• Home

  • Documents

  • - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8...
10
i a. § S":r~" ~ ~"8 tF r ~ ;i nQ.",ee-n~aC'" on n n C n ii1;::; n" .., n 0 3 i ] "0 J'" e- =' -, =' 3 ... !! '< 0 n ~ - n =' ~ = 0 =' - Q. 0 ,. n CJQ !:!.. ~ - n '" ::s~ ",' ..",;:r n 1 s' Q. ~ 1 ::r: ~ n "" Iii' n "0 0 - ... 0 ~ ~ ~ -~. 0 8 g..~. "0 3 0 :rQa :r -, "i :r ~ § '< n :r 3 - c~:"'o n ;E=- ~ ~ 3 ~ ,~< ii1~Q~~ A n < j ~ n J~ ;:;. 5 _. ~ 0 c, ~ =,~:r=,.n =I ="'O~- ...~c-. 0 e-ii '<:r~C: ~"~ e-. ~ ~ § Iii' =' ~ 0 '< =r-' ~ g. -< ~ n Q. n ... < ~ 0 n-< =' n "..e-~ 0 o!...e -~ 0- -, n"""' 3 _,<:-n~ ::;.; > AI n n ;: 3 "0 Q.:r ~ :::t, -. ;- n -":r 0:; ...=;' 0 ..2 0 3 ... n a ~ _ i - g ' 0 '< "0 ~;S . no ,<n... "0 =' ... _. A e- c: - &. &1 ~- "'e-."""n gn~" nH~ "O=':r~go 3~~~'" § ""~ !':r ;:; ~ - 1;;" ~' ~ =' c ~ ~ dQ s' e- =' ~::: Q. ~ n ~::r: s..nS=,~~e:::;"a -< ~ 1 !! '" c" '" ~ C '" "0 ... i :r . ~ ~ '" O'ci ~ ~ ... !.. :3 c:r~R~"'",~CI~'" ; ;;-ii:rge-~~;~~ 0 ~ ~ 0 e- ~ ;i n :r ~ - a s' - - Q. e.. ~ .r CI ~ ~ e- e--- < ~':r '<'" t:. R O-~. n n s;: !..::so...n on~ 0 oq _. '" .e 0 0 g =' "0 _. e- ~ 8 n e-.!:!..<: CC"'~S!3"O =,=' -< if::;' if 0::: g..~ c: ~ a ~ = ::r: n"'n::;:r~CT~:I"O~a~ AI Q. 0 n=:o '< 0 0 a ~":r =' :;: e.;;1 s.. 0 § 0 § a: o' dii ... ::s ~ Q..e ;--Q.-~ 0::1 !3 I'D <:..,... ;"":1' c::~ $" a :r 5" a. ~.g nO!.. S" ~ :~ !I~ I ~o '::L ~ Ilg. ~~~ 2i~ .. i i ~i . ~§"I H i. ~~ I- f j h~( C- o fA (I) '0 ~ J: (I) Q) r+ ~ .."'n"Q~"'!TQ.."'~nQ..:C> C -g;- a sr 1~ :: ;r~ §':;;.. III i' ::I n... ,... ~ -'... - =- ::.: III fIi r n <e ~ 0 :; 2, i' ::: O ""n$:l ~~"'I11::!~a,::!" n Ii III ~ ~... (,; III 0 d $:I ::In..~ !:J...n- ::::10111 = 0 C='.o $I '" .. Q..:: !T Q.. '" §'a ~ ,c_' :-<!IIn~g,,!II.!"11 ~n -""--111'" ~ < J'I'~ ~ § ;,g,ri r~ ~fs lIIo!!!':c~!Tg-,O(;;':!,......... ::1...0 ...n .::::Ino(JQn'<~ Q.. c ~ ~ ~ 1't: =' III ~... g-::J 0 0 ..1't: "'III -::::IIII!T::Id...C ~ !T~::IillllllD1iii'::' n~ ~ ~ i'o ~ 5- 0 !T:g ; .. : if ~ ... a""O... (JQ n ., .. ... ::I ~ ~ '< ~ !!..!T III ~ ~ 0 ;;' ~ 6.. if" n 1II..1II~::I~'<~R,~","'§n '" '" ~'n Q.. III 0 ;;' "':;! -, '" -, 0 :i' 0 .. ;;'c:'; ... Ii ~ ~ ~ s g ~ qg... III .. !II ...:; -,.. ~ Ii -, n n .s c CI g; r;;' j ~!TGa -, Q.. ~ ~ < "'cnR' "'...e~ ~e,gClIII", ,1i~::I'lIIg~o a:;; 0 ::I a,... :; n (JQ ... -:::,'" -,...~Oo~ ::;"""<0" ~ ~~ a,::I .. 0' g" c if" ~ ::I n~ ~!T;;"'o!T...;if;"< ~",OQ..I11~~",,"Q::!'-"'~!!.. -' 1"'... ... III ~, (JQ 0... -, F! :-. g :c S!:~ !' a. ~~ 2 ;- e-. ~!!!,IIIr;;'n..-,gc!T"'~ ~co:f~o::l~!!'" ~ III -,::I .. ... ::: Q.. Ii ~ 0;;' ~ n~ i':; ~..n..- III ... -, n ... III III n -, !II n III - n n:l... ~:; :f i::- 0"'8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ qg . CJQ ~ n a Ii 0 :; ~ ~ ,:r-g ~'iii' 0Illg03e-.c:; ;i ::I ::I III '" 0 n ~ -'!T;:Z -ci ~ c::! "'.. ~ ::! ci ~ (JQ n o n ~ ~...' iii' < ... a ... n '< ..""... "... ::I::I"<i'~"Q:-.;;.. Q.."'~t1I:I!;;t1I ;;>1IIQ.n- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g"e: w f'8 ~' ~' 0 ;.~ ~ ~ 0"<1 ~ ~ , 0 2~ ;. . t'I < 0 .. 3 i[a ~'§. t'I t'I -II> ~. ~. 3 ~ .. t'I ... o' ::I :t II> [ 3 II> '" '0 ii1 011 3 II> ... ij' l t'I :r II> t'I ...

- 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

ia.

§ S

":r~

" ~

~"8

tFr~

;inQ

.",e

e-n~

aC'"

onn

n C

n

ii1;::

; n"

.., n

0 3

i]"0

J'"

e- ='

-, =

'3...

!!

'<

0n

~ - n

=

' ~

=

0=

'-

Q.

0 ,.

n C

JQ

!:!..

~

- n

'" ::s

~

",'

..",;:

r n

1s'

Q

. ~1

::r:

~

n ""

Iii

' n

"00 -

...

0 ~

~

~ -

~.

0 8

g..~

. "0 3

0:r

Qa

:r

-, "i

:r~

§'<

n

:r3

-

c~:"

'o

n ;E

=-

~

~3

~

,~<

ii1

~Q

~~

A

n <

j

~

n J~

;:;

.5_.

~

0 c,

~

=,~

:r=

,.n

=I

="'O

~-

...~

c-.

0 e-

ii '<

:r~

C:

~"~

e-

. ~

~ §

Iii

' =

' ~

0

'<

=r-

'~

g. -

< ~

n

Q. n

...

< ~

0

n-<

='

n".

.e-~

0

o!...

e -~

0-

-,

n"""

'3

_,<

:-n~

::;.; >

AI

n n

;:3

"0

Q.:r

~

:::

t, -.

;-

n -"

:r

0:;

...=

;' 0

..2

0 3

...

n a

~

_i-g' 0

'<

"0

~

;S

.no

,<

n...

"0=

' ...

_.

A e-

c:

-&

.&1 ~

-"'e

-.""

"n

gn~

" nH

~

"O=

':r~

go

3~~

~'"

§""~ !':

r ;:;

~ - 1;;"

~'

~

='

c ~

~

dQ

s'

e- ='

~:::

Q

. ~

n

~::r

: s.

.nS

=,~

~e:

::;"a

-< ~

1!!

'" c"

'"

~

C

'" "0

...

i:r

.

~ ~

'"

O'c

i ~

~

...

!..

:3

c:r~

R~

"'",~

CI~

'";

;;-ii:

rge-

~~

;~~

0 ~

~ 0

e-

~ ;

i n

:r ~

- a

s'- -

Q. e.

. ~

.r

CI

~

~

e- e

---

< ~

':r

'<'"

t:. R

O-~

. n n

s;

:!..

::so.

..n

on~

0

oq_.

'"

.e

0 0

g =

' "0

_.

e-

~

8

n

e-.!:

!..<

: C

C"'~

S!3

"O

=,=

'-<

if::;

' if

0::: g

..~

c: ~

a

~ =

::r:n"

'n::;

:r~

CT

~:I"

O~

a~A

I Q

. 0

n=:o

'<

0

0 a

~":

r

='

:;:

e.;;1

s.

. 0

§ 0

§ a:

o'

di

i ...

::s ~

Q

..e

;--Q

.-~

0:

:1

!3I'D

<

:..,..

. ;"

":1'

c:

:~

$"

a :r

5"

a.

~

.g

nO!..

S

" ~

:~

!I~I

~o

'::L

~

Ilg.

~~

~2i

~..

i i

~i

.~

§"I

H i. ~~ I- f j h~

(

C- o fA (I)

'0 ~ J: (I)

Q)

r+ ~

.."'n

"Q~

"'!T

Q.."

'~nQ

..:C

>C

-g

;- a

sr1~

::

;r ~

§':;

;..

III i'

::I n.

.. ,..

. ~

-'...

-=

- ::.:

III f

Iir

n <

e ~

0 :;

2, i'

:::

O""

n$:l

~~

"'I11

::!~

a,::!

"n

Ii III

~

~

...

(,;

III

0 d

$:I

::In.

.~

!:J...

n-

::::1

0111

=

0 C

='.o

$I

'"

.. Q

..::

!T

Q..

'"

§'a

~,c_'

:-<

!IIn~

g,,!I

I.!"1

1 ~

n -"

"--1

11'"

~

<

J'I'~

~

§

;,g,r

i r~

~fs

lIIo!

!!':c

~!T

g-,O

(;;':

!,....

.....

::1...

0 ...

n .::

::Ino

(JQ

n'<

~Q

.. c

~

~

~

1't:

='

III

~...

g-

::J

0 0

..1't:

"'I

II -:

:::III

I!T::I

d...C

~

!T~

::Iill

llllD

1iii'

::'

n~~

~

i'o ~

5-

0 !

T:g

; .. : i

f ~ ...

a""O

...

(JQ

n

., ..

...

::I

~

~'<

~

!!.

.!T

III

~

~

0 ;;'

~

6.

. if"

n

1II..

1II~

::I~

'<~

R,~

","'§

n'"

'" ~

'n

Q..

III

0 ;;'

"':

;! -,

'"

-,

0:i'

0 .

. ;;'

c:';

... Ii

~ ~

~ s

g ~

qg...

III

.. !II

...:

; -,

.. ~

Ii

-, n

n .s

c C

I g;

r;;'j~

!TG

a -,

Q.. ~

~

<

"'cnR

' "'.

..e~

~e,

gClII

I",

,1i~

::I'lI

Ig~

oa:

;; 0

::I

a,...

:;

n (J

Q

...

-:::,

'"

-,...

~O

o~

::;""

"<0"

~

~~

a,

::I

.. 0'

g"

c

if"

~

::I

n~

~!T

;;"'o

!T...

;if;"

<~

",O

Q..I

11~

~",

,"Q

::!'-"

'~!!.

.-'1"

'...

... I

II ~

, (J

Q 0.

.. -,

F!

:-.

g :c

S!:

~ !

' a.

~~

2

;-

e-.

~!!!

,IIIr

;;'n.

.-,g

c!T

"'~~

co:f~

o::l~

!!'"

~III

-,

::I

.. ...

:::

Q

.. Ii

~

0;;'

~

n~i':

;~

..n..-

III

... -,

n

...

III

III

n -,

!II

n III

- n

n:l..

. ~

:;:f

i::-

0"'8

~ ~

~ ~

~ q

g .

CJQ

~ n

a Ii

0 :;

~~

,:r-g

~

'iii'

0Illg

03e-

.c:;

;i::I

::I

III

'"

0 n

~ -

'!T;:Z

-c

i ~

c:

:! "'.

. ~

::! c

i~(J

Q

non

~

~...

' iii

' <

...

a

...

n '<

.."

"...

"...

::I::I

"<i'~

"Q:-

.;;..

Q.."

'~t1

I:I!;;

t1I

;;>1I

IQ.n

-~

~ ~

~ ~

g" e

: w f'

8 ~

' ~' 0

;.~ ~

~0"

<1

~ ~

, 0

2~ ;. . t'I

<

0..

3i[a ~'§

.t'I

t'I

-II> ~.

~.

3 ~ .. t'I ... o' ::I :t II> [ 3 II> '" '0 ii1 011 3 II> ... ij' l t'I :r II> t'I ...

Page 2: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

8 S

~ 5'

~ g-

~ ~

a: S

F 8

~' 8

~ ~

~ e

8' ~

~ t:

?. S

~ §"

" g.

, ~ ~

~ a

'8

, ~n

~

eo

... ~

'"

it C

'" S

Il g.

. - ",

' ~

a

c -,

0 -,

Q. ::r

'aq

~

::I

C;'

t'D ~

8

if~

g..

g,. 1

;;' ij'

g.

. S'

0""

~

fIi t

t'D ~

In'

~,

...

;i ~

C

JQ

!-~

e

1" g~

; R

0

<II

g., a

;i.5

n'~

B ~

'i :J

j t'De

CJQ

~

g., i

~ 0

2

!if ~

ci ~

~ s'

~ 8

~

'H

':""'~

§

~.~

~

~

In' n

~

... .

.. ~

'& ~

...

, t'D g

.. '" c§

."""

~ 0

i 0 - a

0 CJQ

~

e;

...:r

~ R

- if-

S'

~~

i;~i,~

I ~

~~

~ff'

; ~

~,~

l~c;,t~

~~

'g'~

::j!~

~ i e~

~'~

0 <

: -,

0 ~

CJQ

~

~

i

::I

n n

ii:

~

E;

><

Son

0

n V

I J"

sr

rr

0 0

CJQ

g. :r

e-. e

. tt

0 f':

, if

0 0

8 ~

...

~. t

t "S

f !if

...

,~,

5'::1

~

$' ~

fIi

8

In: =

!I,

=: §

=

: I::

c:

... ~

~

~ B

;: En

cs ...

... e

g..;,

" !!.

~

'"

;...

R &

.! 0

$ a

e-~

~'II

I C !

)C

<

: n

-'"

n.r'

-,'0

'" a.

'" iii

~

-, .

.. ...

::r

~

w

~

cs

...

g ~

r~f'~

l §

~,~

~'~

~3"

1 ~

g'~

~'O5:

,Ao:'~

i'~

f~

~~

'ia ~

'g'~

:[ii:

~

n'"

~-'o

""::r

nn;;!

=

o::s

-,1t

1'\::

r~

~'O

~

t'D~

~~

g 'O~

~

~

~

e- i

:' t'D

~

§

~

~

g g

... ~

Q

, ~

::s ::

a ~

!t g'

C'"

~a~

= I

n' g

~'"

~

~

Iir ~

~

0

.,.!A

::s

'"5,

n

"g.

~

0 2:

"5

, '<

-

,~,

"- -

, ~

0 n

~...

, II>

'"

'i"'

t'Dr

OIl

-,

'" n

~g

0 '<

I'D

a

...

0 q9

, ~

rr

...

S

Iii

-<

-,

0t'D

~

III>

n o

...e

III

~ -,

0§

a -,

::s'

,""

"'...n

-,

, lir

e ,::

st'D

~'

::s

-"0

0~

n

5 i"'

...

Iii c

: ~

!)

~.

0 =

-- 0

~

,g; 0

<

' e~

] !if

it'

go, e

a ~

'< 1

g.. ~

a '8

S ::s

~,s

:I:

8"~

,q9,

~::S

e.

.C§.

e~

~

~~

'::!)

"g.::

S

B n

~s.

.!f9

G,!i

fO'p

-g

a 0

a ~

Y'

'<

~

ii1

" ;i - 9

- w'"

... e

':1'"

':'i

:1,

" ~

...::

0 '<

c:

0

::s a

..

...,::

s '" -3'

g., ~

~;

e-.::

s ::"

~

g-

~ =,

e:C

§. g.

, g ~

~ e

.. ~

eg-

o B

' ~ ~

. 0 ~

! g

~ ...

~"O

r!-

~ ~

~

~ <I

I ~

:":J

j ~

';;

"', ~

~ ~,

~ S

~f g

.. e, e

;:-

~

..., e

- e- ~

s' ~

a tt

8'.a

"'~

~ 9

;;' ~

[ ~

a.

~'

:?.:

~

~ a

q ~

'-e

' ~

~

~

!,

fi [~

-~[

tl B

~ :f;

; e

~'

~ -<'n"

, "'n

-<'"

t'D"':

:rn~

:rB

;;!

"~

1t...

o a'in

AI';

'"...

::s

'0 t'D

...,

-<

c:

t'D .

..0III

~

~

i"' .

, 0

~ '8

:r S

a;;;r

0

-<

!-

0 8

-, w

!)!

)"

t'D =

-'0 '<

!-

::;"

~

Q;!

~

~ ..

. -,

- ~ ;

;;r...

t'D

'<

...

'~t'D

~

0,

, ~ i'

~ 1

e; 8 g

g S

g, ~

a ~

11 ;;'

~

~ 8,

s-~

, E

~ 1

~ 2:

g,

~, §

;. ~ ~

&.

~ ~

,.g

!if:?

. ~

...

g ::.

B F

' ~ ;

S, g

- ;i

8 §

:;.E

' ~

c g

ii1

!if C

'" cs

;:;'

a s'

=

i);i'

t'D

!..::S

~'"

-< 8

~ B

R...

ii!

fo...

t'D

e.~

~!i

-.f!,

Y'

::,c;

.,<

n;:;.

i ~

a.~

:f-

<">

<""

<~

~

'<~

_.c:

..""~

~

~t'D

.,!/I.

-:r.

..;iC

;",0

; ...

-"

""S

fC

f':

c:

::s::s

"""

_i:I"

,:r",

o::r

...

w...

""

"'8

g. g

., -,

e; ~

~ g

., !!!,

~ O

'CJQ

9-"

~ ~

S 5

' s.

. g.

i "

-, c

: ~

§

... ~

e- 0

§;

i ~

S' I

I> i"'

~~

o'

~!f~

~

2 B

aS

g -,

s.

. if. .

.. -<

a- ~

'"

C§.

i c

~ ~

tt

~ z

, :~

:r

0' ~

::s

::,

~

~;;;

r e;

B

::s tt

~

!-

Q

. S

' ",

' ~

0

t'D R

a-

::s e

,!)

2 "

ii'::S

;s,

fAF

' ~ i

g 5'

!i,

6: l

a ~

~

I::r

~

~,~

~ ~

~

: cS

E

. ~ ~

t'D

g

g,.g

~

8

g.,!!

f w

~

~,

II)

~

0 ~

...

t'D

::r

, n

0 -

S

c ~

a.

:r~

g

::s

" 0

I)

; :s

-<

0

e;

=-:

:s

~

-,

fI)'"

w

...,.

~

~

n ".

..,::=

0

'" ",

t'D

.

, .

'" ...

, Q

."

'" "

::s

" ~

CJQ

"

.....

~ ::r C1)

I» = I» s- IC '< ~ ::0:

::r 2" ~

5~ir;

.S~

~

~'"

-.

~

i:f.

'" -9

'"

0

0 ~

. ~

yo ~

ci

CI~

"':r2

:r~

-.

5

" e-

0

ir<jg

-~!O

)s(I

Ig~

~(I

I:tS

-"

~

11

e-O

)0)

!:

_.~

,,:

rn

0) .

:r

0)

"0

...

~"s

..~

ri 0)

9

-~

'" :r

s.

~

~

(II

so

~

I:f

e-.

"'~

2ae-

&.~

~,,~

::;

O"

~ 0)

2

0)

'<

r:T

" =

. '"

"0

'" ID

Q

.. n

(II

1 r~

. ~

~

. gO

:i!"s

..oS

o~

~C

Cl"'

"~

-.

:rO

Q

n <

0 e-

;;o:r

" ~

r:T

~0

-.

" I:f

0)

Q

..

-.

C

; -

0)

~.

~e-

O~

<n

~

~(J

Q

'-!

0) -

:r

'<

=--

0)

ID I

D

II:

Q..-

'C

I ~

;;°

;;.-.

9

~

~ :

.. ~

~

yo

~ ~

l' ::

a.

;:t.

is

~ ~

§. ;;°

!~

:r~

. a.

-< "

-.

- "

Q..n

~

O)

~

_o:r

:t::r

'""~

no,,~

0...

~

:r

C!

::r""

'0)"

'00)

~""

"~S

-~~

Q

..~",

,::r

~

0.':

"

~;ie

.~o~

~=

~~

~e.

g.

;~e-

e-~

2""

n n

n ".

0 n

...

_.

n =

. =

=

' <

-<

a

~

(\

...

""'"

1/1

fI\

- c:

'

e-.c

iii'

3 0

:=

Q

j' n

"...:

;::r'

~~

~O

~"~

III-I

/ICI/l

~

~

o ...

