24
~ Cami Ryan ~ Total Utilization of Flax Genomics (TUFGEN) University of Saskatchewan VALGEN, Vancouver March 2012

Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This presentation documents the rise and fall (trade and industry costs) of Triffid, a genetically modified flax variety that was approved for food and feed approval in two countries.

Citation preview

Page 1: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

~ Cami Ryan ~ Total Utilization of Flax Genomics

(TUFGEN)

University of Saskatchewan

VALGEN, Vancouver

March 2012

Page 2: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

2

Page 3: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

Act I

Triffid Flax

Act II

Triffid’s Demise

Act III

The Resurrection of Triffid

3

Page 4: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

4

Page 5: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

5 Source: FAO Stats

Canada

India

US

China

Page 6: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

6

O for a Muse of fire, that would ascend The brightest heaven of invention, [this Triffid],

A kingdom for a stage, princes to act And monarchs to behold the swelling scene!

Henry V, Act I

Page 7: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

1989 1988 1994

Feed Approval

1996 1996/97

Food

Food/Feed

1998

Page 8: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

8

‘Tis a vile thing to die, my gracious lord,

When men are unprepared [ for consumers’ response to GM]

and look not for it.

- Richard III, Act III -

Page 9: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

9

Recall and crush organized

2000 2001

CDC Triffid deregistered

CDC Triffid transported/crushed/destroyed

Page 10: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

10

What may this mean That thou, dead [Triffid] corse, again, in complete steel,

Revisit'st thus …

- Hamlet, Act I -

Page 11: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

11

July 2009

Sept 2009

16K tonnes in quarantine

Oct 2009

Testing!!!!

Page 12: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

12

Page 13: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

13 Data Source: Saskatchewan Ministry of Agriculture (2011)

NPTII marker discovered

FP967 notification on RASFF

Launch of Stewardship Protocol

Page 14: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

14 Source: Viju etal 2011

Page 15: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

15

Canada:

EU:

$30,000,000 (CDN) $52,000,000 (CDN)

(calculations based on: Ryan & Smyth 2011; Dayananda 2011) ; (COCERAL Report 2011)

> $80,000,000

Page 16: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

16

Page 17: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

17

Page 18: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

“…often gain quick acceptance …and on occasion they do have direct impacts on

government policy...”

Paarlberg and Pray (2008)

18

Page 19: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

19

Page 20: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

20

S. Somers on GM Foods: “fake” and "loaded with toxins, chemicals”

Page 21: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

21

“GMO health risks and their impact on our most precious resource - our children”

Page 22: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

22

Page 23: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

Klaus Ammann

Page 24: Triffid Flax: a drama in three acts

Questions? Comments? Questions? Comments?

Cami Ryan Departments of Plant Science & Bioresource Policy, Business and Economics

University of Saskatchewan

Twitter me @DocCamiRyan

Blog: http://doccamiryan.wordpress.com/

24

Acknowledgements: Stuart Smyth

TUFGEN team VALGEN SaskFlax

Flax Council of Canada