45
CARREFOUR BANQUE BANQUE INVESTOR PRESENTATION 2015

201512 Investors presentation CARREFOUR … 60% Carrefour SA, international food retailer - 40% BNP Paribas Personal Finance, consumer finance specialist Page 4 Investor Presentation

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

CARREFOUR

BANQUEBANQUEINVESTOR PRESENTATION 2015

Agenda

CARREFOUR BANQUE (FRANCE) 3

SFC (SPAIN) 23

FIMASER (BELGIUM) 27

CARREFOUR BANCA (ITALY) 30

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 2

CARREFOUR BANCA (ITALY) 30

CARREFOUR BANQUE CONSOLIDATED 33

APPENDICES 36

FRANCEFRANCE

Carrefour Banque France at a glance

Key highlights as at 31 December 2015

− Carrefour Banque is the French captive personal financial services arm of the largest European retailer

− Carrefour Banque is duly authorized as a credit Institution by the French Banking Authority (ACPR)

� Strong commercial footprint in France:

- More than 210 retail outlets for Carrefour Banque

in Carrefour hypermarkets in France

- 2.18m holders of PASS credit card

� Solid and stable shareholding structure since 1985:

- 60% Carrefour SA, international food retailer

- 40% BNP Paribas Personal Finance, consumer

finance specialist

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 4

� Strong and stable revenues:

- Sustained growth of net banking income (+2.4%

from 2012 to 2015)*

- Stable credit outstanding volume (since 2011

around €2.8bn )

� Solid profitability and low risk profile:

- S&P rating: BBB+/A-2 stable outlook

- Strong capital structure: Tier-1 Basel III ratio at

14.37%*

- Solid cost income ratio at 53.9%*

- Stable market share in consumer finance in France

since 2011 around 5% (source : ASF **)

* Consolidated Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Fimaser** The credit market is 60% ASF & 40% banks

G4 at a glance : France, Spain, Belgium & Italy

Breakdown overview - key (statutory)

− Carrefour Banque France refinances almost all the perimeter

− A credit outstanding is an unsecured loan

BUSINESS OVERVIEW (in M €)

Carrefour Banque

France

Servicios Financieros Carrefour

Spain

Fimaser

Belgium

Carrefour Banca

Italy

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 5

* Earmarket : specific purchase loans provided to customers of Carrefour Banque for purchases of specifically earmarked goods at Carrefour Banque Stores

CREDIT OUTSTANDING (End of month) 2,736 1,947 218 241

Personal Loans (%) 50% 30% 10% 63%

Revolving Credit (%) 38% 64% 84% 36%

Earmarket Credit (%) * 12% 6% 6% 1%

NET BANKING INCOME 393.4 273.2 26.0 23.4

NET INCOME 37.5 109.0 4.5 -0.4

SECTION 1PRESENTATIONPRESENTATION

Focus on Carrefour Banque’s shareholders

− Carrefour Banque enjoys 2 strong committed and complementary shareholders:

A stable capital structure since 1985

Carrefour

Rated BBB+ stable (S&P)

� Founded in 1959, headquartered in Boulogne-

Billancourt (France)

� 2nd largest food retailer in the world

� 1st retailer in Europe

� Presence in 35 countries

� Over 12,000 stores and +380,000 employees

� Over €104.4bn net sales under banners

Rated A stable (S&P)

� 100% subsidiary of the BNP Paribas Group

� Leading European provider of personal loans

� Over 20,000 employees operating in about 30

countries over four continents

€68.5bn outstanding loans managed

BNPP Personal Finance

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 7

� Over €104.4bn net sales under banners

� 12.5 million checkouts every day in stores

worldwide, more than 104 million households

customers in our stores worldwide

� €68.5bn outstanding loans managed

� 27m customers

Core subsidiary

� Same brand name franchise which increases

customer’s loyalty to Carrefour

� Strong commercial relationships

� Carrefour’s dedicated business line with an

increasing contribution to the group’s total

earnings

Strategically important subsidiary

� Capital commitment

� Ongoing liquidity support

� Provider of expertise in risk management and

sharing information technology development

cost

� Business support: outsourcing, risk committee,

etc.

