54
Comparing and Contrasting the Open Approach and the Walled Garden Approach • Highlighting the differences between the walled garden approach and the open approach • Analysing the benefits of each approach • Examining the challenges of each • Discussing whether we are seeing a migration towards a more open approach

Open Vs Walled Gardens

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Comparing and Contrasting the Open Approach and the

Walled Garden Approach• Highlighting the differences between the walled garden approach and

the open approach• Analysing the benefits of each approach

• Examining the challenges of each• Discussing whether we are seeing a migration towards a more open

approach

Page 2: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 3: Open Vs Walled Gardens

• The transaction cost of group activity has fallen through the floor.

• This creates fundamental change in how value is and can be created.

• It means the value of hierarchies, gatekeepers… walled gardens falls through the floor too.

Page 4: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Ideas Ideas

Ideas

Action

Page 5: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Ideas Ideas

Ideas

Action

ValueValue

Page 6: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Ideas Ideas

Ideas

Action

Conversation

Conversation

Conversation

ValueValue

Page 7: Open Vs Walled Gardens

• Enabling the rapid, real-time evolution of communities of purpose unlocks the value.

• It turns the potential of group forming network theory into practice.

Page 8: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The value of random friends

Page 9: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Tearing down the walls…

Page 10: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The real 3 Cs?

Content > Conversation > Community

Page 11: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The real 3 Cs

Content > Conversation > Community

Conversation is the intersection of ideas. It is where ideas coalesce into action

Page 12: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The real 3 Cs

Content > Conversation > Community

Conversation is the intersection of ideas.It is where ideas coalesce into actionAction is where value is created

Page 13: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is worthless

Page 14: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is worthless

• Except that it isn’t

Page 15: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is worthless

• Except that it isn’t• It gives us something to talk about

Page 16: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is worthless

• Except that it isn’t• It gives us something to talk about• Talking about stuff is where ideas turn into

action

Page 17: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is worthless• Except that it isn’t• It gives us something to talk about• Talking about stuff is where ideas turn into

action• Action is where value is created

Page 18: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is valuable• Because of the because effect

Page 19: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is valuable• Because of the because effect• You won’t make money with it

Page 20: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is valuable

• Because of the because effect• You won’t make money with it• You will make money because of it

Page 21: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Content is valuable

• Because of the because effect• You won’t make money with it• You will make money because of it• Eg Prince, Radiohead

Page 22: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Value chain is now a value web

Page 23: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Value chain is now a value web

Two disruptions

Page 24: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Value chain is now a value web

Two disruptions• How, and by whom,

content is being created

Page 25: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Value chain is now a value web

Two disruptions• How, and by whom,

content is being created• How, and by whom, content is being

distributed

Page 26: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The world we’re witnessing

Share

Trust

Connect

Community

Page 27: Open Vs Walled Gardens

The networked world

Page 28: Open Vs Walled Gardens

We Species wants…

Page 29: Open Vs Walled Gardens

To engage with the network

Page 30: Open Vs Walled Gardens

A community is a community…

Page 31: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Always on

Always with you

Always yours

Page 32: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Starting a fire on the village green

Page 33: Open Vs Walled Gardens

• Curate content

• User-driven customisation

• Manage the web of peer producers

• Contribute thehard-to-do

Page 34: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Two advantages

Always ready LBS

Page 35: Open Vs Walled Gardens

7th Mass Media1. It’s truly personal2. It’s always on3. It’s always with you4. Has a built-in payment

mechanism5. Allows creation

at the pointof inspiration

Page 36: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Screen size?

Page 37: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 38: Open Vs Walled Gardens

What’s wrong with operators?

Why don’t they value me?

Page 39: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 40: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Itsmy.com

Page 41: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 42: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 43: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 44: Open Vs Walled Gardens
Page 45: Open Vs Walled Gardens

User-centric portals

• Mippin

Page 46: Open Vs Walled Gardens

User-centric portals

• Mippin• Widsets

Page 47: Open Vs Walled Gardens

User-centric portals

• Mippin• Widsets• Squace

Page 48: Open Vs Walled Gardens

They show the way

Page 49: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Inside and out

Lump it Throw off your chains

Page 50: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Mash it up!

Page 51: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Our position in this ecosystem?

• To enable, • To understand,• To facilitate the connections.• To find acceptable ways to share in the

value that we have helped to create through both our facilitation and our contributions.

Page 52: Open Vs Walled Gardens

Takeaways

Make money withcontent

UnderstandYour placearoundThe campfire

Don’t restrict the view!

Don’t restrict the view!

Page 53: Open Vs Walled Gardens

In summary

• You won’t make money WITH content but you will BECAUSE of it.

• Focus on content, conversation and communities of purpose to create value.

• User-Centric Portals (community-enabled aggregators) will aid discovery.

• Enable communities to self-form and share what they trust.

• Don’t restrict the view!

Page 54: Open Vs Walled Gardens

David CushmanFasterFuture.blogspot.com Bauer Consumer Media