Anthropological TheoryAnthropology 330

Kimberly Porter Martin

What is Theory?

DEFINITION Definition: a set of

related hypotheses that provide a better explanation than any single hypothesis.

KEY COMPONENTS Definitions for the central

concepts used for explanation or prediction

Logical connections between concepts to create a system of explanation and/or prediction

Explanation and/or prediction The development of

assumptions that affect the way a problem or issue is viewed.

The World of Theories Theories can be based on logic, ideas or belief without the use of empirical evidence Grounded theories are derived from empirical evidence, and are continuously tested

against new empirical evidence Many different and sometimes conflicting theories can coexist and be used for

different purposes Theories are the basis from which world views are developed and changed

General Types of Theories Materialist Theories Focus on practical, concrete economic factors

such as technology and distribution systems as the shapers of culture.

Ideological Theories Focus on ideas, beliefs and symbols such as

religion and values as the shapers of culture.

Anthropological Theories and Their Proponents

Theory Major Assumption Advocates

EvolutionismAll societies pass through a series of

stages.Tylor, Morgan

DiffusionismAll societies change

as a result of cultural borrowing,

Graebner, Smith

Evolutionism The nineteenth-century school of cultural

anthropology, represented by Tylor and Morgan, that attempted to explain variations in world cultures by the single deductive theory that they all pass through a series of evolutionary stages.

Lewis Henry Morgan Edward Tylor

19th Century Evolutionists

Evolutionism in Brief

All cultures pass through the same developmental stages in the same order.

Evolution is unidirectional and leads to higher levels of culture.

Ethnocentric because evolutionists put their own societies at the top.

Evolutionary StagesLower savagery: From the earliest forms of humanity subsisting on

fruits and nuts.Middle savagery: Began with the discovery of fishing technology

and the use of fire.Upper savagery: Began with the invention of the bow and arrow. Lower barbarism: Began with the art of pottery making.Middle barbarism: Began with domestication of plants and

animals in the Old World and irrigation cultivation in the New World.

Upper barbarism: Began with the smelting of iron and use of iron tools.

Civilization: Began with the invention of the phonetic alphabet and writing.

Diffusionism in Brief

Societies change as a result of cultural borrowing from one another.

Overemphasized the essentially valid idea of diffusion.

Very popular in Europe – especially Germany

American Historicism in Brief

Ethnographic facts must precede development of cultural theories (induction).

Any culture is partially composed of traits diffused from other cultures.

Direct fieldwork is essential. Each culture is, to some degree, unique because of

the specific history of events that caused it to change over time.

Ethnographers should try to get the view of those being studied, not their own view.

Franz Boas Franz Boas, the teacher of

the first generation of cultural anthropologists in the United States, put the discipline on a firm empirical basis.

Developed the theory of American Historicism AKA Historical Particularism

Anthropological Theories and Their Proponents

Theory Major Assumption Advocates

FunctionalismUnderstand how cultures

satisfy the needs of individuals.

Malinowski

Structural functionalism

Determine how cultural elements function for the

well-being of the society.

Radcliffe-Brown

Functionalism in Brief Through fieldwork, anthropologists can

understand how cultures work for the individual and the society.

Society is like a biological organism with many interconnected parts.

All parts of a culture are interconnected so a change in one part of the culture is likely to bring about change in other parts.

Empirical fieldwork is essential. The cultural traditions of a society persist because

serve a purpose in society.

Bronislav Malinowski

During one of the longest uninterrupted fieldwork experiences on record, Bronislav Malinowski not only set the standard for conducting fieldwork but also developed an important new way of looking at cultures known as functionalism.

Anthropological Theories and Their Proponents

Theory Major Assumption Advocates

Psychological anthropology

Show the relationship among psychological and cultural variables.

Benedict, Mead

Neoevolutionism

Cultures evolve in proportion to their capacity to harness

energy.

White, Steward

Psychological Anthropology in Brief

Anthropologists need to explore the relationships between psychological and cultural variables.

Concluded that nurture was more important than nature with regard to personality and gender traits.

Focused on socialization and enculturation of children.

Margaret Mead and

Ruth Benedict

Margaret Mead devoted much of her long and distinguished career in anthropology to the study of how culture affects the process of growing up.

Ruth Benedict Benedict described whole cultures in terms of individual personality characteristics.

Psychological Anthropologists

Interested in exploring relationship between culture and the individual.

Benedict studied Native Americans and wrote about the Japanese during World War II to make them intelligible to Americans

Mead’s early research brought her to Samoa to study emotional problems associated with adolescence.

Later she studied male and female gender roles in New Guinea.

Neoevolutionism in Brief

Cultures evolve in proportion to their capacity to harness energy.

Culture is shaped by environmental conditions.

Human populations continuously adapt to techno-environmental conditions.

Leslie White

Anthropological Theories and Their Proponents

School Major Assumption Advocates

French structuralism

Human cultures are shaped by the

preprogrammed way the human mind is

organized.

Lévi-Strauss

EthnoscienceCultures must be

described in terms of native categories.

Frake, Goodenough

French StructuralismCulture as Mental StructuresStructures of knowledge about kinship. All kinship systems classify relationships by gender, generation and collaterality.

Structures of meaning within myths. Myths consist of (1) elements that oppose or contradict each other and (2) other elements that "mediate", or resolve, those oppositions.

Ethnoscience An attempt at cultural

description from a totally emic standpoint, using only the concepts and categories of the people being studied.

Ethnographic Interviews to elicit native categories.

Charles Frake

Anthropological Theories and Their Proponents

School Major Assumption Advocates

Cultural materialism

Material conditions determine human

consciousnessand behavior.

Harris

Postmodernism

Human behavior comes from how people

perceive and classify their world.

Rosaldo

Cultural Materialism All aspects of culture

can be explained by economic factors.

Sacred cows in India. Aggression and

protein in the Amazon Basin

Postmodernism Rejects the existence of

objective facts in favor of emic perspectives.

Studies culture as a phenomenon that creates different realities for each person and each society.

Writes descriptions rather than research reports

Renato Rosaldo

Powerpoint Study Guide

TheoryGrounded TheoryMaterialist TheoryIdeological TheoryEvolutionismDiffusionismAmerican HistoricismFunctionalism

Structural Functionalism Psychological Anthropology Neoevolutionism French Structuralism Ethnoscience Cultural Materialism Postmodernism