From loyalty cards to banking

Carrefour Banque: a successful 33-year story

Creation of “Société des Paiements PASS” (S2P) as banking subsidiary of Carrefour

Launch of Epargne Libre Carrefour savings accounts

Launch of the first bank cards

SecuritisationCopernic 2009-1 ( 730M€ AAA)

Launch of brand name “Carrefour Banque” in France

Merger and Acquisition of the Italian subsidiary Carrefour ServiciFinanziari

Launch of savings accounts “Compte Sur Livret”

Launch of mobile application

Launch of the PASS Payment Card

Fimaser

Subsidiary

100%

2013/09

Transfer of

Carma shares

to Carrefour

2014/12

Launch of the range PASS MasterCard

Securitisation

under MCCP*

400M€ AAA

(2015-1)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 8

2013

20142015

Launch of personal

loans business

Launch of Carrefour Horizons

life insurance

Merger of the finance (S2P) and insurance (Carrefour Assurance) networks into

“Carrefour Banque”

Subsidiarising of CARMA and Carrefour Servici Finanziari

SecuritisationCopernic 2012-1

(500M€ AAA)

Inaugural Fixed Rate

Bond 710M€ issue 2015/09

FRN• 300M€ issue 2016/04• 500M€ issue 2018/03

Securitisation MCCP*•400M€ AAA (2013-1)•110M€ AAA (2014-1)

* MCCP: Master Credit Cards PASS

(2015-1)

FRN•500M€ issue 2020/03•300M€ issue 2019/10

Carrefour Spain

55.9%

6.8%

99.9%

Carrefour Banque: unchanged scope of consolidation

Carrefour Banque : an active shareholder

Carrefour Spain

55.9%

6.8%

99.9%

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 9

SFC

(Spain)

CetelemSpain

55.9%

37.3% CB branch since

10/2011

CB subsidiarysince

09/2013

Carrefour Banca

(Italy)

Fimaser

(Belgium)

SFC

(Spain)

CetelemSpain

55.9%

37.3%Branch

since10/2011

Subsidiarysince

09/2013

Carrefour Banca

(Italy)

Fimaser

(Belgium)

Consolidated* financial ratios

Satisfactory and steady results

� An improving solvency ratio

- As at 31 December 2015, solid capital position with tier 1

ratio Basel III of 14.37%

- Distribution of dividend

2012 : 75% 2013 - 2014 : 50% 2015 : 75%

- Target: to pave the way for the ongoing conversion into

subsidiaries and a European expansion

� ROE decrease

A strong and stable financial position built over the years

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 10

� ROE decrease

- Exceptional assets depreciation of 10.3M€ (sales

consultants’IT tool)

- Change of deferred taxes rate from 38% to 34.4% for an

impact of 5M€

- At constant scope (excluding Carma and exceptional) ratio

would be 8% in 2014 and 7.74% in 2015

� Slight decrease cost-to-income

- Thanks to the progression of our Net Banking Income

concurrently with operating costs under control

* Consolidated •2010-2012 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Carma•2013 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Fimaser - Carma•2014-2015 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Fimaser

Net Income 2015 €36.52 m

S&P RatingsA-2 (Short)BBB+ (Long)Stable

Net Banking Income 2015 € 412.88m

Solvency Ratio 2015 (Basel III)

14.37%

Carrefour Banque : funding profile

− A strong liquidity position: a positive headroom of €2.2bn on

€6.5bn of funding as at 31 December 2015:

� Multiple sources of funding: bank credit lines,

securitisations, bond issues, deposit certificates, savings…

� Diversification of bank counterparties

� Liquidity reserve equivalent to 23 months of activity at the

end of December 2015

A diversified and well-balanced funding mix

− Bank facilities: significant amount of mid-term credit lines

Sources of funding (as at 31 December 2015, €m)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 11

− Bank facilities: significant amount of mid-term credit lines

provided by diversified, highly rated banks

(100% of credit lines mature beyond 1 year)

− Equal support from BNPP (loan with tacit agreement to

renew) and Carrefour SA for a total of €1bn for a maturity

of 2 years with annual renewal

− Amount of committed credit lines which are available for

drawdown: €2,115m

Asset & Liability Management profile

Debt Duration & repayment profile as at end of December 2015

� 23.7 month average duration on Assets

� 25.1 month average duration on Liability Funding sources

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 12

CB’s liquidity is « adequate » (S&P credit opinion 2015)

