76
§£¦³²£ ©£¦¬ ¢®³¨ ´£ ±°¦ ¢®³¨ ´£¥ ´³ " ° 1233/08 ²´¬ : §´² £®² , ´ .  . 057859373 ¬ " £ " ¬ ¥ " ²ª¬ ©´£ £ © 75 £¦°² 46403 ¦¢ ' : 9545706 - 09 , «±® : 9573974 - 09 " ¦ : [email protected] - ª - §££³¨ : 1 . ¢¨« ² , ¦´ ¬¦ £²  ©£ ´£ ´¢®³ - £ 2 . ¦´ ¬¦ £²  ©£ ´£ - £ 3 . §£¦³²£ ¬¦ £°² ©£ ´£ 4 . ¦²³£ ´ª£¨ ²° ²³¨ §£«¨ ´³² 5 . «²¢³ªª£¦ ¥£¨ , ª£¨ ²±¨ ¬ " ª£¨ ´¢£¦±²® £ , §£¢®³¨ ²³¨ ¡² ' ¡¦° - ©£ 29 , £ §£¦³² ¦¬ ° ©´¨¦ ²£´¬ - £ª´ , ££ª£ ° ¢¦¡¨ ° §

2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

"1233/08

: ,. .057859373

"""

7546403

' :9545706-09 , :9573974-09

" :[email protected]

--

:1. ,-

2.-

3.

4.––

5. ,

" ,

'-29 ,

-,

Page 2: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

.........................................................................................................................................................3

..................................................................................3...........................................................................4

.....................................................................................................................................................6

..........................................................................................................................................6..............................................................................................................................................8

.........................................................................................................................................9..........................................................................................................................................9

.........................................................................................................................................9

' - ,"..................................................................................................10

..................................12

.................................................................................................................15

,-..........17

–...........................................20

."...........................................................20

...................................................................................21...............................................23

/2-2' '...................25

–....................................................................27

...........................................................................33

"................................................33"–,........36

-2000.......................................................................37 -2004-2005..............................................................40

....................................................................................41

."-2007......................................................................41

.......................................................................................44............................47

"....................................................................................................................53

".......................................................................56

.................................................................57

:-......................................................................................................60

.........................................................................63

..65

.....................................................................................................................................................67

......................................................................................................................................................72

.......................72

............................................................................................................................................73

Page 3: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

3

.""

1951:

" -

;

, ,

."

.

, ,

,2002 .

.' .

)"2909/04]" [06.06.2004 (

8)(:

""– ..."

,

... .

,

."

"2909/04'.

.

,

.

.–

.

" " . ,

,– ,

, , , .

–.

. ,2004

) :3 :" ,

" .(

.)" (

, ,2 :"

Page 4: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

4

, ,

" .

." ,- ,2 :

" ,

, .

.

" ." , :

" , .

.

, .

, ,

" .

" .

.

:

1.-2003

- .

2.2006)"– (

.

3.2004 '" ,

.

. ,

.

.–- .

, ,-

.

.

. , ,

, , ,

,.

Page 5: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

5

. ,

,

,

, .

.

" "" ')

18.1.087 ( :" , ,

]–" [ .

"" , ,"

. . ,

65 ," .

. ,

)( ,

,

.

, , , ,

.

.

,

,

. ,

,

,] '16.06.2005 '21 '27-30 ,

'28 '1-2[:

" :

,-

?

:?

:?

: , ,

."

Page 6: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

6

. , ,

.

. ,

'

, ,, , ,

.

."

,

.

.

. ,

".

1. ,

,:

1.1. ' '5883/05

'– ?

1.2. '?

1.3. '

,27.03.2005"

?

1.4.

?

1.5.-- '

5883/05 '– ,)–"" (

09.03.2006) ' , :

(

?

1.

Page 7: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

7

1.6.

,

?

1.7.1.6 ,

?

1.8.259/06

'–)–"" (

20.09.2006) ' , ' , '

, : (

?

2.

1.9. , ,:

1.9.1.

?

1.9.2.

?

1.9.3.

?

3.

1.9.4.

