52
Appendix A Public Notices and Outreach Materials 27

Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Appendix A Public Notices and Outreach Materials

27

Appendix A Table of Contents

A ldquoTake Onerdquo Fliers 2

B Newspaper Advertisements

1 The Union Tribune 4

2 La Prensa 8

C SANDAG Fares Webpage 9

D Transit Operatorsrsquo Websites

1 MTS 12

2 NCTD 14

E Transit Operatorsrsquo Surveys

1 MTS 16

2 NCTD 17

F SANDAG Region Newsletter 18

G SANDAG Press Release 20

H SANDAG Media Advisories

1 Chula Vista 22

2 MTS Board Room 24

3 City Heights 26

4 Escondido 28

5 Oceanside 30

I SANDAG Social Media

1 Chula Vista 32

2 MTS Board Room 33

3 El Cajon 34

4 City Heights 35

5 Escondido 36

6 Oceanside 37

J SANDAG Community-Based Organizations Working Group 38

K SANDAG Public Meeting Agendas

1 Chula Vista 44

2 MTS Board Room 45

3 El Cajon 46

4 City Heights 47

5 Escondido 48

6 Oceanside 49

L Public Meeting Contact Information 50

M ldquoPop-Uprdquo Events and Other Meetings helliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphellip 51

28

Public Meetings for input on fare changes and revisions to Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance Post Until 11218

NOTICE

Public CommentsTo submit your comments in writing mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Email piosandagorgDeadline for public comments November 9 2018

The public meetings will be conducted in an open house format where participants can attend at any time during the meeting ask questions of staff complete comment cards or make their public comments to the officiant and participants In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in the public meetings listed above If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request the materials in an alternate format andor additional language(s) please call (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affecting the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance are proposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Why fare revisions are needed

PUBLIC MEETINGSMonday October 22 2018530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200-400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600-800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares

Monday October 29 2018330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 20181200-200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600-800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To request interpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting time

Reuniones puacuteblicas para obtener comentarios sobre cambios de tarifas y modificaciones a la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas

AVISO

bull Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenuehas declined and fares have not increased

bull Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of servicebull These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings Customers may also call (619) 595-5321 email piosandagorg or submit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards of Directors at which time the public can also make comments

Comentarios puacuteblicosPara enviar sus comentarios por escrito haacutegalo por correo postal aSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Correo electroacutenico piosandagorgPlazo para enviar los comentarios puacuteblicos 9 de noviembre de 2018

Las reuniones puacuteblicas se llevaraacuten a cabo en un formato de evento de puertas abiertas donde los participantes pueden asistir en cualquier momento de la reunioacuten hacer preguntas al personal completar tarjetas de comentarios o hacer comentarios puacuteblicos a los presentadores y el puacuteblico presente De conformidad con la Ley de Estadounidenses con Discapacidades (ADA por sus siglas en ingleacutes) SANDAG asistiraacute a las personas que requieran ayuda para participar en las Reuniones puacuteblicas que figuran anteriormente Si requiere tal asistencia comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 con al menos 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten Para solicitar los materiales en otro formato o idiomas adicionales llame al (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) o enviacutee un facsiacutemile al (619) 699-1905

Se llevaraacuten a cabo seis reuniones puacuteblicas en el condado de San Diego para recibir comentarios sobre la propuesta para modificar las tarifas del transporte puacuteblico que afectariacutea las aacutereas de servicio del Sistema de Transporte Puacuteblico Metropolitano (MTS por sus siglas en ingleacutes) y el Distrito de Transporte Puacuteblico del Condado Norte (NCTD por sus siglas en ingleacutes) Se propone que todos los cambios aprobados en la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas y en la Ordenanza de TransNet entren en vigor a partir del 27 de enero de 2019

iquestPor queacute es necesario ajustar las tarifas

REUNIONES PUacuteBLICASLunes 22 de octubre de 2018530 a 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Martes 23 de octubre de 2018200 a 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Mieacutercoles 24 de octubre de 2018600 a 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Formularios para comentarios disponibles en sandagorgfares

Lunes 29 de octubre de 2018330 a 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Martes 30 de octubre de 20181200 a 200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Jueves 1 de noviembre de 2018600 a 800 pmOceanside LibraryCommunity Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

bull Los costos operativos han aumentado en los uacuteltimos 10 antildeos mientras que los ingresospor tarifas han disminuido y las tarifas no han aumentado

bull Un aumento en los ingresos por tarifas ayudaraacute a mantener un alto nivel de serviciobull Estos cambios simplificaraacuten la estructura de tarifas en toda la regioacuten

A continuacioacuten encontraraacute informacioacuten sobre el programa de reuniones puacuteblicas Los clientes tambieacuten pueden llamar al (619) 595-5321 enviar un correo electroacutenico a piosandagorg o entregar comentarios por escrito si no les es posible asistir a una de las reuniones Luego de recibir y analizar los comentarios del puacuteblico las Directivas de la Asociacioacuten de Gobiernos de San Diego (SANDAG por sus siglas en ingleacutes) MTS y NCTD consideraraacuten una recomendacioacuten final que en su momento el puacuteblico tambieacuten tendraacute la oportunidad de opinar

Servicios de interpretacioacuten en espantildeol estaraacuten disponibles en estos lugares y fechas especiacuteficas Para solicitar servicios de interpretacioacuten en otros idiomas comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 al menos con 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten

29

PROPOSED FARE CHANGESbull Single one-way fare price ($250) for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE

bull Addition of a $3 Day Pass for SeniorsDisabledMedicare and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER andBREEZE ($6 for Rapid Express)

bull One discounted pass price of $26 for SDM and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE ($36 forRapid Express)

bull Increasing the minimum age for senior discounts from 60 to 65 years (seniors 60 or older prior to the effectivedate will remain eligible for reduced fares)

bull Price increases for COASTER one-way Day Pass and 30-DayMonthly Passes

bull Elimination of 2 3 4 and 14-day passes

bull Elimination of Trolley transfers to align with bus policy

bull Elimination of the SPRINTERBREEZE monthly pass (will now be $72 to include service on the MTS bus and Trolley)

bull Consideration of a $5 or $6 Adult Regional Day Pass

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

CurrentActual

ProposedPropuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $250

SDM $110 $125

MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same Igual

Rapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same Igual

MTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500-1000 $800

SDM $250-500 $400

NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125

NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125

COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250

COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275

COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325

NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambios

NCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambios

MTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFTProposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICODAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare ProductTarifa de producto

Pass TypeTipo de Pase

Current Day PassPase de un diacutea actual

Proposed Day PassPase de un diacutea Propuesto

Current 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas propuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE

Adult Adulto mdash mdash $5900 Removed Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Regional Pass (MTS Bus Trolley Rapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

Adult Adulto $500 $500 or $600 $7200 $7200

SDM mdash $300 $1800 $2600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+$500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn Adult Adulto $1200 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Premium Regionaldeg Adult Adulto mdash $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM mdash $600 $2500 $3600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + all COASTER zones)

Adult Adulto mdash $1500 mdash mdash

SDM mdash $750 $4125 $6500

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional Zone Passes

1 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $12000 $14000

2 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $15000 $16100

3 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65+

+Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free) Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372

degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (Except FLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto por FLEX 372)

CAMBIOS DE TARIFA PROPUESTOSbull Precio uacutenico de tarifa unidireccional ($250) para autobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE

bull Adicioacuten de un pase diario de $3 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes para autobuacutesMTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($6 para Rapid Express)

bull Precio de pase con descuento de $26 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes paraautobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($36 para Rapid Express)

bull Aumento de la edad miacutenima para descuentos para personas mayores de 60 a 65 antildeos (las personas mayores de60 antes de la fecha de entrada en vigor seguiraacuten siendo elegibles para las tarifas reducidas)

bull Aumento de precios para pases unidireccionales diarios y mensuales30 diacuteas de COASTER

bull Eliminacioacuten de los pases de 2 3 4 y 14 diacuteas

bull Eliminacioacuten de los traslados de Trolley para cumplir con la poliacutetica de autobuses

bull Eliminacioacuten del pase mensual SPRINTERBREEZE (ahora seraacute de $72 para incluir servicios enautobuacutes MTS y Trolley)

bull Consideracioacuten de un pase diario regional para adultos con un valor de $5 o $6

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar esta informacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To request please call (619) 231-1466

30

ths ntildean Bteoo

UniorugraveuintilderuePROOF of Publication

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoCA 921 01 -4231

STATE OF ILLINOISCOUNTY OF Cook

Proof of Publication ofThe Undersigned declares under penalty of perjury under thelaws of the State of California That heshe is and at all timesherein mentioned was a citizen of the United States over theage of twenty-one years and that heshe is not a party to norinterested in the above entitled matter that heshe iexcls CtriexclefClerk for the publisher of

San Diego Union-Tribune

a newspaper of general circulation printed and publisheddaily in the City of San Diego County of San Diego andwhich newspaper is published for the dissemination of localnews and intelligence of a general character and whichnewspaper at all the times herein mentioned had and stillhas a bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers andwhich newspaper has been established printed andpublished at regular intervals in the said City of San DiegoCounty of San Diego for a period exceeding one year neacutextpreceding the date of publication of the notice hereinafterreferred to and which newspaper is not devoted to norpublished for the interests entertainment or instruction of aparticular class profession trade calling race ordenomination or any number of same that the notice of

See Attached

which the annexedsaid newspaper inperson(s) requestingthereof on the followi

l8

of

Stefanego Uniacuteon-Tribune

copy has been published inwith the instruction of the

pub and not in any supplementng dates wit

the laws of the State ofcorrect

lllinois2018

tsa

Datedon this

SalAdvertiacutesing

5910220

31

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 2: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Appendix A Table of Contents

A ldquoTake Onerdquo Fliers 2

B Newspaper Advertisements

1 The Union Tribune 4

2 La Prensa 8

C SANDAG Fares Webpage 9

D Transit Operatorsrsquo Websites

1 MTS 12

2 NCTD 14

E Transit Operatorsrsquo Surveys

1 MTS 16

2 NCTD 17

F SANDAG Region Newsletter 18

G SANDAG Press Release 20

H SANDAG Media Advisories

1 Chula Vista 22

2 MTS Board Room 24

3 City Heights 26

4 Escondido 28

5 Oceanside 30

I SANDAG Social Media

1 Chula Vista 32

2 MTS Board Room 33

3 El Cajon 34

4 City Heights 35

5 Escondido 36

6 Oceanside 37

J SANDAG Community-Based Organizations Working Group 38

K SANDAG Public Meeting Agendas

1 Chula Vista 44

2 MTS Board Room 45

3 El Cajon 46

4 City Heights 47

5 Escondido 48

6 Oceanside 49

L Public Meeting Contact Information 50

M ldquoPop-Uprdquo Events and Other Meetings helliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphelliphellip 51

