1
tel | 1.866.448.4864 tel | +44.121.260.6142 e | [email protected] © 2015 DiscoveRx Corporation. All Rights Reserved. 20514 121615 A Novel Quantitative Biochemical and Cellular Target Engagement Assay Platform for Drug Discovery Abstract It is well established that ligand binding protects proteins from thermal denaturation; however, the broad application of this concept to drug discovery has been hindered by a lack of simple platforms with sensitive and quantitative readouts. Current denaturation-based approaches, including Thermal Shift Assays (TSA) and Cellular Thermal Shift Assays (CETSA), are proven valuable technologies for particular applications, including family-wide selectivity profil- ing and cellular target engagement, respectively. However, each method has limitations. For example CETSA is a cumbersome low-throughput method and TSA lacks quantitative power. It is important that denaturation-based methods continue to evolve, as they are generic across target classes, can be applied to both biochemical and cellular target engagement, and can circumvent problematic requirements of other common biochemical target engagement formats, including the need for antibodies, immobilized capture ligands, purified proteins, and fluorescent labels. Here we describe HitHunter ® Pulse, which capitalizes on two novel DiscoveRx technologies, Enzyme Fragment Complementation (EFC) and Pulse Denaturation, to overcome limitations of current denaturation- based methods. We have successfully applied HitHunter Pulse in both biochemical and cellular settings to rapidly measure quantitative and accurate target engagement potency values for inhibitors of diverse protein classes, including kinases and pseudokinases, bromodomains, methyltransferases, and hydro- lases. These data and results demonstrating that HitHunter Pulse can be applied to elucidate inhibitor mechanism of action shall be described. Pulse Target Engagement Platform Simple quantitative measurement of ligand-protein interactions in both cellular and biochemical milieus for diverse targets. Quantitative denaturation-based ligand binding assays • Measure quantitative cellular and biochemical inhibitor target-engagement potencies • Quantitative biochemical alternative to TSA; facile cellular alternative to CETSA • Simple one-step readout: no wash, centrifugation, or immunoassay steps • No protein purification, fluorescent tags, antibodies, or capture ligands • Exploits DiscoveRx’s proprietary EFC and Pulse technologies Biochemical and cellular assays validated for diverse targets • Kinases, hydrolases, methyltransferases, bromodomains • Accurate potency rank order for known inhibitors Applications • Potency rank ordering during lead optimization; HTS hit validation • Cellular target engagement potency – do compounds enter cell and engage target? • Ideal for targets difficult to assay in cellular milieu • High throughput cellular and biochemical screens – development in progress Split β-galactosidase Enzyme System Underpins Pulse Technology Enzyme Fragment Complementation (EFC) + ProLabel™ (PL) ProLabel tagged native protein Enzyme Acceptor (EA) Inactive Fragments Active Enzyme EA Substrate Light ProLabel (PL) is a dual-purpose peptide tag ideally suited for Pulse • PL tag (~40 aa) allows for sensitive detection of properly folded “native” target protein (fM) • PL tag senses folded state of protein: denatured/aggregated proteins poorly complement EA resulting in reduced luminescence Pulse: How It Works Biochemical target engagement Cellular target engagement EA No Ligand Binding Ligand Binding Pulse Denaturation Protein Aggregate Substrate Light Ligand Protein Target PL No Ligand Binding Ligand Binding Pulse Denaturation Protein Aggregate Substrate Stable Ligand-Protein Complex Light Ligand PL Tagged Protein Target EA Ligand binding protects protein from thermal denaturation and increases EFC in a dose-dependent manner for the measurement of inhibitor EC 50 values • Similar protocols for live cells and extracted proteins • PL-tagged target protein expressed in transiently transfected cells – Cell extract prepared and treated with compound for biochemical studies – Live cells treated directly with compound for cellular target engagement studies • Compound-treated cells or extracted protein subjected to Pulse Denaturation in thermocycler – Gentle Pulse Denaturation protocol does not compromise cell viability or membrane integrity • For live cells EFC is performed in conjunction with cell lysis post-Pulse Denaturation • Gentle lysis conditions do not refold denatured/aggregated proteins • Proprietary Pulse Denaturation step improves assay metrics, including assay window and EC 50 accuracy relative to single step denaturation protocols Pulse: Rapid and Simple Protocol Add compounds & DMSO control to PCR plate Add PL-tagged target protein or live cells expressing PL-tagged protein Incubate Perform Pulse Denaturation Add EFC working detection solution Incubate for 30 min. at room temperature Read chemiluminescent signal Overcoming Key Limitations of Denaturation-based Methods EFC overcomes key limitations of existing denaturation-based methods for biochemical and cellular target engagement Process bottlenecks • No sample processing required (e.g. centrifugation or immunoassay) • No protein purification required Quantitative power and