Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)

Propaganda with a Mission: Learning from the Second World War for the

Christian Sector in a Digital AgeDr Bex Lewis

Research Fellow in Social Media & Online LearningCODEC, Durham University

The Association for the Study of Religion, Economics, and Culture Conference, Durham, September 2014

@drbexl

A public notice aims to inform or command. A poster aims to seduce, to exhort, to sell, to educate, to convince, to appeal. Whereas a public notice distributes information to interested or alert citizens, a poster reaches out to grab those who might otherwise pass it by.

Susan SontagRead more: http://j.mp/ww2posterch2

@drbexl

http://ww2poster.co.uk/phd-research/phd-ww2poster-2004/ @drbexl

Ministry of Information

• Central governmental publicity machine

• Formed September 1939

• Tell the citizen ‘clearly and swiftly what he is to do, where he is to do it, how he is to do it and what he should not do’.

@drbexl

During the war, a ‘shared sense of national identity had to be mobilised amongst the people of Britain’. Achieved partly through propaganda posters, more and more people ‘were encouraged to identify themselves as active citizens, as active members of the nation’, a citizenship ‘to be earned by communal and individual service of one’s nation in wartime’. Lewis, R., Unpublished PhD thesis (2004), quoting Noakes, L., War and the British: Gender and National Identity, 1939-91, 1998, p.48.

@drbexl

Benedict Anderson ‘Imagined Communities’

What ‘makes people love and die for nations, as well as hate and kill in their name’?

1991

@drbexl

https://www.wordnik.com/words/community @drbexl

The Big Bible Project has emerged as an online community using everyday social media platforms. The site itself aims to involve its community not only in Biblical engagement, but also to consider what it means to be a disciple in the digital age (and the digital culture). http

://www.newmediacentreofexcellence.org.uk/resources/communityinthe21stcentury#sthash.CHBenwRc.7AW3LP3H.dpuf

@drbexl

Image: http://j.mp/IaePVj @drbexl

http://audioboo.fm/boos/367199-a-few-pearls-of-wisdom-from-jas-tdc11-re-community

@drbexl

In the 1930s Aldous Huxley recognised that propaganda ‘canalises an already existing stream’; it is only effective on those already in tune with the ideas expressed. Propaganda encourages its audience further along the direction that they are already moving, and reinforces partly formed ideas.Doherty, M., ‘What is Political Propaganda?’ (Lecture), ‘MA in Propaganda, Persuasion and History’, at University of Kent at Canterbury, October 1997

@drbexl

Casting a compelling vision for a Christ-exalting life is part of leadership, but understanding how best to communicate God’s word into individual and corporate circumstances with persistence, persuasion and precision is what distinguishes a visionary from a biblical leader.http://toddengstrom.com/2013/11/18/meeting-people-where-they-are/

Todd Engstrom

@drbexl

Darren Hill, The Worship Cloud

All these great Bible verses arrive on my feed without any context, background or explanation. As believers we are fine with this, we of course know the context to any text that appears online… don’t we? But what about everyone else?http://bigbible.org.uk/2012/11/posts-promises-and-perennial-issues-darrenrhill-digidisciple/

Image Credit: Darren Hill@drbexl

Relationships/Communication

@drbexl

Abram Games (1914-1996), War Office

• 1940: Infantry• ‘an understanding of what

the ranker thinks, does and, perhaps more important, does not do’, as the army mentality was different from that of the ‘outside world’.

• 1941: Recruiting Posters for RAC

• 1942: “Official War Office Poster Designer”

@drbexl

How to Keep Well in Wartime

During three years of total war the nation’s stubborn good health has been invaluable to out war effort. Even so, as a nation we are still using about 22 million weeks’ work each year through common and often preventable illnesses such as colds and influenza, dyspepsia, biliousness, neurasthenia, rheumatism, boils and other septic conditions. This is calculated to be the equivalent to the loss of 24,000 tanks, 6,750 bombers, and 6,750,000 rifles a year, not to mention the pain and inconvenience we suffer as individuals.

