After the Farrell Review

How can Design Review Evolve?

Les Sparks

How can design review evolve?

Where has it come from?

Where is it now?

Where might it go?

Where has it come from

Local Architects’ Panels•No presentations•Conflicts of interest•Narrow focus

RFAC•Presentations but no discussion•Response by letter•Considered London-centric etc.

CABE’s Legacy

•Presentation followed by discussion•Review by eminent practitioners from a range of professions•Development of best practice•10 key principles established•Training for panel members and chairs

Where are we now

The Design Network

Strengths

• Regional coverage• Consistency of

practice based on 10 principles

• Support through NPPF

Weaknesses

• Patchy take up• Funding

uncertainties and organisational insecurity

• Poorly promoted

Design Review or PLACE ReviewWhat’s the difference?

Best practice in design review is already• Inter-professional• Collaborative, not judgemental• Objective, not subjective• Sensitive to context• Independent

How might design review evolve further?

• Open reviews; observation and engagement of 3rd parties

• Strategic reviews; in depth analysis and discussion

• Hands on assistance; design workshops and charettes