44
avement journal preservation SPRING 2014 A PUBLICATION OF FP 2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION

A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

avementjournal

preservationSPRING 2014

A P U B L I C A T I O N O F F P 2 I N C .

WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION

Page 2: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

680128_Crafco.indd 1 06/02/14 4:33 PM

Page 3: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Two in One: The WR 240i from Wirtgen makes a convincing impression when it comes to soil stabilization and cold recycling. In addition to perfect ergonomics and operation, clever automatic functions and outstanding terrain accessibility, the effi cient engine and powerful milling and mixing performance ensure optimal results. You too can benefi t from the technology leader‘s solutions.

www.wirtgenamerica.com

SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS!

WIRTGEN AMERICA . 6030 Dana Way . Antioch, TN 37013Tel.: (615) 501-0600 . www.wirtgenamerica.com

677227_Wirtgen.indd 1 27/01/14 3:16 PM

Page 4: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

4 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

contents

Pavement Preservation Journal is published for FP2 Inc. (866) 862-4587 www.fp2.org

Editor: Tom Kuennen (847) 607-8413 [email protected]

Opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and not necessarily those of FP2 Inc., its directors or staff.

Published for FP2 Inc. by

Naylor, LLC 5950 NW 1st Place Gainesville, FL 32607 (800) 369-6220 www.naylor.com

Publisher Heather Greyling

Sales Manager Adam Lingenfelter

Marketing Manager Tyler Hancock

Account Representatives Paul Walley, Diane Markey, Leron Owens

Editorial Michael Senecal

Design BK Publication Design

© 2014 Naylor, LLC. All rights reserved. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced by any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of the publisher.

PUBLISHED MARCH 2014/FPP-Q0114/9786

Spring 2014, Vol. 7, No. 1

FEATURES

9 Late Season, Long Haul Means WMA for Grand Canyon Surfacing

13 It’s Easy to Educate Legislators with Congressional Field Visits

17 NCAT Update: Benefit Curves for Pavement Preservation

21 N.H. Pavement Preservation Wins 2013 Sorenson Award

23 Report: Pavement Albedo Inadequate to Mitigate Urban Heat Island Effect

32 Under Tight Deadline, Deep Injection Process Stabilizes Missouri U.S. 65

37 Surface Retexturing, Rejuvenation Boost N.C. Interstate Performance

COLUMNS

7 President’s Message27 News Briefs

ASSOCIATIONS

31 IGGA: Illinois Execs Honored with IGGA’s Promotion Award

CENTERS

36 TPPC: Sustainable Pavement Preservation

TECHNICAL PAPER

41 Breakaway Sign Posts, Color Make for Safer Roadways

ALSO

42 Index of Advertisers

20

On the cover: Grand Canyon, North Rim: high-elevation surfacing by St. George, Utah-based Western Rock Products. Photo credit: MWV Evotherm. 26

avementjournal

preservation13

21

32

37

41

Page 5: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

FIBRECRETE CONCRETE PRESERVATION

CONCRETE PRESERVATION SOLUTIONS THAT SAVE TIME, MONEY, and HEADACHES.With installations in all areas of the United States, Fibrecrete has proven itself to be a versatile repair and preservation option. It can withstand heavy tractor trailer traffi c on high speed interstates and the heavy volume of traffi c during rush hours of the largest cities. It performs in cold wet winters and hot dry summers. Year after year, it stands alone as the solution that DOTs and municipalities can count on to repair and preserve their concrete roadways and bridge decks.Fibrecrete G is a hot applied fl exible concrete repair. It is formulated with polymer modifi ed resins, fi berglass, mineral fi llers, and high quality aggregates. The Fibre-crete repair system can repair cracks, spalls, potholes, and joints. The secret is the installation method, which calls for high quality bulking aggregates when repairs are deeper than one inch. This allows Fibrecrete to remain fl exible yet strong enough to handle heavy traffi c and the stresses of changing temperatures and seasons, not to mention snowplows!Fibrecrete G is an effective repair that can replace expensive Full Depth Concrete Repair programs. The long term affordability of this product also eliminates the need to repave to improve ride quality; allowing DOTs to shift their paving and FDCR dollars to more urgent areas. Call today for more information.

FIX IT and FORGET ITPRODUCT ADVANTAGES:LONG TERM REPAIR FOR CONCRETEFibrecrete is designed to move with concrete and will hold up in extremely heavy traffi c in all temperature ranges.

VERSATILEFibrecrete is designed to repair spalls, potholes, and large cracks on interstate highways, bridge decks, and shipping yards.

KEEPS HIGHWAY OPENFibrecrete is normally ready for Traffi c in 1 hour and even the deepest holes are ready for traffi c by the end of the typical workday.

WARRANTYFibrecrete is one of the few patching materials that provides a warranty. Its track record of longevity and performance proves that you really can fi x it and forget it.

PREP IT

BULK IT

FINISH IT

FORGET IT

Fibrecrete Technologies, LLC301 Old Highway 52 South, Mount Airy, NC 27030

Bart Pharr, VP Sales • [email protected]

1-800-930-7324 | www.maiftl.com

669085_Fibrecrete_Technologies.indd 1 14-01-02 10:52 PM

Page 6: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

The coolest thing to happen to asphalt, since the road trip.The road trips you love happen on smooth asphalt. MWV Asphalt Innovations is the global leader in the development of high-performance chemical products and technologies for the world’s paving industry. From revolutionary Evotherm® warm mix technologies to world class

superior performance to customers around the world.

Driving the future of pavingFor more information visit mwvspecialtychemicals.com

679712_MeadWestvaco.indd 1 04/02/14 6:28 PM

Page 7: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 7

Advocacy for pavement preservation, support for research, and communication of their benefits are my goals as new president of FP2 Inc.

I follow in some pretty big footsteps. I congratulate and thank my predecessor, Mike Buckingham, for his hard work on behalf of the foundation. In the last two years Mike has done a great job articulating his vision for FP2 and getting us on track. Under his leadership we tackled the research opportunity at the National Center for Asphalt Technology (NCAT) Test Track, and saw the adoption of pavement preservation as a federally funded enterprise under our existing MAP-21 surface transportation legislation.

FP2 ‘ExtrEmEly ValuablE’To me, FP2 is an extremely valuable organization. In

October FP2 stakeholders met in Dallas to revisit our strategic plan, and I think we accomplished a lot in defining our missions.

First, advocacy for pavement preservation in the halls of Congress will continue. We want to see preservation included in this year’s reauthorization of MAP-21, in addition to a greater revenue stream like higher user fees. But advocacy ultimately will be driven by the levels of funding we can elicit from the industry. That’s why we have to do a better job at selling the value of what we are doing on the advocacy side and its benefits to the industry and agencies.

Secondly, funding of pavement preservation research will continue as a major mission for your foundation. The work that Mark Ishee and Tim Harrawood have been doing as they oversee execution of preservation research at the NCAT Test Track is extremely important; see an update on the work on pp. 17-18 in this issue.

But Mike Buckingham urged us to develop a vision of what we need to do after the NCAT project. There will most likely be the opportunity to continue the research on the track and Lee Road in the next two-year cycle of testing once this cycle is completed.

But some observers have said that while it’s great getting data from Alabama in the deep South, it’s too easy for someone in the upper Midwest, or New England or the Rocky Mountains to decide the NCAT data are not applicable to them in their colder regions. We all know that, generally speaking, if something works in the south it’s going to work up north, but we still will have to regionalize the output.

PartnErshiPs and FundingThe third mission I will support in my tenure is

enhanced communication. In January we made a big commitment for 2014 to improve Pavement Preservation Journal, the magazine you now hold in your hands, and we will see the benefits of that.

But there are other ways pavement preservation stakeholders can enhance communication on a personal basis, and one is by utilizing the regional pavement preservation partnerships. I have been extremely involved in the Northeast Pavement Preservation Partnership (NEPPP) since its inception. The partnerships are administered by the National Center for Pavement Preservation and will continue to play a valuable part in the pavement preservation arena. The continued funding of the NCPP and the regional partnerships will continue to be a priority for FP2.

Lastly, I want to recommit FP2 to a higher level of funding by supporters. If we really want to get to where we want to be via more advocacy and research—such as what we are doing at NCAT—we need to continue research in other environments, and for other levels of highway service. And that can only be done through higher funding levels provided by today’s supporters and the new ones of tomorrow.

That’s the real challenge we all face, and we must be creative and think outside the box about how we can fulfill FP2’s missions. To that end, Michael O’Leary has accepted the post of chair of a Membership Committee. You’ll hear more from us—and him—in the future.

by rod birdsallPresident, FP2 Inc.

PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE

FP2 Goals for 2014: Advocacy, Research, Communication

Page 8: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

We create chemistrythat makes old roads love newasphalt.

Pavement Preservation through systematic scheduled maintenance programs utilizing Butonal® SBR polymers from BASF can help to protect and extend pavement service life, promote safer road conditions, and prevent structural failures. Whether you make products for micro surfacing, chip seals, thin-lift overlays or other eco-effi cient pavement preservation applications, BASF can help asphalt roads perform better and last longer even in the toughest conditions.

Learn more at basf.com/asphalt or call 1-800-395-5152.

657970_BASF.indd 1 10/09/13 7:11 PM

Page 9: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 9

An ultrathin bonded wearing course utilizing warm mix asphalt was the solution for late fall, long-

haul, high-elevation surfacing of roads on the North Rim of the Grand Canyon late last year.

In the late 1800s, the United States created a national park system to preserve the nation’s unique natural wonders for the current and future generations. A network of asphalt roads makes many of these locations easily accessible by automobile.

But to ensure park access, proposed locations must schedule maintenance activities during the off season, after the summer rush and before winter weather arrives. The Office of Federal Lands Highway Division requires reliable, high-performing paving operations to meet these time constraints.

To that end the National Park Service scheduled a significant maintenance effort for the Cape Royal Road area of the Grand Canyon North Rim in the autumn of 2013.

The project included upgrades to the lookout facilities and the maintenance of the primary road atop the Walhalla Plateau.

In September 2013, Western Rock Products, an Oldcastle Company based in St. George, Utah, loaded trucks with Evotherm-modified warm mix asphalt (WMA) from its portable hot plant in Fredonia, Ariz., and headed for the North Rim of the Grand Canyon. The trucks traveled over two hours to Cape Royal Road where a paving train awaited the start of the overlay project.