28

Public Meetings for input on fare changes and revisions to Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance Post Until 11218

NOTICE

Public CommentsTo submit your comments in writing mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Email piosandagorgDeadline for public comments November 9 2018

The public meetings will be conducted in an open house format where participants can attend at any time during the meeting ask questions of staff complete comment cards or make their public comments to the officiant and participants In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in the public meetings listed above If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request the materials in an alternate format andor additional language(s) please call (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affecting the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance are proposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Why fare revisions are needed

PUBLIC MEETINGSMonday October 22 2018530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200-400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600-800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares

Monday October 29 2018330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 20181200-200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600-800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To request interpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting time

Reuniones puacuteblicas para obtener comentarios sobre cambios de tarifas y modificaciones a la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas

AVISO

bull Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenuehas declined and fares have not increased

bull Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of servicebull These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings Customers may also call (619) 595-5321 email piosandagorg or submit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards of Directors at which time the public can also make comments

Comentarios puacuteblicosPara enviar sus comentarios por escrito haacutegalo por correo postal aSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Correo electroacutenico piosandagorgPlazo para enviar los comentarios puacuteblicos 9 de noviembre de 2018

Las reuniones puacuteblicas se llevaraacuten a cabo en un formato de evento de puertas abiertas donde los participantes pueden asistir en cualquier momento de la reunioacuten hacer preguntas al personal completar tarjetas de comentarios o hacer comentarios puacuteblicos a los presentadores y el puacuteblico presente De conformidad con la Ley de Estadounidenses con Discapacidades (ADA por sus siglas en ingleacutes) SANDAG asistiraacute a las personas que requieran ayuda para participar en las Reuniones puacuteblicas que figuran anteriormente Si requiere tal asistencia comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 con al menos 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten Para solicitar los materiales en otro formato o idiomas adicionales llame al (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) o enviacutee un facsiacutemile al (619) 699-1905

Se llevaraacuten a cabo seis reuniones puacuteblicas en el condado de San Diego para recibir comentarios sobre la propuesta para modificar las tarifas del transporte puacuteblico que afectariacutea las aacutereas de servicio del Sistema de Transporte Puacuteblico Metropolitano (MTS por sus siglas en ingleacutes) y el Distrito de Transporte Puacuteblico del Condado Norte (NCTD por sus siglas en ingleacutes) Se propone que todos los cambios aprobados en la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas y en la Ordenanza de TransNet entren en vigor a partir del 27 de enero de 2019

iquestPor queacute es necesario ajustar las tarifas

REUNIONES PUacuteBLICASLunes 22 de octubre de 2018530 a 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Martes 23 de octubre de 2018200 a 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Mieacutercoles 24 de octubre de 2018600 a 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Formularios para comentarios disponibles en sandagorgfares

Lunes 29 de octubre de 2018330 a 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Martes 30 de octubre de 20181200 a 200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Jueves 1 de noviembre de 2018600 a 800 pmOceanside LibraryCommunity Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

bull Los costos operativos han aumentado en los uacuteltimos 10 antildeos mientras que los ingresospor tarifas han disminuido y las tarifas no han aumentado

bull Un aumento en los ingresos por tarifas ayudaraacute a mantener un alto nivel de serviciobull Estos cambios simplificaraacuten la estructura de tarifas en toda la regioacuten

A continuacioacuten encontraraacute informacioacuten sobre el programa de reuniones puacuteblicas Los clientes tambieacuten pueden llamar al (619) 595-5321 enviar un correo electroacutenico a piosandagorg o entregar comentarios por escrito si no les es posible asistir a una de las reuniones Luego de recibir y analizar los comentarios del puacuteblico las Directivas de la Asociacioacuten de Gobiernos de San Diego (SANDAG por sus siglas en ingleacutes) MTS y NCTD consideraraacuten una recomendacioacuten final que en su momento el puacuteblico tambieacuten tendraacute la oportunidad de opinar

Servicios de interpretacioacuten en espantildeol estaraacuten disponibles en estos lugares y fechas especiacuteficas Para solicitar servicios de interpretacioacuten en otros idiomas comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 al menos con 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten

29

PROPOSED FARE CHANGESbull Single one-way fare price ($250) for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE

bull Addition of a $3 Day Pass for SeniorsDisabledMedicare and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER andBREEZE ($6 for Rapid Express)

bull One discounted pass price of $26 for SDM and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE ($36 forRapid Express)

bull Increasing the minimum age for senior discounts from 60 to 65 years (seniors 60 or older prior to the effectivedate will remain eligible for reduced fares)

bull Price increases for COASTER one-way Day Pass and 30-DayMonthly Passes

bull Elimination of 2 3 4 and 14-day passes

bull Elimination of Trolley transfers to align with bus policy

bull Elimination of the SPRINTERBREEZE monthly pass (will now be $72 to include service on the MTS bus and Trolley)

bull Consideration of a $5 or $6 Adult Regional Day Pass

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

CurrentActual

ProposedPropuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $250

SDM $110 $125

MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same Igual

Rapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same Igual

MTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500-1000 $800

SDM $250-500 $400

NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125

NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125

COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250

COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275

COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325

NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambios

NCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambios

MTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFTProposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICODAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare ProductTarifa de producto

Pass TypeTipo de Pase

Current Day PassPase de un diacutea actual

Proposed Day PassPase de un diacutea Propuesto

Current 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas propuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE

Adult Adulto mdash mdash $5900 Removed Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Regional Pass (MTS Bus Trolley Rapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

Adult Adulto $500 $500 or $600 $7200 $7200

SDM mdash $300 $1800 $2600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+$500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn Adult Adulto $1200 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Premium Regionaldeg Adult Adulto mdash $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM mdash $600 $2500 $3600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + all COASTER zones)

Adult Adulto mdash $1500 mdash mdash

SDM mdash $750 $4125 $6500

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional Zone Passes

1 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $12000 $14000

2 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $15000 $16100

3 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65+

+Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free) Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372

degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (Except FLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto por FLEX 372)

CAMBIOS DE TARIFA PROPUESTOSbull Precio uacutenico de tarifa unidireccional ($250) para autobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE

bull Adicioacuten de un pase diario de $3 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes para autobuacutesMTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($6 para Rapid Express)

bull Precio de pase con descuento de $26 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes paraautobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($36 para Rapid Express)

bull Aumento de la edad miacutenima para descuentos para personas mayores de 60 a 65 antildeos (las personas mayores de60 antes de la fecha de entrada en vigor seguiraacuten siendo elegibles para las tarifas reducidas)

bull Aumento de precios para pases unidireccionales diarios y mensuales30 diacuteas de COASTER

bull Eliminacioacuten de los pases de 2 3 4 y 14 diacuteas

bull Eliminacioacuten de los traslados de Trolley para cumplir con la poliacutetica de autobuses

bull Eliminacioacuten del pase mensual SPRINTERBREEZE (ahora seraacute de $72 para incluir servicios enautobuacutes MTS y Trolley)

bull Consideracioacuten de un pase diario regional para adultos con un valor de $5 o $6

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar esta informacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To request please call (619) 231-1466

30

ths ntildean Bteoo

UniorugraveuintilderuePROOF of Publication

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoCA 921 01 -4231

STATE OF ILLINOISCOUNTY OF Cook

Proof of Publication ofThe Undersigned declares under penalty of perjury under thelaws of the State of California That heshe is and at all timesherein mentioned was a citizen of the United States over theage of twenty-one years and that heshe is not a party to norinterested in the above entitled matter that heshe iexcls CtriexclefClerk for the publisher of

San Diego Union-Tribune

a newspaper of general circulation printed and publisheddaily in the City of San Diego County of San Diego andwhich newspaper is published for the dissemination of localnews and intelligence of a general character and whichnewspaper at all the times herein mentioned had and stillhas a bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers andwhich newspaper has been established printed andpublished at regular intervals in the said City of San DiegoCounty of San Diego for a period exceeding one year neacutextpreceding the date of publication of the notice hereinafterreferred to and which newspaper is not devoted to norpublished for the interests entertainment or instruction of aparticular class profession trade calling race ordenomination or any number of same that the notice of

See Attached

which the annexedsaid newspaper inperson(s) requestingthereof on the followi

l8

of

Stefanego Uniacuteon-Tribune

copy has been published inwith the instruction of the

pub and not in any supplementng dates wit

the laws of the State ofcorrect

lllinois2018

tsa

Datedon this

SalAdvertiacutesing

5910220

31

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 3: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Public Meetings for input on fare changes and revisions to Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance Post Until 11218

NOTICE

Public CommentsTo submit your comments in writing mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Email piosandagorgDeadline for public comments November 9 2018

The public meetings will be conducted in an open house format where participants can attend at any time during the meeting ask questions of staff complete comment cards or make their public comments to the officiant and participants In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in the public meetings listed above If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request the materials in an alternate format andor additional language(s) please call (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affecting the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance are proposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Why fare revisions are needed

PUBLIC MEETINGSMonday October 22 2018530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200-400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600-800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares

Monday October 29 2018330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 20181200-200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600-800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To request interpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting time

Reuniones puacuteblicas para obtener comentarios sobre cambios de tarifas y modificaciones a la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas

AVISO

bull Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenuehas declined and fares have not increased

bull Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of servicebull These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings Customers may also call (619) 595-5321 email piosandagorg or submit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards of Directors at which time the public can also make comments

Comentarios puacuteblicosPara enviar sus comentarios por escrito haacutegalo por correo postal aSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101Correo electroacutenico piosandagorgPlazo para enviar los comentarios puacuteblicos 9 de noviembre de 2018