)

( ,"-1997) :""(?

1.10.:

1.10.1. ,

,

?

1.10.2.502/05 ' ,

-2006)3( ,177)–"" (-

,

93.124) (" ?

Page 8: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

8

1.10.3.674/05 ' ,-

2007)1 (783)–"" (–

?

1.11.

?

1.12.38)5 ( ,"-1958]

[)–"" ("

"-

:?

1.13.

,

,

?

2. , '"

/ '" ,"?

3. ," ,

-

-.

4. ,.

5. ,:

5.1.)"

9607/07"1( ;

107.10.2007 .) ( .

"18.10.07 , "– : .

)" (" ." : ,

."" " , , , .

10.

Page 9: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

9

5.2.-

,–

)( ,

,"-2 ,

10.07.2006" .

5.3."27.03.2005

;

5.4."

200327.03.2005-

" ,

.

6. , ,

) (2003

.

7. ,

, .

8."

.

9.

"" ,.

'"

.

2 '" ,04.08.200586-872005)" (

"-)".(

Page 10: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

10

'-

,"

10. '–

- , ,

77)1 (][ ,"-1984 , '

,

,/ , '

.

11.

.

12.2005"

,] '15.05.2005 , '17 '25-30 , '18 '1-10[:

" , ,

]–"[ , ...

,

, .

, , , ,

, ,

, ....

, ,

. .

... . ."

13. ,

,8.10.2003 ,

," . '

, .

'

.

"8.10.2003'.

14.- , ,

,"' ,

" ' ,

' ,",

Page 11: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

11

,'" "

") " ( ,

," , ,"–

" , , ."

" ' ,3.

15.2006-2007

""' ,:

.THE MARKER ONLINE28.8.2006" :

" :""

140 ''" ," :" ,

' ."

.16/4/2006" : :

36" ," :

, , '

, ,' ."

.24.5.2007G" :

" '

.

.16/7/2007" :

:45 ''"

'.

16. , ':

.14.5.2007.

14.5.07'.

.8.6.2007" .

8.6.0721.6.07'.

3 ," . , .-/19–01.03.04

. ' , ,

)" '19 '16-17 .(–1984 . .

, ,) ,

," , .(

Page 12: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

12

17. ,-

23.2.2006

,

.

23.2.06'.

18. ,"

, , ,"

" , ,

, ,

DUE PROCESS .

19. . ,"

' ,

'.

20. ,

.

21.27.8.2003 ,-

)16( ,

,45) (

,:" ,

, ,

".

22. ,

, , .

.

, . ,

,- .

,05.08.2004 ,

23.11.2004

Page 13: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

13

4 ,14.12.2004

, : ..."

" ,

,... ." ,

,-16

,

." :" ,

" . ,"

14.12.2004 ,

" ,2005 ,

.

23.-16

,

–16- ,

, , .

24. , ,

38)5 ( ,"

" .

25. , -16 ,

,

,

38)5 ( .

"4.

26. :38)5 (" ,

, , :

, ." .

27.30.01.2007

) (

4 , , .

,.

Page 14: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

14

2003 ." '

14.05.2007 , :

"

.

.

,

."

30.01.07 ,5.

"14.05.076.

28." '12.6.07 ,

)(:

"2002 .

.– .

, .

,

. ,

. -

,."

"12.06.077.

29.38)5 (

,

: .

30."" ,

""" , ,

38)5 ( ,) (

2003.

"" " ," "8.

31. , ,

, ,

.

, , ,

,38)5 (

: .

Page 15: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

15

32.:

. ,2006

," ,

.

. ,

"" ,30.01.2007 , :

""]–" [ .

.

," .

. ,

,

.

. , '11.06.07 ,"

"" ' ,

-" ,

"" , :"

" .

. , ,

,

.–

".

33..

20012005"2001.

1.09.2002" ,") () (.

01.01.2003 '270/02 , ,).(

Page 16: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

16

10.02.2003" , ,).(

16.02.2003" ,") () ().(

2003 , ," ,)

(– .

16.03.2003 , , , ,5.