– « CB’s liquidity benefits from cautions management »

– « Our assessment includes potential shareholder support because we believe the shareholders will continue to provide

liquidity support if needed »

SECTION 2ACTIVITY FIGURESACTIVITY FIGURES

Credit & Insurance : key figures

Credits Solutions New Business Card Products Insurance Products

New Credit business

(€m)

Payment using

PASS Cards (€m)

Insurance Premium

Collected (€m)

Managed Outstanding

(€m)

Good performance in a challenging market

− Despite the current economic environment and major regulatory changes, Carrefour Banque maintains a strong

position thanks to an appropriate risk management

− Breakdown income : 57 % of interest income / 43% of fee incomes (savings, insurance, or card products)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 14

+2.5%

(€m)

+0.6%

PASS Cards (€m)

-3.5%

Collected (€m)

-3.3%

(€m)

Thanks to the expansion of the web channel

-1.8% since 2012 Number of PASS Cards

2.176 m

Insurance customers

Over 474,900

* * * *

* Change between 2015 / 2014

256

272

283

273

2012 2013 2014 2015

2,788

2,855 2,830

2,736

2012 2013 2014 2015

1,372

1,331

1,261

1,293

2012 2013 2014 2015

7,802

7,705 7,720

7,764

2012 2013 2014 2015

Credit products

Balanced diversification of outstanding loans

Credit outstanding(Euro millions)

1,133 1,167 1,129 1,043

359 362 375 319

Personal loans Revolving credit Earmarked credit

13% 12%

2,830 2,736

13% 13% 13%

2,855 2,788

13% 13%

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 15

* Earmarket : specific purchase loans provided to customers of Carrefour Banque for purchases of specifically earmarked goods at Carrefour Banque Stores

1,296 1,326 1,326 1,374

1,133 1,167 1,129 1,043

2012 2013 2014 2015

38%

50%

40%41% 41% 41%

46% 46% 46% 47%46%

41% 40%

47%

Good performance for the savings accounts

− Strong customer confidence on our brand, global balance is at € 2.37bn

− OPCVM Assets : drop in the outstanding due to a decline in performance based on monetary rates close to zero

Mutual savings (Axa, Axa PM, BNP AM) Savings products (Carrefour Banque)

Life Insurance OPCVM Compte sur Livret

Collected savings(€m) Assets Managed (€m)

+3.6

Collected savings(€m)

* * *

Savings : key figures

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 16

* Change between 2015 / 2014

-6.6%+3.6%

Savings Accounts

Over 337,000

Savings Accounts

Over 75,000

Savings Accounts

Over 27,000

* * +12.4%*

274243

223 209

2012 2013 2014 2015

460

565 507

570

2012 2013 2014 2015

1,429 1,475 1,536 1,591

2012 2013 2014 2015

Carrefour Banque’s strategy

− A philosophy in line with Carrefour’s mission

Offering the best financial and insurance products to the

largest number of people at the best value for money

− All credits are originated on a face to face basis

− Over the past 34 years, the company has acquired an

excellent reputation on the financial services market.

This allowed us to add innovative new products and

improve our client base beyond that of Carrefour

A consumer credit expert at the service of the group

Origination channel for personal loans

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 17

improve our client base beyond that of Carrefour

− Key ambitions and looking ahead

� Personals loans : An expansion of the originations by the

web channel

� Revolving loans : A well-adjusted « IN » and « OUT »

commercial expansion, backed by diversification of its

distribution channels

� A real ambition to support clients through cross-selling

financial solutions, making clients’ day-to-day life easier

� A geographical, operational and managerial expansion

� Ongoing financial innovation in services and products

� A technological innovation on payment methods meeting

and anticipating clients’ needs

OUT **

37.9%

IN *

40.6%

Drawing type for revolving loans (IN vs OUT)

* in : Carrefour outlets and subsidiaries** out : outside Carrefour’s network

ATM

21.5%

France

Satisfactory and steady results

‒ In 2014

• The operating income has decreased of 6,2%, due to an increase of business investments

• The net income has improved because it integrates the capital gain made on disposal of Carma shares in

December

‒ In 2015

• Decline of the usury rate; competitive environment on personal loans partly offset by the slight decrease

of the refinancing

• Joint performance of refinancing and lower expenses, despite a simultaneous decrease in the outstanding

customer and the sales rate

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 18

* statutory : Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca

Income statement

(in € M)FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015

Var.