Las reuniones puacuteblicas se llevaraacuten a cabo en un formato de evento de puertas abiertas donde los participantes pueden asistir en cualquier momento de la reunioacuten hacer preguntas al personal completar tarjetas de comentarios o hacer comentarios puacuteblicos a los presentadores y el puacuteblico presente De conformidad con la Ley de Estadounidenses con Discapacidades (ADA por sus siglas en ingleacutes) SANDAG asistiraacute a las personas que requieran ayuda para participar en las Reuniones puacuteblicas que figuran anteriormente Si requiere tal asistencia comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 con al menos 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten Para solicitar los materiales en otro formato o idiomas adicionales llame al (619) 699-1900 (619) 699-1904 (TTY) o enviacutee un facsiacutemile al (619) 699-1905

Se llevaraacuten a cabo seis reuniones puacuteblicas en el condado de San Diego para recibir comentarios sobre la propuesta para modificar las tarifas del transporte puacuteblico que afectariacutea las aacutereas de servicio del Sistema de Transporte Puacuteblico Metropolitano (MTS por sus siglas en ingleacutes) y el Distrito de Transporte Puacuteblico del Condado Norte (NCTD por sus siglas en ingleacutes) Se propone que todos los cambios aprobados en la Ordenanza regional integral de tarifas y en la Ordenanza de TransNet entren en vigor a partir del 27 de enero de 2019

iquestPor queacute es necesario ajustar las tarifas

REUNIONES PUacuteBLICASLunes 22 de octubre de 2018530 a 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Martes 23 de octubre de 2018200 a 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Mieacutercoles 24 de octubre de 2018600 a 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Formularios para comentarios disponibles en sandagorgfares

Lunes 29 de octubre de 2018330 a 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Martes 30 de octubre de 20181200 a 200 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Jueves 1 de noviembre de 2018600 a 800 pmOceanside LibraryCommunity Room330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

bull Los costos operativos han aumentado en los uacuteltimos 10 antildeos mientras que los ingresospor tarifas han disminuido y las tarifas no han aumentado

bull Un aumento en los ingresos por tarifas ayudaraacute a mantener un alto nivel de serviciobull Estos cambios simplificaraacuten la estructura de tarifas en toda la regioacuten

A continuacioacuten encontraraacute informacioacuten sobre el programa de reuniones puacuteblicas Los clientes tambieacuten pueden llamar al (619) 595-5321 enviar un correo electroacutenico a piosandagorg o entregar comentarios por escrito si no les es posible asistir a una de las reuniones Luego de recibir y analizar los comentarios del puacuteblico las Directivas de la Asociacioacuten de Gobiernos de San Diego (SANDAG por sus siglas en ingleacutes) MTS y NCTD consideraraacuten una recomendacioacuten final que en su momento el puacuteblico tambieacuten tendraacute la oportunidad de opinar

Servicios de interpretacioacuten en espantildeol estaraacuten disponibles en estos lugares y fechas especiacuteficas Para solicitar servicios de interpretacioacuten en otros idiomas comuniacutequese con SANDAG al (619) 699-1900 al menos con 72 horas de anticipacioacuten a la reunioacuten

29

PROPOSED FARE CHANGESbull Single one-way fare price ($250) for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE

bull Addition of a $3 Day Pass for SeniorsDisabledMedicare and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER andBREEZE ($6 for Rapid Express)

bull One discounted pass price of $26 for SDM and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE ($36 forRapid Express)

bull Increasing the minimum age for senior discounts from 60 to 65 years (seniors 60 or older prior to the effectivedate will remain eligible for reduced fares)

bull Price increases for COASTER one-way Day Pass and 30-DayMonthly Passes

bull Elimination of 2 3 4 and 14-day passes

bull Elimination of Trolley transfers to align with bus policy

bull Elimination of the SPRINTERBREEZE monthly pass (will now be $72 to include service on the MTS bus and Trolley)

bull Consideration of a $5 or $6 Adult Regional Day Pass

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

CurrentActual

ProposedPropuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $250

SDM $110 $125

MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same Igual

Rapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same Igual

MTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500-1000 $800

SDM $250-500 $400

NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125

NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125

COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250

COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275

COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325

NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambios

NCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambios

MTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFTProposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICODAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare ProductTarifa de producto

Pass TypeTipo de Pase

Current Day PassPase de un diacutea actual

Proposed Day PassPase de un diacutea Propuesto

Current 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas propuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE

Adult Adulto mdash mdash $5900 Removed Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Regional Pass (MTS Bus Trolley Rapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

Adult Adulto $500 $500 or $600 $7200 $7200

SDM mdash $300 $1800 $2600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+$500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn Adult Adulto $1200 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Premium Regionaldeg Adult Adulto mdash $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM mdash $600 $2500 $3600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + all COASTER zones)

Adult Adulto mdash $1500 mdash mdash

SDM mdash $750 $4125 $6500

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional Zone Passes

1 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $12000 $14000

2 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $15000 $16100

3 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65+

+Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free) Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372

degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (Except FLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto por FLEX 372)

CAMBIOS DE TARIFA PROPUESTOSbull Precio uacutenico de tarifa unidireccional ($250) para autobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE

bull Adicioacuten de un pase diario de $3 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes para autobuacutesMTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($6 para Rapid Express)

bull Precio de pase con descuento de $26 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes paraautobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($36 para Rapid Express)

bull Aumento de la edad miacutenima para descuentos para personas mayores de 60 a 65 antildeos (las personas mayores de60 antes de la fecha de entrada en vigor seguiraacuten siendo elegibles para las tarifas reducidas)

bull Aumento de precios para pases unidireccionales diarios y mensuales30 diacuteas de COASTER

bull Eliminacioacuten de los pases de 2 3 4 y 14 diacuteas

bull Eliminacioacuten de los traslados de Trolley para cumplir con la poliacutetica de autobuses

bull Eliminacioacuten del pase mensual SPRINTERBREEZE (ahora seraacute de $72 para incluir servicios enautobuacutes MTS y Trolley)

bull Consideracioacuten de un pase diario regional para adultos con un valor de $5 o $6

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar esta informacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To request please call (619) 231-1466

30

ths ntildean Bteoo

UniorugraveuintilderuePROOF of Publication

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoCA 921 01 -4231

STATE OF ILLINOISCOUNTY OF Cook

Proof of Publication ofThe Undersigned declares under penalty of perjury under thelaws of the State of California That heshe is and at all timesherein mentioned was a citizen of the United States over theage of twenty-one years and that heshe is not a party to norinterested in the above entitled matter that heshe iexcls CtriexclefClerk for the publisher of

San Diego Union-Tribune

a newspaper of general circulation printed and publisheddaily in the City of San Diego County of San Diego andwhich newspaper is published for the dissemination of localnews and intelligence of a general character and whichnewspaper at all the times herein mentioned had and stillhas a bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers andwhich newspaper has been established printed andpublished at regular intervals in the said City of San DiegoCounty of San Diego for a period exceeding one year neacutextpreceding the date of publication of the notice hereinafterreferred to and which newspaper is not devoted to norpublished for the interests entertainment or instruction of aparticular class profession trade calling race ordenomination or any number of same that the notice of

See Attached

which the annexedsaid newspaper inperson(s) requestingthereof on the followi

l8

of

Stefanego Uniacuteon-Tribune

copy has been published inwith the instruction of the

pub and not in any supplementng dates wit

the laws of the State ofcorrect

lllinois2018

tsa

Datedon this

SalAdvertiacutesing

5910220

31

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 4: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PROPOSED FARE CHANGESbull Single one-way fare price ($250) for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE

bull Addition of a $3 Day Pass for SeniorsDisabledMedicare and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER andBREEZE ($6 for Rapid Express)

bull One discounted pass price of $26 for SDM and Youth for MTS bus Trolley Rapid SPRINTER and BREEZE ($36 forRapid Express)

bull Increasing the minimum age for senior discounts from 60 to 65 years (seniors 60 or older prior to the effectivedate will remain eligible for reduced fares)

bull Price increases for COASTER one-way Day Pass and 30-DayMonthly Passes

bull Elimination of 2 3 4 and 14-day passes

bull Elimination of Trolley transfers to align with bus policy

bull Elimination of the SPRINTERBREEZE monthly pass (will now be $72 to include service on the MTS bus and Trolley)

bull Consideration of a $5 or $6 Adult Regional Day Pass

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

CurrentActual

ProposedPropuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $250

SDM $110 $125

MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same Igual

Rapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same Igual

MTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500-1000 $800

SDM $250-500 $400

NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125

NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125

COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250

COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275

COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325

NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambios

NCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambios

MTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFTProposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICODAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare ProductTarifa de producto

Pass TypeTipo de Pase

Current Day PassPase de un diacutea actual

Proposed Day PassPase de un diacutea Propuesto

Current 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthly PassPase de 30 diacuteas propuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE

Adult Adulto mdash mdash $5900 Removed Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Regional Pass (MTS Bus Trolley Rapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

Adult Adulto $500 $500 or $600 $7200 $7200

SDM mdash $300 $1800 $2600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+$500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn Adult Adulto $1200 Removed Removido mdash mdash

Premium Regionaldeg Adult Adulto mdash $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM mdash $600 $2500 $3600

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + all COASTER zones)

Adult Adulto mdash $1500 mdash mdash

SDM mdash $750 $4125 $6500

Youth+

Joacutevenes+mdash $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional Zone Passes

1 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $12000 $14000

2 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $15000 $16100

3 Zone Adult Adulto mdash mdash $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65+

+Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free) Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372

degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (Except FLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto por FLEX 372)

CAMBIOS DE TARIFA PROPUESTOSbull Precio uacutenico de tarifa unidireccional ($250) para autobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE

bull Adicioacuten de un pase diario de $3 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes para autobuacutesMTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($6 para Rapid Express)

bull Precio de pase con descuento de $26 para personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare y joacutevenes paraautobuacutes MTS Trolley Rapid SPRINTER y BREEZE ($36 para Rapid Express)

bull Aumento de la edad miacutenima para descuentos para personas mayores de 60 a 65 antildeos (las personas mayores de60 antes de la fecha de entrada en vigor seguiraacuten siendo elegibles para las tarifas reducidas)

bull Aumento de precios para pases unidireccionales diarios y mensuales30 diacuteas de COASTER

bull Eliminacioacuten de los pases de 2 3 4 y 14 diacuteas

bull Eliminacioacuten de los traslados de Trolley para cumplir con la poliacutetica de autobuses

bull Eliminacioacuten del pase mensual SPRINTERBREEZE (ahora seraacute de $72 para incluir servicios enautobuacutes MTS y Trolley)

bull Consideracioacuten de un pase diario regional para adultos con un valor de $5 o $6

