25
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC- BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not make commercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution to the author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review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

2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

2*.(��4-".��*()32�3/��/,%�3)&� ��$$/4.3"#,&�'/1�*32��.3*��&7��1"''*$+*.(�(&.%"���)&� .*5&12",��&1*/%*$��&5*&6".%�.&6�%*1&$3*/.2�'/1� ��0/,*$8

�+:3� �/:=6���3/;2+��-�=:<3;�� !/7/589/� $+=7./:;�� +7.

$< 92+73/�(+2+,�

�#231"$3

/BG<>�MA>�I:LLBG@�H?�MA> %:+003-4371�'3-<36;�!:8</-<387��-<�80����:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�>??HKML�A:O>�@KHPG�BG�?NG=BG@�IHEBMB<:E�LMK>G@MA�:G=IHINE:K�<NEMNK>�:II>:E�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�:G=�@EH;:EER��,:KMB<NE:KERBG?EN>GMB:E�BG�LA:IBG@�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�IHEB<R�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�:K>:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG� :=OH<:M>L� PAH� :K>� IKBF:KBER� <HG<>KG>=� PBMAK>A:;BEBM:MBG@� L>Q� PHKD>KL� :G=� >K:=B<:MBG@� L>QN:E� <HFF>K<>�/BFNEM:G>HNL�MH�MA>�=>O>EHIF>GM�H?�IKHAB;BMBHGBLM�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�>??HKML�BG�MA>�1/�FHO>F>GML�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AMLA:O>�:ELH�@KHPG�BG�LMK>G@MA�:G=�OBLB;BEBMR� BG?EN>G<BG@�:�O:KB>MR�H?<NEMNK:E�:<:=>FB<�:G=�IN;EB<�A>:EMA�:K>G:L��3ABE>�L>Q�PHKD>K�:<MBOBLMLA:O>� PB=>G>=� MA>� =B:EH@N>� :KHNG=� L>Q� PHKD>KLY� KB@AML� MA>BK

� �<DGHPE>=@>F>GML��3>� :K>� @K>:MER� BG=>;M>=� MH� MA>� A:K=�PHKD� H?� <HNGME>LL

L>Q�PHKD>K� LH<B:E� CNLMB<>� :G=� ANF:G� KB@AML� :<MBOBLML��+NK� :EEB>L� :K>� ?:K� MHHF:GR�MH�G:F>�A>K>�;NM�BG�I:KMB<NE:K�P>�P:GM�MH�MA:GD�MA>�?HEEHPBG@�I>HIE>:G=�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�PAH�P>K>�<KN<B:E�=NKBG@�MA>�1,.�IKH<>LL�:G=�MA>�PKBMBG@�H?MABL� :KMB<E>�� .:<A>E��BF>>� :K:� �:KEBG� /B>GG:� �:LDBG�)>EBLL:� �KHN=H� ':M> Y�=:FH�'>EEB� HKL>R�.H;BG� NGG��RG=>>��E:R�.H;RG�">P��A>�#HLL>MM��G=B"KB>=F:G� :K;R� $B<D>R��GG� &HK=:G� (N<B>G� &NLMB<>� &�� 'BK;R� �:KHE� (>[email protected]<<B� (>OR� /NL:G� (HI>S�!F;NKR� &BEE� )<�K:<D>G� BE<B:� )HEBG:� �A:O:GG:*:G<A>KE:�5HE:G=:�+KHS<H�/:K:A�,:HE>MMB�/:G=>>I�,K:L:=��N=:<B:�.:R��G=K>:.BM<AB>��AKBLMBG>�/:K=BG:�/NK@>HG�&:RG>�/PB?M�/M:<>R�/PBFF>�.&�0AHFILHG:G=�F>F;>KL� H?�� ��5/3�*� �>LM� ,K:<MB<>L� ,HEB<R� ,KHC><M� �>GM>K� ?HK�$>:EMA:G=�#>G=>K�!JNBMR���$�*#!�� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� B??>K>GM��O>GN>L�$%,/�):=K>0B>KK:� *>P� 5HKD� $:KF� .>=N<MBHG� !=N<:MHKL� />QN:E� .B@AML� %GBMB:MBO>� /M�&:F>L� %G?BKF:KR� />Q�3HKD>KL� ,KHC><M� />Q�3HKD>KL� +NMK>:<A� ,KHC><M� �/3+,1/�� :G=� /3+,� �A:IM>KL�� 1/� $NF:G� .B@AML� *>MPHKD� :G=�3HH=ANEE� />QN:E"K>>=HF��EEB:G<>�� 0ABL� ABLMHKR� <HNE=� GHM� A:O>� ;>>G� PKBMM>G� PBMAHNM� RHNK=>=B<:MBHG� <HEE:;HK:MBHG� :G=� I>KL>O>K:G<>� HG� ;>A:E?� H?� ANF:G� KB@AML� ?HKI>HIE>�BG�MA>�L>Q�MK:=>�

Page 2: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

I>KLI><MBO>L�A:O>�GHM�NGMBE�K><>GMER�;>>G�:<DGHPE>=@>=�;R�1/�IHEB<RF:D>KL��%G�MABL�:KMB<E>�P>�?BKLM�MK:<>�MA>�K><>GM�LH<B:E�ABLMHKB>L�H?;HMA�MA>�G>P�IKHAB;BMBHGBLM�:G=�MA>�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�FHO>F>GML�BGMA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L��*>QM�P>�=>L<KB;>�MA>�NGIK><>=>GM>=�<HEE:;HK:MBO>:<MBOBLM�IKH<>LL�;R�PAB<A�:�ANF:G�KB@AML�:@>G=:�?HK�1/�;:L>=�L>QPHKD>KL�P:L�BGMKH=N<>=�:G=�:IIKHO>=�:M�MA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�$NF:G.B@AML��HNG<BE�MAKHN@A�MA>�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P��1,.��IKH<>LL�3>�?HEEHP�PBMA�:G�:G:ERLBL�H?�AHP�MA>�1,.�IKH<>LL�AB@AEB@AML� MA>HG@HBG@�BFIHKM:G<>�H?�MA>�@EH;:E�ANF:G�KB@AML�<HFFNGBMR�?HK�;KBG@BG@:�=BO>KLBMR�H?�F:K@BG:EBL>=�OHB<>LWBG<EN=BG@�MAHL>�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KLWMHMA>�:MM>GMBHG�H?�1/�IHEB<R�F:D>KL��3>�<HG<EN=>�PBMA�:G�:LL>LLF>GM�H?MA>�NGBJN>�IHEB<R�K>?HKF�HIIHKMNGBMB>L�:G=�<A:EE>G@>L�?:<>=�;R�L>QPHKD>K�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�:<MBOBLML�:L�:�K>LNEM�H?�MABL�ABLMHKB<�FHF>GM�

�&8�!/1%2� ANF:G�KB@AML�L>Q�PHKD�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<.>OB>P�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�MK:??B<DBG@�

,E>:L>� <BM>� MABL� :KMB<E>� :L�� '� (>KNF�>M� :E�� X1LBG@� $NF:G� .B@AML� MH�$HE=� MA>�1/�<<HNGM:;E>�?HK�BML��GMB�/>Q�0K:??B<DBG@��@>G=:��0A>�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P�:G=G>P�=BK><MBHGL�?HK�1/�IHEB<RY %2/��7<3�%:+003-4371�#/>3/?�%LLN>��������II��������

&HNKG:E� 1.(�� PPP�:GMBMK:??B<DBG@K>OB>P�HK@

�<�3;�-:3<3-+5�<2+<�<2/�18>/:76/7<�?8:4�<8�;A;</6+<3-+55A�37>85>/�;/@

?8:4/:;�37�9853-A�./-3;387;�<2+<�+00/-<�<2/6��$9/-303-+55AE/53637+</

0/./:+5� 9853-3/;� <2+<� -8705+</� ;/@�?8:4�?3<2� 2=6+7� <:+003-4371�

37>/;<31+</�+7.�9:/>/7<�2=6+7�:312<;�+,=;/;�9/:9/<:+</.�,A�;<+</

+1/7<;�+1+37;<�;/@�?8:4/:;��+7.�/@+637/�<2/�369+-<�80�-:3637+53;+<387

87�8=:�-866=73<3/;�

������ :K;R�$B<D>R�:<MBOBLM�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K:G=�MK:GL@>G=>K�KB@AML�

�"$*.(�3/�3)&� .*3&%��"3*/.2

�M���:F�HG����):K<A������ :K;R�$B<D>R��P:L�LIKBGMBG@�MAKHN@A�MA>@:M>L�H?�MA>�,:E:BL�=>L�*:MBHGL�BG�#>G>O:�/PBMS>KE:G=��/A>�A:=�;>>G

� -NHM>�?KHF� :K;R�$B<D>RYL�LI>><A�MH�MA>�1*�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE����):K<A�����

� :K;R� $B<D>R� BL� :�F>F;>K� H?� MA>� �>LM� ,K:<MB<>L� ,HEB<R� ,KHC><M� AMMI� PPP�;>LMIK:<MB<>LIHEB<R�HK@�

Page 3: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

GHFBG:M>=�;R�:�;KH:=�<H:EBMBHG�H?�:<MBOBLML��MH�K>IK>L>GM�MA>�?:<>�:G=OHB<>�H?�MA>�1/�L>Q�PHKD>KLY�KB@AML�FHO>F>GM��$>K�FBLLBHG�P:L�MHL><NK>�HG>�H?�M>G�:O:BE:;E>�<BOBE�LH<B>MR�LI>:DBG@�LEHML�:M�MA>�1*�E:M>KMA:M�=:R���0A>�>O>GM�PHNE=�F:KD�MA>�<HG<ENLBHG�H?�MA>�1/YL�?BKLM�1GBO>KL:E,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P��1,.��:M�MA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BEPA>K>�MA>�1/�K><>BO>=�����K><HFF>G=:MBHGL�?KHF�BML�@EH;:E�I>>KL�?HKBFIKHOBG@�BML�ANF:G�KB@AML�K><HK=��0A>L>�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL�MHN<A>=HG�:�K:G@>�H?�BLLN>L�BG<EN=BG@�MA>�=>:MA�I>G:EMR�K:<B:E�IKH?BEBG@�MA>KB@AML�H?�BG=B@>GHNL�I>HIE>L�BFFB@K:MBHG�IHEB<R�:G=�@:R�E>L;B:G;BL>QN:E�MK:GL@>G=>K��#(�0��KB@AML���+G>�H?�MA>L>�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL������P:L�F:=>�;R�F>F;>K�LM:M>�1KN@N:R�NK@BG@�MA>�1/�MH��X>GLNK>:<<>LL�MH�IN;EB<�L>KOB<>L�I:RBG@�:MM>GMBHG�MH�MA>�LI><B:E�ONEG>K:;BEBMRH?�7L>Q8�PHKD>KL�MH�OBHE>G<>�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�:;NL>LY��

3BMA�MA>�A>EI�H?�/:G=>>I�,K:L:=�:��:G:=B:G�ANF:G�KB@AML�:=OBL>KPBMA�MA>�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�G>MPHKD�MA>�/>QN:E�.B@AML�%GBMB:MBO>��/.%��$B<D>RP:L�:;E>�MH�L><NK>�MA>�M>GMA�:G=�?BG:E�LI>:D>KYL�L>:M���$B<D>R�:G=�A>K<HEE>:@N>L�DG>P�MA:M�=NKBG@�MA>�1,.�F>>MBG@�E:M>K�MA:M�:?M>KGHHG�MA>1/�PHNE=�F:D>�H??B<B:E� BML�G>P�IHLBMBHG�MA:M��X*H�HG>�LAHNE=�?:<>OBHE>G<>�HK�=BL<KBFBG:MBHG�BG�:<<>LL�MH�IN;EB<�L>KOB<>L�;:L>=�HG�L>QN:EHKB>GM:MBHG�HK�MA>BK� LM:MNL�:L�:�I>KLHG� BG�IKHLMBMNMBHG�Y�0ANL� CNLMAHNKL�:?M>K�A>K�=K:F:MB<�K:<>�MH�MA>�,:E:BL�=>L�*:MBHGL�$B<D>R�P:L:==K>LLBG@�MA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE��%G�A>K�IK>I:K>=

� 0ABL�;KH:=�<H:EBMBHG��PAB<A� BG<EN=>=�MA>�?HNK�:NMAHKL�H?�MABL�:KMB<E>��MHHD�HGMA>� G:F>� H?� Z$NF:G� .B@AML� ?HK��EE[� ?HK� MA>� INKIHL>� H?� K>LIHG=BG@� MH� MA>1GBO>KL:E� ,>KBH=B<� .>OB>P� IKH<>LL� AMMI� PPP�ANF:GKB@AML?HK:EE�BG?H�

� /I>:D>KL� BG� MABL� ?HKNF�FNLM�;>�:??BEB:M>=�PBMA�:�1*�:<<K>=BM>=�*#+��$B<D>RP:L�BGOBM>=�;R�MA>�/>QN:E�.B@AML�%GBMB:MBO>�:G=�F>F;>K�@KHNI��<MBHG��:G:=:?HK�,HINE:MBHG�:G=� >O>EHIF>GM�

� $NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE�3HKDBG@�#KHNI�HG�MA>�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P�*BGMAL>LLBHG �:+0<�:/98:<�80�<2/�(8:4371��:8=9�87�<2/�&73>/:;+5�!/:38.3-�#/>3/?�&73</.�$<+</;�80��6/:3-+�����#��(����������$.��#>G>O:��W���*HO>F;>K�����

� 0A>� ?NEE� K><HFF>G=:MBHG� K>:=L�� X1G=>KM:D>� :P:K>G>LL�K:BLBG@� <:FI:B@GL� ?HK<HF;:MBG@� LM>K>HMRI>L� :G=� OBHE>G<>� :@:BGLM� @:RL� E>L;B:GL� ;BL>QN:EL� :G=7MK:GL@>G=>K� I>HIE>8� :G=� >GLNK>� :<<>LL� MH� IN;EB<� L>KOB<>L� I:RBG@� :MM>GMBHGMH� MA>� LI><B:E� ONEG>K:;BEBMR� H?� 7L>Q8� PHKD>KL� MH� OBHE>G<>� :G=� ANF:G� KB@AML:;NL>L�Y� 0A>� MK:GLE:MBHG� H?� 1KN@N:RYL� K><HFF>G=:MBHG� NL>L� MA>� M>KFLZMK:GLL>QN:EL[� :G=� ZL>QN:E�PHKD>KL[�� %G� HNK� :=OH<:<R� K>LIHGL>�P>� BGL>KM>=MA>� M>KFL� ZMK:GL@>G=>K� I>HIE>[� :G=� ZL>Q�PHKD>KL[� PAB<A�FHK>� :<<NK:M>ERK>?E><M�M>KFL�NL>=�BG�MA>�1/�

� 0A>�IKH<>LL�H?�PBGGBG@�HG>�H?�M>G�HIIHKMNGBMB>L�L>M�:LB=>�?HK�GHG�@HO>KGF>GM:EHK@:GBL:MBHGL� �*#+L�� MH� K>LIHG=� MH� MA>� 1,.� H?� MA>�1GBM>=� /M:M>L� BGOHEO>=� :EBM>K:E� K:<>� :@:BGLM� L<HK>L� H?� HMA>K� AHI>?NE� I:KMB<BI:GML���L� :G� H??B<B:E� *#+=>E>@:M>�PBMA� :� I>KF:G>GM� I:LL� MH� MA>� 1*� ,K:L:=�P:L� :;E>� MH� ?HK@H� LEHPL><NKBMR�L<K>>GBG@L��0ABL�I:LL�:EHG@�PBMA�:�;HKKHP>=�;B<R<E>�>G:;E>=�,K:L:=MH�L><NK>�MA>�M>GMA�:O:BE:;E>�L>:M�PAB<A�A>�MA>G�@:O>�MH�$B<D>R�

Page 4: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� �

K>F:KDL�$B<D>R�<HG@K:MNE:M>=�MA>�1/�HG�BML�=><BLBHG�:G=�NK@>=�MA>�1/MH�XBGOHEO>�L>Q�PHKD>KL�BG�IHEB<R�=><BLBHGL�MA:M�:??><M�MA>FY��

0A>� =:R� H?� :K;R� $B<D>RYL� LI>><A� :G=� MA>� 1/YL� NGIK><>=>GM>=<HFFBMF>GM�MH�NIAHE=�MA>�ANF:G�KB@AML�H?�:EE�L>Q�PHKD>KL�P:L�HG>�H?<>E>;K:MBHG�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K�:<MBOBLML�:G=�:EEB>L�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�:LP>EE�:L�?HK�@EH;:E�:=OH<:M>L�H?�L>QN:E�A>:EMA�CNLMB<>�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�5>M�;><:NL>�MA>�1,.�=H>L�GHM�R>M�BG<EN=>�LM:G=:K=L�H?�:<<HNGM:;BEBMR?HK�IHEB<R�<A:G@>�:L�H?�MABL�PKBMBG@�MA>�OB<MHKR�K>F:BGL�E:K@>ER�LRF;HEB<�"NKMA>KFHK>�PABE>�MA>�<NKK>GM�+;:F:�:=FBGBLMK:MBHG�A:L�LB@G:EE>=�:IHM>GMB:E�MNKG�:P:R�?KHF�L>GL:MBHG:EBLMB<��NLA�>K:�KA>MHKB<�:KHNG=ZL>QN:E�LE:O>KR[WMNKGBG@�BGLM>:=�MHP:K=L�BLLN>L�H?�E:;HNK�:G=�ANF:GKB@AMLW<NKK>GM�@HO>KGBG@�BGLMBMNMBHGL�A:O>�K>M:BG>=�MA>BK�IK>FBL>�MA:M:EE�?HKFL�H?�L>QN:E�E:;HNK�LAHNE=�;>�<KBFBG:EBL>=��0ABL�:KMB<E>�>O:EN:M>LMA>�IHEBMB<:E�<NEMNK:E�<HGM>QM�H?�MA>�1/YL�?BKLM�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P=>L<KB;>L�AHP�L>Q�PHKD>K�:<MBOBLML�:G=�:EEB>L�JNB<DER�<H:E>L<>=�:KHNG=MA>�1,.�:G=�:LL>LL>L�MA>�<NKK>GM�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�L>Q�PHKD�IHEB<RK>?HKF�HIIHKMNGBMB>L�:G=�<A:EE>G@>L�?:<BG@�L>Q�PHKD>K�E:;HNK�:G=ANF:G�KB@AML�:<MBOBLML�

�/,*3*$*2*.(��1"''*$+*.(���&-/.*2*.(��&7�!/1+

!B@AM�R>:KL�IKBHK�MH�$B<D>RYL�:==K>LL�MH�MA>�1*�,K>LB=>GM�#>HK@>�3��NLA�:ELH�LIHD>�MH�:�1*�:N=B>G<>�:;HNM�L>Q�PHKD�BLLN>L���NM�BG�LM:KD<HGMK:LM�MH�$B<D>RYL�?K:FBG@�H?�MA>�G>>=L�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL�PBMABG�LH<B:ECNLMB<>�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�IKBG<BIE>L��NLA�=>IEHR>=�=B<AHMHFHNL�BF:@>LH?�@HH=�:G=�>OBE�K>?>KKBG@�MH�ZL>Q�MK:??B<DBG@[��:G=�BG=>>=�:EE�L>QN:E<HFF>K<>�� :L� :� XLI><B:E� >OBEY��� 0ABL� =>LB@G:MBHG� H?� L>Q�PHKD� :G=IKHLMBMNMBHG�:L�>OBE�A:L�=>>I�ABLMHKB<:E�KHHML�BG�MA>�1/�:G=��:L�=BL<NLL>=E:M>K�� HI>G>=� MA>� P:R� ?HK� :GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG� @KHNIL� MH� >JN:M>

� ):GR� H?� $B<D>RYL� 1/� <HEE>:@N>L�P:M<A>=� A>K� IK>L>GM:MBHG� EBO>� OB:�P>;<:LM��K<ABO>=� OB=>H� H?� :K;R�$B<D>RYL� LI>><A� :L�P>EE� :L� MA:M� H?� $:KHE=� 'HA� :G=HMA>KL� :O:BE:;E>� :M� AMMI� PPP�NG�HK@ P>;<:LM NGAK< :K<ABO>�:LI�@H��������IF� �1*�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE�/BQM>>GMA�L>LLBHG�:M�MA>�,:E:BL�=>L*:MBHGL� BG�#>G>O:� /PBMS>KE:G=����MA�,E>G:KR�)>>MBG@��K<ABO>=�OB=>H�"KB=:R���):K<A� ������

� X0A>K>YL�:�LI><B:E�>OBE�BG�MA>�:;NL>�:G=�>QIEHBM:MBHG�H?�MA>�FHLM�BGGH<>GM�:G=ONEG>K:;E>��0A>�OB<MBFL�H?�7MA>8�L>Q�MK:=>�L>>�EBMME>�H?�EB?>�;>?HK>�MA>R�L>>�MA>O>KR�PHKLM� H?� EB?>� :G� NG=>K@KHNG=� H?� ;KNM:EBMR� :G=� EHG>ER� ?>:K�� 0AHL>� PAH<K>:M>�MA>L>�OB<MBFL�:G=�IKH?BM�?KHF�MA>BK�LN??>KBG@�FNLM�;>�L>O>K>ER�INGBLA>=�0AHL>�PAH�I:MKHGBS>�MABL� BG=NLMKR�=>;:L>�MA>FL>EO>L�:G=�=>>I>G�MA>�FBL>KRH?�HMA>KL�Y��#>HK@>�3���NLA�:==K>LLBG@�MA>�1*�#>G>K:E��LL>F;ER�HG�MK:??B<DBG@��� />IM>F;>K� �����

Page 5: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

IKHLMBMNMBHG�:G=�L>Q�PHKD�PBMA�MK:??B<DBG@�����NLAYL�LI>><A�P:L�E:N=>=;R�F:GR�K>EB@BHNL�:G=�LH<B:E�<HGL>KO:MBO>L�BG<EN=BG@�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG?>FBGBLML�PAH�LA:K>=�ABL�=BLM:LM>�?HK�L>Q�PHKD�:G=�HMA>K�?HKFL�H?L>QN:E�<HFF>K<>�����L�=>M:BE>=�;>EHP��NLAYL�<HFFBMF>GM�MH�>G=BG@ZL>Q� MK:??B<DBG@[� <K>:M>=� G>P� HIIHKMNGBMB>L� ?HK� MA>� 1/� ?>=>K:E@HO>KGF>GM�MH�<KBFBG:EBL>�IKHLMBMNMBHG�PAB<A�IK>OBHNLER�A:=�IKBF:KBER;>>G�IHEB<>=�:M�MA>�LM:M>�:G=�EH<:E�E>O>E��0ABL�:IIKH:<A�:ELH�<HGMKB;NM>=MH�MA>�IKH<>LL�;R�PAB<A�F:GR�1/�IHEB<R�F:D>KL�<:F>� MH�<HG?E:M>IKHLMBMNMBHG�PBMA�MK:??B<DBG@�:�FBL<HG<>IMBHG�MA:M�A:L�A:=�LB@GB?B<:GM>??><ML�@EH;:EER�

�/>/589371� <2/�&�� !:8<8-85

%M�BL�<E>:K�MA:M�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:<MBOBLML��PAH�BG�K><>GM�R>:KL�A:O>�K>�IHLBMBHG>=�MA>FL>EO>L�:L�ZG>P�:;HEBMBHGBLML[����A:O>�=HFBG:M>=�MA>:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�=BL<HNKL>�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L� BG�MA>�I:LM�=><:=>�$HP>O>K�<HGM>FIHK:KR�<HG<>KG�:;HNM�MK:??B<DBG@�BG�I>KLHGL�:M�MA>E>O>E�H?�MA>�1*�A:L�GHM�;>>G�BG?EN>G<>=�;R�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:<MBOBLMLMH�MA>�L:F>�>QM>GM��"HK�>Q:FIE>�<HG<>KGL�:;HNM�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@OHB<>=�:M�MA>�1*�LBG<>�MA>�����L�P>K>�IKHI>EE>=�:M�E>:LM�BG�I:KM�;RANF:G� KB@AML�;:L>=� :E:KF� HO>K� >@K>@BHNL� ?HKFL� H?� @EH;:E� E:;HNK>QIEHBM:MBHG�����==BMBHG:EER�>:KER�=BL<NLLBHGL�:M�MA>�1*�P>K>�BG?HKF>=

�� />>�� &� �AN:G@� X.>L<NBG@�0K:??B<DBG@� ?KHF� %=>HEH@B<:E� �:IMNK>�� ,KHLMBMNMBHGK>?HKF� :G=� :GMB�MK:??B<DBG@� E:P� :G=� IHEB<RY� 1GBO>KLBMR� H?� ,>GGLREO:GB:� (:P.>OB>P� OHE�� ���� GH�� ����� ����� II�� ����W������ .�3>BMS>K� X0A>� /H<B:E�HGLMKN<MBHG� H?� />Q�0K:??B<DBG@�� %=>HEH@R� :G=� BGLMBMNMBHG:EBS:MBHG� H?� :�FHK:E<KNL:=>Y�,HEBMB<L���/H<B>MR�OHE�����GH���������II�����W����

�� �<<HK=BG@� MH� ?>FBGBLM�B=>GMB?B>=� :GMB�MK:??B<DBG@� :<MBOBLM� HGG:� $N@A>L�� X;RLNIIHKMBG@� MA>� :;HEBMBHGBLM�PHKD� :@:BGLM� MA>� @EH;:E� L>Q� MK:=>� A>� ��NLA�� A:L=HG>�FHK>�?HK�PHF>G�:G=�@BKEL�MA:G�:GR�HG>�HMA>K�IK>LB=>GM�%�<:G�MABGD�H?Y��'(HI>S� X0A>� *>P��;HEBMBHGBLM� )HO>F>GM�� HGG:� $N@A>L� HG� ?B@AMBG@� L>QMK:??B<DBG@D� *:MBHG:E� .>OB>P�+GEBG>� ��� &:GN:KR� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K����� AMMI� HE=�G:MBHG:EK>OB>P�<HF BGM>KKH@:MHKR AN@A>L�������������:LI�

�� 0ABL�K>?K:FBG@�H?�IKHLMBMNMBHG�<:G�;>�EH<:M>=�PBMABG�:�EHG@�@>G>:EH@R�H?�:GMB�L>Q� PHKD� LMK:M>@B>L�� />>�� '� (>KNF� X���/M>I� ">FBGBLF�):D>L� />Q�3HKD>KL/B<D�� $HP� MA>� LM:M>� :G=� MA>� .><HO>KR�)HO>F>GM� MNKG� K:=B<:E� PHF>G� BGMHZNL>E>LL� <BMBS>GL[Y $/@=+53<A����=5<=:/�OHE�� �������II���W���

�� $HP>O>K�:L��GG�#:EE:@A>K�V�PAH�BG������:G=������:<M>=�:L�MA>�K>IK>L>GM:MBO>MH�):KR� .H;BGLHG� MA>� MA>G� 1*� $B@A� �HFFBLLBHG>K� ?HK� $NF:G� .B@AML� ?HK� :L>KB>L� H?� BGM>K@HO>KGF>GM:E� Z2B>GG:� ,KH<>LL[� F>>MBG@L� HG� MK:??B<DBG@� V>QIE:BGL�� Z\MA>� >G=� K>LNEM� �H?� MA>� Z2B>GG:� ,KH<>LL[�� <HG?BKF>=� MA>� A:KLAMKNMA�MA:M�MA>L>�G>@HMB:MBHGL�A:=�G>O>K� K>:EER�;>>G�:;HNM�ANF:G�KB@AML���GR

OB<MHKB>L� HG� HNK� LB=>�P>K>� ;HMA�A:K=�PHG� :G=� BG<HFIE>M>[� �I�� ����� />>���

#:EE:@A>K�X$NF:G�.B@AML�:G=�$NF:G�0K:??B<DBG@��-N:@FBK>�HK�?BKF�@KHNG=���K>LIHGL>�MH� &:F>L�$:MA:P:RY '3:1373+��8=:7+5�80� �7</:7+<387+5� �+?�OHE�� ��GH���������II�����W����

Page 6: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

;R�IHHKER�=H<NF>GM>=�?>:KL�:;HNM�MA>�KHE>�H?�HK@:GBL>=�<KBF>�BG�ANF:GMK:??B<DBG@���� .>L>:K<A>KL�A:O>� GHP�<E:KB?B>=� MA:M�:� =>>I>K� L>M� H?LMKN<MNK:E�BLLN>L�<:NL>=�;R�IHP>K?NE�BGLMBMNMBHGL�:G=�MK:GLG:MBHG:E<HKIHK:M>�BGM>K>LML�P>K>� BG�?:<M�BG�IE:R� BG<EN=BG@�MA>�=>O:LM:MBG@BFI:<M�H?�@EH;:E�><HGHFB<�K>LMKN<MNKBG@�IHEB<B>L�<HGG><M>=��BKHGB<:EER�MH�MA>�1*YL�:??BEB:M>=�:@>G<B>L�W�MA>�3HKE=��:GD�MA>�%GM>KG:MBHG:E)HG>M:KR�"NG=��%)"��:G=�MA>�3HKE=�0K:=>�+K@:GBS:MBHG���

%2/ !:8<8-85�<8�!:/>/7<��$=99:/;;�+7.�!=73;2�%:+003-4371�37�!/:;87;�

�;9/-3+55A�(86/7�+7.��235.:/7��MA> 1*�0K:??B<DBG@�,KHMH<HE��������<K>:M>=�:G�NG=>KLM:G=BG@�H?�MK:??B<DBG@�BG�I>KLHGL�:L�:�L>M�H?�ANF:GKB@AML�OBHE:MBHGL�:IIEB<:;E>�MH�:GR�E:;HNK�L><MHK��0ABL�,KHMH<HE�:ELHLNI>KL>=>L� >:KEB>K� BGM>KG:MBHG:E� =H<NF>GML� LN<A� :L� MA>� �����87>/7<387�08:�<2/�$=99:/;;387�80�<2/�%:+003-�37�!/:;87;�+7.�80�<2/

�@9583<+<387� 80� <2/� !:8;<3<=<387� 80� <2/:;� MA:M� ?H<NL>=� HG� MA><KBFBG:EBL:MBHG� H?� IKHLMBMNMBHG���� $HP>O>K� MA>� BG?EN>G<>� H?� :GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:=OH<:M>L�PAH�EH;;B>=�MH�G:KKHP�MA>�?H<NL�H?�MA>�,KHMH<HEMH�MK:??B<DBG@�BGMH�MA>�L>Q�L><MHK�BL�>OB=>GM�BG�MA>�=H<NF>GMYL�LI><B?B<K>?>K>G<>�MH�MA>�X>QIEHBM:MBHG�H?�MA>�IKHLMBMNMBHG�H?�HMA>KL�HK�HMA>K?HKFL�H?�L>QN:E�>QIEHBM:MBHGY��/N;L>JN>GM�BFIE>F>GM:MBHG�;R�/M:M>L,:KMB>L�A:L�:M�MBF>L�BG<EN=>=�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�F>:LNK>L�>O>G�MAHN@AMA>�1*�%GM>KIK>MBO>�*HM>�MH�MA>�,KHMH<HE�BML>E?�BG=B<:M>L�MA:M�MA>�,KHMH<HEBL�G>NMK:E�HG�MA>�BLLN>�H?�IKHLMBMNMBHG��0A>�?HEEHPBG@�L><MBHG�=>L<KB;>L

�� />@K:O>�)BEBOHC>OB<�:G=�,B<D>KBG@�<KBMBJN>�MA>�<KBFBG:E�CNLMB<>�?H<NL�H?�@EH;:E:GMB�L>Q�MK:??B<DBG@�IHEB<B>L�PAB<A�?K:F>�MA>�BLLN>�BG�M>KFL�H?�<KBF>�:L�HIIHL>=MH� E:;HNK� :G=� ANF:G� KB@AML�� "NKMA>KFHK>� MA>R� <KBMB<:EER� :==K>LL� MA>� GHMBHGMA:M� E:K@>�L<:E>� ZHK@:GBL>=� <KBF>[� BL� K>LIHGLB;E>� ?HK� L>Q� MK:??B<DBG@� �:L>OB=>G<>�LN@@>LML�MA:M� BL�FHK>�EBD>ER� MH�;>�Z<KBF>�MA:M� BL�HK@:GBL>=[�K:MA>KMA:G�ZHK@:GBL>=�<KBF>[����/>>��)�/>@K:O>�/�)BEBOHC>OB<�>M�:E� $/@�%:+003-4371��7</:7+<387+5� -87</@<�+7.� :/;987;/�3BEE:G� ,N;EBLABG@� >OHG�1'� ����� II��W���

�� �L�F:GR� E:;HNK�L<AHE:KL�:G=�><HGHFBLML�A:O>�GHM>=� E:;HNK�>QIEHBM:MBHG�:G=MA>�=>O>EHIF>GM�H?�ZLP>:M�LAHIL[�BL�H?M>G�KHHM>=�BG�ZLNIIER�LB=>[�><HGHFB<:G=� LMKN<MNK:E� ?:<MHKL� LN<A� :L� @EH;:EBL>=�F:KD>ML� :G=� /MKN<MNK:E��=CNLMF>GM,KH@K:FF>L� �/�,L��� 0A>� <HG=BMBHGL� MA:M� <:F>�PBMA� MA>� %)"� :G=�3HKE=� �:GDEH:GL�F>:GM�MA:M�G:MBHGL�P>K>�?HK<>=�MH�K>MK:<M�LI>G=BG@�BG�GNF>KHNL�L><MHKL:G=� EH<:E� ><HGHFB>L� :G=� MABL� <HNIE>=� PBMA� BG<>GMBO>L� ?HK�FNEMBG:MBHG:E<HKIHK:MBHGL�MH�BGO>LM�HNMLB=>�H?�MA>BK�;HK=>KL�F>:GM�MA:M�IHO>KMR�BG<K>:L>=:G=�:G�BG<K>:LBG@�GNF;>K�H?�I>HIE>�?HNG=�MA>FL>EO>L�?:<>=�PBMA�>QIEHBM:MBO>PHKDBG@� <HG=BMBHGL�� />>�� &� /MB@EBMS �58,+53B+<387� +7.� 3<;� �3;-87</7<;� 3�3�*HKMHG� *>P�5HKD� ������ /� /:LL>G� X#EH;:E� �BMB>L� :G=� /NKOBO:E� �BK<NBMLY� BG� &.:=P:R��>=�� �6/:3-+7�$<=.3/;���7�+7<28581A�3BE>R��E:<DP>EE�3>LM�/NLL>Q�����

�� ��&HK=:G &��%:+003-4371�!:8<8-85���7�369/:0/-<�+99:8+-2�,KH@K:F�HG�$NF:G0K:??B<DBG@� :G=� "HK<>=�(:;HK� �>GM>K� ?HK�$NF:G�.B@AML� ��$NF:GBM:KB:G� (:P����� K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K������AMMI� KB@AMLPHKD�HK@ PI�<HGM>GM NIEH:=L ���� �� %LLN>�,:I>K���I=?�

Page 7: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

AHP�HG>�1*�F>F;>K�LM:M>�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�H?��F>KB<:�<:F>�MH�L>>IKHLMBMNMBHG�:L�:G�:<MBOBMR�MA:M�BL�BGMKBGLB<:EER�BGL>I:K:;E>�?KHF�ANF:GMK:??B<DBG@�

%2/�&$� 5/13;5+<3>/� :/;987;/� <8� <:+003-4371

0A> %:+003-4371� '3-<36;� !:8</-<387��-<� 80� ��� �MA>� 02,��� :G=LN;L>JN>GM�K>:NMAHKBL:MBHG�:<ML��02,.���:K>�:�<>GMK:E�I:KM�H?�MA>�1/YL?>=>K:E�K>LIHGL>�MH�MK:??B<DBG@�;HMA�PBMABG�MA>�<HNGMKR�:G=�MAKHN@ABGM>KG:MBHG:E�F><A:GBLFL�<K>:M>=�;R�MABL�E>@BLE:MBHG��0A>�02,��>F>K@>=?KHF�MPH�L>I:K:M>�:G=�HIIHLBMBHG:E�LMK:G=L�H?�IKHIHL>=�E>@BLE:MBHG:G=�:=OH<:<R��+G>�L>KB>L�H?�;BEELWPAB<A�<HGLB=>K>=�MK:??B<DBG@�:L�:GBLLN>�:??><MBG@�:GR�E:;HNK�L><MHKWA:=�BML�@>G>LBL�BG�MA>�PHKD�H?�EB;>K:E/>G:MHK� ,:NE�3>EELMHG>� � �)*�� :G=� MA>� >??HKML� H?� ANF:G� KB@AML:=OH<:M>L�<HG<>KG>=�IKBF:KBER�PBMA�PHF>GYL�KB@AML���GHMA>K�L>KB>L�H?;BEELWPAB<A�?H<NL>=�HG�ZL>QN:E�MK:??B<DBG@[�:G=�IKHLMBMNMBHGW;>@:G:L�:�K>LNEM�H?�MA>�>??HKML�H?�<HGL>KO:MBO>�.>IK>L>GM:MBO>��AKBL�/FBMA�.�*&��PAH�A:=�PHKD>=�PBMA�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�<HGLMBMN>G<B>L�MH�=>O>EHIMA>�Z"K>>=HF�"KHF�/>QN:E�0K:??B<DBG@��<M[�BGMKH=N<>=�HG�):K<A���������1G=>K�IK>LLNK>�MH�:=HIM�:�<HFIKHFBL>�:�=>?BGBMBHG�BG<ENLBO>�H?F>G�PHF>G�:G=�<ABE=K>G� BGMH�;HMA�L>Q�:G=�GHG�L>Q�L><MHKL�P:L:<<>IM>=�:G=�BG<HKIHK:M>=�BGMH�MA>�02,�����3A:M�BL�LMKBDBG@�A>K>�BLMA:M�:EMAHN@A�LHF>�BGLIBK:MBHG�?HK�MA>�02,��<:F>�?KHF�ANF:G�KB@AML:=OH<:M>LY� <HG<>KGL� :;HNM� E:;HNK� :;NL>� ;HMA� >??HKML� E:<D>=K><H@GBMBHG�H?�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�I>KLI><MBO>L�

�?M>K�FHK>�MA:G�:�R>:K�H?�BGM>GLBO>�=>;:M>�:;HNM�MA>�>Q:<M�G:MNK>�H?MA>�IKH;E>F�<HG<>KGBG@�MK:??B<DBG@�MA>�?BG:E�<HFIKHFBL>�E>@BLE:MBHG<HGM:BG>=�=B??>K>GM�=>?BGBMBHGL�?HK�MA>�<KBFBG:E�E:P�:G=�?HK�HMA>K�GHG�<KBFBG:E�:K>:L�H?�E:P�LN<A�:L�BFFB@K:MBHG�LH<B:E�L>KOB<>L�:G=�?HK>B@G:B=�T�0A>�GHG�<KBFBG:E�E:P�IHKMBHG�H?�MA>�E:P�=>?BG>L XL>O>K>�?HKFL�H?MK:??B<DBG@Y�:L�>BMA>K�����XL>Q�MK:??B<DBG@�BG�PAB<A�:�<HFF>K<B:E�L>Q:<M�BL�BG=N<>=�;R�?HK<>�?K:N=�HK�<H>K<BHG�HK�BG�PAB<A�MA>�I>KLHGBG=N<>=�MH�I>K?HKF�LN<A�:G�:<M�A:L�GHM�:MM:BG>=����R>:KL�H?�:@>Y�HK���XMA>�K><KNBMF>GM�A:K;HKBG@�MK:GLIHKM:MBHG�IKHOBLBHG�HK�H;M:BGBG@H?�:�I>KLHG�?HK�E:;HK�HK�L>KOB<>L�MAKHN@A�MA>�NL>�H?�?HK<>�?K:N=�HK<H>K<BHG� ?HK� MA>� INKIHL>� H?� LN;C><MBHG� MH� BGOHENGM:KR� L>KOBMN=>I>HG:@>�=>;M�;HG=:@>�HK�LE:O>KRY���T

�� �AN:G@� I�� ������� 1�/�� >I:KMF>GM�H?�/M:M> ����%:+003-4371�37�!/:;87;�#/98:<�1�/�� +/�����

II�� �W�� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�LM:M>�@HO =H<NF>GML HK@:GBS:MBHG �������I=?�

Page 8: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

�R�L>I:K:MBG@�L>Q�MK:??B<DBG@�?KHF�HMA>K�?HKFL�H?�E:;HNK�MK:??B<DBG@MA>�02,��K>BG?HK<>=�MA>�MK:=BMBHG:EW:G=�=BLMBG<MER�:GMB�?>FBGBLMWGHMBHGMA:M�:<MBHGL�BGOHEOBG@�ZL>Q[�:G=�ZBGMBF:<R[�<:GGHM�;>�<HGLB=>K>=�ZK>:EPHKD[����"NKMA>KFHK>�MA>�=><:=>�?HEEHPBG@�MA>�I:LLBG@�H?�MA>�02,��BG�����A:L�;>>G�F:KD>=�;R�BGM>GL>�IHEBMB<:E�:=OH<:<R�?KHF�P>EE�?NG=>=<HGL>KO:MBO>�@KHNIL�PAH�A:O>�BG<K>F>GM:EER�=>?BG>=�MK:??B<DBG@�:LIKHLMBMNMBHG�����R������MA>�H??B<B:E�1/�IHLBMBHG�A:=�EH<D>=�BG�HG�MABL<HG?E:MBHG�LM:MBG@�MA:M�XIKHLMBMNMBHG�BL�BGA>K>GMER�A:KF?NE�?HK�F>GPHF>G�:G=�<ABE=K>G�:G=�MA:M�BM�<HGMKB;NM>L�MH�MA>�IA>GHF>GHG�H?MK:??B<DBG@�BG�I>KLHGLY����/BG<>�MA>�MNKG�H?�MA>���LM�<>GMNKR�IKHAB;BMBHGBLM>??HKML�A:O>�<HGMBGN>=�MH�@KHP� BG� ?NG=BG@�IHEBMB<:E� LMK>G@MA�:G=IHINE:K�<NEMNK>�:II>:E�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�:G=�@EH;:EER���><:NL>�HMA>KLA:O>�PKBMM>G�>QM>GLBO>ER�:;HNM�MABL�FHO>F>GM�:G=�BML�ABLMHKR���P>MNKG�G>QM�MH�>Q:FBGBG@�:�?>P�LB@GB?B<:GM�BFI:<ML�

���1"*,�/'��"-"(*.(��/,*$*&2

/BG<>�MA>�>:KER�����L�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�IHEB<B>L�:M�MA>�?>=>K:E�E>O>EA:O>� MK:GLE:M>=� BGMH� BG<K>:LBG@ER� :@@K>LLBO>� LM:M>� :G=� EH<:E�E>O>EIHEB<BG@�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL�:G=�MA>BK�<NLMHF>KL��1/�CNKBL=B<MBHG:E�E:P�:EEHPLMA>�?>=>K:E�:G=�LM:M>�@HO>KGF>GML�MH�:=HIM�MK:??B<DBG@�E:PL�PABE>IHEB<B>L�:G=�IHEB<BG@�:KHNG=�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:K>�<HGMKHEE>=�;R�LM:M>�:G=EH<:E�E:PL�:G=�;R�?>=>K:E�E:P�PA>G�BM�<KHLL>L�;HK=>KL��0A>�<HG?E:MBHG

�� 3ABE>�?>FBGBLML�O:KR�HG�MA>BK�I>KLI><MBO>L�HG�L>Q�PHKD�FHLM�?>FBGBLML�:@K>>MA:M�ZPHF>GYL[�E:;HNK�BL�MK:=BMBHG:EER�BGMBF:M>��:G=�A>G<>�=>GB@K:M>=��E:;HNK�"HK�:� <KBMB<:E�HO>KOB>P�H?� MA>�IHEBMB<L�H?� BGMBF:M>� E:;HNK� BG<EN=BG@� L>Q�PHKDL>>�� !� �HKBL� .� /� ,:KK>G:L� �>=L�� �7<36+</� �+,8:;�� �=5<=:/;�� </-2785813/;�+7.� <2/�9853<3-;�80� -+:/� /M:G?HK=�1GBO>KLBMR� ,K>LL� /M:G?HK=� ��������

�� ,� /:NG=>KL� X,KHAB;BMBG@� />Q�3HKD� ,KHC><ML� .>LMKB<MBG@�3HF>GYL� .B@AML�� 0A>BGM>KG:MBHG:E�BFI:<M�H?�MA>������1�/��#EH;:E��% /��<MY �/+5<2�+7.��=6+7�#312<;OHE����GH���������II�����W����

�� &� $N<D>K;R� X1GBM>=� /M:M>L� H?��F>KB<:Y� BG� #EH;:E��EEB:G<>��@:BGLM� 0K:??B<� BG3HF>G��>=�� �855+</:+5��+6+1/��%2/�369+-<�80�+7<3�<:+003-4371�6/+;=:/;�872=6+7� :312<;� +:8=7.� <2/� ?8:5.� #��03� ����� I�� ���� K>MKB>O>=� &:GN:KR����� AMMI� PPP�@::MP�HK@�

�� />>�?HK�>Q:FIE>��(�)��N@NLMBG $/@�+<�<2/��+:137;���31:+<387��5+,8=:�6+:4/<;+7.�<2/�:/;-=/�37.=;<:A�6>=��HHDL� �(HG=HG�������!��>KGLM>BG�X0A>�/>QN:E,HEBMB<L� H?� MA>�Z*>P��;HEBMBHGBLF[Y �300/:/7-/;�� �8=:7+5� 80� 0/6373;<� -=5<=:+5;<=.3/;�OHE�����GH���������II�����W������3��A:IDBL X/H?M�#EHO>�,NGBLABG@"BLM�� 0A>�0K:??B<DBG@� 2B<MBFL� ,KHM><MBHG��<MY� BG� !� �>KGLM>BG� :G=� (� /<A:??G>K�>=L��T#/1=5+<371�$/@�.HNME>=@>�*>P�5HKD���������AN:G@�II������W������#� /H=>KENG=� X.NGGBG@� ?KHF� MA>� .>L<N>KL�� *>P� 1�/�� <KNL:=>L� :@:BGLM� L>QMK:??B<DBG@�:G=�MA>�KA>MHKB<�H?�:;HEBMBHGY �+<387+5�(86/7D;�$<=.3/;��;;8-3+<387�8=:7+5�OHE�����GH���������II����W����3>BMS>K�I������

Page 9: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

H?�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�IKHLMBMNMBHG�IHEB<R�AHP>O>K�A:L�:EEHP>=�?HK�?>=>K:E=HEE:KL�MH�;>�NL>=�EH<:EER�?HK�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�INKIHL>L���GMB�MK:??B<DBG@K:B=L�LN<A�:L�+I>K:MBHG��KHLL��HNGMKR�A>E=�:GGN:EER�LBG<>������A:O>K>LNEM>=�BG�MA>�:KK>LM�H?�F:GR�L>Q�PHKD>KL�G:MBHGPB=>�NLBG@�?>=>K:E:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�=HEE:KL�����==BMBHG:EER�<HGL>KO:MBO>�IHEB<R�F:D>KL�:G=:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�EH;;RBLML�<E:BF�MA:M�:KK>LMBG@�<EB>GML�A>EIL�OB<MBFL�H?MK:??B<DBG@�;R�Z>G=BG@�MA>�=>F:G=[�?HK�L>Q�PHKD��"NG=BG@�?KHF�1GBM>=/M:M>L�?>=>K:E�E:P�:@:BGLM�MK:??B<DBG@��MAKHN@A�K>:NMAHKBL:MBHGL�H?�MA>02,���A:L�>G:;E>=�LM:M>�:G=�EH<:E�E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM�MH�:@@K>LLBO>ERXBGO>LMB@:M>�:G=�IKHL><NM>�;NR>KL�H?�<HFF>K<B:E�L>QY����/BFBE:KER�MA>L>L:F>� ?NG=BG@� LHNK<>L� A:O>� >G<HNK:@>=� /M:M>L� MH� BGMKH=N<>� G>PZ=HF>LMB<�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�E:PL[�MA:M�?K:F>�:EE�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:L�:�?HKFH?� MK:??B<DBG@�:G=� BG<EN=>�AB@A>K�I>G:EMB>L� ?HK�;NRBG@� L>Q� ?KHF�:MK:??B<D>=�I>KLHG�>O>G�BG�MA>�:;L>G<>�H?�>OB=>G<>�MA:M�MA>�I>KLHGA:=�;>>G�MK:??B<D>=��/N<A�:IIKH:<A>L�A:O>�=HG>�GHMABG@�MH�K>=N<>:G=�BG�F:GR�<:L>L�A:O>�BG<K>:L>=�MA>�ANF:G�KB@AML�OBHE:MBHGL�H?�L>QPHKD>KL���

,HEB<B>L�MA:M�BG<K>:L>�MA>�:EK>:=R�BGM>GL>�<KBFBG:EBL:MBHG�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL=BLIKHIHKMBHG:M>ER�L<KNMBGBL>�:G=�INGBLA�MA>�FHLM�=BL>G?K:G<ABL>=BG<K>:L>�MA>�><HGHFB<�:G=�LH<B:E�F:K@BG:EBL:MBHG�H?�;HMA�MA>�IKHOB=>KL:G=�MA>�INK<A:L>KL�H?�<HFF>K<B:E�L>Q���:G=�<K>:M>�G>P�P:RL�MH�I>G:EBL>F>G�PHF>G�:G=�MK:GL@>G=>K�I>HIE>�H?�<HEHNK�:G=�BFFB@K:GML����/>QPHKD>KL�H?�<HEHNK�:K>�H?M>G�LBG@E>=�HNM�;R� E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM� MANL

�� />>�?HK�>Q:FIE>��/�)NKIAR�X"BO>��KK>LM>=�BG�1/�/MBG@�:M�):KKBHMMY %2/��8;<87�58,/� 7537/� ��� ">;KN:KR� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�;HLMHG�<HF G>PL EH<:E F:LL:<ANL>MML :KM B<E>L ���� �� �� �9:KK>LM>=9BG9NL9LMBG@9:M9F:KKBHMM �

�� %:+003-4371�'3-<36;�!:8</-<387�#/+=<28:3B+<387��-<�80����� L><MBHG� ������ />>��/>Q�3HKD>KL�,KHC><M &;/� 80�#+3.;� <8� �312<�%:+003-4371� 37�!/:;87;� /3,

����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�NK;:GCNLMB<>�HK@ I=? IN;EB<:MBHGL 'B<DBG@9 HPG90A>9 HHK9!Q><9/NF�I=?���:L>=�HG�BGM>KOB>PL�PBMAL>E?�B=>GMB?B>=� MK:??B<DBG@� OB<MBFL� MABL� K>IHKM� K><HFF>G=L� :� KB@AML�;:L>=�K:MA>K� MA:G�:� E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM� ;:L>=��:IIKH:<A� MH� B=>GMB?RBG@�:G=� :LLBLMBG@MK:??B<DBG@� OB<MBFL�

�� />>�?HK�>Q:FIE>� MA>�LB=>;:K�X!EBFBG:MBG@�MA>� >F:G=�?HK�2B<MBFL�H?�/>QN:E!QIEHBM:MBHGY�BG�1�/�� >I:KMF>GM�H?�/M:M> ����%:+003-4371�37�!/:;87;�#/98:<1�/�� +/������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K������AMMI� PPP�LM:M>�@HO =H<NF>GML HK@:GBS:MBHG ������I=?��)�/ABO>ER�'�)<(:N@AEBG�>M�:E� �/>/589371�+��+<387+5�-<387� !5+7� 08:� �53637+<371� $/@� %:+003-4371���0��LLH<B:M>L� ����� K>MKB>O>=/>IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� P>;�FNEM<H�NL LBM>L =>?:NEM ?BE>L =H<NF>GML =>O>EHIBG@9:9?BG:E9:<MBHG9IE:G9MH9>EBFBG:M>9L>Q9MK:??B<DBG@�I=?�

�� />>�� �>LM� ,K:<MB<>L� ,HEB<R� ,KHC><M� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� />QN:E� .B@AML� %GBMB:MBO>#/98:<�87�<2/�&73</.�$<+</;�80��6/:3-+���<2�#8=7.�80�<2/�&73>/:;+5�!/:38.3-

#/>3/?�� �,,,� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� � AMMI� PPP�;>LMIK:<MB<>LIHEB<R�HK@ =HPGEH:=L "BG:E1,.�,,,9"HKF:MM>=�I=?�

Page 10: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

OBHE:MBG@� MA>� 1/� �HGLMBMNMBHG� BGM>KG:MBHG:E� LM:G=:K=L� :@:BGLM=BL<KBFBG:MBHG�:G=�MK>:MB>L�LN<A�:L�MA>��HFFBMM>>�HG�MA>�!EBFBG:MBHGH?�.:<B:E� BL<KBFBG:MBHG�:G=�MA>�%GM>KG:MBHG:E��HO>G:GM�HG��BOBE�:G=,HEBMB<:E�.B@AML����"NKMA>KFHK>�><HGHFB<�F:K@BG:EBL:MBHG�=N>�MH�MA>=>>I�BFI:<M�H?�K:<BLF�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�F>:GL�MA:M�I>HIE>�H?�<HEHNKF:D>� NI� MA>�F:CHKBMR� H?� L>Q�PHKD>KL� BG� IN;EB<� LI:<>L� :G=� :K>K>E>GME>LLER�M:K@>M>=�;R�MA>�IHEB<>�BG�MA>BK�>??HKML�MH�<E>:K�MA>�LMK>>ML���

�KK>LM�:G=�LN;L>JN>GM�<HGOB<MBHG�?HK�IKHLMBMNMBHG�K>E:M>=�H??>G<>LBGM>GLB?B>L�MA>�AHF>E>LLG>LL�HK�AHNLBG@�IK><:KBHNLG>LL�>QI>KB>G<>=;R�I>HIE>�?KHF�EHP�BG<HF>�<HFFNGBMB>L�;><:NL>�I>HIE>�PBMA�<KBFBG:EK><HK=L�:K>�;:KK>=�?KHF�:<<>LLBG@�HK�F:R�EHL>�MA>BK�IN;EB<�AHNLBG@���

�EMAHN@A� A>:EMA� :G=� ANF:G� L>KOB<>L� L<AHE:KL� LNIIHKM� IK:@F:MB<>OB=>G<>�;:L>=�:IIKH:<A>L�LN<A�:L�A:KF�K>=N<MBHG�L>KOB<>L�?HK�L>QPHKD>KL��� :G=� IKH@K:FF>L� MA:M� :MM>G=� MH� MA>� G>>=L� H?� FB@K:GME:;HNK>KL���IN;EB<�:G=�IHEBMB<:E�=BL<HNKL>�A:L�;>>G�=HFBG:M>=�;R�AB@A�IKH?BE>�MK:??B<DBG@�ARI>�LN<A�:L�MA>�PBE=�NG?HNG=>=�<E:BFL�MA:M�MA>3HKE=��NI�:G=�/NI>K;HPE�:K>�K>LIHGLB;E>�?HK�:G�BG<K>:L>�BG�<ABE=�L>QLE:O>KR���

%GM>KG:MBHG:EER� MA>� 1GBM>=� /M:M>L� A:L� ;><HF>� MA>�PHKE=YL� E:K@>LM>QIHKM>K�H?�=>MKBF>GM:E�L>Q�PHKD�IHEB<B>L�PAB<A�A:O>�;>>G�LAHPG�MH;>� ;HMA� =:F:@BG@� MH� L>Q�PHKD>KLY� A>:EMA� :G=� ANF:G� KB@AML� :G=BG>??B<B>GM�BG�K>LHEOBG@�E:;HNK�:;NL>L��"HK>FHLM�BL�MA>�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHGEHR:EMR� H:MA� HK� Z:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG� IE>=@>[� :� K>JNBK>F>GM� MA:M

�� �G=K>:� .BM<AB>� ?HKF>K� BK><MHK� H?� MA>� />Q� 3HKD>KL� ,KHC><M� I>KLHG:E<HFFNGB<:MBHG���� ><>F;>K������

�� />>����(�)<�K=E> */:8�%85/:+7-/��"=+53<A�80�530/�+7.�<2/�7/?�9853-/�,:=<+53<A37��/?�)8:4��3<A�//.*�!EB;K:KR�������(�/:NL:�&�'>:ME>R�>M�:E�X,>K<>BO>=�.BLDL:G=��>G>?BML�H?�/>Q�3HKD�:FHG@�0K:GL@>G=>K�3HF>G�H?��HEHK�BG�/:G�"K:G<BL<HY�:-23>/;�80�$/@=+5��/2+>38:�OHE�����GH����II�����W����

�� �>LM�,K:<MB<>L�,HEB<R�,KHC><M� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� />QN:E�.B@AML� %GBMB:MBO>�I������ !IB=>FBHEH@BLM� :G=� L<AHE:K� !EBS:;>MA� ,BL:GB� A:L� PKBMM>G� >QM>GLBO>ER� HG� AHP

>OB=>G<>�;:L>=� A:KF�K>=N<MBHG� BGM>KO>GMBHGL� :K>� LMRFB>=� ;R� IHEBMB<L� :G=B=>HEH@R�� />>�� !� ,BL:GB %2/�(3;.86� 80�(28:/;�� �=:/+=-:+<;�� ,:8<2/5;�� +7.<2/�,=;37/;;�80����$�3��3��*HKMHG����HFI:GR� %G<�*>P�5HKD������

�� 0A>�*:MBHG:E��LB:G�,:<B?B<��F>KB<:G�3HF>GYL�"HKNF��*�,�3"��BL�:�E>:=>K�BG�MA>1/� BG� <:EEBG@� ?HK� <HFIK>A>GLBO>� BFFB@K:MBHG� K>?HKF� :L� :� IK><HG=BMBHG� ?HK:==K>LLBG@� ANF:G� MK:??B<DBG@�� />>�� *:MBHG:E��LB:G� ,:<B?B<��F>KB<:G�3HF>GYL"HKNF %2/��/@=;��/<?//7��=6+7�%:+003-4371�+7.��6631:+<387�*�,�3"�����K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� G:I:P?�HK@ PI�<HGM>GM NIEH:=L ���� PHKDBG@ I=?L 0K:??B<DBG@9:G=9%FFB@K:MBHG�I=?�

�� ��&HK=:G�X":<M�HK�"B<MBHG��3A:M�=H�P>�K>:EER�DGHP�:;HNM�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�Y%LLN>� I:I>K� �� �>GM>K� ?HK� $NF:G� .B@AML� �� $NF:GBM:KB:G� (:P��F>KB<:G1GBO>KLBMR� ����� K>MKB>O>=� � />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� KB@AMLPHKD�HK@ PI�<HGM>GM NIEH:=L ���� �� %LLN>�,:I>K���I=?�

Page 11: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

HK@:GBL:MBHGL�L>>DBG@�?NG=BG@�?HK�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�$%2 �% /�PHKD�?KHFMA>�,K>LB=>GMYL�!F>K@>G<R�,E:G�?HK��% /�.>EB>?��,!,"�.��:G=�?HK�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�IKH@K:FF>�?NG=BG@�?KHF�MA>�1/��@>G<R�?HK�%GM>KG:MBHG:E >O>EHIF>GM��1/�% ��:=HIM�:�IHEB<R�:@:BGLM�L>Q�PHKD��0ABL�IHEB<R�A:LE>=�MH�=>?NG=BG@�H?�>OB=>G<>�;:L>=�L>KOB<>L�:G=�:�PB=>LIK>:=�<ABEEBG@>??><M� :FHG@LM� L>KOB<>� IKHOB=>KL� BG� M>KFL� H?� PHKDBG@� PBMA� L>QPHKD>KL�����==BMBHG:EER�MA>�MB>K�K:GDBG@�LRLM>F�:LLH<B:M>=�PBMA�MA> >I:KMF>GM�H?�/M:M>YL�R>:KER�0K:??B<DBG@�%G�,>KLHGL��0%,��K>IHKMWPA>K><HNGMKB>L�:K>�@K:=>=�:<<HK=BG@�MH�AHP�:@@K>LLBO>ER�MA>R�:K>�=>>F>=MH�;>�BG�M:<DEBG@�MK:??B<DBG@WA:L�LI:KD>=�FBL@NB=>=�<K:<D=HPGL�HGL>Q�PHKD>KL�BG�<HNGMKB>L�L>>DBG@�MH�L><NK>�:�;>MM>K�0%,�K:GD������K>E:M>=<HG<>KG�:KHNG=�MA>�HK@:GBL:MBHG�H?�MA>�0%,�LRLM>F�BL�BML�>FIA:LBL�HG<KBFBG:E�CNLMB<>�HNM<HF>L��>�@��AB@A>K�:KK>LM�K:M>L��K:MA>K�MA:G�ANF:GKB@AML�HNM<HF>L� �>�@�� BG<K>:LBG@�:<<>LL�MH� L:?>� EBOBG@�:G=�PHKDBG@<HG=BMBHGL��:L�:�F>:LNK>�H?�LN<<>LL���

�)&��&7�!/1+&129��*()32��/5&-&.3

/BFNEM:G>HNL�PBMA�MA>�=>O>EHIF>GM�H?�IKHAB;BMBHGBLM�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@:G=�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�>??HKML� BG�MA>�1/�FHO>F>GML�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>KKB@AML�A:O>�:ELH�@KHPG�BG�LMK>G@MA�:G=�OBLB;BEBMR�BFI:<MBG@�:�O:KB>MRH?�<NEMNK:E�:<:=>FB<�:G=�IN;EB<�A>:EMA�:K>G:L��+K@:GBLBG@�?HK�MA>KB@AML�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KLW:�M>KF�:MMKB;NM>=�MH�/:G�"K:G<BL<H�:<MBOBLM��:KHE(>B@A��W<:G�;>�MK:<>=�BG�MA>�1/�LBG<>�MA>�>:KER�����L�MH�HK@:GBL:MBHGLLN<A�:L��+5+0!���:EE�+??�5HNK�+E=�0BK>=�!MAB<L��MA>�*HKMA��F>KB<:G0:LD�"HK<>�HG�,KHLMBMNMBHG�,KHLMBMNM>L�H?�*>P�5HKD��,+*5��:G=�MA>�/:G"K:G<BL<H�;:L>=�,KHLMBMNMBHG�0:LD�"HK<>����<>GMK:E�?>:MNK>�H?�MA>L><HEE><MBO>�FHO>F>GML�P:L�MH�IKHFHM>�PB=>K�LH<B>M:E�K><H@GBMBHG�H?

�� �� �K:@H =:� �3>/;��+<</:�� $/@�?8:4/:;� =73</� 08:� 2/+5<2� +7.� :312<;� +I>G/H<B>MR� %GLMBMNM>� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�LHKHL�HK@ BGBMB:M BO>L A>:EMA ?H<NL LA:KI :KMB<E>L9IN;EB<:MBHGL IN;E B<:M BHGL HNKEBO>LF:MM>K9�������� +NK���(BO>L���):MM>K������/>Q���3HKD>KL���1GBM>���?HK���$>:EMA���:G=���.B@AML�I=?�

�� /HNMA�'HK>:�?HK�>Q:FIE>�I:KMER�:L�:�K>LIHGL>�MH�MA>�0B>K���IE:<>F>GM�I:LL>=:�G>P�Z:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@[�E:P�BG������<:EE>=�MA>�/>Q�0K:=>�,K>O>GMBHG��<M��0ABL�<M� E>=� MH� MA>� PB=>LIK>:=� :KK>LM� H?� PHF>G� PAH� =B=� GHM� P:GM� MH� E>:O>IKHLMBMNMBHG�� HO>K� ����� PHF>G� L>Q� PHKD>KL� MHHD� MH� MA>� LMK>>ML� H?� />HNE� BGIKHM>LM�� />>�� /� �A>G@� X'HK>:G� L>Q� MK:=>� ZOB<MBFL[� LMKBD>� ?HK� KB@AML�Y��LB:0BF>L� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�:MBF>L�<HF :MBF>L 'HK>: "(�� @���AMFE�

36 />>��)�/>@K:O>�)�)BEBOHC>OB<�>M�:E��I�������� �� (>B@A &7:/9/7<+7<�(28:/�� %2/� -855/-</.� ?8:4;� 80� $-+:58<� �+:58<� (:LM

#:LI� /:G� "K:G<BL<H� �����

Page 12: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

IKHLMBMNMBHG�:G=�HMA>K�?HKFL�H?�L>QN:E�<HFF>K<>�:L�E>@BMBF:M>�PHKD�$HP>O>K�;R�MA>�L><HG=�I:KM�H?�MA>�����L�>O>G�MAHN@A�HK@:GBL:MBHGL?HK�MA>�KB@AML�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL�<HGMBGN>=�MH�>QBLM�G:MBHG:E�E>O>E�:<MBOBLFA:=�:EFHLM�O:GBLA>=���

0A>�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�FHO>F>GM�P:L�K>;HKG�BG�MA>�����L�=KBO>G�;RMA>�BG<K>:LBG@�K>IK>LLBHG�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL�IHLM�� ���:G=�?NKMA>K�?N>EE>=;R�G>P�>??HKML�MH�>G=�MK:??B<DBG@�:L�:�K>LNEM�H?�MA>�02,��:G=�MA>�HG@HBG@ZP:K�HG�=KN@L[����%G<K>:L>L�BG�E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM�IHP>KL�BG�MA>�P:D>�H?/>IM>F;>K���������?HLM>K>=�:�<EBF:M>�H?�EBFBM>=�IHEB<>�:<<HNGM:;BEBMR:G=�;KHN@AM�G>P�P:O>L�H?�LRLM>FB<�IHEB<>�:;NL>�?HK�F:GR�L>Q�PHKD>KL���

%G������MA>�/>Q�3HKD>KL�+NMK>:<A�,KHC><M�1/���/3+,�1/���:�G:MBHG:E<:FI:B@G�LMRE>�HK@:GBL:MBHG�P:L�<H�?HNG=>=�;R�.H;RG�">P�PBMA�HMA>K:<MBOBLML��">P�>QIE:BGL�

3>�P>K>�EHHDBG@�BGMH�MA>�?NMNK>�:G=�L>>BG@�MA:M�:�EHM�FHK>I>HIE>�P>K>�@HBG@�MH�;>�:KK>LM>=�:G=�P>�G>>=>=�MH�;>�IK>I:K>=?HK� MA:M��0A>� ?>=>K:E�@HO>KGF>GM�P:L�<HFBG@�=HPG�HG�NL�,KHLMBMNMBHG�P:L�GHM�>O>G�K>E:M>=�MH�?>=>K:E�E:P�;NM�MA>�PAHE>ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�:IIKH:<A�:EEHP>=�MA>�?>=>K:E�@HO>KGF>GMMH�?BG=�P:RL�MH�<K:<D�=HPG�HG�IKHLMBMNMBHG���

�� +G>� K>:LHG� ?HK� MABL� P:L� MA>� HG@HBG@� BFI:<M� H?� $%2 �% /� HG� L>Q� PHKD>K<HFFNGBMB>L��):GR� L>Q�PHKD>K� HK@:GBL>KL� CHBG>=�@:R�F>G� BG� :� ?B@AM� MH� A:O>$%2 �% /� K><H@GBL>=�:L�:�A>:EMA�<KBLBL�� /HF>� E>:=>KL�P>K>� EHLM� MH�MA>� BEEG>LL:G=�F:GR� <HFFNGBMR� K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L� P>K>� ;NKGM�HNM� ;R� MA>� ����L� ;R� MA>BGM>GLBMR�H?�MA>L>�LMKN@@E>L��%GM>KOB>P�PBMA��:KHE�(>B@A�?HNG=>K�H?���5/3�*<HGO>GHK� H?� MA>� />Q�3HKD>K�"BEF�:G=��KML�">LMBO:E� :G=�P>EE�DGHPG�:=OH<:M>?HK� L>Q�PHKD>K� KB@AML�;R�,>G>EHI>�/:NG=>KL���� />IM>F;>K������

�� (>B@A 89��-3<���0A>�GNF;>K�H?�I>HIE>�BG�LM:M>�IKBLHGL�?HK�=KN@�K>E:M>=�:<MBOBMRA:L� BG<K>:L>=� >QIHG>GMB:EER� HO>K� MA>� I:LM� MP>GMR� R>:KL�� />>�� &NLMB<>� ,HEB<R%GLMBMNM> !:=7371�!:3;87;���8?�-=<<371�-8::/-<387;�-+7�;+>/�687/A�+7.�9:8</-<9=,53-� ;+0/<A� &,%� ����� K>MKB>O>=� ">;KN:KR� ����� AMMI� PPP�CNLMB<>IHEB<R�HK@ BF:@>L NIEH:= ��9��9.!,9,KNGBG@,KBLHGL9��9,/�I=?�����(1� �K>:D� MA>�A:BGL� �K>GG:G��>GM>K� ?HK� &NLMB<> �+=12<� 37� <2/� �/<�� %2/� 369+-<� 80� .:=19853-3/;�87�?86/7�+7.�0+6353/;���(1������K>MKB>O>=���">;KN:KR������AMMI� PPP�:<EN�HK@ ?BE>L BF:@>L :LL>M9NIEH:=9?BE>���9������I=?�

�� ��.BM<AB>�&� (�)H@NE �7�<2/�$2+.8?;�80�<2/�(+:�87�%/::8:��!/:;3;</7<�9853-/,:=<+53<A�+7.�+,=;/�80�9/895/�80�-858:�37�<2/�&73</.�$<+</;�.>IHKM�IK>I:K>=?HK�MA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL��HFFBMM>>�HG�MA>�!EBFBG:MBHG�H?�.:<B:E� BL<KBFBG:MBHGHG� MA>� H<<:LBHG�H?� BML� K>OB>P�H?� MA>�1GBM>=� /M:M>L�H?��F>KB<:YL��G=� :G=� �K=,>KBH=B<�.>IHKM�MH�MA>��HFFBMM>>�HG�MA>�!EBFBG:MBHG�H?�.:<B:E� BL<KBFBG:MBHG�����I�����K>MKB>O>=�">;KN:KR������AMMI� PPP��HA<AK�HK@ >G@EBLA ;H=B>L <>K= =H<L G@HL NL: 1/$.*���I=?�

�� %GM>KOB>P�PBMA�.H;RG�">P�;R�,>G>EHI>�/:NG=>KL���/>IM>F;>K������

Page 13: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

+MA>K�:<MBOBLML�PAH�A:=�IK>OBHNLER�;>>G�PHKDBG@�BG=BOB=N:EER�?HNG=P:RL�MH�G>MPHKD��%G�MA>�?:EE�H?������:�<HG?>K>G<>�HG�IKHLMBMNMBHG�:G=L>Q�PHKD�HK@:GBL>=�:M�MA>�1GBO>KLBMR�H?�0HE>=H�+ABH�K>LNEM>=�BG�:G�:=AH<� HK@:GBLBG@�F>>MBG@� ?HK� D>R�:<MBOBLML� LHPBG@� MA>�L>>=L� ?HK� MA>?HKF:MBHG�H?�MA>� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>�:G=�MA>��>LM�,K:<MB<>L�,HEB<R�,KHC><M��,,,���0A>�?HEEHPBG@�R>:K�:G�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�<HG?>K>G<>�MA>�444�"HKNFHK@:GBL>=�BG�)HGMK>:E�BG�):R������IKHOB=>=�:GHMA>K�HIIHKMNGBMR�?HK<:I:<BMR�:G=�<HFFNGBMR�;NBE=BG@��/M:<>R�/PBFF>�PAH�P>GM�HG�E:M>KMH�<H�?HNG=�MA>� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>��:G=�PAH�F>M�MA>��IK>:=�F:@:SBG>��

<HEE><MBO>�:G=�HMA>K�D>R�1/�@KHNIL�BG�)HGMK>:E�?HK�MA>�?BKLM�MBF>�K><:EEL��X%�P:L�BGLIBK>=�;R�444�;><:NL>�BM�P:L�LH�<E>:K�MA:M�>O>KR�HMA>K<HNGMKR�P:L�LH�FN<A�FHK>�HK@:GBL>=�MA:G�P>�P>K>�BG�MA>�1/��%M�:ELH:??><M>=�F>�MH�MABGD�MA:M�%�A:=�MH�@H�MH��:G:=:�MH�F>>M�L>Q�PHKD>KL?KHF�MA>�!:LM��H:LM�Y��

%G������:=OH<:M>L�?KHF�GNF>KHNL�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�<HGO>G>=�MH�>LM:;EBLAMA>� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>�MH�<K>:M>�G:MBHG:E�LI:<>L�?HK�MA>�>QIK>LLBHG�H?L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML��0A>�?BKLM� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>�<HG?>K>G<>�HK@:GBL>=:KHNG=�MA>�MA>F>�H?�.>�OBLBHGBG@�,KHLMBMNMBHG�,HEB<R�P:L�A>E=�BG�(:L2>@:L�BG�&NER�������0ABL�<HG?>K>G<>�P:L�MA>�?BKLM�G:MBHG:E�<HGO>GBG@?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�BG�:EFHLM�M>G�R>:KL��!G>K@BL>=�:<MBOBLML�K>MNKG>=AHF>�MH�<HGMBGN>�MA>BK�PHKD�<A:EE>G@BG@�BLLN>L�LN<A�:L�S>KH�MHE>K:G<>:G=�IKHLMBMNMBHG�?K>>�SHG>L��,"6L��IHEB<B>L����MA>R�:ELH�;>@:G�MH�:G:ERL>MA>�BFI:<M�H?�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�IHEB<B>L�:G=�MH�HK@:GBL>�LHF>�LF:EE�L<:E>�K>LIHGL>L���

�� �IK>:=�):@:SBG>�P:L� E:NG<A>=� BG������ ;R�.:<A>E��BF>>�.>;><<:� (RGG� :G=.:O>G�/MK>@:��0A>�F:@:SBG>�:BF>=�MH�BEENFBG:M>�MA>�L>Q�BG=NLMKR�:G=�P:L�;R:G=� ?HK� L>Q� PHKD>KL�� %GM>KOB>P�PBMA� .:<A>E��BF>>� <H�?HNG=>K� H?� �IK>:=):@:SBG>�;R�,>G>EHI>�/:NG=>KL����/>IM>F;>K������

�� %GM>KOB>P�PBMA�/M:<>R�/PBFF>���/>IM>F;>K�������� />>�?HK�>Q:FIE>�<:FI:B@GL�:@:BGLM�,"6�:G=�K>E:M>=�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�IHEB<B>L

HK@:GBL>=� ;R� MA>��EEB:G<>� ?HK� :� /:?>� :G=� BO>KL>� �� ;>@BGGBG@� BG� ����� :G=K>LBLM:G<>�:@:BGLM�,"6� :G=�Z=KN@�?K>>�SHG>L[� BG�,HKME:G=� BG� MA>�L:F>�I>KBH=MAKHN@A�MH��������EEB:G<>�?HK�:�/:?>�:G=� BO>KL>� � �8>/��5871��!853-371�;/@?8:4�37�(+;2371<87����� B??>K>GM��O>GN>L������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K�����AMMI� =<MK:GL<H:EBMBHG�?BE>L�PHK=IK>LL�<HF ���� �� FHO>:EHG@K>IHKM�I=?��!�'HR:F: $=:>3>371�<2/�(3<-2�2=7<���+<<5/�78</;�0:86�!8:<5+7.D;����>/7=/��� C��� �HG?EN>K>� ,N;EB<:MBHGL� ,HKME:G=�+K>@HG� �����

�� %G� >:KER� ����� ?HK� >Q:FIE>� MA>� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� /3+,�1/�� �>LM� ,K:<MB<>L,HEB<R�,KHC><M�MA>�3HH=ANEE�"K>>=HF�"HNG=:MBHG���5/3�*�:G=�EH<:E�L>KOB<>IKHOB=>KL� BG� MA>� BLMKB<M� H?� �HENF;B:� HK@:GBL>=� MH� K:BL>� :P:K>G>LL� H?� MA>IKH;E>F:MB<�BG<ENLBHG�H?�Z>G=�=>F:G=[�IKH@K:FFBG@�BG�MA> %:+003-4371�'3-<36;!:8</-<387� #/+=<28:3B+<387� �-<�

Page 14: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� �

�GHMA>K� LMK:G=� H?� HK@:GBLBG@� :@:BGLM� K>IK>LLBHG�PKHN@AM� ;R� :GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�:IIKH:<A>L�:G=�A>B@AM>G>=�IHEB<BG@�>F>K@>=�?KHF�A:KFK>=N<MBHG�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�EH<:E�L>KOB<>�IKHOB=>KL�:G=�<HFFNGBMB>L�H?<HEHNK��):GR�<HFBG@�?KHF�MA>L>�L><MHKL�=B=��:G=�=H��GHM�>F;K:<>�MA>M>KF�ZL>Q�PHKD[�:L�:�P:R�H?�=>L<KB;BG@�MA>BK�>G@:@>F>GM�BG�L>QN:E<HFF>K<>����/HF>�L>KOB<>�IKHOB=BG@�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�LN<A�:L�MA>�/M�&:F>L%G?BKF:KR�:G=� B??>K>GM��O>GN>L�P>K>�I:KMB<BI:MBG@�BG�MA>�>:KER�?HKF:MBHGH?� @KHNIL� LN<A� :L� MA>� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� ;NM� F:GR� HMA>KL� P>K>?HKFNE:MBG@� MA>BK� :IIKH:<A� MH� KB@AML�PBMABG� HMA>K�FHO>F>GML� ?HKK>IKH=N<MBO>�CNLMB<>�:G=�:@:BGLM�IHEB<>�FBL<HG=N<M����0A>L>�@KHNILMHHD�E>:=>KLABI�BG�<A:EE>G@BG@�BLLN>L�MA:M�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�HK@:GBL>KL?HNG=�=B??B<NEM�MH�G>@HMB:M>�LN<A�:L�MA>�BFI:<M�H?�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@IHEB<B>L�HG�F:K@BG:EBL>=�<HFFNGBMB>L�H?�RHNMA����0A>R�:ELH�JN>LMBHG>=G:KKHP�BGM>KIK>M:MBHGL�H?�=><KBFBG:EBL:MBHG�:G=�HMA>K�K>F>=B>L�PAB<AP>K>�;>BG@�IKHIHL>=�;R�LHF>�H?�MA>�G>P>K�L>Q�PHKD>K�:<MBOBLM�@KHNIL�

>LIBM>� @KHPBG@� LNIIHKM� :G=� G>MPHKDBG@� :<KHLL� KB@AML�;:L>=HK@:GBL:MBHGL� :G=� ;>MP>>G� <HFFNGBMB>L� H?� :<MBOBLML� :<<>LL� MHF:BGLMK>:F� IHEB<R�F:D>KL� NG=>K� MA>� �NLA� :=FBGBLMK:MBHG� P:LBFIHLLB;E>���G=K>:�.BM<AB>�:MMHKG>R�:M�/MK>>MPBL>�:G=�/:?>�BG�*>P5HKD�GHM>L�MA:M��X,>HIE>�A:=�:�LB>@>�>QI>KB>G<>�NG=>K��NLA��0K:??B<DBG@;><:F>�:�MHHE�?HK�INLABG@�;:<D�HG�:�PB=>�K:G@>�H?�@KHNIL��0A>K>�P:LGH�P:R�MA:M�P>�<HNE=�>G@:@>�BG�=BK><M�:=OH<:<R�BG�3:LABG@MHG�Y�/M:<>R/PBFF>�<HG<NKL�PBMA�MABL�:LL>LLF>GM��X3A:M�A:II>G>=�PBMA�MA>�L>QPHKD>KL�P:L�LBFBE:K�MH�PA:M�A:II>G>=�PBMA�HMA>K�LH<B:E�FHO>F>GMLNG=>K��NLA��0ABL�P:L�MA>�K>:EBL:MBHG�MA:M�NG=>K��NLA�P>�<HNE=�GHM:<AB>O>�:GR�?>=>K:E�OB<MHKB>L��3>�?H<NL>=�EH<:EER�BGLM>:=�:G=�PA:M�P>=B=�EH<:EER�P:L�<HFFNGBMR�;NBE=BG@�:G=�:EEB:G<>�;NBE=BG@\0ABL�I>KBH=H?�<HFFNGBMR�:G=�:EEB:G<>�;NBE=BG@�A:L�K>:EER�I:B=�H??�:G=�BL�I:KM�H?HNK�LN<<>LL�PBMA�MA>�1,.�Y��

�� %GM>KOB>P�PBMA��G=K>:�.BM<AB>�/M>>MPBL>�:G=�/:?>�;R�,>G>EHI>�/:NG=>KL���/>IM>F;>K� �����

�� .BM<AB> 89��-3<������%*�%0!��3HF>G�H?��HEHK��@:BGLM�2BHE>G<>�X*H�/BFIE>�/HENMBHGL��/M:M>�2BHE>G<>

:G=� MA>� />Q� 0K:=>LY� ����IKBE� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� BG<BM>;EH@�PHK=IK>LL�<HF ���� �� �� GH�LBFIE>�LHENMBHGL�LM:M>�OBHE>G<>�:G=�MA>�L>Q�MK:=>L �<HFF>GML�

�� /PBFF> 89��-3<�

Page 15: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

�)&� ���-/-&.3

0A>�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>P�BL�:�K>E:MBO>ER�G>P�IKH<>=NK>�<K>:M>=�;RMA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE��?HKF>KER�MA>�$NF:G�.B@AML�HFFBLLBHG���0A>�INKIHL>�H?�MA>�1,.�BL�MH�IN;EB<ER�>Q:FBG>�MA>�ANF:GKB@AML�K><HK=�H?�:EE�1*�F>F;>K�/M:M>L�� NKBG@�>:<A�?HNK�R>:K�<R<E>�:EE/M:M>L�PBEE�;>�K>OB>P>=��"HK�>:<A�F>F;>K�LM:M>�;>BG@�K>OB>P>=�MA>$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE�L>E><ML�MAK>>�K:IIHKM>NKL��K>?>KK>=�MH�:L�MA>MKHBD:��MH�?:<BEBM:M>�MA>�K>OB>P�IKH<>LL��0A>�>OB=>G<>�NG=>K�K>OB>PF:R�<HGLBLM�H?�G:MBHG:E�K>IHKML�BG?HKF:MBHG�IKHOB=>=�;R�BG=>I>G=>GMANF:G�KB@AML�>QI>KML�MK>:MR�;H=B>L�:G=�HMA>K�1*�>GMBMB>L�:G=�ZLA:=HPK>IHKML[�?KHF�*#+L�:G=�HMA>K�G:MBHG:E�ANF:G�KB@AML�BGLMBMNMBHGL���

%G������MA>�<NKK>GM�ANF:G�KB@AML�K><HK=�H?�MA>�1/�P:L�MH�;>�K>OB>P>=���

%G�">;KN:KR������MA>�/>QN:E�.B@AML�%GBMB:MBO>��/.%��:�@EH;:E�<H:EBMBHGH?�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�PAB<A�:BFL�BG�I:KM�MH�K>?K:F>�L>QN:E�KB@AML�:M�MA>E>O>E�H?�MA>�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE���L>GM�HNM�:�<:EE�?HK�:IIEB<:MBHGL?KHF�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�?KHF�<HNGMKB>L�NG=>K�K>OB>P��BG<EN=BG@�MA>�1/��MHPKBM>�K>IHKML�K>@:K=BG@�K>IKH=N<MBO>�KB@AML�L>QN:E�=BO>KLBMR�L>QN:EBMR>=N<:MBHG�:G=�$%2 �% /����ANF:G�KB@AML�:=OBL>K�MH�MA>��>LM�,K:<MB<>L,HEB<R�,KHC><M�?HKP:K=>=�MABL�<:EE�?KHF�/.%�MH�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�BG�BML�1/G>MPHKD�PAB<A�:K>�:EB@G>=�PBMA�L>QN:E�KB@AML�:G=�CNLMB<>�?HK�I>HIE>�BGMA>�L>Q�MK:=>���,,,�:IIEB>=�MH�PKBM>�:�K>IHKM�BG�I:KMG>KLABI�PBMA�MA> >LBK>>��EEB:G<>�HG�ANF:G�KB@AML�:;NL>L�>QI>KB>G<>=�;R�L>Q�PHKD>KLBG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L��0A>�K>IHKMW=>O>EHI>=�PBMA�>QM>GLBO>�<HGLNEM:MBHG:<KHLL� HK@:GBL:MBHGL�PHKDBG@� ?HK� MA>� KB@AML� :G=�P>EE�;>BG@� H?� L>QPHKD>KL�I>HIE>�BG�MA>�L>Q�MK:=>�:G=�K>E:M>=�<HFFNGBMB>LWP:L�HG>�H?

�� 1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�+??B<>�H?�MA>�$B@A��HFFBLLBHG>K�?HK�$NF:G�.B@AML �+;3-��+-<;�,8=<�<2/�&!#�+$�$.������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K������AMMI� PPP�HA<AK�HK@ >G AK;H=B>L NIK I:@>L �:LB<":<ML�:LIQ�

�� �>MP>>G������:G=������MA>�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BEYL�1GBO>KL:E�,>KBH=B<�.>OB>PAHLM>=�BML�?BKLM�KHNG=�H?�K>OB>PL�PAB<A�<HGLBLM>=�H?����K>OB>P�L>LLBHGL�>:<AH?�PAB<A�?H<NL>=�HG����1*�F>F;>K�/M:M>L��0A>�1/�P:L�K>OB>P>=�=NKBG@�MA>��MAL>LLBHG��BG��������0A>�?HEEHPBG@�EBGD�EBLML�>:<A�F>F;>K�LM:M>�;R�MA>BK� K>OB>PL>LLBHG�� AMMI� PPP�HA<AK�HK@ !* $.�H=B>L 1,. H<NF>GML NIKEBLM�I=?�0A>�L><HG=�KHNG=�H?�1,.�L>LLBHGL�PBEE�<HFF>G<>�;>MP>>G�����W������.>MKB>O>=&:GN:KR� �����

�� 3ABE>�MA>�/.%�A>EI>=�;KBG@�L>Q�PHKD�BLLN>L�MH�MA>�1*�M:;E>�MABL�IKH<>LL�P:L:ELH�?:<BEBM:M>=�;R�FHK>�MA:G�MAK>>�=><:=>L�H?�:<MBOBLF�:G=�L<AHE:KLABI�:KHNG=MA>�<HG<>IML�H?�L>QN:E�A>:EMA�:G=�KB@AML�HG�:�=HF>LMB<��1/��:G=�@EH;:E�L<:E>�/>>�?HK�>Q:FIE>����)BEE>K���2:G<>�X/>QN:EBMR�$NF:G�.B@AML�:G=�$>:EMAY �/+5<2+7.��=6+7�#312<;�OHE����GH���������II���W����/��HKK>:�.�,>M<A>LDR�>M�:E�$/@=+53<A���/+5<2�+7.��=6+7�#312<;�.HNME>=@>�*>P�5HKD������

Page 16: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

:�A:G=?NE�<AHL>G�;R�MA>�/.%�MH�IKH<>>=�MH�=>O>EHIBG@�:�?NEE�K>IHKM�?HKLN;FBLLBHG�MH�MA>�1*�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE��0ABL�K>IHKM�<HGLMBMNM>=MA>�?BKLM�G:MBHG:E�LM:M>F>GM�H?�MA>�LM:MNL�H?�MA>�ANF:G�KB@AML�H?�L>QPHKD>KL�BG�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L���

%G�*HO>F;>K������MPH�F>F;>KL�H?�MA>��,,,�,>G>EHI>�/:NG=>KL�:G= :K;R�$B<D>R�P>K>�BGOBM>=�;R�MA>�/.%�MH�;>�IK>L>GM�BG�/PBMS>KE:G==NKBG@�MA>�?BKLM�1,.�F>>MBG@�?HK�MA>�1GBM>=�/M:M>L��/:NG=>KL�:G=�$B<D>RCHBG>=�=HS>GL�H?�HMA>K�1/�K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L�BG�#>G>O:�MH�=BL<NLL�ANF:GKB@AML�OBHE:MBHGL� BG� MA>�1/�PBMA�F>F;>KL�H?�MA>�1*�$NF:G�.B@AML�HNG<BE��):GR�H?�MA>L>�F>F;>KL�P>K>�BGM>K>LM>=�BG�LI>:DBG@�PBMA/:NG=>KL� :G=� $B<D>R� BG<EN=BG@� MA>� =>E>@:MBHG� H?� 1KN@N:R� PAB<ALN;L>JN>GMER�IKHIHL>=�K><HFF>G=:MBHG�����

"HK�MA>�G>QM�MAK>>�:G=�:�A:E?�FHGMAL��E>:=BG@�NI�MH�>:KER�):K<A�����PA>G�MA>�1/�PHNE=�:GGHNG<>�BML�K>LIHGL>�MH�MA>�1,.�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�:=OH<:M>L�BG�MA>�1/�INLA>=�MA>FL>EO>L�;>RHG=�PA:MMA>R�A:=�IK>OBHNLER�MAHN@AM�MA>R�<HNE=�:<AB>O>��0A>R�?HKF>=�:�PHKDBG@@KHNI�G:F>=�$NF:G�.B@AML�?HK��EE��$."�����PAB<A�>G@:@>=�BG�:�L>KB>LH?�<HHK=BG:M>=�AB@A�E>O>K:@>�HK@:GBLBG@�:<MBOBMB>L�MA:M�BG<EN=>=��MA>=>O>EHIF>GM�H?�:�Z<:EE�MH�:<MBHG[�:==K>LL>=�MH�MA>�1/�@HO>KGF>GM�LB@G>=� ;R�FHK>� MA:G� ���� :<:=>FB<L� IN;EB<� A>:EMA� E>:=>KL� :G=LNIIHKMBG@�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�BG<EN=BG@�G:MBHG:E�:G=�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�ANF:GKB@AML�@KHNIL���MA>�@:KG>KBG@�H?�LNIIHKM�?KHF�AB@A�IKH?BE>�E>:=>KL�BGMA>�?B>E=L�H?�A>:EMA�<KBFBGHEH@R�:G=�PHF>GYL�KB@AML��MA>�=>O>EHIF>GMH?�:�IHEB<R�;KB>?�M:BEHK>=�MH�MA>�1/�?>=>K:E�@HO>KGF>GM�<HGM>QM�BG<EN=BG@:�K>?BG>=�L>M�H?�IHEB<R�:F>G:;E>�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL��:G=�:G�>=N<:MBHG:E

�� �>LM�,K:<MB<>L�,HEB<R�,KHC><M� >LBK>>��EEB:G<>� />QN:E�.B@AML� %GBMB:MBO>�I������� � 0ABL�PHKD� K>JNBK>=� LN;LM:GMB:E� MBF>� >??HKM� <K>:MBO>� OBLBHG� I:MB>G<>� :G=

<HEE:;HK:MBHG�:<KHLL�F:GR�LM:M>�EBG>L�:G=�MBF>�SHG>L���HK>�F>F;>KL�H?�$NF:G.B@AML�?HK��EE� BG<EN=BG@�MA>�:NMAHKL�H?�MABL�:KMB<E>� E:;HNK>=�:M� MBF>L�:KHNG=MA>� <EH<D�NG=>K� <HG=BMBHGL� H?� L>O>K>� MBF>� EBFBM:MBHG�� 0A>� E>:KGBG@�<NKO>� ?HKFHLM� H?� NL�P:L� O>KR� LM>>I� >LI><B:EER� K>@:K=BG@�PKBMBG@� ?HK� :G=� LI>:DBG@� MHIHEB<R�F:D>KL� ;NM� :ELH� BG� E>:KGBG@� AHP� MH� PHKD� MH@>MA>K� :<KHLL� =BO>KL>I>KLHG:EBMB>L�:G=�IHLBMBHGL� �F:=>�FHK>�<A:EE>G@BG@�;R�MA>�G>>=�MH�=H�LH�OB:>F:BE�:G=�IAHG>�K:MA>K�MA:G�?:<>�MH�?:<>���%G�HK=>K�MH�ZPBG[�PBMA�MA>�1,.�P>DG>P�P>�G>>=>=�MH�PHKD�JNB<DER�:G=�>??B<B>GMER�PABE>� ?HK@BG@�:EEB:G<>L�PBMAI>HIE>�BG�IHLBMBHGL�H?�BGLMBMNMBHG:E�IHP>K���NM�BG�HK=>K�MH�ZPBG[�BG�MA>�EHG@>KKNG�:L�:�FHO>F>GM�P>�DG>P�P>�G>>=>=�MH�IE:<>�MA>�OHB<>L�:G=�G>>=L�H?�:=BO>KLBMR�H?� L>Q�PHKD>KL�:M� MA>�<>GM>K�H?� MA>�>??HKM�:G=�MH�AHGHNK�IKBG<BIE>LH?�MK:GLI:K>G<R�:G=�<HGL>GLNL�;NBE=BG@��3ABE>�MA>�>QI>KB>G<>�P:L�BGO:EN:;E>?HK�E>:KGBG@�AHP�MH�<K>:M>�<A:G@>�;R�K>:<ABG@�?HK�:EEB>L�:<KHLL�=BO>KL>�L><MHKLH?� LH<B>MR� HNK� IKH<>LL�P:L� ;R� GH�F>:GL� I>K?><M��+NK� K>?E><MBHGL� HG� AHP� MH;>LM�:<<HFIEBLA� MABL� ;:E:G<>�H?� LAHKM�M>KF EHG@>K�M>KF� @H:EL� :K>�HG@HBG@�

Page 17: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

<:FI:B@G�MH�BG?HKF�<HG@K>LLBHG:E�E>:=>KL�:;HNM�MA>�<KBMB<:E�BLLN>L�L>QPHKD>KL�?:<>�:G=�H??>K�LHF>�IHM>GMB:E�OB:;E>�LHENMBHGL���

#/0:+6371 ;/@ ?8:4� 08: 0/./:+5� 8003-3+5;

0A>� IKH<>LL� H?� MKRBG@� MH� <HGOBG<>� /M:M>� >I:KMF>GM� H??B<B:EL� MHNG=>KLM:G=�L>Q�PHKD�:L�:�=HF>LMB<�ANF:G�KB@AML�BLLN>�:G=�GHM�LBFIER:G�BLLN>�H?�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�<KBF>�IHL>=�:�GNF;>K�H?�<A:EE>G@>L�3>�=>L<KB;>�MAK>>�A>K>�

"BKLM�;><:NL>�H?�MA>�I>KLBLM>GM�FBLI>K<>IMBHG�BG�MA>�1/�MA:M�FHLM�HK:EE�L>Q�PHKD>KL�:K>�OB<MBFL�H?�ZMK:??B<DBG@[�:=OH<:M>L�G>>=>=�MH�<E>:KER=>?BG>�MA>�=B??>K>G<>�;>MP>>G�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�L>Q�PHKD�MH�IHEB<RF:D>KL���R�=HBG@�LH�MA>R�<HNE=�MA>G�BEENFBG:M>�?HK�H??B<B:EL�PAR�BM�BL�:IKH;E>F� MA:M� 1/� IHEB<B>L� :@:BGLM� L>Q�PHKD� :G=�ANF:G� MK:??B<DBG@FBLM:D>GER�LM>F�?KHF�MA>�L:F>�EH@B<��NGEBD>�?HK�>Q:FIE>�IHEB<B>L:KHNG=�MK:??B<D>=�?:KF�E:;HNK�OL��OHENGM:KR�?:KF�E:;HNK��

/><HG=�?>=>K:E�IHEB<R�K>?HKF�:KHNG=�K>=N<BG@�OBHE>G<>�:G=�ANF:GKB@AML� :;NL>L� :@:BGLM� L>Q� PHKD>KL� BL� I:KMB<NE:KER� =B??B<NEM� MHBGLMBMNMBHG:EBL>�=N>�MH�MA>�1/�@HO>KG:G<>�LMKN<MNK>�BG�PAB<A�IHP>K�BL=BOB=>=�:G=�LA:K>=�;>MP>>G�MA>�<>GMK:E��?>=>K:E��:G=�LM:M>�HK�EH<:E@HO>KGF>GML��%G�HMA>K�PHK=L�>O>G�B?�MA>�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�<A:G@>=BML�NG=>KLM:G=BG@�H?�L>Q�PHKD�:G=�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�MABL�PHNE=�GHM:NMHF:MB<:EER�MK:GLE:M>�BGMH�E>@:E�<A:G@>L�:M�MA>�LM:M>�HK�EH<:E�E>O>E���

�� �'�(>KNF�,�/:NG=>KL�>M�:E� #/.=-371�'385/7-/�+1+37;<�$/@�(8:4/:;��(2+<�+:/<2/� 9853-A� 89<387;� $NF:G� .B@AML� ?HK��EE� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����AMMI� PPP�ANF:GKB@AML?HK:EE�BG?H NIEH:=L ,HEB<R9�KB>?9"%*�(�I=?��� $NF:G.B@AML� ?HK��EE �+55� <8��-<387� �/<</:� <8� �+:85.� �82�� �3-2+/5� !8;7/:�� �+>3.$=553>+7� +7.� �+>3.� �=;,A� $NF:G� .B@AML� ?HK��EE� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K����� AMMI� PPP�ANF:GKB@AML?HK:EE�BG?H NIEH:=L /B@G9HG9(>MM>K9������9��IF�����I=?�

�� �L�HNMEBG>=�BG�MA>��HGLMBMNMBHG�MA>�1/�@HO>KGF>GM�BL�;:L>=�HG�MA>�IKBG<BIE>�H??>=>K:EBLF�BG�PAB<A�IHP>K�BL�=BOB=>=�:G=�LA:K>=�;>MP>>G�MA>�<>GMK:E��?>=>K:E�:G=� LM:M>� HK� EH<:E� @HO>KGF>GML�� %G� MA>� I:LM� MA>� ?>=>K:E� @HO>KGF>GM� A:L=>FNKK>=�PA>G�<HG?KHGM>=�PBMA�MA>�>OB=>G<>�H?�@KHLL�ANF:G�KB@AML�OBHE:MBHGL:@:BGLM� L>Q� PHKD>KL� <BMBG@� LM:M>� :NMAHKBMR� HO>K� IHEB<BG@� :G=� EH<:E� E:P>G?HK<>F>GM� BLLN>L�� �KBFBG:E� IKHAB;BMBHG� H?� L>Q� ?HK�FHG>R� :G=� LNKKHNG=BG@:<MBOBMB>L� >QBLML� BG�FHLM� /M:M>L� �PBMA� MA>� >Q<>IMBHG� H?� LHF>� <HNGMB>L� BG� MA>LM:M>�H?�*>O:=:���/HF>�?HKFL�H?�L>Q�PHKD�LN<A�:L�>QHMB<�=:G<BG@�F:R�GHM�;>IKHAB;BM>=� ;R� LM:M>� E>@BLE:MBHG� ;NM� MA>R� :K>� :EP:RL� K>@NE:M>=� ;R� LM:M>� :G=FNGB<BI:E�IHEB<B>L��/>Q�PHKD�MA:M�H<<NKL�BG�IN;EB<�LI:<>L�BL�:ELH�H?M>G�IHEB<>=NG=>K�E>@BLE:MBHG�IKHAB;BMBG@�EHBM>KBG@�IN;EB<�GNBL:G<>�MK>LI:LLBG@�HK�Z?:BENK>MH� H;>R[� :� IHEB<>� H??B<>KYL� =BK><MBO>� MH� FHO>� :EHG@�� >LIBM>� IHEBMB<B:GLY

Page 18: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

0ABK=�PABE>�IHEB<>�OBHE>G<>�:G=�<KBFBG:EBL:MBHG�P>K>��:G=�:K>��MA>FHLM�IK>LLBG@�ANF:G�KB@AML�<HG<>KGL�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�:=OH<:M>LBG�MA>�1/�:=OH<:M>L�K>:EBL>=�MA:M�MA>R�<HNE=�GHM�:==K>LL�L>Q�PHKD>KLYKB@AML�PBMA�1/�E:PF:D>KL�PBMAHNM�:ELH�>G@:@BG@�BG�=B:EH@N>�:KHNG=<NKK>GM�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�F>:LNK>L��0A>K>?HK>�BG�=>O>EHIBG@�F>LL:@>LMA:M�PHNE=�K>LHG:M>�BG�F>>MBG@L�PBMA�$HNL>�:G=�/>G:M>�K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L:G=� MA>� /M:M>� >I:KMF>GM� :=OH<:M>L� G>>=>=� MH� NG=>KL<HK>� MA>G>@:MBO>�BFI:<M�MA:M�MK:??B<DBG@�F>:LNK>L�A:O>�HG�ANF:G�KB@AML�BGMA>�1/��"HK�>Q:FIE>�MA>R�=K>P�:MM>GMBHG�MH�MA>�P:RL�MA:M�?>=>K:E:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@� ?NG=BG@� LMK>:FL� A:O> 37-:/+;/. �K:MA>K� MA:G=><K>:L>=��E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM�:;NL>�HG�L>Q�PHKD>KL�:M�<BMR�:G=�LM:M>E>O>EL�����M�MA>�L:F>�MBF>�=N>�MH�?>=>K:E�?NG=BG@�K>LMKB<MBHGL�?HK�LN<AK>L>:K<A�BG�MA>�1/�;NBE=BG@�MABL�<:L>�PBMA�LRLM>F:MB<�K>L>:K<A�>OB=>G<>�:L�HIIHL>=�MH�:G><=HM:E�LMHKB>L��BL�:G�HG@HBG@�<A:EE>G@>���

�877/-<371�?3<2� 0/./:+5� 8003-3+5;

%G� ">;KN:KR� ����� :=OH<:M>L� F>M� PBMA� />G:M>� :G=� $HNL>K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L� :G=� MA>BK� LM:??� MH� K:BL>� :P:K>G>LL� :;HNM� 1,.K><HFF>G=:MBHG� ���� :G=� MA>� G>>=� ?HK� MA>� 1/� MH� :<<>IM� MA>K><HFF>G=:MBHG�BG�BML�K>IHKM�MH�MA>�1*�����=OH<:M>L�:ELH�F:G:@>=�MHF>>M�PBMA�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L�BG<EN=BG@�$:KHE=�'HAL>GBHK�E>@:E�:=OBL>K�MH�/><K>M:KR�H?�/M:M>�$BEE:KR��EBGMHG�:G=�A>:=�H?MA>�1/�=>E>@:MBHG�MH�MA>�1*�$NF:G�.B@AML��HFFBLLBHG�?HK�MA>�1,.�3ABE>�MA>L>�F>>MBG@L�MHHD�<HGLB=>K:;E>�>??HKM�?HK�:=OH<:M>L�MH�:KK:G@>MA>R�P>K>�?:<BEBM:M>=�;R�MA>�F:G=:M>�IKHOB=>=�;R�MA>�1,.�MH�>G@:@>�BGHI>G�=B:EH@N>�PBMA�F>F;>KL�H?�<BOBE�LH<B>MR��/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�H??B<B:EL

IK>?>K>G<>� ?HK� EH<:E� <HGMKHE� IHEB<BG@� :G=� E:P� >G?HK<>F>GM� A:L� :G=� <:G� ;>:??><M>=�;R�?>=>K:E�K>@NE:MBHGL��"HK�>Q:FIE>�LM:M>�:G=�EH<:E�IHEB<>�=>I:KMF>GMLA:O>�;>>G�?>=>K:EER�HK=>K>=�MH�:EM>K�MA>BK�ABKBG@�:G=�MK:BGBG@�IHEB<B>L�MH�>GLNK>MA:M� PHF>G� :G=� >MAGB< K:<B:E� FBGHKBMB>L� :K>� @BO>G� :<<>LL� MH� CH;L� BG� MA>L>:@>G<B>L�� ">=>K:E� K>@NE:MBHGL� <:G� :ELH� :??><M� LM:M>� @HO>KGF>GM� <HGMKHE� H?IHEB<BG@� MAKHN@A� ?BL<:E� ?>=>K:EBLF� HK� @K:GML�BG�:B=� IKH@K:FF>L�

�� />>� />Q�3HKD>KL�,KHC><M &;/� 80�#+3.;� <8� �312<�%:+003-4371� 37�!/:;87;� /3,����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�NK;:GCNLMB<>�HK@ I=? IN;EB<:MBHGL 'B<DBG@9 HPG90A>9 HHK9!Q><9/NF�I=?���:L>=�HG�BGM>KOB>PL�PBMAL>E?�B=>GMB?B>=� MK:??B<DBG@� OB<MBFL� MABL� K>IHKM� K><HFF>G=L� :� KB@AML�;:L>=�K:MA>K� MA:G�:� E:P�>G?HK<>F>GM� ;:L>=��:IIKH:<A� MH� B=>GMB?RBG@�:G=� :LLBLMBG@MK:??B<DBG@� OB<MBFL�

�� />>��3>BMS>K�I�������� �EMAHN@A�MA>�1,.�BL�:�F:MM>K�H?�MA>�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�:G=�GHM�:G�BLLN>�MH�;>

OHM>=� HG� ;R� />G:M>� :G=�$HNL>� K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L� :=OH<:M>L� ?>EM� MA:M� MA>� 1,.IKH<>LL�P:L�:G�BFIHKM:GM�>=N<:MBHG:E�HIIHKMNGBMR�?HK�?>=>K:E�E:PF:D>KL�PAHOHM>�HG�=HF>LMB<�E>@BLE:MBHG�LN<A�:L�MA>�02,��

Page 19: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

MHHD�MABL�1*�F:G=:M>�L>KBHNLER�:G=�K>I>:M>=ER�:KMB<NE:M>=�MH�ANF:GKB@AML�:<MBOBLML�MA>BK�BGM>GM�MH�=>FHGLMK:M>�MH�MA>BK�@EH;:E�I>>KL�AHPMA>�1/�BL�:�FH=>E�?HK�AHP�MH�;>LM�>G@:@>�PBMA�<BOBE�LH<B>MR�=NKBG@�MA>1,.�IKH<>LL�

%G�MA>BK�F>LL:@>L�MH�K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L�H?�MA>�$HNL>�:G=�/>G:M>�:G=/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�:=OH<:M>L�LMK>LL>=�MA:M�IHEB<B>L�FNLM�;>�:<<HNGM:;E>MH�K>EB:;E>�>OB=>G<>�:G=�:LL>LLF>GM��0H�:==K>LL�MABL�G>>=�MA>R�NK@>=K>IK>L>GM:MBO>L�MH�;NBE=�X<:I:<BMR�?HK�ANF:G�KB@AML�MAKHN@A�K>L>:K<A:G=�=B:EH@N>Y����%G�:==BMBHG�:=OH<:M>L�NK@>=�MA>�1/�@HO>KGF>GM�:G=�HG@K>LL�MH�X7F8H=B?R�HK�>EBFBG:M>�>QBLMBG@�?>=>K:E�IHEB<B>L�MA:M�<HG?E:M>L>Q�PHKD�PBMA�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�IK>O>GM�L>Q�PHKD>KL�?KHF�:<<>LLBG@L>KOB<>L�LN<A�:L�A>:EMA<:K>�$%2�IK>O>GMBHG�:G=�LNIIHKMY���=OH<:M>L:ELH�K><HFF>G=>=�MA>�K>OH<:MBHG�H?�MA>�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�EHR:EMR�H:MA�BGLMKN<MBG@�MA>� >I:KMF>GM�H?�&NLMB<>�MH�<>:L>�BML�:II>:E�H?�EBMB@:MBHG<A:EE>G@BG@�MA>�H:MA��:G=�IKHIHL>=�MA:M�L>Q�PHKD>KL�LAHNE=�;>�BG<EN=>=BG�MA>�1/�*:MBHG:E�$%2 �% /�/MK:M>@R�K>@:K=BG@�IK>O>GMBHG�:G=�A:KFK>=N<MBHG�>??HKML���

"HK�MA>�?BKLM�MBF>�LBG<>�MA>�K>;BKMA�H?�MA>�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�FHO>F>GMBG�MA>�����L�:=OH<:M>L�<:KKRBG@�<E>:K�:G=�P>EE�=>O>EHI>=�F>LL:@>LA:=�@:BG>=�:<<>LL�MH�L>GBHK�IHEB<R�F:D>KL�:G=�>E><M>=�?>=>K:E�H??B<B:EL� NKBG@� MA>L>�F>>MBG@L�F:GR� IHEB<R�F:D>KL� BGBMB:EER� :LLNF>=� MA:M:=OH<:M>L�A:=�<HF>�MH�K:BL>�<HG<>KG�HO>K�ZL>Q�MK:??B<DBG@[��LHF>P>K>�BGBMB:EER�NG:;E>�MH�@K:LI�MA>�B=>:�MA:M�GHG�MK:??B<DBG@�K>E:M>=ANF:G�KB@AML�:;NL>L�P>K>�?:<>=�;R�MA>�<HGLMBMN>GML�K>IK>L>GM>=�;R$NF:G�.B@AML�?HK��EE����0A>L>�F>>MBG@L�BEENLMK:M>=�MA>�>QM>GM�MH�PAB<AZL>Q� MK:??B<DBG@[� A:=�<HF>� MH� ;>� NG=>KLMHH=�;R� IHEB<R�F:D>KL� BG

�� 0H� =:M>� MA>� 1/� LMBEE� E:<DL� :=>JN:M>� :G=� KB@HKHNL� :LL>LLF>GM� H?� MA>� ANF:G<HGL>JN>G<>L� H?� BML� HPG� :GMB�MK:??B<DBG@� IHEB<B>L� ;HMA� HG� :� =HF>LMB<� :G=� :@EH;:E�E>O>E��/>>�#EH;:E��EEB:G<>��@:BGLM�0K:??B<�BG�3HF>G �855+</:+5��+6+1/�%2/� 369+-<�80� +7<3�<:+003-4371�6/+;=:/;� 87� 2=6+7� :312<;� +:8=7.� <2/�?8:5.#��03������II��������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K������ �AMMI� PPP�@::MP�HK@ �HEE:M>K:E��� :F:@>9"BG:E LBG@E>?BE>9�HEE:M>K:E :F:@>?BG:E�I=?�� /P>=>GW:GHMA>K� @EH;:E� E>:=>K� BG� :@@K>LLBO>� :GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG� IHEB<B>LWA:L� :ELH� ;>>G<KBMBJN>=� ?HK� BML� =>:KMA� H?� KB@HKHNL� :LL>LLF>GM� H?� BML� IHEB<R� BFI:<M�� />>����&HK=:G�0A>�/P>=BLA�(:P�MH��KBFBG:EBS>��EB>GML����?:BE>=�>QI>KBF>GM�BG�/H<B:E!G@BG>>KBG@�� �>GM>K� ?HK� $NF:G� .B@AML� �� $NF:GBM:KB:G� (:P��IKBE� ����K>MKB>O>=� &NG>� ����� AMMI� KB@AMLPHKD�HK@ PI�<HGM>GM NIEH:=L ���� �� %LLN>�,:I>K���I=?

�� "HK�MA>�?NEE�EBLM�H?�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL�L>>��(>KNF�>M�:E�������� 89��-3<��� ��:KEBG�$NF:G�.B@AML�?HK��EE�<HFFNGB<:MBHG�;R�>F:BE�/>IM>F;>K���������

Page 20: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

3:LABG@MHG� ����:L�MA>�<>GMK:E�BLLN>�>G<HFI:LLBG@�:EE�ANF:G�KB@AMLJN>LMBHGL�BG�K>@:K=L�MH�IKHLMBMNMBHG��$HP>O>K�MA>L>�F>>MBG@L�:ELH=>FHGLMK:M>=�MA>�BGM>EE><MN:E�HI>GG>LL�H?�LHF>�<NKK>GM�H??B<B:EL�MH;KH:=>G�MA>BK�NG=>KLM:G=BG@�H?�MA>�BLLN>L�:M�A:G=�W�>LI><B:EER�PA>GIK>L>GM>=�PBMA�F>MB<NEHNL�>OB=>G<>�:G=�PA>G�LNIIHKM>=�;R�:�;KH:=<H:EBMBHG�H?�K>LI><M>=�:<MBOBLML�L<AHE:KL�:G=�A>:EMA�H??B<B:EL�

�L� :� K>LNEM� H?� MA>L>� LN<<>LL?NE� <HGG><MBHGL� :<KHLL�F:GR� EBG>L� H?=B??>K>G<>��;HMA�PBMABG�MA>�$NF:G�.B@AML�?HK��EE�<H:EBMBHG�:G=�;>MP>>GMA>�$."��:=OH<:M>L�:G=�?>=>K:E�H??B<B:EL��MA>�F>LL:@>L�=>EBO>K>=�;RMA>� :<MBOBLML� BGLMB@:M>=� :� L>KB>L� H?� ;HMA� I>KLHG:E� :G=� IHEBMB<:EMK:GL?HKF:MBHGL��)HLM�GHM:;ER�BG�>:KER�):K<A������MA>�1/�K>E>:L>=K>IHKM�MH�MA>�1GBM>=�*:MBHGL�BG�PAB<A�MA>�@HO>KGF>GM�H??B<B:EER�:<<>IM>=K><HFF>G=:MBHG� ���� LM:MBG@� �8� 87/� ;28=5.� 0+-/� >385/7-/� 8:.3;-:3637+<387�37�+--/;;�<8�9=,53-�;/:>3-/;�,+;/.�87�;/@=+5�8:3/7<+<387

8:�<2/3:�;<+<=;�+;�+�9/:;87�37�9:8;<3<=<387�����L�P>�=>L<KB;>�G>QM�MABLK>F:KD:;E>�:G=�ABLMHKB<�LM:M>F>GM�;R�MA>�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�A:L�HI>G>=NI�:�G>P�L>M�H?�HIIHKMNGBMB>L�:G=�<A:EE>G@>L�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>K�:<MBOBLML�

�411&.3��00/134.*3*&2�".%��)",,&.(&2

0A>�1,.�IKH<>LL�AB@AEB@AM>=�MA>�HG@HBG@�BFIHKM:G<>�H?�MA>�@EH;:EANF:G� KB@AML� <HFFNGBMR� ?HK� ;KBG@BG@� :� =BO>KLBMR� H?�F:K@BG:EBL>=OHB<>LWBG<EN=BG@�MAHL>�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KLWMH�MA>�:MM>GMBHG�H?�1/�IHEB<RF:D>KL����%M�BL�HNK�<HGM>GMBHG�MA:M�MA>�1/�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GMYL�:<<>IM:G<>H?�K><HFF>G=:MBHG�����BL�:G�BG=B<:MBHG�H?�MA>�:;BEBMR�?HK�HK@:GBL>=L>Q�PHKD>KL�:G=�MA>BK�:EEB>L�MH�IK>LL�?HK�<A:G@>����.><HFF>G=:MBHG

�� 1�/�� >I:KMF>GM� H?� /M:M> &�$�� #/;987;/� <8� <2/� &�� �=6+7� #312<;� �8=7-35(8:4371��:8=9�#/98:<�1�/�� +/����):K<A������ K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K�����AMMI� PPP�LM:M>�@HO C =KE NIK �������AMF�

�� 3ABE>� MA>� @>HIHEBMB<:E� =BO>KLBMR� ;NBEM� BGMH� MA>� 1,.� IKH<>LL� BL� <KN<B:E� ?HK?:<BEBM:MBG@� MA>� K:BLBG@� H?� G>P� BLLN>L� LH� MHH� <:G� MABL� =BO>KLBMR� BGAB;BM� MA>K:BLBG@�H?� HMA>KL�� "HK� MABL� K>:LHG� MA>�PHKD�H?� MK:GLG:MBHG:E� <H:EBMBHGL� LN<A:L�MA>�/.%�:K>�<KBMB<:E�?HK�MA>�LN<<>LL?NE�?K:FBG@�H?�F:K@BG:EBL>=�BLLN>L�:M�MA>E>O>E�H?�MA>�1*�

�� 0ABL� IHM>GMB:E� BL� :ELH�;HKG>� HNM� ;R� HMA>K� LB@GB?B<:GM� K><>GM� OB<MHKB>L�PHG�;RL>Q�PHKD>KL� :M� LM:M>� :G=� EH<:E� E>O>EL� BG<EN=BG@� MA>� HO>KMNKGBG@� H?� MA>� L>QH??>G=>K� E:P� BG�(HNBLB:G:��/>>��&�"E:A>KMR� X/>Q�H??>G=>K� K>@BLMK:MBHG� ?HK� L>QPHKD>KL�>G=L�BG�(HNBLB:G:Y�(HNBLB:G:�&NLMB<>�%GLMBMNM>����&NG>������K>MKB>O>=/>IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� EHNBLB:G:CNLMB<>BGLMBMNM>�;EH@LIHM�<HF ���� �� L>Q�H??>G=>K�K>@BLMK:MBHG�?HK�L>Q�AMFE�

Page 21: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

���

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

����BL�BML>E?�EBFBM>=�BG�PA:M�BM�<:EEL�?HKW?K:FBG@�ANF:G�KB@AML�:;NL>LBG�M>KFL�H?�;:LB<�K>LI><M�NG=>K�MA>�E:P�:G=�:<<>LL�MH�LH<B:E�L>KOB<>L���

$HP>O>K�:�;KH:=>K�ANF:G�KB@AML�LMK:M>@R�:KHNG=�L>Q�PHKD��>�@��HG>MA:M�:ELH�BG<EN=>L�E:;HNK�KB@AML�BFFB@K:GM�KB@AML�:G=�L>QN:E�KB@AML�A:L�MA>�IHM>GMB:E�MH�<ABI�:P:R�:M�MA>�A>@>FHGB<�NG=>KLM:G=BG@�H?�L>QPHKD>KL�:L�I>HIE>�PAH�FNLM�;>�K>L<N>=�L:O>=�:G= HK�K>OBE>=�

NKBG@� MA>� >B@AM� R>:KL� H?� MA>� #>HK@>�3�� �NLA� :=FBGBLMK:MBHGIKH@K>LLBO>L�PHKDBG@�HG�$%2 �% /�MK>:MF>GM�:G=�<:K>�K>IKH=N<MBO>KB@AML�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�?HNG=�MA>FL>EO>L�:L�HNMLB=>KL�BG�3:LABG@MHG �����F>:GPABE>�<HGL>KO:MBO>�?>FBGBLML�:G=�MA>�K>EB@BHNL�KB@AM�P>K>IKHOB=>=�HI>G�:<<>LL�MH�BG?EN>G<>�IHEB<R����0A>�>E><MBHG�H?�,K>LB=>GM+;:F:�E>=�MH�@K>:M�AHI>�MA:M�D>R�IHEB<B>L�BG�MA>L>�:K>:L�PHNE=�K>MNKGMH�;>BG@�;:L>=�HG�L<B>GMB?B<�>OB=>G<>�;>LM�IK:<MB<>L�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AMLLM:G=:K=L�� +;:F:� BGBMB:EER� INLA>=� ;:<D� HG� LHF>� H?� MA>� FHLMK>MKH@K>LLBO>� L>QN:E� :G=�K>IKH=N<MBO>�IHEB<B>L� BFIE>F>GM>=�NG=>K�NLA���;NM�HO>K�MBF>�IKH@K>LLBO>L�A:O>�;>>G�=BL:IIHBGM>=�HG�F:GRBLLN>L�

%G�K>@:K=L�MH�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�IHEB<B>L�MA>�+;:F:�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GMA:L�BG=B<:M>=�:G�HI>GG>LL�MH�IHEB<R�<A:G@>�;NM�A:L�:ELH�E>?M�:�@K>:M=>:E�H?�MA>��NLA�:IIKH:<A� BGM:<M��0A>�:=FBGBLMK:MBHG�A:L�IN;EB<ERK>C><M>=�:G�:;LHENM>�EBGD�;>MP>>G�MK:??B<DBG@�:G=�L>Q�PHKD�LM:MBG@MA:M�XIKHLMBMNMBHG�;R�PBEEBG@�:=NEML�BL�GHM�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�K>@:K=E>LLH?�PA>MA>K�BM�BL�E>@:EBS>=�=><KBFBG:EBS>=�HK�<KBFBG:EBS>=Y����$HP>O>KBG� ����� :?M>K� :� M>FIHK:KR� LNLI>GLBHG� H?� MA>� 1/� :II>:E� +;:F:=>?>G=>=�MA>�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�EHR:EMR�H:MA�;R�<HGMBGNBG@�MH�INKLN>:II>:EL�H?�:G�BGCNG<MBHG�PHG�;R�1/�;:L>=�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�:B=�HK@:GBL:MBHGLIK>O>GMBG@� MA>�:IIEB<:MBHG�H?�IHEB<R� MH� MA>BK�HK@:GBL:MBHGL���� !O>G

�� �==BMBHG:EER�PA>G�:<<>IMBG@� K><HFF>G=:MBHG����� MA>�1/�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM:ELH�LAB>=�:P:R�?KHF�MA>�M>KF�ZL>Q�PHKD[��PAB<A�PHNE=�A:O>�BFIEB>=�K><H@GBMBHGH?� L>Q�PHKD� :L�PHKD�� HIMBG@� BGLM>:=� ?HK� MA>� M>KF� ZIKHLMBMNMBHG[�

�� /:NG=>KL� ������ 89�� -3<��� "HK�>Q:FIE>�BG�>:KER������+;:F:�K>L<BG=>=�MA>�@EH;:E�@:@�KNE>�HG�:;HKMBHG��� />>� MA>� LB=>;:K� X3A:M� BL� GHM� 0K:??B<DBG@� BG� ,>KLHGLY� BG� 1�/�� >I:KMF>GM� H?