2015/2014

NET BANKING INCOME 375 397,7 405,3 393,4 -2,9%

GROSS OPERATING PROFIT 172 178,6 173,0 172,1 -0,5%

COST OF RISK -79 -101,6 -100,8 -99,0 -1,7%

OPERATING INCOME 93 77,0 72,2 73,1 1,2%

NET INCOME 52 46,2 64,9 37,5 -42,2%

Asset quality : S&P* and ACPR** feedbacks

− Risk position according to “Standard & Poor’s”

credit opinion dated September 10, 2015

- Strengths :

- “Good credit risk management »

- “Adequate capitalization considering the bank’s risk

position”

- “We also anticipate that the bank will contain its cost of risk

and pursue its sound management of liquidity“

A « moderate » risk position (S&P credit opinion) A reliable management (ACPR* - audit Q1 2013)

− Efficient risk management performed by Carrefour

Banque

− “ Recent investigations lead to an overall favourable

opinion thanks to the relevant, responsive and

independent nature of the credit risk monitoring ”

− “ The underwriting policy seems to be well-structured

and to fit with undertaken risks ”

− “ No reservation about the bank’s provision rates […]

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 19

- “Core status to parent, retailer

Carrefour S.A., and strategic

importance to BNP Paribas Personal

Finance”

- Outlook stable :

“We could upgrade the bank by one

notch if we take a similar action on

Carrefour”

− “ No reservation about the bank’s provision rates […]

according to practices observed by the inspection ”

− “ Servicing and recovery management appear generally

rigorous and effective ”

*ACPR : “Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution” is the French supervisory body of banking and insurance **S&P : Standard & Poor’s

Asset quality : Strong and committed

governance

− A “partnership” committee with BNPP Personal

Finance

Support provided for quarterly committee :

- Underwriting and recovery benchmark indicators

- Litigation process management

- Regulatory amendments and impacts on risk management

Participants :

- Risk Management of both entities

- Partnership Management Department

− A strategic risk committee : A decision-making entity

dedicated to the credit policy

“ Joint presidency of the credit risk management committee

shared between the Deputy CEO and the COO France,

promotes early solving of discrepancies. Promotion of dialogue,

as early as possible, is a strength of the organization “ *

Support provided for quarterly credit risk committee :

- Support presentations

- Completed by action plans

Strengths of Carrefour Banque

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 20

- Partnership Management Department

An organisation based on 3 pillars - Preventive risk: scores, expert systems, fraud detection

- Curative risk: scores, amicable and judicial recovery

- Risk analysis: generation risk, provisioning, Basel II

- Completed by action plans

- Presentation of underwriting, recovery and fraud indicators

- Regulatory amendments and impacts on risk management

- Minutes of resolutions

Participants :

- Risk Management

- Business Management

- Finance Management

- Compliance Management

* Source : ACPR

Asset quality : Underwriting and Servicing

− Personal Loans

− tighter rules of granting

− implementation of the credit committee on large

commitments.− Revolving Receivables

− implementation of the review of authorized overdrafts as part

of the study of solvency

− review of steps of increase in authorized overdrafts

− drop of the granting ceilings

Underwriting : main improvements Non performing loans (in € m) under control

341,7

377,8

438,0 437,5420,7

85,5%78,4% 74,7% 75,2% 75,1%

30%

60%

90%

120%

150%

100,0

200,0

300,0

400,0

500,0

Gross non performing assets (€m) - left_axis

Loan loss reserves / Gross non performing asset (%) - right_axis

Non performing ratio (%) - right_axis

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 21

− Thanks to a more restrictive policy on personal loans and credit cards beginning a light reduction since 2014: reduction in entrances to the covering since S2 2014

− Deposit of stable over-indebtedness vs 2014, but personal bankrupt orientation in light increase

