Upload
peter-cavanaugh
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
1/90
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
United States of America, ))
Plaintiff, ))
v. ) Honorable Sean F. Cox)
City of Detroit, et al. ) Case No. 77-71100)
Defendants. )____________________________________)
NOTICE OF JOINT STATEMENT OF THE UNITED STATES AND MICHIGAN
FOLLOWING OCTOBER 12, 2012 NOTICE
The United States of America, on behalf of the United States Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA), and the State of Michigan, on behalf of the Michigan Department of
Environmental Quality (MDEQ), hereby file this Joint Statement as a follow-up to the United
States October 12, 2012 Notice.
EPA and MDEQ have taken the opportunity to review presentations made by
management consulting firm EMA to the Detroit Sewerage and Water Department (DWSD).
These presentations were dated August 2012 and September 6, 2012 (EMAs Presentations or
EMAs Proposal).
In general, EMA made recommendations concerning a potential reorganization of DWSD
and the deployment, use, and optimization of automation, technology, and systems control for
the purpose of achieving greater efficiency and cost savings. EMA is not an environmental
consultant and its Presentations do not deal directly with EPAs and MDEQs areas of
jurisdiction and expertise. Nevertheless, because EMAs Proposal was raised in DWSDs
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 1 of 90 Pg ID 16702
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
2/90
2
Motion for an Interim Order, EPA and MDEQ reviewed EMAs Proposal to assess whether any
aspects of it appear likely to affect DWSDs compliance with its NPDES permit and the Clean
Water Act (CWA), 33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq.
Since this Courts October 12, 2012 status conference, representatives from DWSD and
EMA presented and explained EMAs Proposal to EPA and MDEQ. EPA and MDEQ also
reviewed available public documentation concerning the Proposal. In addition, from
November 6, 2012, through November 9, 2012, EPA, with the participation and assistance of
MDEQ, conducted a Compliance Evaluation Inspection at the DWSD wastewater treatment
plant.
At this time, EPA and MDEQ take no position on the appropriateness of EMAs
Proposal. However, EPA and MDEQ have identified one aspect of the Proposal that, if
implemented as written, could have a negative impact on CWA compliance: the significant
projected reductions in staffing levels within DWSDs wastewater operations group
(WWOG).1 DWSD informs EPA and MDEQ that the WWOG currently has over 600
employees. By contrast, after implementation of all recommended actions, EMAs Proposal
projects fewer than 150 WWOG employees.2
In discussions with EPA and MDEQ, DWSD managers indicated that EMAs projected
staffing levels have not been adopted by DWSD and are onlyprojections, not a plan. DWSD
1 EPA and MDEQ do not, at this time, take a position or comment upon other recommendations
in EMAs Proposal, including, for example, job classification redesign, computerizedmaintenance management systems improvements, automation and IT support system changes,and control system upgrades.
2 August 2012 EMA PowerPoint Presentation at 16. The August 2012 Presentation lists 68employees under the wastewater manager and 76 employees under the field/central servicesmanager. Some of those 76 field/central services employees will perform duties currentlyundertaken by WWOG employees.
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 2 of 90 Pg ID 16703
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
3/90
3
represented that it intends to move forward with EMAs proposed staffing actions (i.e., job
classification redesign, team training, etc.) in a step-by-step, piloted manner, with time to
evaluate and adjust as necessary. DWSD further represented that no recommended actions
would be implemented that threatened safety or compliance.
Safeguards already in place should help to minimize the risk that reductions in WWOG
staffing levels might undermine DWSDs ability to comply with its NPDES permit and the
CWA:
1. DWSD entered into an Administrative Consent Order (ACO) and a FirstAmended ACO with MDEQ on July 8, 2011, and May 18, 2012, respectively.
The ACO and First Amended ACO are Attachments 1 and 2 to this Notice.
