10
ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have receivedspecialattentiooover the past few decades in the search for reagents for improved flOiatioo separation of minerals,especiallynon-sulphides. The majority of suchreagents that have been proposed over the past few decades have remained largely a \al)(ntory curiosity, excep pemapsallcyl hydroxarnates, because their selea.ioois seldom based00 canmercial viability. In this regard, the choice of canplexing agents such as oximes may be more realistic be£ause of their widespread use in solvent extractioo of copper. Our earlier studies havecmfmned that they are also effective ascolleClors for copperoxide minerals, including chrysocollawhich is the most difficult copper mineral to beneficiate. The flotation behaviour of chrysocollafor severalstructurally-related hydroxyoximes were studied as a ftmctioo of pH and oxime coocentration and the role of structural features examined. The structural changes studied included substitutioos in ~ chelatingand non-chelating partsof the molecule. The results indicatedthat, cootrary to expectations, many of the structural changes in the basic molecule, salicylaldoxime,do not have a positive effeCl00 collector efficiency. The reductionin collector efficiency is ratiooalised on the basisof possiblesteric factors affecting canplexation and packing of the collector species 00 the mineral surface as well as effects due 10 changes in electron density brooght about by substituents. Introductioo of alkyl substituents on the oximic carbon of salicylaldoxime yielded the highest collector efficiency. INTRODUCTION Over dte past six decades or so, since dte advent of soluble surfactants as collectors in flotation, dtere has been a relentless searchfor new chemistries for improved separation of minerals, bodt sulphidesand non-sulphides. Whedter it is for flotation or depression, organic-<:omplexing agents or chelatingagents. have received special attention (Barbezyet al, 1977; Drzymala and Laskowski, 1981; Fuerstenau and Pradip, 1984; Gutzeit, 1946; Holman, 1930;Marabini et al, 1971, 1974, 1973, 1976;Nagaraj, 1987;Sornasundaran and Nagaraj,1984;Taggart. 1930). This is largely driven by dte success of these reagentsin analytical separations. While in principle it is logical to expect metal specificity observed in analytical separations to translate into mineral specificity, in practicethis is far from a straight forward transfer. Neverdteless, an assumption is madein dte majority of swdies dtat complexing agents oosorbon minerals by forming metal complexes on mineral surfaces under conditions most favorable for metal complexation in solution as observed in analytical separations, and dtat such metal complexes are responsible for imparting hydrophobicity to dte solid. While a variety of complexing agentsare already in large scale use in sulphidesflotation, this is not dte casein oxides flotation. Fatty acids and arninesstill dominate dte industry though numerous complexing agents have been Jroposed. Perhaps dte only significant commercial utility in the non-sulphides area can be attributed to dte alkyl hydroxamales(Fuerstenau and Pradip, 1984) in the former Soviet Union at leastuntil a few yearsago. Current usage of dtis is not known. Limited application can also be found for certain phosphonic acids (Nagaraj, 1987). The prohibitively high cost andhigh dosages requiredof many of dte proposed complexing agents are certainly major factors. The underlying factor, however,may be the choice of a complexing agent. Complexing agentshave been chosen invariably on the basisof success in analytical separation rather than on the basis of commercialviability. Thus many of the proposedstructures fall into the categoryof 'exotic' chemistry and remain largely a laboratory curiosity. h1 this regard the choice of cornplexing agents such as oximes may be more realistic. The commercial viability of oximes has been well established because of their widespread usein solventextractionof copper. One of the early references to the proposeduse of oxirnes is that of Vivian in 1927. Dimethylglyoxime (DMG) was proposed for floating nickel oxide ores. Delitsina et aI (1954. 1956) recommended the use of DMG for the flotation of chalcopyrite. bornite, malachite. pyrite and electrolytic copper and nickel. They concluded that the increaseof hydrophobisationof the mineral was greaterwith DMG than with xanthate. which is an intriguing result, especiallyfor sulphideminerals. Their fmdings contradict those of Petersonel at (1965) who found lack of flotation of chrysocolla with DMG and of Drzymala and Laskowski (1981) who found lack of flotation of synthetic millerite and other nickel minerals with DMG and other dioximes. It should be noted here that DMG forms water-soluble copper chelate. Usoni et at (1971) showedthat a hydrocarbon oil was necessary to obtain acceptableflotation of niccolite with DMG. Teoh et aI (1982) usedseveral homologous dioximes for the flotation of nickel bearing minerals. Optimum flotation was obtained with 2.3-nonanedione dioxime. Peterson et aI (1965) also suggested the use of alpha-benzoin oxime for chrysocolla flotation. De Win and Batchelder (1939) investigated the collector function of salicylaldoxirne (SALO). its meta- and para- isomers. and its mono methyl ether, for chalcocite, covellite, azurite. malachiteand cuprite. Only SALO was found to function as a collector. The meta- and para- isomers could not function as collectorssince their structure doesnot permit chelateformation. It was alsoproposed that if the phenolic hydroxyl is replaced by a methoxy group. the resulting monomethylether of SALO would not be a collector. Mukai and Wakamatsu(1976) also used SALO as a promoter of xanthateadsorptionfor the flotation of chrysocolla. Adsorption of xanthate increased with the addition of SALO. while a complete coating of SALO on chrysocolla adverselyaffected xanthateadsorption. No effort was made to investigatethe collector action of SAW alone. It is not clear what the mechanism of this coadsorption is and why a xanthate is required in addition to SALO. Barbery el aI (1977) and Cecile et aI (1981) investigated the collector function of oxirnesfor malachiteand chrySOcolla. They studied adsorption of SAW on malachite with supporting information derived from IR analysis. Multilayers of copper chelate were observed on the mineral surface. Nagaraj and Somasundaran have conductedmany systematic studies on the adsorption of oximes on copper oxide minerals and their flotation (1979a. 1979b. 1981). The collector pro~rty of commercially used solvent extractants of the UX type 'were evaluatedfor the flotation of chrysocolla and cuprite. These investigatorsalso conducteda fundamentalstudy of the system tenorite-SALO in order to elucidate the mechanism of collector The terms'complexing' and 'chelating' will be used interchangeably in this paper sinceall of the discussion applies equally to both, andsince 'chelation' is but a special case of 'complexation'. 1. Henry Krumb Schoolof Mines, ColumbiaUniversity,New York, NY 10027, USA 2. AmericanCyanamid Company, Stamford cr 06904,USA. XVIII International MnefaI Proc»ssing C«'Ig(ess Sydney, 23 - 28 May 1993 577

ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

ABSTRACT

Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the pastfew decades in the search for reagents for improved flOiatioo separationof minerals, especially non-sulphides. The majority of such reagents thathave been proposed over the past few decades have remained largely a\al)(ntory curiosity, excep pemaps allcyl hydroxarnates, because theirselea.ioo is seldom based 00 canmercial viability. In this regard, thechoice of canplexing agents such as oximes may be more realisticbe£ause of their widespread use in solvent extractioo of copper. Ourearlier studies have cmfmned that they are also effective as colleClors forcopper oxide minerals, including chrysocolla which is the most difficultcopper mineral to beneficiate.

The flotation behaviour of chrysocolla for several structurally-relatedhydroxyoximes were studied as a ftmctioo of pH and oxime coocentrationand the role of structural features examined. The structural changesstudied included substitutioos in ~ chelating and non-chelating parts ofthe molecule. The results indicated that, cootrary to expectations, manyof the structural changes in the basic molecule, salicylaldoxime, do nothave a positive effeCl 00 collector efficiency. The reduction in collectorefficiency is ratiooalised on the basis of possible steric factors affectingcanplexation and packing of the collector species 00 the mineral surfaceas well as effects due 10 changes in electron density brooght about bysubstituents. Introductioo of alkyl substituents on the oximic carbon ofsalicylaldoxime yielded the highest collector efficiency.

INTRODUCTION

Over dte past six decades or so, since dte advent of solublesurfactants as collectors in flotation, dtere has been a relentlesssearch for new chemistries for improved separation of minerals,bodt sulphides and non-sulphides. Whedter it is for flotation ordepression, organic-<:omplexing agents or chelating agents. havereceived special attention (Barbezy et al, 1977; Drzymala andLaskowski, 1981; Fuerstenau and Pradip, 1984; Gutzeit, 1946;Holman, 1930; Marabini et al, 1971, 1974, 1973, 1976; Nagaraj,1987; Sornasundaran and Nagaraj, 1984; Taggart. 1930). This islargely driven by dte success of these reagents in analyticalseparations. While in principle it is logical to expect metalspecificity observed in analytical separations to translate intomineral specificity, in practice this is far from a straight forwardtransfer. Neverdteless, an assumption is made in dte majority ofswdies dtat complexing agents oosorb on minerals by formingmetal complexes on mineral surfaces under conditions mostfavorable for metal complexation in solution as observed inanalytical separations, and dtat such metal complexes areresponsible for imparting hydrophobicity to dte solid. While avariety of complexing agents are already in large scale use insulphides flotation, this is not dte case in oxides flotation. Fattyacids and arnines still dominate dte industry though numerouscomplexing agents have been Jroposed. Perhaps dte onlysignificant commercial utility in the non-sulphides area can beattributed to dte alkyl hydroxamales (Fuerstenau and Pradip,1984) in the former Soviet Union at least until a few years ago.Current usage of dtis is not known. Limited application can alsobe found for certain phosphonic acids (Nagaraj, 1987). Theprohibitively high cost and high dosages required of many of dteproposed complexing agents are certainly major factors. Theunderlying factor, however, may be the choice of a complexing

agent. Complexing agents have been chosen invariably on thebasis of success in analytical separation rather than on the basisof commercial viability. Thus many of the proposed structuresfall into the category of 'exotic' chemistry and remain largely alaboratory curiosity. h1 this regard the choice of cornplexingagents such as oximes may be more realistic. The commercialviability of oximes has been well established because of theirwidespread use in solvent extraction of copper.