simplicity of readout • Superior to immunoassay or TSA • Sensitive, precise, simple, and quantitative with broad dynamic range Pulse denaturation improves EC 50 accuracy EC 50 values right shift during aggressive denaturation protocols • Reduced denaturation times and temperatures improve EC 50 accuracy • Pulse denaturation addresses this challenge Pulse Assay Status HitHunter Pulse • 10 validated assays covering 5 target classes • 8 assay ready kits covering 5 target classes InCELL Pulse • 5 validated assays covering 4 target classes Target Target Class HitHunter Pulse Assay Status InCELL Pulse Assay Status BRD4(1) Bromodomain CREBBP EP300 ABL1 Kinase ABL1(T315I) BUB1 BRAF MLKL Pseudokinase G9a Methyltransferase MTH1 Hydrolase Assay ready kits Validated assay In progress Not determined Pulse Validation HitHunter Pulse InCELL Pulse BRD4(1) bromodomain 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Assay Signal (norm.) [Inhibitor], nM JQ1 Bromosporine SGC-CBP30 Biochemical target engagement assay Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) JQ1 220 Bromosporine 700 SGC-CBP30 3,000 Robust assay window (4.1); JQ1 EC 50 in agree- ment with published ITC K D value (50 nM) Diverse BRD4(1) inhibitors give expected potency rank order 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Assay Signal (RLU x 10 6 ) [JQ1], nM Cellular target engagement assay Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) JQ1 390 Robust assay window (3.5); good agreement with published cellular IC 50 from c-Myc expres- sion assay (100 nM) ABL1 tyrosine kinase 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 10 -2 10 -1 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Assay Signal (norm.) [Inhibitor], nM Biochemical target engagement assay Dasatinib: EC 50 = 0.57 nM Nilotinib: EC 50 = 0.81 nM Ponatinib: EC 50 = 1.3 nM Imatinib: EC 50 = 6.1 nM VX-680: EC 50 = 48 nM Staurosporine: EC 50 = 320 nM SU-14813: EC 50 = 650 nM Purvalanol B: EC 50 = 3400 nM Robust assay window (3.2) Diverse ABL1 inhibitors including both approved drugs and tool compounds give expected potency and rank order Companion ABL1(T315I) resis- tance mutant assay shows selective sensitivity to Pona- tinib as expected (data not shown) 500 400 300 200 10 -1 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Assay Signal (RLU x 10 3 ) [Inhibitor], nM Cellular target engagement assay Dasatinib VX-680 Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) Dasatinib 2.8 VX-680 570 Robust assay windows (4-5 fold) Good agreement with published dasatinib cellular potency data (IC 50 = 1 nM) MTH1 hydrolase 600 500 400 300 200 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 10 5 Assay Signal (RLU x 10 3 ) [SCH 51344], nM TH588 (S)-Crizotinib SCH 51344 Biochemical target engagement assay Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) Published IC 50 (nM) TH588 93 15 (S)-Crizotinib 2,600 70 SCH 51344 3,000 50 Robust assay windows (~4-fold) Diverse inhibitors give correct potency rank order TH588 EC 50 offset from published value only 6-fold; larger offsets for other two inhibitors 750 700 650 600 550 500 400 Assay Signal (RLU x 10 3 ) [SCH 51344], nM Cellular target engagement assay 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) Published IC 50 (nM) SCH 51344 370 < 20,000 Simple solution for target difficult to query in cells Published SCH 51344 cellular IC 50 < 20 µM Optimized assay window >3-fold G9a methyltransferase 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 Assay Signal (norm.) [UNC0638], nM Published UNC0638 biochemical IC 50 = 10 nM Biochemical target engagement assay 10 0 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 Plus SAM Minus SAM Inhibitor EC 50 (nM) UNCO638 (+SAM) 22 UNCO638 (-SAM) 480 Cooperative binding of UNC0638 and SAM cofactor reveals uncompetitive inhibition mechanism Robust assay window (3.5) and accurate inhibitor potency data 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 1.0 1 10 100 1000 Assay Signal (RLU x 10 6 ) [UNC0638], nM Published UNC0638 cellular IC 50 = 80 nM Cellular target engagement assay EC 50 (nM) Assay Window Inhibitor UNCO638 13 5.0 Robust assay window and good agreement with published UNC0638 cell potency data Much simpler solution than measuring cellular histone methylation levels Summary HitHunter Pulse Pulse InCELL Pulse Biochemical target engagement Cellular target engagement Technology Novel biochemical and cellular ligand binding assay platform • Improves upon and complements existing denaturation-based methods including TSA and CETSA • Simple, quantitative method with minimal reagent requirements • Proof of concept demonstrated for five diverse target classes • Serves major unmet need for cellular target engagement assays Applications • Biochemical and cellular target affinities to support lead optimization • HTS hit validation and proof of cellular target engagement • Inhibitor mechanism of action • Biochemical and cellular HTS applications in development • Applications for integral membrane proteins in development Elena Menichelli, Pietro Ciceri, Alex Lun, Mark Floyd, and Daniel K. Treiber DiscoveRx Corporation, Fremont, CA 94538 HitHunter Pulse InCELL Pulse Daniel K. Treiber and Elena Menichelli are the co-inventors on a pending patent application covering aspects of the Pulse method, to be assigned to DiscoveRx Corporation.

