25
What are (healthy) habits anyway? Dr Benjamin Gardner Lecturer in Health Psychology Health Behaviour Research Centre, UCL [email protected] 30 th April 2014

Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

What are (healthy) habits anyway?

Dr Benjamin GardnerLecturer in Health Psychology

Health Behaviour Research Centre, [email protected]

30th April 2014

Page 2: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Actions that have come to be automatically triggered by

situational cues(e.g. Maddux, 1997; Verplanken & Aarts, 1999)

2

Page 3: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Defining habit

• Learned– through context-dependent repetition (Lally et al, 2010)

• Cue-dependent (stimulus-response)• Automatic

– Do not require intention

– May be initiated without awareness

– Are initiated outside of volitional control– Requires little/no effort (Bargh, 1996)

3

Page 4: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

How do habits form?Lally, van Jaarsveld, Potts & Wardle (2010)

• 96 participants– Performed a new healthy eating, drinking or exercise

behaviour...

– Once a day, every day

• Each day, participants reported– automaticity of behaviour (i.e. habit)

– whether bhvr performed

• Participants tracked over 12 weeks

Page 5: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habit formationLally, van Jaarsveld et al (2010)

• Habit

formation best

modelled as

asymptotic

curve

Page 6: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habit formationLally, van Jaarsveld et al (2010)

• Median time for automaticity to plateau = 66 days

• Range: 18-254 days

• Simpler actions tended to become habitual quicker

Page 7: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Knowledge

Intention

Reasoning

Reflective and impulsive routes to behaviourStrack & Deutsch (2004)

REFLECTIVE

(Associative store)

IMPULSIVE

Perception

of cueBehaviour

• Habits are situated on the impulsive route to behaviour

Page 8: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits narrow attention towards the habitual optionVerplanken et al (1997)

• Measure of bicycle use habit

• Hypothetical task: making an unfamiliar journey

• Choose 1 of 4 transport modes (inc bicycle)

• Information available on each mode re 6 attributes– e.g. physical effort, probability of delay, travel time– 24 pieces of information available in total

8

Page 9: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

• Habitual bicycle users:– chose bicycle more frequently (82%) than did non-habit

pcpts (50%)– used less information (14.45 pieces) than non-habit

users (19.45)

• Similar findings for car users, familiar journeys

9

Habits narrow attention towards the habitual optionVerplanken et al (1997)

Page 10: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits make alternatives less accessibleDanner, Aarts & de Vries (2007)

• Computerised lab task• Participants shown goal-behaviour combinations

– e.g. ‘relaxing-television’, ‘writing-computer’– Combination shown 1x, 3x or 9x

• Participants then shown goal, followed by:– either the paired behaviour (e.g. relaxing-television)– or an alternative goal-serving behaviour (relaxing-bath)

• How long does it take for participant to recognise the behaviour as appropriate?

10

Page 11: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits make alternatives less accessibleDanner et al (2007)

11

Page 12: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits and decision-making

• Habitual actors– Choose their habitual actions more often– Prior to decision-making:

• have less cognitive access to alternatives• use less information on utility of available options• use less information on features of the choice

scenario• think less prior to making decisions

Page 13: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Process model of habitual choiceVerplanken et al (1997)

Page 14: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits have two main effects on behaviourTriandis (1977)

1. Habits determines behaviour frequency

2. Habits override conscious intentions:

- where habit is strong, intentions have weakened impact on behaviour

- where habits and intentions conflict, behaviour more likely to be habitual than intentional

14

Page 15: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits override intentionsGardner (2009)

• 105 car users• University staff• Measures:

– Intention to commute to campus by car over next week– Habitual car commuting to campus

• One week later:– Car use (% journeys to campus done by car)

Page 16: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits override intentionsGardner (2009)

16

MODERATE HABIT

STRONG HABIT

Page 17: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habits persist despite conflicting motivesNeal, Wood, Wu & Kurlander (2012)

• 105 cinema-goers• Ostensibly a personality study• Watched and rated 15mins of trailers• Given either fresh or stale (1 week old) popcorn• Stale popcorn rated as less pleasant than fresh

popcorn

Page 18: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Habitual popcorn-eaters will eat stale popcornNeal et al (2012)

Page 19: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Effects of habit on behaviourGardner, de Bruijn & Lally (2011)

• Review of (21) applications of Self-Report Habit Index to diet (14) and physical (in)activity (7)

• On average, habits strongly associated with behaviour frequency

• 8 of 9 tests showed habit to override intentions in predicting behaviour

Page 20: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Problems with traditional views of habitGardner (in press)

• If habit is a form of behaviour, it cannot also be a predictor of behaviour

• Habitual behaviours can be inhibited, so are not inevitably enacted

• Can we impose a concept rooted in animal learning studies on complex human behaviour?

Page 21: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

‘a process by which a stimulus automatically generates an impulse towards action, based on learned stimulus-response associations’

Rethinking habit: a new definitionGardner (in press)

Page 22: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Corollaries of this definition

• Habit does not activate behaviour, it activates an impulse towards behaviour– Habit impulses are unconscious unless they are frustrated– Habit impulses can be overridden given sufficient skills, resources and

mental capacity

• Habit is independent of behaviour– When cue is not encountered, habit will not be enacted– A behaviour may not be elicited for some time but can still be habitual– Re-exposure to cues may reactivate ‘dormant habits’

Page 23: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Types of habitGardner (in press)

• Habits of decision– Selecting one behavioural option from several– e.g. choosing to have a coffee

• Habits of performance– Executing the chosen option– e.g. making the coffee

Page 24: Ben Gardner Habit Summit

Summary

Habits:•Form through repetition (with reward?)•Activate an impulse towards the habitual option•Focus attention on the habitual option and make alternatives less available•Can override conflicting intentions•Come in two forms

– Habit of decision– Habit of performance

24