One of the early references to the proposed use of oxirnes isthat of Vivian in 1927. Dimethylglyoxime (DMG) was proposedfor floating nickel oxide ores. Delitsina et aI (1954. 1956)recommended the use of DMG for the flotation of chalcopyrite.bornite, malachite. pyrite and electrolytic copper and nickel.They concluded that the increase of hydrophobisation of themineral was greater with DMG than with xanthate. which is anintriguing result, especially for sulphide minerals. Their fmdingscontradict those of Peterson el at (1965) who found lack offlotation of chrysocolla with DMG and of Drzymala andLaskowski (1981) who found lack of flotation of syntheticmillerite and other nickel minerals with DMG and otherdioximes. It should be noted here that DMG forms water-solublecopper chelate. Usoni et at (1971) showed that a hydrocarbon oilwas necessary to obtain acceptable flotation of niccolite withDMG. Teoh et aI (1982) used several homologous dioximes forthe flotation of nickel bearing minerals. Optimum flotation wasobtained with 2.3-nonanedione dioxime. Peterson et aI (1965)also suggested the use of alpha-benzoin oxime for chrysocollaflotation.

De Win and Batchelder (1939) investigated the collectorfunction of salicylaldoxirne (SALO). its meta- and para- isomers.and its mono methyl ether, for chalcocite, covellite, azurite.malachite and cuprite. Only SALO was found to function as acollector. The meta- and para- isomers could not function ascollectors since their structure does not permit chelate formation.It was also proposed that if the phenolic hydroxyl is replaced by amethoxy group. the resulting monomethyl ether of SALO wouldnot be a collector. Mukai and Wakamatsu (1976) also usedSALO as a promoter of xanthate adsorption for the flotation ofchrysocolla. Adsorption of xanthate increased with the additionof SALO. while a complete coating of SALO on chrysocollaadversely affected xanthate adsorption. No effort was made toinvestigate the collector action of SAW alone. It is not clearwhat the mechanism of this coadsorption is and why a xanthate isrequired in addition to SALO.

Barbery el aI (1977) and Cecile et aI (1981) investigated thecollector function of oxirnes for malachite and chrySOcolla. Theystudied adsorption of SAW on malachite with supportinginformation derived from IR analysis. Multilayers of copperchelate were observed on the mineral surface.

Nagaraj and Somasundaran have conducted many systematicstudies on the adsorption of oximes on copper oxide minerals andtheir flotation (1979a. 1979b. 1981). The collector pro~rty ofcommercially used solvent extractants of the UX type 'wereevaluated for the flotation of chrysocolla and cuprite. Theseinvestigators also conducted a fundamental study of the systemtenorite-SALO in order to elucidate the mechanism of collector

The terms 'complexing' and 'chelating' will be usedinterchangeably in this paper since all of the discussion appliesequally to both, and since 'chelation' is but a special case of'complexation'.

1. Henry Krumb School of Mines, Columbia University, NewYork, NY 10027, USA

2. American Cyanamid Company, Stamford cr 06904, USA.

XVIII International MnefaI Proc»ssing C«'Ig(ess Sydney, 23 - 28 May 1993 577

Page 2: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

TABLE 1TIte stnICtlD"U and ~Ur solubility of hydroxyoximes.

Structure Name Mol.\Vt.

$ALO

WaterSolu-bility, M

2.0 x 10-1(Salicylaldoxime) 137.1

OHAPO (O-Hydroxy Acet0-phenone Oxime) 4.5 x 10-3151.2

OHBuPO (o-Hydroxy Butyro-phenone Oxime) 5.0 x 10-4179.2

Q-: HC"-It

aiM»f

~V',c,'0f0

aiM»f

Q-: ai,of.aisC""II<»IM»fQ-~ ~

~C-J! ::::JIIailQ{QI.

OHBePO (O-Hydroxy Benzo-phenone OxIme) 1.5 x 10-4213.2

2H5MeAPO",,0\

CII

C»IPQt

~

3.0 x 104(2.~roxy 5-Methyt

Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2

2HSMBAO (2-Hydroxy 5-MethoxyBenzaldoxime) 5.0 x 10.3168.2

OHNAO (2-Hydroxy 1-NaphthaJ-doxlme) 1.0 x 10-4189.2

OHCI-K) (o-~roxy Cyclo-hexanone Oxime) 129.0 -1.0

OMeAPO (o-Methoxy keto-phenone Oxime) 165.0

OHAPOMeO (o-Hydroxy Aceto-phenone o.methylOxime 165.0

Generalized Structure ..

.,..R,CII

OH~

The structure of a complexing agent and, dterefore, itsproperties. can be changed by incorporating substituents in eidIerthe chelating part or dIe non-(;helating part of the molecule. Theeffect of such changes on dte collector efficiency of a number ofstructurally-related hydroxyoximes for chrysocolla as a functionof pH and reagent concentration is discussed in this paper.Information on structure-activity relationships is important fromdte point of view of not only understanding fundamentalmechanistic aspects, but also for dIe commercial viability of

action of hydroxyoximes. Aliaga and Somasundaran (1987)found an interesting correlation between dte UV spectta ofseveral struCttlrally-related oximes. dteir copper chelates and dteircollector properties.

