View
216
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
1/185
THE LOVE THAT DARE NOT SING ITS NAME:
AN EXPLORATIVE INVESTIGATION INTO THE STATUS
OF LESBIAN, GAY AND BISEXUAL ISSUES IN MUSIC
THERAPY TRAINING AND EDUCATION
TRABAJO DE INVESTIGACIN
MASTER UNIVERSITARIO
DE MUSICOTERAPIA
Autor: Bill Thomas Ahessy
Fecha 28 Septiembre 2007
Facultad de Ciencias de la Educacin
Puerto Real, Cdiz - Espaa
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
2/185
II
Abstract
This thesis investigates the status of lesbian, gay and bisexual (LGB) issues and perspectivesin the field of music therapy. It is divided into three parts. First, a comprehensive review of
lesbian, gay and bisexual issues in the music therapy literature and the related disciplinesof psychology and psychotherapy; second, a global survey of music therapy programswhich assesses the provision of lesbian, gay and bisexual issues in music therapy education;and finally, a global survey of music therapy associations which assesses guidelines andopportunities for continuing professional education regarding LGB issues. The provision ofLGB issues for both music therapy programs and associations is examined using quantitativeand qualitative perspectives. Although the data from both surveys indicate that the musictherapy community considers LGB issues important they are largely overlooked in casereports, journal articles and the music therapy literature. LGB issues are relatively neglectedin music therapy curricula, education and professional development.
An analysis of the data supplied by the surveyed music therapy programs indicates thatthese issues are receiving more attention now than they were in former years in musictherapy programs. Nevertheless, LGB issues are under addressed, in comparison with othermulticultural topics. Although many respondents thought LGB issues an important componentof music therapy education, less than half specifically addressed LGB issues in their trainingprograms. The majority of music therapy directors agreed that university music therapyprograms were the place to best address LGB issues, and there was support to addressthese issues in continuing professional education too, with a majority of the respondentsindicating that guidelines or further training opportunities in LGB issues from the musictherapy associations would be professionally beneficial for music therapists.
Analysis of the data supplied by the surveyed music therapy associations, reveal that only 1association out of those surveyed provided guidelines and further training opportunities forits member music therapists. A majority of the respondents also thought that training in LGBissues at university level would professionally benefit practicing music therapists. Many ofthe music therapy associations were also aware of members working with LGB clients or inLGB clinical settings. This paper is an exploration of this relatively untapped area of musictherapy. A comprehensive literature review together with descriptive research byquestionnaire-based survey was used to achieve the aims of developing and broadeningour understanding of the status of LGB issues and perspectives in music therapy.The implications of these findings from the literature review and the surveyed educationprograms and professional associations for music therapy training practice and futureresearch are discussed.
Key Words: Music therapy training and education, LGB issues, music therapy curriculum,
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
3/185
III
Dedication
This thesis is dedicated to my grandfather Sean Kennedy andmy grandmother Angela McKeogh
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
4/185
IV
Acknowledgements
Firstly I would like to thank my Professor, Patricia Sabbatella for inviting me to Spain to do
this Masters by research in Music Therapy. Patricia encouraged and supported me studying
in a new language and guided me in all aspects of this work.
I would like to thank my parents, Shay and June Ahessy and my brother Mark for their
encouragement. I would not have been able to undertake this project without them and I am
truly grateful.
Much gratitude to Professor Tom Hayden for his help with project design and revisions. He
was a constant support to me and his input was greatly valued throughout the year.
I would like to especially thank Maria Rey Piulestan for her patience and work on the
translation of the questionnaires.
I would also like to thank Mr. Alan Frisby, who was involved in reviewing the questionnaires
and his knowledge of statistics and survey research was of great help.
I wish to acknowledge Professor Celia Kitzinger (University of York) for advice and
guidance on LGB topics and terminology, and Dr. Gregory Herek (University of California
at Davis) for his advice on terminology. I would also like to thank Dr. Joanne Harrison
(University of South Australia) for sending articles and resources on LGB ageing issues.
Sincerest thanks to Carla Bongiorno for the editing and proof reading of the thesis and
Anya Gardiner for her online support and advice throughout the research.
Finally, I wish to express my sincere gratitude to all the music therapy programs and
associations, without whose participation, this study would not have been possible
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
5/185
V
Table of Contents
Title page........
Abstract...Dedication...Acknowledgements..Table of contents.List of tables & figuresAuthors note....Prologue...........
I
IIIIIIVVIXXIXII
Introduction.......
Chapter I Theoretical Foundations .
1
5
1.1: Music therapy practice and research
1.2: Emerging issues in music therapy and music therapy training....
1.2.1: Multicultural music therapy.1.2.2. LGB issues in music therapy1.2.3. Multicultural issues in music therapy training..1.2.4. LGB issues in music therapy and psychotherapy training...
Chapter II Literature review.
6
9
10111314
18
2.1: LGB sexualities and therapy.
2.1.1: Historical perspectives....2.1.2: Homophobia and heterosexism..2.1.3: Societal and institutionalised forms.
2.1.3.1: Education.2.1.3.2: Media..
2.1.3.3: Health care..2.1.4: Internalised homophobia2.1.5: Mental health among LGB individuals
2.2: LGB lifespan issues
2.2.1: Youth and adolescence.
2.2.1.1: The coming out process2.2.1.2: Models of coming out2.2.1.3: Disclosure to parents...
2.2.1.4: Adopting a LGB identity..2.2.1.5: Conversion/reparative therapy.
19
192123
2324
24
2831
33
33
3435363839
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
6/185
VI
2.2.2: LGB midlife.
2.2.2.1: Prejudice against LGB families....2.2.2.2: Affirming LGB families
2.2.3: LGB ageing2.2.3.1: Aged care settings and fears..2.2.2.2: Affirming ageing LGB individuals...2.2.2.3: Ageing successfully......
2.3: Gay affirmative therapy....
2.3.1: Critique.
2.4: Summary
40
4041
42434445
46
52
53
Chapter III Methodology.. 55
3.1: Justification for the Investigation....3.2: Investigative method..3.3: Participants3.4: Survey A
3.4.1: Participants in Survey A3.4.2: Structure of Questionnaire A
3.4.2.1: Introduction to Survey A...3.4.2.2: Professional and program contexts (questions 1-5)3.4.2.3: Provision of LGB issues (questions 6-13).3.4.2.4: LGB issues in music therapy (questions 14-17).....3.4.2.5: Final section (questions 19-21).....
3.5: Survey B...
3.5.1: Participants in Survey B..3.5.2: Structure of Questionnaire B...
3.5.2.1: Introduction to Survey B3.5.2.2: Association information (question 1)3.5.2.3: Provision of LGB issues (questions 2-4)3.5.2.4: LGB issues in music therapy (questions 5-7).
3.6: Ethical Implications.3.7: Method of Distribution...3.8: Procedure................3.9: Data Collection..3.10: Data Analysis.
56575960
6062
6364656870
71
7173
73737475
7676777878
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
7/185
VII
Chapter IV Results..79
4.1: Results of survey A Music Therapy University programs..
4.1.1: Professional and program contexts..
4.1.1.1: Characteristics of the respondents...4.1.1.2: Theoretical orientations of the respondents music therapy training4.1.1.3: Academic levels and duration of the music therapy programs...4.1.1.4: Theoretical orientations of the music therapy programs..
4.1.2: Provision of LGB issues in music therapy programs
4.1.2.1: Multicultural topics addressed in music therapy training.4.1.2.2: LGB topics in the music therapy programs...4.1.2.3: Reasons for not addressing LGB issues4.1.2.4: Manner in which LGB issues are addressed.4.1.2.5: LGB topics in music therapy curriculum4.1.2.6: The Importance of LGB issues in the music therapy programs.4.1.2.7: Preparation for working with LGB clients4.1.2.8: Clinical practicum with LGB clients...
4.1.3: LGB issues in music therapy education
4.1.3.1: Importance of LGB issues in music therapy education..4.1.3.2: Academic level for the provision of LGB issues...4.1.3.3: Most important LGB topics for music therapy curriculum.
4.1.3.4: Guidelines and training opportunities for working with LGB clients4.1.3.5: Provision of LGB issues in the respondents own music therapy training...
4.2: Results of survey B Music therapy Associations...
4.2.1: Association information...4.2.2: Provision of LGB Issues...