~

~::,

n -'"

=

;:;

1::::

,g- ~

...

' ~

-,

- ~ C

<

:: 'tI

...

...'"

- -, -

='

-, '"

~

'" '"

a- =

' ...

(\

...

OQ

::r e

- S' ~

0 ~

(JQ

!!

= !

' ;:;

I if

-. "

2 It

...

::r' ~

I:)

£...

=

,nc:

~

O"=

1/I

H-'"

-""'e

-....

.::r

~

"

...

1/1

_.

_.

0"

=

_.

n =

"=

=

Q..:

::-

n (\

" ...

;;

~

0 1/

1 1/

1 n~

' III

:T

ii"

=-

"..

n n

~

~-

::r =

... -

= if

-

~:I"

~

~

-. a

a 0

...

:I~

a ~

~ :To

0 Q

..~.:I

, e:"

' -,

::l.

S

' =

3&

;~

" ~

... n

:I

(JQ

~

:=

" n

~ =

-..:

":

::-

U;'

~...

...n

~":

s '"

~::r

'~

...0

"...

:T

C

1/1.

. '

::r

0 0

~

...

nl/l~

'-~

~...

e-.e

-~"'~

~"'~

l='

='

"'~~

e-...

a

;; ~

" ::!

. 0-

n

;; if

n c:

" !.

~

~

-,;::

. ~

a

e-

fl\n'

~n-

":...

,<

:TO

O

...<

iI-III

-"'=

~

g., "g

;; 0

0'

e-.

a j!!

~

0 fA

;;-

~ ..

. !

~~

':;'

" 0...

-,

='

=...

:::

::...

a-'"

- ;::

r - §

'§'tI

(\

"'tI

=

' Q

..'"

c:3...

" B

.. t;,"

...

::1

, "

::::'

0.. ~

...

.....

;;- -,

-<

...

n"'::

r' (J

Q 't

I 0,

(\

'"

...a

.. :s

'8U

;' 0

!!S

""

!: "

::r..

:s 0

~"g

:I

Q

if

""(J

Q

~""

"n

<go

1/

1=

~...

.

:!~...

°Q

..n'tl

°"~

n'tl

e:

~'2

'"8"

n 0

0 ..

_. fI

\ ...

...

Q

..::-

. 1/1

It 'tI

g.

, .~i

A 0

!"t.-

_~~

-'~n~

Q..I

/I~

...~t

"!..

ille-

=

;:r

:T

0:S

fI\

:s

-, ~

_.

0 ;:r

D

)'"

" "

" e-

. D)

c: ..

.0B

, :::

:, Q

...;r

='!:

-~

,~D

) -,

~

n:s

nQ..

0 '"

""tI3

~

~.;r

n

'" 1/

1 'tI

!.(JQ

:! -

0 !J

D 't

I -,

D) " <

..."g

=-

0 "-

' ,'"

D

) 1/

1"""

~

, 1/

1 =

' 0

'tI -,

~~

:To~

~

n Q

.. S

Q..

8_, =

' ...

n ~

.. '

<

~ 'tI

...

Q..

D)

-,

n -

i3~

n'

" ,

n:1

.gS'

0

~'tI

g"

~ e

- " 31/

1 ~

t"!..

S

' /"

I g

S ~

:1

t.i...

~

Q

.. 'tI

...

0

I:)

::r'..

.;::r

'""

' ;;-

0 -<

='

-. D)

n a-

::-

. 0-

co"

D) -,

"

j:::

... "

C

...~

!JD

;-

~

It B

.. '<

;;1 ;;

Q

.. III

.;r e

- ;;:

r c:

!! It

... 0n

" _.

-,

<

Q

.. Q

.."'"

0 D

) D

) =

' C

"

-..

::r'

< ~

3"

0 =

-,

' n'

" =

...

~ '"

0

g..;r

=

~=

'~8~

"'r;i!

.e-.

~i~

D

):;~

~g.

,gD

)~

~ S' a

. S- if

g ~

t a

~ ~

~

&. ;.;

g :;

g ~

-..:

0 (J

Q

0-

1/1

~

~

n U

;' 5'

=

:1

D

) D

) ~

:;

='

n U

;'!l.

C

;;

-..:

ff :;

...

e-.

g :;

(JQ

!!.

:! O

il 'tI

:;:

:'.0

;; a

~,

D)

...

Q..

Q..

- -,

~

...

Q

.. -

c:

"C

- c:

:S

1/1

=':;

"

-, Q..

3=

' n

III'

0' <

III

8n

" n

n ...

tS

":::;

:~~

0 n

] D

):r

D)

:s

n ::r

' 0

~

n n.

..D)

~""

::-'D

) n.

..'tIn

l/l~

......

n 0

51 ...

:T,<

~

-,C...

8

Co

(I)

C

III0...

n

-".,

's,n

n"~

c:

_.

...

......

(JQ

Q

..:S

::!

sr n

III:;:

:' 0

..,:;'

~

...0

'tI

0 -,

-,

=-

.t,"',

.",

:-,

, 1/

11/1

..

",,-

~N

::r

~

~ 'C .i" go S e: (")

... Ct

n ~ N ~ ~

ii- ::

c: ~

~ ~

;. ~

~ ~

O'~

, f.:

~ ~

~ g

o ~ a

~ i~

~~

ni~

8<~

n~-

A~

an~

o~o~

~ ;r

~ ~

~ i

f ~

: 8

~ ~

§, 5

" g'

~'~

~

;' =

'i

~w

g~

~

~

0 :I

~ 0

'"

0 ~

~ ~

g

0 ~

;;

~ "0

~'5

'~III

",O

:l:::C

""'~

""'""

~"'"

O

:l(JQ

<C

;~

go~

~a.

;.a~

~o-

j~~

Qa~

~t~

~~

:in

"0r

::r"O

~ ~

<

!9::r

Q

,. '<

~

a. ~

'"

0 ~

~

c:

rC

o: d

;.

~

:! :I

7'

n' ~

~:::

0

"0

C ;;,

~ ~

~

n c

Iii -,

~

:I Q

.. 5'

~

0

n ~

C

~

~

n

"0

~:::

i &

': ~

n ~

~ ~

~

;:;'a

q ;:;

' ~

~

;; ~

go

~ ~

w~

"0

~

:I

" '<

=

~

:I ~

:I, ~

""':

T:i'

!! ~

;r

n

:-O

w c:

r~ !i

f a 0

~ S

' ~0'

;i

§ c

~ n

~

~

;'-

~

~...

~

. (1

\ n

,go,

:T~

~:I

n Q

,.~

B e

: r;;~

~n~

'g

~::;

';ig~

a

g ~

~]e

~~

~;.a

§CR

[~g:

r~~

:g~

~~

~~

~

n~

On

-:l~

~

;on~

:! no

~S

! ...

&. S

'..,

n ~

c:

raq

~

Ii" ~

roo

&':~:I

g ~

go

&': ,

go, ~

~:I

-, ~

"',

~ :

I /}

.,0

~

0 t:r

-,

...

Q

~

Iii"<

a0

'" ~

:I

n ;::

; «"

, ""

""

!.;

<.

::r (

JQ :3

~

:I 0

"I ~

~~

, ~~

"'0~

R _.

N' n

; ~

~::;

~!..

n:t,"

'n-

:I n

n ~

","

~

"'-n:

l :I,

~

..,

;,'

<O~

_.~

'" '"

~ - c:

r ~

~::r

0

n -n

n:

n'"

~:r

- n

ern

c:r

~

~

0 ~

c:

r~

;;Z 0

~

n

"'w

~::r

no

-,

II) n

n

-,;.

~'5

Iii

' e: a

. g ~

., <

~ "0

2'

£i' ~

noe:

~ ~

8 ~

a-'~

~"'-

-'...,

n

~""

"-~

:I"

':I.o

!::'

'" ..'

i::f

::r '"

:I

~ -,

n n

~

~

;; ~

aq

., ~

<

C;

8 ~

0'

~

~

(J

Q

'" ~

e:

:T

~

:I c:

r e-

. ...

' '"

Ii g

Iii'

t ~

:I~:I~

~

goQ

,. ~

~~

On"

"'2'

n ~

:T:I

g,

; ~

~ n

;;-:-

~

~I

§ ~

~ ~

B,

o-j..

!!.. ~::;

, g

~:l

r~'<

Tt

~~

!i-A

~

~nO

~if"

":;°

1.o

! ro

o ~

_.

'"

n ~

~

..,

<

C;

o'

a.

~:;I

~

S

Q

,. (ji

i' a,

::r

,r~

~ ~

'" ar

:r ~

n

:I_n~

~~

"'-:l:

:rn

:T

w-'n

n ~

'"

'" ~

go

;; 0

~

.!:::!

~

n'

~

"V~

~

~

~

n

Iii'

~::r

-,

n '"

n -

~

'"a

n 11

);

n t;.

0

'<0

'" a

if:t.:

:r:l

:r ~

0 n

;;z

'<9

i ~

::;

~

C

n ~

.,

:I ~

0

_.

-. g

: :I

-,

~

-, C

!

o-j

is: ~

:;I ~

aq ~

::r

,i ~

~ g,

:I,

:I &

': ~

~

'" ~

nw

1=1 if

2":l5

'n~

ngll)

cif:l

<§.

;'~

"<cc

:r

jilin

tI) g

.(JQ

:I,

~

:I,

w ~

n

~

w'"

B

n ~

~

go ~

~

"0

~0

- III

~

0'

~

::;

' n

::;'

", s:...

It

::1'\

n...,

<:

M0",

<:

3 :;I

-'aq-

'- ..

:T(I

J "';

'~"':

I'"n

g ~

Q

'<

Q

~

g II)

g.

. n Y

' ~

n

-;'..

. ~

w ;;

'i'

Iii

'

:c I I ur S»

I- J n 5' 3' I

~I

N C11

Page 3: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

If:~

=~

~

2=~

-i~~

Or~

,J.~

~ ~

~

e-

A"'~

~

.:,

~

~.2

;

2 =

= o

Q'

&j'

~

o:"'Q

i.,...

~ci

f<c

.,c:r

.a.

~"O

-o

-<o~

...~

...~

~

,...

...

~,-

'::r'"

...

¥>

.,

...

;:I ~

0

0 0

...

~

",~

e-.~

c;:::

...,<

~~

'<

c""'~

-:l.

o~~

...ac

:;~""

",lf:

o~C

I'i!!i

!'<~

~

~a~

...=

nO

=O

°n

~~

noQ

...ii~

;;;r=

Q.~

~

=~

:r.,"

;""'"

-...

",.

"'C!°

",~

,==

Q.;;

;r"'-

<

SJ

Ia

e'

a.

$i'

;s,

II ~

~

:r

R a

: a

~

a.

;i~,

0 C

f, ~

=

=;:n

0

co

, lA

' &

} -,

c:

0

~ n

0

=

-i e-

'"

!!..

0c§-

t:,

~ =

ii'

0"""

~

~

"'

...

-,

0

~

~"'.

..~=

'" "'0

~&

j0"'0

Cf,

' "0

a

...

...

~

~:r

=

=

c

=00

"' ""

0'11

1...'

" "'g

.CJI

:I0'"

=

IT::;

""

~

~':r

0

a.:r

;-

~

...

...

:r

==

.20

~

:r~

-<

1!-

1;;'

~...

~

=

'<

0

n <

9

c-,

-,

=

. >

<

~

-<

n~

~

~

-.

:-

' =

cf

. Q

. Q

. ~

"0

-"

0 :-

. '"

=:r

S

J c:

r R

a

!' R

0

=

~

~

0 a

~

Q..o

0

~~

- ...

=""

""

'" c'

"...

0'

::

a "8

i"0

'"

~

if!t

"g

"8

~,[:

:;'

0

~~

o&a

;~~

~~

~~

o..."

'~=

=...

"'=

~ii"

'~-"

"~~

=

~

0~

g ~

"8

...

=

cf,

g.:a

~ s

,...

~ 0

=

@'::

:r

"'~"'~

~ag

"'~if~

r~~

~aa

::;"~

=iii

::c~

""'~

§!=

I~~

~~

::;,~

1ii

0 ~

c:r:

:r

Iii-

' i

a §

~

5'

c:r'<

...

9,

0

~

='

0 [

&j'

0... ...

Q.

~

...

Q.

jiT"'O

0

'" C

JI:I

II)

::r

~

~

IJ,

~

a ...

A

g,

2

: ~

=

--

i =

~

a

~

~

~ q

§ fir

~

a"

I ~

=

~

0

a c

~

cf,

~ ~

-.:!

.&

.;

...

"'~

=,

;;;r

0 ;;;

r a

~'e

-;;1

~

-,

- ~

. '"

a,

~

~

,...

c:r'"

I

j ::

8 "0

0

...

-,

fJ

~..,

jiT

' Ii"

... ~

.a..

:T

_.

0..

0 =

-<

g.

it

<

Q..;

;;r~

_.

=<

c:r

"'.

11>

...'

~<

~

~

A...

oQ

'" It-

""""

~

~""

";;;r

0

-~

~

!. 0

g,

~~

'"

~';;

1 ::;

'...

~ g-'"

-i X

~~

e~=

5""

_:;_

,<

S"'~

'.

.. ...

Q

.. ::c

0

CJI

:I ~

~

~

-,...

c.

:::

- -,

0...

=

...

a

a ;-

....

=

CJI

:I...

'.0

:r

=

......

...

c:r

'" 0

~

~ ~

~,...

0

n ~

= Q

. 1;

;'

"'008

, t:l

nQ."

""""

'nc

2::

~ ~

~ 2

.. ~

a I;;

~~

' ~ ~

~ ;

'?-

r. ;.

~

~

~-

. ..

~ ~

~'

are-

: :

go g,a

~

g ~

E 8

;. 2

~:;.

e- ;.

~ e

-.

~'

~s.

. e-

~ §

" §-~

A8- a

. a N

~ §

~ 0-

r;["

~,

::I

A

~:=

-.

:=-.

0=::1

tII

~

a -,

3 Ao

!Ii ~

A

tII

0..

'" tII

A

"0

aq

a

a I»

Q

~'<

~

0

a~

0 -'.

.. 0.

. 0..

I»

'" tII

"'::

r "',

...

= s

'" I»

:::

r 0

;a

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~'~

.!- ~

~ ~

~~ ~

ag

~ a

0 ~

[[ g

- ~ ~

~ r-

~ ~ !

./& ~

. g: g

g';'

&

. ~ ~

;--',

<::I

<

tII

1»

OO

""-Q

'. -"

,-'tI

IO::l

-' ...

",

~

,"-a

q.:<

o..O

tll...

O'."

'tIIC

;i o.

.AtII

A~

~

. ~

a"

j;)

j;)

0 s

c 5'

1;

;' ~

I» g

a 0.

. ~ 8

n A

~ I»

::I

0 0"

0 Y

' f;!

1;;'

~ tII

1;

;' e-

.2-

~ e

-. :.

,.. i.

i"- 5'

0.

. tII

::I

~

;;.;;,

0

...

!2.

cs"

... ~

'"

::;'::

1 ~

0

Q '<

'"

e- 0

...

I»

of!::

::'

><

"0

;:&

I»

g

...~

,""

"".:1

.1'"

~::r

~~

O'<

::r"'A

::ItII

3c

5"~

,~::1

...

""A

3""

::I:f<

'."O

o""

0 02

.g .

a ~

;. ~

:: I»

1;

;'~,

s.. 1

;;' &

. =

Y

' 0.

.;-

~

~

5! ~

r-

s- s

- ;. ~

3 rrS';-

~ 0.

. ~

;- J

! !! t

II ~

;. g,

g,

~ ~

;:1\

...

0..

tII

tII

&.

e:: ~

~

~ '<

~ ~

2

~

~

tII

0'

O'

~ 5

' ~

I» 0

::r

c:

5' !

1!,~

:::r

"O;:&

~

g- <

e:

~ a

;;' a

a g-

~ ~

0 ~

~::

I»

!'1 a

~ go

~' ~

6 0.

. 5!

5!

::;

.aq

=. g a

s ~

~ ~

a R

g j;)

: a.

s.

~

=- ~

"00

~,d

ii tII

~

I»

-"

""

I»

...

Y.1

- ~

0

::r'

0.. ~

~

0 '"

"0

::I

::!

~

~

Y' -.

~ -'..

. _.

0.. :

:;. g

-g

.g s.

. =

, 5' ~

~

S" S

' E, Q

Q' 8

5' ;;

~ -

5' 5

' s.

. :::

~ aq

~ 0

if;-;

- a

~:-

. ~

~ g ~

~

:f 1;

;' i

~ .

0

Q

i:::,

5' - 0

aq

...

::r::l

a.

~ 0

.. 5'

g"a

q aq

e-:§

' s ~

0 .

.. e

'<

'<

go~

!' 0

=.

~

0 .a

c

~a

0::1

C

I»

~

aq ;,!

, e-

a. ~

: a"

::r n

'"

go 0-

!!,~

, r!

!.::

~'<

;-

e: §

1;;,~

A

0 ~

i 1;

;'~

... ~

~ :;

§ ~

§- ~

&

.]\' g

- g-~

~ ~

:.g

; ~

~ ~ 0

~~

' 8 ~

g 3~

,!hO

D

~ i,.g

t] r

~; s

..: ~

g, g f e

.~

tII

cr

I» e-

O

! 0

... ;-

go:!

::I

tII

tII

e-

<

~

i'i

-::I

0 e-

. ~ ~

~

s -

, 2"

;'::1

5'

o:!

0 8

::r S

'~

g

~;.

: ~ ~

~ 8

~ tII

~

~ a.

:: &

:~'

~,g

~'~

g' a

~

a. 8

~ &.

~ g ~

~~

. ~ ~

~~

:f ~ c:

::r A

::;

. S

'2...

'8 g

. &.

&. ~

~ s

.. ~

a 2

> a

aq

::I

A

"g.

'" go

0 ~

A

~

>;.:

:r

~ ~

g s

' "',

"'.

<

1»::r

1;;'~

e.

""~

'5!::

;'~c.

A""

ao'

e-~

~go

o!!a

tlll»

lj'a

O~

;-;-

~I»

~oo

' ~

5&

61»

"'I»

n::r

~.

-"".

..::!,

::I

:::

r c

><

"'~"O

""

"j;)J

"I

'.""t

IIl»

go

R:3

:-'

~ &.

~, ~

:~

~ g

.a- a

~ R '

:<;'

;. g

1S

tII

~ I»

~

. g ~

~ a

~

~ 5'

~. g

. a g

- 6 i

~ g

>

::;' ~

~0

:.. a

A

0 0

!.. r

r =

0..:

:1 rr

;. 06

' 0.. a

3 ;

. ~

!h

~ "0

~

::I

A

::I

1»'

~ I»

~

2:

~ a

q "0

1;

;' ~

:::

z:=

I"""

1»

00

",1\

1:'-'

::;'<

1»

_,A

tIIA

::I-f

::l~

tII

><

::;

'::Ie

-::I~

O.,A

",::r

1»

!2.

ia

1»::1

~

::I""

io..:

:11»

1»""

a"

~~

1»

""::r

0~...

::r"O

tII

:!:

:IO""

"'~

~

I»

'8 g

-~::I,~' 2,

g

~ ~

~ ~

;- ~

s:

i a a

s' §

~ 1;

;' ~

g' §

,; a

!1 ~

a g

~'g

g ;

-~'

8 a-

f

~ e'

..

::I::r

!

3~'

2 ::I

~

;:

8,

°:r

a 0

:;:

aq

::;

A

;-!..

'"

a.~

~'

0 =

. c:

~

;:'

.::1

::I'

go

a ~

g.

. ~

-=

~

1;;'

a =

=

n g

;; 5

~

'" 0

~

~

::I::

=r

0 !..

~

'"

g ~

. ~

~

2

0 ~

0'

~

~

;i I»

-,

8

e:

0..

i'

::I

0'

::Il»

oo..:

:rtll

::l

"'~

ootll

::;

';-aq

tll-f

::r

~o"

'°::l

;:Stll

:;:tII

"'a

1»"'-

R i

-:s:

f :::

:-

tII -,

a 5'

::t' ~

rr

q!!.

2' '"

5 ::r

0..

~ I

» e-

. ~

1;;'

3 ~

!'

3 0.

. ~

0..

Sol

» ...

15

A a.

u;

a. a

-5 ~

~

,I»

g- ~

: ~

I» 1;

;';-

~.~

~

i-

g. S"

~ ;:

2' ;.

a' ~

~

~ ~

g : q

go ~

a :,~

e-

~. ~

I»

g, 0

~ ~

a,

8, g

e.. ~

~

~ ~

5'

F ~

g' a

~~

!. ~ ;

. a,

~ ~

-3- ~

'~'

~ a

g ~

~ ~

~~

5'

i R

. §,

~;

~

AI..

. ~

~ it

ai ;

'; "0

-,

3

~ ~

r:- s

::s

: ;.;

g

A)

~ 2

. :I,

~~

,pr ~

~ .

::r

~ ~

S'

~, ~

~,

e:

.6-:

!f a

~

g' ~

~

[ go

~,~

[ !f"

.'~- ~ E

: ~ a

' ~ ~

s..

~ ~

. 5'

~. ;;

. 5;, ~

. ~ s

.. ~

~~

9- a

if

~ ~

5'

~ e. :I N

I I_

I ~

...

