2016 Foreign Direct Investment International

Arbitration Moot Hosted at Universidad de Buenos Aires

Case Committee Each year's FDI Moot Case Committee begins its work the preceding June. Liaising with the FDI Moot's Board and Organisers, it develops a fact scenario and procedural background. Generally, the case evolves on the basis that the home and host State are parties to an IIA (BIT, MIT, etc), the New York Convention of 1958 and the Washington (ICSID) Convention of 1965.Generally, each year's case will involve one or two "procedural" issues (e.g. jurisdiction, admissibility, interim measures, disqualification of arbitrator) and one or two "substantive" issues (e.g. expropriation, denial of justice, discriminatory treatment, violation of fair and equitable treatment and/or full protection and security standards). The Case Committee submits its final draft to the FDI Moot Organisers and Board for approval at the end of the preceding year, and the case is then published in February each year. The Case Committee remains responsible for responding to any requests for clarification (if scheduled) between June and August of each year.

The 2016 case arises out of a (contested) territorial change and consequent sanctions (“restrictive measures” or “counter measures”) against an investor (in the weapons production sector). The investor’s links to this territory may result in a change of nationality and the applicable BIT (and its investment definition and MFN clause). The situation is compounded by allegations of corruption by the investor with potential relevance to the clean hands principle.

Bench Brief Committee Each year's FDI Moot Bench Brief Committee begins its work in March. It analyses the fact scenario and procedural background of the case and may submit confidential requests for clarification to the Case Committee (contemporaneously with the requests of the competing teams) and may liaise with the Case Committee and the Organisers regarding proposed responses to the requests. The FDI Moot’s Bench Brief Committee submits its final draft of the Bench Brief to the Organisers one week before the memorial deadline each year. The Bench Brief Committee may submit a revised draft one week before the orals if it believes the teams’ memorials have raised relevant, not previously considered arguments.

Tirth Bhatt

Dominika Jedrzejczyk Patrycja Treder

Tirth Bhatt

Dominika Jedrzejczyk

Amélie Landriault Daniela Rojas Supritha Suresh Patrycja Treder

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 2 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Teams University / Institution Country Alias Comp

Addis Ababa University School of Law Ethiopia CLXA

Africa Nazarene University Kenya Castro

Guillaume

G*

A

Allameh Tabataba'e University ATU, Faculty of Law Iran (Islamic Republic) CLXG

Amity Law School Delhi, GGSIPU India Onyeama S

Bayero University Nigeria CLXA

Belarusian State University, FIR, International law Belarus Barros G*

Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University Poland Golunsky G

Carlos III University Spain Ammoun G

Charles University Czech Republic Shi CXLG

Concutta University India CLXS

De La Salle University, College of Law Philippines Owada

Donoghue

G

P

Diplomatic Academy of Vietnam, Faculty of Law Viet Nam Jennings P

Dr. Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law University India Wellington S

ELTE Law School Hungary Camara G

Faculty of Law, Universiti Teknologi Mara Malaysia Mo

Bustamante

G

P

Far Eastern University, Institute of Law Philippines Azevedo P

Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul Brazil Elias G

Foreign Trade University, Faculty of Law Viet Nam CLXP

Gujarat National Law University India Alvarez S

Handong International Law School Korea (Republic) Winiarski P

Haramaya University College of Law Ethiopia McNair A

Harvard Law School United States Elaraby G

Hidayatullah National Law University India Sepulveda S

IELPO LL.M. Spain Koo G

Ilia State University Georgia CXLG

ILS Law College, Savitribai Phule Pune University India Ferrari

Visscher

G

S

Istanbul Sehir University, Faculty of Law Turkey CLXG

Jagiellonian University Poland Jessup G

Jindal Global Law School India Shahabuddeen S

JKUAT School of Law Kenya Khan CXLA

Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz Germany Mbaye G

Kathmandu School of Law Nepal CLXS

Kenya School of Law Kenya Mosler

Skotnikov

G

A

Kenyatta University, Faculty of Law Kenya Bennouna A

King's College London United Kingdom Tarazi G

KLE Society's Law College India CLXS

Kobe University Japan ElErian P

Kyoto University Faculty of Law Japan Weeramantry P

La Sabana University, Faculty of Law Colombia CLXG

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Lomonosov Moscow State University, Faculty of Law Russian Federation Alfaro G

Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg Germany Lachs G

Masaryk University Czech Republic Tanaka

Baxter

G

A

Moscow State Institute of International Relations Russian Federation Ladreit G

Mumbai University, Government Law College India Herczegh S

NALSAR University of Law India Xue

Lauterpacht

G

S

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens Greece Ruda G

National Law Institute University – Team B India Pinto

Sette

G

S

National Law Institute University, Team A India Aguilar S

National Law School of India University India Waldock

Bedjaoui

G

S

National Law University Delhi India Morozov S

National Law University Jodhpur India Nervo

Vereshchetin

G

S

National Law University Odisha, Team A India Lipton

Alkhasawneh

G

S

National Law University Odisha, Team B India Arechaga

Spiropoulos

G

S

National University of Study & Research in Law India Abraham S

Nepal Law Campus, Faculty of Law Nepal Read S

New York University School of Law United States Moreno CXLG

Newcastle University United Kingdom Evensen G

NRU Higher School of Economics, Faculty of Law Russian Federation Badawi G

Paris Bar School France Fitzmaurice G

Peking University School of Transnational Law China CLXP

Penn State Law United States CLXG

Pepperdine University School of Law United States Singh G

Pontifical Catholic University of Minas Gerais Brazil CLXG

Pontifical Catholic University of Paraná Brazil Carneiro G

Pontifical Catholic University of Sao Paulo Brazil Hsu G

Pontifícia Universidade Católica do Rio Grande do Sul Brazil Quintana G

Rewa University, Faculty of Law India CLXS

Riara University Law School Kenya CLXA

Rosario University, Faculty of Law Colombia Rau G

Russian State University of Justice Russian Federation Zoricic G

San Beda College Philippines Bhandari

Gaja

G

P

São Paulo Law School of Fundação Getulio Vargas Brazil Bravo G

School of Law Christ University Team B India Greenwood CXLS

School of Law, Christ University, Team A India Rezek S

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 4 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Seoul National University Team A Korea (Republic) Sebutinde P

