Simon Carley - Are You as Good as You Think?

Are you as good as you think?

Are you as good as you think?

Are you as good as you think?Is it?

Are you as good as you think?

Are you a better than

average driver?

93% of Americans 69% of Swedes

Svenson 1981 Acta Psychologica

Illusory superiority cognitive bias

Influential

activity

knowledge of subject

communication skills

enthusiasm

trained high volume

younger

feedback

does feedback work?

Passive Activefeedback

Passive

Active

Tools

reflections diaries

peer review

Peer review

Do it

I'm great

I'm great

ClarifyExpectations

Review Logistics

Focus Lens

Plan the feedback

Observed event

(teaching)

Debrief and

Actions

ClarifyExpectations

Review Logistics

Focus Lens

Plan the feedback

Observed event

(teaching)

Debrief and

ActionsYou're great

peer review tools

bedside teaching procedures

out patient clinics lectures

small groups

bedside teaching procedures

out patient clinics lectures

small groups

Feedback in Emergency Medicine clinical feedback

patients

case mix

peer review

One more thing

I will

thank you

trained teachers high volume teachers

younger

do a personal reflection

keep a diary

follow up my patients or students

be observed or peer reviewed

observe/peer review someone else

develop a team feedback system in my department

take part in a 360

do something else

I’m not going to bother because I know I’m awesome

knowledge of subject

communication skills

enthusiasm

Good stuff Not so good

Good stuff

Easy Effortless

Comes to you Trackable

Interhospital comparisons

Not so good

Good stuff

Easy Effortless

Comes to you Trackable

Interhospital comparisons

Not so good

Vague Small speciality problems

Groupings sometime unclear Often targeted reviews

Fidelity low

MSF for educators

• Passive feedback

• happy sheets

• departmental assessments

• National training surveys

• quality framework

• deanery reports

• ARCP outcomes?

Trainer Dept.vs

Membership Fellowship

Corporate Membership

AOME standards 2012

http://website.professionalperformanceonline.nl/en/

All trainees Ranking

Approachability Empathy

Knowledge Supervision

Formal teaching Setting

Feedback

All trainees Ranking

Approachability Empathy

Knowledge Supervision

Formal teaching Setting

Feedback

Not you……

trainersmodular

portfolio paymentrevalidationappraisal

http://cmftpostgrad.com

are you a good educator?

how do you know?

what are you going to do next?

–Quotes I made up to try and sound clever

“we are all learners”