218

Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The final presentation of the American Institute of Architects Sustainable Design Assessment Team (SDAT) project in Sebastopol, CA

Citation preview

Page 1: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 2: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 3: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 4: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Wayne Feiden, FAICP, Team Leader

Ken Buckland, AICP, LEED AP, Land Use

Steve Durrant, PLA, Bicycle and Pedestrian

Christine Carlson, ASLA, Green Infrastructure

Lesley Bain, FAIA, LEED AP, Urban Design

Ian Lockwood, PE, Transportation

Joel Mills, Director AIA Communities by Design

Erin Simmons, Director AIA Design Assistance

Page 5: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Sebastopol speaks• “We are a Subaru and Prius Town”

• “We are deserving of our vision”

• “We don’t suffer from low self-esteem”

• “Our brand is ‘Unique small town’”

• “Want to stay a working class community”

• “I never let my children bicycle to school”

• “Sebastopol goes both ways” downtown streets”

Page 6: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Center of the City

Students: Safeway

sometimes plaza

Main St: Not so muchAdults: the plaza

Page 7: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Sebastopol speaks• Downtown inundated by through traffic

• Streets too highway-like

• Pedestrians and cyclists uncomfortable

• Bicycle trail ends before the destination

• Parking available in the wrong places

• Unattractive downtown gateways

Page 8: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Sebastopol speaks• Design/development should reflect values

• Residential, commercial and industrial mix

• Need new civic center

• Underutilized lots are key opportunities

• Weak downtown-The Barlow connection

• Nature in the city

Page 9: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Bullish on downtown/The Barlow

• Downtown synergy

• City worker/jobs balance (4,000±:4,000±)

• Housing (residents support downtown)

Page 10: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Land UseKen Buckland, AICP, LEED AP

Page 11: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

A Cross Roads City

Page 12: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Community Grows

Page 13: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

A Community Over Time

Greenbelt

Core

Corridors

Transitions

Page 14: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Opportunities

Page 15: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Heart of the City

Page 16: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Precedent: Palmer Square

Page 17: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Opportunities

Page 18: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Frame the Boundaries

Page 19: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Opportunities

Page 20: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Frame the Boundaries

Page 21: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Opportunities

Page 22: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Vehicle Storage/ Smart ParkingLocation Units Parking Spaces Parking RatioSouth Orange NJ 200 250 1.3Madison NJ 149 178 1.2Lansdale PA 346 222 0.6Portland OR 288 150 0.5Portland OR 124 93 0.8Gresham OR 90 135 1.5Beaverton OR 185 218 1.2Mission Wells CA 391 508 1.3Montelena Apt CA 188 208 1.1Park Regency CA 854 1352 1.6Verandas CA 282 282 1.0Wayside Plaza CA 156 166 1.1Bethesda MD 497 746 1.5Arlington VA 231 258 1.1Silver Spring MD 406 406 1.0Alexandria VA 457 560 1.2Arlinngton VA 499 499 1.0

Page 23: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Vehicle Storage and Links

Average Parking Ratio 1.1

Average Distance to Transit 994’

Steps to Transit – 47

Steps to Main St - 126

Page 24: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Value Proposition

Cost of Vehicle Ownership

Additional Mortgage Valueof $100,000

Page 25: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Zoning as Land Plan

Page 26: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Zoning as Future Land Plan

General Plan Update Needed, from that process:

• Define Outcomes• Include Flexibility

Page 27: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Defining Success

Pre-Planning Program

• Community-Based Process• Define Desired Public Outcomes• Determine Owner/Developer Benefits

Page 28: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Outreach and Marketing Plan

Market to Successful Businesses Market to Quality Developers Create Marketing Materials:

Context What is required What is desired What is offered How to proceed 

Page 29: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 30: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Urban Design Lesley Bain, FAIA, LEED AP

Page 31: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Design Review

Frames a conversation between property ownerscommunity membersdesigners and regulators

Page 32: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Design Review

Allows the conversation to happen before you need it to happen

Page 33: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

NATURAL SETTINGOak and redwoodTopographyViewsCreeklands

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 34: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

NATURAL SETTINGOak and redwoodTopographyViewsCreeklands

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 35: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

HISTORY Apples Warehouses Trains

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 36: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

ICONSENTRIES

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 37: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

HISTORYMain StreetFine grain scale

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 38: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

ARCHITECTURAL LEGACY

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 39: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Ability to create for the future

Designs reflect Community Values: Character

Page 40: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Human scaleComfortableInteresting

Designs reflect Community Values: It’s About People

Page 41: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Quirky!