Seoul National University Team B Korea (Republic) Ago P

Seoul National University Team C Korea (Republic) Spender

Koroma

CLXG

P

Shanghai University of Political Science and Law China Jimenez P

St. Petersburg State University Russian Federation Kooijmans G

Strathmore University, Kenya Kenya Ranjeva A

Suffolk University Law School United States Gros G

Sungkyunkwan Law School Korea (Republic) Petren P

Symbiosis Law School, Pune India CLXS

The Chinese University of Hong Kong Hong Kong, China (SAR) Schwebel P

The WB National University of Juridical Sciences India Padilla

Buergenthal

G

S

Tribhuwan University, Faculty of Law Nepal CLXS

Universidad Catolica de Asuncion, Faculty of Law Paraguay CLXG

Universidad de Buenos Aires Argentina Fabela G

Universidad de San Andrés Argentina Zhengyu G

Universidad Externado de Colombia Colombia Pathak G

Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie Brazil Dillard G

Universitas Gadjah Mada, Faculty of Law Indonesia Crawford G

Universitas Pelita Harapan, Faculty of Law Indonesia Morelli

Fleischhauer

G

P

Université de Sherbrooke Canada Gevorgian G

Université Paris-Est Créteil France Cordova G

University of Belgrade Faculty of Law Serbia CLXG

University of Dar Es Salaam Tanzania Koretsky A

University of Denver United States Ajibola G

University of Economics and Law Viet Nam Kojevnikov P

University of Gondar, School of Law Ethiopia Yusuf CXLA

University of Helsinki, Faculty of Law Finland Tomka G

University of Hong Kong, Faculty of Law Hong Kong, China (SAR) Forster

Robinson

G

P

University of Marmara, Faculty of Law Turkey Oda G

University of Mauritius Mauritius CLXG

University of Miami, School of Law United States Higgins G

University of Namibia Namibia CLXA

University of Ottawa, Faculty of Law Canada Ni G

University of Santo Tomas, Faculty of Civil Law Philippines Simma

Erskine

G

P

University of Sultan Zainal Abidin, Faculty of Law Malaysia Hackworth P

University of Victoria Canada Keith G

University of Warsaw Poland Klaestad G

University of Zimbabwe Zimbabwe Basdevant CXLA

Yonsei University Law School Korea (Republic) Armand P

Young Arbitrators Committee of the Brazilian Centre of Mediation and Arbitration

Brazil Krylov G

S=South Asia Regional A=Africa Regional

P=Asia Pacific Regional G=Global Rounds

CXL=Cancellation/No-Show *=written only

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Regional Rounds

Organisers

The Korean Commercial Arbitration Board is the local organiser of the Asia Pacific Regional Rounds, hosted in Seoul, Korea (Republic) in August.

Kachwaha and Partners is the host and local organiser of the South Asia Regional Rounds, hosted in New Delhi, India in August.

African Nazarene University is the host and local organiser of the Africa Regional Rounds, hosted in Nairobi, Kenya in August.

Arbitrators: Seoul, New Delhi and Nairobi Himanshu Agarwal Aayush Agarwala

Huzefa Ahmadi Tony Andriotis

Hiroki Aoki Meenakshi Arora

Ayong Lim

Seung Hyo Baek

Raghavendra Bajaj Sharad Bansal Tecle Hagos Bahta Ashish Bhan

Tirth Bhatt Jayant Bhatt James Chang

Yong-Jae Chang

Matthew Christensen

James Claxton Tecle Hagos Bahta

Liz Kyo-Hwa Chung

Nitesh Daryanani Jayems Dhingra

Timothy Dickens Utkarsh Divyankar Niti Dixit Arie Eernisse

Mark Goodrich Mehul Gupta

Shotaro Hamamoto

Jinsoo Han

Yewon Han Arthur Igeria

Tarun Jain

Aniket Jain

Prateek Jalan

Woo-Jung Jon

Hyunsoo Joo

Jung Dae Joo

Naman Joshi Samar Kachwaha

Hansa Kaul Yutaro Kawabata Shruti Khanijow

Mohit Khubchandani Emmanuel Kiarie Ji Un Kim

Julie Kim

John K. Kim

David Kim

Sung Youl Kim

Sae Youn Kim

Rooney Kim

Saemee Kim

Sujin Kong Hyunyang Koo

Vaibhav Kumar Malavika Lal Eunjai Lee

Hangil Lee

Hyung Keun Lee

Kyunghoon Lee

Francoise Lewalle

Sanyat Lodha

Jessica Los Banos Wajakoya Luchir Sushant Mahajan

Rahul Malhotra

Govind Manoharan

Darren Mayberry

Binda Mbembe

Mike McClure

Jayant Mehta

Richard Menard

Tanvi Misra

Vedika Mittal Mohit Mudgal Ketan Mukhija

Aakanksha Munjal Emi Nagaoka

Anusha Nagarajan

Collins Namachanja Sambit Nanda

Rahul Narayan

Dennis Ndambo Kariuki Njeri David Njoroge Wycliffe Nyabuto Ken Obura Mehul Parti Chanan Parwani Diggaj Pathak

