60
Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma Mathias Klang

Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma Mathias Klang

Page 2: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Three layers of society

Page 3: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 4: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Law

Contextual & programmed social

rules

Architecture

Page 5: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Norms from above

Page 6: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Contextual & programmed social

rules

Page 7: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

privacy(from Latin: privatus "separated from the rest, deprived of something, esp. office, participation in the government", from privo "to deprive") is the ability of an individual or group to seclude themselves or information about themselves and thereby reveal themselves selectively. (Wikipedia)

Page 8: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

.Privacy.integrity.Identity.anonymity.pseudonymity.

Page 9: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

The Right to Privacy

The intensity and complexity of life, attendant upon advancing civilization, have rendered necessary some retreat from the world…solitude and privacy have become more essential to the individual; but modern enterprise and invention have, through invasions upon his privacy, subjected him to mental pain and distress…

Warren and Brandeis The Right to Privacy, 4 Harvard Law Review 193 (1890)

Page 10: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

"You have zero privacy anyway.

Get over it."

Scott McNealy (1999)

Page 11: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

“Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity”

Mark Zuckerberg (2010)

Page 12: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 13: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 14: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 15: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 16: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Data/information

Page 17: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Data

Spatial

Page 18: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Game changer: storage

Page 19: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Production costs

Page 20: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Musikhistoria är olagrad för 1857

Page 21: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Betydelse?

Page 22: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Mike WelschWeb 2.0 ... The Machine is Us/ing Us

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLlGopyXT_g

Page 23: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Game changer: communication

Page 24: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Digitalization

Connectivity

Storage

Devices

Page 25: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Flickr

2000

2001

2002

2003 2005

2004 2006

Wikipedia

Linkedin

Blog

ger 1

999

Second Life

My Space

Skype

Digg

Facebook

Ning

YouTube

Twitter

Spotify

Google c:a 1998

2008

2007 2009

Farmville

iphone

WikileaksAngry Birds

Page 26: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Technology changing society, but social rules slow to evolve…

Page 27: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Surveillance: gaze from above

Page 28: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

powerHow is surveillance possible?

Page 29: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

The stateInformation gathering

Page 30: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma
Page 31: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Sousveillance: A gaze from below

Page 32: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Social ties How is sousveillance possible?

Page 33: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

“friends”

Page 34: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Autoveillance: a gaze from within

Page 35: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Exhibitionism? How is autoveillance possible?

Page 36: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

We used to leak information

Page 37: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Compartmentalization

Page 38: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Analog social norms

Page 39: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Protection from the outer gaze

Page 40: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Today we have a mix of sur, sous & autoveillance. regulation mainly focuses on surveillance.

Page 41: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

End of privacy?

Page 42: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

The Hive-mind

Page 43: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

If you have done nothing wrong,

you have nothing to fear

Page 44: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

We have (theoretical) control over Big Brother

Page 45: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold

Page 46: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

personalization

Page 47: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

The internet is shows us what it thinks that we want to see – not what we need to see Eli Pariser

Page 48: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Identity & Information junk food.

Page 49: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

It will be very hard for people to watch or consume something that has not in some sense been tailored for them. Eric Schmidt, Google

Page 50: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Technology is not inherently democratic

Page 51: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Law without infrastructure

Page 52: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Problem 1: We are stupid

Page 53: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Problem 2: We don’t know what we don’t know

Page 54: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Problem 3: difference between who I want to be & who I am…

Page 55: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Problem 4: The keepers of algorithms know this

Page 56: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

There have always been gatekeepers.

Page 57: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

We have (theoretical) control over Big Brother

Page 58: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

A Squirrel Dying In Your Front Yard May Be More Relevant To

Your Interests Right Now Than People

Dying In AfricaMark Zuckerberg

Page 59: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Thank you.

Page 60: Society vs Privacy: the impossible dilemma

Information• All images from www.flickr.com (unless specifically stated)

• Image & licensing info in the notes section of slides

• Presentation licensed: Creative Commons BY-NC-SA

• The presentation can be downloaded from: www.slideshare.net/klang

• More information about me: www.techrisk.se & www.digital-rights.net

• Mathias Klang. [email protected] or @klang67