Designs reflect Community Values: It’s About People

Page 42: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Artistic

Designs reflect Community Values: It’s About People

Page 43: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

SolarEdibleShaded

Designs reflect Community Values: Sustainable

Page 44: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Filling in gaps, needs Adding landscaping,

seating, activity

Designs Contribute to Community

Page 45: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Making connections

Designs Contribute to Community

Page 46: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Making connections

Designs Contribute to Community

Page 47: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Making connections

Designs Contribute to Community

Page 48: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Main Street Industrial heritageInner corridorEntry corridorSingle family area

Tailor Guidelines by districts

Page 49: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Identify places of high significance:

GatewaysViewsKey sites

Tailor Guidelines by districts

Page 50: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Main Street typology Industrial heritage

Tailor Guidelines by districts

Page 51: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Tailor Guidelines by pedestrian priority

Existing conditions

Page 52: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Tailor Guidelines by pedestrian priority

Pedestrian priority in red--near term

Page 53: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Tailor Guidelines by pedestrian priority

Pedestrian priority in red--longer term

Page 54: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

1. Site Analysis

Each site has unique attributes.

What are the specific opportunities for each project to contribute?

What is the best approach to design?

Design Review Process

Page 55: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

2. Design Concept

Addresses unique attributes.

Identifies the specific opportunities for each project to contribute

Design Review Process

Page 56: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

3. Execution

Parts complement the whole.

Details, materials, and scale are most appropriate.

Design Review Process

Page 57: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Not just Design Guidelines

Humanizing

Page 58: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Not just Design Guidelines

Humanizing

Page 59: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Fingers of space for people

Public Realm

Page 60: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Public Realm

People-scaled connections

Page 61: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Public Realm

People-scaled connections

Page 62: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Language of the Street

Engineering language

Page 63: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Language of pedestrians and natural systems

The Language of the Street

Page 64: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Language of the Street

Language of pedestrians and natural systems

Page 65: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Language of the Public Space

Use your asphalt space well

Page 66: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Design for who you are

Page 67: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Green Infrastructure Christine Carlson, ASLA

Page 68: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Santa Rosa

Sebastopol

GratonFarmland

Atascadero C

reek

Laguna de Santa R

osa

Woodland

Page 69: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

ThePlaza

Rialto TrailHigh Street Greenway

Page 70: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

The Barlow

To Analy H.S.

Rialto

Pocket Park

Pocket Park

To Rodota Trail

Laguna

Railroad Woods

SebastopolCrossingThe Plaza

Rialto Trail

Page 71: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Rialto corridor

Page 72: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 73: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Neighborhood Greenway

Page 74: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

60’ foot right-of-way

Page 75: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 76: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

WayfindingRenaturing

Page 77: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Backyard Nature

Page 78: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Backyard Nature

Page 79: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Street trees

Page 80: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Cluster trees and shrubs for backyard habitat

Connect to streetscape bioswales

Plants for birds & bees

Residential Lots & Streetscape

Page 81: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Bicycle & Pedestrian ConnectionsSteve Durrant, PLA

Page 82: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

to Santa Rosa

to Graton

to Petaluma

Page 83: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

15 minute walk15 minute walk

High SchoolHigh School

LagunaLaguna

Libby ParkLibby Park

PinecrestPinecrestSchoolSchool

NO

YES

Yes, if only…60%

15 minute bike ride15 minute bike ride

Page 84: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Plaza

LagunaAnaly High School

Rodota TrailIves ParkParkside

Page 85: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Highway Bikeways

Page 86: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Highway BikewaysTrails

Page 87: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Highway BikewaysTrails

Page 88: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Highway BikewaysTrailsBike Lanes

Page 89: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Highway BikewaysTrailsBike LanesNeighborhood Greenways

Page 90: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Plaza

Page 91: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Rialto

Co

rrido

r

Ives Park Connector

Page 92: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

High S

treet Neighborhood G

reenway

Page 93: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Buffered Bike Lanes

Page 94: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Cycle Tracks

Page 95: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Analy High

School

The Laguna

Pinecrest School

Broomhaven School

Libby Park Rodota Trail

Page 96: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Cycle Track: A bikeway

protected from traffic by parked

cars or another barrier.