...

;;!~

5' ~ ~ QO

g' n i: (")

~ =:

n r;r

3 ~ ~

~II)

"'O

"'~ns

e j"'

n'"

a..:S

<~

E;;;

' :!,

~S

c .:!

2:

s;

~ ~

a, 1

'8

2 ir

g s

~,

~

!! ~

"0

~

:r C

oe-

II)

5"

e-

e-

;,

~

8 g

8,

e-

~

~

:r::I

: 8

~

~ ~

t. i!

0 g

~

~"0

;

0 $3

;;;'

...:s

~

-,

II)

~

"0

0

;;;,!!

..~e

i: 1D

c

1'8

c ::r

;; 0

~,

-,:S

;:;.

'" =

--

1'8

t: $3

~

1'

8 ::!

::s

0

Q.:<

Q

..E

..Q

.. -:

s ~

;;

6 ~

~

...

'" 1'

8 ...

~

II)

1'

8 ...

<

-'.

-':

S:::

' [!!

, 1'

8 ...

1'

8 -

~

...'"

1'8

6'~

1'

8 <

1'8

II)

n

!: ~

I)

e-

.::

: ~

.. ~

...

-

= :r;

.:;

-,

c Q

.. II)

. 3

1'8

Q..,

<:r

II)

Q

..'.

.. ~

~

8 6

:r

a,

II)

~

a &

. ~

&

. if

~

:s'

~'

8~ g"

~

~

&

. g-

g"

i

2'

-':s

Ie

...

0 -

1'8

-,

1'8:

:1

1'8

n C

IQ

~a

n-,

n'"

ti -:

s S

:s

...

1'

8 II)

:s

0

'" 1'

8 -.

<

0;

- s:

r:s

[!!

,rn

II)0...

...

- :

'" n

...

-O:r

Q

..:S

~5'"

,~

'" ...

Q..

...

-,

:r

Q..

.. ~

...

...

'"

...

0 1'

8 :r

n.:!~

0

a 11

1'

8 81

1 -,

:rE

..:r~

,n

:r

tr

o'~

8 ~

~

~

~

:1

J=I

"00e-

;-

g ~

i

5 Q

.. II)

~

C

IQ

3,

t: :

~

J=I

o:s-

II)

:r

.:..!

5,

1'8:

; 1'

8 !1

...

n

a-

~""

C

IQ

- ':t

<

II!

=

1'8

::;:!!

.. ~

0

~.

~

1'8

a-

Ii 0

;: n

8 -,

::s

-..;

=

Q:

~

-c;

~

,<",

nll)'

<_~

-'II)

"'II)

...~

...~

...::S

OIl)

~

0 :r

S

Qq'

;; a,

[!!

, '"

~:so

::s

-::s'

[!!,

~:r

~

...

CIQ

IT

...

1'

8 5"

P

i' 6

~::S

::l~

~g;

:;;'II

)e-

n 1I

)0'~

!:::I:

a..n

~~

: :r

a ~

~

...

5'

~

9-

=

...

~

e-

a :.

- :i'

"8

~

~

e-

[!!

, ~

c

:r

s

...~

~0

::I...

0Q..8

11)"

'~n

::In~

,08:

sa.-

n~

Ria

: ~

a

S

B'

~

'" ~

'::

==

;-

~

, ~

a ~

i~

~ 0-

~

~

II)

~~

n"O

:r

g"

"O~

-'Q..C

lQII)

III'"

!;i'~

""

"~

, g,

,::1

n 1'

8 ... ~

;;;'

0g"

...:r

~

...

=

~

...:r--

':--'o

::~~

0

=

It>

n'

6 n

:s

...

1'8

- o~

0

~

;i e-

~

~

[!!

, ~

2

1'8

~ ~

,e-

- ~

i

8 1'

8 II)

g

8 e-

;.

..

...1'

8 c:

!8<

...~

nnno

e-

::I~

"'n~

n 1'

811)

~ 5

' 0:

a.

~~

r:

! ~

-<

8~

~,

1'8

g.,

~ 0

~

~

Er~

0-

~~

=

"'.

.. II)

=

:r

~

E

ta

n 1'

8 ~

:s

-:;r

~

0 (J

CI::

S

~ a

, g"

a

~

if ~

~

;:;'

ir a,

_.

=

ji{

' g,

§

~

0 a

~

;:;' 5

nO

Sc~

t:a~

:r...

o"'~

o:S

~~

-;;:1

o:

sif

]~

CIQ

i:

-,...

~

;;;'

8 ;

-,

'"~

...

n"'S

i! ~

;:;"<

...

~'"

3 1'

8 :r

C

I...

'" 0;

;; 11

)...:

: ej

ij'

;V!l

a ...

0

:s

"0

II)

::s

<

-,

II)

Q..

-,

~

~-.

.; !!.

.::s.

...

g.

-,

::;...

0.

..II)

II)

~

::s

<F

1'

8 '"

; a

<~

-

~

1'8;

;' 0

<§

Q.. ~

a

1'8

~ j&

. "'Q

:",o

re

-,

n II)

-I

I)"':

S

i;:~

<II!

a-

-,

c

...

1'8

1'8

II)

g.

~

~

II)

n "0

~

~

0

~

~:J

:r<; ~

II)

::S

n:rg

~

-,

=

1'83

~

a-

~

:r

a a

Q..

II):S

"0

1'

8

=

'" ~

8:;r

:S

0 ...

-,

1'

8 <

-,

'"

n ;;

'"

n:r-' II)

~

;:;'

g II)

1'

8 ~

~

<

if!

! 0

~

s.:q

!! :

CI..

. a

<II.

.....

-.

a '"

II)

~

- _.

~

-

~-

1'8

...

e-

g'

~

R

~

g~,

t: e-

6:

~

... e-

~

a ~

~

~

, t

~

8

n.

Q...

'<II)

,'rn.

..on

-..;I

I)Q

..""

"'~

3 ~ 1);"

i t ;:t

Page 4: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

~C

'~~

a, e

:'"

;-:s

: a, ii

e-0

~'S

0

c ~

0

~ ;

:: ~

0 a,

::c

n IP

';'" no

S'

noci

' e!

.. ::r

!!i'

CT

O~

~-=

o~-

a-~

=~

""'~

- ""

'0-

~:=

-

~~

" n

=

=

0"":

=

=

-,

u §

n'

-"

~

~

0 ",

~

~

=

=

-

(JQ

0

a ~

=

0

=",

~

2"

~

ff e-

=

a-

~

!. ~

~

,~

:t g.

en

15

~

S

n

0 g,

g"

" t

CT

:r

5"

n ~

,"8

&.

a g,

,:rF

-;;:

~

~

c:

J&

~

~

~

n ~

~

'"

i 0

a ~

0

8 -

go:!,

=

' ~

0

n n!

3 g"

S

:=

c

C

~

9-~

, 0

e

IN

~

g,;

a,

~

~

8 5'

g"

~

~

15

';::

: ~

&

. ~

~

e-

. =

-;;

15

~

=~

t

a'~

a

g,

g.

~.g

;

a'Q

}

g.

~

=

c 15

~

~"

0 ii

e-::r

n

~

:=

;' a

5'

ii (J

Q "

""

='

Q.

n ...

n

::;

0 =

=

=

",

t:.

~

nQ

. ::r

. -

9-

~

~

g.

. ~

.a

n ~

~.,

8'

g C

T 0

a'

Q

~"~

rr:

T i

i a:

8

8 :s

c

~

~

., 0

ii if

~

n ~

~

-,

-, ~

-

~

I: ~

n

~

n:s

...

n n

=

0 :s

Q

. e-

-

...

e.."

""

~

Q.

0 :s

~::

5"

=

~

8 ~

~

s

c ~

g

~

~!3

i!l

~

,R'

0;i

~

~

~

R

: n

~

e a

~

A

CT

83

~

ii

::r~

n=

~

...9-

~

(JQ

~~

~9-

'" A

nC

<",

~o~

Q

"'n~

2~

=

n =

8'

-

~

a g.

0'

iii

" ::;

.; It

;::

en~

-

-,

~

"8

e n

a =

A

-

n :s

0

U

8'

~

0 -

"8

~

C

Ra

~

a ~

~

"g

~

~

~

~":

J F

-:

;. 5

(;

!. 5'

3= a

~

=

g,,;-

a:

~

.

co

:. ~

~

;-

~

. ~

r

~

-,

~

I\)

C

e-.

'" I\)

1i

~'

a,"

...'

5'"

Q.

I\)

<

0 ~

=

:c§

en

a,"'"

Q

.

2 ~

:-

f. ~

~

~

s:

g'

~

~

e:

&.

::rR

~,r

~J

~

a ~

~

!':

A

~

g 2-

2'

: g

g ~

g-

&

.!

n -

~

en

C

- n

;;r

=

8 -

a,

~

- n

-,

-!

-':=

-,

i-"

-

- ~

-

- -

::t'

3

~

a,

~

g,,8

S

!~"

~

~

::;

ii ~

~

~

e-

15

a.

~

A

J&

:T

g.

. ~

!-

0 r

~

a 8

c§

='

a.

~

J&

0':

8 if

~

: a

i.a

=

" e.

s:

0

~

:::

~

S'::

;';

~

&.

~

~

e-

~

n n

~

a-

6 n'

S

' e.

. ~

g

~

s

~i(~

~"'

2iil

~~

ig.r

attf~

~i~

~rr

~~

""~'i

~~

al~

~:

e ~

I\)

-<

"

~:;<

II

n::r

~'

~

~

<I!

<

~

~

0 n

n ~

~

n

~

:!:

n 0

0 '"

5':=

...

..

-0::1

...

,:.4

(JQ

-

~

~

""";

;r -

;-

'" n

;;r-"

;;;

0 "0

~

~

§f

;::

~

;-

~:-

~

::c

8

~

S

§ e::t

' 5"

~

,~

~

~

e-

~~

§'

S

'~'

a.t

g '"

~

a J

I[ ~

~

,~

~~

s

-.

-,

a,

='

I\)

r:T

n

<I!.

..~

:s

ID

~

c:-.

en

I\)

C

:. ~

n

-"0

n _.

!!i

=

.,::.

a.

~ a

0 ~

c;

:. :r

0 !..

~ n

' ~

' ~

:. 9

:: 2

... ~

a:

~ - 9

- Q g

" ~

~. 1

5 n:

:r;::

~

~'

- '"

~

15

EJI

'; ~

",,"

., 9-

! I\)

~,

n'~

~

!l.~

a

~,a

;::~

~

...

9-E

.f:..a

'Q

><

~

~

a.

~

~5'

c:.:

Iii'

~

!..

~

~

3 ~

['!

tl &

. ~

~

::r

=

~

~8-'

!..

~

~

A

\II

~

n'

g.

~

A

~

~

~

g ...

!t

~",

a'

Q

9-

-nro

"aoe

n~n"

, C

Te-

~

;-

a"~

~l\)

n...;

-Ai~

iio

1\)0

"~

~

=

J&

~

a

;::

~

a,

~

5'

~

nag

:r:

~

g.::t

' ~

i;

&.

~

~

~

e-.

~

~

"0

~

a a:

~

~

a "2

S

'!.

5'

S'

~

~~o

[~

, g'

8

~

g-.

~

~

~

=-

Iii'

s:

a.

e-

e..

~

; ~

~

t

~,~

~

. r

11

~

~

"g

a,

e-

e-~

- ~

=

e-

-<'

- ~

A

'"

0 ~

~

",

n ~

~

~

=

~

e-~

1m

~

,.a

e a

~

r:T

-

A

..,

1\).

, .,

0...

-,

n ~

. "~

"':3"

...

8 n

~

5-

::c

~

~

g ~

~

a

0 n

:..2

8 O

f ~

B

, t

51

~

a R

:r

a

-i 8

~

:: 9-

e-

. ...

~

g-

t~~

~

~

~

f~

~r~

~

rj ~

'~

~i~

ll'~

~'[~

:f§.~

:;-~

'~

~'~

~

~

-,

::r

15

!: n

c e,

D

r ~

~

e-

~

~

~

c

!! g:

9-

/)

aq

a

- ~

~

!

::t'

9-

e-

~

~

;-

~

CT

:=n.

,~

~

,_,.n

n.

.~

"Onn

n~l\)

n.

0 .~

"'A

n .=

.,~.

N -4 =-

CD

CD

I» ~ '< < ai'

~

=

~ -

!! ~

~~

...

0

lI)::r

c=

20::

c-~

:-

.en

~

-'...

n=

::r

...~

~

0

:!,

a'

~

~~

. ""

...

eI.

...=

°a

-"0

'<

'" '"

< 0

~

n <g.

'" -,

!!!. C

-on

,=

II)

::S~

en

(Jq

~ C

§' ~

2". -,

5i"

n ::1

'\...

::r~

nc-

::s'"

0 ...

~§

II)

~,=

~

II)

...II)

--

.

...

0 0

:: ~

::I

2".~

~en

':T::t

n ~

II)

=~

:r-<

~E

Is:

'"

~,;;

; c

ena:

;. "'~

i ~

,i~

~

~

5'7

::r

8 g,

e-.

R'" ::,

~ g

~ Ii

)" 8

~ g

8

S g

., a 8

ci' 8

~o~

"i ~

e- 5

' g,

8

j{ R

' 8 .~

~

:3

:;ce-

Q~

A~

A

":=

~~

en

"':

=::r

0 ca

~"';

;:=:=

n~:3

~A

AA

Q:-

<" Ii

0 ~

::t,

e: a

if;;

::t,

I'> .

.-j

Q:

A ~

a- 2!

, a ~

~ It

Iii "8

;

S '"

fi . 5'

~

A

; S

~g

[ ~

~'

g A

;;;

'~

a ~

:

~

~

g e

(JQ

;

a a.

n

~,s

, 5'

;;;'

g'

[s,;-

e-

~

iii

3"

~'

s:

:, ~

!

~

;-

g 4

~

g g.

, e:

e-

S

~

~

,~

S

...

n ~

g

i.g.(

JQ

~

0'

j; g

g ~

a

~ ~

g.

, ~

g ~

"2

~

:, '"

!:4

~;;.

~

~

8

~

~

1:

~

a 8

g g.

, i'

A

; ~

~

:::

~

~

ii'

~

0

" S

' I'>

a

~r

~::r

sg

(JQ

oeA

~~

~~

~~

o~e-

o(~

"::r

if:=

O'

~;r

~~

=;-

1'>

'",

~

a

~~

~

~

i 0

;;;'A

~

1iI.S

~

g'A

,"

",IiI

S'~

~

~

~

R'~

~

c)'::

; ~

n

~;;;

'A

:=

A

A

~

0 ~

A

...

::r

c.::I

B

n

c.

~

n ~

::t

, n

...

A

iii

A

:s A

;:;

' 0

n. C

. i"

~

I'> ~

a, e

~ I'>

:s :3

= .

0 ~

A (J

Q Y

' 0

::I ~

Q.::

r e-

'<

0 '"

9 "

; iii

~

::r ~

.g ~

~ ;;'

g. fi'

::r ~

~ Q

e-

A I'>

~

5 ;

~ '"

~ ~

~'a' g.

, 8 g :-

iii ~ ~

~ g.

, g ~

;n~

~

~

~,~

8

~

;i::r

5-

;'~'

a ~

gQ'

~r

~

6.

g.

[~

~

e-~

~

if

if s'

i ~

9

g'~

,;0

c g

5:::1

:=

~

~

,I'>

(J

Q

(JQ

~

A

u;

1:

'f/

:"

0 (J

Q

- 'A

-,

-

,...,

(JQ

A

A

A

1:

1 e

c.

'"'"

-!!

CT

" ;;

" =

,~A

=

-::r

. 5'

0

~ '"

:s:=

A

:= g

:tl ~

~

;J'

g, -,

;;;'

I'> ~

~ i

ii C

T~

C

. ~

n

n :..

! ::r

~

C

, g

""'"

'"'"

c.

<

2!,

0 ~

0

!:1..

U

I'>

-,

n'

~

1:1

n :=

, -.

'""

'; '<

~

",~

u:s~

~

I'>

~

:s

'""'~

- C

T:=

~

1iI

-:s

-

~

g ;-

ef

~

.~

~

~

~

~

,l A

~

if

§ [a

}

~

e-

;;;,-

~

n-<

: ~

.$~

' ~

~

(J

Q

~

-<

S

~';r

a"8

~,-

~~

e-

~

S'~

s:

8

~~

'~'t~

A

::J

A

g ~

<

-&

.A

e-~

~I!~

!1-

. 1:

:tl

0 :c

A

n:

S

a :s

:;J

~

=t

~ "

a 8

-,

~

'" S

' 3

~

I'>

0 j;

e-.]

~

g:

I'>

; -2

~

~

~

g,

s

~

~

i ~

8

s-e.

.° a.

~

~

:3

.5

~

~'~

~

a.

Iii

;r

&

. g

S,

~

j; ~

A

~

I'>

D

S n

::t,"

~

-:

. 0'

c.

a

:= e

- ..

~..

~

'q

A

'<;;;

' ~

~

n

iii

I'>0

., !"

t ~

~

~8

~

a.

n ~

n

:s5

, e-

. It

C.

n i5

...0

g I'>

~

_::t,

e-

;,

A

~~

c.o

~i

<~

o..~

.. "~

_"A

iii

'""

'~

nO

A"'~

OnA

~I'>

~1'

>

A!!'

" g

~

...

'" 0

A

~,°

ii"

(JQ

0

0 ~

0

:s

~

0 :=

A

~

0

I'>

iii

2!,

~

~

'"

c.

~

I'>

A

I'>

a.

~

...~

, g:

(JQ

§

"':=

n

~

e-.

n-

CI

1:

~

~'g

. ~

:!,

~

~::I

~

. go

a. ~ 1

: ...

1'>

, ~ :4

C§.

~ ~

S

c. ~

~ !"

~

~'

::t,~

A

0 - S'

~

A

~

-< :!,

~

"'~ S' e

:..

~,:=

~

c.

a

gg

~

g S

R

~

9

g..;i

~

gA

g.,

'"'"

e-~

~

,i5

~

! a

I'>

5'

8 !l

~

~

:: ~

,8

:"!1

~

!1

c.

;;;'

~

~

~

g.,

c ~

. g.

, '"

g.,

e:

S

~

:; ~

:3

~

;: e:

g

;; e-

8

::r

0:3

~

0 1:

'"'

" ~

e-

e-

e

e:

:=

"'...,

~

g.

, iii

;; :c

~

g:

:'!

':':

0 :=

~

:=

~0

A

...

.e

I'>

n A

"'"

n'

5'

e-

~

a:=

=

--

<

...

I'>

A

::;

0 a=

--,"

",::!

::t

, A

n'

S'

0 g-

.0

<

;...

;-

~;;;

' ::r

(JQ

A

::r

a

0 "

;; ~

'"

~

"'<

:=

(jQ

;; 0

- 0

A

if ~

~

~

g

~

g ~

a'

a ;;.

; e-

g.

, 8

: ~

,~

if !.

eo:

~

a if

8 ~

~

!.

a ~

':cP

g

?A

Iii

'" n

iii

-,~

:tl

~

A

~

~

0

c.

c -,

I'>

:S

:s"

I'>

~

=-

:s C

T~0

A ~

:::r

" '"

0 <

if

:tl e

-~ ~

:s (J

Q ::;

:3 ~

:3

n '

" ~

c.

AS' a - 8

I'>

~

0nn

,.,

...

A::r

.~

A'"

AO

A

AA

A

::ren

A

:tl

CT

O(J

Q,!'

II

e:

~

0'

~

~

~

a::;J

c.

;-

e

:s

rr

~

0 ;

~

;-

~

~

gg

~

5'

~:3

~

n

; ':<

1'>

~\1

1","

::a,"

",

00

e _,

:=;A

l"c::"

':S_'

C:;"

'" A

n~S

t::'A

I::r9

::1"';

::s g

::s o

::r

,~G

o c:

::I

Go t

:T

enS

-,

-

;:;. ~

::s

= :

:s t:

T iii

~ g

~~

::s

n' I

'> ..

. ::r

c.

I c.

..,

;;;' S

'"

A

~.

~

A"

'" ';'

iii

:s

Po

'" ~

(J

Q '"

(J

Q '<

1:

"'~

I

A~

. I

::r '

" !"

. A

l.~ I '< go g i: i f ~ ~

-cr

1~

II)

a!;',

cO'2

;"'..

.;-g,

e-"

'.~

n ~

",as

~ ~

-+:r

~ 1

;;'

11)0

<::

: a ::s

:r a

-,n

0 ii

O':l

i;!=

=-'1

1)0:

:;-~

~::.

"-"

'0

II)=

"'C!!!

~

~

BII)

II)

::%'a

.0

g:I

ov

S,.-

-e:

§"'.

....

< 0

n'~ ~ ,

:""':

1""

- 1;;'-

<'"

'"C

n

83

~a

a

[~..,

~if

11 ~

. X ~

'>£<

"....

.O

"'ga.

~"2

ii"- n

!';

.::t

;- g

~ "

5:0.

1;.."

"0.

~

-.

><

..

"r:I~

~Iii

'::S

5;-:

"8

ii:.

