View
43
Download
0
Category
Tags:
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
2014 Transmission & Distribution Benchmarking Data Review Conference. Storm Restoration. Nashville, TN June 25-27, 2014. Agenda. Guidelines Review Key Measures Anomalies, Issues, Outliers and Corrections Next Steps. Guidelines. Key Terms and Definitions. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
1
Storm Restoration
Nashville, TNJune 25-27, 2014
2014 Transmission & Distribution BenchmarkingData Review Conference
2
Agenda
Guidelines Review
Key Measures
Anomalies, Issues, Outliers and Corrections
Next Steps
Guidelines
3
Key Terms and Definitions
4
Storm Event An individual storm or closely spaced series of storms which
resulted in numerous, widespread electric service interruptions. Multiple storms are typically grouped and
counted as one storm event if restoration from an earlier storm was still in progress when subsequent storms
occurred.
Excludable Classify storms as excluded if the majority of restoration days
Storm Event * were excludable as major event days per the IEEE Standard 1366 (2.5 beta method)
Peak Number of The peak number of simultaneous sustained customer Customers Out interruptions that were recorded during a storm event
Total Customers The total number of sustained customer interruptions Interrupted caused by a storm event calculated on a cumulative
basis throughout the duration of the event. Individual
customers that may have experienced multiple sustained interruptions during a
storm event should be counted multiple times. Do not count momentary
interruptions.
* New definition to be added to Glossary
Key Terms and Definitions (Continued)
5
Significant Storm A storm event that interrupted more than 1% up to 10% of a company’s total distribution end use customers
(cumulative interruptions)
Major Storm A storm event that interrupted more than 10% up to 20% of a company’s total distribution end use customers
(cumulative interruptions)
Catastrophic Storm A storm event that interrupted more than 20% of a company’s total distribution end use customers
(cumulative interruptions)
Hours to Complete The time in hours that it took to restore all customers Restoration interrupted by a storm event,
starting from the hour when the first service interruptions occurred and extending
through the hour when the last affected customer that could receive
service was restored Storm CAIDI = Total Customer Minutes Interrupted/Total
Customers Interrupted, calculated for the full duration of a storm event (same timeframe as Hours to
Complete Restoration definition)
Key Measures
6
Storm Activity Profiles
7
* # of reporting companies that experienced storms in these size ranges
We need more companies to report their 2013 data. These early results suggest that the overall storm activity in 2013 was much lower than what was experienced over the previous six years
2013 YE 2012 YE 2007-2011
Min Mean Max # of Bars Min Mean Max # of
Bars Mean # of Bars
Number of Storm Events Per Company Per Year
Significant Storms 3 6.7 11 7 1 8.4 15 11 8.0 15
Major Storms 0 0.4 2 7 0 0.7 3 12 0.5 17
Catastrophic Storms 0 0.1 1 7 0 0.3 2 12 0.2 17
Average Storm CAIDI Per Event (minutes)
Significant Storms 99 157 223 7* 135 185 325 11* 162 15*
Major Storms 104 260 416 2* 104 219 348 4* 444 9*
Catastrophic Storms 465 465 465 1* 450 1467 1883 3* 1248 8*
8
Number of Storm Events Experienced in 2013
Report page 2
OutlierStorm experience varied widely across the community
Min 3
Mean 7.2
Max 12
9
Average Storm CAIDI – 2013
As expected, the average Storm CAIDI increased with storm size
(This graph should show parallel bars for each storm size grouped by company, not stacked bars. 1QC will fix)
Report page 3
Avg. for Significant Storms
157
Avg. for Major Storms 260
Avg. for Catastrophic Storms
435
10
Major and Catastrophic Storms – Percent of Poles Replaced
Report page 8
2013 2007 - 2012
# Bars 4 19
Min 0.0095% 0.0033%
Mean 0.0107% 0.1368%
Max 0.0112% 0.9471%
The pole damage for the four 2013 storms was very uniform and falls at the low end of the range experienced in 2007 to 2012
11
Major and Catastrophic Storms – Total Restoration Cost per Customer Restored (Capital + O&M)
Report page 10
2013 2007 - 2012
# Bars 4 24
Min $3.16 $3.59
Mean $45.24 $65.12
Max $86.83 $131.61
The cost per customer restored varied widely on the 2013 storms. Overall the 2013 costs rank at the low end of the very wide range experienced in 2007 to 2012
12
Major and Catastrophic Storms - Peak Line Staffing Per 1,000 Customers Out at Peak
Calculation Used:Storm 1: RP30.1A/RP20f.1A, RP30.2A/RP20f.1AStorm 2: RP30.1B/RP20f.1B, RP30.2B/RP20f.1B Report part 2, page 2
2013 2007 - 2012
# Bars 4 27
Min 1.0 2.3
Mean 6.9 8.0
Max 11.3 33.5
Company 38 should verify its line staffing data for Storm 1. This is the lowest value in our database for major and catastrophic storms going back to 2007.
