~~~1W~lt~~~li_r_i~w~__r~w~~_i~~r~__-~~~r

H 1llE~

-~~$~~GATTS~~

~ ~1

ilgt-tt

~

PI

lt~wlt~-~IIil~~~~~~~~~~~ ( W$$~-amp-

~amptIl$tFIlDl() -~

i~ ~

11n

llHlttI~ 1~ltK-~m~ 1Dl~~ft$yen1~ ~ 8

$yen1~-a-~~~-K~~iiiIJl~1e-bull

l4J~~~~tlijll O~~~-R

grm

0 W

1 ~~

1 t-1(m~~- ~ ~~ 1~~ 1-~~tW1l11 0

2R1E-~l4J~~~~~1If ~lfpound$yen1~~~Jt-

~ ~~iii I ~~ 1-~g1~Hjlj~~~flll11IK~ ~

~- r tIm~liJI(~ J

( m

anaged trad

e) ~i~~~lE111C ~ bull

bull~ -K~~ ~mj~

~~

1rmlE~tIij~ll(I[~~J5B~~~~t~~ ~ i~~~~~it~ tlih~miii~iI~_~~lIIlD(~~-NLj

0

-Pltbullbull~mt~~fpound~lHR~~~~m~$yen1l1~~il~~

~~ ~~~liSnW~~

gt(~$H~~I~~IR

0

~~~~B~ =t$ltD

l tt$IEr~~~_~il$K

t~ ~cr~ffg~I[In~~_~fl~lt~~IIlID(~fltJi ( General

Agreem

ent of Tariff and T

rade GA

TT

) ~JIIW~~~~lI~lHI~111~$~itrlt~Mit 0 ~~IPIyentI1l~yentI1+1~

~~~-Pltampi~~

~ ~

~tir~~~~~~tKr~

Jtt~~11~~~l(~~~1lH1ll$~lEI-N 1 ~ ~~

I ~1110-~gt1+1liSle-~~~~ 0 lEI~ ~ 11~$lst-Kli-N

~

tl8 Ci~IlJlIt r liil(CltIi~~ J ( A

rrangement betw

een thl Governm

ent of Jap

an and th

e Governm

ent of T

he United S

tates of A

merica

Concerning T

rade in Sem

iconductor Pro

du

ct) bull

-Plt~ 1

ampIIIf r $ltC~IUili J (U

S -Jap

an

Sem

iconductor Ag

reemen

t) bull

The A

sian

Wall Street Journal Ju

ne 7 1993 p 14

jjKolrU~w--IHH1HiilifiGAI

T~~

--lll

n_ C

oc5__-_ ~~j~~~Z--~~_--~

~~ ~-~~~~+_-

li~~~~~~~~-~~~~~-middot-t~~iil

~ ~i~-~~f-

0

i

1iljLlja t~Jt~t )

i1tiFi 49 49 26 23 64 09 55 89

- 95 311

- 339 275

- 254 - 2S0

364 - 671

1125 1222

-1450 1595

-1270 -1160

10S1 - 736

~~~ o~~ ~amp~ ~ ~ 0 ~ - ~ sf if ~$)~~

February 1992amp nomic Indicators

frtIPl-BttimtllJ tit~Jt~Jt)

--L-~_

1987 1990

J rnics and Statistics ensus Statistical c985 ampUS Departshy~nt Business June 979

Jfta9JiI JLffl-A ~tf1l1l _ ~ a9 ~ J JL JL reg 0 II ttI]$~OftlmlyenffI~ift~~MI]~Wlyen~lm~f-tJJ1itIW71~1a9 - ItIlJIilyen~1it~II~II ~iJfJ ~ ~ ~ a9 Jilflll M ~ 1 a9 f4 bull fit ~ amp1 ifii1 II Rri It 1 a9 II 110 5t a9 ift tt

0 8JiIJjiiJjJJ~jf~~tEmif~Yeuroia9-filj~l3f4a a9111JIlIli11t-lil~~ +71mzttiiJjfjIfijIl~~HjET1fW1f ~ tE qt ~ f4 ~ ~1 ~ ~ ~ 4- iii ~ bull tt

0ItIl 1tIl amp1 tt ~ il x bull ~ 13 1it Iii jJ j] lfi~f4mqt~~~~1~iiJjoa913 ~t 1i 1it lJ ~ 1amp a9 II fii Jtt lJ iiI9 ~ fsect fF- ~ )Iri - ~ oJ 5t ~ l1I St li 7X Jtt M1 ~ 1amp jE - ~ ffl ~ fy ffl DC m 15Jt Til ~ iJfJ ffif III II bull ~ ~ JQ 7Itl~tJc~P~$~ 13 ~1E~I jg 0 ~~ mm1it~nllSt~ mJt~a9-ltifiiJillitEffl~Jj~m $J~~~ a ~m-~T1f~~ aI3I]710w~~JL~tEPifa9~~ft~iampJIiift-t$~MtJc ift I ~ If ~ ~ ~ f - 1ft 0 ~ -Et JIi ~ ~Rf ~ ~ ~ t1 bull ~~ JIi lEt 1f a9 M a9 ~ tE 111 Yjfil ~ ffP j] - jJ f-t fU It If m ~ ~a9aro3degO1lI0~oo bullbull Jt~ ~ItplusmnH ~jfsect $ iyenI 9a 0

a9 ~ ~ a9 8 1i Jtt $11 a9 1it JtIJ mfilitg-WJjtJk ~ ~ bullbull ~~ooaJLffl ~lJZ~gftfU -t~ ~I-li~~tEm-T1f m~ 0 II ErJIiJjm~lyen11 ~J a ~ sect W a9 jI J jJ ~~~~~~m~Ra9 11 sect ~ Id ~ ifiiJ 1f + It ~ ~ - - PI bull ~ Z 1i -Et ff ~ JL 110 P ~ it 13 a9ffl-t1tEtr ~~~~

