View
266
Download
3
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
1/35
G.
>-
.+1
'o
-:
q,
g';
a+
-d
c
gL
-+,
3
J
SJ
o-
-t-
J
T-
s
c+l
o
$I
S\J
5'-6
\j
trl
in
Jauarrcse
Culhrye-
The
ltlco,
of
Pozuttr'
{'.i>ffiH
Benedict
ll.
O'G.
Ancler.sol
l\18(JDr
,
'1
tO\
,r
Lr
spitc
of
rLc consicieral,lc
bocly
of
sotrolar.ty
rvortr
ittar hns
becD
,1n,,
"i,
1,,J,.,,, \,,,.
.,n,t
,
.t4
,
)
J1 ,,,
-
I
i\t,.r\
:r,,t
,,,t,,,,,..
l,"r
'q,
r'J
l5
I'. rc
1",
n
n.r,J. it
x
.\
t^1,rtr.
..,.,h i,
,.ill,,.r
ur
rr1,j.,,,n"1
t",r',:rl
,....,t,,r^,^or
.'rt,,t,
p.,*.,r,,t ,o.,t
.,rirei
,
T...1,,.o,,,.1,t,ol"l,)
I,"tn,,..i,.
i,
Thc
ffrst
dencicncv
c.ln
h
pxrt
Le aitdbuted
to
the
fact
that
Iad,
r,:i.r\
(lF\i.,1
';t^j..r.,,...
,r..".^
rJ,^\.
ot CJ,irx
dr,l
lndir,
cl,ni.rirl
no
tull-flcdgcd
expositirn,s
uf aDy
indigolous
.?otitical
theorv."
A
conteDporaq,
rccoDstnrclioD
of
sL,ch
a ih.o,y
lrai there-
Iore
to
l)c abst,acte.l
{rom scatord
histdrical
soulccs
ancl
thcn
s)nrl.,
ri/e,r
\vith
tr..8,,.
n,,,"
i,,.r-t,Is,trrunhornE,.t,t,.xf,ri,n.F
'I
J
..
{
u.lJ,lcf.j"r.,
),,
.',.
",,'t"
r,n,n,,,..
ff
r.r.
rJ,,.,,tA,,,.c
oJ
.1
s)stemtjo
cxpositiorl
of
.l
pbl;rical
tireory
in
tlrc
classical
litera_
r,
.
oI
l.,l.,a^,Jt..,.
In'r,r..ttt,,
1$'.r,,1
ruI
rr,.rna.,,ct,
tt.,or..
J"{..
rr i.,t,lr,.,r
.\i.,,.,..1
'1,,r.
l,.s
t,r,,.r,
r,.,t
.,,,
1,..".,,.s.
"t
,r,c
.,r'...,,1'.,.
",
1,,.1
r.,
.
.,,,
',liri,,r.,l
t.,lrri,
l,^r,^lvir.\.T1,:{
t.r.r
"r"..,
.t..,,,,.,,.1
i,
.. ..,.,
.,,
.,,,.r
,\
,t
.,,,,..,
,,1
lI.
:
.ljr.,,....
,.1
....
l,
,
u,
'
,
,
...
.
.r.,,,
,,
,.)
tnjit
-.,1
lr-
r, ..Iml
r.L)l or
itLir.s.r
orv.s
nmch
to
Lt,c nNiqhrs
and
onicd.om
jf.;
,,.
',
. ., 1"
.,
-f
u,,,J..
|
......,r,.
r,,r ,r
r..ih,
,
.
'.r.
.t..,
rt4l,
4.n
,- (.r
t,,,..t
r_ \
li
ji,t
I
i,
r.,
"
'{,.
1
.t,\.
r..,..."i.\t.
,urtr..
Lr.,,tolh. i
..,,i
..
,l
.,,
t,,,,.,.
.rrri.:
,r.q,ii,..i*,lt
o,,",
\
'..
..tI
.',tt
, *r,,.
.,
.\t,,
,s
,
t,
.,,.1{.-.:
ri ,
.n,
,tl
rt,i.
1.,
t."
i,rl'.1 rl.'.r.1'r
to,,t,.,",,,.n,"tth,,
F.l.
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
2/35
2
lJrirtucr
lt.
OG. i\\DrnsoN
Li\iu"
rl'.1,".'^,'-)
l,1s
l-,,,
r,
qr,,r
"".rr-
l'
,r,'s
l|r"
tradftiolxl crlture1
and coirelate
th.r
jD
aD arbilra,y
and
ad Loc
nxt1n..r with
frL
icrl.u
.isfccts
oI
prcscnt
(LtI
Politjcs-
(lulturtl
factoN rrc
qljcalll
brnrght
nt
as
1r
sott
ol
(leus
ex
nnchirut \\bcn
thc courbiniLtnn,
ol
social,
,l({,ntrnic,
rnd
histo
crl
Yrri.1Llcs
sccDrs
not cortPlotoly
to
ac:ronnt fol
tr.1rticul.lr
{orms of
politicrl
l)ctu1vior'
These
clltuLal
elomeris
arc
tlUs introchcnl
cssentinllv
to
"s.rve
thc
pheLro
cLrx."
'rhc
nnplicit $srnrptnnl
of
a
l.rck
ot
rnherence
ir
thc
(ultur.rl
tra.ljLjon hrs,
jt
rxxrms
io
ntc, irrclitrbh
lcd
to
a
la.rk
ol rnctlotl,logical
cohcltrx,c
nr dvcloping
rn
.
.iFxll
^PPro.lclt
to
co
temporary IndoDcsix,r
l)olitics.
Tbc
prcscni
css.ry
is
ar cffort Lo
r.mrdy
at
lcrlJ
th(]
first
o{ tLc
tlro basic
(1(.E.jcrt.ii's
tbat
I
l,avo ponnccl
o,,t. Il'
oflcrjlrg
r s)s
?
tixnxti. e\potition
01 tra.liliood
J.r\xneso
coDccPtions
x
xLoIrt
Poli'
tics
ind demorstntnrq
rcir iNrcr
colurcrtco.
I hofc
io takc
a
prcli
nriry
stil tou,arcl r
irll.r
nivcstigatur
ol
iho
nrLf
rclrti()ll
dripi l,dq,c.n crlturc
rurl social
xction 1,r(lo1,csir.3
Srch a
1,tc-
sortatioi
slloul.l rxakc
it
cvi(l(xrt
thrl
tradilbn,rl
Javartcsc
orltur
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
3/35
.
coNalEtls
oir I,()\fEn
Shr.l\
oI
.lissi.il
Jr' n$.
lirlrrl'r.
rrtrl
pcs.nr di).
l,oliti.il
l lrxrir)r
sr .s,.ris
ilrt
oD. ln r to rrrj(l,rsrrn(ling
th(:
,rv,,)(.s.
tlr(rrr.
ol
l)olili(is
rrr\ lr, tL.
tfu(i
ln),,i1
i,,l.,fr,,,rtnnr
r)l \\rL,rt
s{)rilt
sci.,L.N
r.l(,s
to as
Lr^rcr.r
ii, lIc
In\x
.,su
roruPtk)f
(lillcrs
rldi.r
h
hOD rl,e
co c(ln
r)l po\\1)r
n
',i.L
ll.s . ol11,:1
jtr
rho
\\icsr
snrcc
l]
IfnLlL,
1\g.s,
inrl
lrcIr
tlrs
ditl,r.ncc
lircLc
logicallv
Iollorv
contrastiig
vjqvs
ot
tlrc
worlinrgs
ot pditi.s l1nd Listor'_v.s
'I
:,
.. ..
.
.."r
.u...tr.r,
..
rntr,. j.
,' 1l
. .,,-
l','l
..
.4
.lnl,
n,
,,,
tI,'
c$_x) is
\r,
lcn
nr l'i
glish,
b), a nativ.
I'Jrgli ],
st,,rko.,
trnnr'j]f
tor nitn(
lt,gljsl
rfrk.rs. a,d
xllr b.crrrc
it
o\vn
n,r.Tl..hrxl
fdsllr.Ljr.,
js
n:
,cx,.diil)lr
$:1.sle',,,
I
r.c
o cl,oi.c
Lnt
k,
nsc
qrxls
an.l .,or.qns
likc
'irotr1r,
Nli.l, rrr
(lrn*.
rnnn a
1t,,sr.D .,,rlyrictrt rnd nrL.Trrarjr. liluc-
\'o*, i,r n.;ri,,g
NiLh rt,.
tnlJhrr
ol
(,ir,r,iing
rt,.t
f,"n,","u,t
,,irt,
tt,,
.lxvr,
{\.. 11i.m
is,l.r,lv
i
I'nxl,Ln,rntnl
hrr n,ltrr.nt
nr
s,.h
r rr(lr.,l
.I
w.,1,. lniL \vilh.
1
^
srlcrur(lntk
h.gtrrg.
(l
.on.rl,hrrl
Ilx
nay.'L
nr
illirh to
f1..,-
lrnl'
\:f.st.rn aid
Tru r
rllrrs
rn.l .on.nrr , rli rhr
onc
cm
do is
lo,.rognizc
atr.l
nrr'rn'
(rslrDtlr
ana,..I
lhi
l,ixs.
WIcn
t.,
:
'.l''",
r,r.
.,{"rt',
.
'I, i
i..i'_
''
i..,.
ti,
,
\\ ,
.
,..''. t.,,l',,.
I,
i, .
.l.i
1.
,,1
.
..t,.rn.
lcNclv,
sl]l.,rl.nrr
lun rjLli,, tL.
lxv,
,.s.
nrnr$o,I, dnf
.rrrl.l
s:(,
tlxt
'1.
\\.,
1
|
.,,
l.
r
,1.
jxun.sc,,n,ilc
i hd ixrl,n
llrrglisl
d..r
'i)r
,,.trllv
l . $rl, r
(.rrjlr
ar
all.
(Tn..l.l
,,sxq,..l 11,.
Forrl
f.v..,
\tLnt' rn'riv{,s i, sdr
tih,N*
ns
"1h.
a;irt
t,,trr{r.i'o 1h, lturr 11,n
olr.t I'n1,"
rl\,roriD,Lt..r rh.
lrvr..s.
nk.r,
I)rrr
]rr..o
nn,r,I
r,)ninlLr
lvirh
n.t Il,r,r
nr
slri
nrrr|.,rLral
t
jn.iLrl.
llr.
Lvl 1.:
li{rL*io,,
ol
(li
.,nrtr..i..t,rs.l
f.r,,
n, tl,
rn$nrq
,,',,,''llil
.o,rcnrts.l Lrn,lli,,.
rs n.r I'.r,r th.
l,
ynn.s.
rn\r?onir
'tlis
tlrrll,,l
l.
...
r.
.i'.
..,
,1,.1.
loD onr, t}.r
diri,lr.
n nf
nrto.o)i.{Its liku
,u{,,,
l. ili,,ir.y.
rrd
,htr.irnr.",\
n,ll
d.rr.l)trxrt.l tLis ih(,ol
irl\s, ir
in(lirt(r':rlr.
iD
tr
ci ., l,LLt I.r tlr r.rrrr
gmr
nl). c
J l,rv. nor
.tr,rn|trd
t,rr.
n)or.
rhrn
I)oint.r
xr
ro
l, trv it
sLonl{l lr q),okl,.d
l,'..])ablr o"lr
I
lrynncsc
3t,
....
.i.
,.
..
"
L,
...,.(,
.
it...ui
t{i,.
,,.
,,i
I
.'
, l.^.
tr. ,t
|
...
.
t.'
, ,l
rultur.
1rtrl rn .\lr rely {,o,rfll,x
tJ|.no,rer.,
r, n,
\vl,icl,,
s
,r'
rr;
othr
t.t.....-,,,,t,
..' .l ..
r.. l.
',-
r'
-
i
,v
tr-.
'l
contoundiri
qilh
h...r.otr,r.orr
ll,1li,ni,in,
lnrUl,ist,
rnd
h1."i.
cl.lndrrs.
Nonedelc$,
t[e slow
,trc(rs
o4.al]vDplnn and svdl,esisroler
rh.
.cnL"'i.r
PIid
to tl'. iorrnrg.l
lh.r
\\irst'p .ritni th.
qvrrlr
liTatnD
oI a r.l.ti ,lv
t'ti
t'rt,t ,f
ro,,:r
in
laDdnc\c Cutturc
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
4/35
6
II.-rtDtc1
R. O'G'
Ar\'Lnso\
{ormrtla
{o|
cb,txjh
obscNeal
ptlttorrrs
of
w)'i'l
i*craction
'l-hns
,r,, ,-".,,11t
trtr
rlc
'?ristc'icc"
ot
potr1)r
irl
x lvicle
vxicl)
of
sifrrtions
i,; whc|
lo
c
tncn
xPPirar
to ob'Y'
1l'illirgl)'or
utn'jll
i,,.r rl r.rl,
.. i,....\\'..t,,rt
.'.,.-1r1,r"i,,1:.