.. I:

::s::s

=

~

!1

;:..

n'<

_.

;; ..

0

;'~o'

;-3

" ..

..::!

3a.

::s..1

A1:

.. -"

'0

C

::s-.

::s

"0

"0

_.

31;..

~~

O~

..:;

~

-g

-.

cr

S;;:

..'

g..=

..~

ggS

!a.

2"'1

1 ..

- -;

; 0

-.~

a.

-;'i

1:..0

';'-

0' g

...

B

S..

::s g

c.:r

~;.~

go-.

~ ;

a. ..

::s -.

- ..

;;"'0

"0"0

::S""

"o

":::

0

< ~

0

g' :r

E- ~

'8...

"0

11 a

:~'

~

~

~

g 0'

"Oo~

..::s

i..

=-_

..

3 -.

n

;;-

.. g.

0

0-

~

::S::s

. ~

r -.

Ii

-

:"=

=g -<

'11>

:"'-

::::I:

CD

a ;:r ~ =r

a Cii"

I» < e!-

o: ~ (")

Dr

3" .-.)

~

Page 5: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

c -,

~

...

-, -

" 0

f'\

n aa

...

n

-" ~

0.

.'"

~

n ...

0

- 3

... .

.. 0

aa

~:s

-"

0 -,

a"'

aa 3

"0

a"'

C

n~

~

.B g

.-<

;: S

- 0

g i"

g-;-

;;

aa ;

;' g-

a. g

e.=

a. aa

;- g

:s

aa

~ ~

a"'"

~

" g

~ a

'< &

.;-5

~

&; ~

,It

0 ~

" ~ ~

. ~~

£

§' ;i

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

':<

fi ! ~

;. 0.

. s:

e ;

i g ~

~ 6

: 8 ~

, ~

r ~ aa

g. '8 g

- ~ ~

" ::c

~. t ~

a t 1

1 ~

n ~

~. ~ ~

~ ~~

~ ~

~

. ~

1 H

i [ r H

d

i ~! ~

~ ~ ~

~

I: i

l ~

!~

0 a.

;;- s

fi ~

" ~

i5...

~ ~

.B ~

': ~

~ §

~'

~ :=

. ~

a.:::

~ ~

§

l ~

; ~

-< g

s:

~

~. ~

;;-

0 r

i a.

~<

~

0

:s

-."

~"

0 C

o.."

,:S

0..

...

lit

'<

...

aa

t:IC

I -. ...

~

(II

...

-':S

0

... a

a ::r

-~

~"

~ 3

Q.. ~

~ g

~. '"

fir <"

;;. ~

c g-

~ S

- ~ E

~ S

- ~

~ S

- ~ =

=:: :

;.; &. aa

g ~

ce :r

ir g

0 a "

O o~ g-

c. "

...::;

.; 0

s- aa

;;':

3"

~":

s!!..

"O

0 n"

;.

0 "

:s

aa a

a -

c::

£:r

C,:3

5;

aa

n

-=

c::

0

~.~

~

i ~ h

~,:~

g 8"p

i!.~

~H

~ J:

~~

!! g,H

~g~

h~.~

~.H

i ;~

U~

CI

3 ~

!it

aa "g

;-

::t'

it 0

6-~

' ~ ~

~ ~

;

;. g.

;;' "

E ~

g-;;'

; 0

Ii ~

:s

~ 5

~ g

- Co

!}

a. ~

~ ~

~

,

S'

~

-c:

~'

3°3

::r-3

~ Q

Q ri

CI

0 :s

' aa

aa

;:;

S-O

ii"::C

0 aa

o..

CI

3'<

0

0 Q

.."

Q..

~

~"u

;.::!

n S

- 0

" ~

C§

:s

S

~

- S-

:s

(JQ

~

...

:s

"'.

0 ..:

S

~...

c'

" n.

-,

3

:3 a

a i

-"

ff ["

!"~

in~

~ffi

~IH

I"~

ijqlf~

fijlil

~~

fS

- S

- o.

.:s"

"0

0 0

: ;

C

~,

~ 3

e:

~ ~

S ~

~

= c

~

~"

~ ir

:s

~

~,

~r

i ;

n "

~

S"~

" aa

g ~

3 "g

n"

~

e-.

It a

:? s

' 0

=, I

i ...

'<

;'

0 0

0 ri

0..

g- ~

:r

n

0 e:

Q..'"

5'

g,

" ~

"

;-

3 a

aa [

!..

5' a

g.g

"g

0 ri

ao.

.~

. 5l

""

:so~

ge

;;;-

g::s

!.!.

~

"3

Q

0 g-

~ p.

. 0.

. ~

E.: s

- 0

:s

g-.:s

Q

.. 8'

E

5'

g- &

. n

aa (J

Q

= :s'

n0.

.0

"joli

"'aa-

<'"

c::"

";:j'

" ":

S-

aao

aa

aa:s

;:;

~

on

:r3

-"'0

:r

g.

.:s

" aa

"g

~

::r-

~

c ~

3

0..

0..

Q.."

::;

"

o..;;

.:s

~

;:;::.

.. S

-:-"

:::

0

aa I

I':"'

(II

1S:s

n

0 (J

Qg.

~

0"

R a

a ~

0 a

: '<

~

:S;;.

~

~ ~

a

aa, a

a g.

:s

o..::

r- ~

~

~

::t

'" ...

~

s ~

~

:s

O::t

' ii

g ~

aa

;;'

~ a

: ~

2 5

';; M

] 1S:s

~ ~

... It

R' r 0

S

o. 0

n

!!'

g 0

~ ~

~ ~

;;' 8

if cS

' ~ aa

8,

9 ~

£ ~

g a

0 &

. S-

~

0 "'.

.. >

< -

::,

?Ii

aa n

o"'"

0 :s

" ~

'<

"n

~

.,

" :s

-

aa <

:s

'-,

aa

~ ~

~

~ ~ ~

~ g

' 0 ~

r~" ~

g ~ i

~ g

- ~ ~

g ~

' g ~

ir ~

::;.; a. g

':< :'

~ §

' ~ [

g- 0

:r ~

~ ; 5

, g., 5

"~

8

~ e

!, (I)

i

!..!!.

. ~ a

. 0 .

a-~

~'~

, ~ ~

~ :r

go:

s 8 g

&.~

':r

Er S

- = "8

~,~

g- §

:J 8

"-<

: e-. S

-:,

3 ~

3 g

., o'~

, 8

~ :I

, ~

(JQ

;:;

c:~

~

::t'

~ 0

g

-;; ~

~

is

: 0

... [

'2. ~

&.~

. g.. ~

... 0.

. 0

3 3

.F ~

"a

'8

~!,

aa :

s (I

) a

i"~

~ ::

.: S

- ~

ii

...

5'

3 !.

It ~

~ i

s: 0

.. e.

~ aa

'<

~

_.

0' a

a ~

i ; g

. "8 a

;;':-,

£

.a g

~ ~

r. ;-

~ s

;. i

§'~

, ~ !t

~ ~

~ ~

~ i

~ S ~

s ~

~ ~

[

5 §.

5,~

~ g

o ~

2

g, g

S' ~

!t ~

11;

g ~

;:;

~ "

'0 "

~ ~ 3

~

~~

, c:

:: 5

~ n

8 ~

:: ~

§ ii

~

g. aa

~ S-

~ ~

:~ P

. ~ .

.. ~

g::r

So.

~ --

Q

:: ~ ~

aa e

:s

;- ~

aa ~

g

S':S

0

0 <

"""

g-:s

5

~ :::

0.

.;iJ

~

~. ~

=, 8

~ 0

0

;i:S

S

o ;;"

i

:::g'

g-

~

~

g., ~

~'

g- @

Ef ~

' :r a

~ ~

g- g

:~ g

- a ~

. ~ :

;r: ~

~ g

';:

~ ~

~.::

! ~ ~

~ ;;

' a. ~

g- 2

: g ;.

~O

<O

aq-

-'~-'-

'-'n=

Q.~

"""~

"'-""

"'~~

~O

3, .

.. ji'

...

~ ~

S

- 0 ci

ci i

g

:: 8

" ~

or~

: ~ ;

- g-

&.

= .

..

~.~

~~

~:'f

~§.

~ ~

~~

t;a!.g0;

~i.~

t~:

~:

3-~

! ~ ~

§ r~

~5.

1~~

~

~

~"':

r'"

(JQ

0

3:

...

;::

=

Q.

§ ~

1-,

"" -

!!.

.. a.

_. ~

~

n

aq

n;;

;; ~

E

ri:;'

~;

; ~

::

-< ~

~ s

~ ~

...

Q.

~::;

' e:

3 ~

Q

.:!

~

~ ~

=

:r

§' 9.

~ a

n"'..

."'..

.:r~

"'"

~

"""i'

~

""

...o

n .

n==

=

~

~

...gg

ell ~

-,

i' n

...

...

n

'<...

:r

a.

'" <

:-

. -.

;S

, O~

o:r

~

0 0

...

15 '

0 n

n n

'" '<

0

~

"!..~

"'-d"

5i!~

g.n'

" c;

;'~;;:

"="'o

a §c

~o=

:=",

,"

~n.

..o~

n~'"

= ~

5ii

~ ;

! 61

r ~

~ ~

s:~

' c

~ ~

8 ;;.

'S

c:

~ e

f!

~

~

:3 g

..! a :

3 0

E

'"

~ g

~ I

ii' &

. ~S

' 0

"0 ~

" ~

~

",'

~ ~

...

...

0:

C'"

> 0

. e:

~

~ 8

aQ

~ e:

5"8

~

a r~

a'Q

:I\)r

;t.;;!

~

oa

~""

"Q."

':::,'

O::;

-~"'~

"'=:r

""""

'5,o

A

=

"'=...

g 0

~

S'

5' ~

g a

: g I\)

=

~

S::

0 ~

'003

~ ;

-<

c'

~...

~

'"0

8

~

~a~

g-

g s

g 8

- ~ a

g.""

'C"

II>l\)

d<"'~

""

""""

"'Q

°g..o

~...

",

",

=:

~...

=

"'~~

~

l ~

~

a

~

~

~ ~

~

; 9

~

~

: ~

'5

!1

...

~

§ g

~

~~

§

2..;.

a.

n

~

S,

5 &

t e-

Iii""

-,

0

=--

if

~

0.

><

0

~

...

~ -

g :r

...

S

C;;'

~

Q

. 0.

:::

. ;.

a'.

e- ~

~

c;

;' ~

g-

'" &

. S

... ]

Ii of

~

"0

if S

, ~

'g.,

! ~

:::

~

=

~

8 go

, ...

;.:.

S

! ci

~

5'

a

c;;'

~

5';

t; ~

e:

:~

r ~

~,~

~ ~'

g- ~

a,

.. ;'

8~'!

t e-

.~' r

;-

g g

g ~

~;-

g 8'

~;

~~

i 5

~ ~

g-e,

-;.;g

...~

;':~

~g.

i t;:

:!.

o..."

,'o...

A...

o ~

",

1I:a

;'08~

e-$f

c!'"

a.6.

g'~

R

g:g

'~~

~ Q

.g

~!:<

i;s.i;

g'5-

ci'~

~r~

!£~

=.~

;:r

5'o;

'S-,

R ..

. 0

::I

o.~

...

:r

'0

~

- ~ 41

...

~

co

r",

=

~

a <

~

aq

=

/0

, .,

t: ::I

!'!

.. is

: !..

~ >

10 I\)

a '

<

~..c

~ ~

~

...

R ~

;s

, e-

= s

aq8'"

:3'"

A .

..0aq

0

'<1I

>:r

"-'g

.n~

""

~a

::t...

n

"""0

. 0

~

"""0

' -'=

~

< .

. :i"

" 0

0. ~

. a

.g ...

'"

~

:r g

e- ~

...

~

~

...

5' 5

'..

f! S

n

~...

=

Q

. g"

I!!...

'" ...

~Iii

':r;:;

' O

O"'A

,:r~

...'"

""",

...~

...

"""

"' :r

"'::;'

"'--'"

'~".

..n-"

" -',

...

M--

'n

<aq

Oaq

aq"':

:"""

'o

:r-'

8S

'-""-

~"O

'" 0<

"'-

"'-=

n ...

<

:r..0

'" ":

:r"'c

, ""

""0

S ~

3 ~

~

g ~

~

i!

if o'

!1:::

F: Q

.:r

F ~

e- g

e =

=

!I ~

~ 8

g

8 ",

' e

a ..

... ;

;; ;:

2, s

:~3:

g

~,~

~

...

!. 8

~

j: 5'

:C

E

~

c:

a s-

[~

~

g 8'

a

~

c;;'

2..

~ o

g ;

- e,

S'

i1 i

f c

:"

! :.~

. ~

3:

n

~

- g-

~

~

-<...

~

n

aq ~

-

&.

s= n

~

. 5

...

S'

="~

::;

~

if ~

[~~

~

2 1~

'8 S

~

~'8

~

~'

a g"

~ [

E

g"o

a i'

~ ;

: ~

;;

~c:

§ i-

~

0.

S ~

~ ~

~:

f. ~

: i

~ a

. ~

~

i r ~

t: 8,

~.§

~

~ ;!,

~

~' ~

~ r

g. ~

t ~

H

' 81\

)' if

0.

ii'1

-< >

n0-.

~

...

e- =

' ~o.

~

1:;"

0 ...

~

...

!!I

,.g

~ ~

::::

::r =

'"

~

"'.

=-

..0...

""

" ~

""

=

-dij.

.."n

I:I

=;

"' ,0

~

~

II:

-'..

c;.:.

S

! ...

Ii"

S

"'<

"':

~

r:

a

~,

:I.

aq

=

!! ~

a

...

g ti.

=

C

JQ

~...

0 "0

~

.; it:

r - g.

C

T

n Q

. =

a:

:;'

c 0

aq

~

-.:4

'"

...

0 Q

.'"

aq

...:l.

'" ~

...

S :

rI

:: ii"

n

~ -

< =

0

0 ~

0"

'0

~

F

:rg:I.

ci

~

2. a

.. ~

;; F

5'

~

go.2

~ s

: 0. ;;.

. ~

"'::.;

a

...

~ =

'" =

'0

0

=...

...

t:I

:I!3

~

:4

... a

q "S

, i;

..~

...0~

0

a c

3:;:;

- ..

~

;r.~

' 0

5,

-, ~

~ ~

0

... a-

=-

c ...

:3

-, -

<n:r

0 2

I'> S

'~

'i

."T

""

"""

"'(I)

""""

" (I

)~

",,1

11..~

~ =

iJre

i";i~

~~

9- E

. ~ c

..

'"_.

= .

. '"

;5'

'"

IJQ

0)

c 9-

= =

:rIJ

Q ~

::;

.~.

is.. n

~

ns.

.~ ~

n

n ~

Q.. ~

we"

..

o. 0)

'<9-

c .

. n

S 0

ei"-

'n=

;.g=

=

~a

~ 9

- ;:;.

e-. ~

9- 0

)

~;~

a~n~

if~

~ ~

§ ;

. C

;;' if

;n

Q..:

r Q

.. n

5'"

-,!'

-,'<

n

.. '"

0 '"

~ ;

.:11

-.:t

~ 9

-:r

..n;~

c=~

O):

r":r

:;,s

g",

c n

n Q

.. n

"'0

s:

'" O

)_",

,=n~

'n

::1,..

:;,

'"

IJQ

n

;.

;. <

§. ~ g

q Q

..;'

9- ..

n S

~ =

!!!

, n

0) ~

iraog

ao~

:.~

'"

e. ~

9- ~

C;;'

~n

Q..

Q..

:r

0)"

~:;r

"O)~

,<".

.;na

3':::

..;' ~

0 8

c5

_,O

n 0)

~

<!9

Ie.."

'" IJ

Q.,=

/Ac

Q..

a ci

g

O'~

' s.

.:;'

n~n"

::1Q

..-~

~ if

a..

CI

0)

0)-

O)w

=:::

! '<

0)

-.

-,

'"

IJQ

~..~

~~

~-c

0)

n -,

-

'" ~

0)

=

- 0

'" s:

C

;;'

-,IJ

QQ

.. 0)

:;,

_.

~

0,

n~

~ '

" 5

g:F

a ..

....

:rQ

..~

$'a

, 0)

::r

. 0)

...

...

n

0)'"

'-.n

...

0 _.

n <

!9 e

~

w

0)

::;'

... ~

Q..

<'

0)

CT

~-,

::r

Q..5

, n

t; c

=..

n.

:;"...

...

£hf

~

Co)

='°

~ ~ go g i: (') a: n ur :3 ~ ~ :c C1)

a :=r

:E =-

a (if S»

< e!-

o: ~ 0 i» 3" "-.)

Cot

)..

Page 6: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

r ~

:Q

...

'..

...;

'",:

T::r

" C

'

. n

i;-

~

:

; Q

. I

a:

I~

:I I

- S

~

")~ 5 0

, -

~, g

-

~~

'i~

c

~ S

,~

0 :I .

- ~~

' a

li'

.:

;;;'

~t

~r

t~'0

~

ri

g ~

IQ

.

"'Q..~

J0

~

=

(JQ

:::

. ~~

gS

!0

~

j

S Q

CT

!O

...n. :T ~

:

n :t

.-2

3 ~

i~

0

,a-

~ :

:1. i

A'

(JQ

~

:- n

'"' .

A ;

P

:

a...!

l:;-

!..

re..

:0

...

f!!.

'.:=

! :T

= ,

. 8

n :

:t ~

g.

0 :::

.~ .

~

n ~

n!..=

<..Q

..~

~ :

::~

=

- C"'1

:;-3

:::. _

.Cn

... '

"

a~~

o.:t

~=

~

n

a.:r

as'

a ~

...

~

O.

:T '"

~

.'n~

Q..

'Oon ..

c ~

n -

~.

Q..

0'0

=--

§~

~,(

~ ::

r '"

~

.. n

n ~

ri

n - ~:!

~

n

c..;'

QQ

'" ;.

9- n

"0

Q,

I,!

~

~ ~

!!,

~

E

)::;,

=

E)

~

'<

n'

~

ii"~

' n

g ~

n n

g a

0

:5

S'

~

a 14

0'

13

' ::r

~

' ~

'8

!"

~~

""

'i a

~'

0 ~

~

e;

~ ~

e-

.~

; ~

:t, O

Q::r

~

:;'

9- ..

..

'"r1 r:

r e: n

~

I:i

e!..

n ~

0

Q,.r

o ~

2.;;

~ ~

~ 8

g- n

~

S

'.!!,

~ a

",' 0

s' ~

0 '..

. "0

g

::t' 8

~::-

-, ~

'<

~

=

... "

0 - n

~::t

' -,

S'§

-. :

= 0

;. ~

'"

n ~

;

'" ~

O

J ..

"0

<

""".

.. -,

~

-,

~

O

J n

.. a.

a-

S

' ~

~

=

0 ;;

n '=

i)i

' n

...'

~ ~

a <

§.1'"

...

Q,

0' =

'8 ..

.

~ <

sa

n 0'

~

~ ~

~

OQ

~

s'

i ~

0'

Eo

~

9 ~

g ~

'2..;

if

~

...

'"'

9- =

-,

OJ

'" :I:

n

n !!.

c.

.::3

c.!:!

a

~

;;r

~§

[::r

0 ~

J"

;a

g,

~

~

~

~n,

0

ii ::r

d

cr:f

'" ::r

:;1,

~

I'D

~ ~

a~,

~

::t' ~

...

= s

- ~ 0

n'

~ ~

::t

&!

Q,

no"

OQ

~

~

0 :

:3, -,

::r

I't

'<

n if

~

n ~

~

"'~

::r::3

'"

i)i'

0 ;;1

-.

~

~

!l...

0 ~

g:

~

9~

nn""

'=--

d:

:r...

on;.a

--'O

~=

~

'<=

S E

~ n

Jf

::t'i'

8]

~ =

~ a

a :::

n

ii" ~

5:

~

a ~

~ if

c..

a

==

oo~

a 0-

,' ",

~c.

. ~

0"O

...

On

~=

On

t]A

g a

~ ~

~ 9

g, ;i

a. i

f ~

,tI

~ a

~ 13'

~

c.. E

~ a.

!, g

EIQ

~

':r

2, ~

tI

= ...

?

i)i'!!

, 0

::r...

n-

] if~

:::

~

3

~

!!,

0 c'

a

g.,

~

...

§ e:

. 0

ij g,

~

i-- a

g ~

if

8..

::t'

a ;;

0'

~

=

~

a g,

=

(ii

'n

- n

..,

0 ..

~...

n

a_'

-.

~

Q

",

c..

'" C

! 0

s-~

~a,

<",

~~

::r

;'c..n

:ro~

~,<

n oo

o~~

~1f

n ~

'"

n no

" n

n ~

...

'" O

Q...

tI:

2'I

0 n

-.

- -

S'

~

=-

ii" =

n c

<

...

...

::r

0 ...

-,

e!..

~

OQ

0

ji)""

E

o;. '

i'"~'"

~

-< =

-§'

~

n ::;

~

0

'" ~

-.

II>

0

n ~

c'

" I;

::.

c..

~

ri O

Q'"

;:;

...nn

e".

-,

n oo

~"

'" "

"0

g.. g

~

0 g

;; e-

.:r]

0 t

~ f

f a

c..