0

0

JA~Oiff-i-tIIJIi~1I ~ 1f 1f JL a9 ~ jf- 1)3 ff Jt qt jt f-t J ~ ~ bull bull Ii 5l i) qt reg Jt 0 ~ 111amp jJ ~ ~ ~ Jt Jt ~ 1f - 5t 5t Jr ift T ~ T Jt it f - 1it if it Iff ffI fit fI iiJj 00 tE - Jt Jt it jE 1m f-4 9a

0

- JL - Iii T fIt~lttttfl JL-tlli1Elil

tE I ~ -Et 11 11 a9 M1m~ a9o~~ ~~iftW JIi-~~ ~7X~m iii tit ~ a9 1~~m - ffl ~

110 bull Ii 1 ~ bull ~ _ffImfampitJJyenift ~ it ~ Iff II 11 jJPif m a9 f-t jJ fJJ a9 ~ f 110 bull 1i 1 ~ Pif ~ m ttMli~

871~1Iffl -t=~~ bullbull itift ffiimiiJj-rtE 1yen~~Jj ~ft1ft lJ~Jjtiil~lyen-~JIi~ ~JIim ~ bull ~ mI JJ ~J Jjt 1amp PZ - ~ 31l Pif 11 a9 Jt ~ Ifij 13 - tfI laquo tI JL ift yenlJ M I

o~~JLEit lt17 rm 0

or I-l 0 ~

-sect-t~Xmlyen-m ~ II iG 11 fJl if( ~ ~ ~ ~ rJl 1ampI]m IIIbull ~ miltE fn ~ ~ ~ bull fJf I] if( bull ~ f1j ~ miI ~ 1it Iij g-TJr -Mi JJjll ~ JL I] 32

~mlm~ rc J)t jE 1m a9 g

~~~1f~ i II~Jktl g Iij~ ~ tmfr~ IIyenf ~ sect jEJk 82 ~~ 1 m - Iij fyen ~ S tit ~plusmn 8 ~~ 1iiII7I J1 E~wlllla9 omiddot a9I~ it sect~plusmnlHEm mJ ~ ~ ili~~~ ~iI~~T1f IP i j] JIi = ~ tlJa9a9 ~sAmlt if(~ o~-shy~~gt1tJL IIS bull -3 iIII 0

1T -3 rff shy

~a9iftilesect-ims Ell ~ ~ jESaA

-- rI -~JLplusmn -tl~m~ ~ mt ifiiJ jE m ~ JtO Z a9 ~ Jloqt~tpound Jj~o~(fi 1 Jffl ~ ~9U i Jtt IIlaquo III il 1m ~-om~ mt~~Jk JtU -3 0

aa9a9tltdJtilillf6mtfJJfJJ1itgJtu bullbull - ~

fi () sect ~ ~ f f

l ~

5 s-as r ttl

~ 1l

~ 0

~ 8 i

~

~ ~ ~ pW - ~ ~ 2 oi g 0 0 S gi 0 ~ 3 g g ~ ~ -

$ t-gt

~ ~ tIgt s

~ gj 8shyXl ~ tlt gtJIJ ~ IIl

1 bull IIl

bull Tl lO

Mi 1= ~rOle

J t f~ f 0shy

ltII

i it i t Mi tl je 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

f omiddot ~

I

Iii ~ ~ ~ Il9

1fi i iii

ltII

~ I

smiddots E

~ I~ ~~

~r 0- c 1

~

~ s

I i gt R ~

~ k S f ~ ( ~

f

i

~( tO imiddot tIgt

gt ~ Cl ~

1 c iI

f 1i ltr ~ to

~ st 0 Cle sshye lO

J] ~ JlIJ 1L ~

H 8t ~E -t fpound (I)tb 13 fjljO ~~ ill ~ 0 tf1L45shy~k reg t-tm ~i1J ZO~ avail fMtf1l iI~iI it m ~~~ 13 ~bt[ 1- fLim WI~ ~~~ ~III 7t sect~ iXt~ ~1t~ Hif(~ bullbull Iff ~~ IUl ~ 1II1l~ fl 1l ~ iiIJ n 11 aramp 1t

~

if 11 11 1 WI ~ fiB ~ ~ 13 ~ i1J f(

(I)

jfi ~ ~~~ 1i 1l 11ft lte J rPJ 1Y fi~nX ~ m [1(-1bull - ~~ ava tfi~Ji

i 0 III til Igt t j

gt-3 IUlgt-3

a~jj -shy F JttJllt ~ m~(I)

~ ~~ $amp0 ilma

~ ~ ~(I) () Jtlj ~ ~ 1~0

~ IIIn 00

titS - f( 0

~~ ~iI 1m ff rPJ~ 011gt~i

=shyf( Jllj ~ 0

~-~M~~~WQampM~~~bullbullbull ( 1960~1991 ) ( -t1t~j(~1i )

4ft t1D JfiD ampMi 1960 197 148 49 1~5 264 215 49 1970 425 399 26 1971 433 456 23 1972 494 558 - 64 1973 714 705 09 1974 983 1038 - 55 1975 1071 982 89 1976 1147 1242 95 1977 1208 1519 -311 1978 1421 1760 - 339 1979 1845 2120 275 1980 2243 2497 254 1981 2371 2651 - 280 1982 2112 2476 - 364 1983 2018 2689 671 1984 2199 3324 -1125 1985 2159 3381 -1222 1986 2234 3684 -1450 1987 2503 4098 1595 1988 3203 4473 1270 1989 3614 4774 -1160 1990 3896

r 4977 1081

1991 4165 4901 736

fU4lmt l Economic Report of the Presuient February 1992amp Joint Economic committee Economic Indicators March 1992 bull

( 1972~1990 )

50r---------------------------------------

o r---=o~--_~__

-50

-100

-150

-200~~----~----~--~-J~---~----~----~~ 1972 1975 1978 1981 1984 1987 1990

4lIil l US Departmept of Commerce Economics and Statistics Administration Bureau of The Census Statistical Abstract of the United States 1991 1985~US Departshyment of Commerce Survey of Current Busines8 June 1975 December 1976 1977 1978 June 1979

---

~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~~

~~

sect~~4l1l1ti+lt~~l$~~