MW

V EV

othE

RM

Use of warm mix additive preserved workability of asphalt mix for ultrathin bonded wearing course, despite three-hour haul time to Grand Canyon North Rim, late-season paving and cool ambient conditions due to strong winds and high elevation

Late Season, Long Haul Means WMA for Grand Canyon Surfacingby brandon milar

.

Page 10: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

10 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

The NPS specified the construction of an overlay using an ultrathin bonded wearing course (UBWC). This overlay technique utilizes a spray paver, designed with an integrated emulsion spray system that in a single pass applies the emulsion directly in front of the wave of asphalt mix under the paver machine.

The UBWC combined a 0.2 gal/sq. yd. polymer-modified emulsion with a 1-in. lift of gap graded asphalt mix.

“As a subcontractor to Western Rock, we were impressed with the workability (of the WMA) and final mat on this project,” said Scott Dmytrow, marketing manager for material provider Telfer Oil Company. “We install bonded wearing courses throughout the western states and have placed hundreds of thousands of tons of bonded wearing courses over the past 13 years. The benefits of a warm mix asphalt are apparent in a thin-lift process like an ultrathin bonded wearning course. Kudos to Central Federal Lands for putting these processes together to get the best

product possible under the adverse conditions and long hauls.”

Wma KEEPs mix WorKablEMany state DOTs utilize

bonded wearing courses as a regular preservation treatment for their pavements.

“Efficient completion of this project would have been difficult without the addition of Evotherm in the HMA” said Derrick Pack, general manager for Western Rock Products. “There were concerns that late season paving at elevations over 8,000 feet with a two-to-three-hour haul—and winds that some days exceeded 40 mph—would make this job very difficult to complete in the tight paving window provided.”

Contractors typically produce BWC at temperatures up to 340 deg F and place it at temperatures near 280 deg F. These high temperatures result in a workable mix that can be properly placed.

The Evotherm additive reduces the compaction temperature of the asphalt mix to 230 deg F. This results in lower production temperatures, the

ability to undertake long hauls without losing workability due to temperature loss, and lower-temperature ambient conditions on-site.

On this project overlooking the Grand Canyon, the plant produced the mix at 310 deg F, the haul time pushed to three hours, and the field conditions included a sunny high in the 50s with strong winds. Even under these challenging conditions, the mix behind the screed measured 240 deg F and was easily compacted to a smooth surface.

Most WMA processes generally reduce the viscosity of the liquid asphalt through a variety of means, and enable the complete coating of aggregates at temperatures 35 to 100 deg F lower than conventional hot mix asphalt. WMA technologies reduce compaction challenges associated with cooled mixes or cold weather, may lower the number of rollers required at a job site, and reduce the risk of failed compaction with stiff mixtures.

Evotherm additive adds lubricity to individual microscopic asphalt particles. Development of “slip planes” allow the

665660_Editorial.indd 1 30/10/13 11:41 AM

Page 11: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 11

MW

V EV

othE

RM

MW

V EV

othE

RM

Despite falling temperatures, WMA mix stayed workable and contractor was able to attain required density

To prevent mix segregation after long haul, material transfer vehicle is used between haul truck and paver hopper

Contribute Your Technical Paper to Pavement Preservation JournalProsPEctiVE authors arE invited to present articles on original research on any topic relevant to pavement preservation, such as preservation techniques, materials, construction, testing, performance, recycling and pavement management to Pavement Preservation Journal.

Papers discussing best practices for pavement preservation treatments, including asphalt overlays, scrub and fog seals, crack sealing, chip seal, hot in-place recycling, micro surfacing, and

slurry seals, would be welcome as well.

Authors must prepare their manuscripts in accordance with the guidelines outlined by the Pavement Preservation Journal. All articles should be submitted as an e-mail attachment to Dr. Yetkin Yildirim, P.E., at [email protected].

For more information, including style guidelines, please visit the Pavement Preservation Journal’s home page at www.fp2.org.

avementjournal

preservationFALL 2013

A P U B L I C A T I O N O F F P 2 I N C .

GAO STUDIES PAVEMENT PRESERVATION

Double Chip Seals

avementjournalpreservation

WINTER 2013

A PUBL ICAT ION OF FP2 INC .

NCPP:

A DECADE AS THE

VOICE OF PAVEMENT

PRESERVATION

In-Place Recycling Workshop

asphalt particles to move more easily, requiring lower levels of energy. Because the energy is lowered, this unique warm mix has the same viscosity properties at lower temperatures as conventional hot mix asphalt.

Lower asphalt mix production temperatures translate into reductions in energy consumption. Energy reductions of 30 to 60 percent compared to conventional hot mix asphalt have been documented. Lower production temperatures and less fuel consumption mean reduced emissions at the mix plant, and later on the job site, enhancing the environmental attractiveness of the process.

building on succEssEsThe NPS Grand Canyon project

built on earlier successes with Evotherm WMA by the Office of Federal Lands Highways.

In 2011, Central Federal Lands Highway Division (CFLHD) used Evotherm technology to pave the Golden Gate Recreation Area in San Francisco, maintaining workability despite heavy fog and strong winds in the Bay area. In 2013, CFLHD also utilized Evotherm WMA when paving the Beartooth Highway, the highest elevation highway in the Northern Rockies at over 10,000 ft., where trucks take 2.5 hours to travel the 60 to 70

miles through the high-elevation mountain ranges.

By using Evotherm for Cape Royal Road, the Grand Canyon project could be properly completed before the weather turned harsh. The NPS and Western Rock were pleased with the quality of the finished surface, mix workability and ease of compaction throughout the project. Use of a WMA modifier like Evotherm was a key component to their success.

Edited by Pavement Preservation Journal. Milar is technical marketing manager, Evotherm of MeadWestvaco Corp.’s Specialty Chemicals division.

Page 12: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Chip Seal, Scrub Seal, CHFRS-2P. Sometimes things slip through the cracks. Don’t let it be the rain. Fix the surface, protect the base. The result will be a stronger, healthier road.

Mend.

Providing innovative resources that drive people forward.

ergonasphalt.com

Let me bring you up to speed at

680748_Ergon.indd 1 10/02/14 11:34 PM

Page 13: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 13

The inclusion of pavement preservation as a federally funded program in 2012’s Moving Ahead for Progress

in the 21st Century (MAP-21) surface transportation legislation was a major accomplishment for FP2 Inc. and its allies in Washington.

Through continuing contact, conversations and Hill visits, FP2 and its lobbying partner Williams & Jensen LLC were able to bring the story of pavement preservation to elected representatives and senators, successfully illustrating its many benefits.

As MAP-21 expires this Sept. 30—unlike previous “highway bills” it sunsets after only two years—FP2 is vigorously working to make sure those gains are not lost in subsequent legislation. In the meantime, FP2 and the pavement preservation industry are grappling with new interpretations of federal regulations, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA),

which may hamper application of the right treatment, to the right road, at the right time for municipal, township, county and state governments from coast-to-coast (see When Preservation Becomes Alteration, Winter 2013, p 7).

‘outsidE thE bEltWay’Obviously “inside the Beltway” is

the arena where much of this work takes place. But stakeholders outside the Beltway can have an enormous impact on the conversation by reaching out to, and inviting, federal legislators to their local business facilities—or to a job site—when legislators are home from D.C.

For example, in 2010 Western Emulsions, Inc. welcomed Rep. Harry Teague, D-N.M., to its new Roswell, N.M. plant. And in April 2011, Asphalt Recycling & Reclaiming Association member Cutler Repaving, Inc., Lawrence, Kan., welcomed its Congresswoman, Rep. Lynn Jenkins, R-Kan., to its manufacturing plant.

“All we had to do was ask, and she was more than willing to take the time during the Easter recess to stop by and learn more about our business and the environmental benefits associated with hot in-place recycling,” said John Rathbun, Cutler vice president-sales. “It is a fairly easy process of asking, through either an e-mail or a letter, and then devising a simple plan to meet them and show off your business and employees.”

And in early December 2014, freshman Rep. Susan Brooks (R-Ind.) visited the extensive laboratories and plant of Heritage Research Group and Asphalt Materials, Inc. in suburban Indianapolis.

“A year ago I began working with [FP2 president] Mike Buckingham and [FP2 executive director] Jim Moulthrop to see how we could continue our outreach efforts to legislators from the states where we have operations,” said Mark McCollough, director of business development for Asphalt Materials,

It’s Easy to Educate Legislators with Congressional Field Visitsby tom Kuennen

HO

W F

P2 W

OR

KS

FO

R Y

OU

Asphalt Materials, Inc.’s director of business development Mark McCollough escorts Rep. Susan Brooks (R-Ind.) at Heritage Research Group’s lab complex in Indianapolis

Heritage Research Group’s director of research Tony Kriech explains role of aggregates in asphalt tests to Rep. Susan Brooks during December lab tour

toM

KUE

NNEN

toM

KUE

NNEN

Page 14: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

14 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

and 2013-2015 president of the Asphalt Emulsion Manufacturers Association. “I sat down with Williams & Jensen’s Tracy Taylor and we identified members of Congress who represented our company, or the areas in which we do a lot of work. Congresswoman Brooks represents our company headquarters in Indiana.”

Hill visits are an essential part of the outreach, McCollough said. “Usually we make an appointment and sit down with their staffers who are involved in transportation, although we sometimes meet with the representative himself,” McCollough said. “What I’ve found is that they need to be educated about pavement preservation. They generally do not know exactly what it is, how pervasive it is, nor do they understand the extent to which it extends federal, state and local infrastructure dollars, or recognize the environmental benefits of pavement preservation. We need to educate them as to how pavement preservation can enhance and preserve the investments that cities, states, counties and the federal government are making. This is all the more important now that infrastructure dollars are at a premium, and resources limited.”

In addition, McCollough wants to impress the legislators as to just how high-tech pavement preservation is, and the way to do that is to get them out to Heritage’s laboratories. “Most people look at a road and don’t see it as an engineered product,” McCollough said. “It’s flat, and black; how hard can that be? But there is a lot of chemistry, physics and math that go into these engineered systems. We also incorporate a lot of recycled materials into the products. We need to make sure our legislators understand that.”