4.2.2.1: Provision of guidelines for working with LGB clients....4.2.2.2: Training opportunities in LGB issues.4.2.2.3: Music therapists working with LGB clients
4.2.3: LGB issues in music therapy
4.2.3.1: Training in LGB issues at university level..4.2.3.2: Importance of LGB issues for practicing music therapists.
4.3: Comparative results...
4.3.1: Guidelines and training opportunities in LGB issues....4.3.2: LGB issues in music therapy education
4.4: Main findings.
80
80
80838586
87
8788899192939496
97
979899
102103
104
104106
106106107
107
107107
108
108108
109
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
8/185
VIII
Chapter V Discussion & Conclusion...................................................................................111
5.1: Discussion of results - Survey A..
5.1.1: Professional & program context.5.1.2: Provision of LGB issues...5.1.3: LGB issues in music therapy
5.2: Discussion of results - Survey B...
5.2.1: Association information...5.2.2: Provision of LGB issues...5.2.3: LGB issues in music therapy
5.3: Limitations..5.4: Recommendations and implications for music therapy...5.5: Directions for future research5.6: Conclusion..
References ..
Appendices.
Appendix 1 Music Therapy associations codes of ethics
Appendix 2 Survey A Introductory letter and debrief page...
Appendix 3 Survey A Questionnaire
Appendix 4 Survey B Introductory letter and debrief page.Appendix 5 Survey B Questionnaire
Appendix 6 Survey A Introductory letter (Spanish version)..
Appendix 7 Survey A Questionnaire (Spanish version)
Appendix 8 Survey B Introductory letter (Spanish version)...
Appendix 9 Survey B Questionnaire (Spanish version).
Appendix 10 Survey A Further comments...
Appendix 11 Survey B Further comments...
112
112114124
128
128129130
131131134135
137
153
154
155
156
160
161
162
163
168
169
170
172
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
9/185
IX
List of Tables
Chapter I Theoretical foundations
Table 1.1: The range of music therapy settings and clientsTable 1.2: Professional Research Topics.Table 1.3: Implicit and active gay affirmative therapy.
68
17
Chapter II Literature review
Table 2.1: Essential qualities of therapist working with LGB clients 51
Chapter III Methodology
Table 3.1: Survey research dealing with training and education in music therapy.Table 3.2: Music Therapy websites consulted.Table 3.3: Number of eligible participants for Survey A (by country)...Table 3.4: Eligible music therapy programs who received the surveyTable 3.5: Questionnaire A Dimensions...Table 3.6: Number of eligible participants for Survey B (by country)Table 3.7: Eligible music therapy associations who received the survey.Table 3.8: Dimensions of questionnaire B...
5859606163717273
Chapter IV Results
Table 4.1: Music Therapy Programs that respondedTable 4.2: Responses continent by continent.Table 4.3: Respondents years of clinical experienceTable 4.4: Association between experience and provision of LGB issues.Table 4.5: Theoretical Orientations of the respondents own music therapy trainingTable 4.6: Academic levels of music therapy programs...Table 4.7: Duration of music therapy programs...
Table 4.8: Theoretical orientations of the music therapy programs..Table 4.9: Multicultural topics addressed by the programs..Table 4.10: Programs that specifically address LGB issuesTable 4.11: Reasons for not addressing LGB issues in music therapy programs.Table 4.12: Where LGB issues were addressed in the programs...Table 4.13: LGB topics addressed..Table 4.14: Importance of LGB issues as a component of the music therapy programTable 4.15: Clinical practicum with LGB clients...Table 4.16: Importance of LGB issues as a component of music therapy...Table 4.17: The importance of LGB issues as a component of music therapy educationTable 4.18: Academic level for the provision of LGB issues...Table 4.19: Important LGB topics for music therapy education..Table 4.20: Guidelines and training opportunities in LGB issuesTable 4.21: Provision of LGB issues when the respondents trained as music therapists...Table 4.22: Respondents who received training in LGB issues in their own training...
81818283848585
8687898991929396979799
100103103103
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
10/185
X
Table 4.23: Respondents by continentTable 4.24: Music therapy associations that responded to the survey...Table 4.25: Establishment of associations..Table 4.26: Provision of guidelines on LGB issues...Table 4.27: Further training opportunities in LGB issues.
Table 4.28: Members working in LGB area...Table 4.29: Would training in LGB issues professionally benefit music therapists..Table 4.30: Importance of LGB issues for music therapists in your country.Table 4.31: Guidelines and training opportunities in LGB issuesTable 4.32: Provision of guidelines and training opportunities in LGB issues..Table 4.33: Would training in LGB issues professionally benefit music therapists..Table 4.34: Programs that specifically address LGB issues
104105105106106
107107108108108109109
Chapter V Discussion & Conclusion
Table 5.1: Important topics for working with LGB clients 126
List of Figures
Chapter III Methodology
Box 3.1: Introductory letter.Box 3.2: Debrief page... 6370
Chapter IV ResultsFigure 4.1: Continental response: Survey AFigure 4.2: Duration of experience of directors of music therapy programs..Figure 4.3: Duration of experience in relation to provision of LGB issues...Figure 4.4: Theoretical orientations of the programs respondents attended/direct...Figure 4.5: Duration of programs...Figure 4.6: Multicultural topics addressed by the music therapy programs
Figure 4.7: Reasons why LGB topics were not addressed...Figure 4.8: The manner in which LGB issues are addressedFigure 4.9: The importance of LGB issues in the programs.Figure 4.10: The importance of LGB issues (LGB+/LGB-)...Figure 4.11: LGB topics which respondents addressed and rated important.Figure 4.12: Correlation between important LGB topics between LGB+ and LGB .Figure 4.13: Continental response: Survey B...
808283848688
90929498
101102104
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
11/185
XI
Authors Note
Throughout the course of this thesis the acronym LGB is used rather than the termhomosexual or homosexuals, to refer to lesbian, gay and/or bisexual persons/individuals.
The word homosexual has several problems of designation. First, it may perpetrate negativestereotypes because of its historical associations with pathology and criminal behaviour; second, it isambiguous in reference because it is often assumed to refer exclusively to men and thus renders lesbiansinvisible. Third, it is often unclear (American Psychological Association, 1991).
The researcher contacted two leading professors in the field of LGB psychologies to ensurethe wording for this thesis is politically correct and up to date. 1Both professors approved that the title for this thesis and reported that usage of the term LGB wasin line with what is in common use in both scholarly and activist context.
The term heterosexual will be used in the course of this thesis as an adjective for those whodo not engage in sexual relations with people of the same gender. The AmericanPsychological Association (1991) suggests that heterosexual as an adjective is acceptable forpeople who have male-female affectional/sexual relationships.
The term sexual orientation is used rather than sexual preference inline with theguidelines of the American Psychological Association, due to the word preferencesuggesting an element of voluntary choice that is not necessarily reported by lesbians andgay men, and that has not been demonstrated in psychological research (AmericanPsychological Association, 1991).
The American Psychological Association defines sexual orientation as an enduringemotional, romantic sexual or affectionate attraction to individuals of a certain gender
(Fordham, 1998:14).
Although transgender and intersex issues are not addressed in this thesis, they arementioned by other authors.
Glossary
LGB lesbian, gay and/or bisexualLGBT lesbian, gay, bisexual and/or transgenderedLGBTI lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgendered and/or intersex
1Prof. Celia Kitzinger Department of Sociology, University of York... She is author of the book Social
Construction of Lesbianism (1987) and co-author of the books Heterosexuality: a Feminism & PsychologyReader (1993), Changing Our Minds (1993), Feminism & Discourse: Psychological Perspectives 1996), andLesbian & Gay Psychology: New perspectives (2002) as well as many scholarly articles.Dr. Gregory M. Herek Professor of Psychology at the University of California at Davis, editor of the Journalof Sex Research, the Journal of Homosexuality and Applied Social Psychology. His edited and co-editedbooks include Hate Crimes: Confronting violence against lesbians & gay men (1992), AIDS Identity &Community: HIV & Lesbians & Gay Men (1995), Out in Force: Sexual Orientation & the Military (1996), andStigma & Sexual Orientation (1998).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
12/185
XII
Prologue
Two LovesI dreamed I stood upon a little hill,
And at my feet there lay a ground, that seemedLike a waste garden, flowering at its will
With buds and blossoms. There were pools that dreamedBlack and unruffled; there were white lilies
A few, and crocuses, and violetsPurple or pale, snake-like fritillaries
Scarce seen for the rank grass, and through green netsBlue eyes of shy peryenche winked in the sun.