− The NPL coverage rate remains stable since 2013 around 75%

− Dedicated teams for each steps of the recovery process

− Management consistency

− Unchanged recovery objectives and performances

− Target of 90% amicable recovery after 4 months (before

transfer to litigation recovery)

A performing servicing process

12,2% 12,9% 14,5% 14,5% 14,0%

0%

30%

0,0

100,0

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

FINANCIAL STATEMENTSSpain, Belgium , Italy

SPAINSPAINSERVICIOS FINANCIEROS CARREFOUR

Financial ratios

A strong and stable financial position built over the years

− SFC is a subsidiary held at 55, 9% by Carrefour Spain,

37,3% by Cetelem Spain and 6.8% by Carrefour Banque

France

− SFC posted brilliant results and constantly improved

over the years :

�A satisfying solvency ratio

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 24

�A satisfying solvency ratio - As at 31 December 2015, solid capital position with tier 1

(Basel III) ratio at 10.5%

�ROE significantly improves- Mainly thanks to a strong commercial performance after a

decrease mainly due to the distribution of dividend

- In 2012 : 50%

- In 2013 – 2014 : 100%

- In 2015 : 75%

�Adequate cost-to-income- Below that of other rated consumer finance subsidiaries of

European food retailers

Net Income 2015+19.2%

€ 109.0m

Net Banking Income 2015+ 12.1%€ 273.2m

Solvency Ratio 2015 (Basle III)

+10.5%

Key figures

− The credit outstanding business still improved through an activity focused on known customers

Credits Solutions New Business Card Products

New Credit business (€m) Payment using

Tarjeta PASS (€m)

Managed Outstanding (€m)

Good performance in a challenging market

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 25

+12.8 %* +11.5 %*

Tarjeta PASS (€m)

+11.2%*

* Change between 2015 / 2014

+28.9% since 2012 Essentially on Revolving loan Number of Tarjeta Pass over

1,994 m

Asset quality

− The measures of granting taken during

the crisis and the improvement of the

current economic situation allowed us

Non performing loans (€ M)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 26

current economic situation allowed us

to lower the non performing ratio from

11.5% to 10.9% over 2015

− New criteria of classification of the non

performing according to the new

standard of Bank of Spain

SECTION 2FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Income statements

After years of steady results , a great increase in 2014

− Economic reforms encourages the relaunch

− Reinforcement of the commercial momentum (Carta Pass reworking in 2014 : new features, a

wider offer)

− An operational result in progress thanks to the dynamism of card production which generates an

increase in the financial margin

Income statement

(in € M)FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015

Var.

2015/2014

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 28

(in € M) 2015/2014

NET BANKING INCOME 204.8 209.4 243.8 273.2 12.1%

GROSS OPERATING PROFIT 151.2 150.7 178.5 202.1 13.2%

COST OF RISK -63.8 -76.6 -47.9 -45.6 -4.9%

OPERATING INCOME 87.4 74.1 130.6 156.5 19.9%

NET INCOME 61.2 51.9 91.4 109.0 19.2%

BELGIUMBELGIUMFIMASER

Key figures

Credits Solutions New Business Card Products

Payment using

Visa Carrefour (€m)Managed Outstanding (€m)

Good performance in a challenging market

− Fimaser is a subsidiary of Carrefour Banque France

− Regulatory pressures that limit credit business (« zérotage »)

New Credit business (€m)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 30

-2.6%* -4.1%*

Visa Carrefour (€m)

- 4.9%*

-7.5% since 2012 Mainly revolving loans Number of Visa Carrefour around

190,000

* Change between 2015 / 2014

236 236

229

218

2012 2013 2014 2015

268

290 292

280

2012 2013 2014 2015

Asset quality

Non performing loans (€ M)

− Good collection efficiency allowing to

maintain the stability of non performing

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 31

maintain the stability of non performing

outstanding despite a high unemployment

rate and first-related impacts bound to

"Zerotage" (obligation to repay revolving

accounts, gradual application based on

outstanding Authorized Maximum Overdraft)

SECTION 2FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Income statement

Fimaser posted stable results over the last years

− Stability of the operating income thanks to the control of the financial charge and reduction of costs

Income statement

(in € M)FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015

Var.