Kiersmicki et al (1981) swdioo dte effect of alkyl chain lengdtin 5-aikyl SALO in dte flotation of sphalerite. smithsonite anddolomite and suggested dtat a propyl group gave optimumresults.

578 Sydney. 23 - 28 May 1993 XVIII International MnefaJ Pro<»ssWlg Congress

Page 3: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

~.

>-Q::~0<.)w~

Z0

~~

§

INITIAL CONCENTRATION, M

FKJ 1 - ~ of cluy~. as . fulK:lioo of ~ of hmKIIOIues oximes: SALO; OHAPO; OHBuPO.

oximes in flotation. auoysocolla would be a logical choiceamong the oxide-type cower minerals because it is one of memost difficult to float. Its flotation aspects were reviewedrecently (Laskowski el ai, 1985).

(Xmfirmed by IR 8Id T1..C teclmiques. Water solubility of dieoximes wlS measured by derennining die aRk)\D1t dissolved aftershaking the oxinte in 10 ml of biply distilled water for d1ree daysat 25 - 26°C. The values are given in Table 1. These solubilitiesare expected to be close to die equilibrium values.

Stock solutions of oxintes in triply distilled water wereJrepared by adding one per cent acetone to ensure adequatesolubility. This amount of acetone was also beneficial in flotationtests because it Jroduced small. uniformly sized bubbles; aseparate frolher WIS, ~fore, not n«:essary.

EXPERIMENTAL

Mineral

Chrysocolla, CuSiO3, obtained as high-grade lumps from BlackHills Minerals. was crushed. hand-sorted, and crushed again 10.14 mesh. The -14 + 100 mesh fraction was passed dlrough a drymagnetic separator. ground in an agate mortar 10 -48 mesh. The-48 + 100 mesh fraction was passed dlrough a magnetic separatoragain, deslimed and cbied. It analysed 24 per cent Cu. X-raydiffraction indicated mioor amounts of quartz impurity.

Fk)tation

95 ml of the oxime solution at the desired concenb'ation wasstirred in a 150 m1 cyfuder. After pH adjUStmen1 to the desiredvalue. 0.7 g of the mineral was added aJ¥i conditioned fCK the~uired period with continuous COOb'ol and recording of the pH.pH was adjusted with KOH and HN03 to within :t: 0.05 unit.After conditioning. the mineral was floated in a modifiedHallimom tube for one minwe with 20 cchnjn nib'ogen.

OximesThe oximes used are shown in Table 1. SALO obtained from LaChat Chemicals was purified by ~rallisltion from petroleumedler-benzene mixture. 2-hydroxy-l-cyclohexanone oxime wasprepared by the met/X)d described by Nmz el al (1964). All ocheroximes w~ p-epared from their respective ketones or aldehydesby the medtods described by Blatt (1955) and Kohler aid Bruce(1931). All the oximes except OHAPOMeO were purified byrecrystallisltion. OHAPOMeO was obtained as a liquid and itwas purified by etha- ex~oo. The stnK:nIres and pJrities wa-e

RESULTSRotation data for Chrysocolla at pH 4.8 as a f\DK:tion ofconcentration of d1e duee homologous oximcs - SAW, OMAro,and OHBuPO . are shown in Figure 1. pH 4.8 was se1«;ted forthese tests b«:ause preliminary work with UX type of reagentshad indicllai that flotation was opirnum around pH 4.8. The

XVIII k1~ma~ *er8I ~ Congress Sy«IeY. 23 . 28 .-y 1 ~ 579

Page 4: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

(ie 2H5MBAO, see Table 1) as well as methyl substitution in the5-position of OHAPO (ie 2H5MeAPO) decreased die collectorefficiency (more so widt 2H5MeAPO), dtough bodt 2H5MBAOand 2HSMeAPO had lower water solubility compared with theirparent molecules.

Flotation of chrysocolla widt 2H5MBAO and 2H5MeAPO aregiven in Figure 4 as a function of pH. Rotation behavior with2H5MBAO is very similar to dtat widt SALO, while that with2H5MeAPO is quite different and unusual compared widt dtat ofOHAPO. Two flotation maxima are observed for 2H5MeAPO,one at pH 4 and die other at pH 8.

Rotation obtained with the remaining oximes - OHBePO,OHNAO, OMeAPO, OHAPOMeO, and OHCHO at pH 4.8 areshown in Figure 5 as a function of concentration and in Figure 6as a function of pH. Flotation data widt SALO (from Figure 1)are also plotted in Figures 5 and 6 for comparison. Most of theoximes tested in dtis group were characterised by very lowcollector efficiency at pH 4.8 compared with that obtained withSALO. Thus substitution of a phenyl group for Rl (ie OHBePO,Table 1) decreased collector efficiency at pH 4.8. The pH foroptimum flotation with this oxime, however, was at pH 6, not at4.8. A fused aromatic ring (naphthalene) instead of the benzenering in SALO resulted in a very large lowering of collectorefficiency at pH 4.8 (dtOUgh it was optimum at approximatelythis pH). Thus OHNAO was inferior to all the other closelyrelated oximes. Similarly, methylation of the phenolic OH inSALO almost completely destroyed the collector property. Onthe other hand, methylation of the oximic OH of SALO (ie

maximum amount of oxime that could be used in flotation waslimited by its solubility.

