14
ª Ä 0 * Î y : Z ` ; ñ à * e Z Ë ] . ú Š Z ú Z y Abstract Intellectual discourse and divergence of opinions about the partition of Indo Sub-continent and the creation of two separate independent states of India and Pakistan can be classified into four major categories so far as the present study is concerned. An unbiased and impartial approach has been applied to design the theoretical framework of this study keeping in view the four major opinions i.e. to observe the creation of Pakistan in the light of (i) International Rivalry between Communism and Capitalism (ii) Economic Controversy between Agriculturalists and Industrialists (iii) Divide and Rule Policy of the British Colonial Empire and (iv) Ideological Basis. Each of the opinion with its own interesting features tries to define and interpret the establishment of Pakistan in its own way. Taking a holistic view of the partition in general and analyzing the creation of Pakistan in the light of different views in particular is the hallmark of this academic endeavour. ) 9 4 9 1 X 5 4 9 1 ( Æ ˆ * ~ ú c * V ( Ï Ô ç Ù Ô ç Ñ C 1 Š z u ~ ¬ à k B Z z g ' Z 5 ð p ´ V g z ú ƒ N X * Æ ' 6 , F 6 ˜ ´ Z ½ W ñ Z z g ( , ~ ( , ~ à g z / i z Z w ƒ N X Z Ï Æ Ë ~ ' , R 0 * u z y à W i Z Š ~ B Z z g 7 4 9 1 Y ~ W i Z Š ~ Å Ã Ä Ð Š z W i Z Š Z z g p Š U g ˜ ´ y z * y Z z g 0 * Î y ä À 1 X Î Z Ñ ¸ Z ò R 6 , W ä z Z à Z k â q Å Z Ò p = V Ô q Š U * ] c * z Z u ] Æ ú Á z c g ^ a S Ô ¸ ò Z Š Z g { ' , Z ñ ï @ * g õ z p Ä 0 * Î y Ô Z + Z W - E g ; Ô Z s x W ! * Š X *

06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

ªÄ0*Îyþ:Z`;ñÃ

* eeeeZZZZËËËË‚‚‚‚]]]]....úúúúŠŠŠŠZZZZúúúúZZZZyyyy

Abstract

Intellectual discourse and divergence of opinions about the

partition of Indo Sub-continent and the creation of two separate

independent states of India and Pakistan can be classified into four

major categories so far as the present study is concerned. An

unbiased and impartial approach has been applied to design the

theoretical framework of this study keeping in view the four major

opinions i.e. to observe the creation of Pakistan in the light of (i)

International Rivalry between Communism and Capitalism (ii)

Economic Controversy between Agriculturalists and Industrialists

(iii) Divide and Rule Policy of the British Colonial Empire and (iv)

Ideological Basis. Each of the opinion with its own interesting

features tries to define and interpret the establishment of Pakistan in

its own way. Taking a holistic view of the partition in general and

analyzing the creation of Pakistan in the light of different views in

particular is the hallmark of this academic endeavour.

)9491X5491(ƈ™*~úc*V(ÏÔçÙÔçÑC 1111 Šzu~¬àkB

Zzg'Z5ðp´VgzúƒNX™*Æ'6,F6˜´Z½WñZzg(,~(,~àgz/izZwƒNXZÏÆË~',R0*uzyÃWiZŠ~BZzg7491Y~WiZŠ~ÅÃÄЊzWiZŠZzgpŠUg˜´yz*yZzg0*ÎyäÀ1XÎ

ZÑZòR6,WäzZàZkâqÅZÒp=VÔqŠU*]c*zZu]ÆúÁzc

‘g^aSÔ¸òZŠZg{',Zñï@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ‡Z+ZW-Eg;ÔZsxW!*ŠX *

Page 2: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

Zq-„§bÆZò[zC»g�Ûâ¸X@*ëCÙ´ºÆßÍVZzgCÙ¸xÆúÒzVäZyp=VÃZK»zØVÔ].z4Zzg�gq-»%ƒy5â**ÔŒ

pŠ*Æ(ÏçÙZzgçÑC‹tógzVäZ7ZLZL 2222 ZzgŒÛZgŠc*XºmZ0+Z¯„Æ:©~Š¬ZzgZ,zZu]ÅZÂù]ů6,Z7ZZò[zC»³ŒÛZgŠc*X¼Z(„çn&)Ó½ïGL0*ÎyÆz�Š~Wä»ÌìXZZ0+Z¯„ÐmgppzZáßÍVäZÐZZ0+Zi~Š¬Zzg

Ì÷Xz, „Š ZCZC`ÃÒyHX�Zq-Šzu}Ð:ÜsZÉæìZâ!*ÂVÆ]ZtZkK~FWgZY0*ðYC÷XpZyÓxWgZYÃëeg(,}`;ñÃ~„™Mh÷X

Z·ZKZzguâtŠZgZ:ÂxÆŠgxyÎZÑZò83¨Òø FGGIX 1XInternational Rivalry Between Communism and Capitalism.

