55
How (not) to measure Twitter influence Farida Vis Information School, University of Sheffield @flygirltwo

How not to measure Twitter Influence

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

These are the slides of a keynote I gave at Emerce Eday on 25 October 2012 in Rotterdam. The short description of my talk was as follows: With the ongoing rise of third party applications like Klout, tools for measuring Twitter influence are important to understand. This presentation takes a look at the different ways in which influence measures have been developed for Twitter. In particular it will use the case study of the UK riots of 2011 for which a database of 2.6 million tweets was collected in collaboration with Twitter and The Guardian newspaper. By examining the top 1000 most tweeted accounts, it will give further insight in how influence worked during this crisis event, specifically highlighting the emergence of the ‘ordinary influential’ during 2011 as well as how large organisations have incorporated social media practices.

Citation preview

Page 1: How not to measure Twitter Influence

How (not) to measure Twitter influence

Farida VisInformation School, University of

Sheffield

@flygirltwo

Page 2: How not to measure Twitter Influence

REAL TIME

Page 3: How not to measure Twitter Influence

BIG DATA

Page 4: How not to measure Twitter Influence

MOBILE

Page 5: How not to measure Twitter Influence

TWITTER

Page 6: How not to measure Twitter Influence

FACEBOOK

Page 7: How not to measure Twitter Influence

[NAME OF NEXT BIG SNS HERE]

Page 8: How not to measure Twitter Influence

GEOLOCATION

Page 9: How not to measure Twitter Influence

STREAMING

Page 10: How not to measure Twitter Influence

INFLUENCE

Page 11: How not to measure Twitter Influence

KLOUT

Page 12: How not to measure Twitter Influence

PEERINDEX

Page 13: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Following Rules and Best Practice – Twitter Help Center

We don’t limit the number of followers you can have. However, we do monitor how aggressively users follow other users. We try to make sure that none of our limits restrain reasonable usage, and will not affect most Twitter users.

Aggressive following is define as indiscriminate following a few users if their accounts seem interesting is normal and is not considered aggressive.

… every user can follow 2000 people total. Once you’ve 2000 users, there are limits to the number of additional users you can follow: this limit is different for every user and is based on you ratio of followers to following.

Page 14: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 15: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 16: How not to measure Twitter Influence

‘A score in the 40s suggests a strong, but niche, following’

‘… influence is about engagement and motivation, not just racking up legions of followers’ (New York Times)

Page 17: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Sleep deprivation…

Facebook

Community

Page 18: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 19: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Not on KLOUT, still scored

Page 20: How not to measure Twitter Influence

THE ALGORITHM

Page 21: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 22: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Aaron Zinman

MIT SociableMedia Group

Page 23: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 24: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 25: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 26: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Illegal and legalEducationSportOnline

Page 27: How not to measure Twitter Influence

UK TWITTERATI

Page 28: How not to measure Twitter Influence

2011 UK Twitterati (The Independent)

1. Sarah Brown – Campaigner (PI: 93)

2. Richard Bacon – Broadcaster (PI: 92)

3. Eddie Izzard – Comedian (PI: 89)

Page 29: How not to measure Twitter Influence

2012 UK Twitterati (The Independent)

1. Richard Branson – Tycoon (PI: 93)

2. Sarah Brown – Campaigner (PI: 92)

=2. Alan Carr, Broadcaster (PI: 92)

Page 30: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Tweets as: @richardbranson

PeerIndex:93

Authority: 95

Activity: 46

Audience: 97

Follows: 6,414

Followers: 1,834,516

Page 31: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 32: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 33: How not to measure Twitter Influence

NO Jon Hickman on PeerIndex

No score/profile created for him

Page 34: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Free stuff

More than 2,500

companies using

Klout’s data

(NYT, 26.6.2011)

Page 35: How not to measure Twitter Influence

“For the first time, we’re all on an even playing field”

Joe Fernandez

Chief executive and co founder of Klout

Page 36: How not to measure Twitter Influence

BIG DATA

Page 37: How not to measure Twitter Influence

NOT ENOUGH

Page 38: How not to measure Twitter Influence

GIANT DATA

Page 39: How not to measure Twitter Influence

More than 12 billion signals a day into a Hive data warehouse of more than 1

trillion rows

Hundreds of millions of user profiles

Klout blog 11.10.2012

Page 40: How not to measure Twitter Influence

2.6 million riot tweets

Lisa Evans, 8.12.2011

Page 41: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 42: How not to measure Twitter Influence

± 45% Mainstream media

Page 43: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 44: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Viral

Image

Influence

Page 45: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Mentions ≠ insight

Page 46: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Online influence ≠

Offline influence

Page 47: How not to measure Twitter Influence

BIEBER VS OBAMA

Page 48: How not to measure Twitter Influence

2012 UK Independent voices (The Independent)

UK NEWS: Owen Jones –

writer / researcher (PI: 65)

WORLD NEWS: Hossam el-Hamalawy –

Egyptian journalist/dissident (PI: 64)

PEOPLE: Wael Ghonim –

Egyptian Google staffer (PI: 41)

Page 49: How not to measure Twitter Influence

2011 rise of the ordinary influential?

Page 50: How not to measure Twitter Influence

CONTEXT

CONTEXT

CONTEXT

Page 51: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Small data = meaning

Page 52: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Gaming the system

Page 53: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 54: How not to measure Twitter Influence
Page 55: How not to measure Twitter Influence

Implications of reducing

people to a number