Behavior: Levels of Explanation

Behavior: Levels of Explanation

Recall N. Tinbergen

Proximate: Mechanisms (How? Most Biology)

Ultimate: Adaptive Significance (Why?)

Example: Compare Levels

1

Male White-crowned SparrowZonotrichia leucophrys

Breeding Territoriality:Aggression, Mate Attraction,Foraging, Care of Young

2

Territoriality: How?

Spring: Increases in Day-lengthCompared to Circadian ClockTransmitted to Hypothalamus

“Right time”: Neuro-hormones Released,Target Anterior Pituitary

3

Territoriality: How?

Anterior Pituitary Releases Gonadotropinsinto Bloodstream, Target Testis

Testis Releases Steroid HormonesSecondary Sexual Characteristics,Reproductive Behavior: Territoriality

Mechanisms: More Description than Prediction

4

Territoriality: Why?

Adaptive Value vs AlternativesFitness: Survival & Reproduction

Defending Resources - Food, Mate, Nest Site -By Excluding Conspecifics

Advances Reproductive Success

5

Territoriality: Why?

Single-Pair Territory Greater Reproductive Success

Than Alternatives

Fitness Value, Functional Significance

Assume Natural Selection & Adaptation

6

Why Questions

Understand Significance of Individual Behavior and Mating Systems

Model Benefits & Costs of TerritorialityPredict: Why Individuals Territorial or Not

Understand Behavioral Diversity

7

Functional Significance of Behavior

Research Strategies

1. Comparative Method

2. Hypothetico-Deductive Method:Predictive Modeling

8

Functional Significance of BehaviorComparative Method

Cuvier: Anatomy, Paleontology

Newton Era

9

Comparative Method

Comparative Anatomy for Phylogeny

Apply to Behavior: Phylogeny,

Later: Correlate Behavior with EnvironmentAcross Series Populations, Species, …

Does same environment produce same behavior?

Behavioral Convergence Adaptation?

10

Comparative Method

Correlations of Behavior & EnvironmentSuggest Hypotheses re Adaptation

Correlation Not CausalitySecondary to H-D method:

Phenotypic Gambit

11

Phenotypic Gambit

Selective Evolution Favors Certain Phenotypes; Presumably Alleles

Commonly: Natural Selection on Individuals

Result: Populations Adapt to Environment

Evolutionary Genetics Optimization Model

12

Biological Evolution

Change in Gene Frequencies thru Time

What Drives Evolution?

Mutation Migration (Gene Flow)

Genetic Drift Meiotic DriveNatural Selection

13

Natural Selection

Change in Gene Frequencies Due to Variation in Lifetime Reproductive Success Among Individual Phenotypes

Survival and Fecundity FitnessInclusive Fitness

Different Genes Different Phenotypes

14

Natural Selection

Phenotypic Variance Within Population

Genetic Variation:Contributes to Phenotypic VariancePhenotypes Heritable

Different Phenotype: Different Fitness

15

Levels of SelectionGene

Individual: Natural SelectionDarwinian Fitness

Family: Kin SelectionInclusive Fitness

Group, Deme, Species

16

Selection and Adaptation

Natural Selection: Individual Fitness

Result: Population AdaptsMean Fitness IncreasesFitness Variance Declines

Phenotype “Optimized”

17

Selection and Adaptation

Directional Selection (favor 1 extreme)

Destabilizing Selection (favor extremes)

Optimizing (Stabilizing) Selection

18

Optimizing Selection

19

Optimality Theory

Hypothetico-Deductive MethodFunctional Questions

Optimality Models to Predict Behavior:Assume Optimizing Selection

Optimal, “best,” metaphor for adaptation

20

Optimality Theory

Question In Behavioral Ecology

Strategy Set (behavior, animal can do) Constraints (environment, animal can’t do) Objective Function

Hypothesize Currency of Fitness

Deduce Optimal Solution, Prediction

21

Optimality Theory

Identify Strategy SetList Possible Behaviors

Discrete (Eat some prey, reject others)

Continuous (Time in food patch)

22

Optimality Theory

Identify Applicable Constraints

Total Time (or Energy) AvailablePhysiological RequirementPossible vs Impossible

(Cannot Search for Food &Handle Food Simultaneously)

23

Optimality Theory

Listing Constraints: “Phenotypic Gambit”

Ignore Genetic Constraints,Usually Don’t Know What They

Are

24

Optimality Theory

Construct Objective FunctionMaps Any Feasible Behavior ontoAn Hypothesized “Currency of Fitness”

Hypothesis: Increase in Currency WillIncrease Survival, Reproduction

… Test Understanding

Deduce Prediction(s)25

Optimality Theory

Currency of FitnessRate of Energy Gain While

ForagingProbability of StarvingOffspring Produced/Year

Maximize Fitness Currency by Optimizing Behavioral Strategy

26