It is evident from the results given in Figure 1 that an increasein the chain length of R, (see generalised strucwre, Table 1)while keeping R2 = H results in an increase in the flotationefficiency in the order -H « -CH3 < -C3H7. Ackiing the fustcarbon in R, resulted in the largest increase. Thus theconcentration of OHAPO required to obtain about 60 per centflotation is about half that of SALO and the water solubility islowered by almost two orders of magnitude. Increase in thechain length of R, by two more carbons (to give OHBuPO)further imlX'oved the coll~tor efficiency, but not to the extentobserved by introducing the first carbon. The water solubility ofOHBuro was only an order of magnitude less than that ofOHAPO.

Flotation data for the three homologous oxirnes are given inFigure 2 as a nmction of pH. Less-than-optimwn concentrationswere chosen deliberately in order to obselVe the features offlotation behaviour vs pH and to discern differences betweenoximes. These data, in general, support the results discussedabove. The collector efficiencies of OHBuM and OHAPO werehigher than that of SALO at all pH values, though theconcentrations used with the former two oximes was lower thanthat used with SALO. Flotation of chrysocolla was maximum atpH 5.0. The effect of substitution on the benzerte ring on theflotation of chrysocolla as a function of concentration of oximesat pH 4.8 is shown in Figure 3. Flotation data for SALO andOHAPO (from Figure 1) are replotted here for comparison. Itcan be seen that methoxy substitution in the 5-position in SALO

100

90 SAlO

CHAPa

OHBuPO.0~~

~

0::

W

~:Uwa:::

~0-~

~(:)

g

70

80

50

40

[30

20~~

Q-~S ~ 1 n

'~LXV M KNO3

;0:~:L 4 9 8 10 ,

12 4

qQNP.lTtO~fNG pHFIG 2 - R«alioo of chrylOOOI1a as a functioo of pH with hanologues oxirnes: SALO; OHAPO; OHBuPO.

S«) Sydney. 23.28 May 1993 XVllllntemalionaJ Mineral Promssing Ccx98Ss

Page 5: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

~.

>:--~w

~Q4f(k:,

z0~<~0-J~

~~0 o~ 10-3

INITIAL CONCENTRATION, MFKJ 3 . Rotation of chrysocoUa as a function of coocentration of oximes: SAW; OHAPO; 2H5MBAO; 2H5MeAPO.

OHAPOMeO) only reduced the collector efficiency withoutdestroying it completely. pH for optimum flotation with thisoxime was at approximately 8.

The case of OHCHO is a special one because it belongs to theclass of alpha-acyloin oximes, though dte oxime is distinctbecause of the cyclic alkane. OHCHO was found to have anappreciable solubility in water (dte highest of the oximes tested).Its copper chelate was soluble in mildly acidic pH range andprecipitated in the basic pH range. In accord with d1is OHCHOexhibited extremely low collector efficiency even at very highCOncentrations.

DISCUSSION

The flotation behavior for chrysocolla with the majority of theoximes swilled was the same; optimum flotation occuned atawroximately pH 5. For UX65N (2-hydroxy-5-nonylbenzophenone oxime) two maxima in flotation occur, one at pH 5and the other at pH 10. Chrysocolla flotation with octylhydroxamate has a maximum at pH 6 (peterson et ai, 1965).AltOOugh the optimum in flotation of citrysocolla around pH 5can be explained on the basis of CuOW species on the surface(Palmer et ai, 1975), an alternative explanation would involve thepartitioning of the oxime between the mineral surf~e and thebulk aqueous phase in relation to mineral solubility, as in the caseof tenorite-SALO system (Nagaraj and Somasundaran, 1979).PKa of the oxime would also make a significant contribution tothe location of the flotation optimum.

The increase in collector efficiency observed with increase inchain length (ie SAW « OHAPO < OHBuPO, Figures 1 and 2)in the homologous series is in general agreement withobservations made in other systems. For example, Fuerstenau,Healy and Somasundaran (1964) documented this for quartzflotation with homologous amines. As can be expected,introducing the fIrSt -CH2 in SAW causes a much larger changein polarity of the molecule compared with further addition of twoCH2 groups. This is reflected in the water solubility of theoximes - SALO » OHAPO > OHBuPO - and also in thecollector efficiency. Furthermore, the increase in collectorefficiency of the higher homologues may be related to theelectron-releasing (inductive) effect of CHJ, relative to -H, whichwo~ld increase the electron density on the nitrogen. Watersolubility of homologous compounds should provide anapproximate indication of the hydrophobicity that they wouldimpart to the mineral surface assuming that their mode ofadsorption is similar. This has been observed in the case of fattyacids and arnines.

