Emerging Opportunities in Chemical Safety Information ·  · 2016-04-12Emerging Opportunities in...

Emerging Opportunities in Chemical Safety Information

Ralph Stuart

Chemical Hygiene Officer, Keene State College

Leah McEwen Chemistry Librarian, Cornell University

Evan Bolton

Lead Scientist, National Center for Biotechnology Information

December, 2015

Abstract

•  Abstract:Publicandprofessionalconcernaboutchemicalsafetyinlaboratorieshavemountedoverthelastdecadeasaseriesofincidentsinresearch,teachingandhighschoolse8ngshaveledtoseriousinjuriesanddeaths.Inresponse,severalACScommi?eesanddivisionshaveprovidedguidanceondevelopingriskassessmentsforlaboratoryprocedures.However,thisstrategyfacestwospecificchallenges:–  1)convenientaccesstoreliablechemicalsafetyinformaGon;and–  2)lackofsystemaGcguidancetousethisinformaGontoidenGfy

appropriatehazardmanagementstrategies.•  ThiswebinarwilldescribecollaboraGveeffortsbetweentheCINFandCHAS

toaddressthesechallenges.Specificresources,suchasPubChem’sLaboratoryChemicalSafetySummarieswillbedescribed,aswellaslogictoolswhichcansupporttheuseoftheseresources.OpportuniGesforpartnershipsforfurtherimprovingthesesourcesandtoolswillbediscussed.

RBS

Today'sTopics

1.  OverviewofLabChemistrySafetyLogic2.  AShortHistoryofElectronicLabSafetyInformaGon3.  TheLibrarian'sRoleinSupporGngSafetyLogic4.  ACaseStudy:PubChemLCSSs5.  Ge8ngInvolved6.  LookingForward

RBS

RisingConcernsaboutChemicalSafetyintheLab

The Research Lab

The Teaching Lab

RBS

2011

2014

The Issue of Laboratory Safety Culture

2012

2014

AreWeLearning?DemonstraGonmethanolfiresat:1.   BeaconSchool

NewYorkCity,January20142.   DiscoveryMuseum

Reno,Nevada,September20143.   STRIVEPreparatorySchool

Denver,Colorado,September20144.   CubScoutgroup

Raymond,Illinois,October,20145.   LincolnParkHighSchool

Chicago,November,20146.   LincolnHighSchool

Tallahassee,Florida,May20157.   WoodsonHighSchool

Fairfax,VA,November2015

RBS

WhatShouldWeBeLearning?

1.   ReplacingtheHazard:useadifferentdemonstraGonmethod

2.   EngineeringControls:inthelaboratory,primarilyvenGlaGon

3.   TrainingandOversight:forbothdemonstratorsandaudience

4.   PersonalProtecSveEquipment:gloves,glassesorsafetyshieldsappropriatetothechemistryandthescenario

5.   EmergencyPlanningandResponse:bothequipmentandtraining

RBS

TheConceptualLesson:SafeChemicalUserequiresaSystem

Managing chemical hazards in the lab involves organizing 5 strategies into a system:

1.  Hazard Reduction 2.  Engineering Controls 3.  Training and Oversight 4.  Personal Protective Equipment 5.  Emergency Planning and

Environmental Protection This approach is appropriate for chemical risks within the scope of the OSHA lab standard. Other uses of chemicals and other hazards require more extensive analysis.

AdjusttheChemistrytoMinimize

theHazards

EngineeringControls

Trainingand

Oversight

PersonalProtecGveEquipment

EmergencyPlanningandEnvironmentalProtecGon

RBS

TheRealityoftheLabSeVng•  Safetyinacademicresearchlabsisa

longstandingconcern;in1964,theACSCommi?eeonChemicalSafetychairwrote:“Scien'ficresearchinthecampuslaboratoriesisoneofthemostexci'ngac'vi'esintheworldofideas,andoneoftheleastorderlyintheworldoforganiza'ons.”

