How the simple measurements of distances and positions of planets and stars have led to great...

How the simple measurements of distances and positions of planets and stars have led to great discoveries in science

2005 is the World Year of PHYSICS

100th anniversary of Albert Einstein’s “miraculous year” of 1905

March 1905: the quantum nature of light

May 1905: Brownian motion shows the existence of atoms and molecules

June 1905: Special Relativity as a theory of space, time, and motion

General Relativity

Developed in 1907-1915 in close collaboration with mathematicians: Grossmann, Hilbert, Levi-Civita

... in all my life I have not laboured nearly so hard, and I have become imbued with great respect for mathematics, the subtler part of which I had in my simple-mindedness regarded as pure luxury until now.

Marcel Grossmann David Hilbert Tullio Levi-Civita

Measuring distances: a surveyor’s method

an apparent shift of the object on the sky when viewed from different locations

A surveyor’s method in space: measuring the parallax effect

In 1672 Giovanni Cassini together with Jean Richter (1630-1696) made parallel observations of the Mars parallax in Paris (France) and Cayenne (French Guiana, N. coast of South America)

They were also able to determine the solar parallax as ~ 9 arcseconds and find the distance to the Sun (Astronomical Unit) as 140,000,000 km.Current value is 8.8 arcseconds, or 149,597,892 km.

One needs larger baseline than the distance between the eyes to measure the distance to cosmic objects!

Parallax angle A

A

BD

B

D

The angle between these two lines is 2.5 degrees

The angle of 9 arcseconds is 1000 times smaller!

1 arcsecond = (1 degree)/3600

One needs baselines larger than the size of the Earth!

Aristarchus of Samos (~310-230 BC)

Using the distance between the Earth and the Moon as a baseline

Using the Earth’s orbit as a baseline

Aristotle (384-322 BC) could not find measurable parallax, so he concluded the Earth was not moving

Even for the nearest stars the parallax is 0.3 second of arc.This is 10,000 times smaller than 1 degree!

Retrograde (westward) motion of a planet occurs when the Earth passes the planet.

The Copernican Revolution

Nicolaus Copernicus (1473 – 1543):

Heliocentric Universe (Sun in the Center)

1. There is no one centre in the universe.2. The Earth's centre is not the centre of the universe.3. The centre of the universe is near the sun.4. The distance from the Earth to the sun is imperceptible compared with the distance to the stars.5. The rotation of the Earth accounts for the apparent daily rotation of the stars.6. The apparent annual cycle of movements of the sun is caused by the Earth revolving round it.7. The apparent retrograde motion of the planets is caused by the motion of the Earth from which one observes.

Church cleric, but rejected a 2000-yr old paradigm

Seven axioms written in a pamphlet “Little Commentary” (1514)

Born: 19 Feb 1473 in Torun, PolandDied: 24 May 1543 in Frombork, Poland

Johannes Kepler (1571 – 1630)

Kepler’s Laws of Planetary Motion1.The orbits of the planets are ellipses with the

sun at one focus.

Eccentricity e = c/a

c

A New Era of Science

I. If F = 0, velocity constv

Change of motion = acceleration tva /

II. Fam

Acceleration (a) is the change of a body’s velocity (v) with time (t):

1. Acceleration in the conventional sense (i.e. increasing speed)

a = v/t

Different cases of acceleration:

Velocity and acceleration are directed quantities (vectors)!

3. Change of the direction of motion (e.g., in circular motion)

2. Deceleration (i.e. decreasing speed)

a

v

A ball experiences acceleration there must be a force!

Curved path of the Moon there must be some force!