Shweta Pathak

Harshad Pathak

Adit Pujari Abhishek Puri Edward Purnell Ramiila L. Quinto

Ravi Ragunath

Ritin Rai Ginny Rautray

Sulabh Rewari Joel E. Richardson

Shruti Sabharwal Sanjana Saddy

Jai Sahai Nikhil Sakhardande

Shivi Sanyam

Poorvi Satija Toshit Shandilya

Avinash Sharma

Elizabeth Shin Leia Y. K. Shin

Simranjeet Singh

Aditya Singha

Nikhil Singhvi Abhijeet Sinha

Animesh Sinha

Harald Sippel Sudipto Sircar Sumeer Sodhi Sophia Feng

Tobias A. Strecker Mira Sun

Suruchi Suri Aditya Swarup Mukami Thiga

Adarsh Tripathi Young Shin Um

Adriana Alexis Uson

Ankit Vijaywargiya

Aditya Vikram

Robert Wachter Priscah Wambui Wang Xiaoxuan Chege Wangeci Jae Hyong Woo

Skeleton Brief Judges

Christopher Abbott

Devika Agarwal

Radhika Agarwal

Katrina Aguila

Nicolás Alarcón Loayza

Alexey Anischenko

Ravi Aswani

Maria Athanasiou

Lim Ayong

Tecle Hagos Bahta

Andrius Bambalas

Zaira Bamberger

Carolina Bernal

Tirth Bhatt

Andrea K. Bjorklund

Christy Burzio

Martin Canepa

Bernardo Cartoni

Emily Choo

Hamish Clift

Estefania Contreras

Alana M. Daley

William DeGarmo

Jayems Dhingra

Arran Dowling Hussey

Derya Durlu

Arno Eisen

Andrea Ernst

John Gaffney

Shashank Garg

Duarte Henriques

Dimitrios Ioannidis

Noelia Giselle Irisarri Gonzalez Deibe

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 6 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Nevena Jevremovic

Woo-Jung Jon

Marcin Kaldunski

Marina Kofman

Alexander Korobeinikov

Csaba Kovacs

Amelie Landriault

Hangil Lee

Aracelly López

Jessica Los Banos

Kshama Loya

Wojciech Maciejewski

Pedro Martini

Diego German Mejia-Lemos

Trisha Mitra

Erin Morris

Tolegen Myrzabayev

Phu Nguyen

Joshua Offenhartz

Ijeoma Ononogbu

Tatiana Polevshchikova

Dragan Psodorov

Anjanette Raymond

Julio César (h) Rivera

J. David Roberson

Sameer Sah

Celeste Salinas Quero

Irina Samodelkina

Ksenia Shestakova

Christine Sim

Ivo Skolil

Patricia Snell

Jitendra Soni

Krystyna Sowa

Claire Stockford

Supritha Suresh

Anett Szelezsan

Patrycja Treder

Herman Verbist

Daniel Wilmot

Norbert Wühler

Plamen Yotov

Yueran Zhao

Best Oral Teams Asia Pacific

Team Alias Country 1. Universiti Teknologi Mara,

Faculty of Law Bustamante Malaysia

2. De La Salle University, College of Law

Donoghue Philippines

3. Yonsei Law School Armand Korea (Republic)

Universiti Teknologi Mara and De La Salle University were presented with an award by the Korean Commercial Arbitration Board (KCAB).

Yonsei Law School was presented with an award by Kim & Chang.

The FDI Moot distributed a total of €5000 in prize money to the top 2 teams in the Asia Pacific Regionals for their participation at the Global Orals in Buenos Aires, Argentina

Best Oral Teams South Asia

Team Alias City, Country

1. National Law School of India University Bedjaoui Bangalore, India

2. NALSAR University of Law Lauterpacht Hyderabad, India

Semi Finalists

National Law University Jodhpur Vereshchetin Jodhpur, India

National Law Institute University Team B Sette Bhopal, India

Best Oral Teams Africa

Team Alias Country

1. Kenya School of Law Skotnikov Kenya

2. African Nazarene University Guillaume Kenya

3. Strathmore University, Kenya Ranjeva Kenya

Kenya School of Law was presented with a cash award of US$1500 provided by the International Academy of Trial Lawyers (IATL).

Best Claimant Brief Asia Pacific Team Alias Country

1. Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty of Law Bustamante Malaysia

2. Far Eastern University, Institute of Law Azevedo Philippines

3. De La Salle University, College of Law Donoghue Philippines

Universitit Teknologi Mara was presented with an award by Yoon & Yang.

National Law School of India University

Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty of Law

Kenya School of Law

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Best Claimant Brief South Asia Team Alias City, Country

1. National Law Institute University, Team A ex aequo National Law University Jodhpur

Aguilar ex aequo Vereshchetin

Bhopal, India

Jodhpur, India

3. National Law Institute University, Team B Sette Bhopal, India

Best Claimant Brief Africa Team Alias Country

1. Strathmore University Ranjeva Kenya

2. University of Zimbabwe Basdevant Zimbabwe

3. Haramaya University College of Law McNair Kenya

Best Respondent Brief Asia Pacific Team Alias Country

1. University of Hong Kong, Faculty of Law ex aequo Seoul National University Team A

Robinson ex aequo Sebutinde

China (SAR) Korea (Republic)

3. Far Eastern University, Institute of Law Azevedo Philippines

University of Hong Kong and Seoul National University Team A were presented with an award by Yulchon

Best Respondent Brief South Asia Team Alias City, Country

1. National Law University Odisha, Team A Alkhasawneh Cuttack, India

2. Dr. Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law University Wellington Lucknow, India

3. ILS Law College, Savitribai Phule Pune University Visscher Pune, India

Best Respondent Brief Africa Team Alias Country 1. Strathmore University Ranjeva Kenya

2. University of Gondar, School of Law Yusuf Ethiopia

3. Haramaya University College of Law McNair Ethiopia

4th Annual Asia Pacific Regional Rounds

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 8 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Highest Ranked Team Asia Pacific

Team Alias Country

1. De La Salle University, College of Law Donoghue Philippines

2. Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty of Law Bustamante Malaysia

3. Seoul National University Team C Koroma South Korea

De La Salle University was presented with an award by Seoul National University Law School.