A Novel Quantitative Biochemical and Cellular Target ......SU-14813: EC 50 = 650 nM Purvalanol B: EC 50 = 3400 nM • Robust assay window (3.2) • Diverse ABL1 inhibitors including

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • tel | 1.866.448.4864 tel | +44.121.260.6142 e | [email protected] © 2015 DiscoveRx Corporation. All Rights Reserved. 20514 121615

    A Novel Quantitative Biochemical and Cellular Target Engagement Assay Platform for Drug Discovery

    Abstract

    It is well established that ligand binding protects proteins from thermal denaturation; however, the broad application of this concept to drug discovery has been hindered by a lack of simple platforms with sensitive and quantitative readouts. Current denaturation-based approaches, including Thermal Shift Assays (TSA) and Cellular Thermal Shift Assays (CETSA), are proven valuable technologies for particular applications, including family-wide selectivity profil-ing and cellular target engagement, respectively. However, each method has limitations. For example CETSA is a cumbersome low-throughput method and TSA lacks quantitative power. It is important that denaturation-based methods continue to evolve, as they are generic across target classes, can be applied to both biochemical and cellular target engagement, and can circumvent problematic requirements of other common biochemical target engagement formats, including the need for antibodies, immobilized capture ligands, purified proteins, and fluorescent labels. Here we describe HitHunter® Pulse, which capitalizes on two novel DiscoveRx technologies, Enzyme Fragment Complementation (EFC) and Pulse Denaturation, to overcome limitations of current denaturation- based methods. We have successfully applied HitHunter Pulse in both biochemical and cellular settings to rapidly measure quantitative and accurate target engagement potency values for inhibitors of diverse protein classes, including kinases and pseudokinases, bromodomains, methyltransferases, and hydro-lases. These data and results demonstrating that HitHunter Pulse can be applied to elucidate inhibitor mechanism of action shall be described.

    Pulse Target Engagement Platform

    Simple quantitative measurement of ligand-protein interactions in both cellular and biochemical milieus for diverse targets.

    Quantitative denaturation-based ligand binding assays

    • Measure quantitative cellular and biochemical inhibitor target-engagementpotencies

    • Quantitative biochemical alternative to TSA; facile cellular alternative toCETSA

    • Simple one-step readout: no wash, centrifugation, or immunoassay steps

    • No protein purification, fluorescent tags, antibodies, or capture ligands

    • Exploits DiscoveRx’s proprietary EFC and Pulse technologies

    Biochemical and cellular assays validated for diverse targets

    • Kinases, hydrolases, methyltransferases, bromodomains

    • Accurate potency rank order for known inhibitors

    Applications

    • Potency rank ordering during lead optimization; HTS hit validation

    • Cellular target engagement potency – do compounds enter cell and engagetarget?