/M:M> �� %:+003-4371�37�!/:;87;�#/98:<�1�/�� +/������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K����� AMMI� PPP�LM:M>�@HO =H<NF>GML HK@:GBS:MBHG �������I=?�

�� %G�FB=������:�?>=>K:E�:II>:EL�<HNKM�KNE>=�MA:M�1GBM>=�/M:M>L�<:GGHM�?HK<>�1/�;:L>=� @KHNIL� L>>DBG@� BGM>KG:MBHG:E� $%2 �% /� ?NG=BG@� MH� =>GHNG<>� L>Q�PHKD�0ABL� =><BLBHG� ?KHF� MA>� 1�/�� �G=� �BK<NBM� �HNKM� BG� *>P�5HKD� NIAHE=L� :� EHP>K<HNKM�=><BLBHG�BG�?:OHNK�H?�MA>��EEB:G<>�?HK�+I>G�/H<B>MR�%GM>KG:MBHG:E���+/%�,:MA?BG=>K� %GM>KG:MBHG:E� MA>�#EH;:E� $>:EMA� �HNG<BE� :G=� %GM>K:<MBHG�� />>�� '':=>�X�GMB�,KHLMBMNMBHG�,E>=@> .NEBG@��HKK><ML�)BL@NB=>=�$:KF?NE�,HEB<RY�&NKBLM��$HMEBG>����&NER������K>MKB>O>=�/>IM>F;>K������AMMI� CNKBLM�HK@ AHMEBG> ���� �� DKBLMR�D:=>�IKHLMBMNMBHG�IE>=@>�IAI�

Page 22: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ���

MAHN@A�MA>L>�1/�;:L>=�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�A:O>�:@:BG�IK>O:BE>=�BG�<HNKMMA>�:GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG�EHR:EMR�H:MA�<HGMBGN>L�MH�K>F:BG�BG�>??><M�?HK�MA>O:LM�F:CHKBMR�H?�HK@:GBL:MBHGL�L>>DBG@�,!,"�.�?NG=BG@�PHKE=PB=>�NG=>KM>KFL� :EFHLM� B=>GMB<:E� MH� MAHL>� BFIHL>=� NG=>K� MA>� �NLA:=FBGBLMK:MBHG���

>LIBM>�MA>�FBQ>=�;:@�IK>L>GM>=�;R�MA>�+;:F:�:IIKH:<A�MH�:GMB�MK:??B<DBG@�IHEB<B>L�:=OH<:M>L�?HK�L>Q�PHKD>KLY�KB@AML�P>K>�=>EB@AM>=PA>G�LHF>�FHGMAL�:?M>K�MA>�1/�:<<>IM>=�K><HFF>G=:MBHG����1//><K>M:KR�H?�/M:M>�$BEE:KR��EBGMHG�NL>=�MA>�M>KF�ZL>Q�PHKD>K[�=NKBG@�:LI>><A���HFF>GMBG@�HG�MA>�:<AB>O>F>GML�H?�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�=>O>EHIF>GMPHKD�?HK�KB@AML�:M�:�<>E>;K:MBHG�H?�(#�0�,KB=>�)HGMA�<H�AHLM>=�;R�MA>/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�:G=�#:RL�:G=�(>L;B:GL�BG�"HK>B@G��??:BKL��@>G<B>L�EBGMHG�K>IHKM>=��X7H8NK�<HEE>:@N>L�:K>�F>>MBG@�PBMA�ANF:G�KB@AML:<MBOBLML�A>:EMA�:NMAHKBMB>L�RHNMA�:<MBOBLML�L>Q�PHKD>KL�MA>�?NEE�K:G@>H?�I>HIE>�PAH�:K>�BGOHEO>=�BG�:G=�PHKDBG@�MH�IKHM><M�(#�0�I>HIE>YLKB@AML�:G=�EBO>LY����0ABL�LM:M>F>GM�<HF;BG>=�PBMA�MA>�:<<>IM:G<>�H?K><HFF>G=:MBHG� ���� BG=B<:M>L� MA:M� <>GMK:E� ?B@NK>L� BG� MA>� /M:M> >I:KMF>GM�:K>�?HK�MA>�?BKLM�MBF>�BG�FHK>�MA:G�:�=><:=>�IK>I:K>=�MH=B:EH@N>�:;HNM�MA>�KB@AML�H?�L>Q�PHKD>KL���

�� %G� ����� LF:EE� <A:G@>L� P>K>�F:=>� MH� MA>�PHK=BG@� H?� MA>� IHEB<R� NG=>K� MA>+;:F:� :=FBGBLMK:MBHG�PAB<A� =B=� GHM� LN;LM:GMB:EER� <A:G@>� BML� HI>K:MBHG�� *3BMMEBG� �G=�� X1/� "NG=BG@� ?HK� $%2 �% /Y� AMMI� PPP�LQIHEBMB<L�HK@ �I������,K>LB=>GM� +;:F:� <:GGHM� K>L<BG=� MA>� :GMB�IKHLMBMNMBHG� EHR:EMR� H:MA� :L� A>K>L<BG=>=�MA>�@EH;:E�@:@�KNE>�HG�:;HKMBHG�;><:NL>�MA>�EHR:EMR�H:MA�BL�>GLAKBG>=BG�E>@BLE:MBHG�MA>������#EH;:E��% /��<M��0A>�EHR:EMR�H:MA�<:G�HGER�;>�K>FHO>=;R� :G� :<M� H?� �HG@K>LL�� />>�� X HGYM� >QI><M� :� K>OHENMBHG� �:K:<D� +;:F:�F:R=B??>K� EBMME>� ?KHF�#>HK@>� �NLA� BG� ABL� :IIKH:<A� MH��?KB<:Y� 0A>� !<HGHFBLM� ��):K<A� ����� AMMI� PPP�><HGHFBLM�<HF GH=> ���������

�� ,�/M:KK� X�EBGMHG��)>>MBG@�3BMA� X/>Q�3HKD>KLY� %L� X,>HIE>�MH�,>HIE>� BIEHF:<R:M� %ML� �>LMD� �*/� *>PL� ��� &NG>� ����� K>MKB>O>=� />IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� <GLG>PL�<HF G>PL :KMB<E> <EBGMHG�F>>MBG@�L>Q�PHKD>KL�I>HIE>�I>HIE>�=BIEHF:<R�BML�;>LM�

�� �EBGMHG� A:L� EHG@� :OHB=>=� :GR� IN;EB<� LM:M>F>GM� H?� L>Q�PHKD� LBG<>� LA>� P:LIN;EB<ER�:MM:<D>=�?HK�;>BG@�ZIKH�IKHLMBMNMBHG[�=NKBG@�MA>�=>O>EHIF>GM�H?�MA>1*�0K:??B<DBG@�,KHMH<HE�BG������;R��HG<>KG>=�3HF>G�?HK��F>KB<:�:G=�.>IN;EB<:GL>G:MHK� &>LL>� $>EFL���M� MA:M� MBF>� �EBGMHG�P:L� <H�<A:BK� H?� MA>� ,K>LB=>GMYL%GM>K:@>G<R� �HNG<BE� HG�3HF>G� :G=� MA>� 1/� =>E>@:MBHG� MH� MA>� 1*� �KBF>L�HFFBLLBHG�PA>K>�MA>�0K:??B<DBG@�,KHMH<HE�P:L�NG=>K� =>O>EHIF>GM�� /A>� A:=;>>G� I:KM� H?� >??HKML� MH� BG<EN=>� :� =>?BGBMBHG� H?� MK:??B<DBG@� MA:M� BG<EN=>=� :EEE:;HNK�L><MHKL�K:MA>K�MA:G�IKHLMBMNMBHG�HGER��/>>��&� H>S>F: $/@�$5+>/;�+7.�3;-8=:;/��+;</:;��%2/�-87;<:=-<387�80�<:+003-4371�������=H<MHK:E�=BLL>KM:MBHGII� ���W�� �O:BE:;E>� HGEBG>� :M�� AMMIL� =H<L�@HH@E>�<HF : NP�>=N OB>P>K�:�O�J�<:<A>��,�D*�J*�SL&�FRP>;�=:E�<: F@HH=R>: H<NF>GML )B@K:MBHG�����LMN=B>L />Q�����LE:O>L�����:G=�����=BL<HNKL>�����F:LM>KL�����������0A>�����ABLMHKB<:E�����<HGLMKN<MBHG�����H?�����MK:??B<DBG@�����BG�����PHF>G����� H>S>F:�������������� ,ABE�����0A>LBL�����%/ �=H<CH=H>S>F:L>QLE:O>L:G==BL<HNKL>F:LM>KLMA>ABLMHKB<:E

Page 23: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

��

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the CreativeCommons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC). Under CC-BY-NC license, the public is free to share and adapt but not makecommercial use of the work. Users must always give proper attribution tothe author(s) and the Anti-Trafficking Review.

�.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6��������������

�/,%*.(�3)&� ��"$$/4.3"#,&�3/��4-".��*()32��1*.$*0,&2

3>�:K>�GHP�BG�:�ABLMHKB<�FHF>GM�PA>G�ANF:G�KB@AML�:G=�L>QN:E�KB@AML:K>�;>@BGGBG@�MH�;>�BGMKH=N<>=�BGMH�?K:F>L�H?�;HMA�L>Q�PHKD�:G=�ANF:GMK:??B<DBG@����"HK�MA>�?BKLM�MBF>�BG�FHK>�MA:G�:�=><:=>�L>Q�PHKD>KL�BGMA>�1/�:K>�?BG:EER�@:BGBG@�IHEBMB<:E�@KHNG=���K:<DL�A:O>�:II>:K>=�BGMA>� :EFHLM� A>@>FHGB<� 1/� :IIKH:<A� MH� MK:??B<DBG@� BG� I>KLHGL���G=I>KA:IL�?HK�MA>�?BKLM�MBF>�BG�1/�ABLMHKR�L>Q�PHKD>KL�:G=�MA>BK�:EEB>LA:O>�=>O>EHI>=�PHKD:;E>�K><HFF>G=:MBHGL�?HK�<A:G@>�HG�MA>�?>=>K:E:G=�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�E>O>E�

�=OH<:M>L�K><H@GBL>=�>:KER�HG�BG�MA>�1,.�IKH<>LL�MA:M�MK:GLE:MBG@�MA>KA>MHKB<:E�LN<<>LL�H?�MA>�1,.�BGMH�M:G@B;E>�IHEB<R�K>LNEML�PHNE=�K>JNBK>=><:=>L�H?�PHKD��0A>�1,.�IKH<>LL� @:O>�KBL>� MH�:G�:<MBO>�PHKDBG@@KHNI�H?�L>Q�PHKD>K�KB@AML�:=OH<:M>L�PAH�A:O>�<HGMBGN>=�MH�<HEE:;HK:M>PBMA�PHKDBG@� @KHNI�F>F;>KL� ;>RHG=� HK@:GBLBG@� :KHNG=� MA>� 1,.��=OH<:M>L�PBMA�MA>��,,,�A:O>�<HFFBMM>=�MH�F:BGM:BGBG@�:�IK>L>G<>BG�3:LABG@MHG� ����PBMA�:�=>=B<:M>=�IHEB<R�<HGLNEM:GM�FHGBMHKBG@�:G=:G:ERLBG@�K>E:M>=�IHEB<R�:<MBHGL�BG<EN=BG@�MA>�3:LABG@MHG� ����IHEB<B>LHG�,KHLMBMNMBHG�"K>>�6HG>L��0A>�IKH<>LL�A:L�:ELH�BGLIBK>=�HMA>K�:=OH<:M>PHKDBG@�@KHNI�F>F;>KL�MH�@>G>K:M>�FHK>�<HEE:;HK:MBO>�;:L>=�K>L>:K<AHG�L>Q�PHKD�BLLN>L�:G=�MH�:==K>LL�MA>�=>:KMA�H?�JN:EBMR�=:M:�:O:BE:;E>�

0A>�IK>�� :G=�IHLM�1,.�IKH<>LL>L�=BL<NLL>=� :;HO>�K>IK>L>GM� LF:EEOB<MHKB>L�?HK�MA>�K:G@>�H?�BG=BOB=N:EL�BGOHEO>=�BG�L>QN:E�<HFF>K<>�:LP>EE�:L�MA>BK�:EEB>L�:G=�:<MBOBLML��3>�GHP�?:<>�:�NGBJN>�HIIHKMNGBMRW:??HK=>=� ;R� :� @EH;:E�F:G=:M>� H?� MA>� 1GBM>=� *:MBHGLWMH� ;>@BGLRLM>F:MB<:EER�BFIE>F>GMBG@�ANF:G�KB@AML�IKBG<BIE>L�BGMH�K>L>:K<A:<MBOBLF�:G=�IHEB<B>L�K>@:K=BG@�;HMA�L>Q�PHKD�:G=�ANF:G�MK:??B<DBG@�%G�ABL�<HG<EN=BG@�LM:M>F>GM�MH�MA>�$NF:G�.B@AML��HNG<BE�$:KHE=�'HA

<HGLMKN<MBHGH?MK:??B<DBG@BGPHF>G H>S>F:�����AE�>G�@E�NL�IB=�;E�LK<B=�� #!!/BRF)!&�0O.-GC�?!;�:�5>O6D-9=�FOCR+D2R��-.6��:G;���S:N�,9�N?Q�9HA)K;�;D/��<�$��OJC@�(+%6&N�0!EH/H+��,G��*�0��D ;6R;�O� %FA�J$'@/:;J "S*�LB@��$%!M;/D062**G�>1 L&L3��S?�)?MB1L@.>MKB>O>=�&NG>������/>>�:ELH��&� H>S>F: $/@�$5+>/;�+7.��3;-8=:;/��+;</:;�%2/�-87;<:=-<387�80�<:+003-4371� 6>=��HHDL�(HG=HG������

�� />>�� �>GM>K� ?HK� $>:EMA� :G=� #>G=>K� !JNBMR� �>GM>K� ?HK� $NF:G� .B@AML� :G=$NF:GBM:KB:G�(:P�:M��F>KB<:G�1GBO>KLBMR�3:LABG@MHG��HEE>@>�H?�(:P �=6+7%:+003-4371����'����$��+7.�<2/�$/@�$/-<8:��$NF:G�.B@AML�?HK��EE��$�*#!�:G=�>GM>K� ?HK� $NF:G� .B@AML� :G=� $NF:GBM:KB:G� (:P��13�(� ����� K>MKB>O>=/>IM>F;>K� ����� AMMI� PPP�@>G=>KA>:EMA�HK@ ?BE>L NIEH:=L <A:G@> IN;EB<:MBHGL ABO:B=L:G=MA>L>QL><MHK�I=?�

Page 24: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)

�&14-�&3�",���.3*��1"''*$+*.(��&5*&6������������� ��

(>@:E��=OBL>K�H?�MA>�/M:M>� >I:KMF>GM�LM:M>=�MA:M�XMABL�BL�:G�HG@HBG@IKH<>LL�E>:=BG@�MH�<HG<K>M>�IHEB<R�:G=�L>E?�<HGL<BHNL�<A:G@>Y� />QPHKD�:<MBOBLML�:G=�K>L>:K<A>KL�BG�MA>�?B>E=L�H?�L>QN:E�:G=�K>IKH=N<MBO>A>:EMA�ANF:G�KB@AML�:G=�CNLMB<>�FNLM�<HGMBGN>�MH�PHKD�MH@>MA>KW:EHG@�PBMA�HNK�BGM>KG:MBHG:E�:EEB>LWMH�AHE=�1/�@HO>KGBG@�:G=�IHEB<BG@BGLMBMNMBHGL� :<<HNGM:;E>� MH� ANF:G� KB@AML� IKBG<BIE>L� ?HK� :EE� I>HIE>>G@:@>=�BG�L>Q�MK:=>�PHKD�

�"1*� �&14- ��)�� �/$*/,/(8� � BL� :G� �LLH<B:M>� ,KH?>LLHK� H?%GM>K=BL<BIEBG:KR��KML���/<B>G<>L����NEMNK:E�/MN=B>L�:M�1GBO>KLBMR�H?3:LABG@MHG��HMA>EE�:G=��=CNG<M�,KH?>LLHK�BG�#>G=>K�3HF>G�:G=/>QN:EBMR�/MN=B>L�:M�1GBO>KLBMR�H?�3:LABG@MHG�/>:MME>��$>K�K>L>:K<A:G=� M>:<ABG@� ?H<NL� HG� BGLMBMNMBHGL� L>QN:EBMR� L>Q� PHKD� LH<B:EBGLMBMNMBHGL�:G=�LH<B:E�CNLMB<>��$>K�:KMB<E>L�A:O>�:II>:K>=�BG�:�GNF;>KH?�LH<BHEH@R�:G=�L>QN:EBMR�K>E:M>=�CHNKG:EL�:G=�>=BM>=�OHENF>L�!F:BE��DE>KNF�NP;�>=N

�*&2)"��$�413*2� ����� BL� MA>� IKHC><M� <HHK=BG:MHK� H?� MA>� >LBK>>�EEB:G<>��/A>�BL�:�IKHIHG>GM�H?�<HFFNGBMR�;:L>=�K>L>:K<A�LMK:M>@B>LPHKDBG@�PBMA�L>Q�PHKD>KL�:G=�(#�0-�<HFFNGBMB>L�:G=�ANF:G�KB@AML�;:L>=�:IIKH:<A>L�MH�$%2�IK>O>GMBHG�MAKHN@A�K>L>:K<A�:=OH<:<R�:G=MK:BGBG@��!F:BE��DF<<NKMBL�=>LBK>>:EEB:G<>�HK@

�&.&,/0&��"4.%&12���)���.3)1/0/,/(8��"3*.��-&1*$".��34%*&2��BLMA>�<HHK=BG:MHK�H?�MA>��>LM�,K:<MB<>L�,HEB<R�,KHC><M��/A>�BL�:�IKHIHG>GMH?�<HFFNGBMR�;:L>=�K>L>:K<A�LMK:M>@B>L�PHKDBG@�PBMA�L>Q�PHKD>KL(#�0�<HFFNGBMB>L�BFFB@K:GML�:G=�MA>�AHF>E>LL��$>K�:KMB<E>L�A:O>:II>:K>=�BG�MA>�CHNKG:E $8-3+5��=;<3-/ �/+5<2�+7.��=6+7�#312<; :G=HMA>K�IN;EB<:MBHGL��!F:BE��IL:NG=>KL�;>LMIK:<MB<>LIHEB<R�HK@

�3 0)".*&�!")"#���)���/$*",�!&,'"1&��BL�:G��LLH<B:M>�,KH?>LLHK BGMA>� >I:KMF>GM�H?�/H<BHEH@R�#>G=>K�/MN=B>L�:G=�/H<B:E�3HKD�:M�+M:@H1GBO>KLBMR��$>K�M>:<ABG@�:G=�K>L>:K<A�?H<NL�HG�LH<B:E�CNLMB<>�BGMBF:M>I:KMG>K�OBHE>G<>�<HFF>K<B:E�L>Q�PHKD�:G=�FHMBO:MBHG:E�BGM>KOB>PBG@�$>K� :KMB<E>L� A:O>� :II>:K>=� BG� LH<B:E�PHKD� A>:EMA� IN;EB<� A>:EMAJN:EBM:MBO>�:G=�L>QN:EBMR�;:L>=�CHNKG:EL�!F:BE� LM>IA:GB>�P:A:;�HM:@H�:<�GS

Page 25: 2*.( 4-. *()32 3/ /,% 3)& $$/4.3#,& '/1 *32 .3* &7 1 ...This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC-BY-NC)