Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Developing a contributor role taxonomy for science: Project CRediT
11 Dec 2014
11 Dec 2014
Capital Hilton
CNI’s WiFi INTERNET ACCESS
Attendees Conference Code: @cni-14f
SSID: PSAV_Event_Solutions
Capital Hilton
CNI’s WiFi INTERNET ACCESS
Presenters Conference Code: #cni-2014f
SSID: PSAV_Event_Solutions
Capital Hilton
CNI’s WiFi INTERNET ACCESS
Code: JOLLY2014
SSID: attwifi
2
Project CRediT: Welcome
Clifford Lynch
11 Dec 2014
To explore the value and uses of developing a taxonomy to enable greater granularity & transparency around the contributions to scholarly output in science
11 Dec 2014
Workshop aims
share the results of the latest consultation have a lot of discussion get more clarity on how to implement network
Please take shareable notes
hashtag: #projectcredit
5
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
11 Dec 2014
Project CRediT: overview
Amy Brand & Liz Allen
PublishersHelen Atkins, Cameron Neylon, PLoS
Kalyani Narasimhan, NatureMonica Bradford, Science
Laura Fedoryk, WileyEtta Kavanagh, PNAS
Emilie Marcus, Cell PressJulia Laurin, Thomson Reuters
Tamara Welschot, Springer
Research fundersLiz Allen,Jo Scott, Wellcome Trust
Jamie Doyle, Neil Thakur, Walter Schaffer, Bart Trawick, NIH
Chris Mentzel, Moore FoundationDaniel Katz, NSFWyatt Korff, HHMI
Community stakeholdersDavid Baker, CASRAI
Amy Brand, Sara Roui, Ashlea Higgs, Digital ScienceLayne Johnson, Duraspace
Abigail Cabunoc, Kaitlin Thaney, MozillaRichard Wynne, Aries Systems
Laure Haak, ORCIDNettie Legace, NISOClifford Lynch, CNI
Carol Meyer, CrossRefAndrew Sallans, Center for Open Science
Research institutionsMicah Altman, MIT Libraries
Margaret Burri, Barbara Pralle, Jing Wang JHUMelissa Haendel, OSHU
Dean Krafft, Cornell U. LibraryKathleen Kern, U. Illinois Urbana
Julia Lane, American Institutes of ResearchRichard Malham, Academy of Medical Sciences
Paul Uhlir, National Academy of Sciences
Workshop attendees
Publishers
Increase transparencyReduce author disputes
Simplify process of chasing authorsIdentifying peer reviewers
Research fundersSupporting grant applications
Understanding impact Awarding credit
Identifying peer reviewersIdentifying new funding opportunities
ResearchersGaining credit for true contribution
Credit for ‘new’/specific rolesIdentify collaborators
Benefit junior contributorsReduce authorship politics?
Research institutions
Support tenure & appointmentNew esteem & credit metrics for
staffUnderstanding impact
Contributor role taxonomy: rationale
11 Dec 2014
Project origins & milestones1.Wellcome-Harvard workshop 2012
2.Initial collaboration with medical editors (ICMJE)
3.Developed draft taxonomy (2012/13)
4.Pilot with recent corresponding authors (2013)
5.Refining taxonomy & consultation phase 2 (2014 - )
11 Dec 2014
14 role taxonomy
11 Dec 2014
Road testing: phase 1 Further work oTaxonomy needs to balance comprehensiveness with being fit-for-purpose
oShould taxonomy include ability to assign a ‘lead’ or ‘supporting’ contributor to a role?
oShould the roles extend beyond traditional author roles?
oHow to accommodate ‘equal’ contributions to roles?
oHow to ensure agreement among authors through process of assignment?
oNeed to keep process light; don’t create researcher burden
NatureApril 2014
11 Dec 2014
Contributor role project: phase 2oDevelop taxonomy further: science focusoEstablish cross-sector-disciplinary working groupoOutreach
o Project support from CASRAI & NISOo Engagement with potential implementers (e.g. Lab
management software vendors; publishers; Manuscript Submission software (MSS vendors)
o Workshop December 2014
11 Dec 2014
Phase 2: Working GroupLiz Allen (Chair) Wellcome Trust
Micah Altman MIT Libraries
Helen Atkins PLOS
Monica Bradford Science/AAAS
Amy Brand (Chair) Digital Science
Jon Corson-Rikert Cornell University
Jeffrey Doyle Cornell University
Daniel S. Katz University of Chicago & NSF
Veronique Kiermer Nature Publishing Group (NPG)
Nettie Lagace National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
Jo Scott Wellcome Trust
Gene Sprouse American Physical Society
Walter Schaffer National Institutes of Health (NIH)
David Baker CASRAI
11 Dec 2014
Key considerations
oTaxonomy needs to be fit-for-purpose
oHow to deal with large numbers of authors
oHow/whether to assign ‘level’ of contribution
oNeeds effective implementation & clear use
oMust not add to ‘researcher burden’
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
AM: Project overview Feedback of results of consultation Potential integrations & use cases
11 Dec 2014
Workshop agenda
PM: Potential integrations & use cases Challenges Next steps
Later: networking reception