8..

n If

~ ri

8

~

~

!!.::r

g, ~

O

Q -,

~ '"

~ ~

~

~

~

a ..

n e-

. =

..;::,

ii"

ij!

0 g

~n

=-;

; ::r

;"'O

S

' n

n ::ro

~

~ 0

g

~

a jlf

"O

...

!!, ;

. Q

, g,

~

Q, Q

.

0 ...

n

~

~

"0

'"S'

ii"

'"

"0 .

. ...

=

0 =

~

::r

1,/

0 c - ~

Q.

a tI

I; \if

~ ~

0 _.

0:..

Q,

n 0

E)

-. ~

=, n

j:S

.. ~ &!

~

n ~

;:;'

0 n

t:!

n -.

0 ~

0 !!,

0

-2

9-

n.

e:

i" n

g 8

!;'~

~, ;

. rr

~ a

~ 1

4 ~ n

:I:~

' n "

2 -g

' ~ ~

~.~

. ~

~ 0'

~n

a c.

:;.

n ~

0

.. =

..

~

e: 50

; ~

=

~

0

...8

n -,

§-.

"a

a ~

0

0 ...J..

. =

~ =

:, i

'1 :r

a ~

rr

1:;;

;;'"

;""

0'0

-, '"

a =

::r

. 0

0 =

n

.. e.

. -,

...

~ ~

n i

f"§

9- ~

~

~

a:r

a ~

I;f

~

;; ~

~

s'

0

e!..:

r g

:iI -

, e-

~nn

~"O

Q

o~~

~..

",on

~

o~n_

s="'n

if 0

.. H

~

n

a'

Q,

",;:r

~

"'~

R

n

:1,"

0 g,

/'}

~

c.

. 0

~,~

"0

I: n

n a

<

~

n <

n

!:L o

' ;'O

Q"

=

c,

0 ...

c.

.:2'1

~ .

.~'"

-, ~

0 !'

n -~' a

nt!

e!.. s

..

<

~::r

~

~ ~

Eo if

S' ~

::r

0'"

-"'"

0 n

j;i' =

; ..'

Q

~

n ...

S ..

. -.

'" c.

. =

- "0

...",

~ j

cc.

.o""

" !::

:'o'"

QQ

Q,.,

o...

;;r

::T

' n

-,-,

~

0 - '"

::r g

g, n

nO

:, if

c.. ~

~ .

? if =

if ~

e!

.. ~

5' i

f If

g, 0

!l

";'

-,

...

cr

n ~

-,

- ~

~

~

C

Q

. no

n C

...

'"

~

n ~

-.

...0

W

~

Bc:

:r

n 0

0 ::I

.!!

... ~

.. ::I

" 0

.. 0

::I :

:r -

, ;r

0

.. ::I

0

-f"

.."

::1"';

:; '!:

!. ,,~

~

Q.

::I

::I

Q.

n :3

" ::I

~

~

<

~

,::I

-t

-0

n ..

::I Q

...

" '<

~

II'

;""

-, -,

... rn

-

0 n

n ~

~

,-<

;i §

><

a- S

"0 (J

Q ~

0

2, -i

~ 5

. It- g

~:

.. ~

8

~ n r 2

t g- J

i! B i

f 0

~ ~

5::S

<

'" ~

aI

::I

,pog

::n" - '5

! 0'

cr ~

0

:I, ~

~ i

f is

.: 0'

0'

0' S

!!."

::I

:-

0 ~

~

i;

III -g

3 =

~ g

- 3 3

"~

II)

- Q

.

~ a.

; a.

E. E.

~ ~

.; ~~

.ij iii'

~

~ ~

~ ~

5.:

~ ~

Qi ~ :

~ ~

~ ~

~,g

~ ~

~~

i ~

g. ~ i

~

~~

~ a,

~' ~

~ :::oe:

; § ~

~ a

~ B. i

:;: ~

~ ~~

~ ~ ~

g' ~~

' ~

~ j

a: ~

oc~ t:r

f

~ ~

~

iO

~ i

0 0

~

~

C

0 ~

::r

" :E

n :3

;::;,

~

.. n

C "

Y

' :3

~

:! "

:r 0

:::

'<

C

'" -,

I»

a'

~

;; ~

.::I g

5. a.

; gg

j;' r

i iii'

a ~ g

~ .;

'~:E

a ~

;

&. ii

1 e-!

!. g,

Ji!'

~ ;

. i)1

g; ~ :r ~

~ a

~ ~

..,

~, ~

e- e-

g,,"

...

~

; :3

:5,

~

0 e-

.-Q

~

e: ~

'" ~

~ ~

n

;"

~ ~

~ ~

...

~ '"

~

~

n

C

~

;;S

, e- e

- ~ g

0' ~

a. s;

~ ~

~ ~

g, s

; :E

a: 9

- ~ ~

~:E

Q

. '<

]

~

g:r

~ ~

:: ~ ~

~;.

8 2 ~

S

' .ar

~ n

iii

' e-

'" ..

~

::r

an""

" ~

a ~

" 0

~ 11

)" ~

;;'

~ =n'

e- ~ CJQ~

_.

;; ,"

~!I:

~ Sr~ Q

.. ~

::I

g.

CJQ

-a

;;:

...

Q.

-",

::r -'

.. "

II) '"

::r

~

".

i;, e

.."::1

g

'" "I

I';""

::I

::s

'" 1I

):r

".."

Q

.,"

CiI

...-,

::I

~ 0

:3

a,

~ ~

~

"~.a

0

Q.

-. ii

i' ::r

c"

...

~..:

:;'

=

3 rn

III

::;

. n;

; S

' n

~ § ~

if fa

:::c a

~,~

[i,

~ 8

~ ~

0 ~

~ ~ ~

~ a

' i ~

~ i ~

~ [~

,~ "3'"

~. ~

~ S

F

~ ~

0 ..

...

!!!,C

JQ ~

0

II)

...

II!

, ::-

5

11):

:1

,. ;r

n

~..

,,-'

:r...

::s

-,

rn S

' .::

;' '"

- !"

t....

~ ~

n ~

~,..

:r

5' I.;

!!!

. 0'

(JQ

go

, !!!.

"tI

~

S""

;; :

::I

C

:E;;:

g.

. n 3

F- ~

, ::I~

<J<

I ~

>

0'

g =

~

:r

;' 1I

>1

;r a

~

.. C

JQ ::

:- ~:

:t:I:

:-.

~ "

::t.

0 ~

C

JQ :-.

~ ;

. 0.

.. ::r

0

III "

'<

~

... ..

'<

n::l"

0

~E

: e- g,

~

~ ~

~ e-.

08Q

. ~

II)

~

g,,~

';i :

E ~

e..~

!n' n

S

: g'

= e

.. ~ ~

0

t;. ~

~ ~

8

~ ~

Q

. 5.

~

8::1

!!.

II) a

'" ~

O

'...:r

0

~

~ :

E -,

~ ~

: ...

;-

.. 1I

)::r

, n 0

sg Ii

;=;';

' a

8- ~

Q

, ~

..

~ -

< iii

"~;;-

S

' o";

~

0 ~

a

if;!

;- g

::I ;:!

it ~

. ;i'

a. ~

8' :r

~ 8

g ~

:r

g.~

~ ;

:i'!!

5'::I

!;!

~ i

::I

0::;.

...

n

::I ..

E; ~

W

i !:f

g

::I

""

~, a.

~::I

::s

~ iif

Q..

~

i><

J<I

t'I

CJQ

Q.

iii'

"Q

. 5"

i if

~ Y

'.g

:4 a

- 0 ~

e:

~

c:S

, :5

, e-~

a 8

' S

0' e

:; e-

. ~ ::;

' g'

::s

~ g

' ;.

a 8

e- 0

;;

~

:c~

...

"'"

0.

..,.,:

:1

Q.

'" ~

:I n

n ~

"0

n

oe:"

e:

:r,

Q.

11 t

'I ...

3

::s .

. 11

~

~

(h

~~

s:

::;'

O'~

go

'" ~

S

!:f

a:

a.

~ :

~:E

8

!i a

~

:E if

~

9:

...

g $J

t

A ~

~ .

.. ...

to

'" ~

~

~

g:r~

E

1o"'!

!.&.~

Sg!

!, ~

oll';

""::1

~'8

~g

~o!

!.~;"

o::=

,~8f

1i

§;.."

O

~>

<..

~ ;

; II'

;""

'" 5.

~ 8

~ ~

;r

!!. :3

~

:E::I

~

8 ~,

~

0: 2

~ ~

:E

~;!

e..;'

~ a

~ c

;:; ~

~

']:IE

::rga

O

_,B

-::I

~o"

'e-

:Ee-

°"'::

I'"

a-S

-~"~

B

Er'<

"'C3"

:::

;:;

~

'" r:

(11

e:

:: g,

ci'

1;;, g

. -'::I

i3

~ -,

n :E

, ~

Q. g

!' !'I

I n

5' :

E '<

""

:r

0' ;:

.. x ~

~

~ 0

' s-

jt,!

I!I.

'5! "'~

e-

~::I

(J

Q fir

" 9

e-.

e- ...

G

o '" 5

'='-

a: !!

. ~

'" 0

"0

::r

0 0:

: i)1

0 '

<

~

~.O

.. ~

Ii.

-

0 <

" "I

I)

~0

-, a

. a. 1

e:

...

1l C

JQ ~

0

n;;.

~ :

:I ..0

" ...

:;':

r 8"

-::s' e:

:r...

:::

!:!

i3..

...

_::I'

~~

-,

n -

::I <

II 0

0 '"

::r O

S

::I..

-, e-.

::I

"

-.

'" i;"

C

'. w

o 0

-~

~

i

::r:4

~,

::;-

~

~'::

I g

S-

iii'

~

~.

ii" Y

' g

~

~

a:"8

'"

~

'" ~

i;

9- g

0'

C

" ~

0

~

~

<'"

w

~

~

a C

§. a

a"

,,:::

e-.8

a

~ ~

~':-

';:;

~

0..

g !!!

,] g,

5-

3 ~

" ~

'a

::: Q

g:,,

<

;; !:

.§-.

~::r

!it

~ a

;;,g~

it!

g,-

<

;; 8

a ~

r!'

~ ~

.~Y

' g.

II';"

"CJQ

~

~

~ S

~ i-S

~o:

~

e:

9 §:

.. ~

...

;::

;,~ -

'X

::I

"c

~...

g

-'::1

n

" "'.

.. -:

:s

It n

'<a

!!. ~

~

fj"

ri: -<

~'O

j"!!. ~

g

0: ~

~ if

Qi j:

II) !t

!!.

ii1 -6

-

~ 7

~ s

: aJ

~~

g a.

';'

~

n ii. 3w ~w

1

."

Co\

)=

:N

Q

e' ~

8 _§n

2 ~

Q

~ ~

~ca

'J

-'"

~...

:T

...~

" ...

>.,.

.. '<

~ -

=

' ...

:-' :

r n

0 :r

::t.

e-'"

...

!"

" 8

='"

go

<ttl

;;':r

,0

1:1_

,

g~

n=,

~O

so.."

"

., .,

::I,'"

g"

t;:

r :;r

-

" "0

11

~

~

01:1

-.

I»

'" =

' :r

;:r

-, 0

='-

"0

o..~

'" "

~ ..

.'"

CJQ

("

')~

"-'.

.. 0

~

i:f,"

'n"'S

'~'"

~

a:.

<",

~

;::

;:=.

~

(')!!.

~

So"

e-!

!""

" S

!':'

: :-

. 0

0 "

i%~

. 0.

. =

nC

'" ""

" ...

::0'-

~ -~

0

N...

o..~

o~~

0.

. ".

if 0-

if:

::!. :

:I, ~

$I

-'"

-, Q..

[:r

- -,

5'

=0'

"'"

"

0'"

~

~n

0 o.

.:ro-

;::t

05,

~ ~

g '<

Iii

a.

o:r.

.. ~

~

~=

' ...

-,

-,

5'~

~:;r

=~

CJQ

0

~

8'"

Q..

=, a s

Q..

0' a

c:T

~5,

~

...

. '<

~

"no

-!

~

.. ..,

"::r

~=

'1i!~

~

s.."

~

e'

0

a.

R'

~

0':1

"0

'80

='-~

I\"'=

' ~

~o-

,...::

O'..

. ::r

...~

='~

cj':r

!l

~

5"'0

:o

r,"

!:Ta,

CJQ

a

~"-

~

~0

~"2

...

n

n -,

='

~:r

o~

...~

...

-,

" a

~

;;'=

' "

::t,

~

"i)

::IQ

.. ~

g

~

a 8'

~

~

:1

!!.

a 1;

;' ..

...

E3 -- ... ..

.;.

;-'"

...--

'"C

lQC

::;n

9-9-

~ ~

...~

~. ~ --

W -I ="

CD :r - i» - 0' = I» :< 5' - CD -a .... ! C

I:0 =

Page 7: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

<

0 -,

<

d 0'

"S

' ...

I\>

'"

-, Q..

-, 0'"

<d

I\>

~

C::"

'O

. . ~

n:

:l . 0

0

:j1\

>0"

"""'(

\ O

on~

n::ln

'" ",

;;r::s

-:1"

'I\>

O"O

O

::r::-

.::s

go

go

~

oq

~

t:!,]

'" ::1

'1

~

- e:

~

n

"0

~

~

~~

...

~

-

c:s

nQ

.. Q

.. ...

;;r

::r...

0

-,

0 ".

.. (')

(\

n

... ~

...

-,

::t'

n d'

-,

I\>

0

::r::l

;

oq

=,

Q..

0 Q

.. ~

-,

8

'" Q

..:--

~

Il ...

::I

Il

~

:1,

:3~

-'~""

""'<

dn",

...::r

t:!'c

<-"

"I\>

::II\>

o~

~

0'

"0O

"e:!3

1\

>.'"

!""

" !!.

.gO

oP:::

;:...i

ti...t

:!,o.

..,g.

-'a-,

:jc

l\>~

~ ~

::s

' f'D

::I

::t' Z

~ ~

Il

E:..

g, ~

p: ~

Q.. &

: ~

;: if

f'D ~

'" ~

~ g,

S'

-, g

., S'~

~ C

: 8 0

~ g

~

~,::

s Q

.. g :3

~,c

'"

::r"O

8 ce

, =,

0" "0

::I

oq

~ C

oq 2"

. '" ~

,Eo

~ ~

&! S

c:

'" 0'

":'

0 g.

g,

g. ~

p: a

~ ~

~ a

8 0

'" ::;

0

'" ~

= Q.

. c:

:.;:3

J:; g:

0'"

Eo '<

0

(;

...

::s

n I\>

'"

f'D

0 -,

'< 0'

"...

.....

g.f'D

o:

:r

n",f'

D(\

f'D

<I9

"'::r

:3

O'"O

::lI\>

:3o-

::rg.

f'D S

'" O

'"g ~

g-~

Q..g

.Q..;

g 8"

~r;

J'g.

n g.

n!i'"

::1

~ ~

'"g g

e 0

f'D

(; ~

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

.a a

, ~~

""'.

if:3

~,~

~

~';i

§

;: 5'

a ;f

1;;' 2

~1;

;' ",

'" '"

I\> a.

'" n

S' =

~ -

, Q

.. I\>

g

~ f

it p:

:3 oq

C

S

:::I

::I

g. "'"

::I

I\> I;;

,g'_

,~

eoq

~ C

g,

a:&

~

I\>

~

I\> 0

"'-

,;,~

...

8;'"

'::0

&.

::s::s

n f'D

...

!!.. g

. c:s

p: ~

0

...

0 ~

::t

' C .

. r;

' 8"

'" ...

0 "

0"'"

Q

..~'

~ -,

g. Q

.. if~

...

~

g 5'

0

~ go

f'D

g.

1;;'

~ ~

::r

'" if

~ &

. ~

~ a

: g :3

.g 5

' 5' 8

g. ~

f!!,'"

g..g

p: .

.. ~

8 n

;'

~ ~

g. g

. Q.. ~

a: a

~f'D

o~

oqQ

..f'D

(\n:

:l::t'

nOI\>

e-.I\

>...

c"

:;rf'D

n~nO

~

::I (

; ~

~ I\

> e

-. 1

;;' ~

'" ::I

Ii

g ~

:;, ~

:;:: ~

g-;

; 'E. ~

n (;

::I

p:

I\> ~

1;;'

... a

go t:

!, ::;

: 0

-,::I

8

...

.. f'D

0'

Il P

:::r

; I\>

C:::

-. 1

;;' ~ :

3 ::s

0 "

0go

C ~

;, ~

~ g"'"

~

g ~

g-

g.

R

'; 0

g ~

~

~

~

0'

" ~

::I

!3

5'

C

.::

~"':

:;r:;'

I'O'

::I",

of'D

n!

l;;

'n::!

..(\_

OI\>

~::S

~c

I\>n

:1

...n

ag-

a'"

Q..<

""

"of'D

I\>~

a.t:!

,-o

'~-~

::s"'o

::;-

~'"

1\>

1\>

,",

CQ

.."O

-'I\>

1\

>0.

.."'-=

'<

"'I\>

~'<

~

e f'D

::r g

.::s

J:; ~

g.

n 0

' 2, ;

:: sr

- fl,

:3

0 ~

::s ~

" ::s

~

c:s

0'"

o-J'

" nf

'Dc"

""

_,0_

",-

0 ::1

0 1\

>01

\>Q

..-~

Il

S,::

t' ::I

0

::;

g-

e:

g.,::

S

g Q

, g

~'

::I

'"g

~oq

a

~

C

&.

~

~0

'" 0'

"~

C

0 f'D

-, -

"0

I"j 'E

. ...

::I :

:s .

.. ..

n g.

~ _

,;;r

0~

I\>C

~::I

""""

f'D~

"""0

0

Of'D

~O

I\>O

o::r

::lf'D

--'t:

! ",

1\>

",~

~I\>

f'D""

" ::s

...

~",

f'Doq

:1O

'"::r

~

0'

0 .2

::I

-';

if 0

A-'

~

~,

~

g. g

o ;r

~

-,

:;.

0

'f'D

~

e-.::

I ~

s'

C

~

g.

'" '"

r;'~

' 61

~

~

~

1;;'

~

;g ~

I\>

~

p:

t fit

t::::.

..;;;

I\>n"

",..-

,n!..

' ",

::r

'" O

'"-'-g

.=...

8 f'D"'"

0 I\>

~

~ ~

Il r

g;. S

Q.. rl

-, I\>

=

~ f

it 5'

a

~ g

g ~

n ~

p:

f'D""

'O

nnC

:"""

"I;;'

::I

Of'D

"0

"""

- "'8

:3

::I

if]

a,~

'<

"0

~

~

8

::;

~

:; I\>

is

: ~

g.

'"

5"0

g.,

1;;'

~

,., 05'

n'"

"'"

o""-

'(\~

1l

c "':

:;'..n

O"'-

_"'1

\>~

~ ~

n

c:s ~

'"

::t

'" e;

g.

~ "0

~

5'

0

'" N

' ~

~ 2

=

&. a.

"O::-

.a

"'1\>

i3~

0",~

' f'D

1l0

onI\>

O'"n

",~

f'DS

'_'O

'"~

~ e

-. g.

§'

;;J

0 :3

~

~-;

:-.

&!

'" <

d~'

~ Q

.. ~

9 .

P- g

. ::;'

:',o

q g,

,<

n0

O"t

...

<

d f'D

~

n'

0'"

~:s

f'D

3' 0'

"0

...0

...0

.. -,

...

I\>

!:!0

...

"0

.. 0

_;;r

c:' "

~

- I\>

-,

-,

-...

, ,-

nn

-

""".

.."""

""

"

- °

~

~_n

."lII

n C

OC

""~

~;;:

:Iojll

;;O-

g:"'8(J

q::r

...n

::I::I

n ::I

,(

Jq~

n

-,

III

.. ..

.. ~

'"

~

0 ~

~~

!t~gg

~.e

-.ti

~=

~o

'<i

I: '<

i ~

:-

~

0'

g

t. ~

::s'..

. "5

!..'

..:

t '

..,

...

n ;:r

(J

q ::r

°

:r5'

00:r<

:81J

"~nO

n.

..~r:

:r~

::I

-.

co"'"

r::r

::r'"

no~

n-

"~C

~

~"'

3;:0

""

:r

0 :r

0.

. :r

n

'" ~

...::r

",~

~"'1

;;'!T

' nE

i' n'

&;'o

~:r

...

ce -,

n :

0 (J

II -.

"0

~0.

.'T:I<

.::I::

I c.

. o.

.::s

'

E.,O

;;n(J

IIIJ"

-Is:

::r

000:

;'o.

.ctJ

Q

n...:

:r

n ~

C"O

n::ln

lll;n

nco.

. ~

~O

:;.oo

..nn"

'On~

1;;'

~...

f!!.o

::I

n 11

10

!..::I

0

...

'

.."'-

§",

::111

1-'

OM

""'-

111"

'- -,

_0..:

:1

...0-

='

S

'"0.

.::1

0:

-.

::1

n =

8

::s

~

- ::I

..

n :t.

n"

o ~

~

III

o..:r

g:

~ ;

; 0

c."

~ g

_::t,

::I

n ,,0

..::I~

1II

~(J

qno

o:;."