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar esta informacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To request please call (619) 231-1466

30

ths ntildean Bteoo

UniorugraveuintilderuePROOF of Publication

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoCA 921 01 -4231

STATE OF ILLINOISCOUNTY OF Cook

Proof of Publication ofThe Undersigned declares under penalty of perjury under thelaws of the State of California That heshe is and at all timesherein mentioned was a citizen of the United States over theage of twenty-one years and that heshe is not a party to norinterested in the above entitled matter that heshe iexcls CtriexclefClerk for the publisher of

San Diego Union-Tribune

a newspaper of general circulation printed and publisheddaily in the City of San Diego County of San Diego andwhich newspaper is published for the dissemination of localnews and intelligence of a general character and whichnewspaper at all the times herein mentioned had and stillhas a bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers andwhich newspaper has been established printed andpublished at regular intervals in the said City of San DiegoCounty of San Diego for a period exceeding one year neacutextpreceding the date of publication of the notice hereinafterreferred to and which newspaper is not devoted to norpublished for the interests entertainment or instruction of aparticular class profession trade calling race ordenomination or any number of same that the notice of

See Attached

which the annexedsaid newspaper inperson(s) requestingthereof on the followi

l8

of

Stefanego Uniacuteon-Tribune

copy has been published inwith the instruction of the

pub and not in any supplementng dates wit

the laws of the State ofcorrect

lllinois2018

tsa

Datedon this

SalAdvertiacutesing

5910220

31

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 5: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

ths ntildean Bteoo

UniorugraveuintilderuePROOF of Publication

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoCA 921 01 -4231

STATE OF ILLINOISCOUNTY OF Cook

Proof of Publication ofThe Undersigned declares under penalty of perjury under thelaws of the State of California That heshe is and at all timesherein mentioned was a citizen of the United States over theage of twenty-one years and that heshe is not a party to norinterested in the above entitled matter that heshe iexcls CtriexclefClerk for the publisher of

San Diego Union-Tribune

a newspaper of general circulation printed and publisheddaily in the City of San Diego County of San Diego andwhich newspaper is published for the dissemination of localnews and intelligence of a general character and whichnewspaper at all the times herein mentioned had and stillhas a bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers andwhich newspaper has been established printed andpublished at regular intervals in the said City of San DiegoCounty of San Diego for a period exceeding one year neacutextpreceding the date of publication of the notice hereinafterreferred to and which newspaper is not devoted to norpublished for the interests entertainment or instruction of aparticular class profession trade calling race ordenomination or any number of same that the notice of

See Attached

which the annexedsaid newspaper inperson(s) requestingthereof on the followi

l8

of

Stefanego Uniacuteon-Tribune

copy has been published inwith the instruction of the

pub and not in any supplementng dates wit

the laws of the State ofcorrect

lllinois2018

tsa

Datedon this

SalAdvertiacutesing

5910220

31

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 6: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Ghe Eumlan iETHirooItnionttriblne

hlOTlCE Publir Mcetinqiexcl for lnout on Trrniexclit Fiexclre Chenqrs

The 5iquestn DiexclEacutego A$o(laringllon of Governrnenrs sAgravetiDAringG will host rix publir meetrngr tn 5anDiEcircgo- Cucircunty to-giexcltlrcr lgRur on propo5td uacute4ntit liexclEcirc charingngtr bilecring McriacuteopolrtrnTriexclnsiexclr sstem MTs tnd liexclorth f_orniexcly Triexclnsit Distratt f l(T0l riders Any apfroved chrnEcsro thEcirc Recircglonagravel Contprehenslve Frre iexclnd TriexclnrHet ordiexclnancEcircr would Eumlcraringm effeclrvriumloiexclooner than Januiexclry 7 iexcl019 Aiexcl the firrt propored farc lnccedilreiquestre lor MTS and I|CcedilTD llnce1009 thEcirc procircporecircd rhangal viexclll rn(rEumluumlEuml taringrecirc rEuml$ecircnut offlct llrcreiexcliexcle d operatlcnal (o1landmalntail highlevclt ol rEcircrvi(euro Fagravertiexclcipethnlr can aringtleurond at iexcliexclrI tirne during themeEcircting3 acircriexcl( gu5fiexclonrr agravend write or record commenti After publir lnput ir receiexclvid afiniexcll riquestcornmrfldiexcltlon wllt be coflsiderrd by tlre AHIIAG MTS iexclntl lt(TD gtiexcliexclrdiexcl

BillToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

Sold ToSANDAG - CUOO46949O401 B St Ste 800San DiegoC A 92101 -4231

locircntildelry OtlnEgraver 2tr Amt ltocircto F-nrcucircuh vlt|l UTHORNntilderry clvrccedil crnsr tuEacuterqftum316 F SIFiexcl| C$ulr 14iexclt Lq10_ ___ui$Llgccediltougraverrll lOlt l pnilrS Eorru loilrl 1 ltotilde lccedillr A[ry l0th FTHORNSuumligrave cA 941ocirct

ilrdttSANBAGPIO40f B Strrl Sum tooSrn Drgc CAtiexcl10rFheuronr ElIacute595Euml321EligravettlIrccediltpuacuteE orgtiumlfTHORNDiexcliexclccedil hlotr lntildelorntildertiofi ndcoarmGnl fontildenr avuumlbbh atwwvrrurCiexclaeliglhrr

THORNiexcliexcldlnEcirc lu guiexcliexclE commcnriexclHoviexclnbrr0 018

ofilry Orlucircocircr ll lucirc lt 3ucirctS0 pIacuterCrq Hqh[| tlDrry C6mntildeuntt| FloornllslfRo-u$ lr$iexclr TIuml 9rg cttz 0-5 -urrdry ocircorotrr l0 lSll tiquest riooniquest 9mEaeliggr[luacuteucirc LEgraveucircy lwnctrnr Roomt3iexcl S KlJrnil EreffidldotA 9f015uumliexcliexclrulry tarembiexclr 1 l0tl iuuml pmOsarigraverlfi LEcircrtry Cariexclmriexclr-tily f ssn

h sornTHORNhtnETH tviexclth iht Amtrccedilrnr wiEgrave Olfrbihot Acl (AucircA )SAIiexclEAG rriexcliH iexclccomicircroddc FG ran r rr h o cquETH ucircrlugravelrnil toFiexclltcipiexclll lntilde lrr Fiexcljbliexclc [iquesttucircrlgr llttrd boccedilr tf surhrrriexclLnca iiexcl rtquirrd or if you ould ro to roqoaiexcltrddrligntfbrigravegrocircgocirc iexclnlffpilqton t Ecirc iprcrfic nr rmE ptiucirc EumloriexcltEcirctSANOAEumliexcll t Iacuteiexcluuml9t-t$00ilrerl72 horiexclfiexcl iexcln rdvrnEgraverslhrniexclrling To nrguntlhr nrhriiexcltiexcl iiexcl rn iexclirmriexclfcmtndiexclTHORNrrddiexcloniexcl bniexclccedil||f riexcl phTHORN+ crll E | iexcll Ecirc9amp I 9O0 (Ecirc 1 t r Eumltt04 TTYl orlrr iquest8lStucirctt1tOS

Single on-rrr BRGEiexclE Additlon tl aring 5iexcl oay Patr for SentoriexclIacuteDiexcliexcliexclblcdMccedildiciexclregrave flDiMl iexclnd vouth for MTS burTrylleyi Raringpiexcld5PBlNTE8 iexclnd BREEiquestE f 36 fot Riexclpid Erprriexcliexcl) Orrt dliexcliquestouiexclrlEcircd mocircnthll parr prlce ol 526 lor iDMiexclnd Youth lor Mf S bur lroltey Fapid5P8lIacuteTEcirc[ and EBECZT lf 36 for Rrpid Fxprrr]lnrlcartng tftc miexclnlrnunr rgc for iexclenlor dicorlnszlig ltocircrn oacute0 ta 65 yeuroethr3 [sEacutetliucirciexcll Eacuteucirc or oldccedilrprior to tht effectivc diexcltEcirc will nmiexcln rligibtr for reducruacute fiexcliexclpc Piexclice increiquestl+iexcl for C0+5TEszlig onEacute-way 0ay paringrs and lEgraveOaringyVigraveonlhiexcly paiexclre5

Ellnrinaringtron of iquest l and 14-day piexclriexclcs bnd Trolley tllnrfrrrElimiexclnaringtion ucircf thEcirc SPFIilTER8ftECfEcirc rnEcircnrhly pasi fwiexclll now be T12 ro iexclnrlude secircryszligecirc ucircnthq MIS buiexcl iexclnd Trolleyj

s+rnuacutethorn iexcliexclgiexclgntrlD|rbloiexcl[lbr tvrdabh al thl bcathornnr

PUtLtCEumlOffitiexcllt

lrllUacuterrlryr Ogtucircbr 21 eol t uumla pntildet-El CFntilde Eacuteollucirc OlPsrflanl Cotlrmlrigravery Roofl

5910220

32

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 7: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Order ID 5910220

Page 3 of 3

1012018 61652 PMPrinted

GROSS PRICE $52393

Agency Commission not included

Legal-Metro-Legal NoticesPACKAGE NAME

33

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 8: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

34

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 9: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

35

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 10: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

ABOUT SANDAG | CIVIL RIGHTS | MEETINGS | CALENDAR | PUBLIC NOTICES | CAREERS | CONTRACTS | INVESTOR RELATIONS Search

Transportation

Land Use and Regional Growth

Biking and Walking

TransNet

Public Safety

Borders

Environment

Economics and Finance

Regional Airport Access

Demographics and Other Data

Maps and GIS

Regional Models

Publications

Public Information Office

Service Bureau

Keep San Diego Moving

511

iCommute

FasTrak

Get SANDAG updates deliveredright to your inbox

Subscribe

View Region newsletter

Select LanguagePowered by Translate

Public Transit

Comprehensive Fare Ordinance

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceencompassing fares charged on all public transit vehicles in San Diego County operated byMetropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) on March 242006