~~~mtnRlllbullbull~~

1~H ~

~~~~mt~Nlll~bullbull~mtbullbull~Mo

0$~1S~~E[

2~tI(a1ll ~

egtI~1ll-( depreciation ) g~1t( ~

Ml$ttirabull

bull~~1HIf ( tax

credit)

~

~~~Ii~~4iIQeiltl bull

JJJ1S~~~

2~~~

egtI ~

ji~~~~I$1ij-~h(lll~lFiiibull

bullHI~

gr$~H~~Iaf ( m

1~AJOlt-~~-=l)

-~o~middot~

NimQe~-lt~bull

~

~imQe~IS~bull

~ ~111ll ~bullbullbull~~bullbull~bullbullbullbull~1llshy

N~~~~~~~~~1llHI~~o

~t-~~~mt~~~++11JSJ~~~

i1IlEil11I ~ ~

~~-Riiit~Bbull

bullltl~~-Rm1~~rllIj~~

0

ii 0 ~1I~~bullbull~ifi$ltIIbull

bullbull

~lEilllI ~ 1lJ~1SfIbullbull

tlicent~ olII-~ 1~l1I11lt-Ilm5~ ~ $

ltlIl~~tR~bull

bull r~~II~m~r~~ll~Iilj ~ ~$1Ilm~91~~~~lIi~IIIlm5~bullbull

1E-~ 01 ~1S-m~lI~~~liii4Ilzl ~

1it8 iilt~~SlClWlilWltElt1IiiiWKlpoundlt1I=KIiC

0 n-Ill Okim

oto Dan

iell Takuo S

ugano and Fran

klin

B W

einstein Com

petitive Edge T

he Sem

imiddot conductor Industry in th

e U S and Jap

an

( Stanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984 ) p

124 tS

O

kimoto D

aniel I Talm

o SUgano and F

ranklin B W

einstein Com

jrtitiue Edl1 T

he Semiconductor Industry in

the U S

an

d Ja[XJn (S

tanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984) pp 9

9-1

00

t

I ~ltgUIHIKIItI1iWCllpoundlii~~f-~

0 iH~ClItW~-Klflliimiddot Cl~~lt11iii ( Hitachi ) ~

~~leg I Oamp

iliillnbullbull

bull ClIlIg~~ampi~ sect+~ilKl~lpoundlfllii~~lQilKBIbull

bullIi1W

tr11i ( DR

AM

) lemiddot I1lI1m~NlIampi~IUI-lIllI~~-lK~~-R bull ~

mi I ~~i1JjHili-k1gt(~llIj(~-R

iii Il1~ ~ ~t~ltllIHti~bullbull~Blt-$~

r-

~~~~~~~~t-bullbull~~M~mt~~t

~~~~~Z~~~~~II~m1_~~ r~-

---~--shy

~ ~ tIgt s

~ gj 8shyXl ~ tlt gtJIJ ~ IIl

1 bull IIl

bull Tl lO

Mi 1= ~rOle

J t f~ f 0shy

ltII

i it i t Mi tl je 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

f omiddot ~

I

Iii ~ ~ ~ Il9

1fi i iii

ltII

~ I

smiddots E

~ I~ ~~

~r 0- c 1

~

~ s

I i gt R ~

~ k S f ~ ( ~

f

i

~( tO imiddot tIgt

gt ~ Cl ~

1 c iI

f 1i ltr ~ to

~ st 0 Cle sshye lO

J] ~ JlIJ 1L ~

H 8t ~E -t fpound (I)tb 13 fjljO ~~ ill ~ 0 tf1L45shy~k reg t-tm ~i1J ZO~ avail fMtf1l iI~iI it m ~~~ 13 ~bt[ 1- fLim WI~ ~~~ ~III 7t sect~ iXt~ ~1t~ Hif(~ bullbull Iff ~~ IUl ~ 1II1l~ fl 1l ~ iiIJ n 11 aramp 1t

~

if 11 11 1 WI ~ fiB ~ ~ 13 ~ i1J f(

(I)

jfi ~ ~~~ 1i 1l 11ft lte J rPJ 1Y fi~nX ~ m [1(-1bull - ~~ ava tfi~Ji

i 0 III til Igt t j

gt-3 IUlgt-3

a~jj -shy F JttJllt ~ m~(I)

~ ~~ $amp0 ilma

~ ~ ~(I) () Jtlj ~ ~ 1~0

~ IIIn 00

titS - f( 0

~~ ~iI 1m ff rPJ~ 011gt~i

=shyf( Jllj ~ 0

~-~M~~~WQampM~~~bullbullbull ( 1960~1991 ) ( -t1t~j(~1i )

4ft t1D JfiD ampMi 1960 197 148 49 1~5 264 215 49 1970 425 399 26 1971 433 456 23 1972 494 558 - 64 1973 714 705 09 1974 983 1038 - 55 1975 1071 982 89 1976 1147 1242 95 1977 1208 1519 -311 1978 1421 1760 - 339 1979 1845 2120 275 1980 2243 2497 254 1981 2371 2651 - 280 1982 2112 2476 - 364 1983 2018 2689 671 1984 2199 3324 -1125 1985 2159 3381 -1222 1986 2234 3684 -1450 1987 2503 4098 1595 1988 3203 4473 1270 1989 3614 4774 -1160 1990 3896

r 4977 1081

1991 4165 4901 736

fU4lmt l Economic Report of the Presuient February 1992amp Joint Economic committee Economic Indicators March 1992 bull

( 1972~1990 )

50r---------------------------------------

o r---=o~--_~__

-50

-100

-150

-200~~----~----~--~-J~---~----~----~~ 1972 1975 1978 1981 1984 1987 1990

4lIil l US Departmept of Commerce Economics and Statistics Administration Bureau of The Census Statistical Abstract of the United States 1991 1985~US Departshyment of Commerce Survey of Current Busines8 June 1975 December 1976 1977 1978 June 1979