2015/2014

NET BANKING INCOME 25.9 27.5 26.0 26.0 0.3%

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 33

GROSS OPERATING PROFIT 12.5 14.1 11.1 11.4 1.9%

COST OF RISK -6.5 -7.2 -4.5 -4.8 7.5%

OPERATING INCOME 5.9 6.9 6.3 6.2 -0.8%

NET INCOME 3.3 4.5 3.1 4.5 43.1%

ITALY ITALY CARREFOUR BANCA

Key figures

Improvement of its outstanding credits

Credits Solutions New Business Card Products

Payment using

Carta PASS (€m)

Managed Outstanding (€m)

* * *

− Carrefour Banca is a branch of Carrefour Banque France

− A global production in improvement vs 2014 taking advantage of the generalization of the day Pass in all the

hypermarkets

New Credit business

(€m)

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 35

+9.4% +15.2% +9.6% * * *

+26,7% since 2012 Good balanced : Personal Loan 54% /

Revolving credit 46%

Number of Carta Pass over

107.000

* Change between 2015 / 2014

190 199220

241

2012 2013 2014 2015

75

6573

80

2012 2013 2014 2015

191

153 145167

2012 2013 2014 2015

Asset quality

Non performing loans (€ M)

− Changes in non performing loans was driven

by the growth in outstanding litigation and

lack of assignment of receivables in 2015

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 36

lack of assignment of receivables in 2015

− The branch increased as a consequence the

cover rate for the NPL from 81 % in 2014 to

83,9 % in 2015 and reorganized for the

management of the amicable collection and

litigation to improve the efficiency of cash

receipts

SECTION 2FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Income statement

Carrefour Banca

− A tough economic environment− Uptrend confirmed for 2015 : an operational result in marked improvement, increase of the

financial margin and the good performance of the co sts of structure

Income statement

(in € M)FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015

Var.

2015/2014

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 38

NET BANKING INCOME 17.6 19.3 19.7 23.4 18.7%

GROSS OPERATING PROFIT 6.5 5.6 5.9 11.2 89.8%

COST OF RISK -6.4 -8.0 -10.4 -11.8 14.0%

OPERATING INCOME 0.1 -2.4 -4.5 -0.7 -84.8%

NET INCOME -0.4 -1.5 -3.0 -0.4 -87.7%

CONSOLIDATED ACCOUNTSCONSOLIDATED ACCOUNTS

Consolidated* income statement in IFRS

Income statement

(in thousands of euros)FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015

Var. 2015/

2014

− The 2015 consolidated net income is decreasing by 3 2.9% with € 36,521 million − At constant scope (without the exit of Carma, effec tive mid December 2014), the decline was 23.5% − The 2015 result includes an asset impairment charge of approximately € 16 million

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 40

* Consolidated•2010-2012 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Carma•2013 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Fimaser - Carma•2014-2015 Carrefour Banque - Carrefour Banca - Fimaser

NET BANKING INCOME 403,383 424,157 448,300 412,888 -7.9%

GROSS OPERATING PROFIT 187,660 182,588 193,876 190,366 -1.8%

Cost of risk -78,686 -101,232 -102,046 -113,741 11.5%

CURRENT PRE-TAX PROFIT 108,448 87,771 88,974 60,518 -32.0%

Income taxes -42,837 -31,145 -23,621 -23,998 1.6%

Non-controll ing interests 2,680 2,497 10,925 0 -100.0%

NET PROFIT ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE GROUP 62,930 54,129 54,428 36,521 -32.9%

Appendice IFRS7

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 41

USEFUL INFORMATION

Your Contact Persons

Alessandra GIROLAMI Head of Financial

Communication and investor [email protected]

Relations

+ 33 (0)1 41 04 28 83

Matthew MELLIN Investor Relations Director [email protected]

Mathilde RODIE Investor Relations Director [email protected]

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 43

Frédéric MAZURIER Deputy CEO / CFO + 33 (0)1 60 76 48 00 [email protected]

Dominique MOLLIET Treasurer + 33 (0)1 60 76 48 15 [email protected]

Disclaimer

This document is for discussion and information purposes only. It is highly confidential and is the property of Carrefour Banque (“the Originator”). It should not be transmitted to any person other than to a limited number of

sophisticated or sufficiently experienced prospective investors in order to assist them in determining whether they have an interest in the type of securities described herein and is solely for their internal use. This document is

confidential and may not be distributed, passed on, published, reproduced, transmitted, communicated or disclosed, directly or indirectly, in whole or part, to any other person without the Carrefour Banque prior written

consent.

