Presidential Elections and the Electoral College · The electoral college was a compromise...

Preview:

Citation preview

PresidentialElectionsandtheElectoralCollege

TrueorFalse?

2

Thecandidatewiththemostvotesiselectedpresident.

TrueorFalse?

3

Thecandidatewiththemostvotesiselectedpresident.

Answer:NotNecessarily—AskHillaryClinton

TotalPopularVotein2016Election:

Trump 62,979,636totalvotes(46.1%)

306ElectoralVotes

Clinton 65,844,610totalvotes(48.2%)

232ElectoralVotes

HistoricalBackground

TheframersoftheConstitutiondisagreedonhowtoelect presidentMajorConcerns:

*GeneralPublicuneducatedandUninformed*IntensecandidatepopularityinONEareacouldswayelection

OPTIONS:CongressionalselectionORDirectpopularelectionTheelectoralcollegewasacompromisecombiningfeaturesofbothapproaches.

3

Thereareatotalof538electoralvotes

Inorderforacandidatetowinalltheelectoralvotesofastate,acandidatemustwinamajorityofthepopularvote!

270ElectoralVotesareneededtowinthePresidency

ByTheNumbers:

RedStatesandBlueStates48 outofthe50 stateshavea“winnertakesall”method

Candidatesmaywinstatesbylopsidedornarrowmargins.

NebraskaandMainedivideuptheirvotesbasedonhowspecificcongressionaldistrictsvoted

Whatifnoonereceivesamajority?Ifnocandidatehasamajority:� theHouseofRepsselectsthepresidentfromamongthecandidateswiththemostelectoralvotes.

� Ifthishappens,eachstatehasonevote.�Happenedonlyonce!�1824

� TheSenateselectsthevicepresidentfromthetoptwovice-presidentialcandidates.

PopularVotev.theElectoralVote• Inacloserace,thepopular

votewinnermaynotwintheelectoralcollege.

• Electoralvotewinnerswholostthepopularvote:

– TrumpoverClinton2016

– BushoverGorein2000

– BenjaminHarrisonoverGroverClevelandin1888

– RutherfordB.HayesoverSamuelTildenin1876

BattlegroundorSwingStates

StatesbyPerCapitaElectoralCollegeVotes

ELECTORALCOLLEGE

PROSCONS• Resultsmorecertainwith

ElectoralCollege• Nosingleregiondominates

withElectoralCollege• Facilitatestwo-partysystem

stability• Directsmorepowerto

statesasvitalpartofsystem• Greaterinfluencetorural

areas,interestgroups,andminorities

• Undemocratic—majorityofUSmaynotfavorwinner

• Outdated—basedonelitistpoliticalconsiderations

• Swing/BattlegroundStatesgetalltheattention

• Maydiscouragevoting• Hinderschancesof3rd party

candidates• Smallstatesgetmorepower

percapita

In1992,RossPerotwonalmost19percentofthepopularvotebutnotonevoteintheElectoralCollege.

ProposalsforReform

• Eliminateelectorsbutstillcountelectoralvotes.• SplitElectoralVotesviacongressionaldistrictsasMaine

andNebraskado• Choosethepresidentbydirectpopularelection.

ShouldtheElectoralCollegebeAbolished?

Recommended