Å»gZzgiŒZg6~çÙ“X 2XEconomic Controvery Between Agriculturists and Industrialists

',¤â~‚%Z`Å„™zZzgÓ#Ö™zÅ0*ŒX 3XDivide and Rule Policy of the British Empire

Ãc*ããCŠX 4XIdeological Basis

tz{Z`;ñÃ÷�ªx0*ÎyÃZLZLZ0+Zi~ŠÙ÷X¬`ûŠú~ìāTŠzg~',RÃWiZŠ~BZkŠzg~™*ÆŠz(,}çÙZzg(ÏÂñVÆŠgxyÎZÑZò83¨Òø EGGIizgzV6,¶)Ë~',R

ÃzZuoÅOñŠzZzgÜsŠz„˜´Åßg]~WiZŠ~BZzg0*Îy»ªx¿~WeXzg:ZÐZq-„oª�{yz*yÅßg]~WiZŠ~Q

c*Qyz*yFZq-gKgKgc*2Vª˜´~„ƒ™WiZŠƒ@*XZm,¼-VìāÎÛ,œ~{~~-g8™*~QZz[WäÅzz

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y _____________________________________ 48

Page 3: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

ÐZQ˜´~çÙŠzhÑzqƒð�ˆ~(Ï£«Åßg]Z(g™ˆXŠgZÝZ#-g\~QZz[Wc*Âz;VÅÅÃ`äÆ

(ZêZL”V~£/lZg~ Raw matecal nig¦Zzgn*C{xâw)x:åXZzgŠzu}˜´Ð{xâwyh+™ZKÅÃ`**Zênߊq

c*‡&ÿELJw:åX®ZZrVä‚%Z`»gz\Š;gäZzg¾d$˜´6,ï

Šc*T‚%ZÛA (¯ä»ŸÑzq™ Empires ™Æ(,~(,~à)Zy‚%ZY¤!Vä$zg˜´ÃZCÝx 3333X (ÅãCŠ7,~ Empekialism)

(¯1XÑzqÑzq~Z½äzZà¤!V~6,…wÔzßm,Ô�ÛZ÷Zzg Colony)',¤6÷áï÷X

(Ã�ÛzrŠïƒñ™*ƽãÓx¾d$ Colonialism MVä)˜´ÃZCÝx¯1Xz;VÐ{xâwZ‰™ÆZKÅ`DZzg¡¬]

(¯™Z7QŠZñV�Ûz|#™DZk§b¾d$˜´Å Final Products)Z»kÔigZùÔz‚bZzgŠzªCÙqu%ZY¤!VÅ!k�ˆXZSbZk

(Æ�¾d$o¾d$оd$F,ZzgZ÷ Capitalism uâtŠZgZ:Âx)(Zzg¾d$ Haves oZ÷ÐZ÷F,ƒD‰X™*Šz(,}4]ªZ÷)

gzi',zi(,fƒðZk4CÔçÙÔçÑCZzg 4444 (~#$™g{ˆX Have nots)(ϸ&Zzg·z]Æg›¿Æîg6,gzk~Zq-6ÂxäZ·K

(Åßg]~À1XZzgŠy$+y:Üs¢oÉuâtŠZgZ: Communism)ÂxÆ�

²CÑõN

FƒñßÍVc}Åßg]~CÙŠ+m,ƒ@*ŠHXZ[tŠzâVÂxªuâtŠZgZ:ZzgZ·ZKZq-Šzu}Å¡¸XuâtŠZgZ:ÂxÅñ�ŠÏ~Z·ZK‡ì7ƒ$˲Z·ZKÆÂx~uâtŠZg6ÅÃðRö7¶Éz{',Z',~ÆZßw6,CÙ�ÛŠc',Z',ñZµZzg£tÆ‚B‚BuâtZzgz‚bÆœāZÜZs»bŠZgìXZ[Z·ZK»gziZ‚ÛzV(,kƒZZW,z

58 _______________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 4: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

Ói™*ÆuâtŠZg6ÃZKñ]Åßg]~ÃWg;åX®ZZkäZKÓx&¬»Zzgz‚bZ·ZKÆ{8ÔZzgaÐZ3häZzgZn°x;î

Šzu~Y+$ÎZÑZòR6,Zq-Zzg(,~ 5555 (6,%Ãi™ŠbX containment)~ÌQZz[gzúƒŠHÔpZkz‰ÜJ-‚g~ 2222 p~tāP'×h+˜´