J.,:
i."ti,,t
t,.r
g",r1, 1,,'
I
".' , .',r
1,.
,1",r",'Ir'lirr'
rr'"
caus.rl
h,hrq.
r,,,i,.'.,;,
,L,,
ord'r,
clPlicit
or
implicil'
and
its
lcgiftrl.rt{,? Or, riioro
Lroi'rtcdl),
wll.tt
is tlc rchtiorslrip Lelwecn
thc
positivist cor.ePt
oL
porcr
aDd thc
cthlcd conccpt
o{ righti'}
ljricfly, ihcD,
lh,,
cootorrpoiaLy
wcstcrn .orccpt
rlf porvcr
ls
atr
nLshaction dc.luccd fro
o)sclrcd
p.rttcrN
of socid nrleraciioltj il
is
bdicvr:cl
to clcrivr: from lieterogcncors soruccs; it
js
itr
no
\,1y
n,hcri:ritly selt-liuritnrg;
it d
it
is,nomlly a,nLiguous.
Il1
csscncc, crch of
thr:sr:
prcmiscs
itLout
P(^\'cI
Nrs counter io
tur
e(Irivrlcnt
p(uisc
iD
Lhe
Irvrrlcsc traliiiion,
irDd
jt
is lroDr thc
intcrchiiorls
bci\v.cl th$c cotrhrtsting
Ucnriscs
thai iI(i cohcrcr)cc
rrd
co si lcr].)
oI
lliat lraditior
rle
vc.
r.
Pou:et
is
catLcrctL.'llis is
tle Iirst
:1rtrI
cortr.ll
pl..rliso
of
Jrvr-
,,(sc
troliij.al
tJ,onglrt.
l1rpcr i:xiss,
clr:ptrrcldri of
its
poisiblo
nnrs.
Tt
is
not
r lhcr) r.ti(rl
foshrlLLic
bIt
{n
c\istclrtirl
r.rlit_\..
Il)wcr is
LLat n,itlrgiLlc, LryslcrioLrs, alrd dnnrc
cncrgy
\rhi(h
nniurtos tlc ari[rs.. lt is
Drilifcst.d
xr
eve.y
as])ect
of thc alLrrxl
\\,or1.1,
jI
stoD.,s,
tr(.s, rlor(ls,
rnd
Irc,
but ir
cxprcsscd
qujlt(s-
s{,1tixlh,
nr thc ccDtra, rn)sicr), of
ljfc,
thc
Proccss
o{ gctl.x,rtion ancl
"
'
r.,l
or.
lr,J.\. lr...
r.ar.'rll,Ll.r,:
l,,':..a,,:l,1rt,Ji i
.',,rlL,\.,,,, .r.r,.r,l I'o-:,,',. j,,.,tt.i
lor,.'.r1,1,i'.g
is
s'r
-\
Ir,,I.r
rr,o.,r,,
i,.,ii,
I,o$,..'r'.;,oI., IniJ,
ut tlr,
,1rl:.c
u,sros
bchg
m{hrscd
br
a fornrlcss, cor.strntly creativc cncrgy
fro-
vidcs the Lxsic ]n,k l,.lir.xx, tlic
"ar
]lisni
ol
tho
Jawln.:sc
l,illxgcs,
rLnd tl,c hilh 1]roiapjr],si.al prlrthcism of tlre 11r1)rn {ters.1o
).
PotLcf
is ha,'ott
nail.
it
tulli^rs
I rn tt s
conc()rtn,t
tldt rll
Io\1r
is
ol:th.
s0r.
l)'l).
rrrl
hxs t]rq
sanrc
sourcc.
llowcr
nl 11)c
Irrnds
of onc
iDdi
kl,,rLl oI
orc
grolrp
js
icle,,{icrl
witl
power
i)1thc
l,rn.ls
ol: rnv or h.r
i,rli|idll.1
or gru,f.
:t.
'tht:
rtritlt.r.jt
ot' por)ct ii thc utiictsc is dd,rst.?nl.
I1t tho
Jivari(Jr)
riqr,
tlic
cosr[os
js
rx]ithor()xfrndiDe
nor
.oniracti
g.
'IIrc
td.rl .rrxDrt ol
,)l\ .r
\itlin it
k)0,
rc)naiDs
fir,i.
Snrco
powcr
sinrpl
c:(isrs, anl
is 1,oi
rhc
prcdrrct
ol
orglnizAtnnr,
wcalth,
.
i,
.,
.
J..
-
i.,,i,
,
,J
I',,
. r
'.
.,ii .,r
rt., \,
.
1,1
,,,.
k.
.
'1,'
rhr'llr,
,r'
.
i'.
l^','.r',
r'l',' Ll
.
r.i
,j.:,...,
'1
I
11,,.
,
ilc dist
l)rtnnr o
lo\rcr
irt
tlrc
rlnivclsc
n15v
\'aq. l,br
politicnl
''
l.
r
,
- \v
in,, r 7.,, r, ,,'-'t
t,
tt,,
,,.,1
t
t
.
.rfr.sses tbc .on., 1.,n.$
of
ll,c
Javaies.
id.i
ol
.nc..
lh. divinc
poy'er
is tlr..ss.r.c
of
I, .l
rlr.
nilf,
'l'hc
ldc,1
(1[
r, t,t i
laDanesc
C,ulture
7
z.'1hc
v,ruts
t)l
l
x) 4ft
ht't'to 'tt'\rts
Sin'c
Pr^vcr
is
11s
cLibd
io
or
t.Lrcrl
lronl
cetxiu
]rxit'ros
ol h
avil]l
xnd
lr'Itrin
so(i.r1
r.l.llonslrlIs,
x
'trcil
(1(Il
of
1\isl'Dr
1)olil;'il
l1r(nrglLl
Lrs
L,u,
dc\'(,t(.1
n, ih(,
c(,r*ilili.
iotr
ml .1nrllsil
of
t|csf
l)rtt(rls
an'l
rchtnnNhi|s,
in(l
ih.r.l)'
10
llrt)
ilstjrrgrrislrinil
of
dil1'r(rn
sonr'cs
.f nolror.
f} s
st l;r'c
crrtc
to
r..d l
such
vlukrrs
s.urccs
"
",,,i".
"'
",',1tr,.
s,).i,11
sti 1Lrs.
Iomrl
oliicLr
or arlnizirlon
trr'irLn)rs
i' ,, r..,;n.
,l
.' i
l
r
'"
i"
1''
r 1
lr
"r
"
;,,"',,
"l'J
'
li
'rl
r"r'r'
''r'11
1,
ii,'
.t
",
t..
'
ri'l"
'
.'r'
r'
:
'c
J.
Thc
,c,:ttnllntiah
at'
Pattet
ln^ 1tu
inhcrcnt
Li'rits
Snrc'
Po\\(ir
,,1,,,',t'..,
I,
"
,
,
i,
'il
lr"'"
r"
'i'
''i'i
-'
I
,-
',o'''1t',.
r''
l.
i,,.'"l '""r'
ir'
r'r
"
\'
"''r'l
r"'
",,r.*,'
rf p-',.
rs nrdtrlirg
$crlnxrs,
\rixlth'
orgxrizttn'r'
ald
t.'th,,rnog,
r'r'rt.ogrizc
llrLt rrl
l''1sl
nr tlrtl)n
th(rc
lrrc
no
liltits
t,,
irs,,".,,,,,',1"U,),.'ft,
lnLl
lt rrrotl'r
wrr\,
orr)
()
Ik1 sIq'lcsl
thrri
tlrcfuixl
xrllrLfr
ol pofur
itr
llr.
\orl(1
I lx|
is si8njfi'rr(T\'hrgo'
1l,rn
il
{r11
ilrirL\
,,',i,'
"g"
("' il )
r'sxll
l(n crurrplc
ol ilrc
i
-
v.rin,r
,)l
1l
.
i,.,i',,{",,
1,,,,1,1.
rtrr(l
llut
this
s'r
ol
portr
\rill
,,'
l,tr,l\
,,r
l"''"
L
l'"
], 'r r'.''.'i:r h ' 'l'1' '' l'rt
i,L
dL\Lt ,nrlr
I
"l'rlt
Ll
n"luj''
..1,,,'.
l'
,t,1'-'
't-t'l
'"'
ll r''
n" u''
"
li
l'"
sccthL
corrcct]tion
of
Poljti(|rl
Po\1cr
Ns l
rchinmsliP
b't\v,i:1xl
h,,,na,
bch,gs
rhai
..,"i,
1,"n''
is
lot
inhcrctily
lcgr&nxrc
:l'Lis
rllor.rl
amLignitl
is,
r)f
loLrrsc,
culrrlr((l
Lv
ouL
vio1.
oI porvet
tLs
,Lriri',r
.rln
i,,,'-,',
'
"
r"
rlir l,
rn'
'r'.
l'
r '
,.,.nr,,..r:'J
1,.
t,",,
;',"',,. l'ur'l'\r'ol
r'1'r'''r'r'
'
l'i'
'
'"'n-
tirn,di
io
prCic.il1]lrhdliti.Cl'
thcor
sts:
What"kinds
of pott'er
aLc
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
5/35
8
tlr.-nncf
li O'C;.
ilNDrrnsoN
,1,,o,).
rl'i'
r,"
r',.'o,1.
r,r
'u"'l'.r)
rr'
'ir''1
I'
r'rlrii'
'
lio'\'
r
in
orx, phcc
or;n
orrc
lx,sorL
l{{|rjnrs
'r
PrPrln'ixl
dinlnrrtiknr
.t. I\t..|t
lor:s
rt
1lzis..
Ihc
qltcstitr,
ol
ltgi'"l''lr
Snr
r
']ll
poi,,",l,"i'"s
lrlnr .l singlo
lrr
uoqrnius
sNrcc,
ln^\ai
itsdf
ttc
.
.,,,
,
..,.1
.
,1
:','1,..1
l,ll.'
1,r.,.''
r"
'r
l'i J'rr'I
,l r,"l.l '
"'
"l''
r.l"'rrl'
u'1"
l'\""r
(lif(]rctrljal
soLrr.. s
,,1'1,(,".]l.
f,,t
"r.,pf.',
n) snv
tllal
L)ov'r
based
on
$.dtL
is legiiinttc,
whcrces
powcr
1[scd on
guns
is
ilk]gitnnrt''
?orvu
is uliithor
l('gittr,atc
ror
ill.gitnnrtto'
P')\ d
is'
lLr
sun ,1,.r',
tl,(,,
tlru
Jxrancsc
s.c
P(^'()r
rs sonrdltnrg
(olrcr'to'
l,r,r".scnr",,s,
(nrstxirr
irr
lotrtl
.1trrtrrLitr,
xrrd
\liihont
i'r] rrcrri
nrorrlirnfl,c.rli(,rs
Is
su.L
I
llE
Qulilj
I
l()n
I'o\\rEll
ll,
r.,.r
'",r ''"'I
r'
'll"r'L
l''r
, 1,. \: l, t .
\\' I rr
'r.
l
'r'
n'
"
l
"'
ll'
or-"
r'''
'r
"
cacrclso
rif Pr\vrr
lnrt
ils
rt(.
.II1ition'
'\ccor1ilrglv,
r \c)
'orts
sido:il,lr
t)ortion
ol
Ihc lrn(litnrrrll
litcrllurc
'lcals
$jlli tlr'
proh-
1..,,,. ,,1 .;
'
r"
.
rr,l
'l
l"'
'
rrir'i
l1 "
''r
"''r'
"
lr
rr'
' 'lr
il
r.iu
.r.ir,',ir,'l'.,
li
,"
'."1r1'r
'ri'l'rrr
.*,,t,t,,",,q1,
\ogrlistic
IrrL.li(s
lrrd'\tr'rn'
asrcsis'
r\lilnrglt
Lhcsc
l
og,,ist;"
j,.,,"1;,:"'
nt \'unrrrs
l,xrts
of
Jxvx
tal
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
6/35
ro llriNE
.r.n.
OC.
r\Nrxr$()N
mnks
oI
tlc
dr:n]ors
ud gi lrs
\,,tro
nr the
,
rajang
stori(js
are
tfic
r-..
