View
217
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
1/20
Caseopea
The Future ofContent
Search & Discovery
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
2/20
Discovery - the pre-trial phase in which each party can request andsubpoena documents and other evidence from other parties
e-Discovery Discovery of documents in electronic form - ESI(Electronically Stored Information)
e-Discovery was officially enforced fall 2006 through several amendmentsto Federal Rules of Civil Procedures (FCRP - 2006)
The Arena
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
3/20
Searching, reviewing and analyzing admissible content
Content subjected to Discovery is growing in volume and complexity
Millions of documents - mainly emails
Hundreds of gigabytes - terabytes of data
Diverse sources and forms:documents, memos, email, chats, spreadsheets, databases, web pages
Dispersed context need to analyze multiple documents in a shared and
unfolding context.
Highly casual and temporal media (emails, chats)
The Scene
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
4/20
Sky-rocketing costs (An average commercial case can cost $10-20 million)
Significant fear factor extreme costs of errors. Low accuracy = high risk(Courts can be very unforgiving, imposing fines of $10s of millions)
Prolonged disruptive processes(3-6 Months of major disruption to daily operations)
Enterprises are forced to settle unfavorably just to avoid costs
Automation is the only practical solution
The process of producing admissible material has becomeintractable
The Pain
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
5/20
$12 billionOverall Expenditureon e-Discovery litigation support in 2007 up 23% from $9.7 billion in 2006.Expected growth well over 20% for the next 2-3 years (IDC)
$3 billion Spent on Software & Servicesin2007(Socha-Gelbmann). Estimated to exceed$4 billion in 2009. Forrester predicts$4.8 billion by 2011
$10-15 millionAverage costofReview & Analysisin commercial cases.
$10 millionper case Charged on average by e-Discovery outsourcing service providers.
Automatic clustering tools charge $10,000-$30,000 per gigabyte of scanned data
$250,000minimum tag price for enterprise tools licenses pricing climbs to over $millionfor top marketplatforms.
A lucrative and fast growing market
The Market
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
6/20
Document
ManagementSystem
Submission
1,000,.. TB 2TB15GB
1/2 Mil Pages
50GB
500K Pages
(Hosting Selection)
$50,000 for Year $15,000 $6-8 Million
The e-Discovery value chain Caseopea Analyzer
Collection andIdentification
Pre processing Review andanalysis
Production
Volume
Cost
The Opportunity
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
7/20
Review & Analysis accounts for 80%-90% of e-Discovery cost
Better automation can save 60%-80% of cost - average saving of$3-5 millions per case
The Opportunity
e-Discovery is considered as the forefront of enterprise mail search -a market that is growing at even a greater pace.
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
8/20
There is a dire need for a better solution
Army of reviewers expensive, slow, error proneA vast coordination problem: a highly iterative, repetitive process requiring continuoussharing of discovered facts
Existing search tools (keywords, boolean operators) provide limited support(Stocks AND (Shares OR Options) AND (NOT OR Warrants ?#!#!$& ..)
Current filtering techniques still generate around 70% of irrelevant content
Existing analysis tools (clustering, classification), leave too much for manual analysisComplex visual maps of repeating textual patterns provide little insight into real content
Current Solutions
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
9/20
Staff warning about dubious financial loans
email X: We argued with Paul about extending Sprouts Corps credit, Liz expressed her reservations
email Y: Sprouts request for another grace period got me really worried
email Z: Accounting are concerned about Sprouts ability to pay back its creditors.
email X: I lent Mary my laptop
email Z: I wished she would listen to my warnings about taking the office holiday loan
Searching an email collection for:
Caseopea will find:
Caseopea will filter out:
The Meaning Beyond the Words
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
10/20
Dramatically reduces e-Discovery costs
Facilitates effective knowledge and sharing
Significantly speeds up the e-Discovery process
Minimizes errors
Facilitates effective exploration / investigation of opponents material
Capturing the meaning beyond words
Caseopea
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
11/20
Truly comprehends text - Combines linguistics, semantics, and common sense.