Å‚g~)F,¹c*Cc*F,¹5+k,™*6,Zy‚%ZY¤!V»ïƒ[åX5Z½äzZàQ¤!VÃZKÅ`äcP¤xªÝx¸ñV

(Å¢zg]¶˜VÐz{{xâwá™ZKÅÃ�ÛzrŠ} Colonies)Redistribution ) ÃXZrVäZkz‰ÜÅ‚%ZY¤!VдVÅ5„

(»_cH�āQrV䤉ÜÆizg6,u}ÐgŠ™Šc*X of Colonies

âñߊ¤!VÆZâ0*k¯YZzg(Ϥ‰Ü:¶āz{‡ì”{‚%ZY¤!VУ¨™Æt´ºáÃX®ZZrVä£Ð:ÉŠ,ÐÆZßw6,¿™DƒñtÎa™kB™ä»ê™1āeìët´º

(Zy¤!VÐá:ÌÃpëZ7Qêï~g�Ì7 Colonies)Š,ÐX®Z¾d$ZZxÅZkÈg!*.$ZzgQz‚%ZY¤!VÅZk!*b

çÙZzg(Ï“ä™*Êz¬@lVÿ¬@kBZzw)8191X4191(Zzg¬@6666 kBŠzx)5491X9391(ÅWv~Ñ7-Šc*X

³z„ƒZ,âñߊQ¤ÐZyÎñ$‰Zzg!hÐ*î OQ¤!VÃZmµ:¶X®ZZ¤/tŠz¬@(:ƒ'ÉZ¤/ÓZKYg;:m7À.ïGL

iÐZy‚%ZY¤!VÅ#:Âh@*Š~™*ÅÝx¸ñVÃÌWiZŠ~:QZÏnÓÊ~™*»7gc*‹z¹Y@*ìX

:Z#@*•',¤6Å#I^_Zzgz{Zk´º6,ïgppƇ.Þ:g;ÂZkäŒVÐå3ZzgZk´ºÃWiZŠ~Š¶cZ(ÑÇ¿»g™äÎ)�t´‘w~Z·KÆi%çGL‚tW™ÂxZ·ZK»z:0

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 68

Page 5: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

nXYèZkßg]~gzkä/x0*EVc*Ô0*EVJ-ì{²[Zzg+?ç ELyÆfg)g‚ð$ÿ LYCXt!*]ZkŠzgÅìZ#z„¸~™*6,Ó#Ö™C‰�™*Æ0*EV6,gZ`™C‰ZzggzkÃ�XƒÐic*Š{Šg7åXz{tåāZ¤/pgzkÅ=q™*~(,|g„¶pZmg‚ðÔ0*EVJ-

:¶X�«gZÐxåz{‚gZuŠ0*ãª',sÅßg]~3ƒñ«gÅ^~åX

8g)4è EG˜igZãe:¶�āgzkÅF,¹ZzgZ·ZKÆ�Ûzr®ZgzkÆŠzgZ5¸Zq-yz*yÆfg) 8888 ~Zq-(,~g»z^¶X

ì{²[J-ZzgŠzuZZk,ZyÆfg)UÃgkJ-XZyŠzâV~W‚yF,+Zzgñ*.çJIF,+gZ3yz*yÆfg)ì{²[J-åXZÏg5Æ”wcgzk

9999 äZk´º~',¤6Ð&(±,Xpz{t´‘8¢~**»xg;XZ[Z#@*•',¤6Šz¬@lVÆË~ZK$zg~Æ;ðVZk

´ºÐå36,6gƒŠHÂZkäÎeāZk´ºÃZk§bWiZŠ~Š}™YñāZq-Ât´‘ZÏÆi%çGL‚tìZzgŠzuZgzkZk´º6,ï:™nXZk´ºÅZKqªt¶ātZylèZ<ØÔYVÔfZÂVXVZzg¸ñV~J7,ZåXTƒÃ',¤6äZLŠz§Ó#ÖÃîwŠ¶cpŠÌ

ƒZŠ~¶XZ[}.˜tåāZ¤/',¤6ZÐZÏqª~gh™`ŠHÂt´‘FgKgKZzg$zggc*2V~„ƒ™g{YñÇXT6,gzk(,~W‚ã

˧jÐì{²[J-VŠHÂZÐ7g~ 4444 Ðï™áÇXZzgZ¤/gzk®Z',¤6äZygKgK¸ñVà 00001111 ™*6,ï™äÐÃð7gzunÇX

Zq-(,~yz*ã¸x~æ™äÅÃÒÅ8g)4è EGz{(,~uJ-»x[Ìg;