Highest Ranked Team South Asia

Team Alias City, Country

1. National Law University Jodhpur Vereshchetin Jodhpur, India

2. National Law Institute University, Team B Sette Bhopal, India

3. National Law School of India University Bedjaoui Bangalore, India

Highest Ranked Team Africa

Team Alias Country

1. Kenya School of Law Skotnikov Kenya

2. Strathmore University Ranjeva Kenya

3. Africa Nazarene University Guillaume Kenya

Best Advocates Asia Pacific Preliminary Rounds Final Match

Julia Therese Pineda Donoghue De La Salle University, College of Law Ms. Pineda was presented with an award by Bae, Kim & Lee LLC.

Ahmad Izzuddin Zahidi Bustamante Universiti Teknologi Mara, Faculty of Law

Best Advocates South Asia Preliminary Rounds Final Match

Varsha Sriram Sette National Law Institute University, Team B

Parul Mehra Bedjaoui National Law School of India University

De La Salle University, College of Law

National Law University Jodhpur

Kenya School of Law

4th Annual South Asia Regional Rounds

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Best Advocates Africa Preliminary Rounds (from a team not advancing to the Final) Final Match

Christopher Rosana Bennouna Kenyatta University, Faculty of Law

John Nyanje Skotnikov Kenya School of Law Mr. Nyanje was also deemed the Most Promising Advocate.

Achievement Award Asia Pacific

University of Santo Tomas, Faculty of Civil Law (Team Erskine), Philippines was presented with an achievement award by the Seoul International Dispute Resolution Center (SIDRC), FDI Committee.

The 2017 Asia Pacific Regional will be held 9-12 August 2017

The 2017 Africa Regional will be held 18-20 August 2017

The 2017 South Asia Regional will be held 25-27 August 2017

University of Santo Tomas

1st

Annual Africa Regional Rounds

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 10 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Global Rounds

Memorial Judges

Christopher J. Abbott Devika Agarwal Radhika Agarwal Lauren Aguiar Katrina Aguila Nicolás Alarcón Loayza Alexey Anischenko Felipe Aragón Barrero Ravi Aswani Maria Athanasiou Lim Ayong Andrius Bambalas Zaira Bamberger Ben Beaumont Jessica Beess und Chrostin Carolina Bernal Tirth Bhatt Nicolás Bianchi Wan Mohd Asnur Bin Wan Jantan Andrea K. Bjorklund Magdalena Bulit Goñi Christy Burzio Martin Canepa Fernando Cantuarias Santiago Capparelli Leandro Javier Caputo Christian Carbajal Bernardo Cartoni Claire Chabat Panagiotis Chalkias Siyuan Chen Patrick Childress Emily Choo Nawazish Choudhury Thomas S. Clifton Estefania Contreras Ignacio D'Alessio Alana M. Daley

William DeGarmo Michael B. Devine Jayems Dhingra Arran Dowling Hussey Derya Durlu Arno Eisen István Erdos Andrea Ernst Frederico Favacho Monica Feria-Tinta Sandra Friedrich Shashank Garg Alejandro M. Garro Patricio Grané Riera Sebastian Green Martinez Carlos Guaia Duarte Henriques Carolina Hess Almaleh James Hosking Dimitrios Ioannidis Noelia Giselle Irisarri Gonzalez Deibe Shimpei Ishido Nevena Jevremovic Woo-Jung Jon Marko Jovanovic Carol Kalinoski Julio A. Kelly Waqar Saeed Khan Marina Kofman Alexander Korobeinikov Csaba Kovacs Lea Haber Kuck Michal König Sophie Lamb Amelie Landriault Sven Lange Florencia Lebensohn

Hangil Lee Julio Jorge Lodos Madina Lokova Jessica Los Banos Kshama Loya Mariana Lozza Carol Ludington Wojciech Maciejewski Lena-Katharina Markart Pedro Martini José Rafael Mata Dona Carlos A. Matheus López Ariel Medvedeff Diego German Mejia-Lemos Trisha Mitra Allan Moore Lisa B. Morris Erin Morris Rebeca Mosquera Francisco Muñoz Tolegen Myrzabayev Pavel Myslivskiy Timothy G. Nelson Matthias Neuenschwander Phu Nguyen María Blanca Noodt Taquela Max Oehm Joshua Offenhartz Ijeoma Ononogbu Monika Pacocha Katya Plokhenko Nathalie Potin Dragan Psodorov Ramiila L. Quinto Tim Rauschning Anjanette Raymond Julio César (h) Rivera

