15
Gabriel S Konayuma Senior Vocational Education & Training Officer, Zambia BA Ed., MBA

A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Gabriel S KonayumaSenior Vocational Education & Training Officer,

ZambiaBA Ed., MBA

Page 2: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

AgendaIntroductionBackgroundProblem StatementObjectives of PaperMethodologyFindingsAnalysisConclusion

2

Page 3: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

IntroductionThis paper focuses on analysis of ODL

policies in Zambia by using tools of policy analysis.

The paper also analyses text produced by respondents in a survey of the use of mobile technologies in education and training using Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). 

3

Page 4: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Background

African Context of ICTsIn Africa, a number of African countries have

developed ICT policies. Some of these are Cameroun, Kenya, Namibia, South Africa, Uganda and Zimbabwe. In Cameroun the ICT Policy seeks to:

to enable each citizen to build his capacities to gain access to information, ideas and knowledge and contribute thereto;

to make the most benefit of ICT opportunities to combat poverty and promote development (National Agency for Information and Communication Technologies, 2007:85).

4

Page 5: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

BackgroundZambian Context of ICTsThe ICT sector in Zambia is governed by a

National Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Policy.

The ICT Policy highlights the potential of ICTs to improve quality of education and training through e-learning and online learning. The ICT policy identifies some challenges that are faced in the educational system:

5

Page 6: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Problem Statement

Though TVET teachers appreciate the need to use ICTs in education in order to improve their teaching and improve learning by students, they do not fully appreciate how some technologies can be effectively in a learning environment.

Lack of adequate ICT competence is likely to have a negative impact on learners in TVET.

Purpose of study is to identify strategies that will strengthen the ICT competence of teachers in TVET so that they can offer ODL programmes effectively.

6

Page 7: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Objectives of the Paper

Demonstrate a critical understanding between the macro and the micro factors at social interaction level.

Mediate interaction of human agents and gather trails of interaction using a mobile application.

Provide detailed description of the conditions of both production and interpretation of text/artefacts.

Analyse the relationships between the created artefacts created and analyse them from micro-to-macro.

7

Page 8: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Methodology Institutional, pedagogical and technological artefacts collected

over a 2 week period . These artefacts were presented to a postgraduate education class at the University of Cape Town in June 2011. The artefacts were documented in Wikispaces, a free web hosting service, where other students in the class could easily access them and make comments.

A mobile application solution, created using a free mobile website builder, Winksite to address the problem of inadequate information on mobile learning was presented.

Creation of mobile forum for lecturers to make contributions to discussion questions that were raised. A total of 4 lecturers and policy makers were chosen from TVET institutions in Zambia. These were invited (by text and by email generated from the mobile website) to join the forum discussion available on the mobile site and respond to the following two questions:

(a) How do you use mobile phones for your teaching/learning?               

(b) Do mobile phones improve teaching and learning?

8

Page 9: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Methodology

9

Figure 1: Screenshot of MobilEdu website showing discussion questions on Forum page

Page 10: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

FindingsA total of four respondents made a combined total of

eight postings on the discussion forum. There were five responses to the first question:

(a)    How do you use mobile phones for your teaching/learning? 

“The mobile phone is handy for sending assignments to learners by typed short message. Learners are also able to listen to recorded voice lessons on their phones”(Dan)

For learning I use a mobile phone to connect to the Internet and research on different study topics. (Dick)

Mobile Phones are used for teaching by sending notes and assignments to students via email, text massaging, conversation. (Dick)

10

Page 11: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

FindingsI just realised that there are some features on my

phone that I have never used to date. I may be missing out on something. (Cleo)

Having been a student not too long ago, I found a mobile phone very important in improving learning. I used my phone to communicate with my lecturer and peers on issues that needed clarification. As a part time lecturer now, it helps me keep in touch with my distant students to communicate important information and also enables me to search information and benefit from Open Education Resources as access to latest reference materials is still a challenge in my school. (Cleo)

11

Page 12: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

AnalysisText Genre Communicator’s Intent is to:

Narrative Tell about a sequence of events

Procedural Give instructions on how to do something

Expository Explain something

Hortatory Encourage someone to do something

Descriptive List the characteristics of something

Table 1: Text Genres and the Communicator’s Intent for each Genre, Larson (1984:365)

12

Page 13: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

AnalysisDescription (Text Analysis)

Interpretation(Discursive Type)

Explanation(Social Practice)

Narrative: The teacher is describing the sequence of events that he uses the mobile phone for teaching.Procedural: The teacher is explaining how the mobile phone is used i.e. connecting to the Internet and researching on different study topics

Expository: The teacher has explained how he uses the mobile phone for learning purposes.

Descriptive: The teacher has listed the characteristic of the mobile phone as being able to connect to the Internet

Procedural: By explaining that a phone can be used for connecting to the Internet and research the teacher implies a mobile phone can be used for teaching and used for more than just making voice calls and sending text messages.

Descriptive: The student knows the characteristics of the mobile phone that can facilitate his teaching.

Most teacher generally have mobile phones and a number of them do use them for teaching though this comment has been made by just two teachers in this study and therefore cannot be generalised.

13

Page 14: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

ConclusionThis study is useful for policy makers in understanding

how certain readily available technologies such as mobile phones can be used more effectively than they are being used presently to enhance teaching and learning in educational institutions.

The findings of CDA are very useful in the development of learning interventions that seek to improve the access of learning to students within a community or those that have certain disadvantages in terms of learning.

The study is also useful to lecturers who struggle to find teaching and learning resources for their classes and who also seek to improve their interaction with learners.

14

Page 15: A critical discourse analysis of odl policies in tvet in zambia

Let’s continue networking via:e-mail: [email protected]: www.educationandtrainingissues.blogspot.com

15

gabrielkonayuma

gabriel.konayuma