ADVANCED TRAINING FOR DISPATCHERS ON EMERGENCY … 8 Villella (p).… · The next step: the PEGASE...

CHOOSE EXPERTS, FIND PARTNERS

ADVANCED TRAINING FOR DISPATCHERS ON EMERGENCY PROCEDURES

EPPC 2011 - 24 May 2011, Altea

Fortunato Villella, Power System Consulting

2

TABLE OF CONTENT

• Advanced training for dispatchers on emergency procedures

• Full dynamic DTS for large scale system (PEGASE)

• Impact of the self-disconnection on the voltage recovery in case of large presence of rotating load

3

THE EXTENDED ELECTROMECHANICAL MODEL

ClassicalDTS

FAST-DTSand its extended

electromechanical model (EMM)

Long-term phenomena

Short-term phenomena

Electromechanical swings

Loss of synchronism

Simulation of protective devices

VVVVV

Quasi-static phenomenaVLong-term phenomena

Short-term phenomena

Electromechanical swings

Loss of synchronism

Simulation of protective devices

VQuasi-static phenomenaV

5

INTEGRATED ARCHITECTURE

Data processing

Power ApplicationFunctions

Real-timedatabase

Simulatordatabase

Simulated data acquisition

Network model

Telemetry model

InstructorSupportSystem

EventSimulator

Trainee

Instructor

= FAST

= EMS from a generic vendor

6

Example of advanced scenario“International” scenario• Aim

- Analyze what happened on 4th November 2006

- Reproduce a similar scenario on the DTS

- Train the operators on the POLICY 5 of the ENTSO/E (Emergency Procedures)

• Frequency leader

• Resynchronization leader

- Let the operators familiarize with the concept of

• Synchro check vs synchro coupler

• Synchronous vs asynchronous coupling

• Power and frequency control

• ACE

• …

• Model- Extended electromechamical model

- ± 7000 equations integrated and solved 50 times a second (20 ms step size)

- Connected to the real scada of the TSO

7

Scenario International (ELIA)• Sequence of events

- Trip of two lines (Vigy [FR] – Ensdorf [DE] –I+II )

- Consequent overload of trips with a total split of FR-DE, FR-CH, FR-IT (due to trip of overload protections)

- All the flows FR->DE goes through the lines FR-BE-NL

- Overloads on the lines FR-BE with consequent trip and split

- WEST system with FR & BE over-

synchronous (f ≈ 50.12 Hz)

- EAST system with DE & NL–CH under-

synchronous (f ≈ 49.90 Hz)F1=50.12Hz

F2=49.90Hz

8

Scenario International• ENTSOE Policy 5 application

- ELIA synchronization leader

• Drives the frequency leaders

• Synchronization on the busbars of the interconnection lines with NL (380kV)

• May use the PST to minimize the post-reconnection flow

- RTE frequency leader WEST

• Decrease the frequency

- RWE frequency leader EAST

• Increase the frequency

RTE -> F1

RWE -> F2

400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800 850 900 950 1000

49.65

49.70

49.75

49.80

49.85

49.90

49.95

50.00

50.05

50.10

50.15

50.20

s

[noord (imported)] NODE FREQUENCY DEIC1A00

[noord (imported)] NODE FREQUENCY FBEZ1A00

860 880 900 920 940 960

402

403

404

405

406

407

408

s

[noord (imported)] VOLTAGE AT NODE : BVYK1B00

[noord (imported)] VOLTAGE AT NODE : BVYK1B01

860 880 900 920 940 960

-200

-150

-100

-50

0

50

100

150

200

s

[noord (imported)] VOLTAGE ANGLE AT NODE : BVYK1B00

[noord (imported)] VOLTAGE ANGLE AT NODE : BVYK1B01

860 880 900 920 940 960

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

550

600

650

700

750

800

850

900

950

s

[noord (imported)] ACTIVE POWER : 380.27 Meerhout --> Maasbracht

[noord (imported)] ACTIVE POWER : 380.28 Gramme - Maasbracht

9

Scenario InternationalConclusions

• Deep analysis of the events of 4th November 2006

• ENTSOE Policy 5 application on a practical case

• Dynamical modeling of the system of fundamental importance- Prime movers and speed governor of the interested units

- Frequency response of the system (loads, prime movers…)

- Voltage angles and synchrochecks/synchro couplers

- UFLS

- Equivalent model of the foreign units (for correct redistribution of the flows)

• Other scenarios simulating a black-out and reconstruction - Analysis of the dynamical behavior that brings to a blackout (e.g. short-circuits,

consequent loss of synchronism, voltage collapses…)