Newton’s law of gravitation

Newton’s Cannon

Clockwork universe

Measurements of parallaxes of the Sun, Moon, planets and stars seemed to fit Newton’s theory amazingly well …

The advance of the perihelion of Mercury

One little speck on the brilliant face of Newton’s theory:

Mercury: the closest planet to the Sun

Sun

MercuryPerihelion = position closest to the sun

Aphelion = position furthest away

from the sun

Perihelion: 46 million km; Aphelion: 70 million km

Mercury's perihelion precession: 5600.73 arcseconds per century

Newtonian perturbations from other planets: 5557.62 arcseconds per century

Remains unexplained: 43 arcseconds/century (Le Verrier 1855)

In reality the orbits deviate from elliptical:

Urbain Le Verrier 1811-1877

Predicted the presence and position of Neptunefrom irregularities in Uranus’s orbit

Neptune was found in 1846 exactly at the predicted position

In 1855 Le Verrier found that the perihelion of Mercury advanced slightly more than the Newtonian theory predicted.

He and others tried to explain it with a new planet Vulcan, new asteroid belt, etc.

In the eyes of all impartial men, this discovery [Neptune] will remain one of the most magnificent triumphs of theoretical astronomy …

Arago

I do not know whether M. Le Verrier is actually the most detestable man in France, but I am quite certain that he is the most detested.

A contemporary

Problem with Action at a Distance

Direct, instantaneous connection between cause and effect!

By the beginning of the XX century, it became clear that Newtonian gravity has other problems

m1m2

0221

21 rr

mGmFF

1F

2F

If ball 1 moves, ball 2 instantaneously feels it.

Faster than light propagation??

Newton’s theory is a weak-gravity limit of a more general theory: General Relativity

Even in the weak gravity of the Earth and the Sun, there are measurable deviations from Newtonian mechanics and gravitation law!

• Precession of Mercury’s perihelion

• Bending of light by the Sun’s gravity

General Relativity predicts new effects, completely absent in the Newton’s theory: black holes, event horizon, gravitational waves.

Einstein’s idea:

Gravity is a strange force. It has a unique property:

M

m

R

2R

mMGF

2R

MG

m

Fa

All bodies in the same point in space experience the same acceleration!

Acceleration of Gravity

Acceleration of gravity is independent of the mass of the falling object!

Iron ball

Wood ball

This means that in the freely-falling elevator cabin you don’t feel any effects of gravity! You and all objects around you experience the same acceleration.

In outer space you can imitate the effect of gravity by acceleration.

"You mighta seen a house fly, maybe even a superfly, but you ain't never seen a donkey fly!"

Donkey

In 1907, Einstein was preparing a review of special relativity when he suddenly wondered how Newtonian gravitation would have to be modified to fit in with special relativity. At this point there occurred to Einstein, described by him as the happiest thought of my life , namely that an observer who is falling from the roof of a house experiences no gravitational field. He proposed the Equivalence Principle as a consequence:-

... we shall therefore assume the complete physical equivalence of a gravitational field and the corresponding acceleration of the reference frame. This assumption extends the principle of relativity to the case of uniformly accelerated motion of the reference frame.

Equivalence Principle

Immediate consequences of the Equivalence Principle:

• Bending of light in the gravitational field

• Time flow and frequency of light are changed in the gravitational field

Acceleration a = gravity gc

The bulb emits flashes of light 2 times per second

An observer on the floor receives flashes faster than 2 times per second

First observed on the Earth by Pound and Rebka 1960: relative frequency shift of 10-15 over the height of 22 m.

Light should be bent in the gravitational field

If gravity can be eliminated by motion, no special force of gravity is needed!

How to explain that in the absence of any force the trajectories are not straight lines?

Because space and time are curved!

The force of gravity is actually the acceleration you feel when you move through space-time

M

m

R1

21

1 R

MGa

All bodies experience the same acceleration, but only in a small region of space. In another region this acceleration is different. Time flows with a different rate, and paths are bent differently in these two regions.

R2

22

2 R

MGa

Space-time gets curved by masses. Objects traveling in curved space-time have their paths deflected, as if a force has acted on them.

Main idea:

“Curvature” of time means that the time flows with a different rate in different points in space

"Matter tells spacetime how to bend and spacetime returns the complement by telling matter how to move."

John Wheeler

The shortest path between two cities is not a straight line

Shortest paths are called geodesics; they are not straight lines!

Low density star

High density star

About 1912 Einstein realized that the geometry of our world should be non-Euclidean.