McCollough also wanted to impress on Rep. Brooks just how many workers and their families were dependent on his company for income and employment. “I think most House reps want to get out and meet their constituents,” he said. “A great way to do that is at an office or complex in which to show them around. They like that and they are very open to it. A lot of people think the process is more intimidating than it is.”

To that end, McCollough asked Williams & Jensen’s Taylor to invite Rep. Brooks to his plant. “We met with her transportation specialist in summer 2013, and asked if she would be interested in visiting, and the office confirmed,” he said. “Two to three months out is a good time frame, longer is better; they also will have a district office which will be coordinating area events and we worked with them. It’s all part of building a relationship.”

touring thE labsRep. Brooks arrived with Karen

Glaser, her district director, at 8:30 a.m. at Heritage Research Group’s facility. Heritage has an extensive laboratory complex and she was escorted throughout by Tony Kriech, director of research, who explained the lab operations in popular terms.

Following the tour she sat in a conference room and saw a PowerPoint presentation on Heritage Group and Asphalt Materials, their impact on the industry and on the local economy, and the relationship between federal legislation and what Heritage does. In a little over an hour she was on her way to the airport and back to D.C.

“The field visit is extremely important,” said Williams & Jensen’s Taylor. “It’s great having them come out, because it puts faces on an issue,” she told Pavement Preservation Journal. “They get to see the people who actually work in the industry and what is done. Specifically, legislators get to hear what pavement preservation really is. We

will speak of pavement preservation at a Capitol Hill meeting, and they get an intellectual understanding, but it really doesn’t hit home until they actually see the product being made or applied, and have the opportunity to talk to industry professionals in the field.”

The legislators like to hear about your industry, first hand from you, their constituents, Taylor said. “A picture, or experience, is worth a thousand words, particularly when dealing with a topic in which there is not as much familiarity,” she said.

The personal connection that is made between legislator and host also is a big benefit. “When they actually come out and see your place, they remember you,” Taylor said. “They will become more interested in your issue. If they have proactively taken time from their schedule to visit you, they have become invested in what you do.”

“Setting up a plant or jobsite visit, or a visit to Capitol Hill, should not intimidate you,” McCollough said. “Just do it. All representatives have a local district director. Call them and tell them you are interested. They want to talk with people in their district. Setting up a visit is fairly easy, but a lot of people assume it’s more complicated than it really is. The hardest part is making the time for it; if we have more stakeholders doing that we will have a much better chance of helping our legislators understand pavement preservation, what it’s all about, and why it needs to be supported in federal legislation.”

Jim Fehsenfeld, president of Heritage’s Construction Group, describes operations to Rep. Brooks (far right) and her district director Karen Glaser

toM

KUE

NNEN

Page 15: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

ALL STATES MATERIALS GROUP LEADS THE INDUSTRY WITH INNOVATIONS IN PAVEMENT PRESERVATION TECHNOLOGY.

WITH THE SUBSTANTIAL RESOURCES OF ASMG BEHIND THEM, OUR TECHNICIANS ARE ENGI-NEERING THE USE OF TODAY’S RESOURCES TO BUILD AND PRESERVE AN EFFICIENT, HIGH-QUALITY, SUSTAINABLE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR TOMORROW.

AND, WITH ASMG’S EXTENSIVE MANUFACTURING, STORAGE, AND DISTRIBUTION NETWORK, THESE INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS ARE DELIVERED COST- EFFECTIVELY THROUGHOUT THE NORTHEAST.

INNOVATION THROUGH LIQUID ENGINEERING

(800) 343-9620 | www.asmg.com

AHEAD OF THE CURVE

AASHTO, AMRL Accredited Laboratory

677579_AllStates.indd 1 22/01/14 10:57 AM

Page 16: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

637625_Blacklidge.indd 1 03/05/13 7:54 AM

Page 17: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 17

HO

W F

P2 W

OR

KS

FO

R Y

OU

t0

t1 t2 t3 t4

t5

Perc

ent A

rea

Cra

cked

Time / Traffic

Control Cell 1

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70 Tr

ansv

erse

Offs

et fr

om

CL

(ft)

Distance from Start of Section (ft)

At time 1 (t1) and time 2

(2)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 3 (t3)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 4 (t4)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 5 (t5)

t0

t1 t2 t3 t4

t5

Perc

ent A

rea

Cra

cked

Time / Traffic

Control Cell 1

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70 Tr

ansv

erse

Offs

et fr

om

CL

(ft)

Distance from Start of Section (ft)

At time 1 (t1) and time 2

(2)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 3 (t3)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 4 (t4)

-11

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6 60 70

At time 5 (t5)

-12.0 -10.0

-8.0 -6.0 -4.0 -2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0

10.0 12.0

0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 80.0 90.0 100.0

Tran

sver

se O

ffset

from

CL

(ft)

Distance from Start of Section (ft)

The old adage, “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” often is applied to pavement preservation.

However, it is difficult to ascertain exactly how much “cure” an agency can get for an “ounce” of pavement preservation.

The ongoing Preservation Group study by the National Center for Asphalt Technology (NCAT) is trying to do just that. By documenting the condition of 25 100-ft. pavement sections prior to treatment, and recording deterioration over time after treatment, life-extending benefit curves will be established for various preservation treatments as a function of not only time and traffic, but also pre-treatment condition.

The test road, Lee Road 159, is a two-lane, half-mile county roadway located in Lee County, Ala., which dead-ends

return to pretreatment condition. To enable complete characterization of the life extension in each section, the two-lane, 100-ft. long sections were further divided into 40 cells each measuring five by ten feet, resulting in 20 cells in each direction, as shown in Fig. 1.

dEVEloPing bEnEFit curVEsTo develop the life-extending

benefit curves, performance data (IRI, rutting, texture) are collected weekly and video images are captured at least once per month for the purpose of crack mapping. These data are collected for each of the 40 cells in a section. This is important as the 40 cells that make up a section have varying levels of pretreatment condition, as is evident by the cells in Fig. 1.

It is how these 40 cells respond collectively that will define the life-extending benefit curves. To explain the process, focus is placed on the circled cell. After treatment has been placed, the pavement condition, here defined by percent area cracked, returns to 0 percent.

As time and traffic passes, deterioration occurs until eventually the pretreatment cracking returns completely, as shown in Fig. 2. As illustrated in Fig. 3, the time it takes to return to pretreatment condition for this cell is then used as the x-component for the following plot, where the y-axis is the

into a quarry and asphalt plant. As a result, the traffic volumes are easy to track and are relatively low, albeit the truck loads are high for a county road.

For this work, Lee Road 159 has been divided into 25 sections which are 100 ft. long and two lanes wide. In the summer and fall of 2012 various pavement preservation treatments and combinations of treatments were placed, including bituminous surface treatments, crack sealing, cape seals, and thin overlays, while leaving two control sections with no treatment applied. For a complete list of treatments, readers can visit www.pavetrack.com.

In the summer of 2012, the research team collected pavement performance data on the county road to characterize roughness and surface distresses prior to placing any preservation treatments. These data will be important in developing life-extending benefit curves, as life extension is defined for this project as the time (traffic) to

NCAT Update: Benefit Curves for Pavement Preservationby mary robbins, Ph.d., buzz Powell, Ph.d., P.E., and Jason nelson

Fig. 1: Example of pre-treatment cracking of section of Lee Road 159

Fig. 2: Return to pre-treatment condition for one cell of Lee Road 159 section

NCAt

NCAt

Page 18: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

18 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

P.O. Box 25511 • Salt Lake City, UT 84125 • Phone: 801.972.2757 • Fax: 801.972.6433 • www.asphaltsystemsinc.com

634889_Asphalt.indd 1 29/03/13 12:19 PM

pretreatment condition (percent cracked in this example) and the x-axis is the time to return to pretreatment condition.

Each cell is represented by a singular data point on this plot, and when combined with the other cells in that section, a curve can be fitted to the data. By reversing the axes such that the y-axis is the time (traffic) to return to pretreatment condition and the

x-axis is the pretreatment condition (here, the percent area cracked), the life extension of the pavement due to a specified preservation treatment can be determined as a function of the pretreatment condition.

These curves will be developed specific to each preservation treatment (and section). Although Fig. 1 and the above example focus on reflective

cracking, an array of pavement condition data can serve as the basis for the life-extending benefit curve.

as timE goEs byThe experiment on Lee Road 159 is

now over a year old and as might be expected, individual cells are changing with time and traffic. In some cases, cells have returned to pretreatment condition. However, it should be kept in mind that it is necessary for all 40 cells in a section to return to pretreatment condition to fully develop the life-extending benefit curve. The expectation is that while some sections may reach this end point within the research cycle, there is the potential for others to be so robust that sections will be extended into future research cycles in order to fully return to pretreatment condition.

These figures demonstrate the general framework for developing the life-extending benefit curves. They are meant purely for the explanation of the developed framework and do not reflect conditions in any of the 25 sections. The authors are affiliated with NCAT.

Perc

ent A

rea

Cra

cked

Time / Traffic

YX

(time to return to pretreatment

condition)

0

100 Pret

reat

men

t %C

rack

ed

Time (or Traffic) to Return to Pretreatment Condition

0

10

Tim

e (T

raffi

c) to

Ret

urn

to

Pret

reat

men

t Con

ditio

n

Pretreatment Condition (%Cracked)

Life Extension = fn(Pretreatment Condition & Treatment Type)

Fig. 3: Development of life-extending benefit curve for example section

Perc

ent A

rea

Cra

cked

Time / Traffic

YX

(time to return to pretreatment

condition)

0

100 Pret

reat

men

t %C

rack

ed

Time (or Traffic) to Return to Pretreatment Condition

0

10

Tim

e (T

raffi

c) to

Ret

urn

to

Pret

reat

men

t Con

ditio

n

Pretreatment Condition (%Cracked)

Life Extension = fn(Pretreatment Condition & Treatment Type)

NCAt

Page 19: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

CALL TODAY! - (800) 395-7325

sealmaster.net

®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®

Premium Surface Coating

THE SMART CHOICE FOR PAVEMENTPRESERVATION

678054_Thorworks.indd 1 1/24/14 7:28 PM

Page 20: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

657948_Unique.indd 1 10/09/13 11:17 PM

Page 21: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 21

with industry, has done a tremendous job in applying all the treatments available to it and is establishing its own values for service life.