And there were curious flowers, before unknown,Flowers that were stained with moonlight, or with shades
Of Nature's willful moods; and here a oneThat had drunk in the transitory tone
Of one brief moment in a sunset; bladesOf grass that in an hundred springs had beenSlowly but exquisitely nurtured by the stars,
And watered with the scented dew long cuppedIn lilies, that for rays of sun had seen
Only God's glory, for never a sunrise marsThe luminous air of Heaven. Beyond, abrupt,A grey stone wall. o'ergrown with velvet mossUprose; and gazing I stood long, all mazedTo see a place so strange, so sweet, so fair.
And as I stood and marvelled, lo! across
The garden came a youth; one hand he raisedTo shield him from the sun, his wind-tossed hairWas twined with flowers, and in his hand he bore
A purple bunch of bursting grapes, his eyesWere clear as crystal, naked all was he,
White as the snow on pathless mountains frore,Red were his lips as red wine-spilith that dyes
A marble floor, his brow chalcedony.And he came near me, with his lips uncurled
And kind, and caught my hand and kissed my mouth,And gave me grapes to eat, and said, 'Sweet friend,
Come I will show thee shadows of the worldAnd images of life. See from the South
Comes the pale pageant that hath never an end.'
And lo! within the garden of my dreamI saw two walking on a shining plain
Of golden light. The one did joyous seemAnd fair and blooming, and a sweet refrainCame from his lips; he sang of pretty maids
And joyous love of comely girl and boy,His eyes were bright, and 'mid the dancing blades
Of golden grass his feet did trip for joy;
And in his hand he held an ivory luteWith strings of gold that were as maidens' hair,
And sang with voice as tuneful as a flute,
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
13/185
XIII
And round his neck three chains of roses were.But he that was his comrade walked aside;
He was full sad and sweet, and his large eyesWere strange with wondrous brightness, staring wide
With gazing; and he sighed with many sighs
That moved me, and his cheeks were wan and whiteLike pallid lilies, and his lips were redLike poppies, and his hands he clenched tight,
And yet again unclenched, and his headWas wreathed with moon-flowers pale as lips of death.
A purple robe he wore, o'erwrought in goldWith the device of a great snake, whose breath
Was fiery flame: which when I did beholdI fell a-weeping, and I cried, 'Sweet youth,
Tell me why, sad and sighing, thou dost roveThese pleasant realms? I pray thee speak me sooth
What is thy name?' He said, 'My name is Love.'
Then straight the first did turn himself to meAnd cried, 'He lieth, for his name is Shame,
But I am Love, and I was wont to beAlone in this fair garden, till he cameUnasked by night; I am true Love, I fill
The hearts of boy and girl with mutual flame.'Then sighing, said the other, 'Have thy will,I am the love that dare not speak its name.'
(Douglas, A. 1896)
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
14/185
Introduction
1
1.1. Introduction
Lord Alfred Douglass prose was used by the prosecution in the famous trial of Oscar
Wilde, the Irish playwright, novelist and poet in 1895 that lead to him being imprisoned
and sentenced to two years hard labour for his sexual orientation. The trial resulted inpublic attitudes towards same-sex sexualities becoming increasingly harsher and less
tolerant. Over one hundred years later, sexual minority rights have improved greatly in
many countries around the world and there are many anti-discrimination laws are in place
to ensure equality for sexual minorities and to enforce the protection of LGB individuals.
Unfortunately widespread prejudice and intolerance exists in many countries and in others,
blatant oppression and sanctioned discrimination of sexual minorities.
Despite the improvements in societal acceptance of LGB individuals, we LGB individuals are one of the
only minority groups that are met with continued legalised discrimination (Safren, 2005: 29).
in recent years the President of the United States attempted to make a constitutional
amendment to ban same-sex marriage;
the Prime Minister of Australia initiated an adoption bill prohibiting same-sex couples
from adopting babies from outside the Australian jurisdiction;
participants in the LGB pride parade in Warsaw this year were repeatedly attacked
during their improvised march after the Mayor of the city refused the participants apermit to hold the parade; and then issued a permit for a normality parade, which in
reality was preaching hate and intolerance against sexual minorities; and
currently around 85 member states of the United Nations consider LGB sexual
relations to be a criminal act and some of these countries impose the death penalty
(Flamer-Caldera & Kahramanoglu, 2007; Joint United Nations Program, 2007).
Since the late 1800s activists have long taken up the cause for LGB rights. However it has
only been since the late 1960s, after the Stonewall riots, and the beginning of the gay
liberation movement in the 1970s, that activists came to prominence in their fight for equal
rights, benefits and protections for the LGB community. A momentous occasion for the LGB
community was the declassification of homosexuality as pathology, and its removal from the
list of mental illnesses in the American Psychiatric Associations (APA) Diagnostic Statistical
Manual (DSM) III (Davies & Neal, 1996). Although music has been used therapeutically in
many cultures for centuries, the specific discipline of music therapy is a middle-to-late
twentieth century development (Bunt, 1997: 249). The first training courses were initiated
after the Second World War, but as with LGB activism it was only from the beginning of
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
15/185
Introduction
2
the 1970s that the profession became established internationally. During this decade music
therapy associations in Australia, Canada, Norway and the United States were established
and more music therapy programs were initiated in the Australia, Denmark, the United
Kingdom and other countries (Bunt, 1997:249). By this decade the music therapy community
and had two peer-reviewed journals in the United States and Canada and pioneers such as
Juliet Alvin, Mary Priestley, Helen Bonny, Rolando Benenzon, Serafina Poch Blasco, and
Clive and Carol Robbins were paving the way forward and solidifying the growing
profession. The World Congress of Music Therapy was also initiated in this decade and the
seeds for the development of a World Federation of Music Therapy were sown (World
Federation of Music Therapy, 2007).
It can be seen from this brief summary that the 1970s was a decade in which both the musictherapy profession and the gay liberation movement were both gaining strength, maturing
and making themselves heard in the world. Since music therapy as a profession was just
establishing itself at this time, it is perhaps understandable that LGB issues and gay
affirmative approaches were not incorporated into the field to the extent they were in the
longer established disciplines of psychology and psychotherapy. Over thirty years later,
LGB issues and perspectives have still not been sufficiently explored or addressed in music
therapy. There was a development of multicultural music therapy literature in the 1990s
(Moreno, 1988 1989 1995; Toppozada, 1995; Sloss, 1996; Brandt, 1997; Darrow and
Molloy 1998; Ruud, 1998; Estrella, 2001; Brown, 2002; Stige, 2002; Chase, 2003),
resulting in more attention being given to this area in music therapy in regard to education,
training and supervision. Nevertheless LGB issues were not specifically addressed in this
domain and as consequence they have been largely neglected by all but by a few authors.
Chase (2004) reviewed LGB psychotherapy literature on working with LGB clients and
provided implications for music therapists. Lee (1996) and Bruscia (1998b) published case
studies on gay men living with HIV/AIDS, and Hedigan (2005) presented a paper on
working with a chemically dependent gay male. There have been no music therapy case
studies, which focus on LGB lifespan issues, nor research on the provision of LGB issues in
training programs or professional development. This is the reason that this researcher
wanted to explore LGB issues and perspectives in music therapy and to evaluate
developments in the literature, and music therapy education and professional development.
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
16/185
Introduction
3
Questions that were of interest to the researcher included:
where and how have LGB issues been addressed in the music therapy literature?
what are the central topics regarding therapy with LGB clients? And LGB individuals
topics the lifespan?
are LGB topics being addressed in music therapy training programs?
which LGB topics do the music therapy programs address? And what format does the
provision of LGB issues take?
do music therapy associations provide any guidelines or opportunities for continuing
professional education regarding LGB issues?
are music therapists working with LGB clients? and
how important do music therapy programs and associations view LGB issues as acomponent of music therapy education and the field at large?
This project aimed to answer these questions and explore LGB issues in music therapy by
a. a comprehensive review of LGB issues in the music therapy literature and related
disciplines of psychology and psychotherapy, to identify the central LGB topics across
the lifespan;
b. a global survey of music therapy programs investigating the provision of LGB issues in
music therapy education; and
c. a global survey of music therapy associations investigating the provision of guidelines
or training opportunities in LGB issues.