    • Ideal for targets difficult to assay in cellular milieu

    • High throughput cellular and biochemical screens – development in progress

    Split β-galactosidase Enzyme System Underpins Pulse Technology

    Enzyme Fragment Complementation (EFC)

    ++

    ProLabel™ (PL) ProLabel tagged native protein Enzyme Acceptor (EA)

    Inactive Fragments Active Enzyme

    EA

    Substrate

    Light

    ProLabel (PL) is a dual-purpose peptide tag ideally suited for Pulse

    • PL tag (~40 aa) allows for sensitive detection of properly folded “native” target protein (fM)

    • PL tag senses folded state of protein: denatured/aggregated proteins poorly complement EA resulting in reduced luminescence

    Pulse: How It Works

    Biochemical target engagement Cellular target engagement

    EA

    No LigandBinding

    LigandBinding

    Pulse Denaturation

    Protein Aggregate

    Substrate

    Light

    Ligand

    Protein Target

    PLNo Ligand

    Binding

    LigandBinding

    Pulse Denaturation

    Protein Aggregate

    Substrate

    Stable Ligand-Protein Complex

    Light

    LigandPL TaggedProtein Target

    EA

    Ligand binding protects protein from thermal denaturation and increases EFC in a dose-dependent manner for the measurement of inhibitor EC50 values

    • Similar protocols for live cells and extracted proteins

    • PL-tagged target protein expressed in transiently transfected cells

    – Cell extract prepared and treated with compound for biochemical studies

    – Live cells treated directly with compound for cellular target engagement studies

    • Compound-treated cells or extracted protein subjected to Pulse Denaturationin thermocycler

    – Gentle Pulse Denaturation protocol does not compromise cell viability or membrane integrity

    • For live cells EFC is performed in conjunction with cell lysis post-PulseDenaturation

    • Gentle lysis conditions do not refold denatured/aggregated proteins

    • Proprietary Pulse Denaturation step improves assay metrics, including assaywindow and EC50 accuracy relative to single step denaturation protocols

    Pulse: Rapid and Simple Protocol

    Add compounds & DMSO control to

    PCR plate

    Add PL-tagged target protein or

    live cells expressing PL-tagged protein

    Incubate Perform PulseDenaturation

    Add EFC workingdetection solution

    Incubate for 30 min.at room temperature

    Read chemiluminescent signal

    Overcoming Key Limitations of Denaturation-based Methods

    EFC overcomes key limitations of existing denaturation-based methods for biochemical and cellular target engagement

    Process bottlenecks

    • No sample processing required (e.g. centrifugation or immunoassay)

    • No protein purification required

    Quantitative power and simplicity of readout

    • Superior to immunoassay or TSA

    • Sensitive, precise, simple, and quantitative with broad dynamic range

    Pulse denaturation improves EC50 accuracy

    EC50 values right shift during aggressive denaturation protocols

    • Reduced denaturation times and temperatures improve EC50 accuracy

    • Pulse denaturation addresses this challenge

    Pulse Assay Status

    HitHunter Pulse

    • 10 validated assays covering 5 target classes

    • 8 assay ready kits covering 5 target classes

    InCELL Pulse

    • 5 validated assays covering 4 target classes

    Target Target Class HitHunter Pulse Assay Status InCELL Pulse Assay StatusBRD4(1)

    Bromodomain

    CREBBP EP300 ABL1

    Kinase

    ABL1(T315I) BUB1 BRAF MLKL Pseudokinase G9a Methyltransferase MTH1 Hydrolase

    Assay ready kits Validated assay In progress Not determined

    Pulse Validation

    HitHunter Pulse InCELL Pulse

    BRD4(1) bromodomain

    1.0

    0.8

    0.6

    0.4

    0.2

    0.0

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (no

    rm.)

    [Inhibitor], nM

    JQ1BromosporineSGC-CBP30

    Biochemical target engagement assay

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM)JQ1 220Bromosporine 700SGC-CBP30 3,000

    • Robust assay window (4.1); JQ1 EC50 in agree-ment with published ITC KD value (50 nM)

    • Diverse BRD4(1) inhibitors give expectedpotency rank order

    3.0

    2.5

    2.0

    1.5

    1.0

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (R

    LU x

    106

    )

    [JQ1], nM

    Cellular target engagement assay

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM)JQ1 390

    • Robust assay window (3.5); good agreementwith published cellular IC50 from c-Myc expres-sion assay (100 nM)

    ABL1 tyrosine kinase

    1.0

    0.8

    0.6

    0.4

    0.2

    0.0

    10-2

    10-1

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (no

    rm.)