NHDOT also has developed Equivalent Annual Costs (EACs) for its most commonly used treatments. An EAC is easily calculated by taking the treatment cost and dividing by the average service life to obtain a cost per sq. yd. per year. The lower the EAC, the more cost effective the treatment is. In New Hampshire, preservation treatments have lower EACs than rehabilitation treatments, and also can be used to select treatments.

Clement has presented detailed performance data to the governor, executive council, legislature, and public entities to secure additional revenues for the department’s pavement and bridge preservation programs. And working in conjunction with private sector industry as a partner, NHDOT staff has developed training courses in conjunction with the University of New Hampshire LTAP center for the DOT and local agencies.

New Hampshire utilizes every pavement preservation process available, including crack sealing, conventional single and double chip

sealing, asphalt rubber chip sealing, micro surfacing, bonded wearing courses, thin HMA overlays, WMA mixes, high polymer thin overlays (HiMA), cold mix RAP, paver shim, and mill-and-fill.

July 1 nominEE dEadlinE For 2014 sorEnson aWard

Plan now to submit your nominee for the 2014 James B. Sorenson Award for Excellence in Pavement Preservation, sponsored by FP2 Inc. Deadline for the 2014 award entries is July 1, 2014.

Intended to recognize agency pavement preservation, the Sorenson award is usually, but not always, presented to city and county agencies. Criteria used to evaluate candidate agencies include: process used to gain acceptance by elected officials, general public, employees, and industry (40 percent); how well the program relates to the theme of The Right Treatment, for the Right Road, at the Right Time (20 percent); tangible improvement in the system (20 percent); techniques used to keep public notified of what is being done and why (10 percent); and uniqueness of program (10 percent).

To nominate an agency, please include a brief write-up of how the agency gained acceptance and support for its pavement preservation program; how long the program has been in existence, any special or unique public awareness actions; press releases; the contact person in the agency; and the person or firm making the nomination.

For more information, or to submit nominations, please contact FP2’s executive director, Jim Moulthrop, at 8100 West Court, Austin, Tex., 78759, voice (512) 977-1854, e-mail at [email protected].

The New Hampshire Department of Transportation has been honored with the 2013 James B. Sorenson Award

for Excellence in Pavement Preservation from FP2 Inc. The award was presented to NHDOT Commissioner Chris Clement during the Northeastern State Materials Engineers’ Conference in Portsmouth, N.H. Oct. 22-23, 2013 and the Midwestern Pavement Preservation Partnership meeting in Indianapolis Nov. 11-12.

Intended to recognize agency pavement preservation, the Sorenson award is usually, but not always, presented to city and county agencies. New Hampshire joins California and Tennessee as the only state DOT winners.

“The future for state DOTs lies in maintaining and preserving their existing transportation infrastructure and networks,” Clement said the Nov. 12 ceremony in Indianapolis. “Pavements are the largest asset value in some states. That’s why it makes sound financial sense to properly maintain and preserve that asset to maximize its useful life.”

Its pavement preservation program has been embraced and promoted by Commissioner Clement and the entire department. Many articles and presentations have been published about their successes and ongoing search for data and new technologies. The NHDOT even has spotlighted its pavement preservation program to obtain additional funding from the legislature.

Its Pavement Management Group, led by Eric Thibodeau, has done an outstanding job with data collection, programming and treatment selection to fulfill pavement preservation’s mantra of The Right Treatment, for the Right Road, at the Right Time. The department, working

N.H. Pavement Preservation Wins 2013 Sorenson Award by tom Kuennen

At Indianapolis October MWPPP meeting with FP2 Inc.’s James Sorenson Award for Pavement Preservation are, from left, NHDOT Commissioner Chris Clement; FP2 executive director Jim Moulthrop; and Eric Thibodeau, chief, pavement management for NHDOT

HO

W F

P2 W

OR

KS

FO

R Y

OU

Page 22: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

543356_Paramount.indd 1 10/11/11 11:38:22 AM

Page 23: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 23

A new research survey from Arizona State University highlights concerns with overreliance on pavement

albedo—its potential to reflect light and heat—to mitigate the urban heat island effect.

The heat island refers to an urban area’s propensity to have consistently higher temperatures than surrounding areas due to its greater retention of heat via buildings and infrastructure made of concrete and asphalt.

A column in a recent issue of this magazine suggested high-reflectance pavements made of portland cement concrete may help remediate the urban heat island effect (see High-Albedo Pavements May Have Environmental Benefits, Fall 2013, p 30). High-albedo pavements tend to be of portland cement concrete, at least early in their life cycle before they age and begin to lose their high albedo.

Addressing the urban heat island effect (UHI) is a growing concern for many municipalities, but a new report from ASU calls into question many common assumptions about the ability of reflective pavements to mitigate UHI, reports the report’s sponsor, the National Asphalt Pavement Association.

Reflective surfaces redirect solar energy and for this reason high-albedo, reflective, or “cool” roofs have been suggested as an important tool for UHI mitigation. However, efforts to apply the same principle to pavements overlook the complexities of urban geography and how ground-level reflections interact with pedestrians, vehicles and the built environment.

The report, Unintended Consequences: A Research Synthesis Examining the Use of Reflective Pavements to Mitigate the

Urban Heat Island Effect, surveys a wide range of recently published research into what happens to the energy redirected by reflective pavements.

“Unfortunately, efforts to promote reflective pavements have moved more quickly than the scientific and engineering research,” said Heather Dylla, Ph.D., director of sustainable engineering for NAPA. “As this report indicates, reflective pavements may cool a pavement’s surface, but there can also be negative environmental and social impacts on the areas adjacent to the pavement.

“We cannot assume that reflective pavements will behave the same as reflective roofs,” Dylla said. “When energy is reflected from a ground surface, it doesn’t return directly to the sky. It reflects back at buildings and pedestrians. Heat concentration in urban areas is a multifaceted problem; it requires a solution that looks at more than just one mitigation strategy.”

synthEsis oF rEsEarchThe ASU report, authored by

Jiachuan Yang, Zhihua Wang, Ph.D.,

and Kamil E. Kaloush, Ph.D., P.E., of the ASU National Center of Excellence for SMART Innovations, pulls together research from around the world, including previously unpublished data from the team’s field research, that demonstrates the limits and side effects of relying upon reflectivity to reduce UHI.

“The urban heat island effect, the phenomenon of higher temperatures in urban areas compared to surrounding rural areas, has resulted in scientific, legislative, health, and municipal efforts to mitigate this storage of heat within the built environment,” the report says. “One UHI mitigation strategy that has gained popularity focuses on retrofitting urban surfaces with high-albedo or reflective construction materials, including reflective pavements. Despite perceived benefits, this review demonstrates substantial unintended consequences associated with widespread implementation of reflective pavements, including the potential for increased cooling loads in adjacent buildings; increased heating demands during cold weather; roadway snow and ice buildup during winter months; reduction in precipitation, runoff, and soil water content; and adverse human health impacts.”

Reflective materials do have an effect, the report says. “High-albedo or highly reflective materials can reduce the temperature of urban surfaces like roofs and pavements by reflecting solar radiation away from these surfaces,” according to the report’s executive summary. “Although the reduction in surface temperature of high-albedo roofs has been documented to reduce summertime building cooling energy requirements, no similar effect has

Report: Pavement Albedo Inadequate to Mitigate Urban Heat Island Effect

Page 24: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

24 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

ToToo see project profiles aannd moreeee iiiinnnnfffffoorrrmmmmaaaaaaattttttiiiiiooonnnn vvvviiiiiiiisssssiiiiitttttttt:::::::TTT

wwwwwwwwww.roadsciencee.nneet////AAAAADDDDDDhhhhhhhheeeerrrrrreeeeeeeewww

Road Science® delivers the most comprehensive product suite with our AD-here® Class360 additives. This all-in-one

additive product class has the chemistry technology for any process or mix: foamed, warm, hot - while providing industry leading support - a full “360” system.

Road Science TM

Division of ArrMaz

You Have Better Asphalt Additive Options:

Or call us at 1-877-354-1851

677281_Road.indd 1 22/01/14 1:44 AM

been documented with regards to high-albedo pavements.”

Well-publicized simulations by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and others infer that hundreds of billions of dollars in savings due to reduced cooling energy demands can be realized through the deployment of reflective pavements. “A review of these simulations, however, identifies the use of unrealistic assumptions, and the findings have not been confirmed by other modeling efforts or field studies,” the authors state.

no EFFEct on air tEmPs“On the contrary, a number of

field studies and modeling efforts have found that while there can be an effect on surface temperature, there is no discernible difference in above-surface air temperature over sizeable pavements with differing albedos,” they maintain.

“Furthermore, these studies find that reflected radiation from high-albedo pavements can increase the temperature of nearby walls and

buildings, increasing the cooling load of the surrounding built environment and increasing the heat discomfort of pedestrians,” the authors write. “Harmful reflected UV radiation and glare, unintended consequences of reflective pavements, need special consideration for human health. The results presented in this review cast doubt on the idea that large-scale deployment of reflective pavements will achieve overall energy savings. Without further detailed investigation, specification and deployment of highly reflective pavements to mitigate UHI are premature due to the unintended

and adverse consequences associated with the redirected solar radiation.”

Given the growing body of evidence of unintended consequences associated with reflective pavements and the potential negative impact they may have on energy usage, NAPA urges developers of green construction codes to eliminate any provisions that offer credits for UHI mitigation based solely upon a pavement’s reflectivity.

A copy of the report can be downloaded from the ASU National Center for SMART Innovations website at http://ncesmart.asu.edu/news/unintended-consequences.

Fig. 1. Schematic of surface heat budgets in a built environment (USEPA, 2008). Note that in particular the solar (short-wave) radiation experiences multiple reflections between adjacent urban facets, which results in the so-called ‘radiative trapping’ phenomenon in urban areas

AdAP

tEd

fRo

M Y

ANG,

WAN

G AN

d K

Alo

USh

Page 25: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Pavement Texturing for Skid Resistance

Uniform Consistent Surface

Works on all Pavements

Markings Can Be Left Intact

Retexturing Possible

Reduces Groove Steering

Eliminates Road Glare

Bond Enhancer

Restores OGFC

30 Years Experience in USA & Canada

1-800-342-4174www.skidabrader.com

668845_Skidabrader.indd 1 2/6/14 4:49 AM

Page 26: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

26 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

© 2011 Calumet Specialty Products Partners, L.P. All rights reserved.© 2013 Calumet Specialty Products Partners, L.P. All rights reserved.