I.r.,r.'l
{....r,'
I.o,ls
,rl ir..\(ri
fr,.,.,1
,r.."
p..\,r
i:
oflcn
enomrons.
o,
o(ansi.,r .16r)
.r.^.djng
thar
of the
goc1s.
fhc
csseritinl
di1Tr1.ot.c
bciwc(,r
lh. hcrocs
arrcl thcir
advcrsndcs,
how-
ever,
is ltrot
ihri
hiter e\.cnilalh
|crnit
thc,r
poir.r
ro
Le difused
l,/
,,
r'i
,
'
tr.:r
.:..h
$
,r.u
{
r,
\,r..'nr.
sl, r,.s
th tu
,
r
nranrlaiD
thri
stadfrst,r.ss,
th.rr
tL,irrc
singlenr:ss
o{
purpose
u,hich
assnres
thc
mriritora|ce
nnd
co
tinrtcd
rcir"nnlaiion
oI
?ow.r.r6
Bcsnl.s
ilris
ort}odox
,ri.\y
oI th. roa(t
ro
po\vcr.
urolLor.
h.l.ro
,1,.,.
t.io,,,r.,.
l.
t,s,
,'yt
,.\..,,r,t
[,,t
,r].,.,r
son
of iL',
l.tst
lul.r
of Snrglesrri
Ii
ng
l(c
anar]xm.
Lr this
lil,.'r v'
I
,r,..'.
r,.l.r
L,r,
" \r.,
I
ru ql|a
LI
,
li.,'
t,.t.t.t--,
_t.t-t,
././..
,/,.
.4, .r,
.t.,...,.
se lti
or8i.s,
aLLl
ihnl
i,nudcr.rr
Brtt
c\,cn
tlis
t
.ljrior.
$trich
still
fin.ls
rnorc
or less
cla
.l(:sri'rc
a(]hcrclrs
iD
contonpo.xry
hdoncsi.r,
rlti
at.h,
,, ,s
Ir
tl,(, s.r,nc
obj.cri\.
",
tt,,i."r"
orlllo.l{)x
ll'lLditn)r
lh
n] tl).
Ithnjr'.r\,isr
LLrtj.isistirrr.
tlrc
sr,,si.r,-
r1.,.,r,1,
was
l,.lrcvcd {o erhrnsi
rhcs(:
pnssions
x,rrt rh.Lclorc
lo
rn(,rv
a
rnant
l'owcr
to,Lc
coqgonhatc.l
\l,itl)oLrr
jurhcr
trin.li.lrr({,.I,lurs
in
l)oilr lrx(liLnnrs
llrc
ultn)rrlc
airn
\.,s
(oircc,rtrrrr)r
li)r
tlrc
srlkc
(,t
loqrr,
lil(b,)ri lr
th.
pitl,s
d )scu
r{)
rmctr
thjs
t rp(,sc
rx{tk.rly
dircrgcd.
\'V|i1,,
t )s,,lnl
ls( sjs
\ rs
r( rJrlh
r(.qr(t(xt
,rs
tl)(,
1fu,(hlxrit:,t
wr).
i,) rr.r rtri,,,lirro
lrnl rl)so
, t1)$1r,
rr:rdiliof,rl
Jivx,,rs.
iIn)iinrg
als., r.rog,izrll
llut rlis
l)ro..ss
oI NLsorpriori
or
rcdnmrlxltun
cori(l
bc
rl(l(icd
Loth
ly
c.rrai,r
rirlats.
oIt.n
.onrxnrirg
ir
corc
of ascotnrtsnr,
su.h
ns fasting.
n.ritirxrn)n.
xuit
.o
fo,tt,,
a"J
bv tl
c
t'..
',,,.,.r,r
,,.1j-.r .,,\ .
E
fi,,.,I
\vith
Po(1.r. Sitl(r'(l
C. Jlirg
lrls \ri{rcu
rrtlorsrh
at)our
riri: rilrr.rl
ralt
1"9.
1. sncirBrcd
rhil
l kj'
oI
..nt
jrdgrcfr
rlont
l.os..r
is
i,utrli.ir
in
rlis ,lillrcfcc
tr
l,v..n
I,rd.-
,r".t a-"o,i
Nlv
.\vn
nr.lirrlj.r,
lDn1r.r,
js
t. i,li.r.
tlLrt
irn)lrr
as r rnral
lrdqnronL
i.
--f,,,
it ;.
*,i
,,lnnrt
rIf ,r
.I
r,N.i
l)nL
ibonL is
rtc,,rn)n
;r;iirtrml
(rlirj.;t,
I
rl,o
.LDo.s
is T.ivrlo,l
nL
lI.ir
nrrTrjtiry or
rnrviIir(tr,ss
L,).o,, .rv.
iho
t1nv.r
rl)0
hrv. i.,rrf
r,tarrd.
iiOn
this
tul)nr,
s..
1
ti Sl,, otrjn).
IItl
it
tti\nv
in tte
A,thhn,t
3rl
cd
(l)i)kolx
rf,l C,.,,,ng..
\Volr(,\,
rr5 ),
t,p..3,
rJr,
",,.i
,;,
1;;;i
W
1,.
srr
n .hinn,
SLutit,t
"t
ttrt
.sion,t,a.,-to(,/
t.1.1,"
il"g*,
^.rr,ofl.
19s6),
p.ro7-
143,.
'tha
r.tca
ol
t)otL,ct
it1
laD
nere
C tturc
.rolilD.1tn.,r
of
lc,wrr.
rtmrgh
..r",f,"f
,,,"gr",,
il
th
chroniclcs
oI
old
Jara,
t,rrther
.\ptixrrion
oI
ttrc
srbj;
h.rc
;,
,,,,,,..,"",n,y.,"
But
jt
is
clifficuli
to
lrr(lcNrxn.l
t}c
greLrt
nnporr.rnce
atachr:d
to
ccrcDoxics
oI srrrc
in
ttc
conrcmporary
pcrigd
rithour
bcarjng
this
t-,rol
,r.,.
tlJ;tr,..,,
L,
J..
r.,r,r,,1.
tiris
nbsrssiun
$irh..rrmo \
ll
"
:
,"
.
i,,
..,,
:..r,
rprr,
,r
cirt
,
,
a, ,
-ft,.
r",;,r
;;U;,;;,;
as
manipl
Lr
vc
steiutrt-of-hand,
.onceating
1rotjri.at
.ld
";"_;;
cxli&rs
fiom
thc
popr
rtioq
oi
as
a
rvriy
t;flornr]b.
inieg a(nrg
cor-
fljcrnls
8ro.ps
xn.l
j,rer.srs
i.
a nitjo;
$.hiIc
in"'riruri;,"i
;:;;"
for
tlis
pruposc
llLve
hvays
trccn
,ixcoc.&,ig1i
**r..
s,a,
1,Ji-
n"
r.-,..r.,,r1,,,,
t..'\r,,.t
,..,,J...
St,u,-"i
,.,,,.,)
*.rt
j,n,",
,,,'1,.,
,'...
r...,,i.
t,,,..r,,..r,,,
tut
,ri.,t
t,...,t.rs
tr",,.."r.
\,rui.ty
r,,,,.-,t,,1
r.lt,
{
\.,)
. ln,,
i,,\a,
,l
b. Ir,r..h^rJlrle
lo
'J.
).
rl,
,
,
i..
t",,I.,n,..
r,,..
t,,
J
,,.
,.
., ,,,.,..,,.
.,Jy
jrr)u
tr. ,
.r
^r.'.
J.,.,'u,.1
L,i
,.,.i,,,
,,1r^,;,
Is",
I";i,.,i;",,";;
1,r.
.
t,t
.
.
,...,
,r.,,..'.
.,,:
,,,
rl.,
,-,,,,ts
ut
rir,.toIt,r
r,,,,
\'
l\.:
(),
\lr,,1,r
,,,,
r.,. :
,,.
,1,.
.1.rr.....i.
ir.,l
,, g,.,.ir,.
,r,"rnl
,l
.,., 1,,.i, ..,jr'.,.{.
ro
$tri,r,
r,,"}
r.;,rS.rt
ro
r,i rr,ri..
rti.ilr
,,,,
ur,;IIr,-.
I t,u..,
r
I
.
q.r'r'
.
..,r,
nt,.
I t)
,.t ,rr:{
^^..i
,jr,;
,
trrrr,,,
r:
.
,l.I'.,l'' ,.IL
,,,,.t
,.. rrL,
t...i.,.1i,stLr,..,-.^t\,.,i.,... r,,,\\.-.
\"i'1,
r,J,.,.:
,,
,t .,"..,.J
..,,,r.,.rtr,rfr..r,..'...,t
,tr,r...,J
"\.,rt,oti,,.,
.,,,.":..,,,,..'r.,,r...,,,\,ri...it.
ir...,ti:r
,.
,,,),,,".,,r.,,;r^
r,,
Ir
ti,it,
'.'i.,t,..\.,
..r.,r,,,",,r.r
,r
rt.,.tr,,r.r,.r,r,t,,S
ri,.
l
i. ,.ris,.
.,,
,,,,,r
.,,.
,,,.tr.,
tt,,.\.,,ur.,t
\t,,...r
.,,
rt
r1".,.,;ri,r,
u1..
i
r
."1
.,
..1,1/i,,"...,s,.r,.trJ,.
\..B,,Irn.,,,.,,rlrrrr.p..,,l
.r-
t,.1r,..lnr.'
"
I,1.,.
:,,
l..t,ti.
J,,Jrti,:,'
t.t...;:u,
_,...,'.1
..,rft,,,
)
ri
u'r.
r'.
i
r,
s
l.orr.rrnrr
sl,1, l,...,.vo..,r:urr
.
t
rtr^
tn
rutrrLior,
,-\ -l,l'"
or
rrl.
L:,,i,,.:
rrr.,",,i,,,ro,,
\i,ti
t,.,lrliun.
,,r,,1
i.J",,i
,1,
ri\i,
c
ln.l,i.,ir'
t.,,,
\\,{,,
rn
i,.;i,i,.,t
n,,r.tn,.
;
th.
,sor,Jjc
ir
n.,
1,i
.r
,.ret
t.,\-r
^ri,
rr,"t
i.
l,,,J,"t
,4
co,,,
nrr..r.
i,,/l
'1,c1,i,\
l'o,.,
r .
L,,.
,,1
,,.
,
:
tow,
r
ful
\(,rd"
.,',.'.,
.i.l
'
:
"",
;,.'.:;,,
i:1.:Ti::.-";i.:
rast,"
i"
Srnjftlr,Io
.t
dt,
t.ls.,
^a
tntruhl.tia
to
tnd.lt
rit
t
Itiit,i.
,l,iJ,l'
"
1
.1
:"r
,, t,
r
,,\..
.
r,
,..,5,.1,i.s7',,1
""'"""
,.,
,, ,,,,
.,.
rt,.
I,t,r.t
j,r,,rin,,
,.t...
ll''"
"
'
'r'
'
\'.i'
.
..
r'ri,,,..r
L.
e,rz..Ar,x,
tr...,..r
ir.,,
I1\Ln
\
l,.
li'\,
,
,,r
,\
r,
Nl
;, r\
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
7/35
1,
llr']NrlDr.rr
1t.
OG.
,{NDLlsoN
(hntiu\ild.
tl
olusi.
Sq
t
tt0tgti).\\'
t,^v.r
t(Ll
c\pcricrccs
(rti(j
Iiclol',li.Jn)
afd
lLworl,
I .ollcctivirii,s (rt,c
lroplc).j,
h
.Uc.r.
rrtD),
oI Suliunos
ln)litj.rl
r.1li .s,
ostfr$i])ll
dcsigr(tl
ro
.oir ..\ x
Pr
i rlru
rkssrgc
to
iI.,
I,otrl.rtn),r
r)r
k)
ddrlo,)srrri.
rhc
t,..si
dorLts poluh,
lr,rcHrg,
w(r Do
lcss
nrporrrnt
ff
xrcrhods
of
xc.u
rr
rling
Ilrd
d( r)l(nNhrUng
ll)r'o
frorn ilxr
\\,jllingsubntissiDr
oI
so
nrxD,
tllons.r.ds
oi
(isous.
:l'h{)
grerr,,r
thc
crrclt
to
rhich dill{:r_
eni
r,1.1
c\icn
llostilc
politic.rl
jrorus
coul.l
br)
brouglrr
into
rhese
ccrcnDrics,
il(i
grcrLcr thc
rcxl
and
rhc
i)cr.c(,ed
l,o\r,cr
of ttx,
rrastcr
ol
(crcrno|i.s.