    [Inhibitor], nM

    Biochemical target engagement assay

    Dasatinib: EC50 = 0.57 nM Nilotinib: EC50 = 0.81 nM Ponatinib: EC50 = 1.3 nM Imatinib: EC50 = 6.1 nM VX-680: EC50 = 48 nM Staurosporine: EC50 = 320 nM SU-14813: EC50 = 650 nM Purvalanol B: EC50 = 3400 nM

    • Robust assay window (3.2)• Diverse ABL1 inhibitors

    including both approved drugsand tool compounds giveexpected potency and rankorder

    • Companion ABL1(T315I) resis-tance mutant assay showsselective sensitivity to Pona-tinib as expected (data notshown)

    500

    400

    300

    200

    10-1

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (R

    LU x

    103

    )

    [Inhibitor], nM

    Cellular target engagement assay

    DasatinibVX-680

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM)Dasatinib 2.8VX-680 570

    • Robust assay windows (4-5 fold)• Good agreement with published dasatinib

    cellular potency data (IC50 = 1 nM)

    MTH1 hydrolase

    600

    500

    400

    300

    200

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    105

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (R

    LU x

    103

    )

    [SCH 51344], nM

    TH588(S)-CrizotinibSCH 51344

    Biochemical target engagement assay

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM) Published IC50 (nM)TH588 93 15(S)-Crizotinib 2,600 70SCH 51344 3,000 50

    • Robust assay windows (~4-fold)• Diverse inhibitors give correct potency rank order• TH588 EC50 offset from published value only

    6-fold; larger offsets for other two inhibitors

    750

    700

    650

    600

    550

    500

    400

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (R

    LU x

    103

    )

    [SCH 51344], nM

    Cellular target engagement assay

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM) Published IC50 (nM)SCH 51344 370 < 20,000

    • Simple solution for target difficult to query in cells• Published SCH 51344 cellular IC50 < 20 µM• Optimized assay window >3-fold

    G9a methyltransferase

    1.0

    0.8

    0.6

    0.4

    0.2

    0.0

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (no

    rm.)

    [UNC0638], nMPublished UNC0638 biochemical IC50 = 10 nM

    Biochemical target engagement assay

    100

    101

    102

    103

    104

    Plus SAMMinus SAM

    Inhibitor EC50 (nM)UNCO638 (+SAM) 22

    UNCO638 (-SAM) 480

    • Cooperative binding of UNC0638 and SAMcofactor reveals uncompetitive inhibitionmechanism

    • Robust assay window (3.5) and accurate inhibitorpotency data

    1.8

    1.6

    1.4

    1.2

    1.0

    0.8

    0.6

    0.4

    1.0 1 10 100 1000

    Ass

    ay S

    igna

    l (R

    LU x

    106

    )

    [UNC0638], nMPublished UNC0638 cellular IC50 = 80 nM

    Cellular target engagement assay

    EC50 (nM) Assay WindowInhibitor UNCO638 13 5.0

    • Robust assay window and good agreement withpublished UNC0638 cell potency data

    • Much simpler solution than measuring cellularhistone methylation levels

    Summary

    HitHunter Pulse Pulse InCELL PulseBiochemical target engagement Cellular target engagementTechnology

    Novel biochemical and cellular ligand binding assay platform

    • Improves upon and complements existing denaturation-based methodsincluding TSA and CETSA

    • Simple, quantitative method with minimal reagent requirements

    • Proof of concept demonstrated for five diverse target classes

    • Serves major unmet need for cellular target engagement assays

    Applications

    • Biochemical and cellular target affinities to support lead optimization

    • HTS hit validation and proof of cellular target engagement

    • Inhibitor mechanism of action

    • Biochemical and cellular HTS applications in development

    • Applications for integral membrane proteins in development

    Elena Menichelli, Pietro Ciceri, Alex Lun, Mark Floyd, and Daniel K. Treiber

    DiscoveRx Corporation, Fremont, CA 94538

    HitHunter Pulse InCELL Pulse

    Daniel K. Treiber and Elena Menichelli are the co-inventors on a pending patent application covering aspects of the Pulse method, to be assigned to DiscoveRx Corporation.