2. Under the ACO, DWSD was required to develop and submit a Staffing Plan thatidentified the minimum number of maintenance and operations staff necessary toproperly operate and maintain the Detroit WWTP and CSO facilities and astrategy for successful succession planning and training to ensure competentstaff. Att. 1 (ACO) 3.6. DWSD submitted that plan at the end of July 2011and MDEQ subsequently approved it. The approved Staffing Plan isAttachment 3 to this Notice.3
3. Under the approved Staffing Plan, the WWOGs minimum staffing level for FY
2011/2012 is 645. Att. 3 (Staffing Plan) at 3. As of October 1, 2012, DWSD wasrequired to staff the WWOG at 90% of the minimum staffing level. Att. 1 (ACO) 3.6.c. The Staffing Plan is an enforceable plan under the ACO. Id. 3.6.a, 4.5.
4. Under the ACO, the WWOGs minimum staffing level can be revised only bymutual agreement between MDEQ and DWSD in writing and incorporated byreference into the ACO. Id. 3.6.f.
3While the Staffing Plan is dated April 1, 2011, DWSD did not submit it to MDEQ until the end
of July 2011 and MDEQ approved it on January 24, 2012. EPA and MDEQ recognize that theapproved Staffing Plan is based, inter alia, on DWSDs 2011 organizational structure and theautomation, technology, and control systems then in place. Changes in these and other areasmay well impact appropriate future minimum staffing levels. DWSD must secure the approvalof MDEQ for any changes in minimum staffing levels.
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 3 of 90 Pg ID 16704
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
4/90
4
At this time, EPA and MDEQ have not identified a basis for seeking relief concerning
DWSDs consideration of EMAs Proposal. EPA and MDEQ will continue to monitor WWOG
staffing levels through the ACO already in place. 4
Because the extent to which specific elements of the Proposal will be implemented
remains to be determined and because EMAs recommendations and DWSDs actions in the
future may change, EPA and MDEQ reserve their right to review future developments to ensure
continuing CWA compliance.
By conducting this review and continuing to monitor the situation, EPA and MDEQ do
not intend to impair DWSDs efforts to undertake appropriate reorganization, automation, and/or
technology and control systems upgrades that DWSD may deem necessary to improve
4 The United States and Michigan are aware that, on November 20, 2012, the Detroit CityCouncil rejected a part of the EMA Proposal that called for a $48 million contract between EMAand DWSD. We also are aware that DWSD recently proceeded with a smaller EMA contractinvolving job classification redesign, training, and implementation. There have been suggestionsthat EPA and/or MDEQ should take a position on the $48 million EMA contract (for example,by approving or disapproving it). While the United States and Michigan reserve the right to takeall actions necessary to ensure compliance with the Clean Water Act and any other applicablefederal or state laws, we are not aware, at this time, of any reason why the United States andMichigan would assert authority to approve or disapprove any contract between DWSD andEMA.
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 4 of 90 Pg ID 16705
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
5/90
5
efficiency, control costs, and address DWSDs need for long-term strategic and financial
planning.
Respectfully Submitted,
FOR THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FOR THE STATE OF MICHIGAN
IGNACIA S. MORENO PAMELA J. STEVENSONAssistant Attorney General Assistant Attorney GeneralEnvironment and Natural Resources Environment, Natural Resources
Division and Agriculture Division
s/ Annette M. Lang s/ with consent of Pamela J. StevensonANNETTE M. LANG PAMELA J. STEVENSONTrial Attorney Assistant Attorney GeneralEnvironmental Enforcement Section Environment, Natural ResourcesEnvironment and Natural Resources Division and Agriculture DivisionP.O. Box 7611 6
thFloor Williams Building
Washington, D.C. 20044-7611 525 West Ottawa St.(202) 514-4213 P.O. Box 30755(202) 616-6584 (fax) Lansing, Michigan [email protected] (517) 373-7540
BARBARA L. MCQUADEUnited States AttorneyEastern District of Michigan
By:
s/ with consent of Peter A. CaplanPETER A. CAPLANAssistant United States Attorney
Eastern District of Michigan211 W. Fort St., Suite 2001
Detroit, MI 48226(313) [email protected]
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 5 of 90 Pg ID 16706
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
6/90
6
OF COUNSEL:
Nicole CantelloAttorney-AdvisorU.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Region 5 (C-14J)77 W. Jackson Blvd.Chicago, IL 60604
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 6 of 90 Pg ID 16707
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
7/90
7
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on December 3, 2012, I electronically filed the foregoing paper withthe Clerk of the Court using the ECF system which will send notification of such filing tocounsel of record and that I caused copies of same to be mailed via U.S. mail as follows:
Joseph W. Colaianne John H. FildewOakland County Corporation Counsel Fildew Hinks1200 N. Telegraph Rd. 26622 Woodward Ave.Suite 419 Bldg. 14E Suite 225Pontiac, MI 48341-0419 Royal Oak, MI 48067
Robert J. Hribar Charles E. Lowe16931 19 Mile Rd. Lowe, LewandowskiMount Clemens, MI 48044 905 W. Ann Arbor Trail
Plymouth, MI 48170
s/ Annette M. LangAnnette M. Lang
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 7 of 90 Pg ID 16708
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
8/90
ATTACHMENT 1
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 8 of 90 Pg ID 16709
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
9/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 9 of 90 Pg ID 16710
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
10/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 10 of 90 Pg ID 16711
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
11/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 11 of 90 Pg ID 16712
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
12/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 12 of 90 Pg ID 16713
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
13/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 13 of 90 Pg ID 16714
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
14/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 14 of 90 Pg ID 16715
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
15/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 15 of 90 Pg ID 16716
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
16/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 16 of 90 Pg ID 16717
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
17/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 17 of 90 Pg ID 16718
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
18/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 18 of 90 Pg ID 16719
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
19/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 19 of 90 Pg ID 16720
