Upload
eunice-nuesca-rabac
View
238
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 1/52
Argumentative
Essay
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 2/52
In this kind of essay, we not onlygive information but also present anargument with the PROS (supportingideas) and CONS (opposing ideas) of anargumentative issue. We should clearly
take our stand and write as if we aretrying to persuade an opposingaudience to adopt new beliefs or
behavior. The primary objective is topersuade people to change beliefs thatmany of them do not want to change.
•
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 3/52
Steps in choosing a topic
1. It should be narrowed down. X Marijuana should be consideredillegal. (Not a good topic because it is too
general. In some medical cases,marijuana is prescribed by the doctorsand the patients are encouraged to use it
in case of suffering from too much pain)√ Selling and using marijuana in publicplaces should be considered illegal.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 4/52
2. it should contain an argument.
X We should decide whether we wanta bicycle or a car. (our stand is notclear: do we support having bicycles orcars?)
√ If we are under the age of 30 andwant a healthy life, we should definitelyget a bicycle instead of a car.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 5/52
X Are you one of those who thinkscheating is not good for students? (a
question cannot be an argument)
• √ Cheating helps students learn.
• X Considering its geological position,Turkey has an important geopoliticalrole in the EU. (facts cannot bearguments)
• √ Considering its geopolitical role, wecan clearly say that the EU cannot bewithout Turkey.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 6/52
3. It should be a topic that can beadequately supported (with statistics,outside source citations, etc.)
X I feel that writing an argumentativeessay is definitely a challenging task.(feelings cannot be supported; wecannot persuade other people)
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 8/52
OrganizationThere are three possible organization
patterns:
Pattern 1:
Thesis statement:PRO idea 1
PRO idea 2
CON(s) + Refutation(s)
Conclusion
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 9/52
Pattern 2:
Thesis statement:
CON(s) + Refutation(s)
PRO idea 1PRO idea 2
Conclusion
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 10/52
Pattern 3:
Thesis statement:
CON idea 1 ---> Refutation
CON idea 2 ---> RefutationCON idea 3 ---> Refutation
Conclusion
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 11/52
Supporting Ideas
This is the most important part whenpersuading others. We are asking some
people to change their beliefs oractions. We should be supporting ourideas with such facts, statistics and/orauthorities that there should not be
room for any doubts.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 12/52
Here are some faulty supports thatyou must avoid:
Thesis: Leaving the university andstarting to work is good for theadolescent because …
• Feelings, emotional arguments (… itmakes one feel much better.)
• Irrelevant examples (wandering off thetopic) (… he would then be able to takehis girlfriend to expensive restaurants.)
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 13/52
• Oversimplification (… only then wouldhe understand what it means to be anadult.)
• Hasty generalizations (... it is a widelyknown fact that all adolescents look
forward to earning money.)
• Unreliable, even false outside sources(… according to www.doubtme.com,
80% of working men wish they quitschool when they were at universityand started working at an earlier age.)
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 14/52
Refuting opposing arguments
Before we start saying that theopponents are wrong, we should specify their opposing ideas. Otherwise, it would
be like hitting the other person with eyesclosed. We should see clearly what weare hitting and be prepared beforehand
so that he cannot hit us back. We can dothis by knowing what we are refuting.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 15/52
e.g. X Some people may say thatadolescents should not leave universityeducation; however, they are wrong.(what they say is not wrong. Maybe
their supporting idea is wrong /irrelevant /insufficient. We should statetheir supporting idea specifically to be
able to refute it.)
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 16/52
• √ Some people may say that adolescents
should not leave university educationbecause they are not physically andpsychologically mature enough to copewith the problems of the real world.However, they forget one fact:adolescents can vote or start driving atthe age of 18 (in some countries even
before that age!), which proves that theyare considered physically andpsychologically mature at that age.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 17/52
LanguageSignposts gain importance in the
argumentative essay. They enable thereaders to follow our arguments easily.
When pointing out opposing arguments
(CONs):
• Opponents of this idea claim / maintainthat …
• Those who disagree / are against theseideas may say / assert that …
• Some people may disagree with this idea.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 18/52
When stating specifically why they think like that:
They put forward this idea because …
They claim that … since …
Reaching the turning point:
However,
butOn the other hand,
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 20/52
• say that their argument is irrelevant tothe topic:
What we are discussing here is notwhat they are trying to prove.
