36
Key legal tips for US lawyers about European games publishing Jas Purewal Gamer Tech Law 2013 Seattle, USA

Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Interactive entertainment lawyer Jas Purewal gives 10 legal tips for US lawyers involved in EU games publishing

Citation preview

Page 1: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

Key legal tips for US lawyers about European games publishing

Jas PurewalGamer Tech Law 2013Seattle, USA

Page 2: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

2

About Osborne Clarke

About Osborne Clarke:

• Osborne Clarke is an international law firm with over 1000 people working in 14 offices across the European Union, a European lawyer-staffed office in Silicon Valley and a partner network worldwide.

Our interactive entertainment practice:

• Osborne Clarke is the leading interactive entertainment law firm in Europe.

• We advise the full range of interactive entertainment businesses from small developers to global publishers, platforms and distributors on matters including corporate and tax, funding, development, employment, IP and litigation issues.

• Our clients include publishers and platforms such as Electronic Arts, Activision, Nintendo, Disney, Gameforge and Facebook and developers including Wargaming.net, Ninja Theory, CD Projekt, Rebellion and Team 17.

Page 3: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

3

About Jas

• I'm an interactive entertainment and digital media lawyer at Osborne Clarke – I advise clients from independent developers to publishers on contracts, intellectual property, regulation and disputes.

• I advise on EU law from OC’s Silicon Valley office.

• I write and speak regularly on legal issues in interactive entertainment and digital media, including on my blog: www.gamerlaw.co.uk.

• I like Twitter: @gamerlaw.

• This presentation (and others) is available at: http://www.slideshare.net/jaspurewal.

Page 4: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

Intro: a few words about the EU…

Page 5: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

5

Regional breakdown of the IE industry in 2012/2013

Source: Business Insight

Page 6: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

6

This isn’t the European Union...

Page 7: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

7

THIS is the European Union...

Page 8: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

Top legal tips for publishing a game in the EU

Page 9: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No.1 : be careful using US contracts in European deals

Page 10: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

10

Using US contracts in EU deals

• EU states generally recognise US choice of law clauses.

• You still need to know about EU contract law aspects because:

1. EU states have own rules on formation, performance and enforcement.

2. Many EU states have mandatorily applicable law.

3. In practice, contract enforcement is in enforcee’s territory anyway.

4. Any party with a European presence will have European legal concerns beyond the contract itself.

Page 11: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

11

Using US contracts in EU deals: a (real) case study

• An EU developer enters a publishing deal with a US publisher for a casual online game under CA law.

• An EU data privacy regulator investigates the developer AND publisher over its use of consumer data, including regarding the published game.

• The developer is fined and has to make changes to its practices. Developer and publisher litigate against each other.

• Could have been avoided by dealing with EU data privacy in the contract.

Page 12: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

12

Using US contracts in EU deals: best practice

1. Is US law and jurisdiction actually the best option for the client?

2. If so, then still consider partial localisation to cover:

i. IP ownership.

ii. Data privacy.

iii. Consumer complaints.

iv. Developer-jurisdiction specific issues (Developer to advise).

v. Other regulation (e.g. marketing, gambling) specifically spelled out.

vi. Clear apportionment of all other liability.

vii. Mutually acceptable dispute resolution.

Page 13: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 2: Localise your EU distribution rights

Page 14: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

14

Localising distribution rights in the EU

1.Distributor rights vary by territory: have territory agreements.

2.Price maintenance: MRP no, SRP/RRP yes.

3.Be clear on whether distributor is actually your distributor, or a commercial agent.

4.You don’t have to permit EU second hand sales YET, but…

– Oracle v UsedSoft (C-128/11, CJEU 3/07/12)

– Vzbw v (2013)

5.Use Euro-collapse clauses in distribution agreements (?)

6.Tax structuring is very relevant to distribution arrangements…

Page 15: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 3: know about EU taxation of games studios

Page 16: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

16

EU taxation on game studios

• Little harmonisation of EU state tax systems.

• Widely varying levels of corporation and other taxes.

• VAT structuring increasingly common.

• Tax incentives increasingly important.

• BUT national revenue authorities increasingly aggressive about revenue offshoring and big changes due in 2015…

Page 17: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 4: obtain US AND EU IP protection

Page 18: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

18

IP rights in games in US and EU

1. US trade marks don’t protect vs. EU infringement: get EU trade marks.

2. Software patents significantly harder to obtain in EU (so don’t bother, normally).

3. Cover moral rights in contract.

4. US style work for hire clause won’t work.

5. Different approaches on personality rights and trade dress/design rights.

Page 19: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 5: localise EULA/Terms of Service

Page 20: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

20

EULAs and Terms of Service

• Pure US EULAs/ToS are substantially ineffective in EU:

– EU consumer law is mandatory: it applies regardless of choice of law clauses etc.

– EU consumers always entitled to sue in country of residence.

• The perennial localisation question: a single document or separate versions for US/EU/RoW?

– No correct legal answer or industry consensus

– Balance of legal enforceability vs consumer friction

– Localised content is just as important as localised format

Page 21: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

21

EULAs and Terms of Service

• Which US terms are effective?