---

~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~~

~~

sect~~4l1l1ti+lt~~l$~~

~~~mtnRlllbullbull~~

1~H ~

~~~~mt~Nlll~bullbull~mtbullbull~Mo

0$~1S~~E[

2~tI(a1ll ~

egtI~1ll-( depreciation ) g~1t( ~

Ml$ttirabull

bull~~1HIf ( tax

credit)

~

~~~Ii~~4iIQeiltl bull

JJJ1S~~~

2~~~

egtI ~

ji~~~~I$1ij-~h(lll~lFiiibull

bullHI~

gr$~H~~Iaf ( m

1~AJOlt-~~-=l)

-~o~middot~

NimQe~-lt~bull

~

~imQe~IS~bull

~ ~111ll ~bullbullbull~~bullbull~bullbullbullbull~1llshy

N~~~~~~~~~1llHI~~o

~t-~~~mt~~~++11JSJ~~~

i1IlEil11I ~ ~

~~-Riiit~Bbull

bullltl~~-Rm1~~rllIj~~

0

ii 0 ~1I~~bullbull~ifi$ltIIbull

bullbull

~lEilllI ~ 1lJ~1SfIbullbull

tlicent~ olII-~ 1~l1I11lt-Ilm5~ ~ $

ltlIl~~tR~bull

bull r~~II~m~r~~ll~Iilj ~ ~$1Ilm~91~~~~lIi~IIIlm5~bullbull

1E-~ 01 ~1S-m~lI~~~liii4Ilzl ~

1it8 iilt~~SlClWlilWltElt1IiiiWKlpoundlt1I=KIiC

0 n-Ill Okim

oto Dan

iell Takuo S

ugano and Fran

klin

B W

einstein Com

petitive Edge T

he Sem

imiddot conductor Industry in th

e U S and Jap

an

( Stanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984 ) p

124 tS

O

kimoto D

aniel I Talm

o SUgano and F

ranklin B W

einstein Com

jrtitiue Edl1 T

he Semiconductor Industry in

the U S

an

d Ja[XJn (S

tanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984) pp 9

9-1

00

t

I ~ltgUIHIKIItI1iWCllpoundlii~~f-~

0 iH~ClItW~-Klflliimiddot Cl~~lt11iii ( Hitachi ) ~

~~leg I Oamp

iliillnbullbull

bull ClIlIg~~ampi~ sect+~ilKl~lpoundlfllii~~lQilKBIbull

bullIi1W

tr11i ( DR

AM

) lemiddot I1lI1m~NlIampi~IUI-lIllI~~-lK~~-R bull ~

mi I ~~i1JjHili-k1gt(~llIj(~-R

iii Il1~ ~ ~t~ltllIHti~bullbull~Blt-$~

r-

~~~~~~~~t-bullbull~~M~mt~~t

~~~~~Z~~~~~II~m1_~~ r~-

---~--shy

---

~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~~

~~

sect~~4l1l1ti+lt~~l$~~

~~~mtnRlllbullbull~~

1~H ~

~~~~mt~Nlll~bullbull~mtbullbull~Mo

0$~1S~~E[

2~tI(a1ll ~

egtI~1ll-( depreciation ) g~1t( ~

Ml$ttirabull

bull~~1HIf ( tax

credit)

~

~~~Ii~~4iIQeiltl bull

JJJ1S~~~

2~~~

egtI ~

ji~~~~I$1ij-~h(lll~lFiiibull

bullHI~

gr$~H~~Iaf ( m

1~AJOlt-~~-=l)

-~o~middot~

NimQe~-lt~bull

~

~imQe~IS~bull

~ ~111ll ~bullbullbull~~bullbull~bullbullbullbull~1llshy

N~~~~~~~~~1llHI~~o

~t-~~~mt~~~++11JSJ~~~

i1IlEil11I ~ ~

~~-Riiit~Bbull

bullltl~~-Rm1~~rllIj~~

0

ii 0 ~1I~~bullbull~ifi$ltIIbull

bullbull

~lEilllI ~ 1lJ~1SfIbullbull

tlicent~ olII-~ 1~l1I11lt-Ilm5~ ~ $

ltlIl~~tR~bull

bull r~~II~m~r~~ll~Iilj ~ ~$1Ilm~91~~~~lIi~IIIlm5~bullbull

1E-~ 01 ~1S-m~lI~~~liii4Ilzl ~

1it8 iilt~~SlClWlilWltElt1IiiiWKlpoundlt1I=KIiC

0 n-Ill Okim

oto Dan

iell Takuo S

ugano and Fran

klin

B W

einstein Com

petitive Edge T

he Sem

imiddot conductor Industry in th

e U S and Jap

an

( Stanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984 ) p

124 tS

O

kimoto D

aniel I Talm

o SUgano and F

ranklin B W

einstein Com

jrtitiue Edl1 T

he Semiconductor Industry in

the U S

an

d Ja[XJn (S

tanford C

alif Stanford U

niversity Press 1984) pp 9

9-1

00

t

I ~ltgUIHIKIItI1iWCllpoundlii~~f-~

0 iH~ClItW~-Klflliimiddot Cl~~lt11iii ( Hitachi ) ~

~~leg I Oamp

iliillnbullbull

bull ClIlIg~~ampi~ sect+~ilKl~lpoundlfllii~~lQilKBIbull

bullIi1W

tr11i ( DR

AM

) lemiddot I1lI1m~NlIampi~IUI-lIllI~~-lK~~-R bull ~

mi I ~~i1JjHili-k1gt(~llIj(~-R

iii Il1~ ~ ~t~ltllIHti~bullbull~Blt-$~

r-

~~~~~~~~t-bullbull~~M~mt~~t

~~~~~Z~~~~~II~m1_~~ r~-

---~--shy

tt JIlt II itt~Il ( 1r~jG ) rP~~ff$()