“Ready-to-Use” No Time Consuming or Confusing Dilution Necessary Environmentally Friendly - No Measurable PAH’s (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons) Economical and Improved Stability No Measurable VOC’s (Volatile Organic Compounds)

Fast Drying Eliminates Tracking Stops Slippage and Delaminating with Superior Bonding Strength Minimizes Equipment Clean up Time Better Density With Less Compaction Effort

What Do You Expect?

TRACKLESS TACK = THE RIGHT CHOICETRACKLESS TACKTypical Application

www.calumetasphalts.com(318) 218-2352

663212_Calumet.indd 1 31/10/13 12:17 PM

596432_Strawser.indd 1 7/16/12 5:38:59 PM

Page 27: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 27

NeWS BRIeFS >>

E. D. Etnyre & Co. www.etnyre.com

800-995-2116 email: [email protected]

Asphalt Transports

Heavy Duty Trailers

ChipSpreaders

Asphalt Distributors

Live Bottom Trailers

560114_ED.indd 1 11/8/11 5:33:37 AM

Birdsall Takes Helm of FP2 Inc.

rod birdsall, P.E. is the new president of FP2 Inc. for a two-year term. He succeeds Mike Buckingham, principal of Buckingham Consulting, LLC.

Birdsall is a consultant to All States Materials Group, Sunderland, Mass., and was graduated from Purdue University with a degree in Civil Engineering. He is a licensed professional engineer in the State of New York.

He has served on FP2’s board of directors, is a member of TRB Committee AHD 20—Pavement Maintenance, a friend of TRB Committee AHD 18—Pavement Preservation, a friend of the FHWA Pavement Preservation ETG, friend of the Asphalt Emulsion Task Group, and industry co-chair of the Northeast Pavement Preservation Partnership.

He has over 40 years’ experience in asphalt and highway materials and construction including technical, engineering, operations, marketing, market development and upper management.

He currently works with All States Materials Group as a consultant for technical marketing, materials and product development. He has done many presentations on asphalt materials and their uses including asphalt rubber mixes, stress-absorbing membranes (SAMs) and stress absorbing membrane interlayers (SAMIs) and their performance, pavement preservation and field applications of asphalt materials.

In addition, he’s a life member of the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) and the Association of Asphalt Pavement Technologists (AAPT).

Birdsall provides his vision for FP2 for 2014 in his President’s Message in this issue; read it on p 7.

At FP2 board of directors meeting held in January in conjunction with the Transportation Research Board meeting in Washington, D.C., new president Rod Birdsall, P.E., left, presents immediate past president Mike Buckingham with a plaque commemorating his service to FP2

Page 28: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

28 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

NeWS BRIeFS >>

Two New Preservation Checklists from FHWAtWo nEW Publications from FHWA provide guidance on using in-place recycling techniques.

Hot In-Place Asphalt Recycling Application Checklist (Pub. No. FHWA-HIF-13-061) examines the three main processes that make up hot in-place asphalt recycling: surface recycling, remixing, and repaving. These three processes are combined with the placement of an overlay of new hot-mix asphalt to reconstruct a pavement. To download, visit www.fhwa.dot.gov/pavement/pub_details.cfm?id=356 or www.pavementpreservation.org/fhwa-resources/fhwa-preservation-brochures/.

Full Depth Reclamation Construction Checklist (Pub. No. FHWA-HIF-13-036) offers a handy field guide to using full-depth reclamation (FDR) as an alternative to traditional pavement reconstruction. FDR consists of pulverizing and mixing in place distressed asphalt materials and the underlying pavement materials. Stabilizing agents such as cement, lime, or asphalt may also be added. The resulting material is used as a base for the new pavement. To download, visit www.fhwa.dot.gov/pavement/pub_details.cfm?id=896.

Topics covered in both checklists include preliminary project tasks such as document review and materials checks, preconstruction inspection responsibilities, weather requirements, mix design, traffic control, and responsibilities for project inspection. Also included are common problems and solutions. For more information on the checklists, or for hard copies, contact Lee Gallivan at FHWA, (317) 226-7493, e-mail [email protected].

Microsurfacing Contractors Participated in Recycling DemomicrosurFacing contractors, llc, of St. Louis, provided micro surfacing at the Midwestern States Regional In-Place Recycling Conference held in suburban Chicago Sept. 10-12 (see ARRA, FHWA Sponsor In-Place Recycling Workshop and Demo, Winter 2013, pp 30-31).

The firm was omitted from the copy, and images of a Bergkamp machine and crew should have been identified as belonging to Microsurfacing Contractors. We apologize for the omission and thank Microsurfacing Contractors’ president Tom Ritschel for bringing our omission to our attention, and for its long-time support of Pavement Preservation Journal. You may visit their web site at http://www.micro-surfacing.com.

Microsurfacing Contractors LLC provided micro surfacing for September In-Place Recycling Workshop near O’Hare International Airport

Page 29: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 29

1200 E. Main, Towanda, KS 67144Ph: 316.536.2262 • Fax: 316.536.2789

[email protected]

SERVICES AVAILABLE:

> Surface Recycling> Milled Rumble Strips> Cold Milling

OFFICE LOCATIONSTowanda, KS316.536.2262

Roanoke, TX817.430.3958

El Paso, TX915.849.8773

Pueblo, CO719.583.0905

Lincoln, NE402.466.1184

428693_Dustrol.indd 1 6/3/09 7:19:47 PM

NeWS BRIeFS >>

NCHRP Studies Preservation Performance Specsa nEW national Cooperative Highway Research Program project—NCHRP 10-82A, Performance-Related Specifications for Pavement Preservation Treatments—in April marked its RFP deadline and was moving to launch Aug. 1.

The $400,000 study would take place in two phases over 24 months, and Amir N. Hanna is the staff contact.

Quality assurance specifications that specify end product quality have often been used by transportation agencies as a means for assuring construction quality of highway pavements. However, agencies are increasingly incorporating performance-related specifications (PRS) in construction contracts to specify quality in terms of parameters related to desired long-term performance. These PRS also provide a means to account for the value lost or gained by the variances of these parameters from the specified target values. Although such PRS have been used for the construction of pavements, their use for pavement preservation treatments has been limited.

There are no widely accepted guidelines for PRS for pavement preservation treatments that correlate key engineering properties to treatment quality and long-term performance. Research is needed to develop guidelines to facilitate developing PRS for pavement preservation treatments that provide a direct relationship of key material and construction characteristics to performance. These guidelines will help highway agencies develop and incorporate PRS in preservation treatment contracts. In this manner, agencies would be able to specify an optimum level of quality that represents the best balance of costs and performance, and establish quality-related pay adjustment factors if desired.

The objective of this research is to develop guidelines for use in preparing PRS for pavement preservation treatments. The research shall deal with preservation treatments for all pavement types. For the purpose of this research, preservation treatments are treatments applied to preserve an existing roadway, slow future deterioration, and maintain and improve its functional condition (without substantially increasing structural capacity).

For more information contact Hanna at (202) 334-1432, [email protected].

Thank you to our loyal advertisers; they help make this publication possible.

Page 30: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

30 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

FP2’s Time Out at TRBthE yEar in transportation begins at the annual Transportation Research Board meeting, held in Washington, D.C. in January. Nearly 10,000 stakeholders in all transportation modes came to this year’s meeting, and each year FP2 Inc. takes the opportunity to host members of the pavement preservation community who come to TRB. Among the luminaries who visited FP2’s hospitality suite are, clockwise from upper left, Myles McKemie, Ergon, and John Barton, deputy executive director, Texas DOT; Codrin Daranga and Paul Morris, Paragon Technical Services, and Mrs. Daranga; John D. O’Doherty, P.E., National Center for Pavement Preservation, and Mark Buncher, The Asphalt Institute; Jenna Michael and Mike O’Leary, MWV Specialty Chemicals, Lisa Templeton, TRIP, and Andrew Crow, MWV; Jim Moulthrop, FP2 Inc., and Tracy Taylor, Williams & Jensen LLC; Mike Buckingham, Buckingham Consulting, and Larry Galehouse and Patte Hahn, National Center for Pavement Preservation; Mark Ishee, Ergon, Mike Krissoff, ARRA-AEMA-ISSA, and Rex Eberley, Bergkamp. Photos by Tom Kuennen.

NeWS BRIeFS >>

527637_Cutler.indd 1 6/17/11 3:45:09 PM

Page 31: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 31

The International Grooving & Grinding Association honored two Illinois concrete executives with is 2013

Concrete Pavement Restoration (CPR) Promoter of the Year Award.

The award was presented to Randell Riley, P.e., and Jimie Wheeler of the Illinois Chapter of the American Concrete Pavement Association (ACPA). The award recognizes an individual or company for exemplary efforts towards promoting diamond grooving, grinding and CPR.

The Illinois Chapter of the ACPA was recognized with the award for its extensive efforts to further the use of CPR methods such as dowel bar retrofit, diamond grinding, and joint resealing to improve the performance and extend the life of the heavily traveled concrete pavements in Illinois.

Riley is executive director, Illinois Chapter of the ACPA, whose involvement with IGGA members provides an ongoing partnership and resource to help solve customer problems.

IGGA is the leading promotional and technical resource for acceptance of diamond grinding and grooving as well as pavement preservation and restoration. Its annual awards banquet was held in Puerto Rico in December, and its purpose is to honor individuals and companies/organizations for lasting contributions made to the grooving, grinding and concrete pavement preservation/restoration industry.

“In the past year, we have worked with the IGGA on several occasions to further our CPR efforts with the Cook County Highway Department and the Lake County Highway Department in the northern part of the state,” Riley said. “In addition, we have worked on two successful DBR projects, successful

due in large part to the excellent work of contractors such as IGGA and Illinois ACPA member, Quality Saw & Seal.”

oPErator oF thE yEarThe Operator of the Year (“Iron Man”)

Award was presented to Maynard Michels, concrete grinder operator for Diamond Surface, Inc. (DSI) of Rogers, Minn. The purpose of this award is to recognize the men and women who work in the field for their leadership with special emphasis on his or her dedication to quality and getting the job done right.