Z%z{(,~Šz¸hVªyzZzg›âVÆ�Ûtû:™eX&pŠZkä(Æîg6,ZEwHXZzgZk´ºÃŠz Blessing in disguise

$™.ïEGL7æ{)Z,˜´Åßg]~WiZŠH�åZq-Šzu}ÆŠÔg÷ÐZzgYD

78 ______________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 6: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

YDZ7$©o-êGG

GLº[Ô$©o-êGG

GLXwÔòÔ�**¥/|ZzgozZŠg‰Z,)bghŠH�11111111 ZéŠ#ÃZŠïg÷ÐX

¹Y@*ìŠÔZKyÅ’Y»Ÿðƒ@*ìXªZLŠÔÆ£«~

ZLW\Ãå¢oТoF,™**ZKyÅ6g~c*$zg~0YCì�Zm’YÊzZx#ì®ZtŠzâVŠÔoZq-Šzu}Æ£«cZLW\Ã

¢ogOÐZzgZÏ£«~Z·ZK»Ì¸W,§jЂo™Dg÷ÐZzg:„Zã¢oƒYNÐāÀ',¤6ÄW@Š3ä'Xä

�{yz*yÅßg]~}.˜åXZϯ6,',¤6äZKZ·ZKÅæZf(Å0*Œ6,¿™Dƒñ',RÊzZzg Containment of Commussism)

22221111 ÜsŠz„”Vªyz*yZzg0*ÎyÅßg]~WiZŠHXZk`ÃÅZq-Šzu~Š?tìāgzkäZϵ"ªì{²[J-g‚ðqÝ™äc9791Yâ~Zjjîy6,úH@*āZjjîy6,ï™äƈ0*Îy6,ï™ÆÍZŠgZzg™ZcÆfg)ì{²[Zzg+?ç ELyJ-g‚ðqÝ™ÆuâtŠZgZ:ÂxÃaÐZ3h9puâtŠZgZ:ÂxÆbŠZgZ%MZzg',¤6äo0*ÎyÆfg)gzkÊk‚wJ-Zjjîy„Z{ñ

33331111 g3XÉz÷6,ZkÅa,Z3hŠ,X®ZZ¤/ZyŠzÂñVªuâtŠZgZ:ÂxZzgZ·ZKÆŠgxytÎ

ZÑZò¿:ƒCÂ÷áh+',¤6yz*yÃFgLgL”VÅßg]~

WiZŠ™ÆY@*c*QZЄ(,}oÅßg]~WiZŠ~‚ƒCXª

0*Îy»ªx÷áZ+ñ�Š{ßg]qw~¿~:W@*X

ÙÙÙÙggggZZZZzzzzggggiiiiŒŒŒŒZZZZgggg6666~~~~ççççÙÙÙÙ““““þþþþþþþþ:::: 2222XXXXEconomic Controversy between Agriculturists and Industrialists

Zk`ÃÆqqV»ìwìāyz*yÅ„Zzg0*Îy»ªx

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 88

Page 7: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

ŠgZÝQkŠzgÆiŒZg6ZzgÙg6Å!*bçÙ“ZzgZ%s»³ìX6ā¬ÒyHY[ìā',¤â~‚%Z`ÆŒVWäZzgZk´º6,ï™ä»(,ZøuŒVÐ{xâwZ‰™ÆY**åXZzgZKÅÃ�ÛzrŠbåXz{ŒVÐZzä7äŠZñV{xâwáYDZzgQ¡¬]ŒV

QŠZñV�Ûz|#™DXZk§bŒVÆfgZùaZzZgÆ‚B‚Bz‚bZzgŠzªÌZy´V~vƒCYg„¶Xz‰Ü¦/gäÆ‚B‚BZ#

',¤â~ZëZŠŒV7g~§bLƒŠHÂZkäÎeāŒVÐ{xâwZ‰

™ÆDÙZgzVéŠzg‹™�Ûz|#™ä6,¹‚…Zzgz‰Üyaƒ@*ìXZzgtŠzâVq,QZzg»gz!*g~™*~(,~ZÌÅqï÷XYV:ZKÅ

D6,ÎðYñXDÐ{xâwZ‰™ÆD6,Q¡¬]»gÅYNXZkÐ:ÜsˆgCZyZY]ª{xâwZzg¡¬]ÅWæzgÄ6,yaƒäzZÑ…Zzgz‰ÜaÇÉo«ÅÑb̹ic*Š{(,|YñÏX®Z