NEC a 4500 73 IBM 4400 71

I Jtz a 4300 69 Ii a a 3600 58 MOTOROLA 3000 48

r TEXAS INSTRUMENTS 2700 44

f iIplusmniii a 2400 39 INTEL 2350 38 ~

=~ a 2300 37 fi ~r a 1900 31 ~gt PHILIPS - SIGNETICS 7f 1800 29

NATIONAL SEMICONDUCTOR 1700 27 r~ 7

~ ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES 1100 18 r f

=iF a SGS-THOMSON t

1090 1080

18 18

JUt a 1040 17 OKI a 950 15

fgtr 1

-t -t fiij] a

=pound bullATampT

920 900 860

15 15 15

SIEMENS itt 180 13

tt 21~ 43670 700

_411 Dataquest

~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~

-3lt

~~IIKnI[~~~nI[~II(~nm ( International Trade A

dministration ITC

) ~-3jiB-~ ~ ~IIKII~iElilm~1tlIIKII~llli 1(15[ K

DR

AM

~ EPR

OM

~bullbull

Wllogamp

ilf5-N r ~

lt~~II(~ J bull

bullbull

lj1I r 110 I J ue~~tiii o~~-N~

~ nm$H

+i iti~li[It1(iIlztii

0

~itIIKII~If~nmm~W~~15[ T~~t~~lS~llliue~it~ middot~nnrgtsaiATTlS~llli~U middot~illltmGATT~~1lII(

~~

11 + 111~U~1cm middot~~_IX~~1c

0 j~itIIKm1E-~l[I~1lampm~ll$tiR ~ ~I~~m~~~~~

0 lI[itm

_t--~tiIIKI~Ifue~~tiiim~bullbull~~~HiIIKII~iE_~$F

~~li~ 1 ~lt

Kijl-$F~m_ 0

0

IIKmi2n1[1tll ~lt1(ijl-~~ I m

~1 ~

~$F1c ( j--iJf$1 ~ltK$F1c)

k=lijl--N~ ~ i2n1[~iE~1tl1 ~lt

0

K$l1cm~-y ~ ~1 ~~

1 ijl-1(~l5[m~R~iim$l~ ( j--iJf$ ~~

1 $F1c) 0 j--~~i2~$F1cm1+l~gtji~~ ~

~~lHI~~1+l~iffl~$~~t5~o

I ~lt1(mDi

( ~--iJf$1 ~lt1($F1c) 1~ltK$F1ctrm1+l~gt4r~~ I~it~-1~lIil110 I mt~~~~~~~tlS~llliue~ ~Di2n1[lI[~~-R~~~

IIKnI[~~~~nI[ltlllg1tlmm1E-~l[I~1lamp ~illm~iEII[~~1tlIIKnI[j~~11II~llli 0

1tl~~~-Y~m~iE~~~~~~$F~IIKnI[~~1tlm~~1E-~IiIIIKnI[~~~~llg~~~~_~~~$~~

~~~$~olI[it~~IIKnI[bull

bull~~~m~~-N~m~~~lIi~m~middot~~IiIIIKnI[~li[~m~If~m$~~

~ j~IIK~~itHIIlim~If~wlIi~~it~

0 ~~

~ ~~j~~dEOO~M~~ii1iiK ~ ~~

1 ~~

1ijl-~~t4tim

1E-~110~1E-~l[I~1lamp~1Ill~ o~~~$l1c ~ 1Ji(~1I[~t1t1~ 1$ r

til~~

J ~ -mm~~~~IIKnI[~~~tt ~

~ ~~bullbullbull~~~I~~~~middot~~~bullbull~~~~~~middot~Ibullbull~~~~~~~~o

~ ~~~IIII11K7ll~middotJlmiddot

111~1II~IIi~lIlI~I$~~11ltmji~ r ~~lt-1ft-~J (less than fair v

alue)

bull ~i1l1lmji~~jcent1tl1IItm1111I~l~middot tlI1I~~

~~~~1tl~III1e-bull y~IHill1lmiddot bull

bull~ll~-i ~7ll~III~~~~~bull

bull1lI r lt-1ft- Jl1ltJ~$~~bull

bull~

0 0

~

T

imothy J B

artl The 1991 U

S -Jap~n S

emiconductor A

greement W

ill the New

Approach Y

ield Old R

esults in Minnesota Journal o

f Global

Trade Fall 1992 p

117 Joh

n C

K

ingery The U

S -Ja

pan

Sem

iconductor Arrangem

ent and the GA

TT

Operating in a L

egal Vacuum

Stanford Journal of International L

aw V

ol 25 No2 F

all 1988 pp 474 78

~

~iIIbull

bull~bullbullbull

1tll ~ltI=l~lltmHllcnm 1~4JE~~7llglaquom1I10 1

~11l01lt(pound11lt ~ oEllI1I~euro~II~~~iIlnl(-331I-$middot ~~iIi~1I

1lH1~~l-tJ~liIIU5~ ClllJ~11lt bull rili~lII~fIII~~Iplusmn~ 41I11 ~~illit$BIIt~~~~~~l~tiillit o~

19 U S C

sect 2411

( a) (S

up

p IV

1986 )

~

~~

I 10~1lllmji(o~ I ~~

I ~~iE~~ tJIIgc~Jl~I IO~1ebull lQ~HJ~f$-R~Illlo-middot$~ I liIJlilmiddot

mWltHtl~~lIi1t1ltl~~~-3jQ~~~ll1+k=l~~~a j~_$l~ ~

~~iiiC~IiI~~bull

bull0

0

l$~~llg~tmt1E-~ ( foreign market value) ~ttli$ o

1mIIKnI[~~~~Itli~~~ r lt~JI J m~~~ ~11

lift~m~~~~-3jbullbull~~~~~~~ff~om~II[~jl(lii~~~

bullbull~Q1c~~IIKnI[~~~lEiSli$~~t1-o

~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~

-3lt

~~IIKnI[~~~nI[~II(~nm ( International Trade A

dministration ITC

) ~-3jiB-~ ~ ~IIKII~iElilm~1tlIIKII~llli 1(15[ K

DR

AM

~ EPR

OM

~bullbull

Wllogamp

ilf5-N r ~

lt~~II(~ J bull

bullbull

lj1I r 110 I J ue~~tiii o~~-N~

~ nm$H

+i iti~li[It1(iIlztii

0

~itIIKII~If~nmm~W~~15[ T~~t~~lS~llliue~it~ middot~nnrgtsaiATTlS~llli~U middot~illltmGATT~~1lII(