- Analysis of the dynamical behavior and of the limitation of the capability of the machines in case of blackstart (e.g. UEL, capability curve, frequency regulation, units OEL, frequency stability … )

11

The next step: the PEGASE project

• PEGASE

- Pan European Grid Advanced Simulation and State Estimation

- Funded by the European Commission / Seventh Framework Program (FP7 - Energy)

- 4 years ( June 2012)

- 20 Partners (TSOs, expert companies, leading research centre)

- Advanced algorithmic, build prototypes of software, demonstrate the feasibility

• System Modelling

• Real-time state estimation (SE)

• Steady State Optimisation (OPF)

• Time domain simulation (including DTS)

• Validation, demonstration and dissemination

12

DTS in PEGASE

• Purpose

- Calculation engine able to run system-wide dynamic of the ETN real-time simulation

- Modelling flexibility user-defined models

- Size of the system ~15 000 nodes / ~4000 generators / ~125 000 state variables

• Several control centres

• Scenarios addressing cross border operational issues

• Means

- Parallel processing

- Advanced algorithmic (e.g. multi rate, Schwarz, ... etc.)

13

DTS architecture in PEGASE

European Dispatcher Training System

Computation & Training Centre

Operator Console

2(generic)

Operator Console

1(generic) TSO Y

Rem

ote

c

onnect

ions

Central DB

SimulationEngine

Instructor Console(s)

Operator Console(replica)

TSO X

Operator Console(replica)

Localconnections

DTS in PEGASECurrent status• Large scale model with detailed

topology for all the UCTE system developed (~248000 physical nodes)

• Preliminary tests (similar to split 4th Nov 2006) performed

• Performance gap

- Currently it runs at 0.5x real time in average

• SCADA Communication protocol via OPC (Open Productivity & Connectivity)

- Ongoing

• Test MMI based on an in-house software

14

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

49.6

49.7

49.8

49.9

50.0

50.1

50.2

50.3

s

[peg_v25_fast_is (imported)] NODE FREQUENCY F0W6JW01

[peg_v25_fast_is (imported)] NODE FREQUENCY A3000204

[peg_v25_fast_is (imported)] NODE FREQUENCY Z0WA4W01

FR

DE

GR

IMPACT OF EMBEDDED LOW VOLTAGE -DISCONNECTION ON THE VOLTAGE STABILITY IN CASE OF LARGE PRESENCE OF ROTATING LOAD• Accurate understanding of power system behavior difficult without

a good knowledge of load behavior

• Power plants: lumped and location of data concentrated when loads are dispersed, diverse and located behind the distribution systems

• Load model used for power system analysis

- averaging behavior and/or dedicated model with large industrial load

- what mix?

- what level of non linearity to capture an adequate level of plausibility especially following large disturbances?

15

EXAMPLE OF RECORDINGS WITH HIGH SAMPLING RATE

16

May 11 17Workshop "ENERGY SYSTEMS SIMULATION AND MODELING"

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

8

10

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140203_00 (imported)] Direct Voltage Amplitude(kV)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

1

2

3

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140203_00 (imported)] Direct Current Amplitude(kA)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

49.5

50.0

50.5

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140203_00 (imported)] Actual frequency (Hz)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 2210

20

30

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140203_00 (imported)] Direct Active Power(MW)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

-0

10

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140203_00 (imported)] Direct Reactive Power (Mvar)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

8

10

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140202_00 (imported)] Direct Voltage Amplitude(kV)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

0.04

0.06

0.08

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140202_00 (imported)] Direct Current Amplitude(kA)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

49.5

50.0

50.5

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140202_00 (imported)] Actual frequency (Hz)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

0.5

1.0

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140202_00 (imported)] Direct Active Power(MW)

10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

0.2

0.4

0.6

s

[DFR_signal_20080814_140202_00 (imported)] Direct Reactive Power (Mvar)

SST1 SST1

18

Load model identificationEmbedded under voltage load shedding

• A common general load model is synthesized and implemented

CONCLUSIONS

• Sensitivity to voltage and frequency are NOT sufficient to model the load

- Mostly in presence of large amount of rotating load and power electronic driven loads

• Classical models may give stable results when the system is unstable

• Possible to derive realistic average model including the embedded load shedding using measurements

• Do EMS SA and DSA include load behaviour bifurcation ?

• What is the most efficient way to predict its impact ?

19

Paper: Y. A. Jebril, A. I. Ibrahim,S. A. Shaban, S. A. Al Dessi, K. Karoui, F. Depierreux,A. Szekut, F. Villella,

“Development of a detailed dynamic load model and implementation staged testing of DEWA network”,GGG

POWER 2010 CONFERENCE & EXHIBITION, Doha 18th – 20th October 2010 ;