(‡ì™äÅÎcXZke Industrial Zones ZrVäD6,Q´º)~ZrVäZ’Zðîg6,X&´V»ZN[HZy~™**S-Ô®Zzg›

Yèt´ºgsÔvÃVZzgd~gZ2VÆig):Üs7g} 44441111 ÷áï¸Xyz*yÉÛzã™*ÐÌݸc*KYMh¸Zzg7g}yz*yÐ{xâwZy´VJ-Zzg»g”{¡¬]:Üs7g}yz*yÉ™*ÆŠzu}´VJ-Ì!*W‚ãàðY$ˉX

Šzu~§sig¦Z»kÅßg]~q݃äzZá{xâwÅF,−Ã(,JäcZrVäŒV6,Zq-zWz²!ig¦Zzg1~ÂxÅãCŠeZàX

)nig¦ÒpÐig&´‘ªŠgc*ñ�|ÆyZã´º»ZN[ƒZXZSbyz*yŠz 55551111 ®ZZrVäŒV6,™*»ƒÐ(,}1~Âx‡ìHX

(ªQZzgig¦~„ƒŠHX Zones (,}´V)

98 _______________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 8: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

Zk„~Q´ºŠgCîg6,yzZÒî´º²ig¦´º›ZÒî¸XQZzgig¦5V~¡~îg6,Zq-çÙZzgçÑC“gSì

YètŠzâV6ÌZq-Šzu}Å¡÷XZ¤/ig¦Âx¢ogìÇÂQ

F,¹:ƒ0*ñÏXYèiŒZgZzgY�ŠZg¡LÌZL´ºÆßÍVÃÅ~»x™äÅZYi]:Š,ÐIŠZāZêúZxc*g¬c*Æ0*kçÙ

ñZµWäÐZ7½ZzgÅg:WYñZzgz{Zéa@gZ?ØÔY�ŠZg~ZzgZëZg66661111 ÆÝsWzZi:9~™Š,X

Šzu~Y+$Ùg6»¢ŠZ›ìāßvWiZŠZ:îg6,ZmÅ~

»x™,XZ¤/Y�ŠZg~Âx‡ìg;ÂÃðZéÅ~»x™ä:WñÇZzgÅ:^nÏX®Zz{Z7½Zzg¡Æ‚B‚B]¢zgc*]i0+Ï

77771111 �ÛZë™ÆZ7Å~»x™äÅic*Š{Ðic*Š{F,(Š}ÇXZk§bд‡ðZzg&zZgZ:„z‰ÜÆ‚B‚B4C„»g8-

ŠJgˆXÙg¡WiZŠ~ÔZKã£tÔ£¾²ZVÔ½Ô¡ÔWiZŠ„gZñZzg(Æ‚B‚B/ge$Zzg/g~gzZc*]»bŠZg0™ Modernism ].])

(ÅgzlÆ‚B].h+½ Traditionalism Z½ZX²ig¦¡gzZe$I~)Њzg~pZ&c6,Š{ÔeŠgZzgegŠ-Zg~ÔpÄÅ0*‡Zg~ZzggzZîè<ØÐ

].] ÎîÅ^~gzZe$I¡0™Z½XÙg¡ZzgiŒZg¡Åt„(4]Ÿ&~psƒ Traditionalist (ZzggzZe$I) Modernist I)

ˆXZ[5881âY~Z#yz*yÅ«(Ï)®)ªZ&++D»ôö‡ìƒðÂÙg¡�ā¬„].]IZzgCÙ5WäzZàqÃplWæh+ì

zZÑåä²£ÑõN

ŠwÐZ›Ñ•(gŲiŒZg6äZm#¿Å&4-CéEG

GESt99991111 ÙgZÒe$c*Šzu}ZÖp~yzZÒî0*gK0™g{ˆX

Šzu~Y+$iŒZg¡äZL¢ŠZ]ÆDcZ#6091âY~Ww

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 09

Page 9: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

Z&+c*›>Æ**xÐZK)®)‡ìÅÂZrVäZk~ÑZ•ÅZq-„Ñog¿Zzgz{Zq-{mlZg~i}Å!¶ZkK~½ÔWæyc*Ãð

@*ëˆZiZV3191âY~ 00002222 ZzgçÙÔçÑCc*èIŠgzÈ~Åp{§:g¿ˆXÑZ•ÅÑZ_~p~™ÆZq-‡.ÞZzgñ*.çJIzV·Z»bÃZk0*gK~