The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates the existing fare levels and regulations of MTS andNCTD into a single SANDAG ordinance

The Fare Ordinance is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy whichprovides the regional framework for transit fares All fare changes including fare increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors or the TransportationCommittee Public hearings will be held whenever fare changes are being considered

2018-2019 Fare Changes

In 2018 MTS and NCTD are proposing to amend the ordinance to adjust transit fares and willcollect public comments at six public meetings throughout the region The adjustments are neededbecause while operational costs have increased over the past 10 years fare revenues havedeclined and fares have not increased Increasing fare revenue will assist in maintaining highlevels of service and simplifying the fare structure across the region

After public input is received and analyzed a final recommendation will be considered by theSANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors

Public Meetings

Monday October 22 2018 530 - 730 pm Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 2-4 pm MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 6-8 pm El Cajon Police Department Community Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 330-530 pm City Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 12 noon - 2 pm Escondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 6-8 pm Oceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations To request interpretation services inother languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing if unable to attend the meetings

To submit comments in writing mail to

SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

PROPOSED FARE CHANGES

SINGLE RIDE VIAJE UacuteNICO

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

MTS Bus Autobuacutes MTS Adult Adulto $225 $25036

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 11: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

Pass Type Tipo de pase

Current Actual

Proposed Propuesto

SDM $110 $125MTS Trolley Trolley de MTS Adult Adulto $250 Same Igual

SDM $125 Same IgualRapid Express Adult Adulto $500 Same Igual

SDM $250 Same IgualMTS RURAL Adult Adulto $500 - $1000 $800

SDM $250 - $500 $400NCTD BREEZE Adult Adulto $175 $250

SDM $075 $125NCTD SPRINTER Adult Adulto $200 $250

SDM $100 $125COASTER (1 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $400 $500

SDM $200 $250COASTER (2 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $500 $575

SDM $250 $275COASTER (3 ZoneZona) Adult Adulto $550 $650

SDM $275 $325NCTD FLEX (ExceptExcepto 372) Unchanged Sin cambiosNCTD FLEX 372 Unchanged Sin cambiosMTS ACCESS amp NCTD LIFT Proposed LIFT fee is per BREEZESPRINTER needed to complete trip Tarifa propuesta de LIFT es para BREEZESPRINTER necesario para completar el traslado

MTS $450 $500

LIFT $350 $500

DAY AND MONTHLY PASSES PASES DIARIOS y MENSUALES

Fare Product Tarifa de producto

PassType Tipo depase

CurrentDayPass Pase deun diacuteaactual

ProposedDay Pass Pase de undiacuteaPropuesto

Current 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30diacuteas actual

Proposed 30-DayMonthlyPass Pase de 30 diacuteaspropuesto

NCTD SPRINTER BREEZE AdultAdulto - - $5900 Removed

Removido

SDM $225 Removed Removido - -

Regional Pass (MTS Bus TrolleyRapid NCTD BREEZE SPRINTER)

AdultAdulto $500 $500 or

$600 $7200 $7200

SDM - $300 $1800 $2600Youth Joacutevenes $500 $300 $3600 $2600

RegionPlusplusmn AdultAdulto $1200 Removed

Removido - -

Premium Regionaldeg AdultAdulto - $1200 $10000 $10000

SDM - $600 $2500 $3600Youth Joacutevenes - $600 $5000 $3600

COASTER Regional (RapidExpress + all COASTER zones)

AdultAdulto - $1500 - -

SDM - $750 $4125 $6500Youth Joacutevenes - $750 $8250 $6500

COASTER Regional (Rapid Express + allCOASTER zones)

1 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $12000 $14000

2 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $15000 $16100

3 Zone

AdultAdulto - - $16500 $18200

SDM = SeniorDisabledMedicare Senior = 65+Personas mayorescon discapacidadesMedicare Personas mayores 65++Youth = Ages 6 through 18 (5 amp under ride free)Joacutevenes = entre 6 y 18 antildeos de edad (de 5 y menores viajan gratis)plusmn Currently includes all modes except ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural amp FLEX 372Actualmente incluye todos los modos excepto por ACCESS LIFT MTS Rural y FLEX 372degPremium regional includes Regional Pass modes and MTS Rapid Express and NCTD FLEX (ExceptFLEX 372)Regional Premium incluye modos en Pase regional y MTS Rapid Express y NCTD FLEX (Excepto porFLEX 372)

This information will be made available in alternative formats upon request To requestplease call (619) 231-1466

Esta informacioacuten estaacute disponible en diferentes formatos bajo solicitud Para solicitar estainformacioacuten en un formato diferente por favor llame al (619) 231-1466

37

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 12: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

HOME | SITE MAP | LINKS | HELP | PRIVACY POLICY | LEGAL | FAQ | CONTACT SANDAG 401 B Street Suite(619) 699-1900 fax (619) 699-1905 w

Downloads

Fact Sheet - Proposed Fare Changes [PDF 443 KB]Fare Change Flier - MTSNCTDSANDAG [PDF 281 KB]MTS Fare Collection Whitepaper - November 2016 [PDF 2055 KB]Regional Fare Ordinance - July 2014 [PDF 173 KB]

Related Resources

Links

MTS Fares and Passes NCTD Fares and Passes

Publications

Regional Transit Fare Structure and Revenue Sharing Study [PDF 935KB]

38

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 13: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

39

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 14: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

40

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 15: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

EN ESPANOL MOBILE SITE ABOUT CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE SAFETY AND SECURITY

PROPOSED FARE CHANGE

ANNOUNCEMENT

Click here for the Take One

Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and NCTD are considering several changes to the fare systemWith operational costs increasing and no fare increases over the past decade these changes aredesigned to help maintain higher levels of service and to simplify the fare structure regionallyWersquore asking riders to review the proposed changes and give us your feedback onlineat sandagorgfares or in-person at a series of public meetings

Why fare revisions are needed

Operational costs over the past 10 years have increased while fare revenue has declined andfares have not increased

Increased fare revenue will assist in maintaining high levels of service

These changes will simplify the fare structure across the region

PUBLIC MEETINGS

Six public meetings will be held in San Diego County on a proposal to amend transit fares affectingthe Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD) service areas Anyapproved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fare Ordinance and TransNet Ordinance areproposed to become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

See below for information regarding scheduled public meetings After public input is received andanalyzed a final recommendation will be considered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD Boards ofDirectors at which time the public can also make comments

Monday October 22 2018 | 530-730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium 356 F St Chula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018 | 2-4pm

NEED HELP

At NCTD we are happy to assistyou You can reach us throughour Contact form or theinformation below

Call (760) 966-6500 Email creportsnctdorg

COASTER SPRINTER BREEZE FLEX LIFT

System Map

CUSTOMER SERVICE

Contact Form

creportsnctdorg

760-966-6500

RULES OF RIDING

Welcome aboard Pleasefollow these basic rules tomake your trip enjoyable forall

Rules of Riding

HOW TO RIDE SCHEDULES AND MAPS FARES AND PASSES ACCESSIBILITY Search

41

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 16: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

MTS Board Room 1255 Imperial Ave 10th Fl San Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018 | 6-8pmEl Cajon Police DepartmentCommunity Room 100 Civic Center Way El Cajon CA 92020

Monday October 29 2018 | 330-530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 2018 | 12-2pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room 239 S Kalmia St Escondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018 | 6-8pmOceanside Library Community Room 330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside CA 92054

Comment forms available at sandagorgfares through November 9 2018

Spanish language interpretation will be available at these locations and dates To requestinterpretation services in other languages please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72hours prior to the meeting time

POP-UP MEETINGS

In addition to the public meetings listed above NCTD will also be hosting pop-up station events

Friday October 26 2018 | 200-400 pmEscondido Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 700-900 amOceanside Transit Center

Monday October 29 2018 | 200-400 pmVista Transit Center

ACCESSIBILITY

ADA OverviewLIFT OverviewLIFT PoliciesLIFT FAQsADA CertificationAccessibility ServicesReasonable ModificationReduced Fare Eligibility

ABOUT NCTD

NCTD OverviewBoard of DirectorsCareersNCTD in the NewsConstruction ProjectsPositive Train ControlCommunity OutreachWorking Around the RailsRiderrsquos GuideRailroad SafetyStorm Water ProgramPrivacy Policy

BUSINESS WITH NCTD

Contracting OpportunitiesDisadvantaged BusinessEnterprise (DBE) ProgramTransit AdvertisingLeasing Opportunities

ACCOUNTABILITYCENTER

Financial ReportsPerformance ReportsPublic Records RequestRights Under Title VISustainabilityCompliance

CONTACT

Contact FormKey Contacts at NCTDCustomer FeedbackLost and FoundTransit SecurityTrip Planning AssistanceMedia RelationsPublic Records Request

Safety and Security

42

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 17: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

szlig

Regional Transit Farcs Survey

2 Hoyr do you usually pay to ride MTS

dSO-OV or Monthly Adult Regional Pass ($72)

n SO-Ouy or Monthly Adult Rapid ExpressPremium Pass ($1OOiexcl

I SO-Oy or Monthly SeniorDisabledMedicare (SDM) Pass ($18)

n gO-Ouy or Monthly Youth Pass ($36)

nOun Day Pass ($5)

3 Please rate the following

n nout one-way Fare

sov one-Way Fare

otet

fl ruiexcln - I am not a regular rider

NOtuumlt coulliexclYItaN3iexclt DliexcllItGt

Neither agree Agreeor disagree

oooo

o

ryG F(wAElig

-rMTS is considering several fare changes for its system lf you have not yet reviewed the proposed changesplease visit sdmtscomFareGhange to learn more Please mailform to SANDAG PlO 401 B StreetSuife 800 San Diego CA 92101

1 Your home ZIP Gode

iliumlnJ Disasree

I would rather pay slightly higher fares than have my service reduced O O

Stronlyagree

oooo

o

o

lf the Adult Regional Day Pass increased from $5 to $6 I would beless likely to ride