~~

11 + 111~U~1cm middot~~_IX~~1c

0 j~itIIKm1E-~l[I~1lampm~ll$tiR ~ ~I~~m~~~~~

0 lI[itm

_t--~tiIIKI~Ifue~~tiiim~bullbull~~~HiIIKII~iE_~$F

~~li~ 1 ~lt

Kijl-$F~m_ 0

0

IIKmi2n1[1tll ~lt1(ijl-~~ I m

~1 ~

~$F1c ( j--iJf$1 ~ltK$F1c)

k=lijl--N~ ~ i2n1[~iE~1tl1 ~lt

0

K$l1cm~-y ~ ~1 ~~

1 ijl-1(~l5[m~R~iim$l~ ( j--iJf$ ~~

1 $F1c) 0 j--~~i2~$F1cm1+l~gtji~~ ~

~~lHI~~1+l~iffl~$~~t5~o

I ~lt1(mDi

( ~--iJf$1 ~lt1($F1c) 1~ltK$F1ctrm1+l~gt4r~~ I~it~-1~lIil110 I mt~~~~~~~tlS~llliue~ ~Di2n1[lI[~~-R~~~

IIKnI[~~~~nI[ltlllg1tlmm1E-~l[I~1lamp ~illm~iEII[~~1tlIIKnI[j~~11II~llli 0

1tl~~~-Y~m~iE~~~~~~$F~IIKnI[~~1tlm~~1E-~IiIIIKnI[~~~~llg~~~~_~~~$~~

~~~$~olI[it~~IIKnI[bull

bull~~~m~~-N~m~~~lIi~m~middot~~IiIIIKnI[~li[~m~If~m$~~

~ j~IIK~~itHIIlim~If~wlIi~~it~

0 ~~

~ ~~j~~dEOO~M~~ii1iiK ~ ~~

1 ~~

1ijl-~~t4tim

1E-~110~1E-~l[I~1lamp~1Ill~ o~~~$l1c ~ 1Ji(~1I[~t1t1~ 1$ r

til~~

J ~ -mm~~~~IIKnI[~~~tt ~

~ ~~bullbullbull~~~I~~~~middot~~~bullbull~~~~~~middot~Ibullbull~~~~~~~~o

~ ~~~IIII11K7ll~middotJlmiddot

111~1II~IIi~lIlI~I$~~11ltmji~ r ~~lt-1ft-~J (less than fair v

alue)

bull ~i1l1lmji~~jcent1tl1IItm1111I~l~middot tlI1I~~

~~~~1tl~III1e-bull y~IHill1lmiddot bull

bull~ll~-i ~7ll~III~~~~~bull

bull1lI r lt-1ft- Jl1ltJ~$~~bull

bull~

0 0

~

T

imothy J B

artl The 1991 U

S -Jap~n S

emiconductor A

greement W

ill the New

Approach Y

ield Old R

esults in Minnesota Journal o

f Global

Trade Fall 1992 p

117 Joh

n C

K

ingery The U

S -Ja

pan

Sem

iconductor Arrangem

ent and the GA

TT

Operating in a L

egal Vacuum

Stanford Journal of International L

aw V

ol 25 No2 F

all 1988 pp 474 78

~

~iIIbull

bull~bullbullbull

1tll ~ltI=l~lltmHllcnm 1~4JE~~7llglaquom1I10 1

~11l01lt(pound11lt ~ oEllI1I~euro~II~~~iIlnl(-331I-$middot ~~iIi~1I

1lH1~~l-tJ~liIIU5~ ClllJ~11lt bull rili~lII~fIII~~Iplusmn~ 41I11 ~~illit$BIIt~~~~~~l~tiillit o~

19 U S C

sect 2411

( a) (S

up

p IV

1986 )

~

~~

I 10~1lllmji(o~ I ~~

I ~~iE~~ tJIIgc~Jl~I IO~1ebull lQ~HJ~f$-R~Illlo-middot$~ I liIJlilmiddot

mWltHtl~~lIi1t1ltl~~~-3jQ~~~ll1+k=l~~~a j~_$l~ ~

~~iiiC~IiI~~bull

bull0

0

l$~~llg~tmt1E-~ ( foreign market value) ~ttli$ o

1mIIKnI[~~~~Itli~~~ r lt~JI J m~~~ ~11

lift~m~~~~-3jbullbull~~~~~~~ff~om~II[~jl(lii~~~

bullbull~Q1c~~IIKnI[~~~lEiSli$~~t1-o

--------

-

W IWMi- Ill IIWdeg

Sf-Jiamplt 111 g~rdeg III F II tl dlt ~ If 1i~ if fsect1 m IW fli bull ~J~~

= ~ degIW 2i f lIT V Wi yenm It-M

+rul mamp ~ +-i1iif f~ filt ~mi1i~ fi rl~ amplj -Ntyen4l1T~ ~~ Mill r~ ~ M~-

~ 0 W1fgJ filtm bull

r1 ~ Wlfl 1W~ij 1( fsect1j ftlli1ij

J ~~ ~ll gt yen~ _ ~ iii riM ampfilt~l$

iW EJ ~f lfiWIWpound m Mil iilN1H~ ~tl ~= poundpound iW filt ~~ ~H Ji1i 3yenWJ ~filt EtfIW lJ1lN~ W rIfsect1 ~ayenm ~N ltJ ~ r~ ~ amp IWH frEt lIT ampWfiig if jtl Myeni1I JII if filt bull hlf ~ 2i= 1 4 WIIE-tfi1i yenIt II=~E-tQj $if Wit tli1iMlt_II JiW 1llt1lCi E( ~~ tl sectlWifif l ~$ if~ yenf If Zl If 1WYfr -JI ii1W