11112222 ÷áïHŠH@*āz{Zk6Åñ*.çJIúÒÏ™ÆZê_]]ëZnX5391âYÆZlÆ�ƒäzZá73X6391ÆZN!*]~“WzZà

Ó#ÖÆŠŠ!*]Zzg9391âY~Šzu~¬@kBÆ{8ƈ',¤â~‚%Z`ÅŠxÂhCÓ#ÖäSkgzZe$I¡Ã»°6,.y™Šc*XZzgZrV

I~ÆgziZ‚ÛzV(,_ ].] äÙg6Ågzi',zi(,fƒð¤‰ÜZzgƒñÃc*]ÃZLY�ŠZgZ:Âxc”h+ç{CkHZzgZLnZq-Z´ohe»êH˜Vz{ZCY�ŠZgZ:Âx‡ìgÄÃX!*syz{Zq-Z(´‘

®Z 22222222 qÝ™ä~»x[ƒ‰˜V6,ZïY�ŠZgZ:ÂxW`J-‡ììXZk$½540î

GEJL„ÆßÍV»ÃttìāªÄ0*ÎyŠgZÝY�ŠZgc*gzZe$6,„

¡ÆZLfZC¢ŠZ]Æ”wZzgDÅÃÒÆË~¿~Wc*X

'''',,,,¤¤¤¤ââââ~~~~‚‚‚‚%%%%ZZZZ`ÅÅÅÅ„„„„™™™™zzzzZZZZzzzzggggÓÓÓÓ####ÖÖÖÖ™™™™zzzzÅÅÅÅ0000****ŒŒŒŒ:::: 3333XXXXDivide and Rule Policy of the Britishers Empire

Zk`ÃÆqñV»ìwìāªÄ0*Îyc*WiZŠ~Æz‰Üy*yÅŠz”V~„ŠgZÝ',¤6Å„™zZzgÓ#Ö™zÅ0*Œ»³ìZïItìā',¤â~Z#ˆg]žnÐZk´º~WñÂZk´ºÃ

(Gloden Sparow fgZùZzgz‚bÐâÑâwŠN™ZrVäZÐÎäÅmc*)ZzgZkÆ~6,âW»êHXZ(™**ZÏßg]eåāz{ 33332222 »**xŠc*X

Zk´º6,ï™B�āZÚW‚y»x:åXZrVäŠzgZȈg]ZkZ%»Y,{1āAt(,ZoìZzgCÙnÆz‚bÐâÑâwìZÚ„Zk~

19 ________________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 10: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

çÑCàqÉ·z]0*c*Y@*ìXªŒV6,Zg8-Ô±Ôi!*yÔ¸èZzgè<ØÆßvW!*Š÷�āF'×h+çÑCÔçÙÔÕãZzg(Ï4]ZzgŠgz

ÃZ+{ZVäÅ Ð È-V~„÷X®ZZrVäZyÓxµ‡]Zzg¸‹]VãZzgZq-gc*„Êzu~gc*„ÐÔZq-¸èÊzu~¸èÐÔZq-±ÃŠzu~±ÔZq-¡ÃŠzu}¡Ð8-ö

GWāZq-è<ØÆâ+zZßVÊzu}ÅzzÐ 83¨Òið FEGIV è<ØÆcz»gzVÐ(,~e,-Š4бzZŠc*ZzgZé!*b

ZyÓx4]äZ#Zôm,ÅZk 44442222 ZÚ$zg™Šc*āpŠZy6,‡*ƒÆX(War of Independence) ewÃËuJ-™1ÂZrVäZôm,zVÆÜs

Ô~‘ÐêLŒz]—HXt’q-7g}yz*y~ Y 85ë EEYLWiZŠ~Æ**xÐ7581âZzg8i�ç EbCÙz{’q-�»x[ƒYñZz[ kÅWvŧb’ˆ

BCìpZ¤/z„’q-**»xƒYñÂŒz]Æ**xЙ[ÅYCìaèt’q-ÌZL£œ~»x[:ƒmZzgZôm,äZKz„„™zZzgÓ#Ö™zÅ0*ŒZC™ZÐ(,~ik,uŠ4ÐÊc*XZrVäZÐŒz]

»**xŠc*ZzgZKÓ#ÖÃZPxÛZzgWÒ{ËÌZ+ (Revolt of India) y’q-c*Œz]ÐvcZrVäZKgzZî7À.ïGLiª„™zZzgÓ#Ö

ZzgZ#z{Zk´ºÐzZ:YäÑÂZrVä!*¹ 55552222 ™z6,¿Yg~g3X¸$43ðGGVÃÂZL(Ï¢ŠZ]Æ”wÅ{§1Z‰™1pŠz(,~¸$43ðGGVª

yzZzg›yŸ&ÃZL„¢ŠZ]Å{§ƒZŠ}Š~ZzgSyŠzâV”VÃZkßg]èqw~WiZŠHāz{:ÜsW:~Š„z0*g÷ÉåZkÆ%ƒÈ5÷X®ZZrVä',RÃ�{yz*yÅßg]~WiZŠ™äÅOñZЊz¤™Šc*X„™zZzgÓ#Ö™zÅZk0*Œ»ŸD7g»