How to Keep Well in Wartime, Ministry of Information, 1943 (Booklet)

@drbexl

http://www.propagandacritic.com/articles/index.html

@drbexl

Posters did not stand alone

• Legislation• Newspapers• Radio• Cinema• Leaflets• Window Displays

@drbexl

Simon Edge, ‘Sign of the Times’, Daily Express, Thursday March 19, 2009, p36@drbexl

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_Calm_And_Carry_On @drbexl

@drbexl

Celebrity

@drbexl

Global

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/05/magazine/05FOB-consumed-t.html?ref=magazine @drbexl

http://www.keepcalm-o-matic.co.uk/ @drbexl

Citizen Warriors

The boundaries between the civilian and the combatant soldier were blurred during the war, with ‘propagandist attempts to personify the entire population as heroic’. Lewis, R., Unpublished PhD thesis, quoting Paris, M., Warrior Nation: Images of War in British Popular Culture, 1850-2000, 2000, p.201@drbexl

The Church Front Door?For many churchgoing is no longer the ‘cultural norm’. People don’t actively ignore the church: they don’t even think about it. … With literally billions in the digital spaces, the online social spaces presented by churches need to be appealing, welcoming, and not look like they are just an afterthought: they are now effectively the ‘front door’ to your church for digital users, and you ignore those spaces at your peril.

http://www.churchgrowthrd.org.uk/blog/churchgrowth/growing_churches_in_the_digital_age

Image Credit: freeimages.com@drbexl

[If we are…] means by which God communicates and reveals himself through his spirit, then our blog posts, status updates, tweets, artistic images, and online comments should be products of a life transformed by Christ and indwelled by his spirit. As restored image bearers, our online presence and activity should image the triune god.

Byers, A. Theomedia (2013, 196)@drbexl

@drbexl

@drbexl

@drbexl

@drbexl

@drbexl

@drbexl

Christians and Churchgoing

http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/dcp171776_290510.pdf @drbexl

https://www.facebook.com/maryengelbreit/photos/a.283968321636466.87914.138832742816692/809142355785724/?type=1&theater

@drbexl

Dr Sara Batts (2013)

http://phdinprogress.wordpress.com

@drbexl

The Growth of the Internet

http://oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/sites/oxis.oii.ox.ac.uk/files/content/files/publications/OxIS_2013.pdf @drbexl

The digital environment is not a parallel or purely virtual world, but is part of the daily experience of many people, especially the young. Social networks are the result of human interaction, but for their part they also reshape the dynamics of communication, which builds relationships: a considered understanding of this environment is therefore a prerequisite for a significant presence there.

Pope Benedict XVI (2013)

@drbexl

“Bringing the young in…?”

“Jake told the executive that he never goes directly to a brand like this man’s newspaper or even to blogs he likes. ... he reads a lot of news – far more than I did at his age. But he goes to that news only via the links from Digg, friends’ blogs, and Twitter. He travels all around the internet that is edited by his peers because he trusts them and knows they share his interests. The web of trust is built at eye-level, peer-to-peer.” Jarvis, p.86, my emphasis

@drbexl

Cohen, D.J., & Rosenzweig, R., Digital History: A Guide to Gathering, Preserving, and Presenting the Past on the Web, 2006, p18“Writing history requires that you first immerse yourself in the styles, conventions, and methods of historical writing and that you understand the different genres of history books, whether scholarly monograph, popular narrative textbook, or reference work. The same holds true for those who want to create history museum exhibits, make history films, and teach history classes.” … and of course history websites.

Church: Broadcast Model

Image Source: RGBStock@drbexl

On the Emmaus road, Jesus was recognized in the breaking of bread rather than in the exegesis of scripture. That’s an intriguing lesson to learn when so much of the web and so much of digital communication is about proclamation rather than reception.

Phillips et al, 2013: 10

@drbexl

New Opportunities

Image Source: Stockfresh@drbexl

#DIGIDisciplethose who seek to live out their Biblically-informed Christian faith in the digital space, exploring both what it means to be a disciple in the digital age, and also how the digital age affects or alters discipleship.

@drbexl

https://audioboo.fm/boos/1577833-what-does-it-mean-to-be-a-digital-disciple-with-

changingworship @drbexl

It’s something about the informality and distance; the ability to pause and think, which can be difficult in a conversation; and the way discussions can pick up where they left off several hours, days or weeks later.

Emma Major, BIGBible Post, 2012

@drbexl

Thank you for your time…

QUESTIONS?

@drbexl @codecuk