Substitution of a phenyl group in Rl (OHBePO, see Table 1)decreased the wata solubility appreciably, which is to beexpected from the less polar benzene ring. On the basis of Iowasolubility of OHBePO relative to SAW one might haverxedicted a higher collector efficiency than with SAW. Theresults, however, were quite contrary to this at pH 4.8 (Figure 5).An important reason for this is the shift of the pH of olXimumflotation for OHBePO from pH 5 with SAW to -6 withOHBePO. This shift is possibly related to a change in pK. of theoxime in going from SALO to OHBePO, which can be expected

XVIII International Mneral P~ssing Congress Sydney. 23 - 28 May 1003 581

Page 6: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

100

90

80~

->-

f5>0<.>w~

z0

~~0-.JlJ-

70

60

50

40

30

20

0

0

CONDITIONING pHFKJ 4 - F1owioo of cluysocQla as . f\8Iaioo of pH wiIh ox--= SAW; OHAPO; 2H5MBAO; 2H5MeAPO.

me!hoxy group has reduced dte hydroPiobicity slightly becauseof dte orientation effects.

The low colleclOr efficiency of OHNAO (naphdtalene group,see Table 1), u in me cue of OHBePO, may also be related tolow hydrophobicity imparted to the surf~ after Misorpcion and~ed packing on die surf~ because of die naphd1alene rings.The very low water solubility restricted dte maximwnconcenttation snldied to -10 M.

The drastic reduction in me colleclOr efficiency associated withmemyl subsunltion for phenolic hydrogen (ie OMeAPO, Figures5 and 6) is expected because this molecule is tmable 10 form achelale widt coppa-. This result is in agreement wim dtatobserved by De Witt and Batchelder (1939) for o-methylbenzaldoxime and supports the hypothesis mat chelate formationis a JXerequisite for flotation. In mis context, dte absence ofcollector property observed by Nagaraj and Somasundaran(1979) for die syn-isomer of LlX65N is notewordty; mesyn-isomer is also incapable of chelate formation. It ca., beargued, however, mat OMeAPO could still adsorb on chrysocoUaby forming a complex (!hough not a chelate) wim cower via meoximic nittogen and function as a collector because simplealdoximes (such as R-NOH) are known 10 complex widt copper(Chakravuty, 1974). This 00es not appear to be 1he case from meflotation data obtained here, probably because the methylsubstitution on phenolic OH may impose sterlc hindrance to sucha complex formation wim oximic nittogen on the mineral surf~.

Medlylation of die oxime group (as in OHAPOMeO. Table 1)

~ause the benzate ring can alter d\e electron density on theoxime group significantly. Significanl differences betweenorientalions of adsorbed SALO and OHBcPO can also beexpected based on dieir strucnlres. which dien b'anslate intodifferences in hydrophobicity. Water contact angles. for example,on surf.:es comprising -CH2 or -CH3 are higher than diosecomprising aromatic groups (Wu, 1982). Also in the case ofOHBePO. dia-e is a JX>Ssibility d1at close packing of surfacearomatic groups is hindered. This would furdta- contribule to thelowering of contact angles.

The lower col1~tor effK:iency of oximes widi substitution indie 5-position on the rine. va 2H5MBAO am 2H5MeAPO.relative to SALO is ramer surprising (Figures 3 and 4) in view ofdie fact diat diey bodi form stable, insoluble copper chelales withcopper ions. The lower water solubility would suggest that theywould be less polar. Separate adsorption measurements (notshown here) indicated diat both substiblled compo\D1ds adsorbed. effectively as SAW. In the case of 2H5MeAPO. the pH ofoptimwn flotation is shifted (in f~t there are tWo maxima, seeFigure 4, at pH 4 and 8). This may explain the low flotation atpH 4.8. The reason for die two flotation maxima is W1known andit cannot be rationalised readily ~ all other oximes showed~ flotalioo maximum. In the case of 2H5MBAO, pH of~ flotation was 8PfX'oximately die slme . diat obtainedwidi SAW. though the medtoxy group on the ring can beexpected to alter die pK. because of the elecb'on releasing1eI¥Iency. The only explanation diat can be offa-ed at diis pointfor the lower coU~tor efficiency of 2H5MBAO is that the

Syckl8Y. 23 . 28 May 1993 XVIIlIntemaIionai aIneraI p~ ~582

Page 7: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

is not expected to prevent chelate fonnation with copper and,therefore. its collector JropeIty should be similar to that ofOHAPO. but the results obtained here are quite contrary to thiseXpectation (see Figures 5 and 6). OHAPOMeO exhibited onlyweak collector property even at high concentrations. This can berationalised at this stage only on the basis of possible sterichindrance to complex fonnation on the mineral surface. This isnot unreasonable because steric flK:tors are much more imponantfor surface chelation than for chelation in bulk ~ueous solutions.

The very poor collector efficiency of OHCHO (see Figures 5and 6) is also rather swprising since after adsorption thiscompound should expose the cyclohexane group which should besufficiently hydrophobic. OHCHO was not only very soluble inwater (the highest among the oximes studied). but it fonnedsoluble cower chelates in mildly lK:id and neutral pH range. Theresults given in Figure 6 suggest its collector activity to increasewith increase in pH. but a very high concentration may berequired to achieve high flotation of chrysocolla.

sttuctural changes, however, made a negative conbibution to diecollector efficiency. Correlation existed between reduction inwater solubility of die oxime and increase in its collectorefficiency only for die homologous oximes.

