Science as Conversation, Conversation as Science

Science as Conversation, Conversation as ScienceScience as Conversation, Conversation as Science

PF Anderson, Emerging Technologies Librarian, Health Sciences Libraries, University of Michigan, pfa@umich.edu

DialogueDialogue

Plato & SocratesPlato & Socrates

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Image:Plato_Aristotle_della_Robbia_OPA_Florence.jpg

Early scientific literatureEarly scientific literature

Early science journals preserved discussions

Stenographerstranscribeddiscussion & debate

Early science journals preserved discussions

Stenographerstranscribeddiscussion & debate

Research as conversationResearch as conversation

Marshall-Gies Salivary Factor debate

William Gies

Scientific publication cycleScientific publication cycle

http://www.lib.washington.edu/subject/environment/imt220/pubcycle.jpg

Garrett LisiGarrett Lisi

http://sifter.org/~aglisi/http://sifter.org/~aglisi/

Lisi blogsLisi blogs

http://fqxi.org/community/forum/topic/108

Lisi’s Theory of EverythingLisi’s Theory of Everything

http://www.arxiv.org/pdf/0711.0770

Model of Lisi’a E8 figureModel of Lisi’a E8 figure

More about Garrett LisiMore about Garrett Lisi

http://www.slideshare.net/umhealthscienceslibraries/a-preliminary-forensic-exploration-of-a-scientific-social-technologies-success-the-garrett-lisi-story

Where is the scientific conversation now?

Science Discourse & Scientific Memory

“We have to map the archival pathways that constitute the scientific memory. Only then will we be able to develop strategies that meld with the ongoing practice of science, instead of just cleaning up its messes.” McCarthy, Gavan; Sherratt, Tim. Mapping Scientific

Memory: understanding the role of record-keeping in scientific practice. Archives and Manuscripts 24(1) May 1996, <http://www.asap.unimelb.edu.au/pubs/articles/gjm/mapscimem.htm>

“We have to map the archival pathways that constitute the scientific memory. Only then will we be able to develop strategies that meld with the ongoing practice of science, instead of just cleaning up its messes.” McCarthy, Gavan; Sherratt, Tim. Mapping Scientific

Memory: understanding the role of record-keeping in scientific practice. Archives and Manuscripts 24(1) May 1996, <http://www.asap.unimelb.edu.au/pubs/articles/gjm/mapscimem.htm>

Information seeking as conversation

?>>?>>

?>>>?>>>

?>>>>>

?>>>>>>

Conversation nowConversation now How do:

social technologies facilitate conversations? these conversations change the nature of science,

research, the academy? these conversations impact on libraries & archives? we discover where the conversations are

happening? we become part of the important conversations? we remember & preserve the conversation?

Where are we in the conversation?

How do: social technologies facilitate conversations? these conversations change the nature of science,

research, the academy? these conversations impact on libraries & archives? we discover where the conversations are

happening? we become part of the important conversations? we remember & preserve the conversation?

Where are we in the conversation?

Science as Conversation, Conversation as Science

Technology

Designing Our World: Cybernetics as Conversation for · PDF fileDesigning Our World: Cybernetics as Conversation for Action ... Claus Pias Wolfgang Pircher | ... Cybernetics as Conversation

Data Driven Science at NIH: A Conversation

The Conversation Argument for Actual Intentionalism€¦ · In his influential paper, ‘Art, Intention, and Conversation’, Noel Carroll uses the metaphor of the conversation as

A Conversation: What Do Science and Data Say About the ... · – Possible use of Rapid Diagnostic Test • Not as sensitive as PCR test • Need to be symptomatic • Higher false

Online conversation as networks

Start your conversation with the world. · PDF fileDIGITAL LIBRARY CSESS V Start your conversation with the world. Science Lives Here dl.sciencesocieties.org

Conversation as an everyday method of participation

SUPERVISION AS COLLABORATIVE CONVERSATION: …developingopendialogue.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Anderso… · SUPERVISION AS COLLABORATIVE CONVERSATION: CONNECTING THE VOICES

Conflict as a Positive Force: Deepening the Conversation

Colson Conversation€¦ · “Colson Conversation ... diamond burs, saw blades, cannulated drills and reamers as well as rasps, bone harvesting tools, bone taps, fixation devices,

Conversation As a Model of Instructional Interaction · Conversation As a Model of Instructional Interaction Van Bramer Conversation, then, is highly structured in that each participant

Greater Cambridge Local Plan First Conversation, Call for ...€¦ · Conversation consultation. • The sites submitted under the Call for Green Sites as part of the First Conversation

Constructive Conversation Skills Science. How can an organism be both cold-blooded and warm-blooded? Use the Constructive Conversation Placemat to 1

Science & Religion: Conflict or Conversation?

Statistical Science A Conversation with F. N. David

Content as Conversation

Content as a Conversation: Collaborating with Content Strategists

The Art and Science of Computer Conversation: Talkabot 2016

Conversation Guide-- Spanishlearneverylanguage.weebly.com/.../spanish_conversation_guide.pdfuse of a pocket book such as our Conversation Guide, ... Adjectives and pronouns 114 Possessive

Starting the Conversation about Health, Legal, Financial ... · StartIng tHE ConvErSatIon . To ease everyone in, certain conversation starters can be used, such as sharing a story