Upload
jeff-long
View
280
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
May 20, 2000: "Issues in the Study of Abstractions". Presented at the Eighth Interdisciplinary Conference on General Evolutionary Systems, sponsored by the Washington Evolutionary Systems Society.
Citation preview
Cover Page
Uploaded June 27, 2011
Issues in the Study of
Abstractions
Author: Jeffrey G. Long ([email protected])
Date: May 1, 2000
Forum: Talk presented at the Eighth Interdisciplinary Conference on Evolutionary Systems, sponsored by the Washington Evolutionary Systems Society.
Contents
Pages 1‐15: Slides (but no text) for presentation
License
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution‐NonCommercial
3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by‐nc/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative
Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA.
Issues in the Study of AbstractionsAbstractions
Jeffrey G. LongWESS ConferenceWESS Conference
May 2000
OverviewOverview
Ch i O Mi d• Changing Our Minds• The Reality of Abstractions• Types of Learning• Making Notational Engineering a RealMaking Notational Engineering a Real
Discipline
Changing Our Minds: Four People
• Adam-1: Born 200,000 years agoAd 2 B 100 000• Adam-2: Born 100,000 years ago
• Adam-3: Born today• Adam-4: Born 100,000 years hence
AssumptionsAssumptions
Th l ll d H i• The people are all modern Homo sapiens sapiens
• The people are genetically identical• The people grow up to be competent at p p g p p
living a normal life for their times
If Brought Together, Could They Communicate?
B i biliti l li bl• Basic capabilities always reliable:– Smile, cry, show other emotions– Basic cognition: differentiate 3 > 2
• Basic ontological assumptions/beliefs are very different
• Effectively, each exists in a different world y,
The World of Adam 1The World of Adam-1
N l• No language• No numbers• No time• No shapeNo shape• No relations
N l• No value
The World of Adam 2The World of Adam-2
L• Language• No numbers• No time• No shapeNo shape• No relations
N l• No value
The World of Adam 3The World of Adam-3
L• Language• Numbers• Time• ShapeShape• Relations
V l• Value
The World of Adam 4The World of Adam-4
All f th i l b t ti• All of the previous, plus new abstractions that we cannot even imagine– New concepts of language, numbers, time,
shape, relations, valueWh ll b i– Wholly new abstractions
– Wholly new media– Wholly new values and behaviors
Changing Our MindsChanging Our Minds
Th i d f H i h t l• The mind of Hss is what evolves• It evolves via new abstractions and the
application thereof• This creates a new ontologygy• There is a major chasm between people
having vastly different ontologieshaving vastly different ontologies
Are They Real or Inventions?Are They Real or Inventions?
Wh t it i ld t d t i• What criteria could we use to determine this?
• What are the consequences of one or the other?
What criteria could we use?
H d k thi i “ l”?• How do we know anything is “real”?– Intersubjective agreement– Functional utility– Cultural convention
• Are there parallels to the way we learn to see objects?– Piaget’s developmental stages
What are the consequences?What are the consequences?
If b t ti “ l” th• If abstractions are “real” then:– There is some biological/ontogenetic
ti th t ll t thperception process that allows us to see them– There may be some way to see new
abstractions more q ickl or s stematicallabstractions more quickly or systematically– It changes the nature of reality: what we think
is real is only “surface structure”is real is only surface structure
Types of LearningTypes of Learning
N Ab t ti S thi t t ll• New Abstraction: See something totally new in the environment
• New Paradigm: Change our unconscious beliefs about a system or situation
• New Knowledge: Extend our conscious beliefs about a system or situationy
Making Notational Engineering a Real Discipline
U i it R h L b/P• University Research Lab/Program• Private Foundation• For-Profit Corporation• Federal Research LabFederal Research Lab
• Primary requirement: results