Chapter 1 sets out the theoretical orientations of the project. It examines music therapy
practice and research; multicultural issues and LGB issues in music therapy. It also explores,
multicultural training in music therapy, as well as LGB issues in music therapy training and
psychology and psychotherapy training. Chapter 2 sets out a review of the LGB psychology
and psychotherapy literature, with the aim of identifying central LGB topics relevant for
music therapists and music therapy educators. The literature that has formed the subject of
this review has been divided into 3 main sections for the purpose of this discussion (1) an
inquiry into LGB issues that have direct impacts on healthcare and therapy, (2) an
exploration of LGB issues over the lifespan, and (3) an exploration of gay affirmative
therapy. Chapter 3 contains a detailed explanation of the methodology used in the
execution of the surveys. After a justification for the study, both questionnaires for thesurvey of music therapy programs and the music therapy associations are presented. There
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
17/185
Introduction
4
is an explanation of the method of distribution, the procedure and ethical implications of the
surveys, as well as a discussion of the data collection process, data analysis. Chapter 4 sets
out the results for each question in the surveys. There is a final section, in which comparative
results between the two surveys are presented, finishing with a summary of the main
findings. Chapter 5 is a discussion of the survey results, presented by theme. The limitations
of the study are discussed, as well as applications and implications for music therapy.
Finally recommendations and possibilities for future research are discussed.
Because there is more visibility and acceptance of LGB individuals than ever before, it is
urgent that music therapists explore and become familiar with LGB issues and perspectives.
Music therapists will encounter more opportunities to work with LGB clients and families and
therapists need to be certain that they possess the knowledge, skills, and sensitivity to provide
competent care to this population (Eubanks-Carter et al. 2005, p. 1). Many LGB individuals
will present for therapy at some point in their lives, perhaps more so than the general
population. So it is imperative that music therapists have been exposed to, and addressed
LGB issues in their music therapy training, and have opportunities for continuing professional
development regarding working with LGB clients (Bradford et al. 1994; Jones & Gabriel,
1999. In. Safren, 2005).
This thesis deals only with LGB issues. It does not include transgender or intersex issues. Theresearcher felt that although sharing some common issues with LGB individuals,
transgendered and intersex individuals have very specific issues related to their gender
identity and for that reason they have not been included in this work. Although bisexual
individuals have distinctive issues too, they also share many issues with gay men and lesbian
women, and so perhaps it is easier to speak about LGB issues than LGBTI2 issues. If there
were no discrimination and sexual orientation was as insignificant as the colour of a persons
eyes or hair, then there would be no need to focus on and highlight on LGB issues; however
sexual minorities are stigmatised and still very much discriminated against. Discrimination on
the basis of sexual orientation can in turn lead to important LGB issues being hidden, by
LGB individuals, health-care workers and larger communities. As the literature reveals,
attention to and discourse on LGB issues in music therapy is long overdue. This thesis is the
first study in the field of music therapy to assess the provision of LGB issues in music therapy
training programs and the provision of guidelines and opportunities for continuing
professional education in LGB related matters.
2 LGBTI Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgendered, Inter-sex
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
18/185
Theoretical Orientations
5
Chapter I
Theoretical Orientations
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
19/185
Theoretical Orientations
6
1.1. Music therapy practice and research
Music was perhaps the first art form to be employed therapeutically. There is evidence of
this in Egyptian medical papyri, biblical passages, Greek medical practice, as well as
creation stories, magic and mythology and tribal medicine (Bunt, 1997).Ruud (1998, p. 53)defines music therapy as
The use of music and/or its elements (sound, rhythm, melody, and harmony) by a musictherapist, and client or group, in a process designed to facilitate and promotecommunication, relationship, learning, mobilization, expression and organization(physical, emotional, mental, social and cognitive) in order to develop potentials anddevelop or restore functions of the individual so that he or she can achieve better intra-and interpersonal integration and, consequently a better quality of life.
Music therapy its application is varied and holistic. Educational, recreational, rehabilitative,
preventive, or psychotherapeutic goals can be addressed and physical, psychological,
emotional, intellectual, social and spiritual needs can be met(Bruscia, 1998a, p. 11). Music
therapy is thus a unique fusion between science and art, and can work effectively as a
treatment intervention with clients in medical, psychoanalytical, behavioural and humanistic
domains. Music therapy today is employed in many settings and for the benefit of a great
variety of clients, as illustrated in table 1.1 below.
Employment of Music TherapyRange of clients Range of settingsAutistic children and adultsEmotionally disturbed children and adultsAdults with psychiatric disordersCognitively disabled children and adultsIndividuals with visual, hearing, speech andmotor impairmentLearning disabled children and adultsAbused children, and abuse survivorsSex offendersIndividuals with behavioural, language andcommunication disordersPrisonersSubstance abusers
Medical patientsAgeing individuals,Terminally ill children and adultsAdopted childrenFamiliesRefugees and asylum seekersBereaved individualsNeonates
SchoolsClinicsHospitalsResidential centresGroup homesNursing homesDay-care centresHospicesPrisonsCommunity centresInstitutesPrivate practices
Table 1.1: The range of music therapy settings and clients (Bruscia, 1998a, p. 11).
The range of clients with whom music therapists work with is constantly growing, and
therapists can now be found working with communities as well as individuals for lifeenhancement, stress management, personal growth, spiritual development and a range of
other problems (Bruscia, 1998a, p. 11).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
20/185
Theoretical Orientations
7
Bruscia (1987) has identified two types of music therapy; music in therapy and music as
therapy.
Music in therapy: Music as a form of relaxation to support verbally-based psychotherapy
or in dentistry and surgery (Bunt, 1997, p. 251).
Music as therapy: Music is the central ingredient, changes in the music often being
mirrored in changes within the client-therapist relationship (Bunt, 1997, p. 251).
The clinical practice of music therapy straddles many disciplines. Every music therapistbrings to the profession a unique blend of musical and personal skills and experiences,applied practically in the service of children and adults with wide-ranging physical andmental health care needs. Effective clinical practice also requires awareness of the relevantpsychological and therapeutic processes and knowledge of the appropriate medicalbackground (Bunt, 1997, p. 249).
Research is a vital aspect of the discipline and profession of music therapy. Research, theory
and practice depend on each other, likened to a tripod by Gaston (1968) each necessary in
order for the other to stand (Wheeler, 2005a: 5). Wheeler (2005) differentiates between
basic research and applied research as follows
1) Basic research is conducted with the aim of increasing knowledge. The application of
research findings is not the central aim, but rather knowledge for its own sake
which may ultimately lead to changes in practice.
2) Applied research on the other hand is conducted with the aim of solving a practicalproblem, to test a hypothesis or model in a real situation of interest or to expand
our understanding of an actual situation. The author notes how basic research can
become applied research once the results are applied to real problems
Wheeler (2005a, p. 11)
Bruscia (1998a) divides music therapy research topics into two distinct categories; topics on
the discipline and topics on the profession. In research topics on the discipline of music
therapy, he observes three broad topical areas: assessment, treatment and evaluation.