Michels has worked in the industry since the 1980s, where he started as a water truck and slurry hauler. He soon became a grinder operator and joined DSI in 1989, where he was the second employee to be hired by the firm and their first grinder operator. In his role with DSI, he has held the foreman position for mainline grinding crews, where he is responsible for specialty grinding of bridge decks, and other high profile projects that require a greater degree of skill to complete. He also helps with the training of journeymen operators.

The Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT), Fort Worth District, received the 2013 Government

Official of the Year Award for its innovative use of diamond grinding on I-35. The use of diamond grinding on this heavily traveled highway helped extend the pavement life and improve the overall driving experience. The award recognizes leadership in transportation engineering and innovation with special emphasis on grooving, grinding and CPR.

nEW dirEctors For 2014New directors were elected by IGGA

for 2014. They are• President:Jake Steinberg of

Construction Materials (St. Louis Park, Minn.)

• VicePresident:Terrence Kraemer of Diamond Surface (Rogers, Minn.)

• Secretary:Chris Priest of Multiquip Equipment / Sanders Blades (Quinton, Va.)

• Treasurer:Scott eilken of Quality Saw & Seal (Bridgeview, Ill.)

• PastPresident:Tom Bonness, Jr. of C.P.R., Inc. (Elkhorn, Wis.)

• Director:Jerry Voigt of American Concrete Pavement Association (Rosemont, Ill.)

• InternationalDirector:Jason Seovic of Seovic Civil Engineering (Narellan, New South Wales, Australia)

Illinois Execs Honored with IGGA’s Promotion Award

ASS

OC

IAT

ION

S

Texas DOT Fort Worth District’s Brian Barth, P.E., district engineer, left, accepts Government Official of the Year Award from the IGGA’s Dan Frentress

Page 32: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

32 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

Just weeks before Memorial Day 2011, the Missouri Department of Transportation, District 2, was faced with a roadway which

began to rapidly deteriorate under traffic loads. With little time to spare in advance of the holiday weekend, an innovative process involving deep injection of expansive, high density polymer material into the highway’s sub-base was used to quickly and economically stabilize the highway’s base and sub-base.

U.S. Highway 65 is a two-lane asphalt highway with gravel shoulders. This area of Missouri is mostly farm land, amid rolling prairie and small stream crossings. Near the intersection of U.S. 65 and State Road WW—about 70 miles east of Kansas City—MoDOT had begun a project to lower the crest of a troublesome hill by 5 ft. in order to enhance driver visibility. To expedite the repair, MoDOT had completely closed this roadway section and detoured all traffic.

On Wednesday, May 18, an empty 18-wheeler had caused wide cracks in the exposed base course of the road. Later the same day a MoDOT coring rig created a 2-in. rut in the base as it backed away from the coring spot. The base course material was 10 to 12 in. of reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) mixed into crushed stone. The sub-base soil was comprised of “in-situ” materials taken from a nearby hillside cut.

MoDOT project personnel surmised that the problem was likely this composite subgrade material. The localized area of concern for stabilization of the sub-base was a 541 ft. long X 24 ft. wide section totaling 12,984 sq. ft. where the vehicle transit damage had occurred.

Under Tight Deadline, Deep Injection Process Stabilizes Missouri U.S. 65

On U.S. 65, grid pattern provides guidance during UDI injection process

MoDOT completed falling weight deflectometer (FWD) testing while Uretek finished DCP testing on the problem area of concern

Page 33: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 33

Time constraints and budget concerns would not allow total removal and replacement of the sub-base.

MoDOT contacted one of its specialty highway repair contractors, Uretek USA, Inc., for a review of the problem. Following on-site meetings, Uretek’s stabilization proposal was approved on Friday, May 20. MoDOT needed to open the road before the upcoming Memorial Day weekend, allowing a project time line of only 10 days from proposal to completion. The project’s goal was to effectively stabilize the soils underlying this asphalt roadway using the Uretek Deep Injection (UDI) polymer injection system. Uretek dispatched a crew and began the project testing and subsequent work within 48 hours.

What is PolymEr inJEction?The proprietary UDI process used

on U.S. 65 is a patented technique for stabilizing weak or poorly compacted foundation soils by injecting an expansive high-density polyurethane through holes drilled in the pavement directly into the targeted soils. Additional lifting of the soil structure and overlying pavement is often included in the project scope.

The UDI process is a chemical compaction grouting technique which uses a unique low viscosity polymer to void-fill, infiltrate, and strengthen certain weak soils. The high expansive force results when the two components of the specially formulated polymer react and create a large volume increase.

This patented polymer product is formulated to resist the intrusion of strata water or moisture which would otherwise compromise the structural characteristics of the injection material.

The polymer is placed via direct drilled holes (or injection tubes) which allows the polymer to be “surgically” placed in the strata where stabilization is needed. An injection grid (typically 4 to 5 ft. on centers) provides full coverage of the area being stabilized.

Movement is always monitored at the surface during the injection process. The very first surface movement indicates that the soil matrix has been stabilized around that injection point. If stabilization is the desired goal, injections at that location point cease. Additional pavement lifting is often accomplished by further polymer injections into the soils.

The first step is site assessment, including collection of available geotechnical information, execution of dynamic cone penetrometer (DCP) tests, examination of the structure for load-related distresses, and determination of design, current usage and projected future loading.

A treatment plan then is formulated, including engineering review of the geotechnical information and DCP test data to fully identify those areas of weak and/or poorly compacted soil strata. The data is analyzed and an

On U.S. 65, substantial cracking indicated base failures below MoDOT coring rig created a 2-in. rut in the base as it backed away from the coring spot

Results from the post-injection FWD testing indicated the designed treatment was effective in stabilizing the targeted soil matrix

Page 34: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

34 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

Fight the stress of low budgets andhigh needs — Use Thinlays.

Thinlay asphalt overlays are theultimate for pavement preservation.When a road starts to get rough, there’s one low-cost solutionthat’s good for the long run: Thinlay thin asphalt overlays.Studies have proven that thin overlays are both fast

long service life and low life-cycle costs. Roadusers immediately get a smoother, quieter ride —and they'll be able to enjoy those benefits formany years.

NAPA’s technical publication Thin Asphalt Overlaysfor Pavement Preservation (IS-135) will tell you allyou need to know about Thinlays. Order online atwww.asphaltpavement.org/thinisin

ad

r

and economical to construct while still delivering a

672585_National.indd 1 18/12/13 4:06 PM

injection pattern, often with multiple depths of injection, is then designed.

In the case of U.S. 65, the aggregate base composite mixed with coarse sand required an injection system to fill voids, strengthen and to bind the soil matrix.

Lower percentages of smaller particles in these soils permit greater infiltration into the layer prior to expansion. These soils benefit from the dual events of polymer infiltration (binding) and polymer expansion (compacting). The injection process is

repeated until the surface movement is detected indicating that the soil is now stable and the expansive force is constrained in all directions except up.

The UDI process is often applied to a variety of different soil categories such as saturated fine sands, layers comprised of silts and clay-size particles, and even soft, organic soils.

a Plan For u.s. 65MoDOT and Uretek engineers

designed a project plan for rapid, efficient, and cost-effective remediation

if the U.S. 65 problem. MoDOT completed falling weight deflectometer (FWD) testing while Uretek finished DCP testing on the problem area of concern.

Part of the area received a 3 ft. X 3ft. grid of injection to a depth of 3 ft. But in relatively better areas, a pattern of 4 ft. X 4 ft. to a depth of 4 ft. was specified. Despite severe weather problems (a nearby tornado), Uretek began the actual injection process on the Tuesday before Memorial Day. The crew worked in 12-hour shifts to speed the process of stabilization. Their work was completed in just two days, well ahead of schedule.

MoDOT designed and implemented a geo-grid system topped with 3.75 in. of hot mix asphalt to overlay the base course stabilized areas in order to provide an open highway prior to the holiday weekend. The road’s wear course was applied the following week.

Following stabilization, MoDOT conducted FWD testing throughout the project to evaluate the effectiveness of the UDI process. Results from the post-injection FWD testing indicated the designed treatment was effective in stabilizing the targeted soil matrix.

John O, Donahue, P.E., MoDOT’s construction and materials liaison engineer, provided detailed analysis of all FWD data collected pre- and post-project completion. His analysis showed the average increase in sub-grade modulus after deep injection was 60 percent.

The average decrease in maximum deflection after UDI was 35 percent. The UDI process produced an increase in base soils stiffness which should result in the pavement system being capable of supporting the original design loads. Donahue reported that the geo-grid system would also assure surface ride quality along with providing extended pavement life.

The Uretek UDI Deep Injection process and 486 Star water resistant polymer are protected by U.S. patents. The Federal Highway Administration now allows sole-source products and services for federally funded projects. Fifteen states have now used UDI for federally funded pavement stabilization projects.

Page 35: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 35

www.IntermountainSlurrySeal.com

UTAH - IDAHO - MONTANA - WYOMING - COLORADO - NEW MEXICO - ARIZONA - CALIFORNIA - OREGON - WASHINGTON - TEXAS - NEVADA

668843_Intermountain.indd 1 12/20/13 10:30 PM

Reclamite. Goes down pink. Keeps you in the black.

Sure it’s pink at first. That’s because this is not an asphalted emulsion. Reclamite restores the components of asphalt and the end result is a treated road that no longer exhibits the oxidizing signs of aging. In the early years of your preservation program Reclamite extends your lifecycle before the costlier scrub, wear course and slurry seals are required.

Let the Bear place a pink paw on your roads. The color fades fast but the result has a 50 year proven history. Call us today to find out more.

®

Contact: Jim Brownridge661.393.7110 extension 107Tricor Refining, LLC Producers of Golden Bear Preservation Productsreclamite.com/reclamite.htm

566502_TRICOR.indd 1 12/21/11 6:04:16 PM

Page 36: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

36 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

Sustainable Pavement Preservationby yetkin yildirim, P.E.

rubber, asphalt shingles, steel slag and foundry sand are all common in pavement maintenance. All of these methods contribute to a reduction of material needs in pavement construction and maintenance, as reusing these materials for projects results in a shrinking reliance on unsustainable material production.