Their argument is irrelevant.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 21/52
To write an argumentative essay, use thefollowing steps to help you:
1. Begin by introducing the debate topic inyour own words.
2. Then write if you agree or disagree with
the argument3. Tell people why you hold that opinion and
come up with ideas and examples to back
up your arguments. Try to put these ideasin an order with the most important ideasfirst and links between each idea so that
the essay flows well.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 22/52
• 4. Think about why people might havea different opinion (objections) and try
to show why they are not important orthey are not true.
• 5. Conclude with a brief summary and
try to make a strong last sentence thatpeople will remember.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 23/52
For example Oprah Winfrey famouslywrote," I believe the choice to beexcellent begins with aligning yourthoughts and words with the intention
to require more from yourself." The restof the article maybe forgotten, but thatstrong sentence is remembered.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 25/52
The goal of argument is to gainyour reader's assent to your central
proposition, despite active
opposition “We argue not because we're angry, but because arguing causes us to examine
our own and others' ideas carefully. Itcauses us to weigh conflicting claims;to make judgments about the nature of evidence and the methods of
investigation; to state our thoughtsclearly, accurately, and honestly; toconsider, respectfully and critically, theideas of others.”
http://www.powa.org/argument/index.html
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 26/52
Arguing in ContextWriter: A college freshman away from homeand working part-time at a fast-foodrestaurant to pay her expenses, a seriousstudent majoring in pre-medicine but
getting mentally and emotionally exhaustedfrom the various pressures in her life. Reader: Her parents, but especially herfather who, she knows, will make the final
decision after talking the issue out with hermother.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 27/52
Her father is a successful banker, generally loving and supportive but a bit old-fashioned inthat he wants the daughter to get the kind of education that would fit her for a moreconventional "woman's role" in society, maybedental hygiene or nursing since she is interestedin medicine. Her mother almost always remains
subordinate to the father, but exerts a great dealof influence on the father and has at least hintedthat she supports the girl's desire to become adoctor.
Purpose: To persuade her father to temporarily increase his level of financial support by ahundred dollars a month so that she can quither job and concentrate more on her studies.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 29/52
Stating Your Proposition
Argumentative proposition= thesis statement
stating main point helps youdirect, develop and monitor
at 1st, hunches or goodguesses probably will bemodified or revised make a
claim that is open to debate
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 30/52
Examples
Some people ruin things for everyonevague provides no direction
A small group of thoughtless fans is jeopardizing the school’s whole soccer program.
precise
propositions
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 31/52
Anticipating Oppositionsense an adversary
• How strong is the opposition?
• What arguments might it use against my proposition?
• How can I refute these arguments?
• Will I have to concede any points?• Which of my arguments might the opposition try to
discredit?
• How closely does my reader identify with opposition?
• Can I see any weak links in my adversary?
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 33/52
For (Pro)
1. Faster typists would produce more lines.2. Faster typists would make more money.
3. One less transcriptionist would be needed.
4. One less word processing machine would beneeded.
5. Less office space would be needed.
6. One less benefit package would be needed.
7. Less overtime would be required.
8. Less sick time would be paid.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 34/52
Against (Con)1. Typists would do not do other duties, such as
paper work.
2. Typists would try to type the easier reports.
3. Typists would do a poorer quality of work.
4. Slower typists would be mad.
5. Typists could make more money than the boss.
6. Other people in the department would be mad.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 35/52
Expanding Your ArgumentDevelop points listed in chart.
Think in terms of paragraphs.Examples, explanation, comparison and contrast, facts
Arguments for is confirmingClear, reasonable, solid
Arguments against is refutingShow how case is weak
Both are essential
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 36/52
Three Argumentative Appeals
Reason “Briefly informal reasoning requires clearly linking your
general claims with concrete, specific data.”
Ethics “If you misrepresent the implications of your own value
structure, or seek to hurt some individual or group,you can expect to alienate your readers.”
Emotion “…emotional appeals must be used with restraint and
discretion, or they may prove counterproductive.”
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 37/52
Inductive reasoning
Thinking begins with specifics and moves toward a
generalization.
If you were to taste several green, plump grapes and then
draw the conclusion that all green, plump grapes are sour,
this is inductive reasoning.
In writing
have you examined the evidence carefully?
does the evidence justify your conclusion?
have you given enough specific evidence to make readers
believe your thinking is sound and conclusion is true?
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 38/52
Deductive reasoning
Thinking begins with general and moves toward specifics
by taking a general principle that you know to be true and
use it to understand a specific situation.