Research of the profession of music therapy is any systematic, self monitored inquiry which
leads to a discovery regarding music therapists, professional standards, education and
training, employment, history, and public relations and conditions affecting the discipline of
music therapy (Bruscia, 1998a, p. 253). For research to be discipline orientated the topic
must include four elements: the client, the therapist, the musical experience and the
therapeutic process (Bruscia, 1998a, p. 253). Research on the profession of music therapy
covers a broad scope of interrelated topics (Table 1.2: Bruscia, 1998a, p. 251).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
21/185
Theoretical Orientations
8
Professional Research Topics ThemesEmployment practices Work settings, job titles, salaries, job duties, music therapys place in
health care settings and institutions, music therapy policies andprocedures and accountability
Music therapists Demographics, profession related stress and burn-out, personality
profiles, levels of education, attitudes and opinions regarding clinicalwork, and employmentProfessional education and training Teaching and supervision methods, student experiences and
personality profiles, curricula, and academic requirementsProfessional standards Ethics in music therapy clinical work, competency standards and
registration procedures and issues, academic and clinical trainingprogram standards
Legislation and public relations Effects of laws and regulation on music therapy, licensing issues,relationships between music therapy and other disciplines, politicaland cultural factors in the advancement of music therapy
History and culture Historical narratives of the discipline and profession of music therapyand music therapy associations and organisations, biographies, meta-analysis and descriptions of research literature
Table 1.2 Professional Research Topics (Bruscia, 1998a, p. 251)
Research in music therapy has been growing steadily over the past four decades and
Edwards (2005) observes that for the last 10 years there have been music therapy journals
produced in English in six countries compared with 1 journal in the 1970s and two in the
1980s. Six categories of research in music therapy were identified in a survey of nine
journals: quantitative, qualitative, clinical reports, philosophical and theoretical research,
historical research and professional articles, (Brooks, 2003). Quantitative articles and
clinical reports were found to be the most common, making up two thirds of the articles
analysed, Qualitative, philosophical/theoretical and professional research were equally
represented, while historical research received the lowest attention (Edwards, 2005). More
recently, there has been an increase in qualitative designs in music therapy such as;
hermeneutic, phenomenological and naturalistic inquiry, art-based research, participatory
action-research, first-person research and ethnographically informed research inquiry as
well as mixed designs. After a relatively brief history of research when compared with
other disciplines, music therapy has an effectual, developed and comprehensive body of
research with a variety of designs and we are poised in this new century to use this body
of knowledge to consolidate, refine and further develop our approaches to research
(Edwards, 2005, p. 20).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
22/185
Theoretical Orientations
9
1.2. Emerging Issues in music therapy and music therapy training
Music therapy is an ever-evolving and expanding discipline both in clinical practice and
research. Although music therapists still work in the traditional clinical areas, the 2005
World Music Therapy Conference in Brisbane, Australia presented some more recent and
emerging client groups with whom music therapists work, such as:
women survivors of violence,
adopted children;
mother and infant asylum seekers,
indigenous families;
sexually abused children;children from war-torn countries; and
offenders from ethnic minorities.
More recent and emerging themes in music therapy theory, practice and research were also
highlighted, such as:
music therapy and spirituality,
cultural competency in music therapy;
community music therapy; and
multicultural music therapy.
Music therapists have always worked in communities to some extent. In recent years there
has been more of a focus on community based music therapy and systems theory. From this
perspective ill-health is seen within a totality as a part of social systems and embedded in
material processes (Ruud, 2004, p. 11). Music therapy in some of these contexts hasbecome more socio-political, dealing with whole communities, focusing on systemic
interventions, network building, and providing symbolic means for underprivileged
individuals or being used to empower subordinate groups (Ruud, 2004, p. 13).
Today, music therapy is used alongside other therapies in many conflict zones and deprived
areas. There have been music therapists working with Tsunami victims in Thailand and music
therapy projects in other disaster areas (Fachner, 2007). At the Brisbane World Conferencein 2007 the World Federation of Music Therapy initiated a new commission called Global
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
23/185
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
24/185
Theoretical Orientations
11
in music therapy programs and multicultural approaches in music therapy supervision. The
practice of culturally-sensitive music therapy is intertwined with personal awareness and
requires a music therapist to take another step towards this awareness. It calls for
examination and sensitivity to ones own worldview and a willingness to be open to others,
recognising that both differences and similarities exist (Brown, 2002: 85).
Sue (1996) highlights the fact that the Eurocentric or Euro-American view has been the
standard to judge normality, abnormality and characteristics of good counseling within the
psychotherapeutic tradition (Estrella, 2001, p. 44). The multicultural music therapy literature
has emphasised the need for music therapists to examine their own worldviews, while
becoming more familiar with cultural differences (Chase, 2003). Familiarity with world
musics and the role they play within cultures is also seen as a therapeutic asset for musictherapists (Moreno, 1995). Therapists need to be aware of differences in attitudes and
value-systems of their culturally diverse clients. Lack of attention to these cultural differences
may lead to misdiagnosis and hinder effective therapeutic results (Brandt, 1997).
1.2.2. LGB Issues in music therapy
In music therapy LGB issues are not covered sufficiently in any of the discourse on
multicultural issues, and nor are they addressed in other contexts including: music therapy
case studies, clinical reports and research. There have been some case studies of music
therapy with gay men, but only in relation to having HIV/AIDS or substance addiction.
Bruscia (1998b) has two guided imagery through music (GIM) case studies with two gay
men suffering from AIDS and Colin Lees (1996) Music at the Edge: The Music Therapy
Experiences of a Musician with AIDS describes the journey of a gay man who eventually
dies from the disease. More recentlyat the 10th World Music Therapy Congress (2005) in
Brisbane, Australia, music therapist John Hedigan presented his work on Using music therapy
to explore sexual orientation with a heroin- dependent male. They are all extremely valuablecase studies, but none of them examine the complex spectrum of issues specific to LGB
clients presenting for therapy. The case studies are mainly in relation to HIV/AIDS, and do
not sufficiently explore the multitude of LGB specific lifespan and societal issues.
Furthermore the focus of such case studies has been on gay males, excluding lesbian and
bisexual experiences.
The only exception is an article, which focuses more directly on lesbian and gay issues in
therapy with implications for music therapists by Kristin Chase (2004). Chase reviewing the
literature on therapy with gay and lesbian clients identified four areas relevant to music
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
25/185
Theoretical Orientations
12
therapists. These were (i) general issues and approaches, (ii) attitudes towards therapists,
(iii) choice of therapist, and (iv) heterosexual therapists working with gay lesbian and gay
clients. She highlights some key issues for music therapy
music therapists must feel confident to refer a client if they are not comfortable or
experienced in this area, rather than risking culturally incompetent care;
music therapists may not work directly with lesbian and gay clients, but may encounter
lesbian and gay parents, family members across many settings and be aware of the
effects of negative attitudes in these circumstances and their effects on therapeutic
outcomes. Music therapists may also take on the role of a family advocate to their
lesbian or gay client; and
It is important to have an understanding of transference and counter-transference, aswell as issues such as: the effects of oppression and heterosexism and loss and
mourning of the heterosexual self, or of family and friends.
Chase (2004) also recommends that music therapists engage in rigorous self reflection by
means of a complete cultural self-assessment or reflective journal writing, and that we
become familiar with lesbian and gay culture through literature, films and LGB networks
finally. She also recommends that therapists adapt the clinical practice of music therapy to
be more inclusive by using inclusive terminology, a wider variety of music and adopting a
cultural assessment tool as part of clinical assessment. This author also reviews how lesbian
and gay clients bring a diversity of typical and atypical issues to therapy and that music
therapy is a valuable treatment modality for these clients music therapy has been effective
with grieving persons, hospitalised patients, persons with psychiatric illness, adolescents with
emotional issues and well adults seeking therapy (Austin, 1996; Bednarz & Nickkel, 1992;
Frish, 1990; Heaney, 1992; OCallaghan, 1997; O Callaghan & Cosgrove 1998 in Chase,
2004, p. 37). Chase does not consider bisexual individuals in this article.
Music therapy in its integration of multiculturalism traditionally looked to the disciplines of
psychology and psychotherapy, with their larger bodies of research to inform and
familiarise itself with multiculturalism, thus evolving the field and encouraging multicultural
music therapy literature and research to grow. LGB issues have not sufficiently been dealt
with in the music therapy literature so it seems appropriate to look to the psychology and
psychotherapeutic literature to investigate LGB issues and perspectives further in Chapter 2.
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
26/185
Theoretical Orientations
13
1.2.3. Multicultural issues in music therapy training
In Toppozadas (1995) study of music therapists attitudes toward multicultural issues, she
found that although the issue was perceived to be important for music therapy, training in
this area was taking place in professional contexts, rather than in training programs andthere was a need for music therapy students to do more coursework in the areas of
multicultural psychotherapy and ethical issues. It has been emphasised that multicultural
issues need to find their foundation in music therapy training courses (Brandt, 1997) and
that training courses need to prepare students for working with diverse populations
How can music therapists be aware of possible ethical issues when working with culturallydifferent clients? if they were never taught so during the training programs (Brandt,1997, p. 140).
In a survey of music therapists, Darrow and Molloy (1998, p. 30), found that while musictherapy programs in the United States were incorporating multicultural issues into their
curricula and viewed them important, often there is was little attention given to these issues
in course work or central modules in comparison with music education programs. They also
found that the majority of music therapists felt their training programs did not adequately
prepare them to work in multicultural settings. Brown (2002) argues that training in
multicultural issues should work on Iveys (1997) first and second order skills. These are:
1) The therapists ability to communicate culturally, effectively and sensitively within thetherapeutic relationship
2) The therapists ability to appropriately apply therapeutic interventions within in the
cultural context (Brown, 2002: 88).