Slll(^mos
lrjghl)
tr.lditionlll
srrto
oI irlcanr.t
tory
rllckric nat
ll)
rldderl
ro LLc
pr)tjiical
inpaci of thc
ceri,
nrdr)
ru a
wlrolc. ?
trIotr1)r.r.
jl
,virs
lI r)1{l rrld;rn)l
i,
Jx\it
itrrr
rlrc
rulcr
shoII(l
.onc.ntrrtc
nronn(l
hirrr.u,\
ol)jr.ts
(n
pcrsoDs
hcki
to
harc.,r.(,n-
ll1n1
n,,rLsnxl
ll)w.r.
ltis
1),rtr(.
rrorlil
bc llli,rl
rr,r
o,J\.\ itt,
rt(,
l.'rr
r ,
,',
/.
,
t...-.1.,.
sa. l
Dnrsjcal irrirrrur.lts,
crttiag.s, r'rd
1, I iikc,
tmt
iLlso
\rrn)rrs
t),pes
ol
r\ha0,ili,ir,\'
Io,,nr
lx,nigj, s,
.1,
xs
alt,n,os,
clnrrs.
,l .r\ .
,r.,',."..
i| L ,,.. ',,
I..,,.
\'.r., ,.,t
I
r..
f
.'/,
\
'
1.,.I.. t. ,.t|,,
t,,.,.
,
i,
,.
rt,.i,
rn..
l,\\.1.,,.,r,..
.,.,1ti
r,r,...
l'os1
:,f(l
r)ll.Lr rst]
sijt r lrl tli. ir,tr,,r(li,,1t
d)ll,r|sc
()l
ll,f
(t\1rrst)
1l(
c\lc,ri 1o \1lri,.L
tlrj
,(litn)I
sLL nls
(\1.
jl
,tiic
t)otili(il
'j'
/ .
l.'
'.
t.
I
,.
I
\ ,,,
l.
t' .,
. -
...,
.
.
.
":,,
'
'
I "
o,l,'..
I
,:.1l.r',L...t.../,.
P,i,(.itii.,)
ir t1,...(1..1
ll. Itxlutrf,ir..1,nx{
1:o,,"(.
loi,rrnlir..t
r,r
1r
rr
r\
Tr'
tiri'n.J
.tr]
th
r
Di
.lr\,
,xt
.r
,tr
(t
1.
llrl
r.
i:
.
L
ill
l,)
grin
tJor.r
.
ih|nrrrt[1.
n
j ]
lTrr
\ '(\r
rs
\v.L
\rr
1 n,,1
li
. is ltLrr ilr,.
ll.rr,
ti,.,t,t,
nfuri(l Ll'rL'troL
r. tl)r
ir ol thr
lnionllisr
lord.r
11.
O. S
'thkn,,,ift,r,l
n) tl ,.ro .
polirnxl r|.rrh-D'h.rs
t,or,o\ l
ttj.tr
or.rtorj.rt
sll.te L,,n rn.
vt.t
,
1,,
..t.i,
t;,".,,.
...1
,.,.
-r..1..
r.
...,..t.
..
.t
,. .,,, ,
,,,
t,.
L,t, ....,...,,.,,,t.
5
I
.,
,t
l.
,,,, |
,,.;
.
thr.
llis rllowil
1,n
rh.
sl,itln,l
nrc
ot
n.ndirnnr
i"ii(,"y
{,,t r,.titi-,,,1
--.,,',.,
l,\. L*. .i
r.ti
trhnj.
,.
I
t..
lvillr
thfir rLdi.f..r
t1,..t,t-"
nt
ro,pt
ir
t.,ta?.\,
t,Lttal
rJ
.^":
'".
,
",'
.-.,
t
ru
ul,i,,\,.rs.t
rJ,,
ln.lon.siaay.,,r,.,L..,,r,,,t,r
:
L r9
i,t
r,'
-...
:.....',.r
Lt,.
r,,,r*,..r.,r...t.
r,o\,.\.,
rr,..r
lL.r'J
ll.,
,r,J
I
I.,r,
.
...
,.l.l.,ir
,r
t,.r\.
*
:,i
^,
c,
rJ .tu,..,t
i.
'.'r
r\
I,ut:{'
lr-
... \
,,,,:r1 ,,,,r,,.,.r,,.,,y
r,,ui,,:",r,,,;,,:,
ri,,,,
ll" .",
i,,,,.
\
r,'r: j
i'J'r\r...r..
i, ,,r
rr
.
fr.,;.
,.,,,,,,,,
,....
t...,,
r,,r
.'r'.
,,r,.Iri..r,,
rJ
J
v
,_.
f.ti,n1..\
ru
L,
:.
l,-
Aro' n
rl..t
tl,,,
r,
^
r...\.
nn
F
ut
rhc
r.A li*
ot
l,o\\_r..J
IHI
SI(.\S
Of
to\vER
.
,11 .
,L::-"
.,,r,,':r
u,,
u,
J.Lri,i..,r
rr..sr,r
rr.,,\
r)r,:...r,\
,.,,1r.i.
]
.$1
ri
1r
h
.,,,r
r,.
,t..
.,^."r,. i,",,
,.[
iLs
.rorcjsr:
or
rrsr.
Ihr:so
signs
a]1,
iookccl
fr,.
L,"tf,
;,,
rf,,,1,,,.so,
"i
tf,"
i'oxcr+oLl(l
..nrl
nr
ttro
socjctl
n,
}icti
lc
lviet.ts
Ljs
l,owcr.
1,he
two
alc,
ot
c(nrs,,,
nrriDak,h.
;ctak{I.
Iri
thc
woxts
of oDc
of
IDCto
"
1..,..r,..,.irr
,.,,rrr,..f,r
,r\
.,,
ll..
th
\.,,,r..
I\ -.
rr:..'r,
J
,,,
..
.,I:r:,,,,I
\i.
v
, rl,.
.
t1,,
JL..r
r,hli;,
.]llt,
1,1,,..,,t,, ,r
,.,I
f,,
.,.",
Il,,,J
t,r.
(:rD.L.ir\
,6
.
tlr-
r
,.
r
,l,rr.
..
.-.,.r
,r,.,nj.,,,,t
t,n,v^.,.
1,,r,,
f,,,,
,
..,1.
lrjs
rbjljrv
io
c(,
c.nr.ir.:
to
lo.Is
hjs
o\rn
t)(1s(,rnl
poNcr.
to
rl)sort,
I
$.
r t.,,,,.
I
r. ,,...
,.,,,.
,,,f,,,,
f,,,
..f,
",,,,-,"
,..1.-'
.
r,.,.t
..:,,
rI,.,,.,r1..^.,,,,,.,,.,.,,,'f',,
.,....r
.,..,1,.
;iI
...t
.,.,.r,..,\,
L,r,
,t
,r
,r..
.,,
,rso.li.isnr
is r1,,,
f,
i,),,.
(,\Pr.ssn)I
oI
urc,.rLnt.d
l1^vor.
TI.,
.lbitir
to
rLnrrb
cn(r,r,rt
(orn,r,,irrl:ons
o[
],o\frrt
ts
a
lft.r0rrnt
thr:|rc
]n
botlr
ilxr
1\ajrig
J.surls
or.t
hist(riclll
t
(tifinr.r:r
Ou.
irl)n.il
nx,,ge,
r4ft.1, ]i,l(s
itrjs r\,tn,
,)I
absorprj.,n
*jrt,
,t,.,
"r,,*,;,."i;,1,,
,l;
opl)osjtcs,
js
.
birl]k,
l)cl\1, .r
I trcro
.ud
r
po\\l .trt
idv.$.rr..
i[
1.,,',,,,,,
1,,
.t
rt,r
,rr
r,,.,.rt,...,.,,,r,,.,,..,,,
,,,,1.
.,.1
l.:'
':
r'
.
"','
,',.
\
I
n,,,'
,
\....,t,r,
r,.,
wri
li'
rrl'1, .'
.
r,..r. ,
R.
i
,...1.r ,....,
ri,r1
,1,,
,,,.,,.
,,,
.\,.,;,,,,:
-rx
Some
d rhrDr,.ot
.oursc,
.tu srnti.illtly
lI.Dizr.t
to
mrtc
scridrs
,
1':...1;
'....
t,,t"......,
t,
.
".,.
,.,.i,,,,.o,,
";.
^\ttottn
Cht-
,,.9''
"''"
^
"'
r'
""'
'',',,.,,
..'"
'-',.',,",
:;
l;,i
1"
, ,,.'.
,:
'
'
,i,,''.
".",,,*.",*"u,.
'1
,'",,r,,
**
,....J1
ll
-,,',t,
,
"
''
l'l'
'1":'''
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
8/35
11
InNDn.,r
It.
()
C. r\NDrinso\
rftcr
d,rti]rt
iL
b.rrUc.rr
U
L.,ihcr storjcs, strdr
.rs
tlosc
dcs.ril)nr
lhc
spirit
ol
il.gxwxn
Brgesfnti
( is.onh,g
i,
lo
Trxlistirx
lo
.nxl)lc
lnr
io
Iill
lii)rg Srh:1,
or lhc
lrsioi ol
S,iLrnili
rrxl r\ni1)rlikr tr,.rr-
(rfrp.ss
ll,, ,l,strr(lio,
1)l ll,si llistrri
it ll ollscl
()[
t]r.
l]rilr
j,(l,i
\\'
,,,,r,
Ll
t),r(Lll,
l
t,:,llt
,s i
t
$
l,ilii 1l\ (
is irl)s()rhll lr(,rrr
.rt.rrrl
sourr,
s
r:
ll,,t rl()
L.ss striknrg r,(t
in
lI(: historic.rl
Pcrsp
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
9/35
rat
llr.Nrx,.:I
11.
O'(1. -{.NDrinn)N
'llrc
l(len
ol
l'otd't
i
JnL'attcsc
Oul11ltc
\
17
tlr
',,,
,,r
;.
r
ur,
r,l
l.' r"''''l
Iu\'''
Ilr'
l''i'l'lnti''l
griP,ot
;;:. , ,,.
,,'
'^
.r,",'
"'rrrr:'b"
f/
I' t'i\"r
I':
,l:,1
,
;-
",,,,'
'
,',,
".'\i,,r
r'
'r:rr\
'"rurrr'
..,
'l...,,,,.
,;' ,,t
lrr
",'.,'
u""rr''
-
u'
'lIr
"''''si"r'
r"'
ll"i'i,
'
.,
;,,''
''t,"'
r'';rr''rr
''ri
"'I'""r"nL"r'
'1.:
;,.
l;
ir
.,,.
rr,
"'r
'|ur'tr'r"
"r
'r""
s'r'AI''l{
,ii.,
',',
' '.
rl't
'
'
'r"l
his
r-LI;"
v
''"1
Jism
)
,,.\\,.,1,lx.,..
r,r.
t.......r
\vl,u
iiJ;,d
'r
\irl'irr
tl''
;,.;.
I ' '. .','"'",
'''u"'1'
BLr
-'rr$irhrarlr"lrv.tn'r
l:
li
.,
.
i
"'
.
,,,;
"
"
'-","r)
""r)ri'xr
\nsrr'r'
in
i, .,
'
",,
,
'
"
l'
'
r"1
"
i'''' or
ilr'
ural
'ru:l
tl'"
"i
,i,,
t
:,
'.,'.
Ili''
n''"'
r''r
rli'
urni":urr
$''
r'ut
rlit
,,,
],
,.
,
lI,
'
''
I'r
-"1
'rJ'
'i"n'
L'
t
Irr"'t
rlr:rr
,,'ur,
.,',',
,
I
':.
I
'
''
l"'''r
'"
Irlr''r\'
rl''
sl"'i-
r"or'J-
,''.,.'.
'.:.''",
,'1,
'
'""-"
t'o,''
ir'
lrisrnricrr
J,J
irr
";
i
.
t
.,
,,,.,'',.
,:.
...',,..I.'','.
II'
/./"/
r"Jr
Hirl'1
l'"rl
rl -
;l iil
.;.,,,,','i
""
:
I'rrir"
r'
"
it
r'):1'i,.1)sr\or
''li.
ll
,".,...r..,r..
..
,,.,.,.,
,,,,,',\..'s^,i,'r..r
\\ir"r',
p',r,,i'
.'.li::
li;l',,,;
,';i,,'i,,,",,"
"
';r"'
it'r'
"^*'
or
^nrxnsrnrr'rt
Irr
,..,
"1
"
'
"'
'i'l
'
l''r'
l',''
'"h'
rl
rr'L''J''
,,
'
,
'
,
''
l'
''
ri
I"'l
'l
l''rl
'r'
'r
l" ,
..