I want to use my smart phone to pay to ride MTS

I think transit should be more affordable for Youth (ages 6 - 18) to ride

Currently Youth and SDM riders have a discounted monthly passMTS is proposing to add a new discounted $3 Day Pass for SDMand Youth I like this idea

oooooo

o

o

oo

o

o

oo

o

oln order to offset the lost revenue of the new $S Oay Pass for SDMand Youth MTS is proposing to combine the SDM and Youthmonthly3O-Day passes into a single discounted $26 pass(Youth currently pay $36 and SDM currently pay $18) I like this idea

o

4 I would be willing to pay more to ride MTS to get (Gheck all that apply)

Environmentally friendly electric vehicles I t expensive youth passes

Vor frequent service and service to new places Vor night and weekend service

I vore security tonof the above

5 Comments

43

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 18: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Proposed Fore Chonge Survey TRiiacuteiuumli-rI How often do you ride NCTD

tr Never hove used the BREEZE COASTER FLEX LlFl or SPRINTER

n Former customer but no longer ride

I I doyperweek

I 2-3 doys perweek- thorniacutedoys per week(o-l doys perweek

2 Which mode(sf do you ride most often check oll thot opplylT COASTER

r SPRINTER

f] BREEZE

N FLEX

tut3 Whlth fore type do you usuolly purchose

iexclzaacutedrlt Youth One-Woy Fore

n SDM One-Woy Fore

n SDM BREEZESPRINTER Doy Poss

f Regionol Doy Poss (Does not iacutenclude COASTER)

I RegionPlus Doy Poss (lncludes COASTER)

I SPRINTERBREEZE Monthly Poss (Does not include COASTER)

tr Adult Regiacuteonol Monthly 30 Doy Poss Does not include COASTER)

I SDM Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss (Does not include COASTERI

I Youth Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss [Does not include COASTER]

I SDM COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy Poss

I Youih COASTER Regionol Monthly 30 Doy PossAduli COASTER Regionol 30 Doy Poss

4 There is o proposolto combine $e Regionol SDM ond Youth monthly30-Doydiscgunted $2oacute poss (You$ currendy poy $3oacute ond SDM currently poy $ l8lVytINoI Doni Know

posses into o singleDo you like this ideo

5 There is o proposol to give Youth o 50 discount on COASTER One-Woy ond Round-Trip tickets Wouldthis offect your decision to ride COASTER with your fomilyI Yos

tNn Dont Know

oacute Would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother dron increose fore rotesI would prefer thot NCTD reduce services rother thon increose fores

No I would prefer thot NCTD increose fore rotes ond moinioinimprove services

I Dont Know

7 W9qd you stop using NCTD services or toke fewer trips if fore roles ore increosedYeslwould stop using NCTD services

I Yes I would toke fewer trips

I No increosed fore roles will not chonge my use of NCTD services

fl Dont Know

8 Comments

44

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 19: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Hosted by Escondido Mayor Sam Abed and Poway MayorSteve Vaus

Also be sure to take our interactive survey during the month ofOctober

Community input is a vital part of the plan-developmentprocess and will be used to develop draft scenarios for furtherreview and input later this winter If you havenrsquot already pleasesubscribe to receive email updates about other opportunities toget involved and learn more about the process of developingthe 2019 Regional Plan by watching this series of informationalvideos

Wanted Public Input on Transit FareChanges

SANDAG will hold six public meetings to gather input onproposed transit fare changes affecting Metropolitan TransitSystem (MTS) and North County Transit District (NCTD)riders

Any approved changes to the Regional Comprehensive Fareand TransNet ordinances would become effective no soonerthan January 27 2019 This is the first proposed fare increasefor MTS and NCTD since 2009 The proposed changes willincrease fare revenue offset increased operational costs andmaintain high levels of service

After public input is received a final recommendation will beconsidered by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors

Fare Changes Public Meeting

10242018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10252018 North County Inland RegionalPlan Community Conversation

Regional Energy WorkingGroup

10262018 Borders Committee

Board of Directors

10292018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

10302018 Fare Changes Public Meeting

SANDAG Jobs

Are you interested in a careerwith SANDAG Sign upfor email notifications of jobopenings and internshipopportunities

Customer Service Supervisor

Data Research Analyst

Environmental Intern

Financial ProgrammingAnalyst

Program Manager ofEconomic and DemographicForecasting

Public Outreach Officer

Research Assistant

Senior Quality AssuranceAnalyst

Web Development Intern

SANDAG is an ADA-compliantagency If you require specialassistance to learn moreabout our job openingscontact us at (619) 699-1900We will make every effort toaccommodate your needs

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

45

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 20: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

The meetings will take place as follows

bull Monday October 22 530 to 730 pm at the Chula VistaPublic Library Civic Center Branch located at 356 F StreetChula Vista CA 91910bull Tuesday October 23 2 to 4 pm in the MTS Board Roomlocated at 1255 Imperial Avenue 10th Floor San Diego CA92101bull Wednesday October 24 6 to 8 pm in the El Cajon PoliceDepartment Community Room located at 100 Civic CenterWay El Cajon CA 92020bull Monday October 29 330 to 530 pm in the City HeightsWeingart Library Community Room located at 3795 FairmountAvenue San Diego CA 92105bull Friday October 30 12 noon to 2 pm in the EscondidoPublic Library Turrentine Room located at 239 South KalmiaStreet Escondido CA 92025bull Thursday November 1 6 to 8 pm in the OceansidePublic Library Mission Branch Community Room located at3861 Mission Avenue Oceanside CA 92058

Public comments also may be submitted beginning on October5 2018 by calling (619) 595-5321 emailing piosandagorgor mailing to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 SanDiego CA 92101 The deadline to submit public comments isNovember 9 2018 For more information about the proposedMTS and NCTD fare changes visit sandagorgfares

First Passenger Train Crosses New San ElijoLagoon Rail Bridge

In September the first passenger train crossed the newly builtrail bridge over the San Elijo Lagoon in Cardiff-by-the-Sea Theaging timber bridge was replaced to accommodate increases

Doing Business withSANDAG

SANDAG seeks firms toprovide a variety of servicesincluding construction generalcontractors and constructionmanagement engineeringdesign planning andenvironmental reviewmarketing and publicoutreach financial legalconsulting and trainingservices computer copyequipment and officesupplies Register your firm inthe vendor database toreceive emails aboutupcoming projects

Current Bids

5005443 San Diego RegionalFasTrak CustomerEngagement MarketingPublic Outreach and Branding Proposals are due by1092018

5006135 Maintenance andLandscaping Trucks Proposals are due by10112018

5006104 Traffic ControlServices Proposals are due by10292018

Subscribe Past Issues Translate

46

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 21: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ON PROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE

FARE ORDINANCEDate Thursday October 18 2018 50016 PMAttachments image001png

NEWS RELEASE Date October 18 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETINGS FOR INPUT ONPROPOSED FARE CHANGES AND REVISIONS TO COMPREHENSIVE FARE

ORDINANCE

The San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and North County Transit District(NCTD) will hold six public meetings throughout San Diego County to collect input on proposed MTS and NCTD transit farechanges

During the meetings attendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members and learn moreabout the proposed changes All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services are maintained Over thelast ten years operational costs have increased while fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposedchanges also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassing fares on all publictransit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinanceconsolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy

Because the Regional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases orchanges in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved bythe MTS and NCTD boards of directors before the changes are implemented Because the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional monthly pass discounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior faresthe SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Six public meetings will be held in locations (accessible by transit)

Monday October 22 2018530 ndash 730 pmChula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

Tuesday October 23 2018200 ndash 400 pmMTS Board Room1255 Imperial Ave 10th FlSan Diego CA 92101

Wednesday October 24 2018600 ndash 800 pmEl Cajon Police Department Community Room100 Civic Center WayEl Cajon CA 92020

47

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 22: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Monday October 29 2018330 ndash 530 pmCity Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

Tuesday October 30 201812 noon - 2 pmEscondido Library Turrentine Room239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

Thursday November 1 2018600 ndash 800 pmOceanside Library Community Room330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

Spanish interpretation will be available at these locations

Members of the public also may

Call (619) 595-5321Email piosandagorgUse Comment FormSubmit comments in writing SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes next steps and opportunities to provide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

48

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 23: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 19 2018 43459 PMAttachments image002png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 19 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

First of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday WHEN Monday October 22 2018

530 - 730 pm WHERE Chula Vista Library Civic Center Auditorium

356 F StChula Vista CA 91910

WHO Chula Vista Mayor Mary Salas will make welcoming remarks SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be

available to answer questions and take public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more information and to

provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changes Attendees will have the opportunity tosubmit public comments speak to staff members and learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors over thenext few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposed changes will be implemented noearlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transit services aremaintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fares have remained the same Theproposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a wide rangeof transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare Ordinance encompassingfares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTS and NCTD in March 2006 TheComprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a singleregional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increasesor change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes alsomust be approved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposedchanges include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will be revised if the changesare approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by emailat piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800

49

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 24: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

San Diego CA 92101 For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities to provide input visitsandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planning transportation andresearch agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growth transportation planning and constructionenvironmental management housing open space energy public safety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Boardof Directors composed of mayors council members and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the countygovernment About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than 300000passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTS served more than 88million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annually throughoutNorth San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (with FLEX service)COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safeconvenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

50

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 25: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN

FARESDate Tuesday October 23 2018 55813 AMAttachments pastedImagepng

MEDIA ADVISORY

Date October 23 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUTON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Second of six regional public meetings to take place today WHEN Tuesday October 23 2019

200 pm - 400 pm WHERE MTS Board Room

1255 Imperial Ave 10th FloorSan Diego CA 92101

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take public

comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff members andlearn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards ofdirectors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directors the proposedchanges will be implemented no earlier than January 27 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliable transitservices are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increased while fareshave remained the same The proposed changes also will simplify the fare structure across theregion making it easier to access a wide range of transit options

51

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 26: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego County by MTSand NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidates existing MTS andNCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which is consistent with SANDAGBoard Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since the Regional Fare Policy provides theregional framework for all transit fares any fare changes such as increases or change in faretypes must be approved by the SANDAG Board of Directors The proposed changes also must beapproved by the MTS and NCTD boards of directors before they are implemented Since theproposed changes include the SeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly passdiscounts as well as the qualifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNetOrdinance also will be revised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

For those unable to attend a meeting comments may also be submitted by phone at (619) 595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail to SANDAG PIO401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about other meeting dates the proposed changes and opportunities toprovide input visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy public safetyand binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors council members andsupervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government

About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekday more than300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the county In FY 2017 MTSserved more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use public transportation and savemoney go to wwwsdmtscom

