2014 the Case for 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs

8/11/2019 2014 the Case for 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs

1/11

Seeking AlphaSeeking Alpha Portfolio App for iPadFinance(1)

Home |Portfolio |Breaking News |Investing Ideas |Dividends & Income |ETFs |Macro View |

ALERTS |PROSign in / Join Now

Loading...Symbols:Authors:

2014: The Case For 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFsDec. 24, 2013 3:13 PM ET | by: Arsene Lupin 21 comments |Top Ideas

2014: The Case For 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs - Seeking Alpha http: //seekingalpha.com/ar ticle/1915381-2014-the-case-for-reverse-rotation-into-bond-cefs

1 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM


2/11

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More...)

I'll start with a confession of bias. I subscribe to the theory that red-blooded investors such as yours truly go for stocks, and that bonds are best leftto the portfolio of one's mother-in-law. But changing times require re-examining one's axioms. Given the euphoria around stocks and the gloomaround bonds, now is a good time for said re-examination. And my conclusion is, on a relative valuation, basis bonds offer not only a better risk-reward, but possibly a better absolute reward. I would hasten to point out that I am talking specifically about closed end bond funds , whereyou are playing both the income and the end-of-year NAV discounts. Below are some of my arguments for the bond stock reverse rotation.

How Euphoric Are We? The answer, according the Citigroup's Tobias Levkovich, is high, but with the potential to get to excessive. Nevertheless,he notes that readings at this level (see figure below) indicate the market may retreat with an 83% historical probability of losses in the next 12months . So if you are adept at spotting greater fools, you can certainly play stocks, but risk-reward is not on your side.

(click to enlarge)

We are on the wrong side of growth. The same Zero Hedge article alluded to in the point above also points to a normalized earnings chart. Thischart (below) shows that EPS growth is trending in the wrong direction, and cannot justify the elevated P/E of the current market in the monthsthat follow.

1.


2 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM


3/11

(click to enlarge)

Bond Closed End Funds Trading with Doomsday Discounts. As pointed out by multiple sources, such as the figure below and this article fromForbes , bonds have been vilified beyond what they deserve. On a relative valuation basis, as well as a historical discount basis, they are well worththe look.

(click to enlarge)


3 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM

2014 Th C F 'R R i ' I B d CEF S ki Al h h // ki l h / i l /1915381 2014 h f i i b d f


4/11

(click to enlarge)

Bonds are the Turbo-Charged Tricycle. Bond Closed-End Funds give you a three-pronged vehicle for total returns - dividend, the lifting of steepyear-end discounts, and the upside from a potential scenario of an earnings recession. A recent Barron's article offers a collation of investmentchoices from various hedge fund sources. The Barron's article makes a case for all manner of income vehicles (including Preferred Stocks) butspecifically calls out Municipal Bonds as worthy of a look.

In summation, investing in optical networks, robotics and social media is more fun, and more worthy of conversation at cocktail parties. But if yougo with bonds, you might skip the party altogether and fund that island vacation that sounds vastly more enticing in any case. As always, do your own homework, and pay close attention to valuation and discounts before pulling the trigger.


4 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM

2014 Th C F 'R R t ti ' I t B d CEF S ki g Al h htt // ki g l h / ti l /1915381 2014 th f t ti i t b d f


5/11

Share this article with a colleague

11Tweet 0

0

Articles that link to this one

2014: The Case For 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs by Arsene Lupin

More articles by Arsene Lupin

Sector Strategy: 2014 Thu, Jan 9The Case For ARM Over Intel Fri, Jan 3KKR: 4 Reasons To Buy After The KFN Acquisition Fri, Dec 27GE: Reasons For Cautious Optimism Sat, Nov 30

Comments (21)All (21) Author's Picks (1)

Register or Login to rate comments

omarbradley Comments (402) I don't accept the greater fool theory. "be invested...that includes stocks." Having said that i do accept "The Greatest Fool Theory." there isnothing unusual about "buy at any price" investing. we've had two massive manias in the last two decades...this one "clearly is not a third"(how many 300% gainers on no earnings this year?)24 Dec 2013, 03:30 PMReplyLike0

ShareShare

0ShareShare

About this articleEmailed to: 153,426 people who get ETFs & Portfolio Strategy daily.Author payment: $0.01 per page view. Authors of Top Ideas on small- and mid-cap stocks receive a minimum guaranteed payment of $150-500.Become a contributor Tagged: ETFs & Portfolio Strategy , Closed-End FundsProblem with this article? Please tell us. Disagree with this article? Submit your own .