I
,
r'' L
''r'r""
"l
'\'|
r'il'''-'n
ll
'
:
'
.
r"
"''r
li'r"""
r"n i'r
tl'
irr'"""rr''r
: i
:,.';1,:
):,,'ll'-:"i,'i:
..1
,,1 ll,.,l
l,i\
l'rllu\\
\
"lirl
I
i
j"
'-rrt
,
';;."",,,,
""'
$'ru
rrr(l
$irlitrrr
crPcssnrD'
no\l'
Lis
corrrt
uncc
L,i,,,,
'
.'
r.''l"l
'r'' I'
tr
rri
'
""'"'
"-"'ii,:'irai
""'
''i'i"rv
""
cicrrxr
"...nirerttti.-
o{
rrro
,,,,,.,..,,i ,,,,r, '. :\,'',.ir
'"'rl'l
if '''
rJior"y
irr
, ,,'.
''
.
" '
"
i'r
l'
'
'l
11
{''
r'
rl'"
tul"
rlq
r
"
'
'
I"
l'
l:'i
"rl
;"":l"l'l"l
;''''
'
'
''t
""1'
"
"']
l
l
i
'-
i'
i'
i' l":
'
,
',
i
','.
,
,
11,''
,'
l)'
'",l1l
:,,
'
'''
','.
"..i
"t
t-
"-
t r"t
t"';
':'
"
,.,.ri'
.
')
r
l'\l
L,l',r.
\''li"" l
l''r')
rr'd
irr
l'''
r '.'o'
1.,,,, l.,ll
,,,.,,l
,,r
'.,
,
rl''r)
'rr'l'1""'r
,.,j
.,,,
,
\
,', II
r'
r'
"i
l''
rl'
1"
""r'
'
'l'
''
"1r-
xtio,r
oL
lri(lili,rrr
tlrro'Lgh
rir) l('ririt)'
lilrllr
trlc1't'1'
llrN gn'"
r'
sLrL,&r
arco,,rri
ol
llr,:
rlei.l |rrrorL
(n
tiidor(sirrI
caritLul
rirtjrnr11l
,"r,r,r,.
r",.,,
Sissa
school
slslrnr
Lctur{r
$roLl(l
\\ilr
llri'Sh(l
has
sh,^r,t
hon
ll c
lrrrrr;1lr
SisivrLs
lorrndcr'
Ki lladjar
D'wanlaLn'
rv:rs
rrLlc
to
conrl)irio
\1'I.it
t(
thr)
Lirno
wcr
ultrxnrod'r n
LLrnrtnist
c(lucrtiornl
th.ori.s
$
illt
lrx(litiorid
cli]Incrts
in
Jav'rn(xc
dhLcation
r.
'ror-lc
,,''
r.r:
.'"''l
"
"'
|
'
l)
'l
'
i\
'
'
\
"
"
'
'
,.,,,1,t ,"' ,,,,,-
,,J u'1,
r,r.'
r'
J
"'r'''rr
ri \\lr'r
s
i-,.r..t.,,
.,
"
',rr-''rr',,r
\ ll.'l
r'
il'
r'
rn
Ir''l"L
'1
\lur,,'r
|
',.
:'
i
'
r'
r"
'''
rl''
r''
"
rr'
'' ':
lr
rl
'
fonrtlatiorrs
rL,.urrr
up l)\
Llr(]
tiLdjL
nxiist fu1"17t'u'r
(in(liirliorr)
sroul),
lrrgui,l,.li
s,itn'i,
rti'uu
',
lrtl L\
a
gouP
oI
Ki
rt'ldirLr's
i.i.riL'.
r
l'i,'',r'p],,^f
u.o
sidc.l
'lrrrlitv
ol
rxili'rl
DilioDrlistr
L$
oI
"u..or,,
4"",i
xtnnogrrLl
rL|d
ltlsnrririxl'rPl'itrxli'r'
Inrt
tlris
(loul,lci*s ,'ri,
rrlso
1lr
rrrr
r
rfllnlirrg
ihl:i
d\Drrnic
lb\cr
ork trin)i,,)l
Ir\'rr.ic
llrir,'.iLr(.]:l
It'
tl,r:
rl,iliiv
(o
.orrrrltr..)PPr)s
i(s
it(l
to al']sorf
ltis
rdvrNxrics
,.1
i', ,,
,,,r
'
l' r"
'
'
lrr'
rLl,l,..
.
r
'r.'
r"
'l
i" r
"r
I
l'"
''
'
l'
',.,r,,
'll
r.
,
rr
l'
'
'
\1"''i
'rr"
s s
r,,
I
,,.t.
t. ,,.
'.r.J,t
I
.rirr
..
x
sli..
l,
ri
rIrrrt
r,ilcLr
il
\\rri
s1 r
rrs l
(lrl71lirr
I)lrt
grrarr
or
\lritr'
1 I
tr,.rr
t"
,.
..
r
'tl'
r,,
.,".'
l"
''''
i'
rl'l'"''
l''"
lirl,(
r
l',
',
L,,,;l
l'.'
,'
\'
r'"
I
r'
'l
'
'
t"
I'
", rI..l l" rrl "r' l' '"'1"'''l ""llr''i
"I
"'' "'
another.'ll,c.v il(1x)
1,.t,,,,""
"t
l"t*'
rrLs
norr:
usrrrlJy
rrrrr{.rl
l)y
tlr:
ti\lio
l'-1]",,:,,j
,,1,1,
1 stls
tlrorrqlrr
ro olrtat'
si)lth
Io'1
tr2ll1jtl,
M.\i ,
r',Lrxn
SisNr
.rd
thc
Irnlllr'sixr
'rlnn
l
^lv)L{Lilg"
?r,hn,
r'
11't
r
"r
r
srr'r
',.,"'r
",
rt, I
^,
'1r,,
".i
l
'
\.
l.
"'.
1
"^"'
r I . ,,..
.,' r.
.li
'
'
i'..
l.ntri
'
.
i'
'
,,,.,,. , ,
"
lr'
'
'l
'
'lr ""-'
,,, r"
'l
'
"_' l
I
,i
.,,
r..,.,
.,
I
'"r'
"
'r
"
tl
h\r
tr
,, Ln
'lril,tiL\
I
nr l'
I rr
'
'
1'$"'
'.r\1.,.
I
.1.t.
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
10/35
n)x \rl)1.,,ni (lr)1.,
\{i.-h r(l,r\ to tl,,
st..,*sn)r
.risis
rlt(j i1,.
ricath
ol
-{rr0giruL.rt
11 n, r7(n,
N.1s
dc.ignl.l
t,,
ir(li.rtc \tLy
Prng.
D l\,S.r.
\'M i,illi
l)nl(l
lN1islan..r
rLsru|.(1
tL.
llironc
iloD
lrjs
f.Il)r\r
r\rrrurrg.,,,lt
lll.
trrs lhc {l{r .tn
l
soy.,ci fis
Lgitnrrat(,s,,c..isor.
1'|c slor
is l.l(l
tl,il
thc
Irli:rd]
kntg's rtro,-
hoo(l
sroo(l
or.ct
rirl ,,r
tltr,h)P
ol it
yxs
r radirrnr
lj.qht
(tjxl,j.i),
only
ihc
si1,)
oI
a
grrin
ol
p.pp.r. ]]ut r(n,ody oLs.ncd ir.
Onl)
lrxgcl.
l'jtlgcr
sxi'
ii.
Pri,gcran
Il,q(x
rlnicl(l)
siU:,.d
ul)
ih.
IdLop
r,1l ]iqlrt.,\s
sron
is
rhc ligl,t hr{l
b( i
sit,iul, th,,,.trrlrtxl
.cxscd ro strnd {rc.t. lt
\ras
Alhl)s 1lill thrt Prngcrxri
l'1,ljor
sh(nrld su.ccrxl to
th. dnrrr.."
I
iuclccd
llc
scrLrrl l:crtility of
thrl
rlLlcr
js
o,r
lssoniial
sign ot
rhc
]l(nv,r
thrt
h,) l,r)lds,
lor lis secd
is tlrc
rrnrr)()sr)ric
.xtr.ssior
ol
tll.
]'(^v.r
1rc
lrrs
cofic,rimlcd./'I
hc
li,rtility oli tlrc rrlc'r
s,.rs
srci) as snn,,lixnco sl)
e|c,h,,g
,uul
gurraD
iccjng
lhc
lirtilily of
lhc
lillxl,
tli.
lrrosl)rrity
ol
rlx
soc[t , .u.l thLr
crpelsiorisl
vjtrlil)
ol t)rc rrn;rirr'.
'l
lr.
Strlr.tDo
Inrdxl
onc(]
agrill
provnlcs
a strilti g
uruleru
palllllcl to
ihis
old klcr. Outsidc ob
s.rvcrs
of
tl,c Iniloncsi.,n
vrlr: ierltltly Idn h.it
tlrl] SulllIro's
rell-publicizod
sl,)iurl
aclivitics
ap|crrcd
io
.lo
lilrl
no
polltic.rl
l,.rrrr.
lL
ivrs
-.ii,
s"i,l il,,t tli.
J,tvnroso
nrlirigo,,tlv
cxp,,ci
Llt:lr
nl.rs to r.1 nr tlris
Nry.
Blt il tIo li,.8oirg auil)sit
is
(or,\i,
lh(:
pr,tnrl s|..is ol
Srrkrttrris
lros(nr.rl
lilo
arc ovcrhxrktl
j,r,
:clt:t
f(rspc(riv..
lii,
irigns
r)l th. nl{r's
vi lit}
.tr.
|oliti.rl
irrln'Lrtors
ilrxtlr,riilT
Tuil
lh,iPour'.
(lon l.Nlr.,rn,/
rirrrli,tl
.1, .lirr in s(,{rri
a(livit),co',irl lL LLLkLrr
as
sigi.l \r1rri,,t,
T',^\'cr in olL('r ,1'sf1als.
,\1,?
solrristicrlc(l
olxcLi?is ol
Lrl{)
(;uid(1
ll(]rl)ocr.1c} rr
in(lcc.l
i,rclinci
Lo
srsp.cl ihrrt
I'xh.jc
oll.ilils
(lclil,(rrtd)
ln.cid
o\.1gg.tur.d snnirs
rlxnrt
rL(,
llcrid.,rt's prr"lrrNl lili, ls p.lr1 ol tl
.o,itjrnring.fl(,t
to
r lj tunr
lrjs
rnilorjty.
Tho
sor:irT
signs
of thc
cof..nlrrtion
of
loll.cr
wcr.
l.ltilily.
pros-
pcril),
strLilii\,
x,,d
slol\.,"J
tl,(: rli1lll,,g ol tl,(:
,rlrlrs
,,r/ri? p,,ts
it in
thc.:hssi.rl ifragcll r)l
th. r.r'ir rt
J.rrinr.s.
l.jrg.lonr of
K.,.liril
'lLe
lan.l ol
(.dni.rar
l)c.lcscrjhcd
xs str'.t. lng
lar
i..l
wnl.,,
$'irl,
Iorg
sltufs.
Jtigl
rnonnlxils,
d.1,, llr
ih,
proitu,lr, trm(tril r.d w.ll
or{lcrc(].
If 1,,.ij1.,
it
nis
ll,. vill,rgcs
$l,nt, rr,,rc
nrlil.; if
propcrous.
it
rvas
tltq"liiDg.lo4
whi.l,.rvas
prospcn{s, lopd aiy'
cloLlLire
uc,c
v,rv
ir,
Nnr.rro.o, p.
58,.irir.q
/ral)atL
l
analt
1)itut.i,
ti.
:ntt-
rti
IlrNriDrn il.
()C.
,^NDr
Lrs.rN
11.- t.'-..-
,-l
I
t
.
t \
J,t,
ht
..
1-
11|',
r3
.l,crl).
li1,,
t]l. l,yltr\r
r-nluv
turkl k..l) h.,r
o$1t.lr],1,r,,1
Nirh
tls
frih.tr,i. S,nh
w,s
Ll,,,
rnl,..ss
xn.1
pn)slnr.it),
.t
rh
(iL,q.],D.
. .
.
ll,c,c
\r.re
.o nxr,
$tb
hcgqc(l
Ilql
on,
rnll(.,;
c(h
l,x(l
t),)sscssio,'s
,,t
his
owr.
]1ll
ll,is $rs
lD.inr
til tlri rnlrx.t\
u(l
s.1rl
lrd.,rjng of
''
.
1.,
,'.
L
'.''
Thc
trlo
Iunrhnrc,,lil
id.xs
L.hnnl th.s..or\rInnn,.l
n,r.r.s ri
crcntivjtv
({()
tilitv,rutxit\,
)
aD.l
ir I.4r)
1
t,."",1";lrity-i'ra".1,
exptcsscd
nr
ilo r{..r(1
nr)it,r
so
oft.u
ou
thc
lil)s
of
ihc
contcrlr-
trolrN
dirc, kttt
tt
tt.rt kut.t
tthdrcLiu.