III jifgJ ~yen-IIWWfsect1 iyenl ~ o_~JJ

m ~ii wlW lPJ i1i II Ja If w ~ II myen r1Wrt- l iJrtllf~ ~l~m ~

fglJmll-Nt f if tl if IW

M_ IW yenf J fffI~fj

~If Z II lfj II 1Payen1tifIW w fIl~ N )i3tIl~ ~ if if ~f 4IflfglWiit311ttlZltifJJshy~g~~~ytJ1WAIlfrn fi1L~tlWtl~-fr1IlfiltifWiflWWIf11I~~o~ =W~~a i1irI~rl3t 7Jy J ii -rI QjijIffjr~ _~IIIWO lti1if-Nt~ 1f1W~~

-----------~-~--------

rAt Ifiiii 1Wt ~ ro-shy-1 1JJZ Yitf ~~ tPl-1f IW~ ~

_1if 1IfJ

fU 3t tit ~ If ~o LfffI yenII$ Namp mif4 IW o~

~-

~wJW~~ II 1ifif ~ ~_~ ~ fffI y t ~ t1f fl IW ~ Zpound 1U J tl ifr ~ tll1qEf~~3I~IW 0 ~~ ~ JPIllIl~ if ~ -trw ampIJ II ~ m ~ if e tPl-yenIf

JtPmw lfllf~g~yen4if~JZ-mJ ~ 1f~IIi1ifilt liilMltulf1(lfS~fi Ill 1fl~WJW tl fli i ~ fj a ~ if if ~ - WtP iyeni

iif (ffi1)+i1iWsect1 H~ W wtlitrlILitft 0

J i1irn~1I =~~q~~l1lf~Sf-qfmW~$-r~III~rIf bullbullbull $r~ Ji~Yfr3ti1ioN~yen4 if~yen~~IfJlrn1tl fsect1l1THdS~MWElyen~~II~1I ~~ W ~ ~~t ~3~ IItl mJ ~MM~ iillt~W~ ~

~ryentl~oiflW ~ if hi UII I if if Yfr I ftt ~ -I a r ~1I~1Ifsect1twlW 1tIif~IIJ~gW ~ ~ II IW bull r~ a~lIoif-t --if bull ~ it 1 rlJt~ swr~tllrllW a ltufamp iii 1M hi f~ g 00 -rIIt a iii ~ [ffl - -j r1 ~wrJifj~~Ifrn Jm IWtJ 0

tP amp q II M 11 fU 0

Eyen 8shy ~ EI Il

0 ~ secti ~ It 2 t1feI

~~ 81 1JJ~W ~~ ~ ~fJ -tj ~ y 3iJr f rni lilt ~Jt If ~ ~l ~ ~ ~ y i -a ~ ~ ltu if ~ ~~

o ~ pound t r ~ 8 rllf R o ~

~ tP )8middot ~ ~ J

lilt ~ ~ ~ ~ MIW 8 ij N~~li-m It sect l ~ti~ iii ~ I ji ~ 5l~~

I~~ IW ~3aSca 5 q

0 ~ II ~ ~ I Jill rffl l1lf $ II ~ Ii t1lj ~

0

-Nt if lamp IWq t 1 lfj ib gYfr

bull IW if Ii -~ illif Ilfl

bullEI

aa ~ ff-shy-$I

~ Ci al~

of tltu -c 0

fY ~ -

-k IIi W

~ oj ltI

Illt

~ ~

~ e ~ ltDs tJ 0

gt=l

~ 0

- lt

~ s (5shyt a ~

s ~

i sect

~ S l ~

~ I a

5

fi

~

~

Jap7n _ Trade in Sem

iconductors Rep7rt o

f the Panel G

AT

T D

oc L6309 (M

arch 241988) P

ara 117

tK~~~~AAI~II~~tunMloreg~(1( R

obert 0 K

eoh

ane) 4tlbull

bull-N

( After H

egemony C

ooperation an

d D

iscord

in the W

orld P

olitical Econom

y) I tr-~ ffiil+H~lY$I~~I~~~~tunMl~~~bull

bull~-ll~~mRjL-~rti~~

0 (Jlll I ~

tJOlt-~~IltIsect[~~~-R~l1HIII~iilJllltilfIIm~IilltltK~~~~~tSJ 0 ~~~~~~rj~ G

AT

T 1~lgt~I~~ ( ~

I ~tJl11lt-~ 1 ~tJ~lt-) tr-~ r ~~~$fHIi J till( r ~iiIi~J-~~~)i J ~

~_~~~~ G

AT

T JllliE~~lmfr=~~~+H

~~~M~~~+HtIll(~~+H~~~o~~4tl~I~~~jL-~lltm~IIm~~iE~~~~~bullbull~~~~~N~~

~4tl~~~~Ii~~~IIm~~fltltK~llitIlllaquoltK~~~~~~rti~~~~ ~ fE~~~~lltm~~Il~~~~

~4tlo

~r-- 1 ~lt

Oltl-~tr-~ 1lt1sect[li(~ D~-BI~ltlJ-~~fE~ii~ltilf~tgt(~f~]H~~~tP 0 ~~~~

r ~~tl J (

recipro

city ) ~

~1 ~lt

Olt-~IltIImlBllAAl~~m_~~lmfr~ 0 i

1IlJ-~~~~tl~~~~~N~

r ~$~~+H

J ( m

inilateralism

) ~~~~lieuro~ 1 lmfr~ ~ IltlImm~~~AAI~~~l1Im I