5 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM

2014: The Case For 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs Seeking Alpha http: //seekingalpha com/ar ticle/1915381 2014 the case for reverse rotation into bond cefs


6/11

Zach Mansell Comments (221) Tesla fits the bill. Amazon may too depending on who you ask. Twitter as well. Of course that's just limited to tech.

Any long term indicator of value suggests that stocks are due for a 30-40% correction (Tobins Q, CAPE, mean reversion in profit margins,etc. ). It's anyone's guess as to when, but I think it's likely in the next 2 years or so.24 Dec 2013, 03:36 PMReplyLike0

omarbradley Comments (402)

just look at Solar stocks. Crazy moves all year...but if you'd bought the sell off in the Fall you'd have missed a huge winter rally. same goes in

the opposite direction for mining stocks. they got crushed this summer...and everyone got suckered in and bought and are now finding their mining plays are rolling over as the market sees them as "loss leaders." at some point in the next six months a little "vulture investing" might be in order in the mining space. no need to rush it. at a certain level "everything is over-valued" which is why folks don't get in the market to begin with.24 Dec 2013, 03:43 PMReplyLike1

Arsene Lupin Comments (171)

I'll buy that vulture investing in metals & mining will make sense (may already be there). As Shipping goes to show, when

these spaces turn, they turn quickly.24 Dec 2013, 04:16 PMReplyLike1

GrowthGeek Comments (268) I guess I'm dense, but have always remained 100% in stocks with the money I personally control. I just don't understand the argument for

bonds. Ownership beats loanership over time. Yes, I expose myself to more volatility, but over time I'm destroying the return of bonds. Evenif I was more conservative and/or needed considerable income from my investments--why wouldn't I invest in NMM with a 10% return in acyclical area that is making a comeback? Or if I wanted lower volatility than the SPY with a decent dividend how about JNJ? Help me seethe error of my ways as I'm in my 50's now and all the big investment houses tell me I should be rotating out of stocks into more conservativeinvestments. What's wrong with me???24 Dec 2013, 04:25 PMReplyLike2

2014: The Case For Reverse Rotation Into Bond CEFs - Seeking Alpha http: //seekingalpha.com/ar ticle/1915381-2014-the-case-for-reverse-rotation-into-bond-cefs

6 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM


7/11



8/11

25 Dec 2013, 12:22 PMReplyLike1

birder Comments (975) Earlier this year after many of my muni bonds were called I took a 2nd look at muni CEFs. After all 7% tax free is nothing to sneeze atespecially when one can pick that up with AA rated paper at a 10% discount to net assets. I picked through the universe and found a couplethat at the time met this criteria. Today they do not sell at such a steep discount but one still does yield 7%. BYM is the 7% yielder. The other EIV is currently at 6.8%. Considering that these two in the past year had sold at prices almost 30% higher than currently it seems that muchof the risk has been replaced with potential reward. The universe of muni CEFs is rather large and rather complex with more than 200choices. The site that I use to sort through the offerings is CEF Connect. All of these CEFs are very thinly traded so it is very important to

place a limit order when placing orders and unless you are not opposed to picking up bits and pieces all or nothing also.

It does appear at least from the charts that the muni CEFs have hit a bottom recently and prices are turning to the upside.25 Dec 2013, 09:45 AMReplyLike1

R we there yet Comments (319) I have been a steady purchaser of muni CEFs specific to my state residence for the last 6 months or so.

Yeah, boring, dull and cant touch equities for return, I know.But it is not my only portfolio and the tax free income is a huge plus for me. For some of the cefs the returns are close to 14% if you discountfor the tax advantage. I have trouble attaining that in equities unless I reach into some risky areas.Lets just say I am a bit too "mature" for that.As another writer mentioned, these are thinly traded so its best to go in a few hundred shares at a time or you can amass some large tradefees buying anywhere from 1 to 21 shares at a time. Voice of experience.Thanks for writing this Arsene.26 Dec 2013, 03:38 PMReplyLike0


R we there .. sounds like you've good timing. Here's to that continuing. And yes, CEF's are getting to the point where somehedgies (who get none of the tax benefits) are playing them in any case as a premium play ..29 Dec 2013, 09:46 PMReplyLike0

Akaralph Comments (1327)

2014: The Case For Reverse Rotation Into Bond CEFs Seeking Alpha http: //seekingalpha.com/ar ticle/1915381 2014 the case for reverse rotation into bond cefs

8 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM 2014: The Case For 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs - Seeking Alpha http: //seekingalpha.com/ar ticle/1915381-2014-the-case-for-reverse-rotation-into-bond-cefs


9/11

None of the taxable bond funds in your table are even close to the 52 week low discount to NAV.