(.,rd.r,
pcrcc,
prospedry,
g.rod
lorture). Both Icrtiliiy
nd
ord.r
arr:
si
dy
cxpressiotN
01
P.r\{
er. Poxrr
is iho
nl,jljt). t(i
gilc
lifc.
Pos.er
is
ilso
thc
nbil
}'to
mrirtanr
a srnootli trnrrrcss
1lld to act likij
a magncr $ltich aligns
scnttcred
ilor)
Iililgs
nr
i1
pxtt.rncd
{iclcl
oI
forcc._Convcrscly,
thc
sigr)s
of
a lcsso1tus nr
ihc
tauhress
ol
x
Nlcr s
lorver and
of a dilfu-
sioo
oI ]ris
strcngih
nLo
scc,j cqually
ju
manif..statio.s
ot disordcr in
ll" .
,,
rr. l
$,
r.,1 r'uud
. IIJiu.,
,n
I
1,h,
r
:
..r,J
ir, inlnlro,
priatc no(li,'
of
socjal l,ehrvnnrthcft,
greed, and
Drurder.al
Again,
"r,
rorr'rl
,
.l ;,,
I,\.,r,,,
t.,o
er,t
tt,,
r,. i: ,,o
n..:
j
r,..,r
,.
r.,'
1,,'
..
,
,1,.
L
rr,,.
1',,*,l,
..,
,l
,1.,.
.1,p,..,.',.
nl
rt,
* \
,,
l,
i,
'l
l,
I
.
,,
.
,..
.
..
.t'
.,
,.r'
1,
1,
,\
i.i.
:,r
..
J,,{,,
, l,l,J.,
(l.clinnr{
Po\rr
br{ docs rlot nr itsdI
Iurt]icr
(lnnhisll
rirxt lbw.r.
Il
is
r
s\rnlto,ir
Lrl
uot
r .lusc
(,1
lis
dccho.
l'lr."tlorc,
^
NIcr
\v|(, hr
o,.., p,uriti(l
r
trual
and
social
disord.$ to
rppe
1i,ds
iL
pN,li. lirl\ dilli(Ilt lo rcm,)siiluto
hir
rrill(nil\.
Javnncsc
nnLld
t.rkl
10IrlidcrlLrr
if I.
stijl
hx(i th(j llon.r,
thc
disorckrrs
nrnrl(l
n.vcl
hxv.
arisrn.'tkrv dr) not
sbm
rLltnlat.)ly trcrn
xutuno,
rnrnrs
soci or c(,troxrni
conditnnrr. Lut fronr
lI looscncss
or
difir$ion
,)l
Jr(x\1)
n,itLin Ilr
stilr.
PO\VEII
AND
HIST'OIII
II(^\
dor.s
(hc
nlca
of l1^vcr.rfi.d
thc hrdiijoxnl
Ixva
esc vjc\v
ol Ll)c
nxt,Lrc
or
strrctrn(i
ol:lhc
l]istorical
proccss?
Suh)no
hns
r"'llc.irilior
ir dr.s,n
nom
an urptrblished rransc
ftn,t
and
rraDslarn l
it r
tuaia
i
ht)Li,
t.rt,)Nxn..
r..od.d i.
Uo,orcdio, c.rh.t
Tari,
in
rrl,
riid.
hv
rL.\r
in. oI
llxr
rrjiri
l,iLar, v,r
Ilrt,
,$i
ri
tn./.4.,tu,
tit
iLi
i
ztl.
1r
lir a
food,
alrrrillll
lid
oI iI. un(hr;alr.
hrral
xi{l
so.irl
tluonori
'
'l'"'
'"
''_l P t
"
'"
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
11/35
20
lltr\Irx.r
li.
()(l
]\ND)rnsoi
ar$l(Il
that th..ssortirl
djliorcncc l)etlvcer tirc trrdlliounl
jrvancsc
vielv
of histoN and
thc
rrrdcrn U/cskm
pcrsp(rtive
is
tllnt,
in
lhc urodri'
\'icn,
hislo)',v
is s.or rs
r lir.rr
nr)v.xrurt ilrror :L iirnc,
w]trr.xs
J
rnos. tradilio rllv
rcfd.(l
to ssr
lhcn
l,istory
ns
rl scrics
ol
r.l. D(rrt
c-,-cii:s. IIc
srrggcsts ilirt \rlilc
\Vcs(clr historiens
ard
poljtkrl
s.i.ntists
dillr rrr llx ilir.ctnn of }ist(nvs
lnrcrr
mo'.
Drlrt Ikl tlrr) rl(igr.c
to Nlri.l)
it
is
dctcnrnrc.l
bI
obj..tnc Inciors,
nll
shrr.
lli.
s.ns(i,
.ssoDiirllv
(1(
ri\.(l
lrr)ni
th{
t( .lnrologic.J
l(\'dr-
ri(ri oi
IIrc
hsl
2oo \1rrs,
t]lirt
hjsnrl is
no)r:t(ratiro,
a soricis o{
Luriqre
(0ts
l;rkrrL
Ly a
(nntlor
c.1ullllit\'.
Ir .o,ll.lst
hc bclic\(s
ihrt l,xfii:ional
Trvtii,rsc
I
ist(,i.rxl
lliiilrin{,
in
n.n rl n1
txrt
l)v
S ,skrit
(t,si, rogi(|xl
nilirgs. s,1\r' l,istor)
as
N-c)cl. of tigcs
()iigr)
,,() i,,s Lrrn
rLc
(i,ld
1
ls.
(K/t./qllgz)
rhrn,Ll,
str..r)s
sirrlv
Jcss l,elpl rptx+s
11'fi.tt1tt1tgr
and
DUt|dra
l-ut,/)
io thc cril
Ku.litula
1)cl.tt
lLc
rl,tl rrrnctl
,Lg,r;n
rnrl
brrrght 1,,tck
.t
rc
nrwcrt KdlnIgi,.r trI\
(i\r
int(r|r.txtn),,.
lrorvlicr,
rorlil lx'ifirt
\\'hil(i rl,.
J,r\^rr.s,:
nx\'l,r\'r
,,ijli,cd .lc,n,:r- Irc., In(lic.(,sn ogv
for
turnrxl clrssiEcxt.) \'
Pr
LTos.s,
t|rn
nrtr i|i: s(rrs.
ol thrli'tori
cil
pro(oss
rr'rs
l
nd,1r,(r,tx
y
.1
logi.xJ
coruili^'
of
thcir
conccpt
ot
I']o(.r.
I pot'rhr
Txv{ncslr
iho
glri lo(]xy rntl in tI. rich csrhlto
Jogical
lirortLnc of
tl.
fxn.
o)ir
Ii,,rls iitllc s.
sc r)t
(rJ.s
al
of
orlcrl|
dcclhc
rnrl
rcbirlhi
i,rsl.nd
onc
s.)(]s
r shrrLr.onhirsi.lrx\rn
r,
.1
,,
l,
,/
/,/.r
L
D
.;
,, I
tlrc Dl(1 x{t.:'rL
l'ficsc l1\1)
i\,]1,s of hislr)ri.ul r,}rr)rs
wcrc
srnr
ht)icalll
t$
iiD.t ol
oil(.r.ir)(l
ii,rns
ol
.lisorcl .
ll r
oili|.1l
foi,il.
T l1)inlr.
js
tli.rt
lLc
Jr\'.ln,:sc
1ic\1
ol
hist(,_v \1 s
orr.
.l c.srrolosil]rrl
os.illxtn,r L.t\ 1rr
tr:ri(
s
oI
cor(frLrxlioi of
l'olLcr
a,rd
t.Iiods
ol
ils rlilirsion. I lr.
irIicrl lrist(ni.rl
s.(|r(,r(
is
{r.trir trrtiorfdjl"
ri
s,.
s)n.n,i
k
r
r,rlir,lr,.
1'j,JIal,Jr t,
ntrt)
t
t:i
\'lti
,n
lrr,i /i
,rl,rl
Sitfutrh tulr
-ir
(1. jLLr,ri:
(i,,,1i.'1,
l\,,rh, rr:q). Nr) ,.trtr,r',r\
.,i
Sr'L.n.ii r,1rrt.
r. t 1r
ro
frxir
no
il
i'*
nf.
lli , rnr rlrrf.
i\
rrlulTl
'
''
,, ,l
l
,
,l
,,
,
,,,,
.1iln,Nl
l. l
lii.rr l,inrri(rl
lrliral^1.rm,l.
tI. nrllln\].o rl
I\lxrtLni
.n.linol. .
(rl.
r\o \,..,trr.,
t]].8r
8.i nnrl
ll.n,rifh
Znnil.r,,\1rrli ,nl
\\,1\ls ii 1ntltu1
,\t1
.ntl Ch.ili:atn,1
(\,\v
YorL: l1[t(,
'lrtr.lntukr,
r9ri.).
tt.
r3
r.,3c
J7.
rr
llv.n
I]ndr .o,nol.il
ton,is
nr
rhis
(ln..tior
ri .c llrc
t)rtlarn
ol
(}ang.
is not:trnrrirr
.i,.nhri
t|..liugc
lr.rr Llt
(xlingx
to
thf
l(rllltrga
Jo.
nl-
I
':
:.,r
',1
'i,. r'o.,
|
,
ri$.1
.li
I
1',r,,'.
'1|rc
ltlet
of
t:otrcr in
lautncse
Cult1oe
2t
frsiol
concmLrrinnldjllusion
wjtloni tuv rikir:rato
restnrg-ponrt.r{
ID
o.rd1
pcrn
t,l
con($t
ari(r,
,,,,,r
,,,,;","
oi l,,x"r,,
liynasties,
Nhs) iuc
.onstit[ttrl Ird ,,lit1
is
r(irrtric.li
ir)
crch
pojod {,I
.liflnsnr\
ir(nytr
brgii,s
to
cLb
arvav tronr
rlrc
(mtcr,
rtro rcjgrnrg
,1.r,..-'
l,
.
i .,r'.,,,
,rl,
.
,
l
,lr\nr.l,
r ,t,1.,.,.
.,,rrrit
r,.,
,,.,,-
ccrtlitirg
Iroc.rs
l)cqjirs
rgiiL
Llx
hiill)ri(rl ,xrccsljtt
ol .liliusjor
is
rr; lcss
coJrr'.cllirr,l thrn
lLrt ol
.onoc,rirati)I,
sirlcc
l,olvcr
js
i,,,n,(,rsdl
lurtl
n) rcriin afrt
lus
p(rlr.l,,alt)
to
t).
stNgglcd
fir.
:l'li. sliqhicsr
sL..hr.ss
(,
Ii.k
ot
vigilrncc
nr.1\ l)cgi; thc
process ol
I
,
,',,,,
l.i
,.
t.,,.,,,.
r,,,
,r..,t
',.
tr,.
iuj.,,.
oL
o,inologi.il
.rurn.$
st.,rls tron,
lanrilr-
\,t,jcl, .senrii]lty
rlcrns
,
.
ti,
.
t,."
,
i,,r
,...,,,,
.1,
....,r.l],..,.u.,..
trlnll Po\vcr
oI
t'r{r
stLtlsltr.l;or
ol
Il,sonxl
i)xssi,rs). i
'l'liis
.1)i.cplrJ|
l)1
hisr,)n
bclps to.xpl ,r
r\ir)
norntric
but
,rpt)u.irll,r
.o|l[r(li(]tr,r l(|trirrs
ol
Jrur$|
trriricrLl
psyclohil
I
ils
rIt(r]]irg
t|'s ir
risrrr
rrrrl
:rt
lL. s.1rrtr t1rrc
its sIs( rribilitv
ro
rx,ssjr.ic
ipprlls.
l'I{,
p(.s
-'frjsrn
d.rir
I.o4 tlr.
sc|sc of
thr
i.r ,rr xn.r)cc
of rorrccltr'
(l
l.w.t.
Lhc dilll.rlr
nrvolvcd
i,r s
ic(rldrrrlninnr
f.|(l
r.n,jjtnjr
,
11r
(l lLr)
ir)(a
iitLriliiv
oi
tlisortlcr
orr
rtrc\
lru
snl(i
(,1
ord.r
'l'lr.
susr ptibilitv
to
Ik,ssjarljsnr
i tirncs
ol'dis
rrrlcr,
Loivcvur, riris(s l]IIn
tlr. s(rrs.
thLt
,r xcw.()nccnira
,r
ol:
lion.r is rhlrrs
prcPxr irrt ils(li
\\.ithil
il)it dis(,xlcr,
tlat on.j
rnLrsr
ir rhrr
for porhlrs
oI
iis
i.n nnit
xpp.xrr..r
arcl thrl
approach
I'I
\ror
Ll
liL.
l. rlr.s Lliil nliir
I [r s.)nr. lnc
ir ni.x
rr
as
on irl.,,
Iniurnm
.l
tl1.
lrfd.m
ri.\ ,,1
/ri 1.,r/
iI
I
(luitir
strcilic r.rsc,
It
is
mr
o
n l.,t,rLrti.r
.I ar.