Analyzes documents progressively - from start to end (much like humans do)Analyzes content across multiple passages and documents
Understands free language queries (including full passages)
Extracts events and facts
Incorporates meta data (time,location, identity) into content analysis
Supports fully federated search & analysis for expert users (workflows, rules, logic, history)
Easily customizable (easy expansion with case-specific knowledge)
A functional drilldown
Caseopea
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
12/20
Document ManagementSystems
Autonomy, ,AXS, Guidance, HP, IBM,LexisNexis,Microsoft, Symantec
Collection, Preservation tools Autonomy, AXS, Guidance, Fios, FTI, Isys, Symantec
Analysis and Review tools Attenex, Autonomy, AXS, Clearwell, CT-Summation,LexisNexis, FTI, MetaLincs, Recommind, Symantec
Review and Productionservice providers
Autonomy, Case Central, Fios, Guidance, H5, LexisNexis,KPMG, Kroll Ontrack, Stratify
Overall service providersservice provider
Autonomy, EED Inc,FTI,Guidance,LexisNexis,KPMG,Kroll Ontrack, Stratify
Review platforms are geared towards production of discovery material,
Analyzing your opponents material is even harder!
[Competitors] [Competitors and Potential Partners] [Potential Partners]
Market Landscape
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
13/20
Attenex Autonomy Zantaz Clearwell Lexis Nexis CaseopeaMain analysis capability Clustering Indexing Clustering Indexing Full Text
Understanding
Find all relevantcontent (Recall).
M M M L H
Find only relevant
content (Precision).L+ L+ L L- H
Query Capabilities Nouns / Idioms Nouns / Idioms Boolean Boolean Full passages
Fact Extraction no no no no H
Event Extraction no no no no H
Customization L+ M L L H
Knowledge Sharing LM M LM M HCase Exploration L L+ no L H
Speed H H L M LM
Ease of Setup H L- H L- H
Competitive Advantage
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
14/20
On Site - Search, Review and Analysis platform (site license) Add-on to document management systems Search (Guided, Unguided)
Extraction / Tagging Monitoring Evidence discovery in responsive content Services (Consulting, Integration)
SAAS (pay per case / volume)
Independent Review & Analysis service Co-operation with established outsourcing service providers revenuesharing
Support for currently uncovered market niche, review & analysis ofopponents EDD material (suing parties)
Business Model
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
15/20
July 2007 Autonomy acquired Zantaz for $375 million.
November 2007IronMountainacquiredStratify for$158 million.
December 2007SeagateacquiredMetaLincsfor$80 million.
June 2008FTI Consulting acquiredAttenexfor$90 million.
July 2008 InterwovenacquiredDiscovery Mining inc for$60 million.
August 2008Edmond Scientific Co (ESC) acquiredAccess Litigations foranundisclosed amount (estimated at $50-60 million).
Recent Acquisitions
Technology providers are hot targets for M&A
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
16/20
Semantic Web Search(TTM 3-4 years)
Generic email Search (Enterprise and Consumers)(TTM 2-3 years)
e-Discovery(TTM - 1 year)
Strategic Evolution
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
17/20
Taming
e-Discovery
Thanks for your time
Caseopea
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
18/20
Extracted from the 2008 Socha-Gelbmann Survey
Market Size
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
19/20
Software & Services revenues
Market Size
7/29/2019 E-Discovery Future Trends
20/20
100 Gigabyte data - 1.5 millions documents
Attorney review capacity (unassisted) 10-30 documents p/h, rate per hour $200
Hours needed for review 50,000 total cost $10 million
Conventional review and analysis tools reduce time and costs by 20% - saving $2 million.Saving achieved through basic filtering and customized review tools (reducing the number of documentsfor review and facilitating a more convenient manual review)
Current filtering technology still leaves reviewers with an average of70% irrelevant data.
Higher and better automationcan achieve 60%-80% saving
(achieved through intelligent search, deep culling and case-base content extraction)
(Courtesy of a leading Review & Analysis tools vendor)
A Typical Showcase
Recommended