About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger trips annuallythroughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includes BREEZE buses (withFLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFT paratransit service NCTDrsquos mission isto deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly public transportation services For more informationvisit GoNCTDcom

52

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 27: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Friday October 26 2018 10002 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORYDate October 26 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TOPROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND

COMMUTER TRAIN FARESFourth of six regional public meetings to take place on Monday

WHEN Monday October 29 2018 330 pm ndash 530 pm

WHERE City Heights Library Community Room3795 Fairmount AveSan Diego CA 92105

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and takepublic comments

Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting

WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for moreinformation and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

53

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 28: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

54

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 29: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Monday October 29 2018 13036 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 29 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Fifth of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm WHERE Escondido Library Turrentine Room

239 S Kalmia StEscondido CA 92025

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments Spanish interpretation will be available at this meeting WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

55

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 30: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive FareOrdinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

56

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 31: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

From Gong KristieneTo Gong KristieneCc Gong KristieneSubject SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY AND COMMUTER TRAIN FARESDate Wednesday October 31 2018 24114 PMAttachments image003png

MEDIA ADVISORY Date October 31 2018For Release ImmediatelyContact Jessica Gonzales (619) 699-1950 Jessicagonzalessandagorg

Rob Schupp (619) 557-4511 robschuppsdmtscomKimy Wall (760) 967-2807 kwallnctdorg

SANDAG MTS AND NCTD INVITE PUBLIC TO

PROVIDE INPUT ON BUS TROLLEY ANDCOMMUTER TRAIN FARES

Last in series of six regional public meetings to take place tomorrow WHEN Thursday November 1 2018

600 ndash 800 pm WHERE Oceanside Library Community Room

330 N Coast HwyOceanside CA 92054

WHO SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff members will be available to answer questions and take

public comments WHAT SANDAG MTS and NCTD invite community members to attend a public meeting for more

information and to provide comments on proposed MTS and NCTD transit fare changesAttendees will have the opportunity to submit public comments speak to staff membersand learn more about the proposed changes

All comments will be summarized and presented to the SANDAG MTS and NCTDboards of directors over the next few months If approved by all three boards of directorsthe proposed changes will be implemented in early 2019

MTS and NCTD are proposing to adjust fare structures to ensure that safe and reliabletransit services are maintained Over the last ten years operational costs have increasedwhile fare revenue has declined and fares have not increased The proposed changesalso will simplify the fare structure across the region making it easier to access a widerange of transit options

The SANDAG Board of Directors approved the regionrsquos first Comprehensive Fare

57

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 32: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Ordinance encompassing fares on all public transit vehicles operated in San Diego Countyby MTS and NCTD in March 2006 The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance consolidatesexisting MTS and NCTD fares and regulations into a single regional ordinance which isconsistent with SANDAG Board Policy No 029 the Regional Fare Policy Since theRegional Fare Policy provides the regional framework for all transit fares any farechanges such as increases or change in fare types must be approved by the SANDAGBoard of Directors The proposed changes also must be approved by the MTS and NCTDboards of directors before they are implemented Since the proposed changes include theSeniorDisabledMedicare and Youth Regional Monthly pass discounts as well as thequalifying senior age for all senior fares the SANDAG TransNet Ordinance also will berevised if the changes are approved by all three boards of directors

For those unable to attend a meeting comments also may be submitted by phone at (619)595-5321 by email at piosandagorg through the online Comment Form or by mail toSANDAG PIO 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

For more information about the proposed changes and other opportunities to provideinput visit sandagorgfares

About SANDAGThe San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) is the San Diego regionrsquos primary public planningtransportation and research agency providing the public forum for regional policy decisions about growthtransportation planning and construction environmental management housing open space energy publicsafety and binational topics SANDAG is governed by a Board of Directors composed of mayors councilmembers and supervisors from each of the regionrsquos 18 cities and the county government About MTSMTS operates 95 bus routes and three Trolley lines on 53 miles of double-tracked railway Every weekdaymore than 300000 passenger trips are taken on MTS bus and Trolley services in 10 cities and the countyIn FY 2017 MTS served more than 88 million riders For more information on how you can use publictransportation and save money go to wwwsdmtscom About NCTDThe North County Transit District is a public transportation agency providing over 10 million passenger tripsannually throughout North San Diego County and into downtown San Diego NCTDrsquos system includesBREEZE buses (with FLEX service) COASTER commuter trains SPRINTER hybrid rail trains and LIFTparatransit service NCTDrsquos mission is to deliver safe convenient reliable and user-friendly publictransportation services For more information visit GoNCTDcom

58

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 33: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

22

Interested

Monday October 22 2018 at 530 PM ndash 730 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

365 F St Chula Vista California 91911

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapChula Vista Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

59

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 34: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

23

Interested

Tuesday October 23 2018 at 200 PM ndash 400 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

1255 Imperial Ave Ste 1000 San Diego California 92101

1 Went middot 3 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapMetropolitan Transit System

Events

Events

Create Event

60

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 35: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

24

Interested

Wednesday October 24 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

100 Civic Center Way El Cajon California 92020

0 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEl Cajon Police Dept

Events

Events

Create Event

61

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 36: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

29

Interested

Monday October 29 2018 at 330 PM ndash 530 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

3795 Fairmount Ave San Diego California 92105

1 Went middot 2 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019 Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapCity Heights Library

Events

Events

Create Event

62

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 37: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

OCT

30

Interested

Tuesday October 30 2018 at 1200 PM ndash 200 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

239 S Kalmia St Escondido California 92025

0 Went middot 0 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Show MapEscondido Public Library

Events

Events

Create Event

63

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 38: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Privacy middot Terms middot Advertising middot middotCookies middot MoreFacebook copy 2018

English (US) middot Espantildeol middot Portuguecircs (Brasil) middotFranccedilais (France) middot Deutsch

Ad Choices

Fare Ordinance Amendment PublicMeetingPublic middot Hosted by SANDAG - San Diego Association ofGovernments

NOV

1

Interested

Thursday November 1 2018 at 600 PM ndash 800 PM PDTabout 1 month ago

330 N Coast Hwy Oceanside California 92054

0 Went middot 1 InterestedShare this event with your friends

Six public meetings between October 22 and November 1 will be heldaround the region to solicit input on proposed MTS and NCTD fare changesIf approved by the SANDAG MTS and NCTD boards of directors thechanges would become effective no sooner than January 27 2019

Visit wwwsandagorgfares to find out more about the upcoming meetingsand view the proposed changes

To submit comments members of the public can attend a meeting call (619)595-5321 email piosandagorg use the comment form athttpswwwsandagorgorganizationconfigCommentindexasppid=18 orsubmit comments by mail to

SANDAG PIO

See More

Details

About SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

SANDAG - San Diego Association of GovernmentsGovernment Organization middot San Diego CaliforniaThanks for stopping by the official SANDAG Facebook page Visitour website at sandagorg

Photos of SANDAG - San Diego Association of Governments

Join or Log Into Facebook thinsp Sign Up

Email or Phone

Password

Forgot account

Do you want to join Facebook

Log In

Sign Up

Show MapCity of Oceanside Public Library (Oceanside CA)

Events

Events

Create Event

64

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 39: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Meeting Notice and Agenda 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group The 2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group may take action on any item appearing on this agenda

Thursday October 4 2018

10 to 1130 am

SANDAG Board Room 7th Floor 401 B Street Suite 800 San Diego CA 92101

Please take the elevator to the 8th floor to access the meeting room

Staff Contact Jane Clough (619) 699-1909janecloughsandagorg

Agenda Highlights

bull Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update

bull San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 RegionalPlan Extension

bull Regional Transit Fare Study

Please silence all electronic devices during the meeting

Mission Statement The 18 cities and county government are SANDAG serving as the forum for regional

decision-making SANDAG builds consensus makes strategic plans obtains and allocates resources

plans engineers and builds public transit and provides information on a broad range of topics

pertinent to the regions quality of life

65

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 40: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Welcome to SANDAG Members of the public may speak to the Working Group on any item at the time the Working Group is considering the item Please complete a Request to Comment form and then present the form to the Working Group coordinator Members of the public may address the Working Group on any issue under the agenda item entitled Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments Public speakers are limited to three minutes or less per person The Working Group may take action on any item appearing on the agenda

Both agenda and non-agenda comments should be sent to the Clerk of the Committee via clerksandagorg Please include the meeting date agenda item your name and your organization Any comments handouts presentations or other materials from the public intended for distribution at the meeting should be received by the Clerk no later than 5 pm two working days prior to the meeting All public comments and materials received by the deadline become part of the official public record and will be provided to the members for their review at the meeting

In order to keep the public informed in an efficient manner and facilitate public participation SANDAG also provides access to all agenda and meeting materials online at sandagorgmeetings Additionally interested persons can sign up for email notifications at sandagorgsubscribe

SANDAG operates its programs without regard to race color and national origin in compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act SANDAG has developed procedures for investigating and tracking Title VI complaints and the procedures for filing a complaint are available to the public upon request Questions concerning SANDAG nondiscrimination obligations or complaint procedures should be directed to the SANDAG General Counsel John Kirk at (619) 699-1997 or johnkirksandagorg Any person who believes himself or herself or any specific class of persons to be subjected to discrimination prohibited by Title VI also may file a written complaint with the Federal Transit Administration

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) SANDAG will accommodate persons who require assistance in order to participate in SANDAG meetings If such assistance is required please contact SANDAG at (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting To request this document or related reports in an alternative format please call (619) 699-1900 or (619) 699-1904 (TTY) or fax (619) 699-1905

SANDAG agenda materials can be made available in alternative languages To make a request call (619) 699-1900 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting

Los materiales de la agenda de SANDAG estaacuten disponibles en otros idiomas Para hacer una solicitud llame al (619) 699-1900 al menos 72 horas antes de la reunioacuten

如有需要 我们可以把SANDAG议程材料翻译成其他語言

请在会议前至少 72 小时打电话 (619) 699-1900 提出请求

SANDAG offices are accessible by public transit Phone 511 or visit 511sdcom for route information Bicycle parking is available in the parking garage of the SANDAG offices To access the meeting room

please arrive on the 8th floor

66

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 41: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