,J!"

::IIII

"'e..:

:;'"

0::S

..nn

0.."

,0'

'" ...

::s'"

ifjll~

g.gn

..."2

o ~

~~

"'::1

",

'" &

.:;.::

;' <

C

I -'

~tig

"0..g

,,on0

5 ~

"'a3:

:1

n..,~

n""'"

::!

ooIJ

" n

III

II!

<:

-.

0 ..

o'

0'

:::on

..:

r::l.

..n

'oJ

::-.:"

jIl~

,~(J

II;;..

.ii!

~C

~no

S

:t.

if ::;

'!l

~

.. -<

fl

sn"

,n<

...~

i:I~

2 ...

"""

;;-::1

~ n

::;'::

;' e

IG ..

=--

~

0'3

~

~n

On

1;;,:

r '<

i ~

e-

~

C

In

<:

0 ""

,..,'

0S

-,o

S

~ ~

... n°

~

'<

; ~

S

o.~

!it

'" n

-, n

Ei' ~

-,

n 3

...8

c :;.

S J&

s 8

R ~

Ii)

C

~

~ ~

n

nl5

':::

.. 0

S'

~

<~

::;

,:;.

g 0.

. ~

1II~

:;r

~ r::

r ~

;:::.

0'"

n..::

1 0.

. "

-,~

!,<

i ~ 0

Q ii

0..

ii'

O(J

q~..

=:r

0

3 '6

' 1:: -

~ ~

C

:r

'<I:r

1J""

::I1I

I"0~

!!..

30n

n n

-,

0.. '

" :;r

0

0..

3 ::s

Ii)

...",

nn

1ii'

n -,

" ,.,

r:

:r3

,., '<

~

~~

i5'

tn 0 'C ~ '< Qa

en g Dr

C")

... a:.

n C;;"

3 N ". ~

~~ ~;i

...

n

O'~

~

~"0

n

-....

..II)

0

~ ~

0"0

::I

j;)...

~if'

"...

0

II)

::I0-

... - ::r

!' n ... II) 0- !'

0'3=

2"

'e; <

£ >

c:r=

=

0-"

"C

(1;8

1\)

='<

~o"

'"o~

3

- I\)

<

' ~

=

Q

.. Q

..,.'"

:!

e-c

c:r

..,.,

C

A

- c:

r ::!

A

oc;O

(\C

«J::!

""A

e-::;

:I\)I

\)O

5"""

'" ...

A

i)'"

jI)

~

=

::I...

,O

Q

3 0

Q.."

" =

-""

I\)

=

A

Q..

<

A

""'A

"'N::r

~i"O

"=",

Aa.

':t~

Q.."

'=I\)

I\)C

"""C

-<£

~=

""'E

.(D

a."'A

","'E

" -

0 ;;.

.. <

0

...

Q..

0 C

(D

' I\)

Q..

cd6a

A~

=~

ifA

~""

~ ~

. - a

' n ~

. '< ~

~ 0

...

go 8

..,

a.

I\)

",...

O

"'C

~~

~I\)

~I\)

..,cS

""'~

=::"

"0°

""

nrJo

c;=

-:;"

l\)n~

A

C

'TJ "

0 ::r

OQ

A

::r

I\)

A

o Q

...",

'" ""

A0

, jI)

,..

...

(D

;;:

e..

g.

<

...

O'

A

r;'

-.

5'Q

5.

3 =

A

3=

=

I\)

3

~1\

)0_.

.,1\)

!::1.

I\)

R-"

'Ao

;:rl\)

..,..

Q..A

I\)a

e..

"'.

C§.

A

A

~ '

<

(D

~

,p..

"':-C

:"';:

:!I\)

",S'

cjq:

e:oa'

3'"

-.::1

",

.. "0

.

<

]'" ...3

'E...

, n"O

e-

~ C

e;

~ 0

_. A

..,

A ..,

!:j (;

!..

..,I\)

0.

::10

0 ",

"0

1:'.

A

I\)~

."t

c::.:

"'O

A

~

<.

° =

.::r

A:;<

:~=

'::I'Q

~

~l\)

c.'"

",

I\)

_.I\)

",~

"gQ

..I\)

;:;

. e-

rot

A

~ :

:;: a.

e.. °

c:r

OQ

A--

'o~

A

O-'a

.-3

..'"

=",

~:I~

OA

(D

~ ~

~ ~

Rag

0

a. e.

. 0 g

(\-"

'0"0

""

'OQ

.."""

"

"'o~

=O

'a~

q=~

':!.1

\).

A

OQ

..,

~

ro

t j:

5' °

OQ

..,

6' ~

~ °"

0'

'" e-

'" g

::rSA

.""

E.l\

)g~

~s.

. ~

..,e

5' 2

U;;-

!l. A

.. 5'

8. ~

~ a

g.

'" =

0

j: r;

' 0

I\)

S ::

rOQ

~. I\

) 0

~ .,

I\)

E

r=

OA

O-"

AQ

Q'_

.A=

",R

~

=

=

Q

.. 5'

:1

::r:l

OQ

Q..

rot

.. c~

!"~

'",R

e~~

~5'

-':1

I\)

0'"

A

n (D

..,

~:I

_.~

C

1\

).,

~

:'3

0 I\)

"'0""

..,

~e

°A=

=~

';'I\)

1.

J!'~

;:;'?

Q..~

R

.. -f ::r C1>

Q.

C1>

- i» - S'

= I» -<

-'noo

n~~

n-A

O

<"'n

"Oa

~~

,n

<~

1::'1

;;""

a ;

0 ::r

::r

0 ...

>

<

A

$I)

.::;';

"""

a a

::r

0 ~

;;>

0

0 -,

-,

~

3

A

A

0 :;:

"'0

~

:::-:

: 1i

rJ

n

A

~

c::

0 ~

, ;:;

' 0

c::

3°;;>

"'e

-.~

-c:

:Q

..~"'n

~

::r

",oo

""

;;100

11$I

) ~

;:;

- c:

: '5!..

:i ~

~

,A

e!, ~

-;

:;'

n A

...

<

-

n' ~

A

0

g., 1::

"'0

... e:

0 A

-~-'~

o"'~

:n

Q..-

"""'"

n.

;;>

«'I>

A,<

0 ~

A

~

,~

=-.

=

0

;;I

='

A

Q..

0 "0

0

co=

- a,

Q

.. ~

...

~

~::r

o"O

~Q

..'.O

A~

",A

n"'e

-~;-

~o'

.<

,.=~e

n~

;;r

...' n

=

:

;:;' 8

'" ~

01

1 A

...

;-

Q.. - 0

- o

.S::I

Q

.. ~

A

::r

':< ~

0

=-

A-A

'. :

0 A

~

""'"0

-' ""

"""A

~

'~

..:"

'I A

'"

<

Q..

A

0 -,

e-

° ;;r

=

' 0 -

: 0

_.~

, C

"'

~

;i ..

'"~

",

""

~...

0

A

A

t:I 0

11 5

5'

0

'" 0

e- g

A

0 ::r

'"

0 ~

0 ::r

-- :

:;: !l.

0

C

011

~...

, ~

~

A

Q

.. '"

...

0 01

1 A

~

0:

:10

~

s.:

~

~

5';;

0 c:

: '"

0 ;;r

0

~

...'

0 Q

q'

'" A

n

I!:

~

~

~

A~

~

;:;'

A

ei'

011

A

...2.

'"

=

A=

.;'"

n 0

::r

0 0

0 n

<

...,

0 ::r

~

::r -

, :

0 Iii

...

...

C ~

...

' -

0 ~

...

~

0 0

~

'" Q

.. -,

::ra

;; !l.

:: 5'

~

~

§ [g

, ~

~ if

g, 3

~~

~

o' ~ <

[~

~ :

5'

0 ~

0

n '"

"'::1

~

0

...

C

(JQ

e!

.. ~

_.

-,

...

=.;

;:;'0

11e-

3 s"

" 0

"0

!1 Q

0

~

n a,

&-

::r-<

" ~ 0

0

0 I!:

0'

3 - ~

~~

n

'" ~

~ ::t

".-

, :,

~

a <'-<

~

g 0

~n

1::'

Q.. ~

~ n

' ?i' ~

3 ~

::r

n '"

n ~

'"

0 I::

.n

~

c::

~

;;> ~

n

~...

A

A

~

n..!

!: ~ 3

0

"00::r

1;;'

011

: ~

"0

.., Q

:...,

0 8~

if g

., a

S 01

1 ~

::r 0

~~

~

""

"""'n

"'-"':

~

...

~

an

n '<

c~

~

~

Q..

0 n

::r;i

A a.

a !1

3 r:

::r

'" r:

::r ~

-

e!..

A

0 "O

~

~ ~

I!:

><

!1

~'&

-- fj

!"

a. °

~ "0

... ~

0 ~

g- 5'

~A

a

J, a

. p,

5' ~

;- ~

Q..!if

...,o

~o

r:::r

oA~

<Q

.._,c

::A

e-~

'" -~

~...

.g

"0

~

CO

lI...

~ '

<

~,a

, ~

!1

J! ~

s: ~

e- I

o.S

::I ..

.' a ~

"0

!1

~ 0

...

Q

Q..

0 n

A

a,.

...' c

An

n 3

3 ~

...

~

~

Q..

§~i~

g~~

f~~

g ~

~~

tgl~

:~~

~~

8~~

~ g

. a' f

9 !~

' ~

;; f

~ ['

§,2,

3 g:

g &

. ~

~

~ S ~

9~

~

~

'"

~

~

0 0

0 0

0 ~

-,

~

'" 0

r:r

A

c 0

~0- g

::r

A ...

' '<

o~

, ~

~

:-

;.' f!

:..0""

~

'" n

00'"

~ a~

~

0 ."

tn

- ~ ~

n

,. -,

3~

' ~

::r

...,"

"..

~

:;;

~ ~

3 ~ ~

if ~

e!.. ~

0

~ e

-. 2

.. 0

~

~~

, 3

0 e-

e- ~

3 ~

~

n'

§ 0

~

c ~

c

?i'!1

~

A

~

. g.

, '"

o.S

::I ;i

~

~

' e-

5

~

;"0

C

c:

: ~

'"

~.

~

a,

II)

~

e-.

Q..

n:>

"0

...,

0 ~

,e-.

0

n ~

0

...n

;-

0 ~

0

~

0 -

~ n

;;.

; c::

'" ~

~

0

~

<

n""

...' 1

: '"

0 ...

~

~

I!:

0

0 0

c::

if::r

;::

n ::;

- S

o_,

n '"

n ::r

...

0 n

n "0

...~

0' i

f A

~

a. g

a ~

§

a S

~ 0

~

~ =

- ~ ~

<§:

~ a

, ~

::t

~ ~

...

-, ~i:

: ~

0

...,

~

;:;"

0 8

;;::!G

~ 0

~

n

!::!

~,O

en

9-

- ~

°Q..

::r::r

"':

:r

~cn

oo

n::r

;;1

00

~~

s.:o

;;r::t

n on

_~~

oC

JQo"

'n~

~o~

!1°~

~n

_.

...

non

c::

~

0 ",

::r

~

n i-+

:r

0

~'A

'"

~

:r

~~

<

<

Q

..:3

Y'

Q:

~

0 ~

Q

.. ~

g

~

<

0'

~

::s

S

-..0

-<

!:!

~

n~~

CA

~

=-.

0110

...

n",o

nO~

O...

",""

""- ::

:-: ::

:-: n

Q

.. ~

::r

Q

.. c:

: r:

::r"',

~

n

::;'

'" _ 0

"""

n ~

C

::::r

~

Q..

Q..

a,

::r ~

...

' ~

-011

- -

~::r

~ ~

~.

<II.

.. '"

-, .

.., -. 0

n

<

~

(JQ

A

::r

~

~:I:

0'

::r

0

n n

~

n n

3 -<

-< :

:I 5'

::1 n

i=

!'

3 ';'

~

~ n

~ .

., 1;

;' n !

" ~

';'

';'

0.. ~

:i' - CD

-a ... ! - S'

~

Page 8: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

~ 8

= e

-:r ~

...=

illS

' 8

~

a. !.

a e

'] :r

~ =

--;-

:; Q

... 0

-1!G

8

?f;'

a s'

~.

~

~ Q

...~

~

~ :

r.!l.

~ =

g n

9 i-+

III

. =

- -

1:1 "0

'" 9:

r ~

= =

;~

=

_. n

~

~;:;

=

i" :r

III

"0

0

~

~ n

0 o.

:r

n <

: n"

~

0.

II)

"T! - :

-. o'

It :t

, <

: S

2...,

~no.

:t:

=f -

= i

~

:rn;:r

:r

01

1 - S2

.. c

0... "

0 0

III a n

"T!

-.

-.

0 ~

0

_.

-.

- ...

n:

:r

n -

Ii)

=

n II)

~

=

nO

n

~ g=.

i ~

if

~ ~

~ g='

~

it! r

8 ;

g. ~

c;;' ~

~ 8

~

j' i

~ c

: S

. ~ f

=.

~

if ~

a-"

:r: r=

'g. aJ

oe.:

. ~=

-.

<:-

. "

O~

=~

"""-

' o

a""

'n=

OO

n .5

\1II"

On-

. 11

)0<

11

"'....

.:r

. III

S

' C

;; ~

n

n e-

.!!!..

-

IT

=

0 J'

-<

' =

"0

e.

a~

n

n S

' 3

=

0.

~

3 n

...

II)

III

~

~

=

n Q

.. III

...

..~

Q...

o'

-~ g :: ~

n

;i II)

'<

~

- II)

~

a 0.

II)

3 ~

III

OQ

~

!!!.

. ~

~

"0

Q...

0 ~

. =

~ III

~ :r

e' g.

II)

~

s- =

= ;-

J"

~

g n

.F

II)

0' ~

!: ~

.a "2

S

' =

11

=--

;. 0

e-.

!!!.~

e:

a

_a' "8

~~~

i. - ~

<

t>

~

"0

...

=

:r

n n

~:r'"

~

-. -

n...

~

= ...

_.

0

n ;;:

~

-=

0.

" !!.

~

--

=

01

1 it

c!

!!!.

~

- 0

0 °

1:--

<'

aII)

n

0 ;:r

=

0.

;:r E

'"

= n

=

_. 0

III

~

~

OQ

= n

~

1:1

~

n

a C

3 "

fa]

5:~

~~

.~~

c;;'~

~

~~

~~

'ifg.

g'r~

.~~

t:g-~

~~

t; ~

.~.~

~

~~

~

~ ~

~0

~ "

2 8

~

::: I

ii ~

n

=

0 ...

!!!.

. >

Q..

!r-

=

~

C c

::r

==

... =

. C

~

Q. =

=i

~.;:

;- _

. 0

"8 ~

«'

II g.

; S

:r

- 8.

.fl!.

3 n

a =

ir

II)

0 ~

Q

... 0

=

~

~.::

n 8

&. =

~

~

~

e-

. ~

~n

e-. ~

II)

11

0 ~

a

~

8..~

. ~

::!

. n

n

;:: 9

:ro'

n ~

er ~

~ ;-

0" 3

"0

~ Q

.. ;:;:r

' ci

: a a

~ oe.C

~

~

~!'

i S

~ ...

= ~

.a :ro'

a:::

~ n

'~.;

a o=

~ 0

= ~

-

n =

...

-.

;:;.

C

<:

n ~

...

a. ~

n

'OQ

i;!

. =

... III

n

=

Q..

a ...

;. ~

E. s

;:; .a

~ !!

!. a

~

Q...

g.. g

~

;:;.

~ 2

: a ~

S Q

.. g

.0 ;

~

;:;.

g ~

e

~

~;

8 5

IT

11 ~

'i=-

~II)

Q

. II)

0

...

...

3 !!!

~it:

' "0

'"

n C

! C

;;'

0.

= 2

" II)

IT

:;'

11)

S'

II)

:I.

~ -=' ~

~

~

-. '<

QQ

'...

~

0

=

(I>

C

n

"0

. !II

<

: -'Q

.=

:s

-.

<...

_.

0.

~

8 ~

~

~

g.

. -"

0 II)

a

~ ~

"0 IT

;:t

IT

=

S'

0 .:!

S

'"

a. =

II)

.:!

;. =

~ 0

a if

n :r

; e.

::n

~...

if=

Iii

' ~

it'

<:::

s.

.!"

a'"

a n

;:rl\.

OQ

OQ

a.

O'..

. ~

gO

Q

3OQ

"'~

ir=

&.

_'2'

2.~

11

~

o'~

8 i~

' ~

g'

a

~.~

.] I[

as]

i ~ci

[;.

g R

e. ~

: ~

i &

. ~ ~

~ Q

... n

~as

~. ~

Q... g.

~g

~ ~

~

1\

(I>

~

a n

~

~

0 g-

a: =

~

= :

r n

~ II)

~

Q

..:::

n ~

n

~.~

.:t: e

- Q...

:::

o' ~

!!!.

. [ :.

n

a ~

8 ~

. g

~}-

~

g'

a

9 :-

;. ~

go

if ~

~ ~

:

~ ~

:r

g ~

: ~ 8

; Q

... ~

~

g.::

g ;

~ fl

&.

:~J:

Eg-

l~~

i~

! i8~

'r ~

~i n

H~

;r~

~

H~

~

IH~

~t

0.

C

=

'<

!II

Q.:r

n

~

-.0.

n'

<

1:1

n II)

~

0

a ~

~

=

-=

C

~

:r~

~

0

...

II)

0 'S

. -

~ ~

Ii:

-;;;

. ~

.~

2 ~

"~

~. ~

s' 9

&

S' 9

~. ~

g:

;: o'

::;. ~

g

~ ;

.~.

~ ~

go

ii! 8

.. ~

::i

: :

; ~

go

~n

~

~~

n.

; II)

-=

:r

.(JQ

...

!';;

,rt

8 '<

=

n

=

:r

~ ~

"O

0 ~

n~

n

...=

:

"0

if ;.

~."

a.

~ '"

~ ~

go

r &

. [5

' t ~

~

~ ~

1 &

. ~

g ~

~~. ~

g"

~

~ ~

~. ~

f ~

~. r

~.

9 8

~ t

='~

. a-

~n

n ;;;

. ~

<

~

~

g ~

II)

0"

~

1:

1 ~

...

11

-=

::!

. n

II)

8 "0

"0

II)

II)

Q

.. ;;

= ~

8 ~

!!!

.. II)

~ ~.

: go

if s-

: ~ ~

II)

~

~

g='

a'

ii!

go

g ~

QQ

' S

' ~

a [~

n a

e- g

. ii!

. ~:

~ ~

er a

:r

a =

< - n

~

n

1i

110 -

!.t

J"

0 ~

~

n

:r

~

0 "0

~

~

n

=:;

a 1:

1. ~

0

0 n

C

<t>

n

II)

1:1

n

go g

s::;

>-:

:.. ~

S

' ~

1:

1 ;:;

. e-

~ -.

g II)

~

~

IT n

«'II

~

~...

g

2 ~

. 3

~

1:1.

° a

~

1:1 a

~

II)~

' C

;;'

S"

~

:r

&.?

~

g

;;;. ~

9"

~ p

' &

.11)

~

~

S'~

~

~. S

' Iii

' g

!!!...

? a.

~

II)

g ~

Q...

~ ~

!!!..

~' a

:~ ~

~ ~

e- t-2

~ ~

g. ~

~

~. i

j ~

f :r

g a

~

g ~

g i ~

g ~

2 ~.

'8 g

~ g

~ ~

[ :r

~.H

~ n

J--= It

:~...

...

~ 9

'<.0

:J

...j

It C

o rr

n'

'"

0 I\)

j;l

a ::

r...j

t;

a j;l

~

t;

:J ;

'::r:

J s:

'" t;

...j

0 n

g S

' ~

0, n

j;l

t:r

C

~

n'

..,

C R

- 0 I\)

~

:J

n -"

0 I\)

:J

0 ...

c..

1;;':

J:r

~ aq

!:t

c..

~

g. ~

'~

E

Yl' ~

~ r~

~.

~ ~

~~

. ~

aqo'"

[~~

~

a ;

~

~ ~

;

e.~;

~;;

~ §

~ c

i':r

e~';' ~

~ ;.c

i' C&.

~~

n

. a

~ a.

,rt

n 'g

' 0

n i)

~

1lI:J

n

' 11

> ,

Q

.. It

...

..'

n ...

::r a

0 '2

.".

.. a

;T:J

;-

5!

~

0 -

e-.;i

a.

I\)

~

0 !fO

Q

8 ;.

II>

I\)

~

a. ~

s:

~

0 e-

. ~

~

ag

0

n g

! ~

~ ~

~ [

9: 8E'"

; ~:

~ ~

~ r

~,~

i

~ "

O~j;l ~

~'

~ : ~

~

. ~ e

:.!

~'a

~

~

~ f

~ ~.

f!

i ~

~

an

tit

~"O

n

'..'

II>

I\)

<!!

I;)

'" nO

n J"

II>

n

"0

~

:J

~0

...

e-.:J

c

::,

"0

...

n...

I\)

I\)

if.

.. -

9-

n :J

n

<:

::r

~

cr:J

c.

. 0

"0...

...

t;"

0

0 ~

It

,rt

...

;. 0

n 0

:r!:J

en

...

~

!, -

::r,

g ::r

!, I\)

n

'<

~'~

<

!! ;.:

:;'

~

~

<!!

~

C

...::r;;'

...::

r~

t;"

::,

0 2-

1\

)'"iE

. i)

n "0

iii

" n

...

~

~

1\):

:; n

a.

<

...

... <

: n

"'..,'

" <

:5

~

1\).

.,...

II> "

""""

"""

"'i

~

~..,

1;

)' n'

I;)

~

1:0

=

::s

c..:J

;T

It:r

::r

0 C

::;

'...

II> :

:n 0

0

~

~

~

n ::s

<

n ...

~

a

n a

-..'

cr

if::S

0 !..

:,.

c.. e

. 9

"2

a ::;

' a.

1\

)'"

~

n "0

=

O::r

;. :Jo

C

5!

E.~

n.

_0~

0,

I\)

~

g a

a ~

a

;. ~

'<

:r8:

J ;;.

:J

n n

aq :

.)j .

, 1;

)'"

~

II> .

.. '<

1\

)... -

Co

- ~ ~

..'

< a

. ..

~

!! n

a."8

.

~

t;;'-<

' e-

. 0, ~

",

a.

~,

Q

~,

~

~

e j;l

!

a :J

n

-<'

C

"0

~ :

:r~

. ~

'a

~

g !..

e; .

.., a

go

n II>

=

.'8

a;1

"80~

0 ~

g

EI\) e

cr;i

~

~

~

Q,:J

n

0 "0

-,

::;.

n~

=

~

n ...

C

!"

n a,

0

O:!.

2"

. ~

~

Q

..l

y>

I:

..'

'::S

0

II>

,"0

'<

..'

~

I\)

!. ...

"':

:r:J

II>

I\)

I\)

Q

.. n

C

II>

- Ii>

0

' -

II>

Q..

n ...

n'

"

'" n

C

- n

",'"

'S

:r

<

II>

-,!:t

...

...

n

- 'n

'" II>

:J

II>

'<

..'

<

.

er

~

~

~.~

r:

ie:.~

nh;-

~

H~

H

~H

~

~H

~

H~

~hu

~.

f~~

;-c

5! !

.,..,

0 (J

Q

;;.O~

.r

: ~

I\)

c

:r... '3

~

'"

- ~

a.

Er

C."

;. 0'

c

c!

~

II>

s:::r

~

5!

e' '

" g.

.. a

.'T

R

~:J

",

""01

;)'

~

(JQ

n.

.. ::s

..,n.

., ~

""

...

....

~ ~

8 :

; e-

.;i

2".;

g- ~

~

~

~

a,

0'

~, ;.

f ~

I\)

;;

~

:3 g

~

t

=

~;i

~

g ~

~

~

of ~

~ r

;; ~

1'" >

...

...

:J

C ~

...

::s

~

...

'" ;:;

""':3

C

!

=-:

:s

Q.. 0

..'

0

;. er

0

'" C

o..,

...

-,

n I\)

c.

. '" g:

g ~

~ ?- ~

2.

;. ~

.1- ~

~ ~

a::

~ g

~ §

~:~

~ ~

e;:,

~ $

-? ~

~

;-~

. ~ ~

g' ~

~ ;

~ §

'::r

g :z

:~

!:l. ~

r ~

~

It ~

;- ~

!,

a, J

J 3

s n

~

:r

0" !:

B e

. 8

~

§~,

~ g

~

~

a'~

' ~

a

s.

~

§ ;.:

; a

~

5e.

§'

~ :

;. i

: f

g "' a~

~ ~

~ s

~

~ ~

i §'

~'

9- R

~'S

~

§

~

~

e-. ~

§ "0

~

S'

~

0 ~

a

~ ~

8 ~

I.. n

'" c

n ~

"'~

, ,-

1\

)' n

co..,

~

S

' Q..!

II I\)

"'.

.. i)

~..,

n 'a

.(JQ

:r

'" ;-

0

C

t:r

'" g

ii 0

~~

. g:

=

g ~

0, ~

g ~

~

g

g, g

, =

] 0

1;;'

~

:::

~

;-:J

~

~

n ~

<

0

f;-;;

~

~

~

Q: ~

~ ~

' j;l

~:

!. ~

~!"

!reg

. ~

:: O~

!. a

; ;

~

0 'g

, g.

;:

if ~

s,

:r

5' &

. !,

~

z.::

0 ;i.

g ~

§:

~

:r ~

fir

~

::r::S

- ~

"':

:i C

o..

n cr

~

~

-

= a

:; n

n 0

~

0...

... c

ern

n :J

e

-. 0

- ..'

<

I»

=-

~ : ~

~;

~ ~

~

'r-

a :

g ;

g ~

: R

'; ~

~

'a

8 '£

&

. g

2' gO

' ;.

g ;.

~ ~

~ ~

] ~

' ~

, ;i

B'

iIi>

<:R

""""

" ~

--

"'"

I\)

'" ..'

"'.

.. n=

'"

"'1\)

'" I\)

-

~

'" ::;

'::r

n s'

if :r

EI ~

!:l. "

2 ~

{

s' 0

' E

I 8 V

I n

It I\)

~

E.

::. ~

"2

n :J

II>

~ g

::n

8 ..

. _:

:, ~

ii

t; n

Q.

I\)

I\):r

;-

er

I\)

n

I\)

DS

I\)

0

"""'

~:J

'" ::!

, ~

er

n

Q..

0::

n ::,

...

I\)::!

>

<...

:r

0 0

<

Q..

0 :::

I:'"

:J

...

u =

' n

n n

~

::r

S'

~

~:3

n!

:2

...

~

n ..'

g

-.

er

:J

0'..,

n

C

:3

<';'

n

...

n O

Q:J

;.

n i)

C

'<

I\)

Q..!

it ~

::s

';'

';'

iii

" '"

~

.r-

~

';"

n ';'

.?

-

n'

n !.-

<'..

. !

!.:J!

. !..

n

n n

n Q

.. 1

~

n'!..

n

';"

ill

s:

S1.

II. 3w '" ...

,.

.

dJh\

Co) en

.." =.

0" en 0 "0 -= '< QO en g j»'

("") a: CO

)0' 3 N ~ ~ -

00'

.. ..

II> R

g ~

§~ II>

~::I

:r

a. ;:;

-\!!

- :r

~

;:;-

'Ni;;

- ...

C ~ '" 0 3 ~ :r 5- (JII

"g.

II> '< 5-(J

II S-

A "0 II> ~ 0 ....

II> ::I II> ~ ::t o' ::I '" ciii" ::I

Page 9: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

U'I

C')

0 ::I C')

C en S"

::I

;i ;.

:r g

' ;i

n ~

~ ~

~..,

n n

nn

-,~

II>

~

11>

.. ::t

.OII>

=

~

=

0

0 0

g:O

Q ~

= ..

_. 0

-.:r

~[g

-if~

~~

..",~ ,::

r~::t

~

0 n

~

0'

5 d6

5'

g, ~

~~

"II>

--'"

::;

::t

, n

n "':

1 0

~

o..~

~II>

o.O

Qo-

o..

nOQ

o""'O

0'<

0;'"

""'g

-=n;

!fiaa

8n

...,"

=en

o=r"

on=

="O

i:~

..,

..,

II>

C!,o

q'

~

a.

o'=

::r

':t

0'

=

OQ

g~~

..o~

~~

g-II>

=

~

..

~

0 :-

'~=

..,

e

!' -,

~II>

~=

-:r

II> "

'='"

~ ~

_.~

f;

~ ~

cii!

nall>

0...

0

:!,~

!!!

if

0 "'.

.,c~

o.~

g::;

o.<

~..

n ~

..,::r

~

2 [!n

.n::s

..

..,::t

, i

~

?'"~

~

0

p..::

;,;n«

9-'

"""O

-'~~

°:IE

:IE~

,~

..

II)

~

~

n e.

. Q

a

~ ~

:::..

~ -,

(JQ

n~::I

::-'~

..n

~I'D

I'DI'D

~",

:::":

:r-'n

~p.

.o~

"' j~

::r..,

..,..,

n ~

~

jci

i!::;"

"-'::

I;;g:

:r=

n::l~

::!,"

'fG~

::I::r

~~

~-<

"",,"

""~

~<

8~~

gr~

~~

n::r

..,nn

o~~

"'~~

:::!n

~::I

~

'f"O

n_,-

'&r"

"::1

-~::-

';:1;

'::'"

p..n

-'n..,

9 '"

::I

-,

-,

~

~

::r

e-."

O

~

~

::;'

~

(jq

~

0 0

'" "0

e-

::!

::I

p..

~

n -<

~

::!

,::;'

"'"

-,'

::!,

s:!

0-n

..,

n In

q

n ;:I

-,

0

::r

<;

~

~

-;-

~~

8~&

i~~

~~

~gg

e-~

~~

9'"

:! 8

::I

~

~

::!,

~§

'::I

e:

~

0:

;"'0

g

::2

::r

~I'D

nn

,n!;l

::!,

~"O

~

~

"'n0

p.. '

8 ;;:

5

~

~

0 Y

':;'

0-

en :

;r

fG

Q,

0 ~

~

n ~

'"

;::r

(JQ

::r

"0

::1

'<:

n 0

a'"

-..

'"

..,::r

-,n

n..,~

o..,'

:t -,

n

~-'

n..,~

"'~O

O..,

::2n~

n

w~

'"~

0

0 -<

~

'-:!

~,'<

: -<

' oJ

:)

~

~

.g

"0

~

~

;' e-

n ~

g

~

::r

0 ~

5'

q

~,=

'"

~

a 3

~

- ~

8 ::r

;:;-

0 g

;;-

'" ;;

g n

8 'g

, ~

,"O

~

~

a.

:,0"

'0-.

I'D;:I

~"':

:r9n

~0-

~..,

~

-~

~

i3

<

~

~

n ~

"g

' n

~

(JQ

(i"

'::;,

0 "'"

~

,-,

n ~

~

;:In

=::1

-,

-' ;S

~'"

"g

;' '8

::-

. ~

=

, Q

S

;;

5'!1

;:;

g

'" e:

::r

n$2

.. -

=

e-.

&.c

ii!

n::!,

::I

~

.!!

I (]

Q

~

g..

0 e-

a~

"0

'"

-<

~

"0

0 -

w

...

-~.

~

-,

=:;'

n~a

",0-

"'=

~::2

n~n-

-"'n

9 ~

0

~

5'

S

~

0 8

~

g;~

g

~

§ §'

-<'

~

3 ::;

- -,

Ii

~

(j;'

-.

~

~

n ~

;;

g. p

.."O

"0

::r '"

::r

9 ~

':I -

, q

::!, :

::' n

~

::2

:=.: n

n

0~

on(j;

'~o'

::I~

n=

-.o

~p.

.:iI~

~::I

e-

'<

: ~ (

Jq -

- ~

::I

q

~

-::!-

'::;

' -,

n

~

~~

~

o-

?'

~~

;; ~

n

:IE

~

<'

g:e.

. 0

-,

'" '<

~

n

0 ~

a e

- ~ ~

p..~

n n

g.

~

-:!

~

'" ~

(j;

' 0

~,

e:'

A...

~

5'

:-,;:

;

<n

nn8

nn~

o-"'(

JQn

~ :

:I g,

,;:; "

0 ~

0'

0-

Y'::

r ""

::1

~ ~

"O

' ~

. Ii

i3 "

0 ~

~

..,

5'

p..

~

e:

e-.

p..

5 ..,

;:;

::2

~

n &

r' ~

g

e-

()

Q

a '"

::!,

- (J

q ~

~

e- ~

'<

n

'" n

p..

~

'" 8

0 0

0'

(j;'

~

..,

n ::I

-

n n

=

.., n

~

::I

::;'

~ -<

::r p

.. :IE

::I

f~

'"

0"

~~

'"

n n

-,

0 ..

..,0

'<

~

::I-,

(Jq

-,"0

~

<

-

~

r:.

08

8 "

::I

~

(Jq

11

;:I

!!..

tr

::r

~.

-.

::I

~

~-

q ~

2,

S

0 ~

~

!;;

e-

e-

~

e-

~

;' e-

9 p.

. =;t'

I g" j"9

::1

p.. I

'D n

n

::I

n ~

..,

n

Si

p--':

I: ~

s:

;., a

2'" :

:t<:'

O::t' :r

~ 5'

~al»

9-~

' 8 ~

9-

9- 9

- I» ~

~,

r::r

~

::;' 9

- ~:!,a

~9-

2!..0

'~9-

a-o

~""

o"0

0Qn

Ool

»nn<

:Q,

°nl»

nnn

n"""

OA

-'

9-s'

~a

~11

1»';

a..,

;-~

0Q0'

r::r

0..,

;'~

'r:

:rI»

~0

:3n

"0~

I»~

=0

=c

-~§=

n'"

~~

g,I»

~I»

9-cS

=Q

..11

=eI

.~

~e-

.-9-

~5,

~a

;;i

nr:

:r~

~~

§,=

r::;

'~~

Q:~

....

~'

a.~

~~

=~

'"~

na.

~,

~~

,;;;'

",'

n"=

;A

n~

7"~

'<

:;;-

;;;'

~S

ie:

5~

OQ

~;;;

'"0~

~~

g-~

,~

,;

::;'~~~

'1?

~

a. g

g

g. 5

~ a

'E

g'

g' ~

~ ~'

Q.. [~

~

9- ii

g.

~ ~

s:;.,

~ e-

.] 2!

..l

~

9-~

g

0)

Q.. a

'" 0'

n

> A

~ ;

. ~

~

a $

~,=

,g

~

~, -

, g

= n

~

~ ~

2 I»

"0

;:; Q.

.;--"

': =

g

~

ig-~

~~

=~

I~l»

g~o~

n=

Q..~

~~

Q..~

He~

:~~

I»9-

I»e:

:Pig

cit~

~"0

:!

'" n

CO

'" n

"0

~ -,

= <

: '"

'" n

n ::r

0

i::: ;

;;' - ::r

::r

g.:!

n

n::;

0 n

C

OQ

""~

g- ~

g ~

s: i~

~

~ §

' ~ ~ ;

. ~ S'

S' ~

~ g' ~

; ~

~ 5

' ~ ~

Q

.. ~ a.

.g g

' S

=

g ~

~ g

~'g

0 o:

r'"

e-.~

I»-"

':nn-

'5::r

0,"

-",I:

, o-

o-';;

;.,nl

»gl»

l»'"

e;O

.,=

r\~

~

~.2

::to: ~

:r

~

1f~

~

's' ~

~ ~

~ 5

5 8

a':;

: ~;-

a.

e-. ~

a ~

' 11

g' ~

&.cR

1f

~ n

=:'8

g.

a~

A

n"

"O~

O-t

Pn

n-'<

""""

"II»

,n

~

""'"

",=

n _o

::r""

=i:!

!"'t;

,0

=

11 ~

'i;-

~ .

.., ~

:4

~

g. 8

=

I»

fi' ~

.., Q

.. ~

~ g

8 :

:r e

; g- g

. Q

.. e:

..:.

~

",'

g. 0

1f

~ ::t

: g

...~

8

I»

n "'~

~

:~

5 ~

~'a

n

$ ~

r::r

~~

0 1!

~

0

n 6'

§

~

i:!!,

I»

~

~"'O

'c§

Q..

~

~

~ 8

<:

g ~

~~

~

g- t

8 ~

~ ~

§ ~

~. ~

S ~

~,g

o .g

; a

~ ?

S ;;

;: ~ i

!!!,

a g

n~ ~ ~

go §

e ~

o ~ I»

~

~

e-.~

~sL

~~

~S

I»~

~~

J:;

g~~

:~~

'~g~

~R

s:

;.,g.

s:;.,

~a.

tg;~

e-.~

~~

~

~ 1

fn'J

6 1f

11 ~

9: 8

. =

S'~

;;-

q

0 I»

~

~ n

~ ~

3 ~

Q..:

:;,

2:~

e o::r

::t'::

;.; a

::;,~

.2

1;' n

0 A

0'

~""

':3

n '"

0 '.

0 c;

; =

:

n ::r

0

I»

Q.. -,

-,

",' .

., 0

=,

0'

Q..

C

Q..

~

5 ~

0' !:

8 g

n 0'

~ 8

If.

s:;.,

g.

a 8

. ~

~::t

' ~

~,=

- ~

i:!!

=' ~

~

~ ~

~ [

e 1f

~ ;

~

,~'

~ ~

.."

n-'=

na!"

'!..Q

nl

!:p"'n

..,n

0001

»1

nn

"001

»-""

0_

8A~

l»

aOO

e~I»

g.~

~:4

gl»n

=

C

-q

~n

~

A""

"~1f

8""I

»",e

~s:

;.,~

&

. 0

..., ~

C.:

a, ~

,g ~

0' E

~o~

.Q

~ ~

:ie:

a.::r

;-::;

' ~

'< ~

;;;' "

"o::~

2

<: a

a ~

e:

g

~::;

'(D%

II>

"""'l

»n;:l

::rO

""".

.,;:1

-'~

::r

- ""

-,0

a::tI

»"O

nnn"

"n'"

0 g

s' ~

"0

0'

n ;:I

Q

.. g.

;:I

0 ~

5 I»

0 8

2'" n

A

I»

s.. '

" ...

, 0

~;

nO'

=--

0

I» A

- 0

C

q sa

.

~

;>' a

0 g'

~,

~~

~

~' ~

~ ~

g, [§

g-

s

~ ~

s &

. a g

~ t

!. ~

;;- ~

~!t-

5: §

, s:

;., ~

'::r~

i e.

~

~

-C""

'" <

:1»:

:r;;!

"';:Io

;:l~

C",

""

C

,n

'<I»

n e-

.°::t

:-

"':O

OQ

::-.o

A

. <

00

a !"'!..

s:;.,~n~ A

;;;' -,

~ ;;

C 0

~ g

<;0

~

0 I

::t, g

g. =

,aq

~

:::::

~ 0

' n

Q..;

;;;

,;:1

Q..

2 n o

;r

..,n;

;;T"

"'-"'O

<:"

""'=

S'

."'fI

O>

""

...,

o_-,

_nn

nn=

OI»

- O

QC

...c

m::t

Q

..;:In

~

c~on

l»l»

""

-"':r

::rgo

I:'

Q.."

'I»;:I

"';

:10

e-'n

",cn

n'=

;:1

..

~

~ g

. a g

, ~

-=

i:!!,

8 s

' a,

~ a

~ ~

;:

~ 1f

~ 1

f;n g

8 ~

;:.. ~

g;

~

'8 F

n a

~

:.P-

'" a,

~

ur55

' g,

~

i

~ g g

'~, t

~ ~

~,l

~~

, ~

~'i

E ~

~ ~

g,~

t ~

~ ~

g &

J 2.

8 ~

~ ~

~'

;("

"I

0 O

Q I

» n

n n

::t

I:'

Q..

'" n

n s:

I - :::

::::O

Q ~

0 .r

;:l

"0

~

n ""

'" ~

-, n

-,

=

t:.-

;:I

n=n

~ ~

0

= ~

~ ::

r ~~

::r

£rS

' o'

~'

n .,

8;:1

'"

Q,..

. .,

c a

~

q s'

~ =

g.

. I»

~ '

" a.

E

I»

::t,

:::;:I

na-'O

10

>1»

=

,"""

'I»

nn""

""~

O

"""'o

""c

, ;:I

::r

::1:

1.

::-'~

ooo'

~=

li)iic

g.A

"";;

0g:"

'::r~

~1f

::r

'8

::r;;.

.,1f

g..o

;:ll»

s'r;

'::r

'<~

~

~?~

=

I'a

I Q

..O::n

",::;

";'

""""

1»~

,,,;:I

=~

0 I

~,;,

~n;

:l::r

n~~

;::O

Q:r

~

Sl

= 3"

(0)

"~

CC

.

Cot

)co

""C

:=:

~ ~ =r

'< QO

g $»"

(")

==

(I)

ur 3 N .110

~

~ s

~

:r

g.

s

g. ~

:3

~

~:I:

I 0

~.

3 '"

~ I»

e-

.!!!-

~

:l1»"

,~

n::s

-

OQ

:!.'

" i;'

O

Q n

~<

:r...

0.

...0'

!1.

",

...

3OQ

~

'<

~

g ~

if"

O

",

-'-""

"'1»

00C

§ 5i

~

C

o::s

=

ii;:

",

:!.

~ :r

-.

g

:I C

:ii'::

I'<3c

...g

'N

co...

"'~

:!.

~

&t

'" I

0 :I

...

0 .

'"

",

...

0 ~

; 0

n(jQ

",

~

-.

., 0

'~n(

i'<...

:1;

Co'

3:

re-.

II>

CoO

Q

~",

",

:!.

...

I»

",

:I I»

-.

0n

:I 0

0 :I

3 5!

g;

c'

!. 5'

~

~

Co:

:s-"

,OQ

...~

~

~

~~

~

~

. 2"

.

:I ~

...",

<

n

-'...

:r

0 ;."

, :r

:I ::r

0

-.

. n

...

",

~

"' I»

if ~

:s

~

~

:I

~c'

8"'~

Iii.:r

",:r

:lifn

C

o

"'ne-

.",:r

::s~

&t

0 :!.

C

II>

~

_.

~~

ggJ~

",(i

t""':

1 "'&

t:lc

co-.

&

t c

'" I»

;::

:r~

-:

I n

3 D

. 0

!:::fr

g !!o

S 3

3 II>

...

co

::<

...

...

~ '"

~

a: C

' 0'

if

:r~

2".g

:..."

51O

Q[g

."'~

§o::r

~

3 n

Co

"00

C

-.",

0

3 ~

if

~

~

';'

7'

0'5

~S

'8

~;i~

= ...

(Jq

~

_.

~

c 0

0 (J

q-::S

::s

'll-

<!!;

;.~~

:""

n...

...

_.

~

::s

0 ~

!".

~

_.

'II

t'f1

c:r(

Jq

e.

~

n:S

o3~

~,<

~t"

""""

II!3

:S~

_. _

. ...

Q. ;.

:s'O

!3!3

~~

<nS

n~~

c ~

n

~'1

1...(

Jq~

=--

I::'1

1

s-~

~ s

Ere

-.~

~(J

q 'II

_.

Q.

<tJ

~

;r:s

...

<

~n

......

0

n ~

::;

: ~

!l. j

i)'0

'II...

;r

~-

!3 _

. ~

~e...

.~

n:S

~

~:.

0'<

t(

t(Jq

'll'll

nC(J

q:J(

Jq

~

~

(I>

:S<

:rd~

:S""

"Q..

~n'

ll(tn

;'~~

Q.!3

0

Q.>

<

n =

--[4

-.n"

"'~~

:r~

1I>

~

~

:J.

'II

!3

~

~

s..

!l.~

C§.

~'g

.~

er~

. ~ S

8 n

0

~(J

q

8 n

C

""""

-.

. . ~

~

:s

goo:

:c S

. !if

~ ~

. A (

t ...

~

(t

n'II

ji)

"'"

-. ~

~

0::C

:s _

. ~ :

s '"

::s !3

~ ~

. ~ ~

~ t!

~'O

n~!3

niin

~'"

n'"

n 'II

0

_.a

'" ~

'O

:::. 'I

I':s

a.~

n

~ n

'<

~

:s 0

'IIO

~

:s~

~...

!3

...3

0 =

~...

-

~!3

<

:j I;~

er

n'0

~

~

""'"

-.:s

0

0 :s

n

~...

!"

!3

:s

Q..:

S

~

~

C"'O

Q."

"~...

n ~

on:

S

a 'II

~

:sQ

..(Jq

g. ~

...

n g

~ a

::;

'II.

e-.

!!...

'II

n Q

. 'II

'II

...

.

Page 10: - 1;;homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/validity-claim.pdf · 8 S ~ 5' ~ g- ~ ~ a: SF 8 ~' 8 ~ ~ ~ e 8' ~ ~ t:?. S ~ §"" g., ~ ~ ~ a '8, ~ n ~ eo ... ~ '" it C'" SIl g.. - ",' ~ a c

-- -

--

--~

~..

~N

- 0

~

~

~

~

~

.. ~

N

-

f~il~

fJJl

tJffi

~_~

~f~

~tl~

~~

ll~irr

f§~

irfr~

~iJ

" C

'"

It ~

"

]I t!'

I"

It It

'- :T

-

.. -,

!l ::s

-'..

0 0

Q.;Z

"

It - s

;-

Iii

1";' '

- <

I: :S

:::T

It

It "

~ ~

~ ~

.J~

a ,

~::s

- <

5 ::s

a 3

g. Q..

~~

' a'

;; ~

~ I

f ~

E

o -:

-"

~

Q. e,

6' ~

f5.. ~ ~

!L~:

e:

~ IT

= i

::s"

'" ~

::I

...

~

~,

&F

~

it'

&F

=

~

::I

...

; no

?-

!' ~

'"

!, Q

.r:

1;!~

if

~

/1:' I:

if'-"

Q

.;-

~ 3

:I:

)C

15';:

:T.

n a-

~

::,

a-.

.

7' >

oJ

::I

II>

""::;

' C

J!I

a.

a-

0"

~

:i ,t::s c

:"

"."

~

'"-,

n;z

"~Q

It - 0

It

"-.J

""~

<It:

:! 3

;i...

It

:r

It ...

"'C

:I ..

l...

::s

-;

;: -"

0-

~

-6

- a-

'" ~

:;,,;;

'.;t

~

~

0 .

~,,;

n'

-,

S'

~

::!::s

0

~

F-

t7:I

3 ~

ii'

'&

F~

' o.

~

':'"

::I

- "

~ ~

'0

"

0 -,

'" ...

<

It."

...

~

0 ~

, ..

~

::I

C

a-g,

S

,..

:; 1

~ r ~

~

- j

~ ~

~ at

.:.

e,

ift

-<

~ ~

it

;. ~

;i" ~

~

~

t!'

I8

r-

c:,

!f a,

51

s ~

~

~

- n

~

i :r

~

--

"~

~

":r

~

!!..

3 c:

i ri

..::;'

!4

Q.

1;;'

~

Q.

-,

It 0

3 '<

~

..

Q.

3 Y

'

1I~

~:"

no

~~

'~

~,~

;l~~

sa

t:c§'

~

.2;:o

~

<I:,

~";

f~~

§:'?

~:.=

"'C:IF

~ifg

:"a

!J".

II>

~

...

, ~

::T:r

t'<Q

.::T

7'

::1

"::I~

:r~

...

II~~

-.

c~~

"-'.

ri "

i"°C

~

: ~

i

.g

~

~

e:

.:,

~ ~

~

~

~

:I:

::s ~

,,'

~,

=':

~

~...

8:

;' ~

if;

z ~

s;

. ;. 0

11

~~

;i

!' ~

."

::s

Ii" - 0

..'

Q.

...

<It.

. ~

(')

..

It ...

1"

;' C

'\ '"

Q

~O

oci

..""

;:' - ~

..:

1 01

] ~

if~

, ~

~

g...

;

c:

~,,~

~

Ii.

.. '"

ra

=

;.1

:r

~

~:

s, ~

~

a

~ ~

6.

~ S

~ b

".g

i 3:

~

::;'<

3!ii~

;i:l,(

')..

jie,:'

:1~

'" e.

~

'<~

~!C

'2..

__n:

-~"'N

OV

l!tC

..-O

Q~

-,?,

:~...

'" '"

"l1

:!I

Q. -,

<

1::1

~

'<

'"

a",

- .

I::

'-:r

~

::-

fii'

-,""

;:-

~

... :

~

<S

i! ~

,g

, ;i

i '?

§ ~

~

~

~

if::l!

f S

, §;:

E. t

Q

~

' ~

... 5

;' ii'

a

I': '?

!t

g' ~

3:~

.. ~

.E

S' ~

~

,,~

Ii O~

- ~

fii'

Q"

~

~ ~

i;.",

g

R'

0 ~

m

~

~~

~

I~

tII

e

!: =

1~'

It ~

/Jii'

" Q

0

Q

'<

.. ~

,-

..

.. ~

- ...

::1

,-.:;

..,

,-'8

S'!J

Dr §

' ii,.

. S

, en

;f'::,

F

~

g ~

g J

g ~ ~

E ~

o~

.g

~ :

:- §

, :I:

~

E"-

~

~,c

Q

ii

:;,IJ

II !:

!i!

"Ii

.. 3:

IJII

~;:a

.

'-!

'" ~

-,~

':::

;j - g

, 1\

"""

'" It

.. 0

ii 0;

y.

~a.

;';.1

' ...

~

~

if ~

3

~:i'

f

:s:: ~

0 r

;. en

' g .' ~

~

~::s

~

,,?

p.. if!

f fA

Z

~

;; '"

_:i'

" .

-, Q

. 9- "

'1 ;i

~J ~

C

'\ O

q 5!

:>

E

I °

~

i-~

.. ~

-

- ~

tI

fA

0 .,.

, =

ri

~

111-

~ ~

i' ~

~ j

' a

~

~~

~

l ~

i ~

~

~:;

~ ~

g S

, ~

'~

5!

i ~

~ l

~

I j

~ ~

~.

.. ~

E

. ~

8

':"'. Y

. '<

~

5'

t-! ~

::.

~ ~

'8

~

i' ~

=;.

~

a ~

':I"

2. ~

::s

':i;[

... '?

:::

~ ~

. ci r E

I ~

~ S

, f ~

~

?-.

~

g ~

2.

- <

fi r.

' 0

?;

~

I ~

~ ~

'" 5'

G

: a

~ ~

~ a

. ~ <:)

~

~ ~

~

0:1

~ ~

:.,

~ i!

~ l

~ ~

n' ~

~

~

."

~

:r n

ia

~.

a.' .

t ~

'~'1

~~

~~

, .~::s

~

. g

~

~~

' ~

~ ~

i ~,~

, ~ ~

~ ~

'a' i

,; 8

~ ~

~II>

..

"[O

n.

all

fii'

§-~

~ 1

:',

~ 0

..

it ~

n

fA..;

Z

t..

,8

g-

:r

If-n-

;:;

S3~

.'..~

::I

~

1i

Q.~

"".,.

..O

!:!

-%

:toC

:"o.

e:"

3c:

. - c,

'g

.. f

Ei'

15'

. ..

~

:r n

n (')

ji;

' 3

'" ;:-

:I:

Q

:!,

~

~ --

'1

; ."

g :::

~

~ e

: t"

a f

;z

~ r

n ~

~

2.k"

~

:r'2

.. ~

'<

~

g.

~

..".

:I,

3:

~S

:: ..;

n',

0g

I:>

~

;i ::-

15'

;n

'1t

S~

C ~

~

Q

'"

t.. ~

15' ![

~

i

'":r

~

:r

-:-

~

os

.::

! ::s

- ;t

C:, -,

-,

e, -

- ;z

...

-, :>

;z9

:>

.. ...

.. "

,'"

, Q

" .

Iii

...

n <

II::S

-

'<

:-

~

Q..

::s

.. .

'. '<

~

NN

NN

.I..>

N-

~

t::N

N01

1 ...

,~

~

~ ~ ~.

~ :: ~ a.~ i"

;i !\

Eh'

"'tI" ::O ~ "0 ~ QO

& E!. i £L 3 N .. ~

N""

'"0'

4)00

... ....

:c CD ~ ~ ::r a C;;"

S»

< e. is:

~ n g) 3" .~.. ...

.


DLDpvlo-kop.dld.go.th/pvlo_kop2561_2/old/Monthly trial... · 2019-04-23 · 8 g 8 g 8 8 8 8 8 8 g 8 8 g . 8 8 g 7. 8 8 g 8 a 8 8 g . 8 8 8 3 8 ci 8 8 8

DLDpvlo-kop.dld.go.th/pvlo_kop2561_2/old/Monthly trial... · 2019-04-23 · 8 g 8 g 8 8 8 8 8 8 g 8 8 g . 8 8 g 7. 8 8 g 8 a 8 8 g . 8 8 8 3 8 ci 8 8 8

Documents
Product Index - ASCO Asset Library/Fluid Power-ChapJ-Coils and... · Seals in NBR (nitrile) G 1/8 G 1/8 34602181 G 1/4 G 1/4 34602182 G 3/8 G 3/8 34602183 A Plastic body, adjustable

Product Index - ASCO Asset Library/Fluid Power-ChapJ-Coils and... · Seals in NBR (nitrile) G 1/8 G 1/8 34602181 G 1/4 G 1/4 34602182 G 3/8 G 3/8 34602183 A Plastic body, adjustable

Documents
lancaster.ne.govlancaster.ne.gov/clerk/agenda/2017sm/170831/claim.pdf · lancaster coun'iy sheriff dept pkt ctrl nbr 575 south loth streei' atin: accounts payable lincoln ... 7911mb

lancaster.ne.govlancaster.ne.gov/clerk/agenda/2017sm/170831/claim.pdf · lancaster coun'iy sheriff dept pkt ctrl nbr 575 south loth streei' atin: accounts payable lincoln ... 7911mb

Documents
Webulous.net - Fabulous Wordpress tips en trucswebulous.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Getty-Images-claim.pdf · Compliance Team u helpen bij het verkrijgen van de beeldlicenties

Webulous.net - Fabulous Wordpress tips en trucswebulous.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Getty-Images-claim.pdf · Compliance Team u helpen bij het verkrijgen van de beeldlicenties

Documents
7 S= =1= g 7=8#S=J#8 7#G S 8S#=8 · j ;;;; ;;;;; } }

7 S= =1= g 7=8#S=J#8 7#G S 8S#=8 · j ;;;; ;;;;; } }

Documents
a J 1==/#8 =J - arthritis.org.nz · #8`#S S#=8;S=;S / ;G JS;#8;J N J " a ; J ; ` 1=G#8 ; 8; GG;S=;NWGG=JS G =G1 ;1#`#8 ;a#S";#8-WJg

a J 1==/#8 =J - arthritis.org.nz · #8`#S S#=8;S=;S / ;G JS;#8;J N J " a ; J ; ` 1=G#8 ; 8; GG;S=;NWGG=JS G =G1 ;1#`#8 ;a#S";#8-WJg

Documents
Z |j Z|~ ~ |~ ~ ) 8 G|b} j G

Z |j Z|~ ~ |~ ~ ) 8 G|b} j G

Documents
Moskorze · Ill 888 88 888 sass a 8 g . 8 8 g g a 8 g g gags . leÆeaed P!zpzcu

Moskorze · Ill 888 88 888 sass a 8 g . 8 8 g g a 8 g g gags . leÆeaed P!zpzcu

Documents
3-Axis, ±2 g/±4 g/±8 g/±16 g Digital Accelerometer ADXL345

3-Axis, ±2 g/±4 g/±8 g/±16 g Digital Accelerometer ADXL345

Documents
COMBINED SUMMONS - NewERAdownloads.newera.org.za/NewERA Amended Particulars of Claim.pdf · COMBINED SUMMONS IN THE SOUTH GAUTENG ... PARTICULARS and on the grounds set out therein

COMBINED SUMMONS - NewERAdownloads.newera.org.za/NewERA Amended Particulars of Claim.pdf · COMBINED SUMMONS IN THE SOUTH GAUTENG ... PARTICULARS and on the grounds set out therein

Documents
New lrc.bih.nic.inlrc.bih.nic.in/Advertisement/amin list claim.pdf · 2020. 8. 31. · Mera counseling Amin Post for 22 June 2019 ko huaa. But mera kon reason se candidates rejects

New lrc.bih.nic.inlrc.bih.nic.in/Advertisement/amin list claim.pdf · 2020. 8. 31. · Mera counseling Amin Post for 22 June 2019 ko huaa. But mera kon reason se candidates rejects

Documents
CCSS – 8.G.1, 8.G.2, 8.G.5. 8.G.6, 8.G€¦ · Supplementary Transformation Translation Vertical . Eureka Math Module 2 ... Eureka Math Module 2 – The Concept of Congruence 18

CCSS – 8.G.1, 8.G.2, 8.G.5. 8.G.6, 8.G€¦ · Supplementary Transformation Translation Vertical . Eureka Math Module 2 ... Eureka Math Module 2 – The Concept of Congruence 18

Documents
conatel.gob.veconatel.gob.ve/files/solicitudes/habilitaciones/Re... · Iliill lifll . g 8 8 A g . 8

conatel.gob.veconatel.gob.ve/files/solicitudes/habilitaciones/Re... · Iliill lifll . g 8 8 A g . 8

Documents
5 > : 5 G 8 3 ; 0 H 8 A > 0 H 0 G H 0 G 8 H O A E F C G L

5 > : 5 G 8 3 ; 0 H 8 A > 0 H 0 G H 0 G 8 H O A E F C G L

Documents
The White House · 88 88 88 g 88 88 a 8 s O s 8 z g sagas 888 888888888 888888888 g 8 8 8 z 8 8 z 8 g 3 888 g 8888 c 88 88 0 S g S 8 $ 8 g 8 888 888 2 s g 8 sss

The White House · 88 88 88 g 88 88 a 8 s O s 8 z g sagas 888 888888888 888888888 g 8 8 8 z 8 8 z 8 g 3 888 g 8888 c 88 88 0 S g S 8 $ 8 g 8 888 888 2 s g 8 sss

Documents
8 Proteínas G

8 Proteínas G

Documents
Gob...8888888888888888888888888888888888888888 8888888888888888888888888888888888888 a 88 88888888888 8 a 88888888 s g g 888 g g 8888 88888888888 8

Gob...8888888888888888888888888888888888888888 8888888888888888888888888888888888888 a 88 88888888888 8 a 88888888 s g g 888 g g 8888 88888888888 8

Documents
8 E F O H 8 > 0 H C ; > 8 G 8 H 8 G > F 8 H 8 G A 5 5 G 0 ...users.uoi.gr/gramisar/prosopiko/vlaxopoulos/Halari_Crete_text.pdf · Title: Microsoft Word - ΧΠΠΠΡΠ_Î Î

8 E F O H 8 > 0 H C ; > 8 G 8 H 8 G > F 8 H 8 G A 5 5 G 0 ...users.uoi.gr/gramisar/prosopiko/vlaxopoulos/Halari_Crete_text.pdf · Title: Microsoft Word - ΧΠΠΠΡΠ_Î Î

Documents
BEFORE THE AMERICAN ARBITRATION ASSOCIATIONpaulllp.com/wp-content/.../06/2016-05-17-PHSEKS-Statement-of-Claim.pdf · BEFORE THE AMERICAN ARBITRATION ASSOCIATION TRINA CREECH, individually

BEFORE THE AMERICAN ARBITRATION ASSOCIATIONpaulllp.com/wp-content/.../06/2016-05-17-PHSEKS-Statement-of-Claim.pdf · BEFORE THE AMERICAN ARBITRATION ASSOCIATION TRINA CREECH, individually

Documents
8 8 8 : : a 88888 gaaa 88888 8888888888888 g ¥8 888 g 8888 … Report of... · 2019. 10. 16. · 8 8 8 : : a 88888 gaaa 88888 8888888888888 " "g ¥8 888 g 8888 gaga g s 88888 as

8 8 8 : : a 88888 gaaa 88888 8888888888888 g ¥8 888 g 8888 … Report of... · 2019. 10. 16. · 8 8 8 : : a 88888 gaaa 88888 8888888888888 " "g ¥8 888 g 8888 gaga g s 88888 as

Documents
# N # G 8 1 N 7 # N S J G =7 8 G 8W1#N 8 S N#N ... - Unand

# N # G 8 1 N 7 # N S J G =7 8 G 8W1#N 8 S N#N ... - Unand

Documents
G 8 countries

G 8 countries

Documents
Goicoechea tort claim - idahoednews-wpengine.netdna-ssl.comidahoednews-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/.../09/Goicoechea-tort-claim.pdf · Colleen Zahn September 14, 2017 Her feelinos that

Goicoechea tort claim - idahoednews-wpengine.netdna-ssl.comidahoednews-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/.../09/Goicoechea-tort-claim.pdf · Colleen Zahn September 14, 2017 Her feelinos that

Documents
Probabilty modelling and simulation of insurance claim.pdf

Probabilty modelling and simulation of insurance claim.pdf

Documents
WJ=G 8 8 J g G=` JSg #8 f G# · ï f W S # ` ; N W 7 7 J g ô G # ; N = J # 8 ô S ; ʼ¯¹ pª; ª ¼ Ú;G¯Ó ¼ÆÚ;#ª Ù;+ G#, W J = G 8 ; 8 J g ; G = ` J S g ; # 8 f ; + G

WJ=G 8 8 J g G=` JSg #8 f G# · ï f W S # ` ; N W 7 7 J g ô G # ; N = J # 8 ô S ; ʼ¯¹ pª; ª ¼ Ú;G¯Ó ¼ÆÚ;#ª Ù;+ G#, W J = G 8 ; 8 J g ; G = ` J S g ; # 8 f ; + G

Documents
8 g S J 8 8S#

8 g S J 8 8S#

Documents
C 7 L < 8 = 0 - 5 G 5 = 8 5 ? G 5 ; 8 = K < < 5 4 > < 8 O 4 > 8 O 4 > Author SergeychevAY Created

C 7 L < 8 = 0 - 5 G 5 = 8 5 ? G 5 ; 8 = K < < 5 4 > < 8 O 4 > 8 O 4 > Author SergeychevAY Created

Documents
8 · = ;/ 8; N= Sa J ; ` 1=G J; G ¯ª ; ©p £

8 · = ;/ 8; N= Sa J ; ` 1=G J; G ¯ª ; ©p £

Documents
g 8,g 10 & g 15 Countries

g 8,g 10 & g 15 Countries

Documents
˘ ˇ ˘ ˘ ˘ ˆ˘˙#˙ 6 !˙) $#$- g ˙4 ˘7 9ˆa257 ! ˛ ! 5 e)$$#˙ a88 ˙ ˙ 8)$#$87 8 8 8 h)˙ < g˙ ˛3 )% ) $$'˙)˙ ! 6

˘ ˇ ˘ ˘ ˘ ˆ˘˙#˙ 6 !˙) $#$- g ˙4 ˘7 9ˆa257 ! ˛ ! 5 e)$$#˙ a88 ˙ ˙ 8)$#$87 8 8 8 h)˙ < g˙ ˛3 )% ) $$'˙)˙ ! 6

Documents