This document is not a personalised recommendation and it does not purport to be a comprehensive review of any prospective investors’ investment objective, financial situation or particular need.

This document is for distribution only under such circumstances as may be permitted by applicable law. Recipients of this document should inform themselves about and observe any applicable legal or regulatory requirements

in relation to the distribution or possession of this document to or in that jurisdiction. In this respect, none of the Managers nor any of their affiliates, directors, employees, agents or advisers nor any other person accept any

liability to anyone in relation to the distribution, possession or delivery of this document in, to or from any jurisdiction. This document is not directed at, or intended for distribution or use by, any person or entity who is a

citizen or resident of any jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to applicable laws or regulations of such jurisdictions.

This document should not be construed as an offer, solicitation or recommendation with respect to the purchase, sale or subscription of any interest or security or as an undertaking, promise, warranty or representation by the

Managers to the future provision of services or product or to complete a transaction subject to the terms and conditions described in this document or any other terms and conditions. Any undertaking provided for in this

document should be treated as preliminary only and is subject to a formal approval and written confirmation in accordance with each Manager’ current internal procedures.

None of the Managers has verified nor independently analysed the information contained in this document. Accordingly, no representation, guarantee, warranty or undertaking, express or implied, is made to recipients as to or

in relation to the accuracy, correctness or completeness or otherwise of this document or as to the reasonableness of any assumption contained in this document. The information contained in this document sets out the

principle features of the transaction describe herein and is subject to change without notice. The information contained in this document does not take into account specific tax rules or accounting methods applicable to

counterparties, clients or potential clients of the Managers. Therefore, the Managers shall not be liable for differences, if any, between its own valuations and those valuations provided by third parties; as such differences may

arise as a result of the application and implementation of alternative accounting methods, tax rules or valuation models.

Transactions relating to financial instruments involve risks of adverse or unanticipated market, economic, political or legal developments, risk of illiquidity and the financial outcome of any particular transaction depends on this

variety of factors including but in no way limited to, credit risk (including in relation to the counterparty, the underlying debtor, the swap provider, the liquidity provider, the assignor), investor interest, grade of potential

investor market, selling restrictions in target jurisdictions, rating of the bonds or commercial paper issued, tax considerations, legal documentation, particular features of underlying assets, and availability of collateral. Past

performance, simulated performance or historical data are not reliable indicators of future yields or returns.

Investor Presentation – December 2015Page 44

performance, simulated performance or historical data are not reliable indicators of future yields or returns.

The delivery of this document does not imply in any way an obligation on anyone to update the information contained herein at any time, which is qualified in its entirety by the information specified in the relevant legal

documentation for this transaction.

When you enter into a transaction, you will be deemed to act for your own account and to understand and accept its terms and conditions and associated risks. None of the Managers does act as an advisor, nor owe any

fiduciary duty and this document and the information it contains shall not be construed as financial, legal, regulatory, tax, accounting or other advice. You should also make your own evaluation of the document, the

information herein contained and the investment. You should consult with your advisors concerning these matters before undertaking the proposed transaction and obtain independent professional advice from appropriate

professional advisors if you deem it appropriate before undertaking any action.

Under no circumstance shall the Managers or any of their directors, officers, employees be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, to any person or entity for any direct or consequential damage, loss, cost, charge, expense or

other liability whatsoever, in whole or in part, resulting from, caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on the information and the contents in this document and/or any omission, condition

or other circumstances within or outside the control of the Managers or any of their directors, officers or employees in connection with the procurement, collection, compilation, analysis, interpretation, communication or

delivery of the information and the contents of this document.

The distribution of this document in other jurisdictions than France and United Kingdom may be restricted by law, and persons into whose possession this document comes should inform themselves about, and observe, any

such restriction

www.carrefour-banque.fr

Etablissement de crédit et de courtage en assurances

Société anonyme au capital de 101 346 956,72 euros – RCS Evry 313

811 515

1 place Copernic – 91051 Evry cedex – n° ORIAS 07 027 516