•  Riskmanagementstartswithriskassessment;butlabriskschangeconGnuouslyandunpredictably

•  SoweneedtodevelopflexibleriskassessmenttoolsandappropriateeducaSonfortheiruse.

RBS

A recent census of lab hazards at a major research institution; these proportions are changing rapidly.

Chemicals (80%)

Biological Agents (40%)

Radiation (25%)

EmergingRiskAssessmentToolsforLabHazards

Thesystemissupportedbyemergingtools.Threekeytoolsare:

–  TheGloballyHarmonizedSystem(GHS)–  TheRAMPparadigmfromLaboratorySafetyforChemistryStudents(HillandFinster)andACSCPT

–  Iden&fyingandEvalua&ngHazardsinResearchLaboratoriesfromtheACS

RBS

The RAMP model for Building a Lab Safety System

ManagingChemicalSafetyinvolves6keysteps:1.   EHSCulture2.   HazardIden'fica'on3.   RiskAssessment4.   ManagingSafety5.   PlanningforEmergencies6.   Protec'ngtheEnvironmentOrganizingthesetoolsrequiresapartnershipbetweenlabworkersandtheinsGtuGon.

TheBoXomLine:RiskAssessmentisaResearchProcess

TheRAMPmodelofChemicalSafety

ACRLInformaSonLiteracySkills

Safetyculture ScopetheInquiry

Recognizehazards CollectData

Assessrisks EvaluatetheInformaGon

Managesafety ApplyDatatoMakeDecisions

Plan,ProtectShareLessonsLearned

DocumenttheProcessandOutcome

RBS

IntheRealWorld,InformaSonSystemsareChangingAsWell

•  1990–1998:Web1.0–  datadeliveryviae-mailandhtml;groupcommunicaSonbecomesconvenient

•  1998–2003:Web1.5–  searchenginespromotediscoveryandcross-disciplinarycollaboraSon

•  2003–2010:Web2.0–  SomuchinformaGonisavailablethatinformaGonbrokersarenecessary

–  Thesebrokersdevelopedsiloedpla[ormstosupportspecificusecases RBS

ExamplesofLabSafetyWeb2.0pla[orms

•  Institutional data: lab rooms and worker rosters

•  Safety training: requirements and records

•  Risk data collections: inventories, SDS’s

•  PPE Wizards •  Lab ventilation:

tracking in building management systems

RBS

Mainframes Personal computers

2010–2015:Web2.5

•  Changingtechnologies,userexpectaSons,andtheincreasingcomplexityoftheinterdisciplinarylabworldbrokeWeb2.0efforts.

•  PartofthereasonforthisispoorinformaSonmanagementpracGces(compeGngframeworks;poorprovenancepracGces,hightrainingcosts)ledtounstructuredcommunicaGonthatdoesnotscale,isnottransferablebetweenlabsandisnotsustainable.

Twitter traffic: 2010-2015 RBS

TheVisionBeyond2015•  Theemergingwebfavors:

–  Sitesaredesignedasanodesinthenetworkratherthancontrollersofthenetwork

–  ConsideraGonofContextualUsability(useoftheinformaGonbeyondthescreen)

–  EffecGveopensourcepeercuraSon,buildingone-maillistsandWikipedia

•  Whatisemergingisaflexiblystructuredecosystemofdata,workflowtoolsanddomainexper&semappedtotheessenSalcommonaliSesoftheusecaseandcontent,connectedbygoodinformaSonmanagementpracSces

Wikipedia articles

RBS

InformaSonConnecSons

SDS Search and Product Safety Center

http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/

SIRI MSDS Index

Biological Safety Data Sheets

CHEMINDEX FREE on the WEB!