Furthermore, the skills needed to practice within culturally-centred music therapy will be
learned through training, but also with time and experience. Practicing within a culture-
centred framework is to be seen as an ongoing and incremental process (Brown, 2002).
Stone (1997) defines two approaches in multiculturalism:
1) Inclusive: A broad and international definition of cultural groups; race, ethnicity,
nationality, social class, religion, gender, sexual orientation, age, disability
2) Exclusive: Visible ethnic and racial groups; Native Americans, Australian aboriginal
peoples, Hispanic (Estrella, 2001, p. 47).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
27/185
Theoretical Orientations
14
Culture is a complex concept, and an individual may belong to one or multiple cultures
simultaneously, especially if culture is defined inclusive terms. In the majority of the music
therapy, psychology and psychotherapy literature on multicultural therapy, the definition of
culture has been somewhere in between inclusive and exclusive, however there has been
primarily a focus on nationality, ethnicity, race and religion in relation to culture, exclusive
to sexual orientation.
1.2.4. LGB issues in music therapy and psychotherapy training
There have been no specific studies in music therapy regarding LGB issues in music therapy
training, curricula and continuing professional education. This study being the first in the
field to assess this area, the researcher reviewed the psychotherapy and psychology
literature, to assess the current situation regarding training in LGB issues and highlight keypoints in relation to LGB issues in curricula and education. Educational institutions can be
vehicles for communicating heterosexual bias, and this bias has often served as an integral
part of the underpinnings of theoretical and research paradigms (Greene, 1994, p. 17).
This may explain the dearth of LGB content in psychology and psychotherapy literature and
training courses (Rodolfa & Davis, 2003).
Milton, Coyle and Legg (2002) interviewed 14 gay affirmative therapists and found that
many of these stated that there was limited coverage of LGB issues in training courses and
as a result there was difficulty discussing these issues openly. Participants emphasised the
limited coverage of LGB issues in their own training and also how the provision of these
issues were presented in a highly medicalised context, as opposed to a sociological context
and as a result there was difficulty discussing these issues openly. They were also of the
opinion that the professional literature holds either absent or limited and stagnant views
of therapy with LGB individuals and LGB issues in general (Milton, Coyle & Legg, 2002, p.
16). This was highlighted by Rodolfa & Davis (2003), who surveyed eight major psychologyjournals published during the 1990s and found there were only 2.11% of articles in these
publications addressing LGB issues a haunting and abysmal number and a challenge for
psychology (Rodolfa & Davis, 2003, p. 70). The Guidelines by the American Psychological
Association for working with LGB clients state that even though there has been an addition
of diversity training in graduate education, students often report a lack of education and
training in LGB issues and that graduate students and novice therapists feel unprepared to
work effectively with LGB clients (Garnets & Kimmel, 2003, p. 773). This means that the
lacunae of LGB issues in graduate training and the psychological literature will mean that
most therapists will lack valuable tools for working with LGB clients, including knowledge
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
28/185
Theoretical Orientations
15
about LGB experiences over the lifespan. This knowledge could naturally enhance
therapeutic skills and provide a more effective service to clients (Eubanks-Carter, 2005).
The promotion of LGB affirmative practice relies heavily on the provision of LGB issues in
therapeutic training courses. Adequate space needs to be created within the curriculum to
address LGB issues and educators need to promote competence in LGB affirmative practice
among trainees. This will entail staff developing and refining their own competence in this
domain and becoming skilled in disseminating it to trainees (Milton & Coyle, 1999, p. 56).
The American Psychological Association encourages faculty members and supervisors to
integrate LGB issues throughout training for professional practice. This could be achieved by
providing guest lecturers who have expertise in LGB issues or by faculty members seeking
out continuing education in LGB matters (American Psychological Association, 1998). This is
important for music therapy educators to consider.
In A Delphi study (Godfrey et al. 2006) examining essential components in curricula for
preparing therapists for work with LGB clients, panellists reached consensus on five
important in classroom learning experiences for students , which might prove useful for music
therapy educators:
listening to an LGB panel and guest speakers, including LGB people of colour;
providing therapy to LGB clients with supervision;
doing role plays of coming out scenarios with unaccepting parents, at work, with
friends;
observing therapy with LGB clients; and
writing papers on students own journeys around sexual orientation and goals for
development in reducing heterosexism in their own lives/families/work
settings/schools (Godfrey et al. 2006, p. 498).
It is important that up-to-date information and current research is used in the provision of
LGB topics at all levels in professional development, undergraduate, post-graduate,
continuing education and in-service training (Garnets et al. 1991). Which LGB topics should
be included in program curricula? There may obviously be core topics, which deserve more
attention, and others, which could be followed up through private guided reading. Rodolfa
& Davis (2003) list some core topics that should be minimally known by psychology trainees
if they are to be adequately prepared to work with LGB clients. These include: sexual
minority development, oppression and discrimination, coming out & identity development,
HIV/AIDS, bisexuality, assessment of sexual orientation and sexual identity, dual-minority
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
29/185
Theoretical Orientations
16
status, and LGB parenting. Homophobia, including its internalised and institutionalised forms,
was the topic picked by respondents as the most important LGB topic to address in another
study on components of curricula (Godfrey el al. 2006).
In the treatment of LGB issues, there could be a specific module or part thereof so
designated to address these issues in isolation. However, it has been found that addressing
diversity issues across the curriculum has lead to higher student satisfaction and
understanding as opposed to isolated seminars or classes (Rodolfa & Davies, 2003). It has
also been suggested that role play and reviewing case material for insensitive approaches
may help students to develop a more thorough understanding of LGB issues (Greene, 1994,
p. 20). Godfrey et al (2006) highlight three areas for adequate training in LGB issues:
1) opportunities for students to acknowledge and discuss any homophobic or
heterosexist biases they might have;
2) opportunities for students to become familiar with the strengths and specific
challenges faced by LGB individuals and their families; and
3) exploration of the similarities and differences between LGB culture and the
dominant culture.
Engaging in self-evaluation should also be an important aspect of any training in LGB
issues. Failure to do this may result in an LGB client receiving ineffective or potentially
harmful therapy (Davies, 1996). Reflecting on ones own feelings about construction of
sexual identity and gender as well as examining internal homophobia, heterocentrism and
heterosexism3 is perhaps one of the most important tasks trainees and therapists can
undertake. It may often involve clarifying, evaluating and potentially changingbiases,
prejudices and values (Godfrey et al. 2006, p. 500). Creating space within training
programs should allow students to undergo this process (Milton & Coyle, 1999). In Bersteins
(2000) Cultural Literacy Model it is suggested that heterosexual therapists should employ
an attitude inventory in order to access their conscious and subconscious anti-gay prejudice
and one of the three steps in Purnell and Paulankas (1998) Cultural Competence Model is
engaging in rigorous self-reflection (Chase, 2004, p. 37). Chase has also developed a
3 Homophobia has usually referred to describe individual bias towards heterosexuals and anti-gay attitudes
or behaviours whereas heterosexism has been employed to describe cultural bias towards heterosexuals andrefer to societal level ideologies and patterns of institutionalised oppression of non heterosexual people (Herek,
1999, p. 2).Heterocentrism is also the assumption that everyone is heterosexual and the attitudes that derive therefrom.Heterocentrism is often subconscious and shows up in less intentional ways (Bowers et al. 2006).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
30/185
Theoretical Orientations
17
cultural self-assessment model for music therapists, which may be useful for personal
evaluation.