John David Roberson John D. Roesser Miguel Ruiz Herrera Sameer Sah Celeste E. Salinas Quero Tara Sallar Irina Samodelkina Marco E. Schnabl Mustafa Senel Khushboo Shahdadpuri Ksenia Shestakova Christine Sim John Siwiec Ivo Skolil Mara Smith Patricia Snell Krystyna Sowa Claire Stockford Juan Antonio Stupenengo Ignacio Suárez Anzorena Supritha Suresh Anett Szelezsan Marek Szolc Koji Takahashi Catharine Titi Santiago Torreira Patrycja Treder Fernando Tupa Joaquín Vallebella Subhiksh Vasudev Herman Verbist Gabriela Wallau Rodrigues Elis Wendpap Daniel Wilmot Juergen Woehler Derric Yeoh Plamen Yotov Yueran Zhao

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Arbitrators

Lauren Aguiar Lisandro Allende Lucas Alves Evaristo dos Santos Francisco Amallo Martín Balmaceda Nicolás Bianchi Julian Bordacahar Maria Cecilia Brusa Nicolás Bühler Nicolas Caffo Roque Caivano Christian Campbell Martin Canepa Santiago Capparelli Leandro Javier Caputo Gabriel Cavazos Villanueva Patrick Childress Nawazish Choudhury Thomas S. Clifton Miguel Colquicocha Martinez María Inés Corrá Sebastian Coulon Bauer

Ignacio D'Alessio Nicolas Dulce Sofia Esmerode Maria Alejandra Etchegorry Frederico Favacho Sandra Friedrich Rodrigo Fermín García Alejandro M. Garro Irina Natacha Gedwillo Christopher Gibson Federico Godoy Belén Gonzalez Asaad Diego Brian Gosis Patricio Grané Riera Sebastian Green Martinez Carlos Guaia Belén María Ibáñez Dimitrios Ioannidis Noelia Giselle Irisarri Gonzalez Deibe Pablo Jaroslavsky Marko Jovanovic Emmanuel Kaufman Gabrielle Kaufmann-Kohler

Julio A. Kelly Viviana Kluger Lea Haber Kuck Florencia Lebensohn Luis E Lucero Juan María Mailhos Pedro Martini Carlos A. Matheus López Stephen D. Mau Ariel Medvedeff Ignacio Minorini Lima Guillermo Moro Francisco Muñoz Timothy G. Nelson Bettina Nemeth Matthias Neuenschwander María Blanca Noodt Taquela Mateo Noseda Cecilia Orlando Santiago Peña Sabrina Ramos Tim Rauschning Julio César (h) Rivera

Julian Rotenberg Miguel Ruiz Herrera Veronica Sandler Marco E. Schnabl Mariano Sierra Juan Sonoda Santiago Soria Alastair Stewart Juan Antonio Stupenengo Supritha Suresh Anett Szelezsan Guido Tawil Joseph Tirado Santiago Torreira Patrycja Treder Carlos Luis Trogolo Elicabe Fernando Tupa Joaquín Vallebella Subhiksh Vasudev Mauricio Ariel Ventre Raul Vinuesa Alessandro Vulejser Elis Wendpap Juergen Woehler

Best Oral Team

Team Alias Country

1. Paris Bar School Fitzmaurice France

2. Harvard Law School Elaraby United States

3. Universiti Teknologi Mara Mo Malaysia

Paris Bar School received an award by Investor State Law Guide and the Skadden Arps Trophy.

Highest Ranked Teams

Team Alias Country

1. Universitas Gadjah Mada, Faculty of Law Crawford Indonesia

2. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens Ruda Greece

3. NALSAR University of Law Xue India

Universitas Gadjah Mada received a US$1500 cash award provided by Baker & McKenzie and an award by Investor State Law Guide.

Highest Ranked Team Thomas Wälde Fund Recipient Alias Country

NALSAR University of Law Xue India

The Highest Ranked Team among those receiving travel support from Thomas Wälde Fund received a US$750 cash award provided by the FDI Moot Thomas Wälde Team Fund.

The Highest Ranked Team's overall score is the sum of the points for Memorial for Claimant and Respondent and points granted to the team's oralists during the Preliminary Rounds.

Paris Bar School

Universitas Gadjah Mada

NALSAR University of Law

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 12 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Best Claimant Memorial

Team Alias Country

1. St Petersburg State University Kooijmans Russia

2. Carlos III University Ammoun Spain

3. National Law Institute University Pinto India

Best Respondent Memorial

Team Alias Country

1. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens Ruda Greece

2. Universitas Gadjah Mada Crawford Indonesia

3. Kenya School of Law Mosler Kenya

The top three ranked claimant and respondent memorials have been published in the TDM Journal 6 (2016).

Best Advocates Global Rounds Preliminary Rounds Final Match

John Nyanje Mosler Kenya School of Law

Megha Mehotra Xue NALSAR University of Law Thomas Wälde Best Advocate Award and Manuela Beltrán Best Woman Advocate Award

Nicolas Pralica Fitzmaurice Paris Bar School

Mr. Nyanje pleaded as a one-man team, due to a last minute visa denial for his co-advocate. He won all four of his preliminary round matches, but was barred from advancing to the elimination rounds in accordance with the FDI Moot Rules in place for the 2016 Globals. In recognition of his achievement he received a copy of the “The Iran-US Claims Tribunal at 25” provided by FDI Moot Director and co-author of the book, Christopher Gibson.

Ms. Mehotra received a 12-month free subscription of the ICSID Review from OUP, a US$400 cash award provided by José Manuel Álvarez Zárate, and a silver Argentine Calabasa with Bombilla.

Mr. Pralica received a 6-month free subscription of the ICSID Review from OUP, and an Argentine silver-handled riding crop.