',¤6ZzgZ%MÅZÏ0*ŒÅzzЈ~0*Îy'×h+Šz”V~„ ɃŠHX

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 29

Page 11: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

ÃÃÃÃcccc****CCCCããããCCCCŠŠŠŠ 4444XXXXIdeogical Basis

aåZzgî`ÃtìāªÄ0*ÎyÅZ‚k{ØÃc*CãCŠzV6,

Zzgªx0*ÎyÅßg]~Zk$�çE

b»Z:tZKZ’Zð^Ðñ�Š{ 66662222 ìXßg]~·~VзZ»bJ-ìX$š-ö

GEz{Ãt�ÑWyO²ây·~V(ªvg} Ö³Ó³Ü�mßÓÜæÖo�mà 175âY~Zk™*~á™WñXZzgZrVä)

nvgZgZ3Zzg÷}n÷ZgZ3X»Z´y™ÆŠz¸òÃb»Z’ZðZÖgZnˆ 77772222 si~HZzg™*Å«Ãc*Cgc*„ÅãCŠæÜëg{~g¿X

gZ”+ñäZkÃtÙ*ÆŠzu}´VJ-àä»f)1XZÏ #ñö~·ñ»Šc*ƒZ¸�x³·0‡Ì117âY~yz*yWc*Znˆ

¦zVÔߊÉVZzg!*sy¦VäZÏ�x —VÔ$›Ò©ðGEGVÔ çâ-VÔ¨g-VÔÝñVÔ

88882222 ÃZLZLZ0+Zi~!*Ç™äZzgZn�ÛzrÅCÙeÃÒÅX6021âY~‡ìƒäzZàyz*yÅ«›Ó#Öг7581âYJ-Ë

:Ëßg]~ZkÃb»6,egYg~g;X@*ëZôm,Šz§Ó#Ö~›**È',RäZLZkÃbÃ$zgiƒDƒñCkHÂZLnZq-Zµzí»

,ãCŠZ4ZßßV6, 99992222 (ÃŒÛZgŠc*X Ÿø]ôÖ³³äF]ôÖ׳ä _cHTÅZ‚kZrVä)ƒÏXZßßV6,W`Ð4941‚w¬·~Vä™*Å«Ãc*Cgc*„ÅãCŠ136Yâ~g¿XZzgZkgc*„ƪxÿ~Ñä»x»g**)·~VÆZq-**æZgcz»gäZC**xÌ·„媇Z+ZW·Z»bäuZ�xŠc*X

®ZZk`ÃÆ_.ªÄ0*ÎyŠgZÝZq-@*g]ö»**xì�·~Vз0‡ÌZzg·0‡ÌзZ»bJ-ìX

39 _______________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 12: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

jZ!Y]zjZÙÃQgŠz~ZÒkBx–Zzg7,JY@*ìX' (World War) ¬@kB 1X

BZ85ë EEYLxÆÂÐZ·t7™@*Yèx»{āZðÆ‚Bµ[ƒ»F,À¬@kB„™@*ìX World War YìkBÆ‚B7X®Zz{

2. Gunnar Myrdal, Asian Drama: An Enquiry into the Poverty of

Nations, Vol. 1969, 133; Arthur Meier Schlesinger Jr. General

Editor, Vol. 2, The Dynamics of World Power, A Documentary of

United States foreign policy 1945-1973, (New York: Chelsea House

Publishers, 1973), 166-69.

3. Rajani Palme Dutt, The Crises of Britain and the British Empire

(London: Lawrence & Wishart Ltd., 1957); William Warbey , M.P.,

Vietnam The Truth (London: Merlin Press, 1965), 26-30; D. F.

Flemming, The Cold War and its Origins, 1917-1960 (New York:

Doubleday, 1967), Vol. 1, 300-10.

4. Schlesinger, The Dynamics of World Power, 191-95; A. Z. Minfred,

A Short History of the World Progress (Moscow: Progress

Publishers, 1974).

5. Niall Ferguson, Empire: How Britain Made the Modern World (New

York: Penguin, 2004); Andre Fontain, History of the Cold War from

the October Revolution to the Korean War (New York: Pantheon

Books, 1968).

6. Ferguson, Empire: How Britain Made the Modern World; Fontain,

History of the Cold War from the October Revolution to the Korean

War.

7. Lloyed C. Gardner, A Covenant with Power: America and World

order from Wilson to Reagon (New York: Knopf, 1984); Abulkalam

Azad, India Wins Freedom (Calcutta: Orient Longmans, 1964);

8. Mao-tse Tung, Selected Works of Maotse Tung (Peking: Foreign

Language Press, 1963); Noor Ahmed, Martial Law se Martial Law

Tak [[Urdu: From Martial Law to Martial Law] (Lahore, 1966).