Would avoid any of these until the discounts approach the 52 week lows.25 Dec 2013, 10:00 AMReplyLike0


um .. really? how about DSL?25 Dec 2013, 12:19 PMReplyLike1

GrowthGeek Comments (268) Well Arsene and Debunker--I've held stocks for 35 years and have seen some pretty steep declines, but I've still destroyed bond returns over time. Patience is a virtue. If I was a betting man, and maybe you think I am given my portfolio--I'd certainly pick JNJ over your picks Arseneover the next 5 years. The 80 year old and I are having trouble seeing the error of our ways.26 Dec 2013, 12:06 PMReplyLike0


@GrowthGeek I wouldn't say you're wrong at all. JNJ and NMM/CPLP are good choices. The question isn't outperformanceover a 5 year horizon (bonds have very long odds on that). The question is, outperformance in the 3 to 18 month time horizon. If you're

buying stocks to live on the divvy stream and ride out any gyrations, life is quite simple - 100% dividend growth stocks. Not everybody has

that luxury.

Venu26 Dec 2013, 12:22 PMReplyLike0

WallStreetDebunker Comments (1716) Geek, Until late 2011, the 10-year treasury outperformed the S&P 500 for the prior 30 year period, with minimal risk and a fraction of thevolatility.If you need your money at a time that coincides with the bottom of a 40-55% bear market, your vision might clear up.

g p p g p

9 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM



10/11

26 Dec 2013, 09:24 PMReplyLike2

Zach Mansell Comments (221) There are periods that are 10-20 years long where equities under perform bonds. In the long, long run equties usually do outperform bonds -

but not everyone has the ability to wait 10-20 years for that guarantee to happen. By most measures, U.S. equities are expensive. Thisdoesnt guarantee a crash. It just raises the likelihood that bonds will outperform over the middle term. If you can get CEFs that yield 7-10%at 10% discounts, youre getting average equity returns with a margin of safety and more consistent cash flows. I dont think thats a bad dealin this over-priced environment. Sure, CEFs are unlikely to return 25-30% a year like equities did this year. Theyre also unlikely to fall 50%like equities did in 2000 and again in 2008.26 Dec 2013, 05:04 PMReplyLike1


@Zach well put26 Dec 2013, 05:12 PMReplyLike0

GuestAdd Your Comment:

Publish

Arsene Lupin

Articles (57)Instablog (7)

The Next Great Investment Idea: AusTex Oil Is Trading At 1/3 Of Proved Reserve Value, Growing 300% Per Year byJosh YoungGreat Wall Technology: 6.0% Gross Return In 2 Months by Yuanxi Zhang2.SandRidge Energy: Disappointing Asset Sale Reinforces Valuation Concerns by Richard Zeits3.Deeply Undervalued IXYS Is Our Top 2014 Value Pick With Target Of $22.5 by Value Advisors4.

Dividends & Income

10 Reasons To Go Long Canadian Oil Sands Now by Doc Mike1.Dave Van Knapp Positions For 2014: The Best Dividend Growth Stocks Will Pay Out More This Year by David Van2.

10 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM



11/11

StockTalks (1)Comments (171)Profile

157 Followers21 FollowingFollowSend Message

KnappDuke Energy: A Utility Giant For Your Income Portfolio by Equity Watch3.Ford's Dividend Increase by Tradevestor 4.About Time For Another Sweet Hershey Stock Split by Travis Giarde5.

ETFs & Portfolio Strategy

Unique Application Of Moving Day Average To High Yield Bond ETFs by Cliff Smith1. NexPoint Credit Strategies Fund Will Surge In 2014 by Betalyst2.How To Protect A Portfolio In Utilities by Fred Piard3.Low P/E ETFs Become Less Risky When They Boast Technical Uptrends by Gary Gordon4.Frontier Markets: The Macro View by The ETF Authority5.

Macro View

Is It Time To Sell Stocks And Buy Bonds? by Chris Ciovacco1.Are These Gold Price Forecasts For Real? Will They Stick? by MetalMiner 2.Will China Back The Yuan With Gold? by Ben Kramer-Miller 3.Prasad Capital's 2014 Market Outlook by Prasad Capital Management4.Weak December Jobs Report Likely A Fluke by Calafia Beach Pundit5.

TOP AUTHORS: The Opinion LeadersTOP USERS: StockTalkers | Instablogs

Follow @SAlphaTrending

Mobile Apps | RSS Feeds | About Us | Contact UsTerms of Use | Privacy | Xignite quote data | 2014 Seeking Alpha

18kLikeLike

11 of 11 1/11/2014 1:27 PM

Documents

2014 the Case for 'Reverse Rotation' Into Bond CEFs