In university psychology courses in the United Kingdom LGB issues if mentioned at all are
often only addressed by LGB educators and these issues are said to be barely covered in
important areas such as social, developmental and health psychology. And although people
may ascribe to broadly pro gay principles LGB concerns are often ignored, excluded and
marginalised (Clarke & Peel, 2006, p. 2). There is a need for inclusive curricula, teaching
materials and practices and for the hidden curriculum of heteronegativism to be updated
since is a vital and necessary component of the discipline rather than at best marginal,
speciality concernsa mere add on (Clarke & Peel, 2006, p. 2). Training programs need
to address LGB issues, ensuring that their trainees possess empathy, open-mindedness andability and willingness to reflect on ones strengths and weaknesses as well as the essential
qualities for therapists working with LGB clients (Table 1.3.), such as:
Comfort with LGB individuals;Awareness of ones own comfort level, values, biases and prejudices about sex,
gender, and sexual orientation and how these can affect interactions with clients;Interest in the life of the client and willingness to educate ones self about issues and
social conditions for LGB individuals;Willing to hold ones self accountable for values, biases and prejudices;Awareness of ones own construction of gender and sexual identity, and the origins of
related beliefs (e.g., family, peer norms, religion);Understanding that sexual orientation is about affection attachments;LGB affirmative (acceptance and non judgemental attitudes are not sufficient); andAbility to nurture queerness versus manage or cope with it
Godfrey et al. 2006, p. 498
Table 1.3: Essential qualities of therapist working with LGB clients
The literature on LGB issues in psychotherapy and psychology training suggests that LGB
issues in these training environments are often severely neglected. It remains to be seen
whether the same occurs in music therapy training programs and continuing professional
education. Chapter two of this thesis will fulfil the second aim of this study and identify the
central LGB topics and lifespan issues, which are central to providing effective therapy with
LGB clients, relevant for music therapists, and should be included in the provision of LGB
issues in music therapy educational settings.
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
31/185
Literature Review
18
Chapter II
Literature Review
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
32/185
Literature Review
19
2.1. LGB Sexualities and Therapy
2.1.1. Historical Perspectives
The history of the psychological treatment of LGB individuals by the mental health experts is
marked by a repeated pattern of good intentions and negative consequences, and is often
linked to the Freudian psychoanalytic tradition (Eubanks-Carter et al. 2005,p. 3). It is said
that Freud had a complex view of homosexuality. On one hand he described homosexuality
as an arrest in psychosocial development and on the other observing that same sex
attraction is found in people whose efficiency is unimpaired and who are indeed
distinguished by especially high intellectual development and ethical culture (Eubanks-
Carter et al. 2005, p. 4). Freud also believed that people were born with both heterosexual
and same-sex feelings. Nevertheless later psychoanalysts did not follow Freuds view thatpeople were born with psychological bisexuality, and proposed that LGB individuals could
be converted through long-term psychoanalysis. It has been observed that post-Freudian
American psychoanalysts in the 1940s and 1950s such as Bieber, Bergler and Socarides
mobilised an almost McCarthyite zeal in labelling homosexuals as sick, inadequate
personalities and grievance collectors (Milton, Coyle & Legg, 2005, p. 182). LGB
individuals up to the mid 1990s were also barred from training as psychoanalysts in the
United States and Britain due to their unresolved and unanalysable neuroses and the fact
that they were seen as too political and therefore inappropriate for training. (Neal &
Davies 1996, p. 22)
Psychology and more specifically psychoanalytical theory have often contributed towards
the turbulent relationship between mental health and LGB sexualities (Neal & Davies, 1996,
p. 22). Psychoanalytical theories on LGB sexualities have been criticised for not being
empirically tested on the grounds that the personal beliefs and attitudes of the analyst
biased observations and furthermore subjects who were already in psychiatric care were
used (Herek, 2007). Although there is still much discussion of LGB sexualities in
psychoanalysis and many issues are unresolved, psychoanalysis has at least engaged with
its ambivalence towards same-sex sexualities (Milton, Coyle & Legg, 2005, p. 184).
Behavioural therapists throughout the twentieth century also tried to cure same-sex desire,
developing a range of techniques to convert LGB from sexual activity with the opposite sex.
These included: the use covert conditioning, where clients were asked to imagine same sex
activities, while being exposed to anxiety-inducing images, chemical aversion therapy and
electroshock treatments (Eubanks-Carter et al. 2005). The idea of cure and treatmentthroughout much of the twentieth century was derived from quasi-medical models, which
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
33/185
Literature Review
20
seemed more appealing than the models of good and evil which, they largely replaced
and measures such as: neurosurgery, hormone injections, heterosexual assertiveness training,
religious exorcism and prayer were sometimes used in an attempt to cure homosexuality
even into the 1970s and 1980s (Neal & Davies, 1996, p. 17).
From the 1950s some researchers endeavoured to not only show that LGB sexuality was a
degree on the sexual orientation continuum, but also that there was no difference in
psychological functioning between LGB persons and heterosexuals. Kinsey, Pomeroy &
Martins landmark study (1948) posited a sexual orientation continuum, revealing that many
more American adults than previously thought had engaged in same sex behaviour or
experienced homoerotic fantasies (Herek, 2007). Evelyn Hooker was one of the most
influential researchers of homosexuality of the twentieth century and her 1957 study wasground breaking in several ways. Hooker recruited a group of gay men who were not
under psychiatric care and used a control group of heterosexual men who were matched
for IQ and education. Hooker in her famous case-controlled study known as the fairy
project found no difference in adjustment or psychopathology between gay men who were
not under psychiatric care and heterosexual men (Kimmel & Garnets, 2003). Hookers
studies were replicated later with lesbian and heterosexual women and had a direct hand
in the de-classification of homosexuality as pathology. This directly affected psychological
practice, paving the way for new affirmative models in psychotherapy (Rothblum, 2003).
Psychologists and psychiatrists could not ignore the weight of empirical data with which they
were being confronted as more and more studies were undertaken over the next two
decades confirming that homosexuality was not pathology and LGB individuals had similar
mental health to heterosexuals (Neal & Davies, 1996). Furthermore the growth in humanistic
models of therapy fostered a shift in ways of thinking about human sexuality (Mair, 2003).
As a result in 1973 homosexuality was removed from the list of mental illnesses in the
American Psychiatric Associations (APA) Diagnostic Statistical Manual (DSM) III.4
Nevertheless in a survey conducted of 2500 psychologists soon after declassification it was
evidenced that a majority still though homosexual to be pathological and also perceived
4Although homosexuality was declassified a new classification was introduced in 1980 called ego-dystonic
homosexuality where a person has failed to accept their homosexuality and consequently experiences persistentdistress and wishes to be heterosexual (Milton, Coyle & Legg, 2005: 183). This has been seen as a loophole forconversion therapies, which continued to cause oppression on LGB individuals and it was removed entirely in1987 (Davies & Neal, 1996).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
34/185
Literature Review
21
homosexuals to be less happy and less capable of mature, loving relationships than
heterosexuals (Rothblum, 2003: 675). Old habits die hard!
In an attempt to influence this majority The American Psychological Association in 1975
adopted a resolution, Homosexuality per se implies no impairment in judgement, stability,
reliability, or general social or vocational capabilities (Garnets et al. 1991, p. 964). This
resolution not only supported the removal of homosexuality as pathology, but also
advocated equal civil and legal rights for all LGB persons, urging psychologists to remove
the stigma that had become linked to LGB sexualities and to foster affirmative approaches
with LGB clients (Eubanks-Carter et al. 2005). The shift in thinking about homosexuality
moved at a more rapid pace in the United States than elsewhere, perhaps due to the
founding ofthe Journal of Homosexuality in 1974 and other journals that followed, and the
establishment of such organisations as The Society for the Psychological Study of Lesbian,Gay & Bisexual Issues, who promoted of LGB affirmative research & practice (Kilgore et al.
2005).
In Europe and in other parts of the World, the shift in thinking was much slower.
Homosexuality was still classified as a pathology by the World Health Organisation until
1992 (Neal & Davies, 1996) and was only decriminalised in Ireland, a member of the
European Union in 1993. During the last two and a half decades there has been a
significant growth in gay affirmative therapy and LGB psychology as well as changingattitudes in relation to LGB individuals and their health care needs. Nevertheless, recent
theorists such as Limentani (1994), Rayer (1986), Socarides (1978) and others still view
homosexuality from a pathological perspective (Milton & Coyle, 1999). Socarides is quoted
to have said as recently as 1997 that Homosexuality is a psychological and psychiatric
disorder, there is no question about itIt is a purple menace that is threatening the proper
design of gender distinction in society (Tozer & McClanahan, 1999, p. 725).