Trxfr:c
o,r..|t .I rrn.r.
\.Lnrh I tlinl
is prrlrnuv
i.l.n
I
.onrl)
lr. t.
rh,,
Il linr.
.on..tt |&i
on
th.
.otuln briil
,,'loio,
s. b.illi. .lv ,1,,.n1,i.,1
br Ctilld
C.-rz.
(S.e
cdrz,
t.son,
1'h)
t
rtnl
C. ltrl ,;
,n,/i,
l,t).
,r
,
i* )
ll\ ldlnll1,
.ss.nri.lll
n,hririv., is
llrt
tl,..rl..d'nrl,'i,,rrlIrli,,
1l',rr{rIrt.l ti| .i\
in Jrvr
iho
frum.-
ninr
Nilff \l,n r.r.'\Jx1 irllili
Lrl.r
t[...
]'x
ar)tnics
l,ri,nx,ilv
tr,
l
'
, i
l'
r,
,,
,.
,..
L,,l
.
"
,'
I'i.r,,v
,
I
r' i.
,
..
.l
,
. .
,,,
r
,r
,.t.,..
,..
l.
ilTit,r'rn,
|1.,
\r,Lr\
rl,',nrg[
ll].
rrrT Irirlg
rridili,,r,
ud
rh.
l(nrg
t.d.d
.l
.1(,,inl
u,bln ition.
tI.r. ir r {lirln inv
ol
\vhrt
.nr w;,ld
.rtl
t).]iH.nJ
lrisn)r), \,hn,h is n t,xh,d.i.rl
rt rl. This /rirro/ral p. st.dnc
t.t.]
,.
,
1..,,r
'
i
'.
', 'l
.r
I
,,.
i.
rr
.r.
,i,
J...rnt'.,
,''.-
1 \sod
l)r
s ,ror
i,, d,.
pi.vr
r
v.lrn),.. 1'o
n liDihrl
ltlo$l.dg.,
BJi
stoivs
n
r.larnt l..k ol
Lotl' dlr,aLic listoriogrt)hr
xr(l
f.nsint
xrillcnarjxtrisnr,
riS..
Ll,.r
nr{nnr
"l1trr.r
trr(l llrhi.s"
lnr r
n
]lc.
discusior
of
the
{.xn_
rg
a, signilicrn.c
ol
l,d,r,/,.
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
12/35
z,r
ljli\r) (rr
li
O(l
.\\Dr
so:{
ihc
t (r)rinal
co,ld
rs
rrt)i(ll)
its
PDsslliL,
llLln.hifg
r)rus.ll
t1)
tl
'
rc\\r
(, (.
xs
ii rir,lg.s
lhls
nnrssilrrirr
L .l.rrh
lrrs
lilll'
ol lii''
ljn..rr
rtriht\
l rnxnv
l-unrpcrt
rlill.rrtir)'
'
rrrr' rr.rrts Nhi'rlr
sL1lr'
tlc
\rorl(l
.o,fitq
to
al] cnd
$'ith
tho .llri\,'tll
ol tl).
l\l( ssiJL'
ll
rxdi
tbl]xl
Jrvxn.sti
s. s{r tL]t
histo)-\r docs
rx)t
onr.
lo xn
(rrd,
llrrt
n.ssirlrs
ril r,nh for
thcir:
ti.rc.
inxl tlrtti
tlro
Prirnof.lixl
osr'lllLliior
s
,.t
t,
.....
.
'r,
,
. rrr
.
.1.
rnr
L\l'll
\l' rlll'' .'
l'l:
It
tlrx)
Lr.
usclLLl
to
b( gitl
.lls.,6sio,t,rf
rhc tridiljonxl
lxrlll)'not
lrilh
iis .(,)crct.r
stru.lrrrrs
lirt
s
itL
ils
i.lc.rl sl'rnL,(,1i.
lolr
I
I']( rLxl)s
tll(]
rrosl
.rr.t
jirtlg{r
r)1' tlr('
(,rl(ral
liv: r.,'
Polil}
is tlrxl
ol
x.rrnr'
ol
liglrt.:asr
ar$rv,,rils
l,r
i
rrll.(,lor hrnP
I'i
,
i
txs(i.,rrr(' s.
I
tlink
nror.
r,tumt.l)
llrrr
rrr c
((nnrrrtiorrll
I
nrrnro[rg.
sorrrt
o]
l|o
n,,r,,('s ot
Irt.r,.vr foljtj.xl
lfor,glrt.:r'hr
goo.1
socl.rrr,
is
for
strictl),hicruciLi.rl,
si,rrlr i l
i.rtrd,t
Plrs,,Pl,oses
a
({)
tanl drgrrc
of
Llonr)rr) .1i
,r(h r)l
jlt
lrri
nrs
lcvrls. 1-lxr
ro\1 r.rrL
(rl
hx.ljLji)rrxl
lx iln{,sc
lliorlglLi
j,rplj.)itll
11u1ics
tl,is, sccking
.allv
r snrglr.
lnr
3sivc solx.', of
Pnvor
rnd
.t,,tlrorit).
As rve
shlll
rt,
tlc
qr.1d'Lal,
cvor
dinriirltnrr
rjf tlc lld
rnre ol
llr.
hmf \fith
in.r.rsinll
(]is
ixrcc fu)in
ll,.
l)(ll,
is xrr cia.t
rrr'1lp|or
hrr
1hc
ldrrrr|i'ctrrccp
tjon
not o l)
.rl tlc
strlr
r.('
oI tLc
sl.lr
lnrl also ol
('nt(
pcridr.r\'
n
ltltionslj)rs ,u[l
;f
tcrritorirl
so\ocigrrl .
\\ hiI' rhr:
rrr
.lillcft,rlialrrl
(rrrLlilt
ot
tltr
lirlrt.\l)r.ss s
th(r i(lfr1
(,1
tlr lrr)rn'
-,,'.
,)
,l
l
\
r
rl.,
r
,,
1,,
lr-l
'"'l
lr'
"
r''i
hrsior
oI
rll tlro .olors
ol
tJr.
sll"rtt
urlr, slmhlizec
[ho
nr]if\ nrq
rn(1
conccrrtr
rtn,I
.1sp(x ts
r)l
1t^i1 .
,'I'l,c
.or.r
,)l ih.
lrxditio,,rl
t(rily
l,as nhvr['s
lI
lrr
l]ic
rll'r, \'|o
lc
rn
l.is
tl)f
ffilt
oI
sofict)
r
'f|is
trDit)
is
in its.ll
x
cl]'lul
qmLol ol losrr',
lrr.l
it
is
tlJs
luct
^s
t,rLr.h lls
th. ovcrt
qoals
ol
statist
i.l.r)l)qi.s
thrt
lrclLrs tu
rrrrotrnl lirt
rlr. olx.ssivri.orxtrrr
\rith oucrrls
rihiclt
sL,l|rss
tl)r
ln)lili r1
tlrirrllng
ol
nrrlv cor'
tdnpL,r,tl'
lavxncsc.
Tlrt:
poprrlrr
hosti]itr
c'Prrss{'d
t
rl1ld
thc
Fc(leriil
ltcprrl)ljc
of
lD(lorcslrl
(rg.lq
ro
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
13/35
24
lnrN,J (.l
lt O'C. ]\NDi)rsoN
nnmli:tl
.li .li
:alfi
(so.
urtit(l ,rs o,,.)
nr
lilo.rnd
h dcrl|.1r'
'r1,e
,L,gc
ro,,,,'*'s,
'ii
c,r,tr.rl lo
Iirtn,'n,
ijdiiicxl
.ttti1 dcs,
holPs lo.rphjn
rl,(i
(t{r't)
I*r
cl,okrglcil
]l^r('r
ol
lli.
i(lcx
ol
,ri
(io,rilis,.
i,)
Jx
.
ir r r ,rc
ll,i,r,L
|r)liti.xl
cr{lo,
nriioLrLlis,rr
(\
prcsscs
a
hntirrrcftl)
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
14/35
2{j
liLNrI) .r lt
O'(1.
ANDUT rr;
of
dcs.cnt.;i
Tiis
chdactcristn,
ol
corrsc, is
Dot cxclLrsnark
Ju .r-
n.sc. Ihrt t|{r
rnoi.
nitcrostnig lQLlr.
(,t
Jxvxixrnr
'I.rlsilicrtn)n
ot
Listr)rl
is
lhat it
al.rs
nr)t
i)rxnx.ih
nr\ohc
tlr(: r'stxblislrnrg ol oc.$
lrlll
linlij
wirlr
t),1\,j,),,s
(lr
rrslr(s
t
(l(,r)jrstrrh
l.grl, i,rlx{it(\l
l,giLi,,rx.r--irr
\lricl,.i,sr rl,,(rs(
rf)
r
(.stor
\roLLLl
(1,,
1'\picrlh.
.,r(slrirl
li,rl,s
a(i
i,,a(1.
lvilh
ll,c,,l(,,i
l)q\r'crlLrl
,r,d ..[']r11(r(l
rcpi(iscL,lntivl
s ol
l|oso
(h
nxstnrs.
'lh,,s
i,,
rlilno,l(n,
p.,io,l o,,. nr(ls
1,1v.,,(so
(l.rn,ri,,e
d.sco,l
Iro,,) lh,r
grcirt
Srltin AgLrig
(,i
tl,(i \frLrfrrn
(lyrurlv
(r(irt-$.(il,
r)r th(i
fo:iscssio,
(n
por( ,r
r.lics
(g(rgs,
frisscs,
x,,rl
n)
lortll oI
Itr.i
s.i,rc rrld.
,\ .lai,n to
d.s,r,
Ll lron liis rlo l.ss
ln)l)
lrrilot)roa(iri
tir'i l)Lrt.orrsi(l(x.tl)h
l(,ss
|(riij.rll),
x.l.|t
srr( ss(ns,\nringkrnrrl T.
lI, lIt, rxd
Ms virtr,rlll
rDloown. llrc
ln)i
Li
hcrc
is not sirirpl\ ll .
histori.al
glory of
S,Llr,Ln
r\gL,f,l's rL,lc, l,ut rlso tlc cl,rrx tcr ,)l
lradiinrri
Jxvaf
.rc
.osnn)logi.ll
llouelrt \\,lri.h nritk.s nr) sLilll
dislindbn b,l$1r'tr
tl. lirin{
ru.l llrc
dcrL(1.:lhc dcri rrrl1, lr.rir:
l'u[jrs
Iill
rs
lr]. li'ir)g.
-\
rrl
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
15/35
23
llJ \rnr(:.
1l.
O
(;.
r\\D
isoN
Ioricrl
rlisirn.c
tro I
ilc oriqilrl
vn)rcc
lr(l
(1(xyin
a.l|rirlurcs
oI
roirrorrl se.{l llrls
ile c\scntiirl li|li
1o
thc
fth
is
|rclsurod
in
t(.i,,s
oI j),orjrr)iL\, \lr(ilrc,
tht)rq|
r,i,(.tic
d.s..nr or.
rs
1rc
slr.tll
sr .. xl(rr
otlr(r
tr\.s
of
roll
tr^y.r.
lllLc
s ...ss(ns
tr)
rh..l\r)xst)is
nnrnrllr
(l(
ri .d
llr.jr oiql,
irl lr()1 o
lforn
th. inii rl
jnrprtsc
pr(
virLd
lrr
t}r,irrnrlr,L
hirr l .IIrt tl)is
llnv{i t.rclll
to
irr(^r
(lillusr
ovcr
er:rrcraLions;,rnlcss
jt
\ ,s,orrrcrt
rnrl ,.n,r,,g.:;,rt
l,y rt,,
grs(nrll
.0,)rts ol i
p
ticol.rr
(l.s.cl(tant,
rh.
dynllst\,
1.orl](l
IaI
,,1,'r..
,,
".
'
...
'..1
r,.
L
I
.,
.'j
..
I
r,\\
'
i.
.\\t,
l.Iit.[LL
TLo
J.r .r),.sc
corrltrr,)f
P,^ .r
l,Ls
i ,tricxrn)nr
atso tor
runccp-
ti(,rs
of
sr)\..,rjgnt).
t.rljtoritrl
nrroqrjq,
ar[i ]i)r(:igll
rt'l.ltnrjs.
I,I(x]r-
roxo und
orj).$
liLrc ponrr(tt oIr
ljro
rlrnort
jnvr
rtn.r
r|lc
Lodi
ni
I.\nr.s.