International Chemical Safety Cards (ICSC)

Right to Know Hazardous Substance Fact Sheets

Pathogen Safety Data Sheets and Risk Assessment

NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards

TOXLINE: A TOXNET DATABASE

SDS and Chemical Information from Manufacturers

ChemIDplus: A TOXNET DATABASE

https://www.dol.gov/

http://www.csb.gov/ Does each organization (or scientist) use their own favorite data source(s)? Do these various data sources provide consistent information (gaps, errors)? How does the health and safety decision change with different information (or lack of it)?

LRM

ManyDifferentNeeds

LRM

SafetyOfficersLibrarians

FacultyDepartments

StudentsResearchers

{ InsStuSons:ResearchFundingRegulatory

http://www.betterlivingwithreiki.com

~ ~

~

Stakeholders:AcademicView

LaboratoryChemicalSafetySummaries

LRM

DataSourceofDataSources

Acetone .. seven sources CDC NIOSH, NJ HSFS, DOL OSHA, ILO ICSC, NLM HSDB, CDC ATSDR, EPA/NOAA CAMEO

One chemical .. many useful sources Each resource has some overlaps Each resource has unique content

What if you have ten chemicals? What if you have ten sources for each? How much time will one spend comparing these?

By integrating these, PubChem acts as a one stop shop for

data needs with links back to primary data

sources

LRM

PubChemDataFieldsMappedtoLCSS

acetone

LRM

LaboratoryChemicalSafetySummary(LCSS)Form(NRC)

PubChemLCSS

LRM

FindingLCSSsatPubChem

https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/lcss/ LRM

PubChemLCSSasadatastream

LRM

h?ps://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/idexchange/idexchange.cgi

hXps://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/acetone#datasheet=lcss

SafetyOfficeUseCases

•  Inventorysystems(consolidateddatastream)

•  Chemicalprofiling(safetyplanning)–  incidentanalysis–  reacGvityclassificaGon

•  Researchtoolforsafetysystemstudies

•  ThesystemwillbeusedtoprovidesuggesGonsforsafetymeasures.

Inventory Requirements: •  GHS labeling with pictograms, signal words

and hazard statement codes •  SDS from manufacturer or equivalent for

‘house solutions’ (including incompatibilities) •  Identifiers, preferably with concentration and

physical form specification

LRM

ChemistryEducatorUseCases

•  Chemicalprofilingforlabcurriculum(downloadLCSSsforchemicallists)

•  TeachingliteracyinRAMPprocess(searchingforinformaGonandcomparingdatasources)

•  Analyzingproceduresforchemical,equipmentandprocesshazards

LRM

Need for Targeted Information: •  Identification of reagents, products •  Reactivity and associated hazard analysis •  Associated exposure control information •  Alternative reagents or reaction pathways •  Iterative over repeated experiments

•  Experimentalplanning•  Capturinglabrisk

assessmentsandanylessonslearned

•  PublicaGonofsafetynotesaspartofSupplementalInformaGon

•  UseofsafetyinfotoolsanddocumentaGonpromotessaferesearchgroupculture

ChemistryResearcherUseCases

LRM

ChemicalVendorUseCases

•  RequirementtodisseminatechemicalsafetyinformaGon(e.g.,SDS)

•  VisibilityofcataloginformaGon

LRM

InformaSonPracScesthatSupportthisVision

•  Ontology:themachinereadablesystemofdefiniGonsandlinksbetweenthosedefiniGons

•  AnnotaSon:thehumanprocessofprioriGzingelementsandmakingdecisionsbasedontheavailableresourcesandthegoaloftheproject

EEB

InformaSonPracScesthatSupportthisVision

•  Whatdoesthisgiveyou?–  Improvedquery/analysis

GotoawebsearchengineTypeinanaturallanguagequeryGetananswer

Whatistheboilingpointofbenzene?

EEB

CalltoAcSon!

•  ProfessionalSafetyCommunity•  ChemicalEducatorCommunity•  ChemicalInformaGonCommunity

–  InformaGonScienGsts– Librarians&ServiceProviders

EEB

SafetyProfessionalInput•  Data

– Whatisneeded/availableorshouldbeadded/removed?