2.1.2. Homophobia & Heterosexism
Homophobia and Heterosexism are central issues for LGB individuals, which can not only
greatly affect their daily lives, but can have immense impacts on the level of treatment and
care they receive in the healthcare domain. Homophobia as a term was coined by clinical
psychologist Weinburg in 1972 to describe the phenomenon in heterosexuals of the dread
of being in close quarters to gay persons. Its equivalent in gay persons manifesting as
self-loathing (Shidlo 1994, p. 177). This was later expanded by Hudson and Ricketts
(1980) to include feelings of anxiety, disgust, aversion, anger, discomfort and fear, whichheterosexuals may feel in the presence of gay people (Davies, 1996, p. 41). The term
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
35/185
Literature Review
22
homophobia has not been widely accepted in the literature, as it is not considered to be a
phobia in the classic sense. It is also seen to reflect a prejudice reinforced by society as
opposed to an individual phobia (Herek, 1990). Unlike a clinical phobia, homophobia often
includes hatred and anger, it is sometimes judged to be understandable or justifiable, it
often manifests as aggression or hostility, it can be politically based and is not seen as a
disability with a motivation to change (Bowers et al. 2006, p. 31). Other suggestions for
the term have been homoerotophobia, homosexism, homonegativism, and anti-gay
prejudice to name a few (Davies, 1996). Davies (1996) points out that it has been
demonstrated that some individuals may have a fear response to homosexuality and says
that for this reason the use of the term homophobia seems reasonable. On the other hand
Herek (1999, p. 1) proposes the term sexual prejudice linking it with the research tradition
on prejudice in social psychology. It may be a more suitable because it conveys noassumptions about the motivations underlying the negative attitudes and avoids value
judgements about such attitudes.
Heterosexism has been used over the last two decades sometimes interchangeably with
homophobia and was chosen for its parallel structure to racism and sexism. Heterosexism
or heterosexist bias was defined by Morin (1977) as the belief system that values
heterosexuality as superior to and/or more natural or normal than gay and lesbian
orientations (Greene, 1994, p. 8). Homophobia has usually referred to describe individual
bias towards heterosexuals and anti-gay attitudes or behaviours whereas heterosexism
has been employed to describe cultural bias towards heterosexuals and refer to societal
level ideologies and patterns of institutionalised oppression of non heterosexual people
(Herek, 1999, p. 2).
Heterocentrism or heteronormativity should not be confused with heterosexism and are
terms used to express the perceived reinforcement of beliefs whether by social institutions
or policies, which assert that heterosexuality is the only normal or natural orientation,
against which other sexualities are to be judged. Heterocentrism is also the assumption that
everyone is heterosexual and the attitudes that derive therefrom. Heterocentrism is often
subconscious and shows up in less intentional ways (Bowers et al. 2006).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
36/185
Literature Review
23
2.1.3. Societal & Institutionalised Homophobia/ Heterosexism
Bowers et al. (2006) highlight that for LGBT5 people, the impact of discrimination on
cultural, institutional, inter-personal and internalised levels leads to a reporting invisibility in
relation to harassment, a poorer general health status, diminished utilisation of health carefacilities and a decreased quality of health services (p. 12). Societal homophobia and
heterosexism can be influenced by and reflected back by the media, and have an effect on
LGB individuals in many areas of their daily lives. In educational, employment and health
care sectors, institutionalised homophobia and heterosexism may have negative impacts
resulting in direct mental health problems for LGB individuals. Rather than being inherent in
humans, homophobia is considered to be a cultural phenomenon, something thatis a learnt
behaviour. If homophobia is indeed cultural and it a learnt belief, it is widespread. Eighty-
five member states of the United Nations consider LGB sexuality a criminal offence, and this
type of state sponsored homophobiapromotes a culture of hatred reinforcing sexual
prejudice and continuing the cycle of oppression and discrimination of sexual minorities
(Ohosson, 2007, p 4).
2.1.3.1. Education
In education sectors there has often been a fear of discussing, or portraying positive images
of, LGB sexualities. In the United Kingdom for many years the promotion of LGB sexualitieswas forbidden under Section 28 of the Local Government Act 1990 and as a result many
schools omitted discussion of LGB identities, increasing the conspiracy of silence (Tinney,
1983, in Davies 1996, p. 45). Davies (1996) highlights that the omission of representations
of positive LGB lives in school curricula further stigmatised and devalued the sexualities of
those students who might be LGB and denied them opportunities to learn about themselves.
Davies (1996) also observes how history has been edited to excludepositive references to
homosexuality and the contributions made by LGB people in many disciplines (p. 45). The
situation today has not improved and one recent study revealed that 70% of secondary
pupils have never been taught about LGB people or seen LGB issues addressed in class
(Hunt & Jensen, 2007). Homophobic language is commonplace and current comments like
thats so gay (meaning bad) and general verbal abuse is often overlooked. Homophobic
5 LGBT lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgendered. Transgender is an umbrella term used to describe peoplewhose gender identity (sense of themselves as male or female) or gender expression differs from that usuallyassociated with their birth sex. Many transgender people live part-time or full-time as members of the othergender. Broadly speaking, anyone whose identity, appearance, or behaviour falls outside of conventional
gender norms can be described as transgender. However, not everyone whose appearance or behaviour isgender-atypical will identify as a transgender person (American Psychological Association, 2007a).
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
37/185
Literature Review
24
bullying is also said to have reached endemic levels in British schools with two-thirds
(156,000) of LGB pupils experiencing being victimised. From this group 92% had
experienced verbal homophobic bullying, 58% had been ignored or isolated, 41% had
been physically bullied and 17% had received death threats. It was also revealed that
teachers often turn a blind eye to homophobic language and bullying (Hunt & Jensen,
2007). It is paramount that students are educated about LGB issues and this kind of bullying
is not tolerated. Many of these students will be tomorrows health care workers.
2.1.3.2. Media
LGB individuals are not often portrayed in the media, and when they are they are often
stereotyped or negatively portrayed as mal-adjusted or dangerous. Hollywood is noted for
its homophobia, the absence of positive portrayals of LGB people and resorting to LGBstereotypes, unlike the fringe cinema and stage where diverse sexualities have been
celebrated (Davies, 1996). Television can be a powerful influence in challenging prejudice,
but also in perpetrating it. In over 168 hours of broadcasting by the BBC in 2006,
portrayal of lesbians and gay men occupied a mere 6 minutes. Furthermore, 80% of LGB
references were negative, 72% of references were in the entertainment sector relied on
clichd stereotypes while half of all gay references were for comic effect (Cowan, K. &
Valentine, G, 2006). There were no scenes of homophobia being challenged and in 30
instances gay male sexuality was used as an insult in 22 programs. There were also no
references to LGB individuals with disabilities or from ethnic backgrounds, and no
references to bisexuality (Cowan & Valentine, 2006). These negative or stereotypical
portrayals of LGB identities oppress sexual minorities and further add to the collective
homonegativism which exists in the dominant culture, providing intolerant heterosexuals with
limited information of LGB lives that may well sustain or solidify their negative attitudes
(Greene, 1994).
2.1.3.3. Health Care
In health care professions there has been and still exists institutionalised homophobia and
heterocentrism. Bowers et al. (2006, p. 17) argue that despite being charged with a
fundamental caring role and being a safe-haven for those in need, the health care system
has been repeatedly documented in various studies to have endemic levels of
discrimination and disadvantage against LGBT peoples health care.
Although the relationship between LGB sexualities and the mental healthcare systems hasgreatly improved, there still exists widespread homophobia and heterosexism within these
7/30/2019 The Love That Dare Not Sing It's Name: Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Issues in Music Therapy Training and Education
38/185
Literature Review
25
systems (Davies, 1996, McFarlane, 1998). LGB individuals are more likely to use mental
health services than their heterosexual counterparts, with problems often stemming from
negative reactions to their sexuality and discrimination. Nevertheless research has
suggested that such service users are likely to encounter the same homophobia in the mental
health services as they do in wider society (National Disability Association, 2005).
LGB individuals may face many barriers in accessing services or in the process of coming
out6 to health professionals. They often have fears of availing of services, especially those
who were treated for homosexuality in the past.
Fears may include
Safety concerns
Being judged negatively, stigmatised or pathologisedConfidentiality concerns
Invisibility or lack of acknowledgement of diversity
Multi-oppression7 (McFarlane, 1998: 43).
The decision to disclose ones sexual orientation to mental health workers may still result in
negative outcomes for the LGB individual according to recent studies in Europe, Australia
and the US (Golding, 1997, McFarlane, 1998; King & McKeown, 2003). In one study 73%
of LGB service users in mainstream health services had experienced some form of prejudice
or discrimination in relation to their sexual orientation (Golding, 1997). Furthermore, in the
cases of 51% of participants, their psychological distress had been inappropriately
affiliated with their sexual orientation by mental health professionals. This was supported
by the fact that for LGB service users negative experiences were found to be more common
than positive ones. These include
Recommended