$,rLjorr
sto
rs
rLnd ir thc
histori.rrl
lradi&nr
t|at
th.,
nxnx,s
ot Ifrl)jros
rl)d Kinqrlo,)is
xr.
rlos.
of
rir.r
capiraj
citics.
.{norre
thc \\ cll.b}l^ir
r.riull|l(,s
rr.
}t
ritjrfrtrir,
Sin,,ttusai. Iicdn
j,
ltnd D.n,rl.ri
rlrl{lrd
tj)c
J
af.n, l&(r
so
nrakcs
no
cte.rr
erynrol.,dcil
distin.inD
h,tf;(r,
tL.
nl.l
ol
rxt)jtxt.it\ rr(l
tlrrt
ot
kif((lorr
ir
thc
$nr(l
,era,ri
l)r)r|
irl
if.lrr(1.r1.
1'tros
rl ,
slal.
is
t]'pj.NIlv
n.fi|(.,1,
rrot l)
its
tutrn.t.r.
ln,r l)\'ils
drrt.r.
t.hc
tirril,r'i.rl
.\lr'si,rrr)llL,
rtxt,.is
lltrr\s
jr)
lh\i
ii r.r.i(,s
r.,or(lijrg
to iho
n(nrrl
oI
Jtnn
ru,u",,t,,,r,,t
ai
tt,.,,r,rror.
C.ririn trolti(rs
$,u.)
.r
.nilr.r(tor,,j7rd
I
lr[.ii.1,.
r,)rn
nt,rl)L]
((r,,1
,l)lri.rl
oL,
sir(t(5lil:,r
ro,rft,lirs,L,rd
s,.,rs.
rJrir.lr. l,or.i.r.
t,, ,t,1t
ro
h.
,r,-
r,.1r,.,,,,1,.,.,.I,,,,,r
do,rs
n1)c
nol
rg,rrlrrl
as lridjjjs
rr.d
tnrll
.hin.tc(l
tirnits,
but
rxtlrcr
ll.\ilnt. llrrcl,ixtinq
lr..irri.nJs.
1,r .r r.il
sr|s..
rL
e
rcrc
ro
}oliiic,rl
tronLi,Js
ri
xll. tll l,o$.r
of.nc
L',I.r
qft(t .rllv
tidinjI
:',r1,,1,.',r.,, .r, t,,,t,.. ir,,...,irr;
Ihrcr
ol r rcigl,lrtlIinr:
sorcrritrr.
l
li pcrsBrctjrc
brirgs nrrr)
reln,f ttr.
Irn.ttnurrrl
difloucc
lxhvccn
thc ol(1 i.lca
oI it
Sonrl,clst Asial,
ki,rgdonr
arcl
rle mortcrr
stntc,
irhi.I
(1,.ln1,s
lro,r
totrllv
.olh
tius
vjcN,s
.rl)our
thc
mcarnrg
ot Irolti.rs.
h\rn
ft in
llo
jd.r
ot
rtr.
mo&,.r
sturc
is
rlrc
(r)rcopiior
t]nl
a Iro))ftr
nrirlrs a
(liticat
liLll
;r
tlc
Powcr-voitxgc
ol
thc strtc's
r.ul.rs.
]-cu \,rrds
ihis
snl.
of
tlk, tronkr,
ihcir
po ,er
.6
t.,
...
r;..
'I'tLe
ld.ea
ol
},alaet
in
l@anrs(.
Cult |e
29
'''
'v'r,ir,'.'
\..'. l'.,,11'
'
'.r,..'r..
i.L
rr,.LrI
rrtli-rl,l
.",,
\1..,.,\..
\:t.
r',
ti,,
1",..,,,
r.
t
tJ,...t.,,
1J,,....,..
;
"f
rl.,-,,,,
."
.
rr"
.
r,
lr
,,t
,,,, i.
,,
,\.i1,,
l.Il,l,,
ry
.,.,,.1
I
..1
..'
.r..t,r
,,r,,,11
r,
rrr,..,
r,,,.
.
,,t,1
l,,J,,lul,l;
1r..,\
.'.,IlJ..t,t,h
,.,
.',r)
,,,,
.rt,n,rt
rtr,
l, i,..,).
s:j,,.lt,r
r,.,ti-
tiod
nlc.
oI
lurcr
is
tr)trllv
di0i).crrt
iI
.hancter,
rxl
rho idcr
oI
'l'
,,
I
"
r, 1..', |
,I r,,t'r.
rr.,,,,,.t
I.L,\,.r
i-
..,...rnJh.
1t,,.,
.
,,
t.,
.',,1r
i\,1, l.
,r
'
i,..1..t,
-
..
"
t.)
ir\
0,.ri.i,
t,,.-,
'rh.l,i-hh,.,r.p.Lt,t,,,
,.r.
,,i
i"..
ti,,
.
.arJ,,,.,n.
..
rJ.,.
r.t.,
i,
,'ri\.
b)
:Ir r
r,,'
t,y,i,,,..\,\'nr,,,,
tt.,
snrl,r
irrre
rr6
111,, 5..1
st,rtc- :
Jlra
ard
SlLrllng
(Ill
,Dr(tiliircDriaicd
$,ord rncauirg
..ovor-
scas'
b t
cssc tiirlh
itflrlnrl ro
all
noD-Jrrxncsc
groups ancl
potitical
ollj&s).
,Utlnn,.'L
ontcnrirolu)
poiitcjsc
and
thc i{teotogicat
rc.
qlncnreDts
of hdoncri&
nrtionatisDl
rkc
rhis
kiI.l
ol
divisioD
no
lorecr
publich.
.1c( ?rxblc,
onc
tutrls
ir
frilak,
.tjscussj.,1
\virlr
nr.u).
Jrlv.rDcs.r
stl(nr( irnd
.r^,io s
residl(x
oI rhis
nriclcctuitl
co
,
',tirju'r.
l.'.'..r....,r.,-l)
.1,..,:..,s..
rt..
it,.r,,tr.,t
rt,.
n.r,t\
',
,.t
..
,
.
,t,
i,ti.,-,
tI
.
or.r
,,.t....i
,,'
trJrilui(.ri
t. nirr)loqi(.ulh,
irlo
ldx,,,,.t
rl)o
Oi,t.r
tcgnns.
Ntrn).
lrvfuros,
srill
Iifa ii .\L
o(ti,,,rrih
ditilL,,lr
ro
xc*,F
ltrtiy
rtrc nll,
.1,..,r,
.r'.:. ,..
,,..,.
,.t
..Jr',,,r
"
,,,.,t
i,,,,r..,i
,,
islar(]s
Surrxtrt\
Slihn1si
Iilljrt)lrrtr)),
Tnva,
rmil
Llxr rcst.
All rcrd
'l
t",....,,t.r,.\
t.
,
|
.i
i
1,.r..,,, ,,,
i...;. t,,.
i,
..
Lhrt
r1r. \'.,d
nrlI'rn . is
Lr.rl,
|,trrlI
n,
(l.f.ro..
to
rlc
nL.a
oi
ttr. $vl
^,,
,.",.'
..(.
,n,,.,t.,".,.n,.I
,,',,,|1,,,
i'
r,'.
..
,t
,,.
.,
tt
.
,,l].
u.
.... ..
,,,
...
.
,
,
,t ,
'
l'-."u',.
..1
'.
.,.,
,,
j.t ,t.nr.,
1r..1 ,
,,,
".
L
,r ,t.
..
t,..
1.,,t,
,.
,...,.,.,.
I
r.
,l
,
,rr
I
..,
.
.
,
,,
,,,
..,,.
orirr. r.lr,. t,.,
''1,
.."1,.
t'.'
,',.,$,
rr',
,,,r,,,t rt.i
r,,t..
h. Lr
.1,,,'.",,
\1.i'.
.'.,,
t, \,{tr.,
t.r,th.
rr
r.,(,..,,\
'i,l
,,^
"....:t,,
,\ n.nJtotr
,,i,,''1...r..'1,
or
llk oi.t tn.,r,. rr.
'.
',,
,1.. ,1"i,,
.
.
.\
I .tr,
,t
...\
,",-
, ,,,.,,
.r i
,,.
,i
I
,.'
'1.,
.
..
,
'
r'
.,,
.
,r,,
.
J Ly
r,,
,
",,
r,
I
t.
.,n.t
r., i
,,,.
,
I
,
,l ,,
'r..
,..,...
.t
,"
...r1.,t,utJ...
in..,1n
li't'
,,,
I
',,,tr
.
v.,.v, L
,int,1i..t'Fn,iry
ttl\
.\hl
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
16/35
30
llriNrrrcl
tt.
O'(1. AN, trsoN
ro
l .s,r r
ii)
^r1,,.i,
,lirior6t,iI
lo tlrc..)ri.r
ir\ ). sjj, ilIt ,
nlxD\
.lri,[).s.
0 Lt it
]rii
d ti) rr)rc(.i 1,
ol tl.
.\isrcrr.r
oI r\r) rcqr1,
i,
.1
..
ll, l',,,':i,
.,
,i|,r'i,..,,Iri,.,.,..,i1
Su[kr.tu
][r.
I(1 s.p:LrLr
t .r-]rtcl..s
tor
tuoro
Ltrerr
roo
r.rrs
trll
rJ,.,1 .,.,",
]
,,, ,,,,.
r..:.
.....
L
jt _
t....
l_,r,t.,..,_
,_.,_,
t.,._ti
I
,..,.
.,
,r
. .,
.
..,
,1,i,,
,r..1
.
..
,
tL,,
ot|(r L\
its
rtr(,
ris tl,(
r urrtrl
rrl
oLh,icirr
ir
Tnrto,,r.:irr.:.
'll(,
( rlrif.txlit_l
,,t
Jr\r,r.nr
t,)tili. l
rtrirrkiDg.
rr).rbjr)f(t
\1irtl
,.
..,t,, .r\.r..i
r,/,.,t.
lr.
1..,.
.r
I
1.,
.r
,.
,.
.,
\,,.
rr
r
.r,
,
,
,.
,..,r
,.
r,,
r
Iirsl
phr it
ir)rfli|s
,1
srrss
o)r thc
(urtrot
ol
|ot) hijrnrs
rxtl(,1
thnri
oi r.[itl,\'
JlisL ,rio,Lllr,
r]r(,,:j
s.r.
fu.li.rt
r.r(tuns
1or itris
(.rqrrrsis.
ODI
tl(
.on.r)rti,rtion
ol
L[sc
fot).,iijons
nn(t(]
possil,t.
Lrl irl.,rsiv(r
rj(c
c JtiltLt
or)
(Jnrld
L)rovidc
rL.
(j.onofunr
surtt,rs
and
icy:,vo
.,1
n,ant){r$1,
ntcssl_v
tot
brritrlinq rron,r,rrcnti
rr
arlrjcs
lli,t llir
col(1 rt|xti,nr
(,1
lrrgo
potn,txriois
lLrnr|
8/11/2019 The Idea of Power in Javanese Society by Benedict Anderson
17/35
32
IlINrDr.r l.
a)'C.
ANDrjnsoN
i.sofrr
ff
ilie.],r1xntlti(nr
is not
brrl, it Drat
ot do
so
dccisiv(rv
)
d'
O,
lLc
nror.
Llrc.rrcLicrl
I
\'cl,
(lcslncriol
of r)rh.rs do.rs
nor nr ibclf
rrioDratnr.tlh
m.a
xnl rlnrg(:.r.nt
or
rmr:$ll
oI rh{j
rulcr,s
Poxcr.,,,rrth
tl,o.ljslxjs,1l
oi his riv
s,
whjch niay
t)i, pk,ksl
up
or.rl,so
xi l,) oth.r ri|rl\
\l)r1r^,rr,
(l.srflr(tn)i,
its( is
lhr rnosr
blnr.r,i
irnd
lr(,
((nrdc,
iongl,)
nrcrns
(,t
s,,trdun,g r rn rl,
.1DLl
ou tlris accouut
tlc
hast.l(sirrblc.
trlor. salisfrct( \
is
rlo
nctlro.l
.
.,
",1,,",r,
,
t,
,r
r. .
,"
...
t\.
.
, .
,,,
.,r:.
1,',
'
..
..
,r
.,1,. ,.,1u,
,"..t
\
l
,4
.,,t,
'
.t
:.....,
i.,.
,:.,
..,,:.i
.
..
sut)ciorirt or
slz. i|tr.I
Ll rh,r),r.
xlr(,fikD
i,
s..n
rs
rhc
loluntrry
srl)r)rission
of |.ighbor;rg
liin{(lo
s
1o
ttrr
sUPI.Irc
Recommended