Honourable Mention Advocates Edwin Roberto Concepcion, De La Salle University, Owada; Pedro Della Piazza de Souza**, São Paulo Law School of Fundação Getulio Vargas, Bravo Sonja Heiskala, University of Helsinki, Tomka; Agata Kruczyk, University of Warsaw, Klaestad; Pedro Lins*, Pontifical Catholic University of Paraná, Carneiro; Emily McMurtry, University of Ottawa, Ni; Ksenia Koroteeva, Moscow State Institute of International Relations, Ladreit; John Nyanje, Kenya School of Law, Mosler; Ehsanul Oarith*, Newcastle University, Evensen; Devarsh Saraf, NALSAR University of Law, Xue. *not pictured; **Due to an anomaly in one of the arbitrator’s scoring a calculation error occurred and Mr. Souza was not included in the lineup in Buenos Aires and is thus also not pictured. He has in the meantime received his Honourable Mention Advocate Certificate.

OUP provided Honourable Mention Advocates with a 3-month free subscription to the ICSID Review.

St Petersburg State University

University of Athens

D. Saraf, M. Mehotra, A. Kruczyk, E.R. Concepcion, S. Heiskala, K. Koroteeva, E. McMurthy, J. Nyanje

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Coaches Global and Regional Rounds Alexander Adamou (G)

Katrina Elaine Aguila (G)

Antonio Aljure (G)

Omar Antonio Anduaga Bocanegra (G)

Felipe Aragón (G)

Paula Arias (G)

Bhagirath Ashiya (S)

Claudia Behlendorf (G)

Iuliia Beketova (G)

François Bordes (G)

Clarissa Risel Castillo (G)

Maria Eleni Chrysanthakopoulou (G)

James Claxton (P)

Kevin Crow (G)

Eleftherios Dafermos (G)

Anthony Daimsis (G)

Labin Dmitry (G)

Abhishek Dwivedi (G)

Lucas Alves Evaristo dos Santos (G)

Luis Renato Ferreira Da Silva (G)

Caio Gabra (G)

Anita Garnuszek (G)

Gibson Gisore (A)

Belén González Asaad (G)

Anastasios Gourgourinis (G)

Orlando Jose Guterres Costa Junior (G)

Shotaro Hamamoto (P)

Carolina Hess Almaleh (G)

Mark Dean Itaralde (P)

Pablo Jaroslavsky (G)

Michal König (G)

Fayaz Kurbangaliev (G)

Aditya Laddha (G)

Yuri Leite (G)

Jessica Los Banos (G)

Robert Maclean (G)

Varun Mansinghka (G)

Allan Moore (G)

Amanda Muniz (G)

Simiyu Murambi (G)

Andrew Newcombe (G)

Tatiana Onate (G)

Andrey Panov (G)

Rebecca Pendleton (G)

Esther Lauren Perez (P)

Metka Potocnik (G)

Edward Purnell (P)

Luísa Quintão (G)

Ilia Rachkov (G)

Quinto Ramiila (G)

Giovani Dos Santos Ravagnani (G)

Julio Cesar Rivera (h) (G)

Vivian Daniele Rocha Gabriel (G)

Sarilnezam Salleh (G)

Marco Carlo Sana (P)

Verónica Sandler (G)

Caroline Schaeffer (G)

Krishnan Shakkottai (G)

Jay Smith (G)

Vincenzo Speciale (G)

Mariia Strekalova (G)

Martin Svec (G)

Marek Szolc (G)

Dai Tamada (P)

Daniel Tavela Luís (G)

Tuuli Timonen (G)

Jerome Tumbali (G)

James Upcher (G)

Tony Vanduzer (G)

Deva Villanúa (G)

Gabriela Wallau Rodrigues (G)

Xiaoxuan Wang (P)

Todd Wells (G)

Alemayehu Yismaw (A)

Asril Amirul Zakariah (P)

Aleksandra Żanowska (G)

Group Photo – Main Entrance – Universidad de Buenos Aires, Facultad de Derecho

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 14 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

Students Global and Regional Rounds Siti Syafiqah Abdul Ahmad (P) Endalkachew Abera (A) Daniela Abril Algarra* (G) Elena Adam Cho* (G) Jacob Adams (G) Andinet Adinew (A) Harshita Agarwal (S) Nirmit Agrawal (G) Amiza Ahmad Murad (G) María Pia Alais (G) Ma. Angela Beatriz Alba (P) Victória Albertão Duarte (G) Fernanda Alcantara Gil* (G) Muhammad Fathan Alfian (G) Kays Al-Radzhab (G) Cindy Amuka* (A) Alice Anderson (G) Siti Hajar Anuar (P) Masako Aoyagi (P) Takahiro Arai* (P) Julian Arendt (G) Imam Arouna (G) Bindu Aryal (S) Yavuz Can Aslan (G) Severa Azzarello (G) Victoria Barausova* (G) Sean Beagan (G) Jeremy Bellavia (G) Nuru Beyene (A) Vishesh Bhatia (G) Jue Bian (G) Daniel Binette* (G) Kyser Blakely* (G) Ganna Boicheniuk (G) Mark Joseph Borja (P) Martin Brezina* (G) Jean-Thomas Brière* (G) Guilherme Vieira De Brum (G) Camille Annie Christiane Buewaert (P) Evgenii Bulatov (G) Sophia Bwaki* (A) Olivier Cagnat (P) Stephanie Caligara* (G) Facundo Calvo (G) María Juliana Campo* (G) Juliana Vieira Campos (G) Michelle Carasso (G) Alejandro Castellanos (G)