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 49

Page 13: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

9. Gardner, A Covenant with Power; Tung, Selected Works of Maotse

Tung.

10. Gardner, A Covenant with Power; Fontain, History of the Cold War

from the October Revolution to the Korean War.

11. Russel Briens, The Indo Pakistani Conflict (London: Pall Mall Press,

1968); H. V. Hudson, The Great Divide: Britain, India and Pakistan

(Karachi: Oxford University Press, 1985).

12. Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre, Freedom at Midnight

(London: St James Palace, 1975); Hudson, The Great Divide: Britain,

India and Pakistan.

13. Jawahar Lal Nehru, The Discovery of India (Bombay: Asian

Publishing House, 1945); Gardner, Sphere of Influence: The great

Powers Partition, Europe from Munich to Yalta.

14. Hudson, The Great Divide: Britain, India and Pakistan; Nehru, The

Discovery of India.

15. S. M. Ikram, Modern Muslim India and the Birth of Pakistan,

1858-1951 (Lahore: Sh. M. Ashraf, 1965).

16. Tung, Selected Works of Maotse Tung; Minfred, A Short History of

the World Progress.

17. Tung, Selected Works of Maotse Tung; Minfred, A Short History of

the World Progress.

18. Panderal Moon, Divide and Quit (London: Chatto and Windus,

1964); R. C. Mojamdar History of the Freedom Movement in India

(Lahore: Book Traders, 1979).

19. V. P. Menon, The Transfer of Power in India (New Jersey:

Princeton, 1957); Ikran, Modern Muslim India and the Birth of

Pakistan, 1858-1951.

20. Larry Collins and Dominique Lapierre, Freedom at Midnight

(London: St James Palace, 1975); Ishtiaq Hussain Qureshi, The

Struggle for Pakistan (Karachi, University of Karachi, 1974).

21. Chaudhary Muhammad Ali, The Emergence of Pakistan (Columbia:

Columbia Univers i ty Press , 1967); M. As lam Quresh i ,

Anglo-Pakistan Relations (Lahore: Research Society of Pakistan,

1976).

59 _______________________________________________ ªÄ0*Îy:Z`;ñÃ

Page 14: 06 - Qayam-e-Pakistan Mukhtalif Nuktahay Nazar · gzZ ÷Z ÛÔm,ß zÔw …6,~V!¤àZzä½Z~ qzÑ qzÑX1¯(Colony) X÷ï÷á6¤', d$¾xÓã½Æ*™ñƒïŠ rz Ûà (Colonialism)äVM]¬¡

22. Ian Stephen, Pakistan (London: Penguin Books, 1964); Stanley

Wolpert, Zulfi Bhutto of Pakistan: His Life and Time (Bombay:

Oxford University Press, 1993).

23. Zafarullah Khan, Tehdis-e-Nemat [Urdu: Documenting the Blessing]

(Dhaka: Dhaka Benevolent Association, 1971); Flemming, The Cold

War and its Origins, 1917-1960; Minfred, A Short History of the

World Progress.

24. C. H. Phillip and Mary Doreen Wainright, The Partition of India

(London, 1970); Fazal Muqeem, Tag-o-Taze Javedana [Urdu:

Eternal Passion] (Lahore: Oxford University Press, 1967).

25. Jameel ud Din Ahmad, Historic Documents of Muslim Freedom

Movement (Lahore: Publishers United, 1970); Moon, Divide and

Quit; Muhammad Yameen Khan, Nama-e-Amaal [Urdu: Balance

Sheet of Deeds] (Lahore, 1970).

26. Feroz Khan Noon, Chasham Deed [Urdu: Eye Witness] (Lahore:

Ferozsons Ltd., 1974).

Ali, The Emergence of Pakistan; Qureshi, The Struggle for

Pakistan; Khan, Tehdis-e-Nemat.

27. Ikram, Modern Muslim India and the Birth of Pakistan, 1858-1951;

Khan, Tehdis-e-Nemat; Jameel ud Din Ahmad, Historic Documents

of Muslim Freedom Movement (Lahore: Publishers United, 1970).

28. Ikram, Modern Muslim India and the Birth of Pakistan, 1858-1951;

Khan, Tehdis-e-Nemat; Ahmad, Historic Documents of Muslim

Freedom Movement.

29. Ikram, Modern Muslim India and the Birth of Pakistan, 1858-195;

Qureshi, The Struggle for Pakistan.

C@*gõzpÄ0*ÎyÔ�ÑðDŠc7102Y ______________________________________ 69