Upload
ilri
View
25
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Improving markets to protect food access: an intervention in informal dairy markets in Kenya
Speakers: Silvia Alonso, International Livestock Research Institute
Milk–thewhitegold
HighlynutriXous:• Macro/micronutrients• Highbioavailability• improveanthropometricindices• reducenutriXonaldeficienciesamong
undernourishedchildren
ComparedtootherASF:• Verysuitableforchildren• Moreavailable• Moreaffordable
Rawmilk
Mostavailableandaffordableformofdairyinmanylowincomecountries
InruralareasinLICfreshrawmilkiseasilyavailable(incl.self-producXon)
Inurbanareasco-existswithpasteurizedmilk:
q WidedistribuXonchannels(incl.doortodoor)q Cheaperq Tastepreferenceq Culturalvalues
Rawmilkandpublichealth
Concernsoverthesafetyofrawmilk
v IsitahealthriskinKenya?
v Ispasteurizedmilksafer?
Rawmilkandpublichealth
Concernsoverthesafetyofrawmilk
v IsitahealthriskinKenya?
v Ispasteurizedmilksafer?
PUBLICHEALTHINTERVENTIONSINKENYA
• BasedonincreasedregulaXonandpenalizaXonofrawmilk
VCactors(unsuccessful)
• PromoXngsellingofboiledmilk
• BanrawmilkVCandpromotepasteurizaXon
The“informal”(rawmilk)dairysector
Ø Poorinfrastructure,lackofcoldchain,informalagreementmechanismsbetweenactors,orenunlicensed,poorlyregulated(governmentandself-regulaXon)
The“informal”(rawmilk)dairysector
Ø Poorinfrastructure,lackofcoldchain,informalagreementmechanismsbetweenactors,orenunlicensed,poorlyregulated(governmentandself-regulaXon)
Ø But…InformaldairymarketshaveanessenXalroleinatleastthreemainaspects:
q Foodsecurity(especiallydietandnutriXonneedsofchildren)q SourceoflivelihoodsforthepopulaXon(higherpricesforproducers,
givesjobstoagoodamountofpeople)q Supportwomenandyouth
Abanintheinformalsector
Ø Abanofrawmilkcouldhaveunintendedconsequences
Ø livelihoodsofmanypeopleØ accesstonutriXousfoodØ Increasedpriceofpasteurizedmilk
Abanintheinformalsector
Ø Abanofrawmilkcouldhaveunintendedconsequences
Ø livelihoodsofmanypeopleØ accesstonutriXousfoodØ Increasedpriceofpasteurizedmilk
Whileinthelongtermmarketswillformalize,intheshortandmediumtermsintervenXonsthat
seektosuppressinformalmarketscanbeineffec9ve,an9-poorandgender-inequitable
Sodowin-winop9onsexistthatwillprotectnutri9onandlivelihoodsprovidedbythesemarketsands9llprotectpublichealth?
Upscalingtheinformalmarket
TrainingandcerXficaXon
Milkquality/milkhygienebusinessskills/valueaddiXonSustainable/self-sustained
Upscalingtheinformalmarket
TrainingandcerXficaXon
Milkquality/milkhygienebusinessskills/valueaddiXonSustainable/self-sustained
FINDINGS:
• Improvedmilksafety
• Happytraders/customers
• Limitedgovernmentbuy-in
• Successfulinothercontexts
GivingT&Canotherchance!
“MoreMilk:makingthemostofmilk”project(2016-2021)
TCMschemetoimprovemilksafetyandhealth&nutri=onoutcomesinchildreninperi-urbanNairobi
• Training:milkquality,safetyandhygiene
• CerXficaXon:“qualitymark”
• MarkeXng:milkconsumpXonmessagestomothers/consumers
MoreMilkforbe_erhealthandnutriXon
Milksafetyandquality
PromoXonmilkconsumpXon
Traders
MoreMilkforbe_erhealthandnutriXon
Milksafetyandquality
-Pathogens
-AdulteraXon+Quality
PromoXonmilkconsumpXon
Traders
MoreMilkforbe_erhealthandnutriXon
Milksafetyandquality
-Pathogens
-AdulteraXon+Quality
-Diarrhea/FBD-Waste
Be_ernutriXon
PromoXonmilkconsumpXon
Traders
MoreMilkforbe_erhealthandnutriXon
Milksafetyandquality
-Pathogens
-AdulteraXon+Quality
-Diarrhea/FBD-Waste
Be_ernutriXon
PromoXonmilkconsumpXon
+ConsumpXon
-Waste
Traders
MoreMilkforbe_erhealthandnutriXon
Milksafetyandquality
-Pathogens
-AdulteraXon+Quality
-Diarrhea/FBD-Waste
Be_ernutriXon
PromoXonmilkconsumpXon
+ConsumpXon
-Waste
Traders
Higherreturns
Moreloyalcustomers
Takehomemessages
• Rawmilkandrawmilkmarkets–essenXalrolesinmanycountries(nutriXon,health,livelihoods)
• Can’tlookatfoodsafetyinisolaXon• FoodsafetyintervenXons:onesizeDOESNOTalwaysfitall.IntervenXonsthatpenalizeinformalactorscandomoreharmthangood.
• TakeholisXclookatproblemandfindinnova9veapproaches
• Light-touchinterven9onsininformalmarketscanimprovefoodsafety,andcontributetoimprovedhealthandnutriXonoutcomes.