Claudia Castillo Comabella (G) Floricel Castro (P) Thaiane Chagastelles (G) Man Chit Chan (G) Aninditha Chandra (G) Felix Chandra (G) Trisha Chandran (G) Marcos Chaves* (G) Qichao Chen (P) Yiting Chen (P) Youmin Cho (P) Juneyoung Choi (P) Ja Yoo Choi (P) Sangjin Choi (P) Aleksandr Chuprunov (G) Kazim Cinar (G) Abril Clot (G) Edwin Roberto Concepcion (G) Nathalia Cortez Gomes (G) Leonardo Crivano (G) Uyen Dang (G) Martyna Darczuk (G) Julian Darmun (G) Neelapravo Dasgupta (S) Bianca Bonugli De Lima Amancio (G) Pedro Della Piazza De Souza (G) Alexey Dergachev (G) Rohan Dhariwal (S) Marilou Dostie-Nicol (G) Iuliia Dragunova (G) Thuy Trang Duong (P) James East (G) Drushan Engineer (S) Michael Farchakh* (G) Olya Fateeva (G) Myriam Fleuristil (G) Helen May Frias (P) Stephanie Frien (G) Kin Hang Fung (G) Dmytro Galagan (G) Ketan Ganase (G) Sara Gandini (G) Maria Florencia Garcia (G) Radhika Garg* (S) Covadonga Garralda Cancer (G) Farnush Ghadery (G) Myriam Gicquello (G) Lai Ling Goh (P)

Akshit Goyal (G) Samuel Grondin (G) Gaiane Gulian (G) Sameer Gupta (S) Kanishka Gupta * (S) Tulika Gupta (G) Aishwarya Gupta (S) Daniel Guzmán Martínez* (G) Jungmin Ha* (P) Lalaine Jertrude Hablado (G) Nadia Hairodin (P) Ankit Handa* (G) Jana Havlickova (G) Sonja Heiskala (G) Sarah Hofmann (G) Chikako Hori (P) Yan Hou (P) Tianyi Huang (G) Tamizhoviya I T (G) Tania Iakovenko-Grässer (G) Mai Izumi (P) Kenya Jade Pinto (G) Siddharth Jain (S) Bello Jecko (G) Eleccion John Robert (G) Sayali Kadu (G) Tanuj Kakrania (S) Sheikh Kalia (S) Mikhail Kalinin (G) Holger Kall (G) Hassan Kamalinejad* (G) Tanvee Kanaujia (G) Pratik Karande (S) Rizki Karim (G) Anmol Kathuria (S) Vaia Katsarou (G) Nancy Kisangau Katunge (A) Eduardo Kauffman Milano Benclowicz (G) Wakgari Kebeta (A) Iris Kerkinou (G) Sese Kevin Chris (G) Manju Khadka (S) Mutiara Khairunnisa (G) Tanay Khanna (G) Siddhant Khetawat* (S) Rooha Khurshid* (S) Jihyun Kim (P) Soyeon Kim (P) Miso Kim (P) Eui Seok Kim (P) Shunghyo Kim (G) Hyewon Kim (P)

Mijung Kim (P) Taeyeop Kim (P) Ji Youn Kim (P) Hyunsoo Kim (P) Charles Kimani (A) Akchansh Kishore (S) Maija Kokkonen (G) Natalya Kondrakhina (G) Nastassja Korn (G) Ksenia Koroteeva (G) Athina Kotsia (G) Christos Koutrobis (G) Georgios Kouvaras (G) Manglapus Kria Celestine (G) Anirudh Krishna* (G) Agata Kruczyk (G) Yuki Kunitsu (P) Fulya Kurar (G) Veronika Lakhno (G) Jana Lamas De Mesa (G) Valerii Lamm (G) Raphael Lang Silva (G) Park Yung Lau* (G) Pedro Guimaraes Lauria*(G) Sukyoung Lee (P) Hyein Lee (P) Hyunji Lee (P) In--Hyeong Lee (P) Edith Micaela Lee (G) Yuna Lee (P) Hyunseok Lee (P) Na Young Lee (P) Gabriel Lee Mac Fadden Santos (G) Linnea Lehtonen (G) Noe Leiva (G) Joseph Leonard* (A) Yan Yee Eunice Leung (G) Gregory Lewis* (G) Pedro Lins (G) Athenaís Linhares Moreira (G) Tingting Liu (P) Ashley Lloyd (G) Raquel López Sánchez (G) Bernardo Louzada Bertoldi (G) Yiqing Lu (P) Andrés Felipe Lucumí Asprilla (G) Lena Lueken (G) Rayson Luka* (A) Namratha M (G) Yu Kit Ma (G)

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

Anastasia Magid (G) Tarushi Maheshwari (S) Agung Rosa Maheswari (G) Ngan Ha Mai (P) Luciano Maia Wanderley* (G) Maina Majhi (S) Gaurav Majumdar (S) Manav Malhotra (G) Ewa Malinowska (G) Anna Maltseva (G) Anastasiia Malukhina (G) Alexandra Marais (P) Nicolas Marin (G) José Marinho (G) Oskar Marszałek (G) Marina Martes* (G) Ian Mathenge* (G) Lamprini Mavromatidi (G) Sabrina Mayserafin (G) Emily Mcmurtry (G) Parul Mehra (G) Alisha Mehra (G) Megha Mehrotra (G) Alicia Meier (G) Olga Melnikova* (G) Fernanda Merouço (G) Varvara Metallinou (G) Satvik Mohanty (G) Titiksha Mohanty (S) Muhammad Khairul Azwan Mokter (P) Ana Sofia Monteiro (G) Martina Monti (G) Victoria Morschbacher De Almeida Antunes* (G) Pascal Mshanga* (A) Carina Muir (G) Lida Carolina Muñoz Bernal (G) Jana Nadtocajeva (G) Garima Nagpal (S) Prarthna Nanda (S) Ruby Ng (P) The Hoang Nguyen (P) Ha Duyen Nguyen (P) Thanh Nam Nguyen (P)