~~~IIm~m_ i~m

~lt-~ middotmiddot1 11lt1II~

0

1tJli~4tl~~iifiIlII~iifiI~1E-$~ll[~ middotmiddotill~~r~~~~t~~~~ o~ 1~lt1(lt-~~~lltm~~~~~tIll(~~)i

tr-~~~iifil1E-~~~~~~~lltlImr~~tlJ~~lmfr~~~bullbull~o

~lltm~~~GATTNIil~ter4lt ~ ~

~rr-lt~~fbull

bull~~

~ ~~rgt(~liK~~l~~~A~ ~ 1II~1ilJlll~~eurolm

~~f~lli~~-tl 0 ~

iitpoundl 1E

- 1lt~

bull JllliE~~lm~~~I~~~~~yen~f~I~bull

bull~ ~~~+HAAIll1~~ii5

0 ~~~I]lm

~~lli~1middota$~m~ fgtlt~ ~~~~bullbull

~ $~f~liI~~~tl-R$~hi~~

0 ~iifillmlf~f~~I~~-R ~ IltIIm~m

1~~~~~~~~sectIi~~1E-

~ nR 1 ~~ffiililfl~tIll( ~ llit~~lm~~I~lli~~NAAImlaquo~~ItEl(~~~~tl 0 ~~

$~ti~~~

~ 1lt1IIiItili$~~-Y4n~ ~ -RliII~IIltIII~f~iR~ ilfltlll(1+iAAl~~~lIIm~~1II 1Im~tr-IIm-K1ilii~~lt~ ~~

~ talillillHj 1

i~IltIIm~+H~~bullbull~

~ bullbull~

1i~~~~~+H~~~~~llisect

Iltm~~)iiifillltlIm~~0

fE11lI ~ ~hi1 $ta~A~it~

0

( ~1ilflt+Imiddot~mI+tlI1~)

~

itm

W

~

Robert G

ilpin The P

olitical amporiom

y of International R

elations (Princeton N

ew JerseyP

rinceton University P

ress 1987) p 364

Robert O

K

eohane After H

elJmony C

ooperation an

d D

iscord in the World P

olitical Econom

y (Princeton N

ew Jersey P

rinceton University

Press 1984)

Gilpin op cit p372

$IIIttflf--III11f1l~A

IT~ir

lt11

~

~

~

Jap7n _ Trade in Sem

iconductors Rep7rt o

f the Panel G

AT

T D

oc L6309 (M

arch 241988) P

ara 117

tK~~~~AAI~II~~tunMloreg~(1( R

obert 0 K

eoh

ane) 4tlbull

bull-N

( After H

egemony C

ooperation an

d D

iscord

in the W

orld P

olitical Econom

y) I tr-~ ffiil+H~lY$I~~I~~~~tunMl~~~bull

bull~-ll~~mRjL-~rti~~

0 (Jlll I ~

tJOlt-~~IltIsect[~~~-R~l1HIII~iilJllltilfIIm~IilltltK~~~~~tSJ 0 ~~~~~~rj~ G

AT

T 1~lgt~I~~ ( ~

I ~tJl11lt-~ 1 ~tJ~lt-) tr-~ r ~~~$fHIi J till( r ~iiIi~J-~~~)i J ~

~_~~~~ G

AT

T JllliE~~lmfr=~~~+H

~~~M~~~+HtIll(~~+H~~~o~~4tl~I~~~jL-~lltm~IIm~~iE~~~~~bullbull~~~~~N~~

~4tl~~~~Ii~~~IIm~~fltltK~llitIlllaquoltK~~~~~~rti~~~~ ~ fE~~~~lltm~~Il~~~~

~4tlo

~r-- 1 ~lt

Oltl-~tr-~ 1lt1sect[li(~ D~-BI~ltlJ-~~fE~ii~ltilf~tgt(~f~]H~~~tP 0 ~~~~

r ~~tl J (

recipro

city ) ~

~1 ~lt

Olt-~IltIImlBllAAl~~m_~~lmfr~ 0 i

1IlJ-~~~~tl~~~~~N~

r ~$~~+H

J ( m

inilateralism

) ~~~~lieuro~ 1 lmfr~ ~ IltlImm~~~AAI~~~l1Im I

~~~IIm~m_ i~m

~lt-~ middotmiddot1 11lt1II~

0

1tJli~4tl~~iifiIlII~iifiI~1E-$~ll[~ middotmiddotill~~r~~~~t~~~~ o~ 1~lt1(lt-~~~lltm~~~~~tIll(~~)i

tr-~~~iifil1E-~~~~~~~lltlImr~~tlJ~~lmfr~~~bullbull~o

~lltm~~~GATTNIil~ter4lt ~ ~

~rr-lt~~fbull

bull~~

~ ~~rgt(~liK~~l~~~A~ ~ 1II~1ilJlll~~eurolm

~~f~lli~~-tl 0 ~

iitpoundl 1E

- 1lt~

bull JllliE~~lm~~~I~~~~~yen~f~I~bull

bull~ ~~~+HAAIll1~~ii5

0 ~~~I]lm

~~lli~1middota$~m~ fgtlt~ ~~~~bullbull

~ $~f~liI~~~tl-R$~hi~~

0 ~iifillmlf~f~~I~~-R ~ IltIIm~m

1~~~~~~~~sectIi~~1E-

~ nR 1 ~~ffiililfl~tIll( ~ llit~~lm~~I~lli~~NAAImlaquo~~ItEl(~~~~tl 0 ~~

$~ti~~~

~ 1lt1IIiItili$~~-Y4n~ ~ -RliII~IIltIII~f~iR~ ilfltlll(1+iAAl~~~lIIm~~1II 1Im~tr-IIm-K1ilii~~lt~ ~~

~ talillillHj 1

i~IltIIm~+H~~bullbull~

~ bullbull~

1i~~~~~+H~~~~~llisect

Iltm~~)iiifillltlIm~~0

fE11lI ~ ~hi1 $ta~A~it~

0

( ~1ilflt+Imiddot~mI+tlI1~)

~

itm

W

~

Robert G

ilpin The P

olitical amporiom

y of International R

elations (Princeton N

ew JerseyP

rinceton University P

ress 1987) p 364

Robert O

K

eohane After H

elJmony C

ooperation an

d D

iscord in the World P

olitical Econom

y (Princeton N

ew Jersey P

rinceton University

Press 1984)

Gilpin op cit p372

$IIIttflf--III11f1l~A

IT~ir

lt11

~