04.03.2003 , , , ,.

17.03.2003 , , ,.

27.07.2003.

27.07.2003" ,".

27.08.2003.

17.09.2003 , , , ,6.

24.09.2003.

5) '1727 ( ."

) .( , ,"" .

3309/032003 , . , , ," " ,

2003."2003 ,

" , ,2003. ," ,

"3309/032003 , ,12.12.02 . ," ,27":

"12.12.02 "... . :24.02.03) (

. , ,2002 .–12.12.02

. ,.

. .73190/04 ' ,"2.1.083309/03 .

24.02.03 , :" , ,

,".

3309/03 '"24.02.2003" . ,

"") (.

" , .

6'.

Page 17: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

17

2004 ," .

,- .

," .

22.01.2004.

29.02.2004"."

16.05.2004" , , ,".

06.06.2004 , , ,) .

.(

05.08.2004.

23.11.2004 ..

22.12.2004 ,).(

05.01.2005".

2005" , , ,".

,

-

34. ,

/ ," . ,

, ,""

. ,93.124) (":

")(

. ,

, .

,

."

35.

,"

, ,

, .12

Page 18: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

18

" "– ,

"" , ,

.

, ,

, , , ,

.

36.- ,

, .

37.2002-2003- ,

/ ,

, , ,

,

. , ,7 ,

.

38.1.9.2002" ,

" ."

-3.

39.16.2.2003" , ,

" , .

40. ,

, ,- ,

.

"-80-90 , ,

, . ,1984

2004 ,

."

)142( ,

.

7 , , :)"4 (

-.6.6.04'

.

Page 19: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

19

41.

– ,

..

42."

2003-2004-2005 , ,

.

"" ." ,

.

43.

, .

44. ,-2" ,

,

. ,

, . ,

" ,

.

45. , ,

,

."

,"" .

,

.

46. ,-

, ,

, ,

"

,

."

, , ,

- ,- ,

, ,

, ,

." ,

Page 20: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

20

, ,

,

, ,

, .

47.

, , ,

"

.

.

48. , ,

, ,

, ,

,

"

."

."

49.:

.

.

..

.

;

.

, ,

;

Page 21: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

21

./ ,8?

50. , , ,

, ,

,

,

"

, ,

,

,

.

,

,

.

.

51. , ,

, .

,

– .

.

52."

, .

,

" ,

, .

53. ,

.

8"-- ,""

30.06.2005 , '59 '12-15" : ....

" , ."....") , '18" :( ,."

Page 22: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

22

54. , ,

.

55. , ,

."886/79" '

,'")2 (693 ,697"

, '

:"" .

, ,

,

.

56.

: : .

57.

,

-10.10.2006 ,:

"

, ,

.

45 ."

58." "

,9 .

" ,

.

, ,"10.10.2006

" , '"

"

" ."

. , , '" :

9- , ' ,3 ,"

" :" , ' :"

" .

Page 23: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

23

. ," .

, , :"

,

" . .

59.- , ,

,

, , : ,

: .

.

60. ,

-.

.

61.

,-

-– .

62.

.

" ,

" ,.

63. '"

,

.

64."–

,

, ,

."

. ?" ,

Page 24: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

24

,

– . ,

,

,

, .

,.

65."

,

.

66.

" ,

,

, , ,

.

67. ,

, ,

, , ,

.

68. ," , ,

,"

,"

.

Page 25: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

25

/2-2' '

69."7 ,

:

) () (

12.04.2005

15.05.2005

16.06.2005

30.06.2005

07.07.2005

04.08.2005

09.08.2005

70. , '/

" ,

" .

71." ,

, , :

.7 ;

. ;

. .

72.

.

"-

, , ,

, .

,

,

.

73.8

,

Page 26: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

26

. ,

)16"(

,)25"(" ,

, "- .

,

"– .

74./2-2'" ' ,"560)–"'" (

–-

" , ,

, , .

75.

,

, , ,

,

.

) (

,

).(

76.'" ,

. ,

, ,

, ,

,

.

77.

,)

( ,

Page 27: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

27

,–

,

, ,

.