Tra Linh Nguyen (P) Duc Tam Nguyen The (P) Patricia Njeru (A) Ahmad Iqbal Nor Azam* (G) Martin Novacek (G) John Nyanje (G) Ehsanul Oarith (G) Sami Obama (P) Georgy Obolentsev (G) Barkley Odhiambo (A) Dayoung Oh (P) Arjit Oswal* (S) Karun Pahwa (G) Radhika Pandey (G) Yash Parihar (G) Hyeyoung Park (P) Chulhong Park (P) Joshua Park* (G) Łukasz Paruzel (G) Misha Patel (S) Pragya Pathak (S) Abhishek Pati (G) Shrey Patnaik (S) Nisha Phuyal (S) Łukasz Pierwienis (G) Shruthi Pillai (G) Julia Therese Pineda (G) Sergey Polyarus (G) Charleen Poon (P) Nicolas Pralica (G) Indira Jauhara Pratiwi (G) Elizaveta Rachkova (G) Ahmad Zhafir Rahmat* (G) Medha Rao (G) Srishubham Ray (G) Efa Sakinah Razak* (G) Kevin Reddington* (G) Rahma Reyhan (G) Eeva Riivari* (G) Horacio Risso (G) Raffaella Rivitti Lisoni (G) Astrid Robert (G) Martha Isabel Robles Ustariz (G) Mercedes Rodriguez Goyena (G) Christopher Rosana (A)

Nikolay Ryashin (G) Varun Sabarwal (S) Hikari Saito (P) Aleksandra Samsonova (G) Nathaniel Samuel (G) Annelise Sander (G) George Sant Ana Hauschild (G) Muhammad Syafiq Sapri (P) Devarsh Saraf (G) Avaneesh Satyang (S) Shubham Saurav* (S) Niyati Saxena (S) Junho Seo (P) Noor Sumaeya Sofea Shamsudin* (G) Piyush Sharma (G) Abhishek Sharma (S) Georgy Shashero (G) Svetlana Shelepina (G) Juyeong Shin (P) Anima Shukla (S) Caio Silva (G) Camila Simão (G) Mercy Simatwo (A) André Simch Kafruni (G) Shivangi• Singh (G) Charu Singh (S) Shivali Singh (S) Inaê Siqueira De Oliveira (G) Juliana Sirotsky Soria (G) Maria Skwara (G) Abigail Soemarko (G) Kseniia Soloveva (G) Amelia Rohana Sonang (G) Ling Song (P) Inhyuk Song* (P) Varsha Sriram (G) Aman Srivastava* (S) Amogh Srivastava (S) Tigmika Srivastava (S) Olga Stadnicka (G) Olga Stokowiec (G) Jung Yoon Suh (P) David Sýkora (G) Vaibhavi Tadwalkar (G) Tomoko Taki (P)

Aditya Talpade (S) Mohit Talwar (G) Sisi Tang (G) Anna Thompson (G) Poonam Tiwari* (G) Abhishek Toppo (G) Anzhela Torosyan* (G) Alexandre Toso (G) Thu Thuy Tran* (P) Khoa Tran* (G) Bartosz Troczyński (G) Michiko Tsujishita* (P) Magłorzata Tuleja (G) Charalampia Tzimi (G) Mayank Udhwani (G) Muizz Ul Iftikhar (S) Urubio Ulahmaria Jesusa Nazarene (G) Brian Vaca (G) Swetha Vadarevu (S) Christian Vandergeest (G) Mateo Vargas (G) Marina Vidal (G) Marcela Vidal (G) Paige Von Mehren (G) Anja Weichold (G) Lillian Wong* (G) Devin Woolf (G) Iffah Yahya (G) Miryung Yang (P) Tsun Hai Yim* (G) Minjae Yoo (P) Aahyun Yoon (P) Dong Young Yoon (P) Danielle Young* (G) Muxin Yu (G) Ahmad Izzuddin Zahidi (G) Dinie Zaidi* (G) Alexander Zhdanovich (G) Veronika Zhejbalova (G) Yuan Zhou (P) Laura Ziegler Gonçalves Meirelles (G) Alexander Zodikoff (G)

S=South Asia Regional A=Africa Regional P=Asia Pacific Regional G=Global Rounds *written phase only

Skadden FDI Moot

Page 16 Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot 2016

The Thomas Wälde Team Fund In October 2008, Ian Laird and the late Prof. Thomas Wälde initiated a fund to support teams’ participation in the FDI Moot.

We would like to thank the following individuals who responded to the new appeal launched for 2016 (in alphabetical order):

José Manuel Alvarez Zárate, Emilia Anagbogu, Chikwendu Madumere, Silvia Marchili, Ijeoma Ononogbu, Julie A. Ryan, Clarisse von Wunschheim, and Plamen Yotov.

In addition, we would like to thank the International Academy of Trial Lawyers (IATL) and The Society of International Economic Law (SIEL) without whose assistance John Nyanje from Kenya could not have made it. And again thank you to Skadden for matching the

individual donations. In 2016, over US$10,000 have been distributed among eight teams. For teams from many countries, travel expenses to and accommodation costs at the hearing venue remain significant obstacles.

Sponsors

José Manuel Álvarez Zárate

Gourab Banerji

Skadden FDI Moot

Founders

The 10th Anniversary Edition of the FDI Moot Global Orals will be held 2-5 November 2017 at Suffolk University Law School in Boston, Massachusetts, United States