What’s more, the engineering characteristics of pavement materials are not sacrificed for sustainability. For example, in addition to being sustainable, use of tire rubber asphalt allows for deeper embedment, better aggregate retention, and makes the design more forgiving while also extending a pavement’s life cycle.

In addition to the methods and advantages above, warm-mix asphalt (WMA) has also gained popularity as a sustainable pavement maintenance alternative. WMA is on the rise as a result of reduced temperature reducing fuel consumption (upwards to 40 percent savings), significant decreases in emissions, reduced exposure of workers to fumes, and the allowance of cold weather paving.

The benefits of sustainability go beyond environmental concerns. Pavement preservation practices also reduce project costs, and they also solve common issues associated with a lack of availability of high quality aggregate, shrinking landfill space, and rising waste-material disposal costs.

With sustainable practices standing also as the most cost-efficient approach to roadway maintenance, there can be little argument against the assertion that preservation projects stand as the most effective, efficient and sustainable approach to maintaining our country’s extensive road network.

Yildirim is director, Texas Pavement Preservation Center

Sustainability is defined as meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of

future generations to meet their own needs. Recently, The Texas Pavement Preservation Center presented several papers related to sustainability and pavement preservation at the 17th World Meeting and Exhibition of International Road Federation and the 6th National Asphalt Symposium and Exhibition of Turkey.

These papers address the relationship between sustainability and pavement preservation. Sustainability can be summarized in three words: reduce, recycle and reuse. Pavement preservation treatments provide the highway industry with the means of satisfying these criteria while maintaining an extensive network of roadways.

In the long term, because preservation extends pavement life, we reduce the pavement materials used by applying pavement preservation. It’s assumed that the general public would not support any strategy other than the “worst-first” approach, which first addresses pavements that are in the poorest condition. As a result, there are many hurdles to promoting pavement preservation to the public and industry officials in times of limited funding.

There are a number of sustainable practices and applications that are available to the highway industry. Pavements including reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP), recycled concrete aggregate (RCA) and in-place recycling all are examples of projects utilizing recycling practices.

Reuse of materials is also common. Reuse of fly ash, tire

Ce

NT

eR

S

THE ONE STOP SHOPFOR ALL YOUR ASPHALT NEEDS

VISIT OUR WEB SITE AT:WWW.ASPHALT-MATERIALS.COM

Preservation Construction Specialty Applications

Asphalt Materials, Inc.MATERIALS & SUPPLY

EMULSICOAT,INC.

518609_Asphalt.indd 1 4/18/11 9:39:45 PM

Page 37: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 37

hydroplaning, and correction of in-place asphalt binder rheology for durability and lifecycle extension.

The specific requirements were a significant increase to surface friction following rejuvenator application to NC DOT requirement, as measured by friction testing equipment conforming to ASTM E 274 and ASTM E524, macro texture adjustment verified by outflow meter reading of 10 seconds or less (ASTM E2380 / E2380M-09), and maltene

The initial problem identified by Division 3 of the North Carolina Department of Transportation for a section of

I-40 near Wilmington was twofold: This pavement was about nine years old and exhibited both surface raveling and lower surface friction. The division’s monitoring of wet weather accidents indicated a need to review options for improvement.

The obvious remedy would be to mill and replace the open graded friction course, except for one drawback: lack of funds for that magnitude of intervention.

Albert Edgerton, Division 3 project engineer, recalled a process, that of surface retexturing coupled with asphalt binder rejuvenation using a maltene-based asphalt rejuvenator. This process was developed by two firms: Pavement Technology, Inc. of Westlake, Ohio, and Skidabrader, of Reston, La. Both firms have been in business for more than 35 years, working primarily in pavement restoration and preservation.

Several meetings with Edgerton; Colin Durante, president of Pavement

Technology; and the late Gary Billiard, president of Skidabrader, resulted in Division 3’s development of a new performance-based specification for the unique combination process.

PErFormancE sPEciFicationThe new specification addressed the

needed improvements to the pavement, being surface friction increase for safety, macro texture adjustment for improved transverse water flow to reduce

Surface Retexturing, Rejuvenation Boost N.C. Interstate Performance

On I-40 near Wilmington, N.C., Reclamite maltene rejuvenator is applied with a Bear Cat computer-controlled 2,500 gal distributor truck

Working in tandem the two Skidabrader units, each with an effective width of six feet, covered an entire lane width in a single pass

Directly behind the surface texturing procedure macro texture evaluation at three tests per lane mile were performed using the specified outflow meters

PAVE

MEN

t tE

ChNo

loGY

, INC

.

Page 38: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

38 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

• Micro-Surfacing • Capeseal • Slurry Seal • Crackseal

States • Counties • Cities

Of ces: Illinois & MissouriPh: 800-747-3686

www.Micro-surfacing.com

Pavement Preservation is What We Do

637204_MicroSurfacing.indd 1 18/04/13 1:36 PM

ratio improvement with viscosity reduction of a minimum of 20 percent in the asphalt binder as measured by dynamic shear rheometer (AASHTO T 316) on extracted binder samples two weeks following treatment. The two-week delay in asphalt binder extraction was necessary to insure a product of high volatility was not used as a rejuvenator.

The successful bidder—Pavement Technology—selected equipment provided by Skidabrader and a maltene-based rejuvenator, Reclamite, supplied by D & D Emulsions, Inc of Mansfield, Ohio, a licensed manufacturer of the product by Tricor Refiners, Bakersfield, Calif.

Actual construction began in late June of 2012 with standard lane

closure on I-40, set up to maintain one lane of traffic flow at all times. The train operation began by first testing surface friction on the pavement prior to beginning the process. The friction testing was provided by Dynatest, headquartered in Ventura, Calif., using a 1295 Locked Wheel Pavement Friction Tester conforming to ASTM E274. Tests were run at 40 mph under wet condition using a ribbed tire.

Friction EnhancEmEnt Via abrasion

Following the initial friction tests two Skidabrader units directed abrasive media at the pavement surface. Working in tandem the two units, each with an effective width of 6 ft., covered an entire lane width in a single pass. The texturing process controlled the forward progress of the entire project, operating at a production rate of one lane mile per hour. Directly behind the surface texturing procedure macro texture evaluation at three tests per lane mile were performed using the specified outflow meters.

Following surface abrasion, the Dynatest equipment again measured and recorded surface friction to verify the performance requirement of the specifications. Immediately after the second friction testing the Reclamite maltene rejuvenator was applied with a Bear Cat computer controlled 2,500 gal distributor truck.

The selected rate of application of the rejuvenator, following field test

337507_Cleveland.indd 1 2/5/08 12:04:42 PM

Page 39: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 39384457_Pavement.indd 1 5/28/08 8:36:54 AM

MATERIALS AND PAVEMENT SPECIALISTS

International Business DevelopmentTechnology Transfer Experts

Call: [email protected]

www.pavementpreservationsystems.com

678118_Pavement.indd 1 1/29/14 1:11 PM

strip applications, was 0.06 gallons per square yard. After the rejuvenator was given time to be fully absorbed by the textured pavement surface, a period of about 30 minutes, the Dynatest equipment again measured surface friction for verification that the pavement was ready to accept traffic. In all cases the treated sections were open to traffic within 30 minutes.

The entire process was performed in daylight hours with no measurable disruption to normal traffic flow. This process can be performed at night should traffic volume make that type operation necessary. The process on I-40 was completed in four days at a cost of $2.00 per square yard, which included all testing during and post construction.

documEnting usEr saFEtyThe evaluation of user safety,

although not part of the performance specification, is a significant indicator of the overall value of this project.

The regular collection of crash data by the Safety Evaluation Group of the NC DOT revealed some significant and welcome information. The I-40 nine-month monitoring update indicates a 51 to 84 percent reduction in total crashes per year, and a 39 to 78 percent reduction in “lane departure wet” crashes per year as compared to pre-project data.

These improvements to safety can be attributed to the friction upgrade to

the pavement surface, with additional credit afforded to the macro texture adjustment and the overall removal of foreign materials that affect the porosity of the open graded friction course matrix. This later improvement was provided by the high-efficiency vacuum system on the Skidabrader units removing nine years of deleterious materials from the open graded matrix. The safety data will continue to be monitored in the future to determine the long term performance of this technique.

The need for pavement managers to find new ways to extend the life cycle of infrastructure elements entrusted to their care is ever increasing in importance. As available funds for our nation’s roadway and bridge system preservation continue to be reduced, processes like the retexturing and rejuvenating combination system can help remedy the shortfall. When user safety can also be improved in the process the benefit to cost ratio becomes even more valuable to the professional pavement manager.

Page 40: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

40 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

RECLAIM.REUSE.RECYCLE.

REMARKABLE.

RECLAIM.REUSE.RECYCLE.

REMARKABLE.Cold In-Place Asphalt Recycling

Full Depth ReclamationSoil Stabilization

Crack SealingMicro-surfacing

Ultra Thin Hot Mix

E. J. BRENEMAN, LPCORPORATE

1117 Snyder Road, West Lawn, PA 19609 • P 610-678-1913 • F 610-678-9691FLORIDA

3748 Copeland Drive, Zephyrhills, FL 33542 • P 813-377-1157 • F [email protected][email protected] • www.ejbreneman.com

462688_EJBreneman.indd 1 1/15/10 6:15:46 PM

The Asphalt Preservation Specialists!

More Roads Than Budget?More Roads

Than Budget?

Our Solution:GSB-88

Get More Info: (800) 747-8567 geeasphalt.com/pp

Applications of GSB-88 once every 5 yrs. can: Double the life of pavements Reduce overall maintenance costs

631975_Gee.indd 1 16/03/13 10:38 AM

Benedict Slurry Seal Dayton, OH 45403 • [email protected]

Ph.: 937-298-6647 • Fax: 937-254-2991www.benedictslurry.com

BASIC MANUALCOHESION TESTER

WET TRACKABRASION TESTER

LOADED WHEELTESTER

388779_Benedict.indd 1 7/24/08 10:44:55 AM

Fast, Accurate and ConsistentApplication of Soil

Stabilization Materials

Site Drying

FDR

Road Beds

Runways

Drill Pads

Access Roads

Haul Roads

Street Rehab

Pneumatic fi ll or top load · Trailer or truck models · Standard or custom sizes

Learn more at our website.