78."

. ,"

,

.

79.

.

" '

".

80. , ,

24.03.2005 , ' , ,

:"?" . '

" : ."

' ," :

, ,

." '

,

,"28 .

'28 ,

"" :

".

81." , , , :"

"" .

82. ,

'

" , '

" ,3 :

Page 28: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

28

"3 ."

')27.3.05 (" ,

"."

83. ' ,:

"1 .."

84.–""" , , ,

, ,

.

85. ."

,

.

86." ,

) : .(

87. ,

,–– . , ,

, ,

,"

" ,

,

: ,

: .

88. ,""

/ , ,

, ,

.

89." ' ,

, .

. ,

,

.

Page 29: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

29

-

, '

,

, . '

" ,

" . ,"

"" ,

.

90. ,"-–

,

.– ,

,

" , :

."

, , ,

. ,

,

" . ,

, ,

. ,

"

. , , ,

,10 .

91. , , ,

,

" ,

– ,

" ,

.

," ,

, .

10" , ' , ,

.""" '–.

" ," ," : ,."

Page 30: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

30

92. , ' ,

" ,"

,

" .79][ ,"-

1984 , ,

"

. ,"

,

,

. ,– ,

, ,

".

93.

,".

94. '

,

, , , ,"

. '

, ' .

, ' ,

'

,

'

. ,"

' , ,

'.

95." ,

/–

" ,

, ,

.

Page 31: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

31

96. ,"

"–"/

, ,

".

97. ,"

" ,

) ( , , ,

,""

, , ,

." ,

)

( , ,

"

,.

98. , ,

,"

,

- ,

.

99. , '"" ,"

)11 (

,"

.

100.

,

," " ,

) :"/3–43 '

" ,)1 (85 ;" /3–3" '

,"233 ,237 .(

,

.

11"" ,.

Page 32: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

32

101."

.

102. ,

,"

,

"–,

, ,

,"

, .

103. , ,

,"

, .

104."

,

. ,

, ,

" ,

' ,

. ," ,

, .

105. , '"

, , ,

, '"

"" " .

106. , '

"" " ,/

'.

107.

– ,–.

Page 33: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

33

"

108. , ,

, . ?

" ,

" .

" "2005 ,

.

" ,

" . ,1996 ,

,-" "

2003 , ,

./)

07.07.2005 '77-78(" '12 .

26.03.03'.

109. : ,"

) '07.07.2005 , '64 '11-17( '

) '07.07.2005 , '68 '12(]–"

":[

" -- ,

," ,

."

12 '7":" , ,"

26/12/96 , . ,

) '."("––

)109 .() '07.07.2005 '78 '12-13 (1996.

, '2003" "1996 , ,

'""- , ' ,

," " , . -04.09.200734 , :"

–" .– ' .

Page 34: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

34

110. ,13 . ,"

, ,

.

, , .

, ' ,

"

,

, ,

, ,".

111. :-" ,

) '3-410.07.06(:

"]-"[84 ,

,90? ....

]

"–"[ ,

.' , '

, .63"– .

."

112. :" ,

" , .

2003 , ,

.2003)

– '7" ( ,

. ,

1989

, ' , ,

2005-6 ,

,"-14 .

1310 '13" ' ," ,

, ' , . , ,

.14/ , '

,07.07.2005 '77 '22 '. , ' ' .

Page 35: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

35

,"

1996 .

113."

," ,

.

114." " ,

,1997 .

"

1997 .

, ,

2005 , . :

" " , , ,

. , .

" ,

,

, , .

.

115. ,3 ,

,)" (

"

,)" ( .

,]

)07.07.2005 '79 '13-15( ,"15[ , , ,

, , .3

" ," , ,

.

116."

) :

( , ,

" ,

."

15) '79 '13-15 ( ," : .."

Page 36: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

36

. ," " .

,

.

,02.10.2007

" :".

02.10.2007'.

117." , '

" .

, ,".

"–

,

118. '

. ,

.")"–" () '

12.4.2005 , '9 '13-29 , '10 '1-14()(:

""-...

" , .