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
20/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 20 of 90 Pg ID 16721
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
21/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 21 of 90 Pg ID 16722
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
22/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 22 of 90 Pg ID 16723
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
23/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 23 of 90 Pg ID 16724
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
24/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 24 of 90 Pg ID 16725
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
25/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 25 of 90 Pg ID 16726
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
26/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 26 of 90 Pg ID 16727
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
27/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 27 of 90 Pg ID 16728
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
28/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 28 of 90 Pg ID 16729
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
29/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 29 of 90 Pg ID 16730
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
30/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 30 of 90 Pg ID 16731
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
31/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 31 of 90 Pg ID 16732
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
32/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 32 of 90 Pg ID 16733
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
33/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 33 of 90 Pg ID 16734
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
34/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
35/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 35 of 90 Pg ID 16736
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
36/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 36 of 90 Pg ID 16737
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
37/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 37 of 90 Pg ID 16738
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
38/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 38 of 90 Pg ID 16739
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
39/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
40/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 40 of 90 Pg ID 16741
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
41/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 41 of 90 Pg ID 16742
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
42/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
43/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
44/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 44 of 90 Pg ID 16745
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
45/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
46/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
47/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 47 of 90 Pg ID 16748
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
48/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
49/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 49 of 90 Pg ID 16750
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
50/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 50 of 90 Pg ID 16751
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
51/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
52/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 52 of 90 Pg ID 16753
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
53/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
54/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 54 of 90 Pg ID 16755
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
55/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 55 of 90 Pg ID 16756
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
56/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
57/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 57 of 90 Pg ID 16758
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
58/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 58 of 90 Pg ID 16759
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
59/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
60/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 60 of 90 Pg ID 16761
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
61/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
62/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
63/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
64/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 64 of 90 Pg ID 16765
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
65/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 65 of 90 Pg ID 16766
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
66/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 66 of 90 Pg ID 16767
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
67/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 67 of 90 Pg ID 16768
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
68/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
69/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
70/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
71/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 71 of 90 Pg ID 16772
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
72/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 72 of 90 Pg ID 16773
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
73/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 73 of 90 Pg ID 16774
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
74/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
75/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
76/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 76 of 90 Pg ID 16777
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
77/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
78/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 78 of 90 Pg ID 16779
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
79/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
80/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
81/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
82/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 82 of 90 Pg ID 16783
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
83/90
2:77-cv-71100-SFC Doc # 2509 Filed 12/03/12 Pg 83 of 90 Pg ID 16784
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
84/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
85/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
86/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
87/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
88/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
89/90
7/30/2019 2012-12-03.Joint Statement of EPA and MDEQ Re Oct 12, 2012 Notice
90/90