He consulted his friend Grossmann who was able to tell Einstein of the important developments of Riemann, Ricci and Levi-Civita.

G.F.B. Riemann(1826-1866)

When Planck visited Einstein in 1913 and Einstein told him the present state of his theories Planck said:

As an older friend I must advise you against it for in the first place you

will not succeed, and even if you succeed no one will believe you.

Several versions of Einstein’s GR in 1913-1914 were wrong.

Only in November 1915, after correspondence with Levi-Civita and Hilbert, Einstein published a paper with correct equations.

Hilbert also published correct equations, in fact 5 days earlier than Einstein.

On the 18th November Einstein made a discovery about which he wrote For a few days I was beside myself with joyous excitement . He explained the advance of the perihelion of Mercury with his theory.

Bending of light

Two British expeditions in 1919 confirmed Einstein’s prediction.

The shift was about 2 seconds of arc, as predicted

Gravitational lensing

Gallery of lenses (Hubble Space Telescope)

A black hole is a region of space-time from which nothing can escape, even light (first suggested by Laplace in 1796).

Black holes

22 2

2

1

c

GMR

R

GMmmc s

s

Derivation is wrong and picture is wrong, but the result is correct

Schwarzschild radius

2

2

c

GMRs

To make a black hole from a body of mass M, one needs to squeeze it below its Schwarzschild’s radius

Rs

K. Schwarzschild

Schwarzschild radius: event horizon for a nonrotating body

No signals can reach an outside observer from inside the event horizon! This is a point-of-no-return for everything that crosses it.

The curvature of a 2D slice of a spherically symmetric black hole

Curvature becomes infinite as we approach the singularity r =0

Gravitational bending of light paths around a black hole

Approaching a black hole

Circling around a black hole

Time dilatation

rR

tt

s

o

1

t

t0

As measured by a distant observer, clocks slow down when approaching a massive object

22 1 dtr

Rds s

Tidal forces and contraction of space squeeze and stretch the astronaut. Lateral pressure is 100 atm at a distance of 100 Rs from the event horizon

Black holes are NOT big cosmic bathtub drains!

2R

GMag

Far from a black hole R >> Rs (weak field): Newtonian gravity law holds

Approaching a black hole R ~ Rs (strong field): gravity pull runs away

RR

R

GMa

s

g

12

If our Sun collapses into a black hole, we won’t see any difference in the gravitational pull (but it will be VERY cold)

Black holes in the Universe

1. Formation of galaxies

2. Collapse of massive stars

3. Early Universe?

How to find the object that does not emit any radiation?

By its effect on nearby objects

The Galactic Center

Wide-angle optical view of the GC region

Galactic center

Our view (in visible light) towards the galactic center (GC) is heavily obscured by gas and dust

Extinction by 30 magnitudes

Only 1 out of 1012 optical photons makes its way from the GC towards Earth!

If one looks at this region with big telescopes and near-infrared cameras one can see lots of stars. If one takes pictures every year it seems that some stars are moving very fast (up to 1500 kilometers per second). The fastest stars are in the very center - the position marked by the radio nucleus Sagittarius A* (cross).

Distance between stars is less that 0.01 pc

A Black Hole at the Center of Our Galaxy

By following the orbits of individual stars near the center of the Milky Way, the mass of the central black hole could be determined to ~ 2.6 million solar masses

Black hole vicinity is probably very messy …

Cores of other galaxies show an accretion disk with a possible black hole

Second scenario of black-hole formation: Death of massive starsDeath of massive stars

“All hope abandon, ye who enter here” Dante

Gravitational collapse of the iron core

Supernova explosion

Mass transfer in a binary system

;2

3

21 P

aMM

a – in AUP – in yearsM1+M2 – in solar masses

Binary systems

If we can calculate the total mass and measure the mass of a normal star independently, we can find the mass of an unseen companion

Still, this is an indirect evidence. Proving the existence of black holes remains one of the greatest problems in physics.

1912

You cannot tell the difference between acceleration and gravity!