Spreader ControlCenter

800-843-8731www.stoltzmfg.com

636484_Stoltz.indd 1 10/04/13 12:20 AM

Page 41: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

Spring 2014

pavement preservation journal 41

such as the post support have become the standard for many states, and thousands of lives have been saved.

Global interest in breakaways is increasing. In Israel, highway safety support structures have been used for over 20 years. Dozens if not hundreds of accidents have been witnessed with no fatalities or serious bodily harm injuries reported on light poles using omni- directional breakaways. New Zealand, Australia and Canada have begun to use omni-directional breakaways and there is increasing global interest in this technology.

Research suggests 70 percent of one-vehicle fatalities involves cars leaving the roadway and either overturning, or colliding with fixed objects. Breakaways for ground mounted signs and luminaries can significantly decrease the severity of these accidents and resulting fatalities.

One of the key issues to ensuring greater safety in transport is to identify and treat hazardous locations and objects. By using omni-directional breakaway supports that are designed

Breakaway Sign Posts, Color Make for Safer Roadwaysby arthur m. dinitz

Countries throughout the world are seeking ways to increase safety and compliance with traffic laws

on roads and highways, reducing the number of fatal or serious injury crashes into roadside signs and streetlights, improving traffic flow and pedestrian safety with traffic calming methods and clearly defined preferential lanes, and areas that have proved to increase visibility and reduce unauthorized use. This all boosts safety especially in cities with high traffic flow.

In the United States, the history of “breakaway” posts for signs and street lighting goes back a half-century. In the 1960s, roadside hazards were identified as a major cause of fatalities and serious injuries. It became evident that if the obstacle could not be removed it should be made breakaway; or if it could not be made breakaway, it should be protected.

Sign supports usually are located immediately adjacent to roadways, and are subject to impact by errant vehicles and must yield or breakaway if struck. Since the 1970s in the United States, omni-directional breakaway couplings

to break away quickly and cleanly upon impact, with consistent, predictable behavior, regardless of the vehicle’s angle of impact, reduced property damage and saving lives will result.

More and more people are using bicycles as a means to travel around urban areas. Along with this increase in bicycle use the close proximity of bicycles and vehicles has caused engineers and planners to reconsider the safety of both types of users.

Colored pavements can isolate bike lanes as well as inform riders of bus route locations, while alerting motor vehicle operators of the special -use lane. In cities around the world bus lane violations are being reduced with color pavement overlays.

In the USA over 4,000 people are struck by motor vehicles each year. and many cities have been dedicating their resources to reducing this figure. Choosing the proper material will result in durable, cost-effective solutions.

Dinitz is chairman and CEO, Transpo Industries, Inc.

Pavement Management SystemPAVERTM

Created by the Army Corp of Engineers, PAVERTM software program uses inspection data and the PCI index for consistently describing a pavement’s condition and predicting maintenance and repair needs many years into the future.

Government and private users benefi t from training and support provided by Colorado State University including one year free

technical support. Check our web site for CSU’s next PAVERTM training session.

Order in the next 30 days and receive a 10% discount when you refer to code PPJ10.

www.paver.colostate.edu

635702_Colorado.indd 1 06/04/13 3:05 PM

Color pavement lanes provide unambiguous guidance for users, resulting in safer roadways

Page 42: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

42 View past issues of the Pavement Preservation Journal online at www.naylornetwork.com/fpp-nxt

Index of Advertisers

• High-performance asphalt additives for highways, streets, airports and parking lots

• Unique polymers to extend highway life by up to 58 percent

• Complete technical support

• Customized solutions

• Chip Seal or Surface Treatment

• Micro Surfacing

• Slurry Seal

• Polymer Modified Hot Mix Asphalt

• ULTRACOTE (polymeric aggregate treatment)

INNOVATIONS FOR QUALITY

PERFORMANCE

ultrapave.com

673208_Ultrapave.indd 1 09/01/14 12:18 PM

ASPHALT All States Asphalt, Inc. / dBA All States Material Group ..........15 www.asmg.com Calumet Specialty Products Partners, lP ......................................26 www.calumetasphalts.com National Asphalt Pavement Association .......................34 www.asphaltpavement.org/thinisin Paramount Petroleum ..........................22 www.paramountasphalt.com

ASPHALT ADDITIVES & MODIFIERS BASf Corporation...................................8 www.basf.com/asphalt Calumet Specialty Products Partners, lP ......................................26 www.calumetasphalts.com Road Science llC ................................24 www.roadscience.net/Adhere Ultrapave Corporation ..........................42 www.ultrapave.com

ASPHALT DISTRIBUTORS E d Etnyre & Company .........................27 www.etnyre.com

ASPHALT EMULSIONS OR EMULSIFYING AGENTS Blacklidge Emulsions, Inc. ...................16 www.blacklidgeemulsions.com Calumet Specialty Products Partners, lP ......................................26 www.calumetasphalts.com Cleveland Asphalt Products .................38 Ergon Asphalt & Emulsions, Inc. ..........12 www.ErgonAsphalt.com/etac Gee Asphalt ..........................................40 www.geeasphalt.com/pp MeadWestvaco ......................................6 www.mwvspecialtychemicals.com tRICoR Refining, llC ..........................35 www.reclamite.com/reclamite.htm Western Emulsions...outside Back Cover www.preventpotholes.com

ASPHALT EQUIPMENT & SUPPLIES thorworks ............................................19 www.sealmaster.net

ASPHALT PRODUCTS McAsphalt Industries limited......................Inside Back Cover www.mcasphalt.com

COMPUTER HARDWARE & SOFTWARE Colorado State University.....................41 www.paver.colostate.edu

CONSULTING SERVICES Pavement Preservation Systems, llC ....................................39 www.pavementpreservationsystems.com

EMULSIONS Crafco, Inc. ..................Inside front Cover www.crafco.com

HOT-IN-PLACE RECYCLING dustrol, Inc. ..........................................29 www.dustrol.com

LAYDOWN CONTRACTORS MicroSurfacing Contractors llC .........38 www.micro-surfacing.com Strawser Construction Inc. ..................26 www.strawserconstruction.com

MAINTENANCE & REPAIR SERVICES Skidabrader ..........................................25 www.skidabrader.com

PAVEMENT MAINTENANCE PRODUCTS Unique Paving Materials ......................20 www.uniquepavingmaterials.com

PAVEMENT PRESERVATION Asphalt Materials, Inc. .........................36 www.asphalt-materials.com Asphalt Systems, Inc............................18 www.asphaltsystemsinc.com E.J. Breneman lP.................................40 www.ejbreneman.com fibrecrete technologies, llC .................5 www.maiftl.com Intermountain Slurry Seal, Inc. ............35 www.intermountainslurryseal.com Pavement technology, Inc. ..................39 www.pavetechinc.com tRICoR Refining, llC ..........................35 www.reclamite.com/reclamite.htm

RECYCLING EQUIPMENT Wirtgen America ....................................3 www.wirtgenamerica.com

REPAVING Cutler Repaving, Inc. ............................30 www.cutlerrepaving.com

SOIL STABILIZING EQUIPMENT Stoltz Mfg .............................................40 www.stoltzmfg.com

SPREADERS – STONE, SAND & CHIP E d Etnyre & Company .........................27 www.etnyre.com

TANKS – BULK STORAGE/TRANSPORT E d Etnyre & Company .........................27 www.etnyre.com

TESTING EQUIPMENT, MATERIALS & MEASUREMENT Benedict Slurry Seal, Inc. .....................40 www.benedictslurry.com

Page 43: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

For over 40 years McAsphalt has simply been ‘Customer Driven’. Working hard to understand your business

and your challenges - to be your trusted partner and advisor in today’s volatile global markets. Our people are driven by your goals and business objectives. Our customers not only count on us for quality products but also for education and training, transportation logistics, technical support and engineering services. Your demand and needs drive McAsphalt!

Drive your future… with a true partner!

McAsphalt Industries Limited 8800 Sheppard Ave. East, Toronto, ON, Canada M1B 5R4

T: 416-281-8181 • F: 416-281-8842 • Toll Free: 1-800-268-4238 • www.mcasphalt.com

634521_McAsphalt.indd 1 26/03/13 5:41 PM

Page 44: A PUBLICATION OF FP INC. preservationexpresswaysonline.com/press/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/PVT-PRES-JOURN... · A PUBLICATION OF FP2 INC. WMA PAVEMENT PRESERVATION. Mastic One and

P R O T E C TUse PASS Rejuvenating Seals toextend the service life of roads ingood condition, or Texture Seals

to preserve while maintainingroadway skid numbers.

R E S U R F A C EUse PASS Scrub Seals on light to moderately distressed roadsto add a fresh wearing course,

and rapidly seal and anneal surface cracks and keep them

from coming back.

R E C Y C L EUse PASS R in Recycling

and Cold Paving applications to rehabilitate severely

distressed roads.

MAKE YOUR DOLLARS GO FOR MILES

Asphalt emulsions have been used in roadway maintenance for over a century. In the past two decades, the industry has produced a variety of innovations to make emulsions more stable, user friendly, and environmentally safe.

Polymer modification of the asphalt is one such advance, giving the product increased ductility and toughness. The invention of PASS emulsions in the 1980’s was another significant advance. PASS was the first product to combine a premium latex polymer with a rejuvenator to create a tough yet flexible emulsion that seals cracking and helps restore the properties of asphalt that disappear with age and effects of extreme weather.

Only PASS emulsions offer an engineered solution for greater longevity of each treatment and a wider range of Pavement Management Strategies to allow agencies to stretch their maintenance dollars. Independent research shows PASS products last longer and work more effectively to preserve roadways.

Visit www.preventpotholes.com for technical details and videos on Pavement Preservation, Resurfacing and Recycling applications.Call toll free for consultation (888) 705-4137

w w w . p r e v e n t p o t h o l e s . c o m PASS is a registered trademark of Western Emulsions Inc. ©2013

PR

ESERVE RESURFACE R

ECY

CL

E

PREV

ENTPOTHOLES

636848_Western.indd 1 15/04/13 5:29 PM