13
Major and Catastrophic Storms - Peak Total Field Staffing Per 1,000 Customers Out at Peak
Calculation Used:Storm 1: RP30.1A/RP20f.1A, RP30.2A/RP20f.1A, RP30.3A/RP20f.1A, RP30.4A/RP20f.1A, RP30.5A/RP20f.1A, RP30.6A/RP20f.1AStorm 2: RP30.1B/RP20f.1B, RP30.2B/RP20f.1B,RP30.3B/RP20f.1B, RP30.4B/RP20f.1B, RP30.5B/RP20f.1B, RP30.6B/RP20f.1BReport part 2, page 3
2013 2007 - 2012
# Bars 4 27
Min 5.3 5.0
Mean 11.4 12.2
Max 20.8 40.3
Company 38 should verify its line staffing data for Storm 1. It’s unusual to deploy less line staffing than tree trimming and other field staffing
14
Major and Catastrophic Storms - Descriptions and Damage Summaries
Calculation Used:Data extracted from questions RP20, RP20f and RP31
ID Transmission Damage Substation Damage Distribution Damage Rest. Cost # Poles Repl.23 Storm 1 none none 214 poles, 252 XFMRS, 6,700 fuse links,
900 cross arms, 5,600 lbs of wire.$76,531,455 214
30 Storm 1 Majority of damage was related to distribution
$5,145,802 52
30 Storm 2 Majority of damage was related to distribution
$3,309,899 61
38 Storm 1 6 transmission lines operated out and in; found a few cracked insulators
None several incidents of conductor down $422,450 39
ID Storm TypeStorm Name Excludable?* Date Total CI
Hrs to Restore Weather Severity Conditions During Restoration
23 Storm 1 Snow, Ice Cleon Yes 12/5/2013 881,378 143 Wind, sleet, snow, freezing rain, ice accumulation 1/2 to 1 inch.
cold, ice lasting 3 to 4 days, freezing fog, transportation problems
30 Storm 1 Snow Rocky Yes 2/26/2013 106,678 75 8-12 inches of heavy, wet snow Most snow still on ground, slow driving conditions, cold temperatures
30 Storm 2 Thunderstorm Yes 5/19/2013 77,419 47 Torrential rains, gale force winds with gusts up to 77 mph
Clear weather
38 Storm 1 Wind 2/25/2013 133,762 29 Thunderstorm with high winds gust up to 30MPH
Rain with some high winds
* Answered "Yes" if majority of restoration days were excludable as major event days Per IEEE 2.5 Beta Method
Report part 2 page 4
Company 38 did not answer the “Excludable?” questionCompany 30 should provide more complete system damage information
15
Major Storms - % Impact Curves
Calculation Used:Storm 1: RP35A/(ST5_T&DDist End Use Customers) * 100, Storm 2: RP35B/(ST5_T&DDist End Use Customers) * 100
Report part 2, page 5
Company 30 Storm 2 shows no customers out before the hour of the customer outage peak -- this is unusual
16
Major Storms - Customers Restored (Cumulative)
Calculation Used:Storm 1: Sum RP55A, Storm 2: Sum RP55BReport part 2, page 7
Company 30 Storm 2 shows no customer restorations before the hour of the customer outage peak – this is unusual
Issues found: Storm Restoration
17
Page # Q # Primary Issue Who3 RP15 Change graph type – it should show parallel bars for each
storm size grouped by company, not stacked bars1QC
Part 2, pages 2 and 3
RP30 Verify line staffing data for Storm 1 --- value is low compared to other storms in our database and in relation to reported tree trimming and other field staffing for this storm. Also, the number of line people reported as working on this storm is a small faction (less than 10%) of company distribution line field staffing reported in question SO15
38
Part 2, page 4
RP 20 Did not answer “Excludable” question for Storm 1: mark “yes” if majority of restoration days were excludable per IEEE Standard 1366 (2.5 beta definition)
38
Part 2, page 4
RP31 For both reported storms, please provide more specific information on Distribution damage and clarify whether there was any Transmission or Substation damage
30
Part 2, pages 5 and 7
RP35, RP55
For Storm 2 ,verify that there were no storm-related customer outages and restorations prior to the hour of the reported customer outage peak
30
18
Next Steps
1. Data Stewards will work with companies to address their data gaps, outliers and other issues
2. Insights Conference presentation will include an analysis of all storm activity in the community from 2007 to 2013, including: Updated Restoration Curves incorporating the 2013 major and
catastrophic storms Updated Correlation Graphs incorporating the 2013 major and
catastrophic storms Highlights of Emergency Response practice information collected this
year in the Distribution Reliability section of the questionnaire
Thank you for your Input and Participation!
19
Corporate OfficesCalifornia400 Continental Blvd. Suite 600El Segundo, CA 90245(310) 426-2790
Maryland3 Bethesda Metro Center Suite 700Bethesda, MD 20814(301) 961-1505
New York | Texas | Washington | Wisconsin
First Quartile Consulting is a utility-focused consultancy providing a full range of consulting services including continuous process improvement, change management, benchmarking and more. You can count on a proven process that assesses and optimizes your resources, processes, leadership management and technology to align your business needs with your customer’s needs.
Visit us at www.1stquartileconsulting.com | Follow our updates on LinkedIn
About 1QC
Satellite Offices
Debi McLain Debi.McLain@1QConsulting.com760-272-7277
Tim. SzybalskiTim.Szybalski@1QConsulting.com301-535-0590
Dave CanonDave.Canon@1qconsulting.com817-980-7909
Dave CarterDave.Carter@1qconsulting.com414-881-8641
Your Presenters
Ken Buckstaff Ken.Buckstaff@1QConsulting.com310-922-0783
Recommended