Jeff Glenn CB Richard Ellis Thursday March 19, 2009 2009 MARKET FORECAST: Capital Markets

Preview:

DESCRIPTION

CB Richard Ellis | Page 3 Raleigh – Durham Historical Transaction Volume Source: CB Richard Ellis

Citation preview

Jeff GlennCB Richard EllisThursday March 19, 2009

2009 MARKET FORECAST: Capital Markets

CB Richard Ellis | Page 2

What’s going on…?

CB Richard Ellis | Page 3

Raleigh – Durham Historical Transaction Volume

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 4

Raleigh – Durham Product Allocation (Millions)

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 5

Raleigh – Durham 2008 Quarterly Sales (Millions)

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 6

Raleigh – Durham 2008 Top 10 Sales Transactions

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 7

Raleigh – Durham Apartment Transaction Volume

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 8

Raleigh – Durham Apartment Buyer Distribution (Millions)

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 9

Raleigh – Durham Office Transaction Volume

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 10

Raleigh – Durham Office Buyer Distribution

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 11

Raleigh – Durham Retail Transaction Volume

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 12

Raleigh – Durham Retail Buyer Distribution (Millions)

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 13

Raleigh – Durham Warehouse/Flex Transaction Volume

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 14

Raleigh – Durham Warehouse/Flex Buyer Distribution (Millions)

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 15

Raleigh – Durham Total Buyer Distribution

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 16

Raleigh – Durham Total Seller Distribution

Source: CB Richard Ellis

CB Richard Ellis | Page 17

While Underwriting Standards Relaxed…

Source: JP Morgan, ING 2Q 2008

CB Richard Ellis | Page 18

Allowing Subordination Levels to Fall

CMBS Deal Subordination Levels

CB Richard Ellis | Page 19

Spreads Widen to Historic Levels

Bps Spread over Swaps

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1/2

1/16

1/30

2/13

2/27

3/12

3/26 4/

9

4/23 5/

7

5/21 6/

4

6/18 7/

2

7/16

7/30

8/13

8/27

9/10

9/24

10/8

10/2

2

11/5

11/1

9

AAA.4AAA Cash Spreads

Lenders are rational and have choices. So long as their choices (buying paper in the secondary market) are more attractive than origination, they will not originate.

Source: Markit, Morgan Stanley

CB Richard Ellis | Page 20

Spreads Widened…Why?

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association 2008

CB Richard Ellis | Page 21

Estimated Quarterly Mortgage Originations

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association

CB Richard Ellis | Page 22

Source: RealPoint 2008

Maturing CMBS Mortgages

$0

$20,000,000,000

$40,000,000,000

$60,000,000,000

$80,000,000,000

$100,000,000,000

$120,000,000,000

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015$0

$20,000,000,000

$40,000,000,000

$60,000,000,000

$80,000,000,000

$100,000,000,000

$120,000,000,000

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

Healthcare Hotel Industrial Mixed (Other) Multifamily Office Retail

CB Richard Ellis | Page 23

$3.4 Trillion Debt Outstanding

Source: CBRE Torto Wheaton Research 2008

U.S.- How Much Are We Talking About?

CB Richard Ellis | Page 24

Rates Help Out!

CB Richard Ellis | Page 25

2009: What’s In & What’s Out

CHANGING MARKET DYNAMICSIN OUTOn-Book Lending CMBS

Conservative Leverage High Octane Capital Stack

Equity In-Deal Cash Out Financing

Risk Based Pricing Inefficient Pricing of Capital

Correspondent & Relationship Lending Loan Brokerage

High Touch Loan Servicer Securitized/Impersonal Servicer

Amortization- 30 Year Schedule Amortization- Interest Only

Reserves Funded in Cash No Funded Escrow

450+/- Spreads 100+/- Spreads

CB Richard Ellis | Page 26

New Capital StackMarket Is De-Leveraging

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

2007 2008Loan Breakout

Percen

tage L

TV

EquityPref. EquityMezzanineB-NoteA-Note

Equity, 2%Pref. Equity,

8%

Mezzanine, 10%

B-Note, 15%

A-Note, 65%

A-Note, 45%

B-Note, 15%

Mezzanine, 15%

Equity, 25%

CB Richard Ellis | Page 27

Why Are Values Going Down?

CB Richard Ellis | Page 28

With Buyers Re-Trenching

Source: CB Richard Ellis

Raleigh – Durham

CB Richard Ellis | Page 29

How High Will Cap Rates Go?

4

5

6

7

8

9

1019

86.1

1986

.419

87.3

1988

.219

89.1

1989

.419

90.3

1991

.219

92.1

1992

.419

93.3

1994

.219

95.1

1995

.419

96.3

1997

.219

98.1

1998

.419

99.3

2000

.220

01.1

2001

.420

02.3

2003

.220

04.1

2004

.420

05.3

2006

.220

07.1

2007

.420

08.3

2009

.220

10.1

2010

.420

11.3

2012

.220

13.1

2013

.420

14.3

Base Spiral

Appraisal Cap-Rate, %

Source: TWR Investment Outlook, Winter 2009

Forecast

CB Richard Ellis | Page 30

What To Do

Focus on Your Tenants Right-Size Expense Base Underwrite to Positive Leverage “Partner” with Your Lender Keep the Faith

Recommended