" ."2003

," , ,

,

, , , ,

, ,

, , , .

" ." ,

, , ,

, , . ,

,...

- , ,

,...

. ,

.

...]–"[

."

Page 37: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

37

119." ,

,"

.

, '

.

120. , '"

,

,.

-2000.

121."2"- "2000 ,

"" , .

122.-2" "2000--

".""-"

:" , ,

.") '10.07.2006 '3

(.

123.2" , :

2000 ;2000– :11 .

124.2- , ,

,11

, , :

. ,)

(" "26.11.00" "

" "11 ,7.12.00;

. ,

" "26.11.00" "" "11 ,

7.12.00 .

,;

.-2""

" , ,

Page 38: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

38

2000" ,

;

. ,2"

;

. ,

,11 , ,

, . ,"

" " .

125. .

"16 ."

" " , ,

,

.–"

"2005 , ,

" ,

/) '04.08.2005 '91 '5-8(" : ,

, , ,

, .... ,

."

126.14.10.1999"

, , , , ,

.–"

.

"

.

.

")27(

," ,

"

, ,

, ,

2004.

16.

Page 39: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

39

127. ,

2000 , ,

.

2000)" ,

15.05.2005 '9 '19-24 .(

128."2000

,2")

, .(

129. ,2001

. .

""2000.

130."2001

] :

,– .[ '

"2001]/26[ ,

" .

131.")28" (" ,

2000––

,

"– ,

? ! ,

.

132.:

.

2002-2003 ;

."" ,

,

, '".

Page 40: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

40

-2005-2004

133.2" . .

" ,

,"

.

2" ,

2004 ,2004 .

, , ,

.

134." ,

,) '09.08.2005 '23 '16-28(:

:"16.5.2004– '–

: ." . .

:2?

:.

:3 '–

: .

.

. .

:"2005–/20–1

?

: ."2 ,3.

:?

:.

135. ,

, ,

.

Page 41: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

41

136.

,

- .

137. ,

, .

138.

, , ,

. ,

,,

,

,

, ,

" .

139.

" , .

,

.

."-2007

140."18.10.2007 ,

" ,

,

, ,

" ,

.

. .63188/05]-" [18.10.07'.

141." ,.63188/05]-" [

' . ,"

1990 , ,

) '53 '6-2( :""

Page 42: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

42

- . .

... ." , .

" .

142."18.10.2007-

.63188/05" ,-

, ,

– , ,

,

- .

, ,"

, ,

.-") '54 '12-8 , '56 '

32-20 , '57 '4-1 , '57 '28-21 , '58 '5-3( :

: ,

, ?

... : , .

: ? ?

: , .

...

:" , ?

? ?

: .

: , . -

?

:. ....

: -–

1990 ,-1990" .1990

?

: .

:-2003

?

:.

:5]"6–" [ .

?

: .

.

Page 43: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

43

: - . ?

: ,- .

:)'/4' .(

- ?

: - , - ,

.-

."

143."

. , ,

,

.

144. ,"

:"" , .

.""

" " :"" .

– . .

.

145." ,

–18.10.2007,

,

," , .

,

" , ,2005

,.

146." , , ,

, .27

– .

3"

"– ,-2

,"

Page 44: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

44

."

,.

147."

"

" , , .

148.

- , , ,

"

-

, .

.

149. , ,

,)

12.4.05 , '19 '16 '20 '16 , '21 '16-21()(:

"":

68 '7 .9365/01 '

'.

3.4.200511:00

,12:45 ,

-10

,

, :"

".

,

.

, ,

,

.

–4.4 .

, ,–4.4 .19:10

.–6.4 .17:05

Page 45: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

45

" :

".

. .

.

.

,

.

....

,

, ,

.

...

" :

,

,

.

."

150.15.05.2005) ' '1 '6-16 , '4 '13-16 , '8 '20-21 , '

9 '19-23 , '13 '1-6) ((:

":

..

9389 ,".

.

.

, .

..

.

-

.

...

..

.

–?

. ..

Page 46: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

46

....

:..

,

. ,

. ,

. .