– Legalistic/complex language

– IP ownership

– Licence terms

– Consumer reps + warranties

– Liability exclusions/limitations

– Minimum term exclusions

– Indemnification

– Mandatory arbitration/dispute resolution

– Unilateral/immediate changes

– Termination

X

XXXX

XX

Page 22: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

22

EULAs and Terms of Service: real life example 1

Mandatory arbitration provision:

“YOU AND [we] AGREE TO RESOLVE ALL DISPUTES AND CLAIMS BETWEEN US IN INDIVIDUAL BINDING ARBITRATION. THAT INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, ANY CLAIMS ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO: (i) ANY ASPECT OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN US; (ii) THIS AGREEMENT; OR (iii) YOUR USE OF [the product] , YOUR ACCOUNT OR THE SOFTWARE. IT APPLIES REGARDLESS OF WHETHER SUCH CLAIMS ARE BASED IN CONTRACT, TORT, STATUTE, FRAUD, UNFAIR COMPETITION, MISREPRESENTATION OR ANY OTHER LEGAL THEORY.”

X Not enforceable in EU. E.g. UK consumer guidance: “Terms are liable to challenge if they tend to prevent consumers taking disputes to court, or require them to go to remote or inappropriate courts.”

Page 23: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

23

EULAs and Terms of Service: real life example 2

Limitation of warranties and liability:

“TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, YOU EXPRESSLY AGREE THAT THE USE OF [our] SERVICES, [our] SOFTWARE, AND THE INTERNET IS AT YOUR SOLE RISK.  [Our] SERVICES, [our] SOFTWARE, [our] PRODUCTS AND THIRD-PARTY SERVICES AND PRODUCTS ARE PROVIDED ON AN "AS IS" AND "AS AVAILABLE" BASIS FOR YOUR USE, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, UNLESS SUCH WARRANTIES ARE LEGALLY INCAPABLE OF EXCLUSION. ”

XNot enforceable in EU; Unfair Contract Terms Directive: “A contractual term which has not been individually negotiated shall be regarded as unfair if, contrary to the requirement of good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations arising under the contract, to the detriment of the consumer”.

Page 24: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 6: localise your data privacy approach

Page 25: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

25

Localising for EU data privacy

• EU has the most stringent, sophisticated data privacy system in the world.

• Regulation covers: collection, exploitation, storage and retention of data.

• Tidal change coming in 2014-2015.

• Pure US data privacy approach is insufficient (even post-COPPA changes) – EU counsel input recommended.

Page 26: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

26

Localising for EU data privacy

• Basic tips:

1. Localise privacy policy.

2. Make privacy policy user-accessible.

3. Ensure US-EU Safe Harbor in place (if applicable).

4. Ensure local EU data privacy registrations in place (if applicable).

5. EU data privacy clauses in contracts.

6. Analysis of how EU data will be used by parties.

Page 27: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 7: navigate EU age rating rules

Page 28: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

28

Navigating EU age rating rules

• ESRB ratings don’t apply in EU.

• PEGI widely (but not universally) applied across EU for PC/console.

• Some countries have their own rules for PC/console, especially Germany.

• Mobile remains industry self-regulated (just like in USA) - for the moment…

• Growing regulatory focus on child protection in free to play rules: UK’s OFT investigation (2013)

Page 29: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 8: navigate child protection rules

Page 30: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

30

EU child protection rules

• Evolving rules on targeting/marketing to children in games:– Existing legislation (e.g. Unfair Commercial Practices Directive)

– UK: OFT investigation into free to play games and children

– Germany: regulatory investigation of Gameforge

– Various regulatory guidance on marketing to children

• No legal guidance, or industry consensus, on application.

• Best practice: if the game is predominantly targeted at children, or if children are a substantial part of its audience, then ensure (with EU counsel input) that game content and mechanics comply with latest EU position.

Page 31: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 9: gambling law is (slightly) more relaxed in EU

Page 32: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

32

EU gambling law and games businesses

• No blanket prohibition on online gambling across EU, but varying rules apply.

• Patchwork quilt of EU regulation: legal in some places (e.g. UK), illegal in many others (e.g. Germany).

• Test for gambling is usually different to US test.

• Regulators becoming interested in application of EU gambling law to games businesses.

• Increasing need to analyse game mechanics from an EU perspective.

Page 33: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

No. 10: wrapping up other EU regulation

Page 34: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

34

Other issues

A whole range of other EU state specific rules exist, e.g.:

• Product liability

• Financing/securities legislation

• Fraud/money laundering rules

• Insolvency/bankruptcy

• Employment practices

• Dispute resolution

Best practice: identify key risks upfront and deal with them expressly – don’t rely on US governing law/jurisdiction clauses or generic clauses.

Page 35: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

35

Wrap-up

1. Be careful using US contracts in EU deals.

2. Localise your EU distribution rights.

3. Understand EU taxation of games studios.

4. Obtain US AND EU IP protections.

5. Localise EULAs/Terms of Service.

6. Localise your data privacy approach.

7. Navigate age rating rules…

8. …and child protection rules.

9. Be aware of EU gambling rules.

10.Deal with EU regulation with specifics.

Page 36: Top legal tips for publishing games in the EU

osborneclarke.com

36

Thanks!

Jas PurewalLawyerSilicon Valley Office

T (+1) 650 714 8903

[email protected]: @gamerlawwww.osborneclarke.com

Marketing > Fotos > PP_Pitch > Kontakt 2