Substitution of alkyl group on die oximic carbon ofsalicylaldoxime had die largest positive conbibution to thecollector efficiency which followed the order, o-hydroxybutyrophenone oxime> o-hydroxy acetophenone oxime »salicylaldoxime. Substitution of methoxy or medlyl in die5-position on die benzene ring in SAW and o-hydroxy~tophenone oxime, respectively, decreased die collectorefficiency. This fmding is contrary to expectations based onwater solubility and chelation of copper in solutions, and can berationalised at diis stage on die basis of steric hindrance tocomplexation and packing on chrysocolla. The medioxy group.in addition, may lead to a reduction in hydrophobicity because ofits more polar character. A fused aromatic ring (naphdialene forexample) instead of die benzene ring in SAW lowered diecollector efficiency drastically. Substitution of a phenyl group ondie oximic carbon in SAW lowered die collector efficiency atpH 4.8, but it also shifted die pH of optimum flotation to 12.Also, medlylation of phenolic group in SAW destroyed diecollector property as expected. Mediylation of die oxime group,on the oilier hand, merely lowered die collector efficiency. Thisis attributed to die negative contribution from steric factorsaffecting complexation and packing on mineral surface. Ahydroxyoxime group on a cyclohexane ring offered noadvantage. In fact dtis oxime had extremely poor collectorefficiency even at very high concentrations. This is attributed todie very high solubility of die copper chelate.

SUMMARY

Flotation behaviour of chrysocolla as a function of pH andconcenttation of several, sparingly soluble, sttucrorally-relatedhydroxyoximes is discussed. Substimtion in both the chelatingand non-chelating parts of the basic hydroxyoxime molecule. dtesalicylaldoxime (SAW), was considered.

Rotation of chrysocolla was optimum at pH-5 with most ofthe oxirnes. The major flotation effects observed in this smdy arereadily explained by examining dte changes in slrucmral fearoresof the oximes. Conttary to what might be expected. many

100

Q~~hf.;J'$l<>.

$ALO .OHBePO .OHNAO -.-OMeAPO ~-

OHAPOMeO OHCHO -.-

90

80~

>"-'f:k::

~(:)QL.s;SCt::~

~

0.0,-

m:~

R0~~

70 Condo time = 10 min.

Flat. time = 1 min.Condo pH = 4.860

~JS = 2 x .10 M KNO350

~o,<{,

~~;30

20-v-v

""""~--410..1- -~

01'0 6 \Q~ 0-4 ~~ .1 0-2 ~~.l

;y

INITIAL CONCENTRATION, MFKI S . F1«aaioo of chrysocolla as a functioo of ooncentralioo of oximea: SALO; OHBePO; OHNAO; OMeAPO; OHAroMeO; OHCHO.

XVIII International Mneral P~ssW1g Congress Sydney, 23 - 28 May 1993 S83

~'

Page 8: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

00

90

80~ .'0:>-a:

guw'Q:;

aE~

~

eo

pO

40

~Q

20

0'0 '

3 ($", 9 J

CONDITIONING pHFK) 6 - Halation of chrysocolla as a function of pH with oximes: SALO; OHBePO; OHNAO; OMeAPO; OHAPOMeO; OHCHO.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The authors acknowledge the fInancial suppon provided by theNational Science Foundation and the Engelhard Corporation forcarrying out this work.

F~rstenau, D W, Healy, T W and Scxnasundaran, P, 1964. The Role ofHydrocarboo Otain of Alkyl Collectors in Flotation, TralLf SME,229:321-325.

Fuerslenau, D W and Pradip, 1984. in Reagenls in Minerals Industry(Eds: Jones, M J, and Oblan, R), pp 161-168 (The Institution ofMining and Metallurgy:Londoo).

Gutuit, G, 1946. OJelate-Forming Organic CcxnlX>llllds as FlotationReagents, Trans AIME, 169:272.

Hohnan, B W, 1930. Flotation Reagents, Bull Inst Min Met, 315:53.Kienzniclci, T, Majewski and Mzyk, J, 1981. lilt J Miner Process,

7:311-318.Kohler, E P and Bruce, W F, 1931. The Oximes of Onho-Hydroxy

BenlDpitenone.J Am Chem Soc, 53:1569-1574.Laskowski, J, Fuerstenau, D W, Goowez, G and Urbina, R H 1985.

Studies on the Flotation of OJrysooolla in Miner ProceR Extr MetaURev, 2:135-155.

LOOt, R W and De Win, C C, 1949. The Flotatioo of Copper Silicate fromSilica. TralLf AlME, 184:49-51.

Marabini, A M and Rinelli, G, 1913. Flotation of Pitchblende widt aOJelaling Agent and Fuel Oil, Trans IlLft Min Metall, 82:C225-228.

Mukai, S and Wakamatsu, T, 1976. Sane Problems of Copper OxideMineral Flotation ~sented at SME-AIME Fall Meeting, Denver,Co, USA.

