22
CrossRef Workshop, Gauteng, South Africa, September 2015 1 WhatsThePointSA “Namaqualand Springbok” Managing Errata & Retractions with CrossMark Pretoria 2015 1 Content changes “The Web is by nature an interactive environment, yet online journals are mostly static, befitting their traditional role as a never- changing scholarly record” Interactive Publications and the Record of Science - ICSTI Winter Workshop (February 2010) How to manage change? 2

7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

1  

WhatsThePointSA  “Namaqualand  Springbok”  

Managing Errata & Retractions with CrossMark!Pretoria 2015

1  

Content changes

•  “The Web is by nature an interactive environment, yet online journals are mostly static, befitting their traditional role as a never-changing scholarly record”

•  Interactive Publications and the Record of Science - ICSTI Winter Workshop (February 2010)

•  How to manage change?

2  

Page 2: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

2  

When content changes …

•  … readers need to know! –  Errata –  Retractions –  Updates –  Enhancements –  new editions –  protocol updates –  Notices of concern –  etc.

3  Philosophical  TransacGons  of  the  Royal  Society,  1789  

Mistakes happen to all articles

4  

And  even  this  arGcle  has  been  corrected  !  

Page 3: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

3  

Some articles need to be retracted

•  How can we ensure that it won’t continue to be read … and cited …

5  

Nature 478, 26-28 (2011) Science publishing: The trouble with retractions. http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/478026a

Examples:PubMed Central

6  

Page 4: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

4  

But not so clear on PubMed

7  

And sometimes delayed …

8  

No  menGon  here  …  

Page 5: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

5  

And what about publisher sites?

•  Are updates clear?

9  

Does  this  arGcle  have  correcGons?  

Page 6: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

6  

Page 7: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

7  

And  offline  …  ?  

•  PDF  files  saved  offline  No  menGon  here…    

14  

Page 8: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

8  

Unfortunately

•  Changes are not always very clear •  Every publishers manages them differently

–  Confusing to readers •  They require on-going work from the publisher

–  Staff time, perhaps money to pay for updates

15  

And beyond the publisher’s website

•  Articles are read offline –  PDFs downloaded –  HTML pages cached

•  Articles lodged elsewhere on the web –  Institutional repositories –  Personal websites

•  How can these be linked with any changes?

16  

Page 9: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

9  

HOW CROSSMARK WORKS

17  

What it is

•  A logo that identifies a publisher-maintained copy of a piece of content

•  Clicking the logo tells you –  Whether there have been any updates –  If this version is being maintained by the publisher –  Where the publisher-maintained version is –  Other important publication record information

18  

Page 10: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

10  

Erratum  hWp://dx.doi.org  10.1234/PDS004e1  

Currently:  An  erratum  is  not  linked  to  the  ar7cle  

Unless  you  edit  the  HTML  page  and  the  PDF  

hWp://dx.doi.org/10.7707/BF00279143  

hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00279147  

Sadlksl]jsdf  df  jldj_j  f  

19  

But  they  both  have  DOIs  

Both  are  registered  with  

CrossRef  

So  why  not  associate  the  

erratum  with  the  DOI  being  corrected?  hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00279147  

Associated  with  hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF0027997  

Erratum  hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF0027997  

20  

Page 11: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

11  

Erratum  hWp://dx.doi.org  10.1234/PDS015  

Associated  with    hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF0027997  

Erratum  hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF0027997  

hWp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00279147  

Clicking  on  the  CrossMark  logo  queries  

the  CrossMark  database  

And  calls  up  any  items  associated  with  the  

arGcle  

21  

22  

Page 12: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

12  

23  

24  

Page 13: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

13  

25  

Other uses

•  It can also provide additional information –  FundRef funder information –  Conflict of interest statements –  Publication history (submission, revision and

accepted dates) –  Location of data deposits or registries –  Peer review process used –  CrossCheck plagiarism screening status –  License types

26  

Page 14: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

14  

27  

What  kind  of  Publica7on  Record  informa7on  can  be  made  available?  