..

.

."

:

..

89 ,'16 ,.

.

,

.

."

151. ,

," ,

,""17.

– .

,

.

152." , ,

,

" ,

17 ," , . ?" '

" , ,- . ' .

' , .

Page 47: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

47

, ,

)/13 ,/16.(

153."

, , .

– , , ,

, , .

, ," ,"

– .

.

154.

.

)

(–-

, ,

.

,

.

,-10 !!!

'"9:

'1 - ')" , ,1989(

") '

12.04.2005 , '3 '14( ,

) , '4 '10-11( ,

") , '5 '12(.

)" , ,

1988(:

"-15 .

) '15.05.2005 '3 '4-6( , ,

,

Page 48: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

48

) , '3 '15-16( ,

. ,

?

. .) , '4 '28-29(,.

. , , ,

?

.) , '5 '

22-24.(

.?

. . ,' .) ,

'7 '28-29..(

) ,1980(:

" .

, .

) '9 '16-17.(

.?

. ..

.

?

. ,.

. ,?

.) , '12 '11-18(.

) ,1989(:

"– .

, ,

, . , .

. ,

.

.

]2003–"[

.

]–" [ .

-360]"180–"[

, .

. ,

, ') '15.05.2005 '14 '1-20.[

Page 49: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

49

.

,

?

.?

.?

. ,

,) '16.06.2005 , '21 '

27 '22 '2( .

)" , ,

1988(:

"90

, ,

) ,

'24 '23-25(, ,

" ") , '24 '29-

30( ,) , '25 '4.(

)" , ,

1989(:

" ,

, ,

.

.

") , '27 , '29 '28 '2.(

) ,

1990:(

" ,

) '30.06.2005 '56 '12-14(,

) , '57 '1-2( ,

"

.

.]"

–" .[

) '57 '6-10( ,

Page 50: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

50

.

.

. .

.) , '57 '20-25( ,

) , '58 '5-6(.

) ,

1990(:

. ?

..

.?

..

.?

. , .

, .

) , '63 '1-8(.

,) ,1977 ,2006 (:

" . .

, .

.

) '07.07.2005

'72 '20-25( , . , , ,

,

. . .

-2003 ,

) ,'74 '4-8( ,

.

) ,'75 '22-23( .

) , -80 ,0062(:

") '04.08.05

'86 '27( ,) , '87 '12(.

155."

:

Page 51: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

51

.–

;

.– ;

.– ,

,

.

156. ,18 , .

,-

01.09.2002. : ,

,"01.09.2008 ,

.

157." ,

.".

1830.06.2005 '58 '63–– , , ,)

18.09.2003 .(") '60 '22 :("" .")

18.09.2003 ( , ,-/18"" : , ,

, ." '/7-/11"" ,

-9 , , , , , .

.) '09.08.2005 '17 '11-17 ,21-23:(

" .. .... . . ." : ,

,.

..... .? . , .

! ,"

, .

, , , ,– ," " ,

, ,-- ,.

, ' , , ,/1 ,/7 ,/11 ,

18.09.2003" " , ,-3

. .

Page 52: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

52

"

,)16"(

.

158.")( ,

" " ,"

01.09.2002- , ,9

,

,

.

159. ,

-)30" ("

.

"- .

20032003 ,

.

"-90 ,

," ,

2000 ,2001

)/26.(

160. , , ,

.-2"

,-19 .

,"

,

.–-10 ,

,2

" .

, ' ,

,-2 ,

19 ," ,.

Page 53: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

53

. ,2"

,.

161. ,

,

. ,

,.

162. ,

,

,

93.124) (" .

, ,

, .

163. ,

" , ,

.

"

164. ,

, ,

)25"(" ,

,

"- .

165./)( ,

. ,-

,

" " , , , ,

,

.

166. ,"

,"]/24 []/23 [

]/25 [) :/4 ,

/2 .(

Page 54: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

54

167.

,

.

168." ,

, ,"

,– , .

,

, ,

, ,-22 ,

,.

169." ,

)30"("

, . "–

.34""

."

" ,.

