24
ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor between the sexes and devotion by women to child-rearing NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL: That only the male brain is suited for quantitative and abstract reasoning MEDICAL: That adolescent girls would become barren if asked to study as hard at school as boys PSYCHOLOGICAL: That women are especially prone to mental illness (“hysteria”) Experts began to challenge all these arguments in the 1880s and ‘90s….

ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITYin the mid-nineteenth century

SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor between the sexes and devotion by women to child-rearingNEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL: That only the male brain is suited for quantitative and abstract reasoningMEDICAL: That adolescent girls would become barren if asked to study as hard at school as boysPSYCHOLOGICAL: That women are especially prone to mental illness (“hysteria”)

Experts began to challenge all these arguments in the 1880s and ‘90s….

Page 2: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Rural family scene (1839)

Page 3: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

The (bourgeois) Children’s Nursery (1823)

Page 4: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

“The Sewing Room” (1823)

Page 5: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

The tyranny of French fashion (Iris, 1852)

Page 6: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

“The Female University Student”

(cartoon from 1847)

Page 7: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

“In the Women’s Club” (1848):

“We demand that skirts be abolished and that men take

over the housework!”

Page 8: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

BEYOND Kinder, Küche, Kirche: The Women’s Rights Movement in Imperial Germany

1865Foundation of the “German Women’s Association” (ADF) by Luise Otto-Peters: 12,000 members in 1877; 14,000 in 1914

1894Formation of the League of German Women’s Associations (BDF), with 300,000 members in 1914

1900 German Civil Code takes effect

1904Foundation of the “League for Sexual Reform” by Helene Stöcker, which disintegrated in 1908

1908Women gain the right to enroll for degrees in Prussian universities and to join political clubs

1918German women gain the vote after war’s end

Page 9: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

A female bicyclist (ca. 1900)

Page 10: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Berlin exhibit of women’s “Reform Dress” (around 1903)

Page 11: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Gymnastics class for girls, around 1912

Page 12: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

German parents did give daughters some freedom to choose a suitor (courting in a Berlin park, around

1907)

Page 13: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

A bourgeois family, photographed in the studio around 1895:

The ideal of “companionate

marriage” pervaded the middle

classes by the 1890s.

Page 14: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

THE SPREAD OF FAMILY PLANNING IN GERMANYTotal number of children born by women married in the

years--

Pre-1905

1905-09 1910-14 1915-19

In cities with over 100,000 people

Self-employed

3.30 2.40 1.98 1.61

White-collar 3.01 2.40 2.04 1.74

Blue-collar 4.03 3.16 2.64 2.18

Among the peasantry (villages with under 2,000)

Self-employed

5.42 4.64 4.10 3.52

Farmworker 6.18 5.38 4.87 4.26

Page 15: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Luise Otto-Peters

(1819-1895): The founder of the “German

Women’s Association”

(ADF)

Page 16: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Helene Lange (1848-1930) and Lily Braun (1865-1916)

Page 17: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Girls’ High School in Berlin-Lichterfelde, 1896:Most of these students soon became housewives

Page 18: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Berlin medical students (all male) attend a lecture in 1905

Page 19: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Young women practice good posture at a dancing school, 1899

Page 20: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

University students in 1908:Baden admitted women in 1900; Prussia in 1908

Page 21: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Delegates to the Women’s Suffrage Congress in Munich, 1912

Page 22: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

“Women’s Dreams about the Marriage of the Future” (1908)

Page 23: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

Emmeline Pankhurst arrested outside Buckingham Palace

Picture of her prison cell, 1911

Page 24: ARGUMENTS AGAINST WOMEN’S EQUALITY in the mid-nineteenth century SOCIOLOGICAL: That all progress of civilization depends on a strict division of labor

“Give Us Women’s Suffrage,” poster for the

International Women’s Congress of March 1914,

organized by Clara Zetkin:“Until now, prejudice and reactionary attitudes have denied full civic rights to women, who as workers,

mothers, and citizens wholly fulfill their duty, who must pay their taxes to the state as well as the municipality.

Fighting for this natural human right must be the

firm, unwavering intention of every woman, every female

worker.”