•  Funding  informaGon  via  FundRef  •  Conflict  of  interest  statements  •  PublicaGon  history  

–  submission,  revision  and  accepted  dates  •  LocaGon  of  data  deposits  or  registries  •  Peer  review  process  used    •  CrossCheck  plagiarism  screening  •  License  types  via  CrossRef    TDM  •  and  more…  

28  

Page 15: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

15  

Latest  numbers  

•  2.2  million  CrossMark  deposits    •  22,700  status  updates  

–  15,600  correcGons  –  622  retracGons  

•  5.4  million  asserGons  (Record  tab  info)  •  75  publishers    

29  

•  Marketing Microsite available –  http://www.crossref.org/crossmark/index.html

•  Banner ads for publisher use

30  

Page 16: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

16  

HOW TO IMPLEMENT THE CROSSMARK PUBLICATION RECORD SERVICE

31  

Rules

•  Any CrossRef member can participate –  Any item with a DOI can display a CrossMark logo

•  Obligations of participants –  Maintain your content –  Keep CrossMark metadata up to date –  Adhere to the logo display guidelines

32  

Page 17: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

17  

1. Create a CrossMark policy page

•  Explain –  CrossMark service –  Your commitment to maintain the content –  Publisher policies on corrections, retractions, etc.

•  Define any custom metadata fields for the Record Tab (e.g. peer review process)

•  Assign the page a DOI for persistent linking •  Deposit the Policy Page with CrossRef

–  http://crossmarksupport.crossref.org/crossmark-policy-page/

33  

2. Deposit CrossMark metadata

•  As part of the regular DOI deposit –  Part of the entire DOI metadata record –  For back files you can deposit just CrossMark

metadata

•  http://crossmarksupport.crossref.org/technical-implementation-guidelines/

34  

Page 18: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

18  

CrossMark Metadata

•  The minimum metadata comprises: –  CrossRef DOI of the content the CrossMark logo is

being applied to •  i.e. the original article

–  CrossRef DOI for the publisher’s CrossMark policy page

–  CrossRef DOI of any piece of content that is being updated

•  i.e. the erratum, or the retraction notice

35  

3. Keep your metadata up to date!

•  Send updates –  As you would for URL or other metadata updates

•  <updates> <update type="correction" label="Correction” date="2010-03-24”> 10.5555/1571 </update>!

•  </updates>

36  

Page 19: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

19  

4. Record CrossRef DOIs in the HTML page metadata

•  <meta name=“dc.identifier” content=“doi:5555.1371/0050222”>

37  

5. Add CrossMark logo to HTML article landing pages

•  See logos and usage guidelines –  http://crossmarksupport.crossref.org/crossmark-

logos-and-usage-guidelines/ •  Use the CrossRef widget from CrossRef website

to add logo and link to website –  http://crossmarksupport.crossref.org/technical-

implementation-guidelines/

38  

Page 20: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

20  

6. Add CrossMark metadata and logos to PDFs

•  Metadata –  Minimum = the CrossRef DOI and CrossMark domain –  “pdfmark”embeds metadata in PDF files –  http://labs.crossref.org/pdfmark/

•  CrossMark logo –  “pdfstamp”adds image (stamp) to a PDF with a URL

link –  http://labs.crossref.org/pdfstamp/

39  

7. Collect and deposit additional publication record metadata

(optional) •  Decide which additional metadata you want to

add •  Collect it from editorial and production systems •  Deposit to CrossRef •  Plenty of examples on CrossMark site

http://crossmarksupport.crossref.org/crossmark-examples-and-annotated-sample-site-3/

40  

Page 21: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

21  

The cost

•  No extra cost •  Per-item deposit fee for each erratum/retraction

deposited (the same as for a regular item) –  Current content (within past 2 years) $0.20 –  Backfile content $0.02

•  No additional annual membership fees

41  

Find out morehttp://www.crossref.org/crossmark

•  With introductory video •  Email list for updates •  Webinars and presentations

42  

Page 22: 7-Managing errata & retractions with CrossMark

CrossRef  Workshop,  Gauteng,  South  Africa,  September  2015  

 

22  

43