170."1989 ,

,] '15.05.2005 '13 '1-28[:

"]2004–" .... [

, .

. ,

, ,

" , ." ,

,

, ,

, ,]–" [

, ,

, ... ,

, ....

, ,

. .

2002 .-2004 .

...

,."

Page 55: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

55

171. ,".

172.] '16.06.2005 , '21 '21-26 , '22 '18-21[:

"]–" [

... . ,

25%]–" []–" [ ,

-17 ,18 ,]–" [

7-8 ,-1-3)/8 ... .(]

–" [ ."

173. ,

.

174. ,

.

,

.

175. :

.

, ,

.

,

.

.

."

,"

2003 ,

,

. ,

" ,

.

.-90 ,

,

.

Page 56: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

56

"

176.- ,":

"

, ,

.

45 ."

177. ,

, ,

, ,

,

, ,

.

178. ,

, ,

.

179. ,

, ,

, ,

, ,

, .

Page 57: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

57

180."2003 ,

. ,

2007 ,

' , ,

/ .

.2006-2007 ,

10.10.2005 ,

"" , ,"

,20 .–

, . ,

, , . . ,

, ,- ,- ,

,

, ,

. , ,.

"'.

181. , ,

, ,

, .

.

182. ,

, ,.

183. , ,

,

.

184. ,

,

,

.

20 ,"- , ,.

," , .

Page 58: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

58

185. ,

, ,

,"

,"

.

186.– , , .

, ,

" ,,

, . ,- ,

, ,

, ,

,

, , ,

, . ,

,"

."

,- , , ,

,

- , ,

,-

.

187.- ,

,

, .

.

.

188."" ,

,,)( :

"5 . , ,

"-

".

Page 59: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

59

6 ." ,

,

.

9 . , ,/

,

"

,/

21.

10 .

, ,

, , ,

, ;

;

;

.

11 . ,

,

.

,

.

14 .

,

21")"–"( ,12.04.2005 '10 '6-14 :" ....

. ...."....

') '16 '5 :("" ."" ,12.04.2005 '9 '27 '10 '4 :

"- , ,)–" ( , , ,

, , , ,

". : , '

. , , ," -) (" ,

"") ( ,- ," . , , ,

, , .

Page 60: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

60

".

15 . ,

"– ,

,

."

189. ," .

. ' .

- ,

.–.

:

-

190. , , ,

, , ,

,.

191.

, ,

.

192./

. ," , ,

, ,

,

,

,

,

.

193.:

"13 ... . ,

,-

,

... .

Page 61: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

61

14 ... . -" "

,... .

15 ... . ,

.

,

- ,

,- ... .

, ,

... .

27 . ,

, .

.... .

... . ,

. ,

. ,... .

93.124" ,

,... .

""

.... :

,

.

, , ,

" ,

."

194. ," ,

,"

)2005"( ,

"–

195.)1( :"

" . , ,

:

"20 ... .–

– , ,

Page 62: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

62

. . ,

,. ,

, . ,

.

) ,

– ; , , '209 '

219 .( ,

, ,

)39) .( ,

, , ,

.

21 . .

, .

, ,

. , ,

.

.

,.

22 .

'- ,

, .

, ,".

196. ,

.

,

"

."

, ,

,

, , .

197.

, , ,

Page 63: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

63

, , ,

.

198." ,

. ," , ,

, .

.

199. , ,

,

.

200."

,.

201.")" ("

." ,

.

,

," ,

,

.

202. ," ,

,

.

203. ,:

27.7.07""

:"

"

,

– ... .

. ,

Page 64: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

64

,

?."

21.1.08 ,"

:"

"– .

:") (–

."

21.1.08 ,"

X:"

") ( ,

. , ,

."

22.1.08"

:"

" : ,

. ..

: .

,

. .

."

22.1.08:

""" :"

."

22.1.08""

:"

"" ,

" "––

."

24.1.08:

""

) ( .

,

Page 65: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

65

" . .

, ,

."

11.

204. ,

,

, ,

.

205." ,

" , ,

.

206.22.01.2008" "

."