Naguaj, DR and Scxnaslmdaran, P, 1979.. in Recent DevelopIMnis inS~[»ratio/l ScU/IC~ (Ed: N, Ii), Vol V, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fl,017.

Nagaraj, D R, and Somasundaran, P, 1919b. Trans SME, 266: 1892-1891.Naguaj, D R and Scxnasundaran, P, 1981. Mining E/lg, September, pp

1351-1357.

REFERENC~Aliaga, W and Somasundaran, P, 1987. Molecular Orbital Modeling and

UV-Spectros~c Investigati<XI of Ads()(ption of Oxime SurfactanLSin Lallgmuir, 3:1103.

BarlJery, G, Cecile, 1 L, Fripial, 1 and Plich<XI., V, 1977. in XII/hIniuna/iOfJa/ Mineral Processing Congress Special Publica/ion. VolII, Sao Paulo, pp 19-34.

Blatt, A H, 1955. J Org Chent, 20: 591.Cecile,I L, Cruz, M I, BarlJery, G and Fripiat, II, 1981. Infrared Spectral

Study of Species Formed <XI Maladtite Sudace by Adsorption franAqueous Salicylaldoxime Sotuti<XI in J Coli I nurf Sci, 80:589-597.

OIakravorty, A, 1974. Structural OIemistry of Transition MetalC<mplexesofOximes in Coord Chem Rev, 13:1-46.

Delitsina, G B and Yas)Ukevich, S M, 1954. Flotation of die PrincipalMinerals of Copper and hat widl die Use of Collectors dlat FormC<mplex C<mpounds in Sb Nauch Tr Mask In.It. Tsvel Melall iZolola. 24: 40.

Delitsina, G B, 1956. in Sb Tr KrivorozhskGomIJ~ Ins/, 5:126.DeWiu, C C and Yon Batchelder, F, 1939. OJelate Canpounds as

Aotati<XI Reagents inJ Am Chem Soc, 61:1247.Dnymala, 1 and Laskowski, I, 1981. O1elating Canpounds as Flotation

Reagents in Physicochemical Prob/etns of Mineral Processing,13:39-64.

584 SYnv, 23.28 May 1993 XVllllnternalionaJ Mneral P~ing Congress

Page 9: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

Nagaraj. D R, 1987. The Otemistry and AWlication of Otelating orComplexing Agents in Minerals Separatioos. in Reagents in MineralTechnology (Eds: P, Somasundaran and B M, Moudgil), pp 257-334(Marcel Dekker).

Nenz, A et ai, 1964. -Hydroxy and -Acyloxy Oximes in Belg Patent635,960.

Paltrer, B R. GutieRez. B. G, Fuerslenau, M C and Aplan, F F, 1975.Mechanisms Involved in the Fl~ati(X1 of Oxides and Silicates withAniooic Collectors - Pans I and n in Trans SME-AlME, 258:257.

Peterson, H D, Fuenlenau, M C, Rickard, R S and Miller, J D, 1965.OtryS(X()11a Fl~(X1 by the Formation of Insoluble Surfa~Otelates, Trans AlME, 232:388-392

Rinelli, G and Maramni, AM, 1974. Flotation of Zinc and Wd Oxide,SuHide Ores with OIelating Agents in Proceedings of X IMPC (TheInstitution of Mining and Metallurgy:l.mtdoo).

Rjnelli, G. Marabini, A M and Alesse, V, 1976. Rocatioo of Cassiteritewith Salicylaldehyde as a Collector in Flotation. A M GaudillMemorial Vol- 1 (Ed: M C, Fuentmau), p 549 (American Instittlteof Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum Engineers).

Somasundaran, P and Nagaraj, DR, 1984. OIemistry and Applications ofChelating Agents in Rotation md Rocculation, in Reagents in theMinerai Industry (Eds: M 1, lones and R, ObIatt), pp 209.220 (nleInstitutioo of Mining and Metallurgy: {.(x}don).

Taggan, A F, TaylO1". T C and Ince, R, 1930. Experimmts with R~tiooReagents, TraIlS AIME, 87:285.

T~, E C,l.awsoo, F and Han, K N, 1982, TraItS IMM, 91:C142-C152.Usoni, L. Rinelli, G and Marabini, AM, 1971. OIelating Agent and Fuel

Oil: A New Way to Rotation in Preprint # 71-8.10, AlME Meeting,New York, February 1971.

Vivim, A C, 1927. R(J(atioo of Tm Ores in Mining Magazine, 36:348.Wu, S, 1982. Polymer llllerfaces and Adhesion (Marcel Dekker).

XVllllntemational Minefal PlOC»Ssing Congress Syctley, 23.28 May 1993 5M

Page 10: ABSTRACT - Columbia Universityps24/PDFs/Chelating Agents for... · ABSTRACT Organic canplexing agents have received special attentioo over the past ... Acetophenone Oxime) 166.2 2HSMBAO

- Sydney. 23 - 28 May 1993 XVllllntemationat Mineral P~ssing Congress