14
CLEAN ENERGY FINANCING: QECBs WITH POWERSAVER Presentation to Debt Review Committee Matthew Brown, Principal March 29, 2012

Debt review presentation qecb-power saver, march 2012

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Matthew H. Brown presented to the Salt Lake County Debt Review Committee about a structural option for using Qualified Energy Conservation Bonds, the proceeds of which would be used to fund energy efficiency loans supported by a Title 1 PowerSaver loan insurance project. The Debt Review Committee sent the proposal on to the County Council with a positive recommendation, subject to a review of certain alternatives.

Citation preview

Page 1: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

CLEAN ENERGY FINANCING: QECBs WITH POWERSAVER

Presentation to Debt Review Committee

Matthew Brown, PrincipalMarch 29, 2012

Page 2: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

OVERVIEW

2

Page 3: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

3

VISION FOR SALT LAKE COUNTY

Launch residential energy upgrade market with affordable interest rates and scalable design

The Salt Lake County QECB/PowerSaver model can spark consumer demand for residential energy upgrades, including solar and cost-saving energy efficiency.

Demand can be met with local equipment vendors and contractors, creating not just local jobs but a market as the offering scales.

Creation of the market will attract subsequent investors, thereby allowing the Salt Lake region to become a hub of energy upgrade activity

Page 4: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

4

WHAT ENERGY EFFICIENCY LOOKS LIKELow cost, high return upgrades with immediate savings and increased value and comfort

Before upgrade After upgrade

• Wasted heating and cooling• High utility costs• Hot/cold zones and low comfort• Average resale value

• Balanced, efficient HVAC• Reduced utility costs• Liveable space and high comfort• Marketing advantage on resale

Page 5: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

5

ELIGIBLE UPGRADESMost measures will be available locally and can be installed by local contractors

Insulation Duct sealing Storm Doors Window Replacement Storm Windows Heating System Gas/Propane/Oil Boiler / Furnace Air Conditioner

Water Heater (gas, propane, electric, tankless)

Energy Star Roofs Ground Source Heat Pump Water Heater (Solar) Fuel Cells Micro-turbines Solar Panels Small Wind Turbines

Page 6: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

6

ENGAGING THE LOCAL COMMUNITY

St. Louis County and others have seen tremendous contractor support

• Over 60 contractors were approved within the St. Louis program.

• Many contractors paid for independent marketing, including one that spent over $30k promoting the program.

• These projects are primarily initiated by contractors.

Rollout strategy for integrating contractors with PowerSaver lender will be critical.

Contractors need to understand financing and be enabled to originate projects.

Fannie Mae lenders have used this “dealer loan” model successfully for years.

Page 7: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

COMBINING QECBs WITH POWERSAVER

7

Page 8: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

8

BENEFITS OF QUALIFIED ENERGY CONSERVATION BONDS (QECBS)

• Well below-market interest rates• Up to 70% interest subsidy from IRS• Consumers benefit directly from low rates

• Boulder County – 1.1 to 2.9% for commercial loans• St. Louis County – 3.5% for

residential loans• Available for qualified energy conservation

purposes• Renewable energy• Energy efficiency• Certain transportation projects• “Green community programs”

• Exempt from the 30% private activity cap

• Salt Lake County has approximately $4.49MM of available QECB allocations

Page 9: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

9

POWERSAVER SUMMARY

• FHA-based private mortgage insurance product designed to result in low-cost lending for residential energy upgrades• HUD has approved 17 PowerSaver lenders to

date• The mortgage insurance guarantees up to 90%

of each qualifying loan and up to 10% of the lender’s Title 1 portfolio• The maximum loan amount is $25,000

• Loan must be secured if over $7,500

• Credit requirements include:• FICO ≥ 660; Debt-to-income ≤ 45%; Loan-

to-value ≤ 100%• Employment and income verification

requirement (2 years)

Page 10: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

10

POWERSAVER APPROVED LENDERS

HUD Approved and Utah Licensed:

 

AFC First Financial - Allentown, PA

Bank of Colorado - Ft. Collins, CO

City of Boise - Boise, ID

Neighbors Financial Corp. - Sacramento, CA

Paramount Equity - Roseville, CA

Sun West Mortgage Co. - Cerritos, CA

WJ Bradley - South Jordan, UT

At least 7 PowerSaver lenders would be available to partner with the County

Page 11: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

11

ADVANTAGES OF COMBINING QECBS WITH POWERSAVER

• QECB interest rate subsidy combined with HUD PowerSaver’s mortgage insurance could allow Salt Lake County to launch a below-market rate financing program for residential energy upgrades• PowerSaver mortgage insurance may allow pure conduit structure without

credit support from Salt Lake County for the bond issuance• Establishing a relationship with a PowerSaver lender could allow the

program to scale as QECB proceeds are expended, resulting in a sustainable, low cost model

Page 12: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

STRUCTURE OVERVIEW

12

Page 13: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

13

CONDUIT ISSUANCE QECB WITH SALT LAKE COUNTY SUPPORT AGREEMENT

= Capital Inflow

= Capital Outflow

= Credit Enhancement

Bond Purchasers

Conduit Issuer Created by Salt Lake County

Residential Property Owners

PowerSaver Lender (with optional Administrator)

P&I payments made to the Lender

Loans are originated with funding to contractor

Capital supplied to fund loans

Principal and interest paid to investor

FHA: Mortgage Insurance

IRS: Interest Rate Subsidy

Bond proceeds

90%/10%

Up to 70%

5% Borrower Funded DSR Capitalized

Fee

DSR for benefit of bond purchasers

P&I passthrough

Page 14: Debt review presentation  qecb-power saver, march 2012

QUESTIONS

14