2019 Regional Plan Community Based Organizations Working Group

October 4 2018

Item No Recommendation

+1 Approval of Meeting Minutes Approve

The Community Based Organizations Working Group (Working Group) is asked to review and approve the minutes from its August 2 2018 meeting

2 Public CommentsCommunicationsMember Comments

Members of the public shall have the opportunity to address the WorkingGroup on any issue within the jurisdiction of SANDAG that is not on thisagenda Anyone desiring to speak shall reserve time by completing aRequest to Comment form and giving it to the Clerk prior to speakingPublic speakers should notify the Clerk if they have a handout for distributionto Working Group members Public speakers are limited to three minutes orless per person Working Group members also may provide information andannouncements under this agenda item

Reports

+3 Regional Housing Needs Assessment Update (Seth Litchney) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) and overview the priorities and goals for the development of a methodology to distribute the housing units from the RHNA Determination to each jurisdiction in the region

+4 San Diego Forward The 2019-2050 Regional Plan Extension (Coleen Clementson)

Information

Staff will provide an update on the Board of Directors approval to extend the Regional Plan timeline to allow for additional public input on the transportation network concepts and scenarios For reference the September 14 2018 SANDAG Board of Directors Report will be provided

+5 Regional Transit Fare Study (Brian Lane) Information

Staff will provide an update on the Regional Transit Fare Study initiated by Metropolitan Transit System North County Transit District and SANDAG to consider changes to the regional transit fares to simplify the fare structure and to contain rising operational costs

8 Continued Public Comments

If the five-speaker limit for public comments was exceeded at the beginningof this agenda other public comments will be taken at this time Subjects ofprevious agenda items may not again be addressed under public comment

67

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 42: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

9 Upcoming Meetings Discussion Possible Action

The Working Group is asked to discuss possible topics for the next meeting

The next Working Group meeting is scheduled for Friday November 1 2018at 10 am

10 Adjournment

+ next to an item indicates an attachment

68

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 43: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Item 5 October 4 2018 Action Requested Information

Regional Transit Fare Study

Introduction

SANDAG Board Policy No 029 Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance provides guidelines for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare system within the County of San Diego for the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD) The Comprehensive Fare Ordinance (Ordinance) further defines the existing fare structure used by MTS and NCTD with a detailed listing of the available fares their prices and their limitations

SANDAG MTS and NCTD initiated a regional fare study in the spring of 2016 to look for ways to simplify the fare structure in advance of the procurement of the next generation of fare collection While simplification was the initial primary goal of the study ensuring that fare revenues keep pace with rising operational costs also has become an important consideration for the analysis performed to date

This report provides a history of the Regional Fare Policy and Comprehensive Fare Ordinance discusses the need for and status of the current transit fare study and outlines potential fare changes

Background

Fare Policy and Ordinance History

Senate Bill 1703 (Peace 2003) consolidated transit agency planning and programming functions under SANDAG and designated SANDAG as the agency responsible for developing a Regional Fare Policy including setting fares for transit services in the region through a Comprehensive Fare Ordinance The Regional Fare Policy (Board Policy No 029) calls for setting a uniform fair and equitable regionwide fare structure consistent with revenue-producing requirements and the established budget based on four key elements 1 Regional Participation 2 Production of Revenue 3 Fairness and 4 Simplicity

The Regional Fare Policy was originally adopted in 2004 and the Regional Fare Ordinance was adopted in 2006 Because the Regional Fare Policy is generally broad in nature few changes have been made to it since its adoption The Regional Fare Ordinance has been amended each time a fare change has occurred most notably with fare increases in 2008-2009 for both MTS and NCTD fare reductions in 2011 for numerous NCTD services and in 2014 to allow Universal Pass (UPass) agreements with post-secondary educational institutions

Discussion

Regional Fare Study Purpose Scope and Work to Date

SANDAG included funding to conduct a Regional Fare Study in the FY 2017 Overall Work Program and Budget The primary purpose was to simplify the fare system In addition the most recent state Transportation Development Act (TDA) Triennial Performance Audit of SANDAG recommended that ldquoSANDAG should conduct a fare study to identify and develop opportunities to define fare policies that enhance connectivity between MTS and NCTD and with other connecting providers of public transportation services such as Amtrak and Metrolinkrdquo

69

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 44: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

The scope of the fare study includes the following primary activities

1 Data collection including a compilation of industry best practices peer agency fare structures agencystaff interviews and surveys regarding fares and customer surveys

2 Development and modeling of fare change scenarios to estimate the change in revenue and ridershipresulting from potential fare changes

3 Recommended new fare structure and simplification

A working group of SANDAG MTS and NCTD staff was assembled to implement the scope of work The data collection effort has been completed and reviewed by the staff working group Shortly after initial work began to develop fare simplification scenarios Ridership declines (with associated declines in fare revenues) and cost increases forced the working group to begin thinking about scenarios that could include fare increases

As reported to the Transportation Committee as part of the FY 2018 TDA Productivity Improvement Program on May 19 2017 NCTD was below the state- and SANDAG-mandated farebox recovery threshold for its LIFT and fixed-route services and was considering proposed fare increases to become compliant In May 2017 the NCTD Board of Directors reviewed the proposals and approved a recommendation to submit the proposals to SANDAG for consideration as part of the regional fare study with the desire to have these changes enacted by July 1 2018

Similarly MTS staff presented fare change alternatives to their Budget Development Committee on February 22 2018 to their Board of Directors on March 8 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 1) NCTD staff presented fare change alternatives to their Board of Directors on March 15 2018 and then again on September 20 2018 (Attachment 2) The fare change proposals range from the removal of some seldom-used multi-day passes introduction of a SeniorDisabledMedicare Regional Day Pass increased discounts to youth monthly passes and increases to one-way fares and monthly pass prices Key discussion topics included the pricing for regional fares and potential changes to the TransNet ordinance that would increase the age limit from 60 to 65 for the senior discount and providing an increased discount for youth fares

Next Steps

With feedback from the respective Boards of MTS and NCTD as well as feedback from the Community-Based Organizations Working Group the fares working group will refine the draft alternative fare options and present them to the public to gather feedback These draft alternatives will be incorporated into the Regional Transit Fare Study and presented to the Transportation Committee later this month

Key Staff Contact Brian Lane (619) 699-7331 brianlanesandagorg Attachments 1 MTS Board of Directors Report on Regional Fare Study September 20 2018

2 NCTD Board of Directors Report on Proposed Changes to Comprehensive FareOrdinance September 20 2018

70

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 45: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 22 2018

Chula Vista Library

530 pm ndash 730 pm

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

71

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 46: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 23 2018

200 pm ndash 400 pm

MTS Board Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

72

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 47: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Wednesday October 24 2018

600 pm - 800 pm

El Cajon Police Department Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

73

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 48: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Monday October 29 2018

330 pm - 530 pm

City Heights Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

74

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 49: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Tuesday October 30 2018

12 noon - 2 pm

Escondido Library Turrentine Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

75

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 50: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

PUBLIC MEETING

PROPOSED MTS AND NCTD FARE CHANGES

AGENDA

Thursday November 1 2018

6-8 pm

Oceanside Library Community Room

AGENDA

bull Welcoming remarks

bull Overview of fare change proposal history and reasoning

bull Open house meeting with opportunities to speak with staff and

provide written or recorded public comments

RESOURCES

bull Display boards with information about future meetings next

steps opportunities to provide comments

bull Fact sheets with more information about the fare change

proposal and timeline

bull Take one fliers

bull Surveys

76

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 51: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Names Phone Email

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgZachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Zachary Rivera

(619) 699-4892

ZacharyRiverasandagorg

Kristeine Gong

(619) 595-5342

KristeineGongsandagorg

Jazmin Amini(619) 595-

1466JazminAminis

andagorgKristeine

Gong(619) 595-

5342KristeineGong

sandagorg

Public Meeting Contact InformationPublic

Meeting Venue

Date TimePublic Meeting Officer Name

Public Meeting Transcriber

Escondido Library

10302018 1200 - 200 pmCharles Muggs

Stoll

Oceanside Library

1112018 600 - 800 pm Keith Greer

City Heights Library

10292018 330 - 530 pm Elisa Arias

10222018 530 - 730 pmColeen

Clementson

MTS Board Room

10232018 200 - 400 pmColeen

Clementson

El Cajon Police Department

10242018 600 - 800 pm Linda Culp

Chula Vista Library Civic

Center

77

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1
Page 52: Appendix A - San Diego Association of GovernmentsCity Heights Library, Community Room 3795 Fairmount Ave., San Diego, CA 92105 *Tuesday, October 30, 2018 12:00-2:00 p.m. Escondido

Agency

LeadEvent Type Location Date Time

MTS Pop-up Event H Street Transit Center 10172018 530 - 630 am

MTS Pop-up Event 24th Street Transit Center 10172018 700 - 830 am

MTS Pop-up Event San Ysidro Transit Center 10172018 230 -330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event UTC Transit Center 10172018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event SDSU Transit Center 10172018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Iris Avenue Transit Center 10172018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event University Av amp I-15 Transit Plaza 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Kearny Mesa Transit Center 10172018 430 - 530 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Sabre Springs Transit Center 10182018 600 -700 pm

MTS Pop-up Event City College Station 10182018 230 - 330 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Old Town Transit Center 10182018 300 - 400 pm

MTS Pop-up Event El Cajon Transit Center 10182018 330 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Euclid Transit Center 10182018 400 - 500 pm

MTS Pop-up Event Fashion Valley Transit Center 10182018 430 - 530 pm

MTSOther Meeting

Advocacy DayCrawford High School 10242018 1230 - 230 pm

MTS

Other Meeting City

Heights Transit for

Tacos

Fair44 (4530 El Cajon Blvd San

Diego CA 92105)10252018 230 - 630 pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Escondido Transit Center 10262018 200 - 400pm

NCTD Pop-up Event Oceanside Transit Center 10292018 700 - 900 am

NCTD Pop-up Event Vista Transit Center 10292018 200 - 400 pm

Pop-up Events and Other Meetings

78

  • Item 4 - Att 4 Fares Public Outreach Description
  • Item 4 - Att 41 - Cover Page and Table of Contents
  • Item 4 - Att 41a - Public Notices and Outreach Materials
    • CBO Agenda 10-4-18pdf
      • Agenda - Thursday October 4 2018
      • Item 5 - Regional Transit Fare Study
        • Public Testimony Contact Infopdf
          • Sheet1