, .

""

.

207." ," ,

,28.1.08 :

" ... .

, ,

, ,

, , ,

, ,

."

208. ,

, ,"

.

209. ,

" ,

Page 66: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

66

, , ,

, .

210. ,

.

, ,

, ,

,

.

211.

, . ,

, .

, ,

.

212.

, , ,

.

213. , ,

, , , .

214. ,

,18

,"-1984 ,

,.

215.""

525/84 ' ' ,")1 (673 ,693-695 ,

:

" , ,

."

216. ,

" : ;

.

Page 67: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

67

217. ,"

, ,

.

218. ,

" , ,

, ,

,

,

, .

,

/

/–"

–– .

" ,

: , ,

, , ,

.

219."

,"

,

,"

.

220. ,2000

--90 ,

2003 :" . .

.

, , , ," .

221. ," ./14"06.08.2003

/ :

Page 68: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

68

"5.8.0318:30"

.

10."

222./)16.06.2005 '25 '27( .

223./ ,)

2003 ("" ,

")30.06.2005 '58 '5-7( :"

."

" . :

.

224.

. ,:

.30.08.2004"

.

, , , ,

" ,

")(22 , .

. ,

19.01.200522:00

." ,

, , ,

.

.

.19.12.2007 ,

.

" , ,

. , , .

.

22 , ," , , , , . ,

,-12 , . ," ," ,

– , , , , .

Page 69: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

69

.02.01.2008 ,. .73190/04

]–" [ ' . ,

" , ,"

.) '90-91(:

":

,

, , ,

,– , , ,

,

. ,

.

, ,-

. , ,

.

. ,

, .-22

04' . .

, .

) ( , ,

. .

:

) (–– . .

, , .

. . .

. . ,

. .– ,

. , .

, .) (

,–.

. - .

. ,.

. ,

,, ."– .

–,," , .

. .

. , .,,

Page 70: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

70

?? ." .

, ,

. . .

, .– . ,

, ,

, . , .

, : , , ,

, , .

, ,

.

, ,– .

, . ,

, ,

: , ,

. ,– ,.

. .

? . ,

) ( .-

. . ,."

. .73190/04] -" [02.01.08'.

.06.01.2008. .73190/04]

–" [ ' . '

,"

""

." ,"" :

" ."

- .

.03.02.2008 , '

'2007 ,

.

-

.- '

. ''

, ,

.

225. : .

Page 71: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

71

, ,2003 ,

:

,

,

)( ,

- ,

- ,

" "- ,

,

,

" ,

,

)( ,

.

226. , ,

, .

" . ,23 ," ,

. , ," .

" ,"

,"

–"

."

, ,

,

. ,

, ,

23" :" ."

9.

Page 72: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

72

."

."

, ,

,–

– , , ,

.

227. , , ,

-5 ,–

– .

.

228. ,

.

, ,

,

, ,

, , ,

.

229. : ,

.

230. , , ,

,

, ,

,

,- ,

/ ,

, , . ,

, ,

,.

Page 73: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

73

231. , ,

, ,

,

- .

)

,2002-2003( ,

.

232. ,

. ,

,

," :

" " ." ,

")" (

,

,-01.09.2002

,

, ,

,

.

233. ,) , (–

,– .

,

,.

.

234."4191/97 ' ,")5 (330 ,381

':

" - - .

. ,

") " ,)( ( , ,

--- .

- .."

Page 74: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

74

235. ' ,

.

236.:

.

5.2 ,

- ,

.

.

,

.

237. '""

.

____________

,"

"

Page 75: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

1.

2.

3.

4.

530.01.07

.

6" '14.05.07.

7" '12.06.07.

8"" "16.08.2007

29.08.2007 ." "14.08.2007.

9" :

."

10.

11.

Page 76: 2008-02-07 Rotem v Samet et al (1233/08) petition in the High Court of Justice – original petition record // רותם נ סאמט ואח', בג"ץ (1233/08)- כתב העתירה

,. .057859373"

.

__________________________________

" ,",04.02.2008 ,

/" '057859373

,

.

___________________________