•  Use–  Aredataaccessmechanisms/formatsappropriate?

•  Review–  Isanythingamiss?ChemicalusecasevariaGon?

•  AnnotaGon–  ShareyourannotaGonandhelpimprovethatavailable

•  Tellafriend–  Expandingthecommunitywillincreaseimpact

EEB

ChemicalEducaSonInput

•  Commonchemicallistsandlabprocedures– Aretheycovered?– Mixturesvs.purechemicals?

•  RAMPexercisestomodel–  IstheinformaGonavailabletosupportRiskAssessmentsastheyarepracGcedandtaught?

•  ConsideraGonsuniquetonon-researchlabexercisesanddemonstraGons?

EEB

CheminformaScians…

•  Dataingest,management,structure•  Grouping/classificaGon,terminology/synonymy•  Textmining&analysis•  Clean,saniGze,validate•  Dotheabove…

orelse…(horror!)

EEB

ChemistryLibrarians

•  Suggestdatasources– MOREMOREMORE!!!

•  PromoteLiteracy –  PromoGngawarenessanduseofsources

–  EncouragingevaluaGonofdataandprovenance

•  Developsafetydatare-usescenarios–  Outlineservices,includingannotaGon

–  DocumentinstrucGonsforaccessingdata

–  AssistinestablishinguseinvariousinsGtuGons

•  Teachinglabs•  Researchlabs,ELNsystems,etc.

•  EHSandothercampusserviceoffices EEB

RelatedInformaSonEfforts

•  IUPACInChIprojects– QRcode(integratedwithbarcodescanners)– Mixturesextension(purity,components,etc.)– Lookupservice(protocolsforfederatedsearch)

•  PistoiaChemicalSafetyLibraryiniGaGve•  Others(orenwithvariableusecases)

EEB

FutureWork

1.  Develop process descriptors which can data mine the literature to identify process hazards (CINF professionals)

2.  Develop a Chemical Safety Ontology (joint effort of CINF and EHS professionals)

3.  Develop a crowd annotation approach for EHS professionals, potentially hosted by PubChem, an institution and/or service (TBD)

4.  Lessons learned framework RBS

TheFuture:OngoingCollaboraSonwithaVarietyofPartners

RBS

General news about the project's progress can be found at http://www.irampp.org

References

1.  PubChem Laboratory Chemical Safety Summary, Kim et al. Fall 2015 ACS CHED CCCE Newsletter http://confchem.ccce.divched.org/2015FallCCCENLP3

2.  The Safety “Use Case”: Co-Developing Chemical Information Management and Laboratory Safety Skills, Stuart and McEwen, Journal of Chemical Education http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.jchemed.5b00511

3.  Meeting the Google Expectation for Chemical Safety Information: Chemical Risk Assessment in Academic Research and Teaching, Chemistry International, McEwen and Stuart http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/ci.2015.37.issue-5-6/ci-2015-0505/ci-2015-0505.xml?format=INT

4.  Safety Data Sheets: Information that Could Save Your Life, Rohrig, ChemMatters Magazine. http://www.acs.org/content/acs/en/education/resources/highschool/chemmatters/past-issues/2015-2016/december-2015/safety-data-sheets.html RBS

ThankstoManyColleagues!

•  AmericanChemicalSociety(ACS)ProfessionalMemberDivisionsofChemicalHealth&Safety(CHAS),ChemicalInformaGon(CINF),ChemicalEducaGon(CHED)

•  ACSCommi?eeonChemicalSafety(CCS)SafetyAdvisoryPanel(SAP)

•  NaGonalLibraryofMedicine(NLM)PubChemTeam

•  InsGtuGonalCollaboratorsUniversityofCaliforniaUniversityofNewHampshire

RBS

QuesSons?

U. Minnesota 2014-06-17