For example, bad weather reduces business for outdoor
restaurants. Today is cold and rainy. From this
knowledge, you can say Business will be slow today at the
outdoor restaurants. This is deductive reasoning.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 39/52
Ethics
The best way to put ethical appeal in your writing is to
“build a strong, healthy relationship with your readers.
Convince them that they can trust you to be fair, honest,
well-informed, and well-intentioned. Then having
established that trust, don’t betray it.” http://www.powa.org/argument/appeals.html
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 40/52
Activity Letting 10 represent the highest and 1 the lowest, rate the
following public figures for their appeal to character.Of course, you’ll be considering more that just writing,but the activity should still give you some insight intowhat ethos is and how it affects credibility. Whenyou’ve finished, compare your ratings with those of a
partner. Discuss the reasons for your scoring.
a. Manny Pacquiao b. Adolf Hitler c. Barrack Obama d. Benigno Aquino Jr.e. Gloria Macapagal- Arroyo f. BB Gandang Hari
g. Katrina Halili h. Michael Jacksoni. Tiger Woods j. Mayor Ampatuan
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 41/52
Emotion Don’t overdo emotion or people won’t take you seriously, but
a little bit of emotion will probably help if carefully reasoned
and honestly presented.
Illustrate or dramatize an ideaFor example, if stiffer measures are needed against drunk
drivers, find a place to include a description of the face of a childwho was injured in a drunk driving accident. OR tell the story of a
driver who caused several accidents because the individual’s license
was never revoked.
Careful word choiceDrunk or intoxicated drivers a menace or a concern
Thrown into jail or incarcerated
Teach them a lesson or make them aware of the consequences of
their actions
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 42/52
Form: Tradition and Innovation
…essential parts include theIntroduction
Statement of the Case
Proposition
Refutation
Confirmation
Conclusion
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 43/52
Introduction
Focus your reader’s attention.
Begin with a fact or example
Note a common misconception
Raise a question
Make a bold assertion
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 44/52
Introduction
“Torture: The word itself brings shivers to the
spine and sickness to the stomach. It conjures up pictures
of bamboo strips being driven under fingernails, electric
shocks being applied to delicate body parts and toes and
ears being systematically cut off. Immediate sympathy is
felt for the one being tortured and revulsion for the
torturer. It is generally assumed that torture is barbaric, a
throwback to a more brutal age. Enlightened, “civilized”
societies reject it outright, and regimes suspected of using itrisk the wrath of the United States. I believe that this
attitude is unwise. There are situations in which torture is
not merely permissible, but needed” (Levin).
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 45/52
Statement of the Case
Tell the story behind the argument.
Give any necessary background information.
Clarify the issue.Characterize and define the issue in terms
that work for your argument.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 46/52
Proposition Statement
State your proposition (purpose) much as
you would the thesis in a thesis/support essay
Perhaps set up expectations by hinting at
important sub points that will be considered.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 47/52
Refutation
Examine and refute opposition arguments.
Expose faulty reasoning.
Use these transitions: since, because, if,
therefore, as a result, consequently, however,
but, on the other hand, so
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 48/52
Refutation
“Torturing the terrorist is unconstitutional, but
millions of lives surely outweigh unconstitutionality.
Torture is barbaric. Mass murder is far more
barbaric. Indeed, letting millions of innocents diein deference to one who flaunts his guilt is moral
cowardice. If you caught the terrorist, could you
sleep nights knowing that millions died because you
could not bring yourself to apply the electrodes”
(Levin)?
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 49/52
Confirmation
Develop and support your own case, much in
the manner of a traditional /thesis/support
essay. Use examples, facts, and statistics toback up your claims.
Base your appeal primarily on logic.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 50/52
Confirmation
Order
1. Second most important point
2. Point of lesser importance3. Point of lesser importance
4. Most important point – anchors your
argument – like the knock-out punch in a
boxing match
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 51/52
Conclusion
Whatever you do, end strongly.
Finish with conviction.
1. Ringing conclusion2. Review of your main points
3. A reference to something in introduction
4. A plea for action
5. Discuss defections from the opposition.
8/3/2019 Argumentative Essay Eng2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/argumentative-essay-eng2 52/52
Conclusion
“There is little danger that the Western
democracies will lose their way if they choose
to inflict pain as one way of preserving order.Paralysis in the face of evil is the greater
danger. Some day soon a terrorist will
threaten tens of thousands of lives, and
torture will be the only way to save them.
We had better start thinking about this”
(Levin).