Page 97: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

58’

Page 98: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

58’

Page 99: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

TransportationIan Lockwood, PE

Page 100: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 101: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 102: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 103: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 104: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 105: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 106: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 107: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 108: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 109: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 110: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 111: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 112: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 113: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 114: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:

Page 115: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypass

Page 116: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypass

Page 117: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypassiii)potential network connections

Page 118: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypassiii)potential network connections

Page 119: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypassiii)potential network connections

Conclusions:

Page 120: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypassiii)potential network connections

Conclusions:i)congestion is not the choice

Page 121: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

What We Heard:i)no money for bypassii)no good location for bypassiii)potential network connections

Conclusions:i)congestion is not the choiceii)how Sebastopol deals with congestion is the choice

Page 122: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Choices:

Page 123: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Choices:i)Traffic 1st Approach:

Page 124: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Choices:i)Traffic 1st Approach:

maximize motor vehicle throughput & accept damage

to City’s walkability, businesses,character…

Page 125: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Choices:i)Traffic 1st Approach:

maximize motor vehicle throughput & accept damage

to City’s walkability, businesses,character…; or

ii)City 1st Approach:

Page 126: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Choices:i)Traffic 1st Approach:

maximize motor vehicle throughput & accept damage

to City’s walkability, businesses,character…; or

ii)City 1st Approach:advance community “vision”

being cognizant of the crossroads’ challenge

Page 127: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 128: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 129: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 130: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 131: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 132: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 133: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 134: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 135: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 136: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 137: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 138: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 139: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 140: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 141: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

% By Trip Type

----------18.0%

2.6%

20.2%1.5%

24.2%8.8%

24.5%0.2%

100.0%

Doctors & DentistFamily & Personal

Church & SchoolSocial Recreational

Other

Trip Type

----------Work

Work Related

Shopping

Source: Federal Highway Administration & New York Times

Page 142: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 143: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Reward the short trip and/or the transit trip

Page 144: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 145: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 146: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 147: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 148: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 149: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 150: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 151: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 152: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 153: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 154: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 155: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 156: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Strategy: Relocate Lefts/Short Cylces

vs Split Through/One-Way Streets

Page 157: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 158: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 159: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 160: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 161: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 162: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 163: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 164: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 165: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 166: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 167: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 168: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 169: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 170: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 171: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 172: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 173: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 174: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 175: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 176: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Leverage ExistingRegional Network

(provide routing choices)

ForestvilleRussian River

Source: Colin Doyle

Page 177: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 178: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 179: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 180: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 181: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 182: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 183: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 184: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 185: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 186: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 187: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 188: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 189: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 190: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 191: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 192: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 193: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 194: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 195: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 196: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 197: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 198: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 199: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 200: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 201: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 202: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 203: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 204: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 205: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 206: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 207: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 208: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 209: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 210: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation
Page 211: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Other Downtown: Parking• On-street parking

– up to $200,000 sales/spot IF customer parking

• Main St. parked up– Employees parking; or– Fees needed

• Empty spaces– regulations too strict; or– too much parking

Page 212: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Other Downtown: Events

• Downtown events, programs, and promotion– Business and city cachet

Page 213: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Get it done!

– Downtown merchants– Occupy Sebastopol– Sebastopol tomorrow

• General Plan Update

• Strategic work starts tomorrow– The Perfect is the enemy of the Good– City Council goal setting

• Partners– Core Project– Sebastopol Citizens– Cittaslow Sebastopol

Page 214: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Quick Start: less than one year• Wayfinding: bicycle trail and downtown• Design: better design AND street standards• Revise bicycle and pedestrian plans• Zoning:

– conditional uses to by-right when possible (e.g., office use above 1st floor The Barlow)

– CB parking to one per residential unit– CB allow 4 stories if 4th story setback

Page 215: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Quick Start: less than one year• Paint: narrow lanes-repurpose asphalt• Pre-Plan: opportunity sites for development &

greening• Parking: rationalize system• Identify greenways and smaller scale

connections

Page 216: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Momentum: within two years• Identify site for housing to replace trailer park

• Marketing: opportunity sites

• Reposition asphalt: parking, sidewalks, parks

• Programmatic: empower partners to coordinate more downtown events

• Build neighborhood greenways

• Improve more crosswalks

• Make bicycle trail connections

Page 217: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Eye on the prize: longer term• Restore two-way livable streets downtown

• Embed findings in General Plan

• Cycle Tracks on major streets

• Buffered bikeways on collectors

• Restore the Laguna edge along Morris St.

• Strengthen connections between Laguna and Rodota Trail. Connect West County Trail and Ragle Park.

Page 218: Sebastopol SDAT Presentation

Imagine Downtown Sebastopol• Emphasize downtown character

• Downtown development for city values

• Pre-planning program

• Private and public realm design guidelines

• Re-green (green infrastructure)

• Family-friendly connections

• Livable streets not highways

Presentation and (eventually) final report

www.aia.org/about/initiatives/AIAS075426