Upload
jayde-derby
View
213
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Natural Heritage Systems Planning with Multiple Stakeholders
Elizabeth SpangIM & Spatial Analysis Unit
February 25, 2011
2
• The Real World: A Fragmented Landscape• Why Engage Stakeholders?• Southern Ontario NHS Projects• NHS Design Process• Benefits of Engagement
3
Many organizations and agencies are involved in land management but are
their activities integrated?
Southern Ontario: A Fragmented Landscape
4
MNR’s NHS Approach• Developed in Natural Spaces • An objective, science-based approach to set targets for what should be
included in an NHS • Based on regional, ecological boundaries • Uses a site selection algorithm• Results in a strategic tool to support decision-making• An approach that can integrate conservation activities through Stakeholder
Engagement
5
• One organization can’t do it alone• The stakeholders have a crucial role:
– in identifying objectives for a NHS– in setting the ecological targets to guide the NHS design– in championing the final NHS and implementing it within their own
organizations
Why engage stakeholders to design an NHS?
6
Working Together toward a NHS for Prince Edward County and Surrounding Communities
7
Terms of Reference
• Establishes a Vision, Goals, Objectives, and Guiding Principles• Guiding Principles:• The process of developing the Natural Heritage System will:
1) Engage stakeholders in its design and development
2) Incorporate ecological, economic, social and cultural values
3) Be based on best-available science and information
4) Be open and transparent in reporting on process, methods, outcomes and results
5) Be dynamic and adaptive
6) Be consistent with the Provincial Policy Statement (PPS) and all applicable legislation
7) Consider existing municipal official plans and existing areas of development
8) Recognise the many values of natural and developed areas
8
Stakeholder Interests Represented on the Sustaining What We Value Project
• Area Artist• Cultural• Landowner • Landowner/ Farmer• Stewardship Council/Social• Canadian Land Trust Alliance• Ontario Federation of Anglers and
Hunters• Algonquin to Adirondacks
Conservation Association (NGO)• Eastern Ontario Model Forest
(NGO)
• Upper Tier Municipality – GIS • Upper Tier Municipality –
Sustainability Coordinator• Municipal Planner/ Lower Tier • St. Lawrence Islands National
Park• Conservation Authority• Kemptville District MNR• Ministry of Municipal Affairs and
Housing• Agriculture• Health Unit
9
Technical Support Team
NHS Design Process
Stakeholder Group Diverse Interests Consensus Decision Making
10
Stakeholder Decisions: Socio-Political Constraints
• How should existing land uses be accommodated by the NHS?
• E.g. Should Provincial Parks always be included in the NHS?
• E.g. Can we minimize the amount of prime agricultural land that gets included?
• 48+ items discussed
11
Stakeholder Decisions: Set Targets
• What is the minimum amount of natural area needed for a healthy ecosystem?– 23 Targets discussed:
• Biodiversity• Ecological Functions (e.g. patch size)• Fine Scale Species Habitat (e.g. SAR)• Watershed Functions
(e.g. headwater areas)Percent Forest Cover by Watershed
12
Where Do Targets Come From?
• Scientific Literature– How Much Habitat Is Enough?– Local studies
• Policy Documents:– Natural Heritage Reference
Manual– Significant Wildlife Habitat
Technical Guide– Silvicultural Guide
13
Producing the Learning Scenarios
• Lead Analyst (Southern Region, MNR)
– Assemble all the targets and constraints set by the stakeholders– Prep data layers– Use a decision-support tool (MARXAN) to identify efficient
configurations of sites• Defendable and Objective • Easily Updated• Can run many scenarios
14
Multiple Scenarios Help with Engagement
• Ability to try multiple scenarios helps stakeholders move past areas of disagreement– E.g. agriculture vs. conservation– NPCA agricultural reps wanted to exclude all areas with Class
1,2,3,4 and O soil types
15
Stakeholder Decisions
• Review of Learning Scenarios– E.g. Which NHS option best balances ecological function with
being socially and politically acceptable?– E.g. Which option can all agree on?
16
Ecological Thresholds
Percent Forest Cover by Quaternary Watersheds
17
• Baseline
• Captures 99% of existing natural cover
Reviewing the Learning Scenarios
18
• The Best Half of What’s Left on the Landscape
• Captures 65% of existing natural cover
Reviewing the Learning Scenarios
19
• Forest and Wetland Cover Targets
• Captures 86% of existing natural cover
Reviewing the Learning Scenarios
20
Implementation
• The NHS is a package of compiled information and data layers that can inform:– Priorities for Stewardship Projects– Land Use Planning and Policy Decisions– Conservation Land Acquisitions– Development Proposal Assessments (including cumulative
effects)– Priorities for Inventory Programs and Research Projects
• We will be providing knowledge transfer sessions to key groups (e.g. planners, land trusts, etc.)
21
• Zoomed in we can see the 5ha hexagons which contain the information and areas for each feature
• Using GIS we can map the underlying features captured by the hexagons identified in the final scenario
• We can look at how well the boundaries from the GIS layer capture the actual features on the ground using available imagery
• By developing some rules we can identify areas with restoration potential where existing natural cover is fragmented in order to develop a connected system
• In this example GIS was used to identify areas between features that are within 300m
and
gaps/holes within features at least 300m wide
Example Application: Stewardship
22
Benefits of Engagement
• Sense of ownership• Stakeholders become advocates for the
product• Representing diverse interests increases
legitimacy• Aligned activities
23
Acknowledgements
• GeoConnections• Sustaining What We Value Steering Committee Members:
– Elizabeth Holmes– Josh Van Wieren– Chris Bellemore– Don Ross– David Bull– Amber Cowie– Erin Neave
• Scenario Planning Team Members• Kerry Coleman, facilitator
– Steve Voros– Silvia Strobl– Chris Lemieux– Joy Sterritt– Amy Handyside– Karen Fraser