is done in ignorance, not from ignorance.
Moral responsibility
• If the bad person is not responsible for their bad actions, and these are not done voluntarily, then the good person is not responsible for their good actions, and these are not done voluntarily.
• Actions and character traits are not voluntary in the same way. – Voluntary actions are under our control from
start to finish. Character traits are only under our control at the beginning.
